
Loading summary
Capital One / Sponsor Announcer
This message comes from Capital One with the Venture X card, earn unlimited double miles on everything you buy. Plus get premium benefits at a collection of hotels when booking through Capital One Travel. What's in your wallet? Terms apply details@capitalone.com you're listening to Life Kit from NPR.
Marielle Segarra
Hey, it's Marielle. I have gotten a number of surprise medical bills in my life, more than I can count on one hand. Bills for services that I expected my insurance to cover. And every time my emotional response has been rage. Rage because now I have homework to do. Rage because now I have to dig up my insurance card and call people on the phone and wait on hold while they look into the matter. Rage because the bill says due upon receipt and it feels like the clock is ticking. Rage cause I had other plans for my lunch break. Rage because why is our health care system like this? I say all this because I want to acknowledge if you feel rage or frustration or exhaustion or any of the above when you're dealing with medical billing and insurance bureaucracy, that is understandable. And when you're ready, we have advice for you. Specifically, we have advice on what to do when you get a medical bill for something that should have been covered by your insurance as preventative care. Reporter Jackie Fortier has been covering this topic for a KFF Health News and NPR project called Healthcare Helpline. And on this episode of Life Kit, she's going to talk us through some tips so you'll know who to call, what to say and what information you need to appeal a health insurance denial like this.
Sponsor Announcer
Support for this podcast and the following message come from Green Chef this fall Become your healthiest self with Green Chef. Green Chef recipes feature fresh organic seasonal produce and 100% responsibly sourced proteins. Ease into a healthy routine with 80 plus dietitian approved weekly meal options from Mediterranean, gluten free, plant based and protein heavy. Head to greenchef.com 50kit and use code 50kit to get 50% off your first month, then 20% off for two months with free shipping. This message comes from Apple Card. Each Apple product, like the iPhone, is thoughtfully developed by Skill designers. The titanium Apple Card is no different. It's laser etched, has no numbers and rewards you with daily cash on everything you buy, including 3%. Back at Apple Apply for Apple Card in minutes subject to credit approval. Apple Card is issued by Goldman Sachs Bank USA, Salt Lake City branch terms and more@applecard.com this message comes from Capital.
Capital One / Sponsor Announcer
One with the Venture X card, earn unlimited double miles on everything you buy plus get premium benefits at a collection of hotels when booking through Capital One Travel. What's in your wallet? Terms apply details@capital1.com.
Marielle Segarra
So I thought preventive care was supposed to be free.
Jackie Fortier
Yeah, under most circumstances, recommended preventive care is supposed to be covered at no out of pocket cost under the Affordable Care Act. But rejections do still happen, and sometimes because of billing issues or coding mistakes or how a visit with the doctor is classified.
Marielle Segarra
Well, let's start with the basics. What's considered preventative under federal law?
Jackie Fortier
Yeah, it's actually a pretty long list, but here's some of the big ones. Annual physicals, vaccines, like flu, shingles, cancer screenings like mammograms, colonoscopies, and then, well, woman visits, which include breast and pelvic exams. These are all recommended by federal health agencies, and most health plans have to cover them by law. No out of pocket costs. There are specific lists of preventive care for groups of people, so you can go check those out for women, children, and teenagers, and for specific conditions like cancer or pregnancy.
Marielle Segarra
Yeah, and in some ways, that seems like a pretty straightforward list, but also your eligibility will vary based on your age and gender and health history. Right. So when we talk about cancer screenings, like mammograms, for instance, or colonoscopies, it might be considered preventative and covered for you, or it might not.
Jackie Fortier
Yeah. Depending on your age and your health history, it is best to look over the specific list of preventative care that's covered before you go in, if you can.
Marielle Segarra
What can turn an annual wellness visit into, you know, a problem visit or a diagnostic visit that requires payment?
Jackie Fortier
Yeah, so unfortunately, not all care that may be provided during a wellness visit or an annual physical counts as no cost preventive care under federal guidelines, which is really annoying. So it can be complicated and kind of open to interpretation. If a health issue comes up, like during a checkup that prompts a discussion, you know, you're talking to your doctor, like an unusual mole or heart palpitations. That consult can be billed separately. So the patient could then owe like, a copayment or a deductible charge for that part of the visit. So in that scenario, you could ask the doctor, you know, how they're gonna code this if this is still considered part of your wellness visit. Some doctors, you know, would consider it part of the wellness visit, and other ones might add on an additional charge for chatting about that.
Marielle Segarra
Okay, let's take a common scenario, like say I'm over 40 and I'm eligible for routine mammograms I go and do one, but then I get a bill for it. Does that mean that bill might be wrong?
Jackie Fortier
Yeah, if it meets the preventive guidelines and it was done by an in network provider, it should be covered 100%. No cost to you. You can be billed by accident. You know, the provider may not have submitted the claim to insurance or you get a rejection from insurance, but a rejection in that case that you outlined is often something that you can appeal and win.
Marielle Segarra
Yeah, the billing by accident has happened to me too many times to count. It's so annoying because you get this bill and it says due upon receipt in all caps, Right. And then you look on your insurance company website and you can see a claim was never submitted. And then you call the medical billing office and you say, like, what's the deal? Why didn't you submit this claim? And either they submitted it to the wrong insurance company and then gave up and just billed me, or they just didn't submit it and they're like, oh, that was an error. Our system just sent that out. Disregard. But I could have, in the meantime paid that bill and they wouldn't have told me. Probably.
Jackie Fortier
Yeah. And I mean, like you're describing, it's really annoying to have to babysit them and make sure that it's done correctly, but it can end up costing you a lot of money that you shouldn't have to pay.
Marielle Segarra
Okay. And if you do see that they submitted the claim, but my health insurance isn't covering it, or they're only covering part of it, what do you do from there?
Jackie Fortier
Yeah. So first things first. Don't panic. It looks scary. Insurance companies really count on people giving up, but in many cases, appeals do work. So a tip to remember is not to take the first no as the final answer. It's really just a starting point. It's more like, you know, we said no for now unless you speak up. So make sure to speak up. And that being said, it is hard. It is time consuming. I talked to Anna Deutscher, whose baby son needs hearing tests every few months that her insurance wouldn't cover. And she would spend her lunch breaks on the phone with the insurance company. It feels like the burden goes on the person who's just trying to get health care. I don't need to also make sure that the hospital codes it correctly and the insurance company covers it properly. And I should be worried about him, not about what other people's jobs should be to do properly.
Marielle Segarra
It's so upsetting.
Jackie Fortier
Yeah. I mean, she fought for months to get $1,200 of preventive hearing tests covered because it really strapped her family financially to pay out of pocket. So, you know, if you feel like Anna, we are here to talk about the steps to take to fight it, because you are not alone and you haven't done anything wrong.
Marielle Segarra
Yeah, that's a really good reminder. So, okay, I'm looking at the letter or the insurance company portal. They say this preventative service wasn't covered or was only partially covered. What do I do?
Jackie Fortier
So read that rejection document carefully. The insurance company has to tell you why they aren't covering the claim. And everyone who's who has had care denied has the right to appeal. So we're going to talk about what that means. When it's preventive care, you usually get an explanation of benefits. That is not a bill, but it lists the cost of your care and how much the insurance company will pay and then what you owe. So it might say something like not medically necessary or not a covered benefit. It is insurance speak. But it's important to figure out why they told you no. And then if it's not clear, call them. There's a customer service number on the back of your card. Be polite, ask questions. Write down everything who you talk to and what they said. And if you can get it in writing, that's even better.
Marielle Segarra
So it sounds like get the reason, not just the rejection.
Jackie Fortier
Yeah, exactly. You need to know why they said no in order to fight it. And then you can appeal the denial. And this is called an internal appeal because it's within the company. You don't need to be a lawyer to do it. You're just asking the insurer to reconsider their decision not to pay for a certain portion of your care. So pull up your insurance policy. It's usually called a summary plan description. It'll tell you what's covered, what's not, and then what hoops you have to jump through to appeal it.
Marielle Segarra
Okay. In the meantime, right, I'm dealing with the insurance company, but maybe I've also gotten a bill from the medical billing office or the hospital. What do I do with that? Like, can I call them and say, I'm still working this out with my insurance, so I'm not gonna pay y' all yet. Cause I think this should have been covered.
Jackie Fortier
Yes, you absolutely should call the billing department and tell them the situation. If you're in the appeals process, they can't collect from you, but you need to get that clock going. You may have up to six months, but you Know, it's best to get the ball rolling and start collecting the documents that you'll need for an appeal, which takes time. And be sure to check the denial letter for your exact deadlines. So the best thing to do is don't ignore it. Don't put the bill on a credit card, because then it changes it into credit card debt, and you lose a bunch of protections that you have with medical debt. So contact the billing office and tell them that you're appealing it.
Marielle Segarra
Okay. And can you walk me through the steps to do this?
Jackie Fortier
Yeah, totally. So a lot of the time, there's an appeal form that you'll need to fill out. It's likely on your insurer's website. If you can't find it online, look at your explanation of benefits.
Marielle Segarra
Okay. And what kinds of documents would I need to gather?
Jackie Fortier
Yeah, so this is really important. Back the appeal up with medical evidence. You'll want to write a letter explaining why you disagree with the rejection. Then include any relevant medical records or test results. And if it's a service that's supposed to be preventive, include a copy of the federal regulations that say so. And if you can get a letter from your doctor, this can be a big help. Something along the lines of, this treatment is medically necessary and preventive for this patient, you know, because. And then their medical reasoning from the doctor. That kind of support really does carry weight within the appeals process. So let's say your insurance denied coverage for a mental health screening, which is something that should be covered. Your appeal letter might say, I'm appealing the claim rejection related to mental health screening. On April 1, the insurance company stated it was not preventive, but in this supporting document, it's listed as a preventive service. Enclosed is a letter from my doctor, Dr. Smith, who explained why it's medically necessary. So think of it like making a case in court. Appeals are not about emotion. They're about documentation.
Marielle Segarra
Okay, so I shouldn't include in the letter how this has affected me financially or how mad I am about their mishandling of this?
Jackie Fortier
Yeah. Unfortunately, that won't help your case. It might feel cathartic, but you want to make it, you know, short, sweet, and factual.
Marielle Segarra
All right, so you gather those documents, you write your letter, then you just hit submit and see what happens?
Jackie Fortier
Not quite. You want to make sure that they actually receive it. So either upload it to that portal, they usually have one online, or you can send it via certified mail. Some people feel more comfortable that way. And that way, you have proof that it was delivered. And then of course, keep copies of everything, you know, for your own records. Make sure to keep an eye on your credit report and make sure that that bill isn't showing up as an unpaid or delinquent or anything like that. And then, you know, in some cases they might say to your appeal, you know what, we screwed up our bad. We should have covered you. So make sure that you get that in writing that they have decided to cover you. And then keep an eye on your credit report and hang on to that confirmation in writing for about a year. Okay?
Marielle Segarra
This is all so annoying. It's so annoying, Jackie. Like you just went to the doctor. You had to take time off of work to go to the doctor. You know, you had to call up and sit on the phone to make the appointment and listen to the hold music. You had to go in and get prodded when you get a pap smear or when you get your blood taken. And then on top of it, you have to do this.
Jackie Fortier
It shouldn't be this way. And I mean, a lot of people, people have lives, right? So you could be like Anna, who I was talking about earlier, who needs those hearing tests for her son that should have been covered. I mean, you know, she was getting over giving birth, going back to work, working her full time job, having a newborn, and then gets this diagnosis that he needs these intermittent hearing tests. She has all this on top of then, you know, on her lunch hours, fighting with the insurance company in order to pay for it. It's awful.
Marielle Segarra
Coming up, we'll talk about your options if the insurance company denies your appeal, you do have options. That's after the break.
Sponsor Announcer
This message comes from Charles Schwab with their original podcast Choiceology, hosted by Katie Milkman, an award winning behavioral scientist and author of the best selling book how to Change. Choiceology is a show about the psychology and economics behind people's decisions. Hear true stories from Nobel laureates, historians, authors, athletes and more about why people do the things they do. Download the latest episode and subscribe@schwab.com podcast or wherever you listen.
Capital One / Sponsor Announcer
This message comes from Instacart. Did you see the game last night? Of course you did. Because you used Instacart to do your grocery restock. Plus you got snacks for the game, all without missing a single play. And that's multitasking. So Instacart isn't saying it's a hack for game day, but it might be the ultimate play this football season. Enjoy zero dollar delivery fees on your first three orders. Service fees apply. Valid on three orders within 14 days. Excludes restaurants, instacart. We're here.
Marielle Segarra
Okay, we're back with Life Kit. Jackie, what if the insurance company says no to your appeal?
Jackie Fortier
You still have options. Some people win on the second try. If they say no again, do not give up. Okay, so our next tip is you can request an external medical review. This is when an independent health professional takes a look at your case and they decide whether your health plan should cover it. This is like the Supreme Court of Health decisions. Their decision is final and you cannot appeal it.
Capital One / Sponsor Announcer
But.
Jackie Fortier
But it's unbiased, it's medically based, and it is legally binding for your insurance company.
Marielle Segarra
Okay, so it's like a neutral third party that could say, hey, this person actually does need that care.
Jackie Fortier
Yeah. And the best part is you don't have to figure it out alone. A lot of states have people that will help you through this process for free. Of course, it depends on the state you live in. Sometimes it's your state department of insurance or the Attorney General's office. There's also a lot of nonprofit consumer assistance programs, but usually, I mean, they're used to people not knowing which one to go to. So you can call, like, the AG's office and say, hey, I have this problem, and they'll direct you as to where you can go to get help.
Marielle Segarra
Okay. Is that where you start if you want an external medical review? Like, how do you actually request that?
Jackie Fortier
The insurance company has to tell you how to do it in the documents that they send you. They're required by law to tell you that you have the option to do an external medical review and the steps that you have to follow. But it's usually really buried and in this kind of legalese that can be hard to read. So I would definitely recommend that people go and get help from folks, usually at the state level. A lot of them have really good information on their website, surprisingly.
Marielle Segarra
How often does this work, the external medical review?
Jackie Fortier
Pretty often. It's surprising. I talked with Mary Watanabe, who's the head of the California Department of Managed Healthcare, and she said something that really surprised me.
Marielle Segarra
72% of health fund members that come to us and file an independent medical review end up getting the service that they requested. Those are good odds.
Jackie Fortier
Yeah. I mean, 7 in 10 people get the service paid for. I mean, that's. That's pretty great.
Marielle Segarra
Do you have to find the third party who does this review, or is that provided by either the insurance company or your state regulatory agency?
Jackie Fortier
No, it's provided by the insurance company. The external medical reviewer, the health professional can be part of, like, a third party that they have to contract and pay for. But under federal health law, they have to have an external medical review person. Sometimes there might be a little bit of a fee associated with it. Like, it's nominal, though. It's like 20 bucks.
Marielle Segarra
How long does the external medical review usually take?
Jackie Fortier
So the standard review can take up to 45 days. But if it's urgent, like, your health is at serious risk, you can request an expedited review, and that gets decided in seven days or less.
Marielle Segarra
What if the medical reviewer does not side with you and you don't get this service approved?
Jackie Fortier
Yeah. So this is kind of the point where a lot of people may feel hopeless. You've done all this work. You've filed, you know, multiple appeals. Now this independent doctor says, nope, this isn't preventive care. Insurance doesn't have to cover it. I asked Bernita Haynes, senior attorney at the National Consumer Law center, what should people do? You still have some options to either negotiate the bill with a provider or if you were uninsured at the time or underinsured at the time, depending on your state, you still may have time to apply for financial assistance for the bill. So all nonprofit hospitals, and a lot of hospitals are nonprofit, have to offer financial assistance, so you can apply for that if you don't qualify. Here's another tip. You can contact the doctor's office or the hospital billing department and ask them to lower the bill. It sounds kind of outlandish, but you can do that. Hanes said they just want to get paid. You know, if you offer cash, sometimes there's a discount. And then if they agree to that, make sure to get the negotiated amount in writing. If it's a payment plan, make sure there's no interest being charged and no late fees.
Marielle Segarra
We did an episode on how to lower your medical bills, and one tip we got was to ask them, what's the settlement amount? Like, how much would you take today to close this account if I gave you?
Jackie Fortier
It kind of feels like buying a used car.
Marielle Segarra
Yeah. Yeah, you can do it. Like, you don't think to try to haggle over your medical debt, but it is possible. One other thing I've been wondering about. You know, a lot of us get our health insurance through work. Can your job help at all when your insurance company says no to a service that you think should be covered?
Jackie Fortier
Yeah, they can. If you have insurance through your employer, get in touch with your human resources Department and let them know what's going on. Do you remember Anna Deutscher, whose son needed the hearing tests? I talked about her earlier. Yeah, that's what she did. And it worked. I also have never gone to my HR for something like this before. I didn't even know this was an option. She told HR her son would need these hearing tests for years. Her employer decided to pay Anna back for the tests she'd already paid out of pocket for. They also said they'd add hearing exams for everyone on their insurance in the next plan year, but not as preventive. That means Anna will have a copay for the next round of hearing tests. That's a little irritating because the company never said that they should have covered his hearing tests from the start as preventive. Our expert's reading of federal law was that Anna shouldn't have to pay a copay at all. But overall, Anna's happy that she won't have to pay the full cost of his hearing tests, you know, for years to come.
Marielle Segarra
Hmm. Yeah. I mean, I'm glad it's at least somewhat taken care of, but that is annoying. I think, though, this is a good tip. In general, if you're having an issue with your health insurance denying claims that you think should be covered whether it's a preventative service or not, go to hr. Right. Because there might be a pattern. Your coworkers maybe have experienced this too, because of some mistake on the insurance company's end.
Jackie Fortier
Yeah. It could help HR folks, you know, see a trend that they might want to address at the company level with the insurance company. I mean, keep in mind, your employer pays a lot of money for your health insurance, so they should want to get the services provided to their employees that, you know, they're paying for.
Marielle Segarra
Jackie, thank you so much for walking us through this.
Jackie Fortier
Yeah, thank you.
Marielle Segarra
That was KFF health news reporter Jackie Fortier.
Jackie Fortier
All right, it's time for a recap. Takeaway.
Marielle Segarra
One, under federal law, there's a list of preventative services that must be covered by your health insurance plan with no out of pocket costs. They include things like annual physicals, vaccines, and cancer screenings. You can find that list@healthcare.gov Keep in mind, though, whether you're eligible for a particular test will depend on things like your age and your health history. Takeaway two, Health insurance companies do deny these services, and often that's because of an error. So if you get a bill for a service that you think should have been covered, make sure your doctor's office or hospital actually submitted a claim to your insurance first. If they did, then you find out the reason for the denial. Takeaway 3 Go to your insurance company website and file an appeal. You typically have up to 180 days to do this, and you'll need to compile some documents, including a brief letter explaining why you disagree with the denial, your medical records, a copy of the federal Preventative Health Guidelines, and a letter from your doctor stating why the care was necessary. While you wait for an answer, contact the doctor or hospital billing office and tell them you're just disputing the denial with your insurance. Do not pay the bill at this time. Takeaway 4 if your insurance company denies your appeal twice, you can ask for an external medical review, which will be done by a neutral third party. The results of that are binding and takeaway 5 if your claim is still denied, see if you qualify for financial assistance from the hospital based on your income and ask if they'll give you a discount for paying in cash. You can also set up a payment plan with the medical billing office. Don't put the debt on a credit card. You'll lose certain credit protections and have to pay a lot of interest. Do you have a question or a story about navigating the healthcare system? It could be part of an upcoming installment of Healthcare Helpline. You can share your story by following the link in the show Notes of this Episode this episode of Life Kit was produced by Sylvie Douglas. It was edited by Tanya English. Our visuals editor is Beck Harlan and our digital editor is Malika Garib. Meghan Keane is our senior supervising editor and Beth Donovan is our Executive producer. Our production team also includes Andy Taegle, Claire Marie Schneider and Margaret Serino. Engineering support comes from Stacey Abbott and Jay Siz. Fact Checking by Tyler Jones I'm Mariel Segarra. Thanks for listening.
Capital One / Sponsor Announcer
This message comes from Schwab. Everyone has moments when they could have done better, like cutting their own hair or forgetting sunscreen. So now you look like a tomato. Same goes for where you invest. Level up and invest smarter with Schwab. Get market insights, education and human help when you need it. Learn more@schwab.com this message comes from NPR sponsor Shopify. Shopify is the commerce platform behind millions of businesses around the world and 10% of all e commerce in the US from household names like and Gymshark. Get started with your own design studio. With hundreds of ready to use templates, Shopify helps you build a beautiful online store to match your brand's style. If you're ready to sell, you're ready for Shopify. Sign up for your $1 per month trial and start selling today@shopify.com NPR this.
Sponsor Announcer
Message comes from Capital One. The Capital One Venture X business card earns unlimited double miles on every purchase. Capital One what's in your wallet? Terms and conditions apply. Find out more@capitalone.com venturexbusiness.
Episode: What to do when your health insurance denies coverage
Host: Marielle Segarra (NPR)
Guest: Jackie Fortier (KFF Health News)
Date: September 18, 2025
This episode of Life Kit is an essential guide to handling one of the most aggravating aspects of the American healthcare system: what to do when your health insurance denies coverage for preventive care services. Host Marielle Segarra, joined by healthcare journalist Jackie Fortier, breaks down how preventive services should be covered by law, why denials still occur, and—most importantly—how listeners can effectively appeal these decisions. The episode is filled with practical advice, step-by-step instructions, and empowering reminders that you have rights and options.
[03:05]
“Under most circumstances, recommended preventive care is supposed to be covered at no out of pocket cost under the Affordable Care Act.” — Jackie Fortier [03:08]
[03:30–05:44]
“If a health issue comes up...that consult can be billed separately. So the patient could then owe like, a copayment or a deductible charge for that part of the visit.” — Jackie Fortier [04:41]
[05:31–06:43]
“The provider may not have submitted the claim to insurance or you get a rejection from insurance, but a rejection in that case...is often something you can appeal and win.” — Jackie Fortier [05:44]
[07:02–12:08]
“Do not take the first no as the final answer. It’s really just a starting point.” — Jackie Fortier [07:02]
“Appeals are not about emotion. They’re about documentation.” — Jackie Fortier [12:08] “Don’t put the bill on a credit card, because then it changes it into credit card debt, and you lose a bunch of protections.” — Jackie Fortier [10:06]
[15:20–18:11]
“This is like the Supreme Court of Health decisions. Their decision is final...But it’s unbiased, it’s medically based, and it is legally binding for your insurance company.” — Jackie Fortier [15:51]
[18:34–21:42]
“Han[e]s said they just want to get paid. You know, if you offer cash, sometimes there’s a discount.” — Jackie Fortier [19:54]
Validating Frustration:
“Rage because now I have homework to do... Rage because why is our health care system like this?... If you feel rage or frustration or exhaustion or any of the above...that is understandable.” — Marielle Segarra [00:21]
Real-world Struggles:
“I talked to Anna Deutscher, whose baby son needs hearing tests...her insurance wouldn’t cover. She would spend her lunch breaks on the phone... It feels like the burden goes on the person who’s just trying to get health care. I don’t need to also make sure that the hospital codes it correctly.” — Jackie Fortier [07:02]
On Writing the Appeal:
“Keep it short, sweet, and factual.” — Jackie Fortier [12:17]
External Review Success Rates:
“72% of health fund members that come to us and file an independent medical review end up getting the service that they requested. Those are good odds.” — Mary Watanabe (quoted by Marielle Segarra) [17:20]
[22:10–24:36]
Tone: Supportive, practical, validating the frustration many listeners feel while encouraging them to persist and equipping them with concrete steps.
Best For: Anyone who has faced a health insurance denial, is anxious about handling medical bills, or wants to understand their patient rights under current U.S. health law related to preventive care.
“Do not give up.” — Jackie Fortier [15:26]