Why "we should hang out" won't make you real friends

Summary

Life Kit: Why "We Should Hang Out" Won't Make You Real Friends

Host: Marielle Segarra
Guest: Kat Velos (Author of We Should Get Together: The Secret to Cultivating Better Friendships)
Date: February 9, 2026

---

Episode Overview

This episode tackles the tricky terrain of making—and deepening—friendships as adults. Host Marielle Segarra sits down with friendship expert Kat Velos to unpack why the vague promise of “we should hang out” rarely blossoms into a real connection, and offers practical tips for cultivating genuine, lasting friendships. Together, they explore the art of invitation, building momentum, handling rejection, and knowing when (and how) to invest more—or less—in someone new.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Hone Your Friendship Intuition

• Noticing Friend Potential
  • Kat Velos emphasizes listening to your “friendship intuition”—the subtle, physical and emotional cues of being at ease or warm with someone.
  • Not always the most charismatic person; warmth, groundedness, and mutual curiosity matter more.
  • Quote:

    "Notice for sure who you feel that warmth with, who you feel grounded and safe around, who you feel mutual curiosity with." — Kat Velos [03:40]

2. Make Specific and Timely Invitations

• The Problem with "We Should Hang Out"
  • Vague future-oriented invitations rarely work; specificity leads to actual hangouts.
  • Build on shared context: If you met at trivia, invite them to join your team again soon.
  • Act quickly! Delays make connections fizzle.
  • Research by Dr. Jeffrey Hall (University of Kansas): It takes substantial time (30+ hours) in the first few weeks to transform acquaintances into friends.
  • Quote:

    "The more specific you are, the more likely it is that you’re actually going to get together. Pull out your calendar, pick a time, pick a thing to do together, and actually follow through." — Kat Velos [00:46, 09:45]

  • On not waiting:

    "A common mistake ... is they wait too long to see that new acquaintance again, and in that time, the spark can fizzle out." — Kat Velos [05:06]

3. Overcoming Awkwardness and Building Momentum

• Invest more time—more frequently—than you might think:

  • Don’t be afraid to see someone more than once a week at first.
  • Early regular contact gives the relationship a real shot to gather momentum.
  • Don’t worry about feeling “too forward” as long as you allow the friendship to develop naturally.
  • Quote:

    "You don't have to define the relationship right off. It's just a way to learn enough about each other ... to make a really educated guess about, like, do I want to keep going with this person?" — Kat Velos [07:18]

• Choose Interesting Activities

  • Skip the forgettable coffee dates; opt for memorable, context-rich experiences.
  • Research: Unusual activities (e.g., food truck festival, gallery opening) accelerate bonding by creating shared memories and lowering awkwardness.
  • Quote:

    "The more unusual the experience, the stronger the bond." — Kat Velos [10:58]

4. Navigating Rejection and Busy Lives

• Not everyone will reciprocate—don’t take it personally.
• Appreciate honesty and clarity if someone declines; don't invest energy where there is no capacity.
• For busy friends or folks in challenging life seasons, offer “low-effort hangs” (errands, quick check-ins) that fit their current bandwidth.
• Quote:

  "We should be grateful when people are honest with us and about their capacity. ... We can be grateful that they were honest and clear with us so that we don't end up pouring a lot of energy in a direction that this person just has no capacity to meet." — Kat Velos [12:10]

  • Memorable Tip: Meeting a mom friend at school pickup instead of insisting on scheduled outings.

    "Sometimes the best place to meet her is at school pickup. Let's meet in the parking lot." — Kat Velos [13:14]

5. Deepening Friendships Beyond Small Talk

• Move conversations past “How are you?”
• Ask specific, thoughtful, or playful questions for greater intimacy and storytelling:
  • “How has your morning been?”
  • “What’s one way you’re similar to your 16-year-old self?”
  • Priya Parker’s “magical questions”: e.g., “What was the first concert you went to and who took you?”
• Quote:

  "I am an introvert and my social energy, I want to expend it on, like, as nutritious a conversation as possible." — Kat Velos [14:55]

6. Letting Go When It’s Not the Right Fit

• Friendships need not be all or nothing; move people to “outer rings” as needed.
• Most friendships fade naturally—no need for a formal “friend breakup.”
• Research: Americans tend to lose 1-2 friendships a year.
• Quote:

  "You can kind of drift away naturally and then still have it feel amicable when you see each other again." — Kat Velos [17:09]

7. Making Friendships Stick: The Four Seeds of Connection

• Compatibility – Mutual interest and chemistry
• Frequency – Seeing each other often
• Proximity – In-person interaction; face-to-face is “high-fidelity”
• Commitment – Dedication and trust over time
• The more of these present, the greater the odds of a lasting bond.
• Quote:

  "The more of those you do, the better off you'll be." — Kat Velos [19:42]

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• "Everyone says that, but it’s like, no, literally, we really need to get together. Don’t just say that as a substitute for, 'It was nice to meet you.'" — Kat Velos [09:45]

• "If you pick something that's just a little bit more interesting, it's going to amp up the excitement that both people have to show up and not cancel." — Kat Velos [10:34]

• "It doesn’t mean that all four [seeds of connection] have to be at 100%. ... But the more of them you have, the more likely it is that it’ll work.” — Kat Velos [18:25]

---

Important Timestamps

• 00:46: Kat Velos outlines how specificity leads to actual get-togethers
• 03:40: Discussing “friendship intuition”
• 05:06: The importance of following up soon after meeting someone new
• 09:45: Why vague invitations (“we should hang out sometime”) don’t work
• 10:58: Choosing memorable activities over default coffee dates
• 12:10: Handling rejection and setting boundaries compassionately
• 13:14: Making time for friends in real-life, “un-Instagrammable” contexts
• 14:55: Moving past small talk to build deeper connections
• 17:09: Letting friendships fade naturally when they’re not a fit
• 18:25: The “four seeds of connection” for lasting friendships

---

Recap of Takeaways

1. Hone your friendship intuition: Notice with whom you feel at ease, mutual curiosity, and warmth.
2. Make specific, timely invitations: Don’t wait or stay vague. Act soon and be clear about your intentions.
3. Accept rejection gracefully: Be thankful for honesty. For busy people, offer realistic, low-effort hangs.
4. Go deeper in conversations: Ask specific, meaningful questions; skip the generic small talk.
5. It’s okay to drift apart: Friendships can fade naturally; not every acquaintance needs to become a close friend.
6. Nurture friendships intentionally: Focus on compatibility, proximity, frequency, and commitment for relationships that stick.

---

This episode offers a friendly yet practical roadmap to adult friendship—grounded in research, real stories, and actionable advice—making the daunting prospect of forging new connections a little less intimidating, and a lot more hopeful.

Transcript

[Commercial Announcer]

This message comes from Whole Foods Market. From big game bites to sideline sips, get everything you need for a watch party victory. Find yellow sale signs all over the store. Instant touchdown. Fuel your game day with big flavors from Whole Foods Market.

[Mariel Segarra]

You're listening to Life Kit from npr. Hey, it's Marielle. You know, when you meet somebody and you're like, you, you could be a great friend. Y' all are just hitting it off. The conversation flows. They make you laugh. You want to know more about them. So you say, hey, we should get together sometime. See, that was your first mistake, because.

[Kat Velos]

The more specific you are, the more likely it is that you're actually going to get together. You know, pull out your calendar, pick a time, pick a thing to do together, and actually follow through.

[Mariel Segarra]

This is Kat Velos, author of a book called We should get the Secret to Cultivating Better Friendships. Kat works directly with people who are having a hard time making friends where they live. And she talks to city leaders and urban planners about designing spaces for connection. Another tip she says, is that if you're actively seeking new friends, consider what kind you're looking for. Kat was working with one woman who realized he you know, I'm not actually looking for a new best friend.

[Kat Velos]

I need somebody who wants to get involved in, like, my new fitness hobby with me, right? And so that has a really different shape than if she was looking for somebody who would be a new best friend or chosen family. And so by realizing that what she needed was an activity buddy, it didn't have to be that deep. You know, they just had to have mutual enthusiasm for doing this activity together.

[Mariel Segarra]

On this episode of Life Kit tips on how to make new friends. Kat and I talk about what she calls friendship intuition, about how to make that first invite, about how much time to spend together in the early days, and about what to do when you realize, you know, I don't actually like this person that much after all. That's coming up after the break.

[Sponsor Announcer]

This message comes from Adobe. You need to make a huge presentation in an hour. Luckily, Adobe Acrobat Studio uses AI and Adobe Express to take your files and generate a presentation in a few clicks. Need a last minute pitch deck? Do that with Acrobat. Need to level up your presentation design. Do that with Acrobat. Have 30 plus documents that need to be simplified into a proposal. Do that with Acrobat. Learn [e-mail] do that with Acrobat. This message comes from Synchrony bank, who can help you get your do nothing savings off the couch and working hard. No more sleeping late and eating all the chips. Time to start earning your keep in a big way with their high Yield Savings account that has a great rate, easy access to your funds, and no monthly fees or minimum balance requirements. Put your lazy savings to work. Go to synchrony.com NPR member FDIC Kat.

[Mariel Segarra]

Let'S talk about how to spot a potential friend in the wild. So maybe this is in a community space or at a group dinner or at a bar. I wonder, how do you know that someone has friend potential? I think for me it's like when I feel warm around them.

[Kat Velos]

Yes. So this, this touches on like friendship intuition. And sometimes if folks haven't had to intentionally seek out new friendships as an adult, it can be unfamiliar to be like, well, how do I know who to choose or who to prioritize? So I would say notice for sure who you feel that warmth with, who you feel grounded and safe around, who you feel mutual curiosity with. Those things will vary from person to person, like where that vibe lies and, and it's often like, not necessarily the most exciting person in the room. Like, they might have a lot of charisma, magnetic charm, but they might not be who you feel like grounded comfort, warmth. Look for those kinds of feelings and see who you're drawn to. And also notice if they show curiosity about getting to know you more too.

[Mariel Segarra]

Takeaway one. Start to hone your friendship intuition. When you're out there in the world. Check in with your body. Do you feel at ease with this person? Are you relaxed also? Are you curious about them? Do you make each other laugh? Keep in mind though, the funniest or the most charismatic person in the room may not be a very good friend for you. Friendship is about more than charisma. Okay, so let's say you are out in the world and you meet someone and this is the first time you're meeting them, but you do have that feeling, like you seem cool. How might you ask them to hang out if you do want to do that?

[Kat Velos]

So I really suggest that if it's possible to get together again soon and build on the context of your current hangout moment, that's a really natural way to do that. So one example is if you are at Trivia night at the pub and and you're having this great chat with this person that you just met there, ask if they want to be on the same trivia team next week. Or ask if they want to check out Boombox Bingo. That's happening in a couple of days. So that way you're building on the context of how you met, you know, a little bit about where they are, you know, at this particular night. You know, they go to this thing. So it's highly likely that they're going to be willing to hang out there again with you sometime soon. And I want to emphasize the soon in this, because a common mistake that people make when they're trying to get together with a new acquaintance or build a new friendship is they wait too long to see that new acquaintance again, and in that time, the spark can fizzle out. I see it all the time in my work. But there's a really beautiful piece of research that comes out about how long it takes to convert an acquaintance into a friend or even into a best friend. It comes from the work of Dr. Jeffrey hall at University of Kansas, and he quantified how many hours it takes to convert a stranger into a friend and more than 30 for a casual friend. And it really needs to be compressed, preferably in those first several weeks of meeting each other. And so this research kind of confirms what your intuition might say, which is, like, if you spend a lot of time together when the relationship is new, it's more likely to stick. And this is absolutely true. A lot of times, adults will follow some kind of arbitrary rule that says you can't hang out two days in a row, or you can't see somebody more than once a week. And unfortunately, this is why so many friendships fizzle out.

[Mariel Segarra]

Okay, this might reveal something about my personality, but I would be a little worried to hang out with someone too much right away, someone who I just met because I wouldn't want to rush into being, like, now we're such good friends. And then you realize you don't know them at all, or you being your true self is, like, annoying to them. But now you're too deep in. I mean, I feel this way about romantic entanglements, too. It's often. It feels like a good idea to kind of set boundaries early on. Yeah.

[Kat Velos]

And it doesn't mean that. That you're pretending to be besties right away or that you're calling yourself besties right away. You don't have to define the relationship right off. It's just a way to learn enough about each other in a short enough amount of time that you can make a really educated guess about, like, do I want to keep going with this person? But if you have coffee for, you know, 45 minutes once a month, it's going to be hard to learn enough about each other in any sort of efficient time frame to know if you should keep going.

[Mariel Segarra]

So we've talked about when you met someone out in the world. Maybe it's the first time you met them. But there are also instances where someone's currently more of an acquaintance or they're a work friend. You know, like you're friendly with them, but you haven't hung out outside of work. Or maybe you play on a sports team with them, but you haven't hung out outside of that. How might you see if there's a friendship to be had there?

[Sponsor Announcer]

Yeah.

[Kat Velos]

So to talk about, like the work example, it's useful to start by developing your at work friendship. So in that case, it could be going to some work events together and chatting afterwards. Right. So if there's a cool workshop that the employee resource group is hosting, that's a social event you can attend with this work friend. Right. Or if there's a team lunch or some other kind of after work happy hour, like within the work context, you can simply hang out with them more and then get together to, like, chat or debrief or, you know, how was that for you? Sort of thing. What did you think about that? And learn more about each other within that context and simply be work friends. And then if you feel like this person's pretty cool, I'd actually like to be not work friends with them. Then you can tell them, hey, if you ever want to hang out outside of work, feel free to invite me. I would say yes, you know, and invite them to say, hey, would you like to hang out outside of work sometime? I would love to spend some more time with you.

[Mariel Segarra]

Okay. Takeaway 2. You meet somebody cool, ask them to hang out and do it soon. Especially if this is someone you only met once, because the more time passes, the less likely you are to get together. Also, let's say they say yes and you're hitting it off. Consider hanging out more often than you think you should. You don't have to pretend you're besties right away. Just invest enough time so you can gather some momentum and you can both consider whether this friendship is a good fit. As for what to do together, if you meet them in a certain context, like, let's say playing softball, Suggest something adjacent, like, want to go to the batting cages next week? Kat says you should offer a specific invitation, not just say, hey, we should hang out sometime.

[Kat Velos]

Oh, yeah. Because that we should hang out sometime sometime is a vague sense in the future. And this is part of why, you know, my book is called we should get together. Because Everyone says that, but it's like, no, literally, we really need to get together. Don't just say that as a substitute for it was nice to meet you. Say it if you really mean it and then follow through on it. And the more specific you are, the more likely it is that you're actually going to get together. You know, pull out your calendar, pick a time, pick a thing to do together, and actually follow through. And I want to say a thing here about what often happens is like the default hangout, which is a coffee date. Coffee dates are fine. A lot of people default to them for a first date. But I also want to say that coffee is kind of, kind of forgettable. It kind of doesn't feel that important. It's easy to cancel, and it doesn't give you a lot of fodder for conversation. So if you pick something that's just like a little bit more interesting, it's going to amp up the excitement that both people have to show up and like, not cancel. So, like, if you tell me you're into knitting, I might be like, hey, there's an event happening at the yarn store, you know, or like, there's this gallery exhibit of like really cool yarn art. Do you want to go? You're probably more likely to say yes because it's like something you actually care about and it sounds interesting, right? And there's another benefit I just want to mention here because I love this. So researchers at Cornell University found that when people who don't know each other very well do an out of the ordinary experience together, it actually bonds them a lot faster than doing a run of the mill activity, like just another coffee. And the more unusual the experience, the stronger the bond. Because when we do something that's like a little unusual, people get distracted by the details and they forget to focus on feeling awkward. So it takes away the discomfort of hanging out with somebody you don't know that well. Because that novelty draws both of your attention. And it also gives you a memory that you can have together, like, oh, we went to this classic car show, or we like went to this vegan food truck festival and that's your meet cute. You know, it's going to be a lot more memorable than like, hey, buddy, remember that latte? Like, nobody's going to remember that latte, but you're going to remember that lecture about psychedelics or whatever.

[Mariel Segarra]

So when you ask someone to hang out, they, they might not be interested or they might say something like, you know, I have young kids and I have no time True. I love talking to you. I love hanging out with you. I love being your work friend. And I am not a reliable friend right now outside of work. And that's okay, too.

[Kat Velos]

And that is totally okay, too. And. And I think we should be grateful when people are honest with us and about their capacity. They might say, I really like you. You're great. I really don't have any time for new friends in my life. I am so sorry. You know, and we can be grateful that they were honest and clear with us so that we don't end up pouring a lot of energy in a direction that this person just has no capacity to meet. And sometimes that line is very clear like that where it's like kind of a no. And try not to take that personal takeaway 3.

[Mariel Segarra]

If someone seems unenthused about your invite or. Or if they make no effort to follow up or they flat out say, no, let it go. It's just not a good fit. If they say something like, I would truly love to, but this is a busy season for me. My kids have all these extracurriculars or I'm taking care of a sick parent. You can tell them that you are open to hanging out if and when they free up and you can lower the bar to entry for them. Don't be pushy, but you can offer a lower effort. Hang and try to meet them in this moment. This also works with existing friends.

[Kat Velos]

And so sometimes it just means being creative and being willing to not do a, like, Instagrammable thing together, but actually just getting in each other's real life. You know, I have a friend who has three small kids and sometimes, like, the best place to meet her is like at school pickup. And I'm just like, let's meet in the parking lot. Yeah, let's hang out while you're waiting for your kid to come out of school. You know, and that's okay. It can be something that fits into your regular life. And that's often where friendships take on the flavor of chosen family is because we're fitting the friend into the context of our real life and not blocking it off for a box in the calendar away from the rest of our life.

[Mariel Segarra]

I think that's really sweet.

[Kat Velos]

I do, too. I love it.

[Mariel Segarra]

We'll have more Life Kit after the break. Foreign.

[Sponsor Announcer]

This message comes from NPR's sponsor, Shopify. No idea where to sell. Shopify puts you in control of every sales channel. It is the commerce platform revolutionizing millions of businesses worldwide. Whether you're a garage entrepreneur or ipo, Ready. Shopify is the only tool you need to start, run and grow your business without the struggle. Once you've reached your audience, Shopify has the Internet's best converting checkout to help you turn them from browsers to buyers. Go to shopify.com to take your business to the next level Today.

[Mariel Segarra]

What are some other ways we can really go deeper with new friends? Start to get to know them? Like I think you had an Instagram post where you talked about things to say instead of how are you?

[Kat Velos]

Yes. Yes. So that was born out of the frustration that I have with small talk. I am an introvert and my social energy, I want to expend it on like as nutritious a conversation as possible. And a lot of folks that I know also that I meet through my work are like frustrated with small talk or frustrated with like surface level conversations. My beef with how are you? Is we use it as a greeting and it's not always clear how interested the person really is and how you're really doing. So you have to ask it differently if you really want to hear how someone's really, really doing. Sometimes it is just like you want to check in with somebody on how they're doing, but it's more useful to ask a specific question like, how has your morning been? Right? How are you feeling, you know, on this Monday? Or whatever. And then it's really clear that they really do want to hear, you know, how was her morning? And you can say like, I'm doing great or I have cramps or whatever. And then other times it can be just something a little bit more interesting that helps you learn more about this person or that feels a little bit playful. You know, you can do this in friendship. You can do this at work too. So starting a meeting with the question, you know, what's one way that you're similar to who you were as a 16 year old? And like, what's one way you're different? And it can reveal some really fun storytelling or interesting, like meaningful identity pieces. And it's more interesting than just, hey, so like, yeah, it's like snowing again or it's raining or it's hot again.

[Mariel Segarra]

Takeaway 4. As you get to know your new friend, ask questions that allow them to open up to you. Not just how are you? But how was your morning or how did that thing go for you? You can also consider some of the magical questions that Priya Parker, the author of the Art of Gathering, told us about in another episode of Life Kit. These work well for groups, but they also work one on one. What was the first concert you went to and who took you? When was the last time you went all in on celebrating something or someone? What's the weirdest thing you've ever found in your pocket? Now, as you do spend time with this new friend of yours, you may discover that you're actually not that into them. What about if you have started hanging out and you're just like, oh, I don't actually like them that much, or they annoy me or they, I seem to annoy them.

[Kat Velos]

Yeah. So it's okay to be like, okay, we're not going to take this train all the way to the bestie station at the end of the track, you know, but instead you can decide if it's really like, I actually want to stop seeing them or if you simply want to move them into the outer ring of connection. Because there really are rings. There's like your inner circle. There's the next ring of like friends you might invite to your birthday party the next spring of like, I would be happy if I saw them randomly, but I'm not going to seek them out. And then it's like, it's okay if we're strangers, you know, and so you can decide like, okay, I'm not going to keep moving them into the inner ring, but it's okay if I see them randomly, it's okay if I bump into them at someone else's party, but we don't have to keep hanging out and you don't have to like full on dump them. Like the majority of friendships. This is super interesting. So research found that Americans or adults in general tend to lose one to two friendships a year. And it doesn't usually come from a full on breakup. Usually friendships just fade away and if you stop reaching out, unless they're super, super into you, they might stop reaching out. And so you can kind of drift away naturally and then still have it feel amicable when you see each other again, you know, okay, so let's say.

[Mariel Segarra]

You do have a new friend. It's going well, you know, you've been out a few times. What are some ways that you can try to make the friendship stick?

[Kat Velos]

So there's four seeds of connection. I describe this in my book. These four seeds of connection are the four elements that if they are present, it is more likely that this friendship is going to last. And it doesn't mean that all four of them have to be at 100%. You know, it will vary from person to person, but the more of them you have, the more likely it is that it'll work. So, so the first one is compatibility. So hopefully there's enough mutual interest there in chemistry that you want to keep going. And then from there it's frequency, proximity, and commitment. And the more of that you have, the more likely it is that this friendship will stick and last. So frequency, right? It's like how often are you seeing each other? Proximity is how much time can you spend face to face? How close can you be? And this might be long distance where you might increase your frequency because you're not going to be face to face. But if you have the chance to be face to face, get that time. It's a much more high fidelity connection than being at a distance. And over time, if you're both committed, you're both dedicated. Keep fostering that commitment through trust, through vulnerability, through all of those things that help us feel closer. And so compatibility, frequency, proximity, and commitment. Pay attention to those four things and the more of those you do, the better off you'll be.

[Mariel Segarra]

Okay, Kat, thank you so much.

[Kat Velos]

Thank you so much.

[Mariel Segarra]

Okay, time for a recap. Consider what kinds of friends you're looking for. Do you want a new best friend? An activity buddy? Someone you can see once a week, once a month, and then. Takeaway 1 Hone your friendship intuition. When you're meeting people, ask yourself, do I feel at ease with this person? Am I curious about them? Do we make each other laugh? Does there seem to be mutual interest? Takeaway 2. When you meet someone with friend potential, ask them to hang out and do it soon. And consider seeing them more often than you think you should. You want to give yourselves a real chance to suss out the friendship and gather momentum. Also, be specific when you invite them out. Don't just say, hey, we should hang out sometime. Takeaway 3. If someone says no to your offer of friendship, that's okay. Let it go. And if someone does seem genuinely interested, but they say, listen, I'm in a really busy season right now with my kids or moving into this new house, but I do like you and I'd love to hang out. Let them know you're down for a low effort. Hang too. Walk to the train together. Run errands, Wait in line at the pharmacy. This approach is probably best for people you already know and want to get closer to, not for the stranger you just met at the bar. Takeaway 4. As you get to know your new friend, go beyond how are you to ask questions that actually allow them to open up. And as you spend time with them, you may discover that you're not that into them or this friendship, and that is okay. There are so many potential friends out there in the world. All right, that's our show. By the way, before you go, have you been lifting weights recently?

[Sponsor Announcer]

Yeah.

[Mariel Segarra]

You want to dig deeper into the science of strength training? We have a special playlist with our favorite episodes about strength. Become a subscriber to LifeKit plus to get exclusive access to this and other Life Kit playlists that'll help you start moving your body, master your budget, get better sleep and more. Sign [e-mail] LifeKit this episode of Life Kit was produced by Mika Ellison and Margaret Serino. Our visuals editor is Beck Harlan and our digital editor is Malika Garib. Megan Kane is our senior supervising editor and Beth Donovan is our executive producer. Our production team also includes Andy Taegle, Claire Marie Schneider and Sylvie Douglas. Engineering support comes from Tiffany Vera Castro. I'm Mariel Segarra. Thanks for listening.

[Commercial Announcer]

Foreign. This message comes from Capital One. Capital One offers checking accounts with no fees or minimums. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See capitalone.combank for details. Capital One NA Member FDIC.