Podcast Summary: Limited Supply – S11 E1: New Year, New Nik: Overrated, Underrated, and More

Host: Nik Sharma
Release Date: January 13, 2025
Duration: Approximately 30 minutes
Podcast Description: Limited Supply delves into the real challenges and strategies of building and scaling Direct-to-Consumer (DTC) brands. Host Nik Sharma, founder of Sharma Brands, engages in candid discussions with industry veterans, offering unfiltered insights and provocative takes on current industry practices.

Episode Overview

In the premiere episode of Season 11, titled "New Year, New Nik: Overrated, Underrated, and More," Nik Sharma reflects on the podcast's direction and introduces a bold approach to dissecting widely debated marketing tactics within the DTC landscape. The episode is structured around identifying overrated and underrated marketing strategies, providing listeners with actionable insights to optimize their brand's performance.

Overrated Marketing Tactics

Nik begins by addressing several marketing strategies he deems ineffective or wasteful for growing DTC brands. He categorizes these tactics as overrated, explaining why they may not yield the expected returns.

1. Top of Funnel Facebook Ads

Timestamp: 05:30

Nik criticizes the reliance on top-of-funnel Facebook ads, especially for brands generating up to $75 million in revenue. He argues that these ads often result in low engagement and poor conversion rates.

Nik Sharma [05:32]: "Top of funnel Facebook ads are a total waste of money. You do not need to run top-of-funnel on Facebook for the most part."

2. Programmatic Display Ads

Timestamp: 10:15

Drawing from his early career experiences, Nik highlights the inefficiencies of programmatic display ads. He emphasizes that without substantial ad spend, these campaigns rarely drive meaningful conversions.

Nik Sharma [10:20]: "Programmatic display on its own does nothing. If you just have display ads running, nothing happens."

3. Loyalty and Referral Programs

Timestamp: 15:45

While acknowledging the success of loyalty programs for large retailers like Sephora and Nordstrom, Nik argues that for brands selling one-off or non-consumable products, such programs often fail to deliver incremental profits.

Nik Sharma [16:00]: "If your business model is a loyalty program, it probably works well. But for a brand selling a single product, loyalty programs don't necessarily matter."

4. Paying for Influencer Management Software

Timestamp: 20:10

Nik expresses his disdain for costly influencer management platforms that lock brands into long-term contracts without delivering proportional value. He advocates for organic discovery and relationship-building with influencers instead.

Nik Sharma [20:15]: "I don't like paying for influencer management softwares. Finding your own talent and building relationships organically is so much better."

5. Coupon Extensions like Honey and Capital One Shopping

Timestamp: 25:30

Nik exposes the deceptive practices of coupon extensions, revealing how they exploit affiliate programs to siphon profits from brands. He strongly recommends brands to exclude such extensions from their affiliate strategies.

Nik Sharma [25:35]: "Honey is going to steal 10% by exploiting checkout processes. These are scammers and should be banned."

6. Paid User-Generated Content (UGC)

Timestamp: 28:50

Critiquing the ineffectiveness of paid UGC, Nik points out that much of the content produced resembles blatant advertisements, which fails to resonate with audiences authentically.

Nik Sharma [28:55]: "Most of the UGC looks like an ad from a mile away. Authentic customer-generated content is the way to go."

7. Building Landing Pages Outside Shopify

Timestamp: 32:20

Nik advises against using separate landing page builders like Unbounce for Shopify stores. He advocates leveraging Shopify 2.0's capabilities to create optimized, scalable landing pages directly within the platform.

Nik Sharma [32:25]: "Everything you build for a landing page should just be built into Shopify. There's no reason to pay extra for separate landing page software."

8. Sporadic Influencer and Event Marketing

Timestamp: 36:10

He warns against inconsistent spending on influencer collaborations and event sponsorships without a clear strategy, which often leads to unmeasurable returns.

Nik Sharma [36:15]: "Don't just spend to spend on influencers or events. Have a proper strategy or you'll end up with nothing attributable to your investment."

9. Non Net New Customer Acquisition

Timestamp: 40:00

Nik emphasizes the importance of focusing on acquiring new customers rather than re-engaging existing ones, especially in high-consumable product categories.

Nik Sharma [40:05]: "Ensure your campaigns are aimed at net new customer acquisition. Avoid channels that drive repeat orders unless that's your primary goal."

10. Overpaying PR Agencies

Timestamp: 44:30

Critiquing the high costs of PR agencies, Nik suggests reallocating budgets towards creator-focused strategies that offer broader reach and better ROI.

Nik Sharma [44:35]: "Instead of paying $25k to PR agencies for limited exposure, invest in creators who can generate thousands of videos daily for greater visibility."

Underrated Marketing Tactics

Shifting focus, Nik highlights several underrated strategies that can significantly enhance a brand's growth when properly implemented.

1. Increasing Email and SMS Opt-In Rates

Timestamp: 48:00

Nik stresses the critical impact of boosting email and SMS opt-in rates, which can unlock substantial revenue from welcome series campaigns.

Nik Sharma [48:05]: "Leverage tools like Black Crow and Alia to increase your opt-in rates from 4-7% to around 15%, capturing an additional 8% of your traffic for revenue."

2. Collecting and Syndicating Product Reviews

Timestamp: 52:15

He underscores the importance of gathering extensive product reviews and distributing them across multiple platforms to build robust social proof.

Nik Sharma [52:20]: "Aggressively collect reviews and syndicate them across platforms. A combined total of 5,000 reviews can vastly outperform having just 500 on your site."

3. Responding to Every Ad Comment

Timestamp: 56:40

Nik advocates for engaging with every comment on ads to enhance performance and reduce CPMs, recommending dedicated personnel to manage this task.

Nik Sharma [56:45]: "Responding to every single comment can significantly improve your ad performance. Hire dedicated talent to manage these interactions effectively."

4. Optimizing Product Detail Pages (PDP) Across Platforms

Timestamp: 60:00

He advises ensuring that all product pages, including those on marketplaces like Amazon and TikTok Shop, are optimized with compelling content and consistent branding to maximize conversions.

Nik Sharma [60:05]: "Optimize all your PDPs, not just on Shopify. High-quality content across all platforms reflects your brand and boosts conversion rates."

Conclusion and Future Directions

Nik wraps up the episode by reflecting on the changes implemented for Season 11, such as shorter episode durations and the potential introduction of co-host elements to rekindle the show's dynamic energy.

Nik Sharma [65:30]: "I'm excited to bring back the fun element and make Limited Supply pop again. Your feedback is crucial, so reach out with your ideas to help shape the future of the podcast."

He hints at dedicating future episodes to deeper dives into underrated strategies, encouraging listeners to express their interest if they find the topic valuable.

Nik Sharma [67:00]: "If you like the underrated part, let me know. I'll create a whole episode focused solely on these essential yet overlooked strategies."

Nik concludes by reaffirming his commitment to providing honest, behind-the-scenes insights into the DTC industry, promising more engaging and provocative content in upcoming episodes.

Notable Quotes:

• On Top of Funnel Facebook Ads:

  "Top of funnel Facebook ads are a total waste of money. You do not need to run top-of-funnel on Facebook for the most part."
  – Nik Sharma [05:32]

• On Programmatic Display Ads:

  "Programmatic display on its own does nothing. If you just have display ads running, nothing happens."
  – Nik Sharma [10:20]

• On Loyalty Programs:

  "If your business model is a loyalty program, it probably works well. But for a brand selling a single product, loyalty programs don't necessarily matter."
  – Nik Sharma [16:00]

• On Influencer Management Software:

  "I don't like paying for influencer management softwares. Finding your own talent and building relationships organically is so much better."
  – Nik Sharma [20:15]

• On Coupon Extensions:

  "Honey is going to steal 10% by exploiting checkout processes. These are scammers and should be banned."
  – Nik Sharma [25:35]

• On Paid UGC:

  "Most of the UGC looks like an ad from a mile away. Authentic customer-generated content is the way to go."
  – Nik Sharma [28:55]

• On Landing Pages:

  "Everything you build for a landing page should just be built into Shopify. There's no reason to pay extra for separate landing page software."
  – Nik Sharma [32:25]

• On PR Agencies:

  "Instead of paying $25k to PR agencies for limited exposure, invest in creators who can generate thousands of videos daily for greater visibility."
  – Nik Sharma [44:35]

Key Takeaways

• Avoid Over-Reliance on Ineffective Channels: Nik advises against investing heavily in top-of-funnel Facebook ads, programmatic display ads, and overpriced PR services, as they often do not yield proportional returns for growing DTC brands.

• Embrace Authentic and Organic Strategies: Building genuine relationships with influencers, focusing on authentic user-generated content, and optimizing product pages across all platforms can significantly enhance brand performance.

• Maximize Underrated Opportunities: Enhancing email and SMS opt-in rates, actively managing product reviews, engaging with ad comments, and ensuring all product pages are optimized are crucial strategies that can drive substantial revenue and brand loyalty.

• Strategic Budget Allocation: Redirecting budgets from overrated channels to underrated yet impactful strategies can lead to better ROI and sustainable growth.

Looking Ahead

Nik Sharma hints at exploring more underrated marketing strategies in future episodes, encouraging listeners to provide feedback and suggestions. He emphasizes a return to the podcast's energetic and candid roots, promising more insightful and provocative discussions to help DTC brands navigate the complexities of the industry.

Stay Tuned:
Subscribe to Limited Supply on your preferred podcast platform to ensure you don't miss upcoming episodes that will continue to cut through the noise in CPG, retail, and eCommerce.