Legacy Podcast: Episode 3 - "John F. Kennedy | Clash of The Cold Warriors"
Host: Afua Hirsch and Peter Frankopan
Release Date: October 30, 2024
Platform: Wondery
Introduction
In the third installment of the "Legacy" series, hosts Afua Hirsch and Peter Frankopan delve deep into the tumultuous presidency of John F. Kennedy (JFK), focusing on his navigation through the Cold War's most perilous moments. This episode, titled "Clash of The Cold Warriors," examines JFK's political maneuvers, personal struggles, and pivotal decisions that shaped his legacy and the course of global history.
Early Challenges: Bay of Pigs and Civil Rights
The episode opens by revisiting the stormy early days of Kennedy's presidency. The failed Bay of Pigs invasion—a disastrous attempt to overthrow Cuban leader Fidel Castro—set a rocky precedent for JFK’s foreign policy. Additionally, Kennedy's administration faltered in effectively addressing the burgeoning civil rights movement, exemplified by the brutal suppression of the Freedom Riders.
Notable Quote:
"Never in American history has a man talked so big and achieved so little." — Nixon (04:30)
Afua Hirsch reflects on how these setbacks left Kennedy grappling with both domestic unrest and international tensions, underscoring the immense pressure he faced as the leader of the free world.
The Vienna Summit: A Test of Leadership
Seeking to reassert his authority on the global stage, JFK attends his first summit with Soviet Premier Nikita Khrushchev in Vienna during the summer of 1961. This meeting was Kennedy's opportunity to demonstrate his leadership capabilities.
Key Points:
- Kennedy entered the summit with high hopes but was met with Khrushchev's aggressive stance.
- The discussions quickly shifted to the dangers of nuclear warfare, leaving Kennedy feeling outmaneuvered.
- The summit exposed Kennedy’s inexperience in high-stakes diplomacy, leading to increased skepticism from his advisors and the public.
Notable Quote:
"It's a really dark cloud that's hanging over humanity, and whether that happens or not is concentrated in the hands and decision-making of a small circle of men in Moscow and in Washington." — Afua Hirsch (04:16)
This realization marked a turning point, compelling Kennedy to adopt a more resolute stance against Soviet aggression.
Berlin Crisis and the Construction of the Berlin Wall
Following the Vienna Summit, tensions escalated in Berlin—a divided city symbolic of the broader East-West conflict. Soviet insistence on preventing German reunification led to the erection of the Berlin Wall on August 13, 1961.
Key Points:
- The Wall physically and ideologically split Berlin, fueling fears of imminent war.
- Kennedy viewed the Wall as both a tactical move by the Soviets and an opportunity to showcase American resolve.
- Public perception in the U.S. was stark, with 60% believing war was likely and some supporting military action.
Notable Quote:
"Our goal is not the victory of might, but the vindication of right, not peace at the expense of freedom, but both peace and freedom." — John F. Kennedy (29:18)
Kennedy's response to the Berlin Wall demonstrated his commitment to defending Western ideals without plunging the world into nuclear conflict.
The Steel Industry Confrontation
Kennedy's domestic policies mirrored his foreign policy assertiveness. Confronting the steel industry's price hikes, JFK took a stand against the military-industrial complex, symbolizing his dedication to the middle class and consumer protection.
Key Points:
- Kennedy pressured steel executives to curb price increases, clashing with powerful industry leaders.
- He leveraged his brother Bobby to initiate investigations into potential collusion within the steel industry.
- These actions bolstered Kennedy's approval ratings, showcasing his willingness to challenge entrenched interests.
Notable Quote:
"I have the humanity to understand in a way that people like Curtis LeMay clearly didn't." — Afua Hirsch (37:10)
This confrontation highlighted Kennedy’s integrity and his prioritization of ordinary Americans over corporate power.
The Cuban Missile Crisis: Brink of Nuclear War
Arguably the most intense segment of the episode, Hirsch and Frankopan meticulously recount the events of the Cuban Missile Crisis in October 1962—a 13-day confrontation that nearly led to nuclear catastrophe.
Key Points:
-
Discovery of Missiles: On October 16, 1962, U.S. spy planes identified Soviet missile installations in Cuba, a direct threat to American security.
-
ExComm Deliberations: JFK convened his Executive Committee (ExComm) to explore responses, including airstrikes, blockades, and invasion.
-
Quarantine Decision: On October 22, after intense debates and military pressure, Kennedy opted for a naval quarantine (termed a "quarantine" rather than a "blockade" to avoid aggression) to prevent further Soviet shipments to Cuba.
-
Public Address: Kennedy addressed the nation, informing Americans of the missile threat and the steps the U.S. would take to counter it.
Notable Quote:
"Given the stakes, this is our finest hour." — John F. Kennedy (Contextualized around decision-making moments)
The crisis culminated in a tense standoff with Soviet ships veering away from the quarantine zone and Khrushchev eventually agreeing to dismantle the missile sites in exchange for a U.S. promise not to invade Cuba and the secret removal of U.S. missiles from Turkey.
Notable Quote:
"The greatest defeat in our history." — Curtis LeMay (36:17)
General Curtis LeMay expressed vehement dissatisfaction with the resolution, advocating for a more aggressive military approach, reflecting the clashing perspectives within the U.S. leadership.
Kennedy’s Vision for America: The Space Race and Civil Rights
Transitioning from crisis management, the episode explores JFK's ambitious vision for America, particularly his commitment to the space race and advancing civil rights.
Space Race:
- Kennedy aimed to land an American on the moon by 1970, symbolizing technological prowess and national ambition.
- Despite public skepticism and the immense financial cost, this vision eventually culminated in the Apollo 11 moon landing in 1969.
Civil Rights Movement:
- JFK's relationship with civil rights leaders like Martin Luther King Jr. was complex. While publicly supporting the movement, Kennedy faced criticism for not prioritizing it swiftly enough.
- The episode highlights King's famous "Letter from Birmingham Jail," which criticized Kennedy for his tepid response to segregation and civil rights abuses.
Notable Quote:
"We choose to go to the moon in this decade and do the other things, not because they are easy, but because they are hard." — John F. Kennedy (42:10)
This speech encapsulated Kennedy's ethos of striving for monumental achievements despite challenges, reflecting his broader leadership philosophy.
Vietnam and Escalating Global Tensions
Towards the end of his presidency, Kennedy confronted the intricate and escalating conflict in Vietnam. The episode outlines his strategies and the eventual U.S. entanglement in the region.
Key Points:
- Kennedy supported South Vietnam's government despite its corruption and repression, viewing it as a bulwark against communist expansion.
- Faced with Buddhist protests and military coups, Kennedy grappled with balancing anti-communist objectives against human rights concerns.
- The CIA-backed coup that led to the assassination of Ngo Dinh Diem underscored the moral and strategic dilemmas of interventionist policies.
Notable Quote:
"It's very difficult to hold yourself up as the leader of the free world when so many of your own people are unfree." — Afua Hirsch (48:04)
Kennedy's internal conflicts about Vietnam mirrored the broader struggles of balancing Cold War imperatives with democratic and ethical values.
Legacy and Conclusion
As the episode concludes, Hirsch and Frankopan reflect on JFK's enduring legacy. Despite his untimely assassination in November 1963, Kennedy's decisions during the Cold War crises showcase his nuanced understanding of power, diplomacy, and humanity.
Key Takeaways:
- JFK's presidency was marked by high-stakes decisions that required balancing aggression with diplomacy.
- His leadership during the Cuban Missile Crisis exemplifies the critical importance of measured responses in preventing global catastrophe.
- Domestically, Kennedy's struggles with civil rights and economic policies reveal the complexities of progressive leadership in a divided society.
- Kennedy's vision for space exploration and his confrontations with the military-industrial complex demonstrate his ambition and commitment to shaping America's future.
Final Reflection: The episode underscores that Kennedy's legacy is a blend of bold aspirations and challenging realities. His ability to navigate crisis while striving for progress leaves a lasting imprint on American history and global geopolitics.
Notable Quote:
"Our goal is not the victory of might, but the vindication of right..." — John F. Kennedy (29:18)
This encapsulates the essence of Kennedy's leadership—seeking justice and peace without succumbing to the temptations of sheer power.
Behind the Scenes
The episode was meticulously crafted using a variety of historical sources, including Robert Dalek's John F. Kennedy: An Unfinished Life and the archives of the John F. Kennedy Presidential Library and Museum. The hosts emphasized that while some dialogues are reconstructed for dramatic effect, they remain grounded in rigorous biographical research.
Production Credits:
- Scene Writing: Kirsty Smith for Goalhanger
- Producers: Kate Taylor, Anoushka Lewis, Robin Scott Elliott
- Sound Design: Phil Brown
- Music Supervision: Scott Velasquez for Fritz and Sync
- Executive Producers: Tony Pastor, Jack Davenport
Conclusion
"Clash of The Cold Warriors" offers a comprehensive and engaging exploration of JFK's presidency, highlighting his trials, triumphs, and the intricate web of Cold War politics. Hirsch and Frankopan provide a balanced narrative that not only celebrates Kennedy's achievements but also critically examines the shortcomings and pressures that defined his leadership. For listeners seeking an in-depth understanding of one of America's most charismatic and complex leaders, this episode is an invaluable resource.
Listen to "Legacy" on the Wondery App or wherever you get your podcasts. Binge episodes early and ad-free with Wondery+. Start your free trial here.