Marketing Operators - Episode E051: Why Meta Purchase Conversion Isn’t Enough - Rethinking Ad Optimization for Incremental Growth
Release Date: March 18, 2025
In this insightful episode of Marketing Operators, hosts Connor Rolain, Connor MacDonald, and Cody Plofker tackle a pressing issue in the digital marketing landscape: the limitations of relying solely on Meta's (formerly Facebook) purchase conversion optimization for advertising strategies. They explore alternative approaches to ad optimization aimed at driving incremental growth, sharing personal experiences, strategic insights, and practical recommendations.
1. Introduction to the Challenge
The episode kicks off with the hosts discussing organizational changes and new hires, setting the stage for a deeper dive into marketing strategies. Cody introduces the primary focus:
"Ultimately what we're supposed to do as marketers is drive incremental returns. It feels as if over time Meta has developed the platform in a way that it can very easily become less incremental."
— Cody Plofker [10:28]
2. The Diminishing Returns of Meta Purchase Optimization
Cody and Connor express concerns about Meta's evolving algorithms and their impact on incremental growth:
"Incrementality is not the same as acquisition. It depends on every brand and Meta can still be very incremental, just not as efficiently at reaching new prospects."
— Connor MacDonald [11:34]
They discuss how Meta has shifted focus towards targeting audiences further down the funnel, making it challenging for brands to use Meta as an effective top-of-funnel (ToFu) channel for acquiring new customers.
3. Exploring Alternative Optimization Strategies
To counteract these challenges, the hosts share their experiences with diversifying optimization objectives beyond purchase conversions. Cody highlights a pivotal moment:
"We could tell things were not penciling out from the top line perspective... optimizing for view content like that's performing best was a sign we needed to do something significantly different."
— Cody Plofker [11:34]
Connor adds further depth to this strategy:
"View content optimization focuses on driving browsing visitors rather than direct purchases, which aligns better with our goal of reaching new prospects."
— Connor MacDonald [13:13]
4. Implementing and Measuring Incremental Strategies
The conversation delves into the methodologies for testing and measuring the effectiveness of different campaign optimizations. Sean shares his brand's analytical approach:
"We're running view content optimized campaigns, but the cost per incremental order is just not a number that we would be comfortable with."
— Sean Frank [24:53]
Cody reveals compelling data from their experiments:
"In our top of funnel optimized campaigns, we saw a 5x incrementality factor from what Meta was reporting."
— Cody Plofker [27:37]
They emphasize the importance of using sophisticated tools like House and Prescient to accurately measure incremental returns and inform budget allocations.
5. Case Studies and Real-World Applications
Cody discusses specific case studies demonstrating the effectiveness of diversified optimization:
"In December, we started testing how much budget to allocate to top of funnel, and found this new 'Traditional Flash' campaign was driving 60% of our revenue, proving to be highly incremental."
— Cody Plofker [53:24]
Additionally, Sean references a House case study with Javi Coffee, highlighting the superior incrementality of video ads over image ads:
"They ran video ads as upper funnel and image ads as direct response, finding that the video ads had a significantly higher incrementality factor."
— Sean Frank [45:19]
6. Strategic Recommendations and Best Practices
The hosts offer actionable recommendations for marketers seeking to enhance their ad optimization strategies:
-
Diversify Optimization Objectives:
Move beyond purchase conversions by incorporating objectives like 'view content' to target broader audiences."Identify contributions from each campaign type and prioritize those that drive true incremental and profitable performance."
— Cody Plofker [47:19] -
Implement Rigorous Testing:
Utilize holdout tests and incrementality tools to accurately measure the impact of different ad strategies. -
Allocate Budgets Strategically:
Based on incremental performance data, adjust budget allocations to favor high-impact tactics and reduce spend on underperforming campaigns. -
Invest in Creative Diversity:
Develop a range of creatives tailored to different funnel stages to effectively engage and convert new prospects.
Cody underscores the importance of continual testing and adaptation:
"Identifying contributions from each campaign type and prioritizing those that drive true incremental and profitable performance."
— Cody Plofker [47:19]
7. Conclusions and Takeaways
The episode concludes with a consensus on the necessity of evolving ad optimization strategies in response to changing platform dynamics. The key takeaways include:
-
Understanding Incrementality vs. Acquisition:
Recognize that driving incremental returns is distinct from merely acquiring customers, requiring nuanced strategies. -
Leveraging Advanced Measurement Tools:
Employ tools like House and Prescient to gain accurate insights into ad performance and inform strategic decisions. -
Balancing Creativity with Data-Driven Decisions:
Combine creative innovation with rigorous data analysis to optimize ad campaigns for both performance and incremental growth.
"If you're struggling to reach new people on Meta at a $10 million roll run, you probably have bigger problems... It's about giving things a much bigger effort and not just relying on other channels."
— Connor MacDonald [68:48]
This episode serves as a valuable resource for marketers navigating the complexities of digital advertising on platforms like Meta. By advocating for diversified optimization objectives, robust testing methodologies, and strategic budget allocations, Marketing Operators provides actionable insights to drive sustained, incremental growth in an ever-evolving marketing landscape.