Don't get taken for a ride by your car insurer

Summary

Life Kit (NPR) — Episode Summary

Episode Title: Don’t get taken for a ride by your car insurer
Host: Marielle Segarra
Guest/Expert: Camila Domonosky (NPR’s cars and energy correspondent)
Air Date: March 19, 2026

---

Overview

In this episode, host Marielle Segarra tackles the escalating costs of car insurance—a major, unavoidable expense for many Americans. With rates skyrocketing over the past few years, Segarra and NPR’s Camila Domonosky explore actionable strategies for saving money, the industry’s pricing logic, and essential factors to consider before buying a car or insurance policy. The conversation blends practical advice with eye-opening insights about how insurance rates are set and who’s most affected.

---

Key Topics & Insights

1. Car Insurance Rates: Why They’ve Jumped (00:51–01:54, 02:54–03:01)

• Insurance rates have soared: Between 2022 and early 2025, rates increased by over 50%.
• Root causes: Rising costs for repairs and general economic inflation.
• Current Status: Prices are starting to level off but remain high for many.

Notable quote:
Marielle Segarra (00:51): “Have you seen car insurance prices these days? … rates jumped by more than 50% ... It boils down to lots of things are expensive right now, including the cost of car repairs.”

---

2. Shopping Around is the No. 1 Tip (03:01–03:33)

• Expert recommendation: Always compare insurance rates from different companies before making decisions.
• Why it matters: Companies assume you won’t compare prices, so you may miss out on significant savings.
• Tools: Use online quote tools or insurance brokers to streamline the process.

Quote:
Camila Domonosky (03:03): “It is literally true that you could save hundreds or in some cases thousands by switching providers… You can really miss out on savings if you follow the path of least resistance.”

---

3. Discounts, Negotiation, and Driving Habits (03:33–04:34)

• Negotiation is limited: Rates aren’t negotiable in the typical sense, but you can stack discounts (bundling, good driving, etc.).
• Driving record: Clean records unlock lower rates—safe driving always helps.

---

4. Credit Scores and “Non-Driving” Factors (04:34–07:08)

• Credit score’s big impact: In most states, poor credit can lead to dramatically higher premiums—even for safe drivers.
• Additional factors: Job type, education, and ZIP code may increase your rate, often impacting those with lower incomes.
• State variations: A handful of states prohibit credit-based pricing; most do not.

Notable quote:
Camila Domonosky (05:48): “Richer people are more likely to pay out of pocket to keep their premiums low. … Blue collar workers might pay more than people with white collar jobs. People without college degrees can pay more.”

Doug Heller (Consumer Federation of America, paraphrased by Camila, 06:16):
“Each and every one of those—low credit, blue collar, high school educated—all of those accumulate on lower and moderate income folks, which means that the real pain … gets foisted more directly on those who are already most vulnerable.”

---

5. What Can You Do About Unfair Pricing? (07:08–07:51)

• Shop around: Different companies factor in credit and demographics differently.
• Improve credit score: Long-term solution for lower premiums.
• Policyholder tip: If married, insure under the spouse with the better credit/history if possible.

---

6. Should You File a Claim? (07:51–09:24)

• Fender bender logic: Avoid small claims if out-of-pocket cost is less than your deductible, as claims often trigger future rate hikes.
• Serious or involving others: Always inform your insurer to protect yourself from future disputes/liability.

Exchange:
Marielle (09:24): “People have unrealistic expectations for how their cars are supposed to look…”
Camila (09:38): “We’re pro-dent in my household also.”

---

7. Insurance Costs Before Buying a Car (10:26–11:41)

• Best practice: Get insurance quotes for specific makes/models before you buy.
• Car selection impacts premiums: Expensive, rare, or sporty cars can cost much more to insure.
• Ask yourself: Do you need as many cars as you have (if you own multiple)?

---

8. The Case for More, Not Less, Insurance (11:41–13:26)

• Trend: More people are driving without insurance due to rising costs.
• Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage: With more uninsured drivers, it’s wise to buy these add-ons—even if it raises your premium.
• Raising policy limits: Repair and medical costs are up; your old coverage may no longer be enough, even if you pay more now.

Quote:
Shannon Martin (12:57): “With car insurance in particular, there’s a feeling that you’re paying more and you’re getting less, and that’s because you honestly are.”

---

9. Teenagers & Insurance Shock (13:26–14:53)

• Teen drivers raise rates: Adding a teen can double or triple premiums.
• Real example: Brandi Levine, Yakima WA, quoted $350/month to add her 17-year-old son.
• Policy tip: Insurers may raise rates simply based on a teen license-holder in your house, even if they don’t drive much.
• Recommendation: Delay teen licenses or drive only the oldest car—run the numbers before deciding.

---

10. If You Can’t Afford Insurance: Storage Policies & Options (15:05–16:50)

• Letting coverage lapse is costly: Restarting insurance is expensive after a break in coverage.
• Alternative: Call your agent and ask about a “storage plan” (comprehensive-only) that insures your parked car for theft, fire, vandalism for just a few dollars per month.
• Important: This means you can’t drive the car until the coverage is reinstated, but saves you from future penalty fees.

Quote:
Shannon Martin (15:58): “You take all the liability coverage off, you keep comprehensive for things like fire, theft, and vandalism… the rate is usually like a few dollars a month. It’s nothing.”

---

Notable Quotes & Moments

• On shopping around for insurance:
  “It is literally true that you could save hundreds or in some cases thousands by switching providers.”
  — Camila Domonosky (03:03)

• On non-driving factors increasing rates:
  “Each and every one of those … accumulate on lower and moderate income folks, which means that the real pain … gets foisted more directly on those who are already most vulnerable…”
  — Camila Domonosky (06:16, referencing Doug Heller)

• On small accidents:
  “We’re pro-dent in my household.”
  — Camila Domonosky (09:38)

• On feeling squeezed:
  “With car insurance in particular, there’s a feeling that you’re paying more and you’re getting less, and that’s because you honestly are.”
  — Shannon Martin (12:57)

• On storage insurance:
  “Where you take all the liability coverage off, you keep comprehensive for things like fire, theft, and vandalism ... the rate is usually like a few dollars a month. It’s nothing.”
  — Shannon Martin (15:58)

---

Major Takeaways / Action Items (16:55–19:53)

1. Shop Around: Compare rates between insurers. You may save hundreds or thousands by switching.
2. Mind Your Record: A clean driving history pays off with lower premiums.
3. Be Strategic About Claims: Only file claims if the repair cost is well above your deductible—otherwise, paying out of pocket might save you money long-term.
4. Check Insurance Before Buying a Car: Get quotes for specific makes/models. Consider if you could own fewer vehicles.
5. Reconsider Your Coverage Limits: Increasing your limits or adding uninsured/underinsured coverage may be smart, even if it means a higher monthly premium.
6. Don’t Let Insurance Lapse: If affordability is an issue, consider a “storage plan” while the car is parked.

---

Memorable Segment Timestamps

• [00:51] — Context on rising insurance rates
• [03:01] — Camila’s #1 tip: Shop around
• [04:34] — Why credit scores and other non-driving factors matter
• [07:51] — To file a claim or not?
• [10:26] — Buy a car? Get a quote first
• [11:50] — Why you may want more coverage now
• [13:26] — The cost of insuring teen drivers
• [15:05] — What to do if you can’t afford insurance

---

Tone & Closing Thoughts

The episode blends practical money-saving tips with candid discussion about the systemic and sometimes unfair logic behind car insurance pricing. The tone is empathetic, approachable, and pragmatic—with a focus on empowering listeners to make informed decisions rather than simply lamenting high prices. Both host and guest use humor (“pro-dent household”) and real-life scenarios, making the advice feel accessible.

---

For further reading and to test how your ZIP code and credit affect rates, NPR’s investigative project is recommended.

Transcript

[Announcer]

This message comes from Intuit TurboTax with TurboTax Expert. Full service match with a dedicated expert who will do your taxes for you from start to finish, getting you every dollar you deserve. It's that easy. Visit turbotax.com to match with an expert today.

[Marielle Segarra]

You're listening to Life Kit from npr. Hey, it's Marielle. When I was in high school, my, my dad wouldn't let me get a driver's license. Yep, dad, if you're listening, I'm telling everybody. Nah, I mean, he was concerned about safety, thought that I and my brother were too young to take on the responsibility of driving. Of course, I just ended up getting rides from friends, lol. But I digress. Want to know another reason to not let your teenager drive?

[Camila Domonosky]

Well, it makes your insurance go up a significant amount.

[Marielle Segarra]

And have you seen car insurance prices these days? Between the start of 2022 and the start of 2025, rates jumped by more than 50%, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. There are a whole bunch of reasons for that, but it boils down to lots of things are expensive right now, including the cost of car repairs. Now, car insurance prices have been leveling off, but they're still uncomfortably high for a lot of people. So on this episode of Life Kit, we're taking a look at this big, not exactly optional expense and what you can do about it. I'll talk to NPR's cars and energy correspondent Camila Domonosky about how to shop around, how your credit score and zip code can affect your car insurance and what to do about that and why, when you're buying a car, you should price out the insurance for that particular make and model first. That's coming up after the break.

[Announcer]

This message comes from Midi Health CEO Joanna Strober shares the personal experience that led her to start a virtual care platform for women in perimenopause and menopause.

[Joanna Strober]

I was having anxiety. I had gained weight. I wasn't sleeping. And my primary care doctor never once said that perhaps I was in perimenopause and that all these things could be related to my hormones. So I had a really tough time for quite a while. And a friend recommended that I try a concierge doctor. She prescribed hormones for me, a combination of estrogen, progesterone and testosterone. And I felt very relieved that I had this care. And I also had a lot of sadness that I had spent such a long period of time going through this and not getting the right care. And so essentially, what we really want to do at MITI is democratize access to this type of type of care.

[Announcer]

MIDI Health, committed to helping women in midlife with perimenopause and menopause care. Accessible via telehealth visits@join MIDI.com all right,

[Marielle Segarra]

Camila, you've been reporting on this. Car insurance rates have gone up a lot. What are people supposed to do about this?

[Camila Domonosky]

So what are your options? The number one recommendation that experts make is to shop around. Like, actually compare what you can get from different companies. I don't want to sound like an ad here, but it is literally true that you could save hundreds or in some cases thousands by switching providers. You know, companies assume that you won't do that because it's kind of a pain to get quotes and shop around. So you can really miss out on savings if you follow the path of least resistance.

[Marielle Segarra]

By the way, can you negotiate with a car insurance provider and say, hey, could you lower my rates or could you offer me something a little more competitive?

[Camila Domonosky]

It's not really negotiable in the way that some things that we buy, you can haggle. But what you can do while you're comparing policies is make sure you look for all the possible discounts. All the companies have discounts that you can stack on top of each other. And you should make sure that you're looking at everything that you might possibly qualify for. And again, compare between different companies. I use an insurance broker who looks at a lot of different companies. Lots of people get quotes themselves online and look at different companies. That's really important. The couple other things that we have to talk about that are really important for keeping your insurance costs down. One is obviously, drive safely. If you have no accidents on your record, your insurance is going to be cheaper. And then we also need to talk about credit ratings.

[Marielle Segarra]

Hmm. How does your credit score affect your car insurance?

[Camila Domonosky]

Enormously. And I should note that insurance is regulated on a state by state basis, so it will depend on where you are. There are a few states that prohibit companies from factoring credit scores into insurance, but most states allow it. And so this means that even drivers who have a perfect driving score, great history of being a really safe driver, but have bad credit, they can wind up with really high insurance premiums. And this is a really big issue. You know, our colleagues on NPR's investigations team, they actually did a project about this last year that people can find on NPR's website where you can plug in your zip code and see how big of a difference your credit score makes in what you'll pay for Car insurance. And it can be thousands and thousands of dollars. And there's a big question of whether this is fair. Right?

[Joanna Strober]

Yeah.

[Camila Domonosky]

Part of the argument for why companies factor this in is that drivers who have poor credit, lower incomes, lower savings, if they get in a crash, they are more likely to actually use their insurance.

[Marielle Segarra]

Well, we should all be able to use it if we're paying for it and get in a crash.

[Camila Domonosky]

I mean, yes, you are paying for it. That is the whole deal. That if you get in a crash, they will pay you. But richer people are more likely to pay out of pocket to keep their premiums low. Right. I was listening to the Chicago Federal Reserve's auto symposium last month and Doug Heller spoke. He's an insurance expert at the Consumer Federation of America. And he pointed out that it's actually not just credit scores. There are actually a lot of other quote unquote, non driving factors that companies consider when they're setting rates. Blue collar workers might pay more than people with white collar jobs. People without college degrees can pay more. It varies by insurance company. Here's what he said. Each and every one of those low credit, blue collar, high school educated, all of those accumulate on lower and moderate income folks, which means that the real pain of the higher cost of repair, of trade issues, tariffs, all of those, those get foisted more directly on those who are already most vulnerable in terms of being able to afford life in the insurance market.

[Marielle Segarra]

All right, so if you are in this situation where you may be charged more for car insurance because you have a lower credit score, because you have a blue collar job or you live in a certain zip code, is there anything you can do about that?

[Camila Domonosky]

Yes, there is. First off, it is really important to shop around. Right. Because different companies weight these factors differently. So your credit score, your job, some companies might weight them more or less than others. So it is just super important to compare. Also, it's not a quick fix, obviously, but bring up that credit score if you can. It will really save money in the long run. And then if you're married and one of you has better credit or factors that might weigh in your favor, you might use that person's name on the policy. Shannon Martin, who is an insurance expert with Bankrate, she said that that can sometimes help.

[Marielle Segarra]

You mentioned that there are people who aren't using the insurance that they pay for because they don't want their premiums to go up after a car crash. So they just pay out of pocket for any damage. Well, how might you figure out whether it's Worth filing a claim after you do have an incident?

[Camila Domonosky]

Yeah, I mean, obviously this is going to vary case by case based on what happened and state by state because state rules vary. If you have an insurance broker, somebody who works for you and not for your insurance company specifically, great person to call for advice. General principles here. If you're in a crash with someone else, you are almost certainly going to want to get your insurance involved. There might be more liability than you think at first glance or they might file a claim against you. Shannon with Bankrate, she said if you don't report that kind of crash to your insurer, it really increases the risk of disputes in that situation. So collision with someone else you really want to call your insurance. And if it's just you though it's a single car crash, you're going to look at how much damage is involved and you want to compare it to the cost of your deductible, the amount that you'll have to pay anyway even if you file a claim. And then how much money are you actually going to get from insurance after your deductible? And if you can afford to pay it out of pocket, then it might be worth paying that rather than having your premiums go up for several years. Or maybe if the damage is just cosmetic. I have a dent in the door of my car right now that you know, it's just a dent in the door. It drives just fine. Certainly not going to pay to get that fixed.

[Marielle Segarra]

I mean, I do feel like people have unrealistic expectations for how their cars are supposed to look like. You're driving this thing around in the world, parking next to other people. It is going to see some wear and tear. I say embrace the dents.

[Camila Domonosky]

We're pro dent in my household also. You know, they don't need to look perfect. A car is for getting you a place.

[Marielle Segarra]

We'll have more life kit after the break.

[Sponsor Voice]

This message comes from Grainger. Grainger knows that if you're the purchasing manager at a manufacturing plant, the only thing more important than having the right safety gear is having it there when you need it. That's why you can count on Grainger for auto reordering, helping ensure your team members always have cut resistant gloves on hand and each shift can run safely and efficiently. Call 1-800-GRAINGER Click grainger.com or just stop by Grainger for the ones who get it done.

[Marielle Segarra]

All right, well, any other tips for people who are buying car insurance?

[Camila Domonosky]

Yeah, I would actually recommend that people start thinking about car insurance even before they Purchase a car, it's possible. So price it out. Look at what car insurance for that vehicle would run you because it can be a huge difference in what you're paying based on what you buy. This used to be not very common. People would buy a vehicle and then get car insurance for whatever they got. But with the price of insurance increasing so much, it's really a lot more common now for people to think about this on the front end. I will also note, you know, it's worth considering whether you can actually get by with fewer cars than you think. That's obviously a bigger question, but something to think about. The other thing Shannon Martin at Bankrate really emphasized making sure that you're looking at what you get for the cost of your premium. Because buying insurance is a cost benefit analysis of how much coverage do you want to have In a worst case scenario where you get in a collision, how high of a deductible are you comfortable with? If you have a higher deductible, then you'll have lower premiums.

[Marielle Segarra]

Right.

[Camila Domonosky]

So keep in mind when you're comparing policies to each other that you are comparing apples to apples.

[Marielle Segarra]

Okay? Now did I hear this right? That in this moment, in this era, you have been telling people to actually consider paying more for their car insurance?

[Camila Domonosky]

Yes. You are hearing that right. You might actually want to pay more for insurance by adding uninsured and underinsured coverage. So that's coverage that kicks in if you get into a collision and the other party doesn't have coverage or doesn't have enough coverage. And more people are driving uninsured right now because costs are so high. And Shannon Martin also says you might want to look into paying more to raise the limits on your insurance because costs have been going up for insurance companies. So higher medical bills, higher repair bills, all those things also have gone up for you and your vehicle if you get into a collision right now. And the thing is, your premiums have gone up, but that doesn't mean that your policy has increased what they're willing to pay out to you in that kind of a crash. So if you establish coverage a few years ago, it might not be enough. People are getting into crashes right now thinking they'll be covered and then finding their policy won't cover everything. Here's what Shannon had to say about that.

[Shannon Martin]

With car insurance in particular, there's a feeling that you're paying more and you're getting less, and that's because you honestly are. So it costs you more to buy your policy, but they don't increase the limits for you on your policy.

[Camila Domonosky]

It's not fun advice, but you might want to look into voluntarily increasing the limits on your policy. It will increase your premiums by a small amount, but it would then mean that if you actually get into a collision, you would be more likely to be able to cover all of the costs.

[Marielle Segarra]

Okay, here's a common question. What about if you have a teenager in the house and they drive your car?

[Camila Domonosky]

Well, it makes your insurance go up a significant amount. So certainly one option is maybe they don't get to drive your car, at least not right away. Right. I spoke to one mom who had been weighing this. Her name is Brandi Levine and she lives in Yakima, Washington with her 17 year old son Josiah. She looked into what it would take to add her son. I went through the process to see what it would cost to Adam and

[Announcer]

they told me it would be $350 a month. And I'm like, I can't do this.

[Camila Domonosky]

Like that's so much money, more than double her costs right now. So Josiah is not on insurance. I asked Josiah how he felt about it and he was like, he would love to have access to a car

[Sponsor Voice]

just to go somewhere outside of Yakima. Like, you know, just not being in

[Marielle Segarra]

this cycle where I'm just stuck in this town, stuck with the same life,

[Sponsor Voice]

stuck in the same living situation.

[Camila Domonosky]

And he's gonna be in that spot until he can find a job and pay the cost of getting that insurance coverage himself. I will also note one more thing here. Shannon Martin recommends that you not let teenagers get driver's licenses at all until you've run the numbers and talked with them and made the decision about insurance. Because some insurance companies will see that you have a teenage driver with a license in your house and assume that that person is driving whether or not you give them keys.

[Marielle Segarra]

Oh, no. Okay. Well, what do you do if you are at the point where you really can't afford your car insurance?

[Camila Domonosky]

Yeah. I will note that even though it is legally required, we do know that when car insurance rates go up, the number of people who drive without car insurance also goes up. And we have seen that in the last few years. The stats we have show that that number has increased. Obviously here on life kit, we're not going to recommend that anybody do that. It's very risky on multiple level. And even if you don't get into a collision while you're driving on lapsed insurance, you face higher costs when you get your insurance back.

[Marielle Segarra]

If you let your insurance Lapse.

[Camila Domonosky]

Exactly. If you let it lapse, you have to pay extra to then restart it. I asked Shannon about this, and she said that if it's a matter of covering the bills immediately, that you should call your agent and ask about something called a storage plan option or something similar where you're going to park the vehicle.

[Shannon Martin]

I did that with my car during COVID because I wasn't going anywhere. Where you take all the liability coverage off, you keep comprehensive for things like fire, theft, and vandalism, because that still happens. But your car is still on an insurance policy, and the rate is usually like a few dollars a month. It's nothing.

[Camila Domonosky]

And to be clear, this does mean you will have to stop driving the vehicle. You might have to turn in your license plate even. But what it means is when you have the money and you can turn that policy back on, you're not going to be paying those fe for having a lapse in coverage. So it'll save you money there. And again, I just want to emphasize, you know, look for other plans, shop around, get quotes, see if you can find more manageable coverage somewhere else. Doing this whole episode has reminded me that this is on my to do list for the spring, and I haven't done it yet.

[Marielle Segarra]

All right, Camila, thank you so much for this.

[Camila Domonosky]

Thank you. Happy to be here.

[Marielle Segarra]

Okay, time for a recap. Takeaway one is to shop around for car insurance. You really can save big bucks by switching providers. Also, if you're in a group that gets charged more for car insurance because you have a low credit score or you work a blue collar job. For instance, if you're married and one of you has factors that might work in your favor, put that person's name on the policy. Sometimes that can help. Takeaway 2. Drive cautiously. If you have no car crashes on your record, your insurance will be cheaper. Takeaway 3. Sometimes after a small car crash or a fender bender, drivers won't tell their insurance provider because they'd rather pay out of pocket than pay higher premiums. The experts told Camila that if a crash involves somebody else, you'll almost always want to report it. But if not, look at the damage. Is this something you need to repair, or can you live with a scratch on the side door? Also, how much is your deductible? How much would your insurance pay out? Compare that to the cost of just paying out of pocket. Takeaway 4. Before you buy a set of wheels, look at what the insurance will cost for that particular make and model. Also, ask yourself if you can get by with fewer cars. And if you have a teenager in the house, sorry, teenagers, maybe don't let them drive your car or get a license yet. Or you could have them drive your oldest, most reliable car and look for an insurance policy that'll give you cheaper rates for doing that takeaway. 5 Because the cost of repairs has jumped, you might want to look into increasing the coverage limits on your policy. I know this is counterintuitive and it will mean paying a little more in premiums. But then if you do get into a crash, you won't have to pay as much out of pocket. Lastly, if you're struggling to afford car insurance right now and you decide to stop driving, think about a storage plan option that'll cover you for things like theft and vandalism and should cost about $10 to $20 a month. And that's our show. Hey, one last thing. Would you consider rating and reviewing Life Kit in your podcast app? It helps grow the show and spread the word. Here's a review I liked from a listener called Frank Lee. Sometimes I think y' all are reading my mind or filming me for ideas. Every damn Life Kit is like everything I'm thinking recently. Lol. I love y'. All. Love you too Frank. And yeah, maybe I am reading your mind. Who's to say? Be like Frank. Help us spread the word about Life Kit. Leave us a review in your podcast app right now. This episode of Life Kit was produced by Margaret Serino. Our digital editor is Malika Garib, Megan Kane is our senior supervising editor, and Beth Donovan is our executive producer. Our production team also includes Andy Taegle, Claire Marie Schneider, Sylvie Douglas and Nika Ellison. Engineering support comes from Team Tiffany Vera Castro. I'm Marielle Segarra. Thanks for listening.

[Announcer]

This message comes from Midi Health co founders Joanna Strober and Dr. Kathleen Jordan discuss why they started a virtual care platform to empower and educate women in perimenopause and menopause.

[Joanna Strober]

Historically, perimenopause and menopause have been very stigmatizing. So people haven't wanted to admit that they are in perimenopause and menopause as though it was like embarrassing. Which is insane. It's just something happening to your body. So one of the things that we're trying to do is destigmatize these topics. Perimenopause and menopause are just women's health. So we try to educate women all the time. Maybe it's your hormones and we would like to help you.

[Marielle Segarra]

Yeah, and I find women actually want to talk about it. It's one of the things they always comment at MIDI is that they finally feel heard. One of the ways that women find MIDI is actually from other women, and I think it's meaningful.

[Announcer]

Midi Health Committed to helping women in midlife with perimenopause and menopause care accessible via telehealth [e-mail] this message comes from Bombas.

[Sponsor Voice]

You need better socks and slippers and underwear because you should love what you wear every day. One purchased equals one donated. Go to bombus.com NPR and use code NPR for 20% off.

[Announcer]

This message comes from EasyCater. Making it easy for organizations to order food for meetings and events from favorite restaurants, set up meal programs for their employees, and manage food. Spend all in one [e-mail].