← Mayim Bialik's Breakdown
Mayim Bialik's Breakdown
Premonitions That Came True! Aberfan, Plane Crashes & Death Foretold | New Yorker Staff Writer Sam Knight on Seemingly Impossible Stories of Dreams and Visions Before Catastrophe
01:21:31
Loading summary
Transcript127 lines
- [00:00]
A
John Barker is a psychiatrist at a mental hospital. Hencher rings him up one night and is like, I have a prediction. Barker's like, okay, what is it? Is it another plane? And he's like, no, it's you.
- [00:10]
B
If someone tells you you're gonna die, do you die?
- [00:13]
A
It's the concreteness of those premonitions that then lead on to the forming of.
- [00:17]
B
The Premonitions Bureau journalist Sam Knight. He's a New Yorker staff writer. His book the Premonitions, A True Account of Death, foretold shockingly true stories about precognitive abilities and predictions of future tragedy and even death.
- [00:35]
A
I don't know how you sit down in your kitchen and write down that there's going to be a train crash and you put it in the post on a Wednesday and it happens on a Sunday night.
- [00:44]
B
How many of the things that are predicted do come true?
- [00:47]
A
October 1966. An astonishingly nightmarish thing that happened. Huge coal mining part of the uk. Huge amounts of coal taken out of the ground and they would just pile up the waste of these things. One day, one of these piles of coal waste that had been rained on for weeks and weeks and weeks suddenly dislodged and just rushed down the mountain and buried a school and killed 116 children. John Barker rushes to the village and starts talking to people, uncovering these stories, particularly among the children who, who didn't want to go to school that day told their mom that they'd had a dream and there was something black that came over the school. You can have dreams or bad feelings about kind of various disasters, but the particular configuration of Aberfan is quite striking.
- [01:33]
B
It's something that we all have the ability for and we're just not tapping into it. Is it something that's for a select few or is it somewhere in the middle?
- [01:47]
A
Oh, the car from Carvana's here.
- [01:50]
C
Well, will you look at that. It's exactly what I ordered. Like, precisely.
- [01:55]
A
It would be crazy if there were any catches. But there aren't, right?
- [02:00]
B
Right. Because that's how car buying should be with Carvana. You get the car you want, choose delivery or pickup and a week to love it or return it. Buy your car today with Carvana. Delivery or pickup fees may apply. Limitations and exclusions may apply. See our seven day return policy at Carvana.com Marshall's. Buyers are hustling hard to get amazing new gifts into stores right up to the last minute. Like a designer perfume for that friend who never RSVP'd wishlist topping toys for her kids who came too. Belgian chocolates for the neighbor, a cozy scarf for your boss, and a wool jacket for your husband that you definitely did not. Almost forget. Marshalls, we get the deals. You get the good stuff. Even at the last minute, Find a Marshall's near you. Hi, I'm. I'm Bialik.
- [02:48]
C
And I'm Jonathan Cohen.
- [02:49]
B
And welcome to our Breakdown. Have you ever had a feeling that something was going to happen and then it did? Would you classify yourself as someone who has precognitive abilities? It turns out the ability to anticipate things, even with great specificity is something that occurs all over the world. Why don't we talk about it? Because often it's not right, but the times when it is can be incredibly powerful. And as our guest today is gonna talk about, what if precognitive abilities have the potential to save lives? Do we listen to those messages? Do we not?
- [03:29]
C
We're gonna explore the creation of a department in the UK that explored and gathered precognitive events and tried to test to see if they were real. We're also going to explore how our minds can be influenced.
- [03:48]
B
We're going to be talking with journalist Sam Knight about his book the Premonitions, A true account of Death Foretold. And what the Premonitions Bureau is about. And what we're going to be talking about today is there was a. Is a true story. There was a psychiatrist named John Barker, and he investigated both the power of premonitions as well as the possibility that we can be literally scared to death. Dr. Barker worked as a psychiatrist. He worked with other psychiatrists who were fascinated in talking to patients who had been hospitalized in many cases for psychosis, who had startlingly accurate predictions of very large disasters that happened. And he set out to. To discover what these could mean, how they connect, and if they can tell us anything about our human nature. Sam Knight is the author of the book. He's a New Yorker staff writer, and he's going to tell us how he got interested in the Premonitions Bureau, what he learned about the nature of our potential existence as precognitive beings, and what we can learn from the story of Dr. Barker, who, of course, died mysteriously, as was predicted by two of his patients. Today's episode focuses on shockingly true stories about precognitive abilities and predictions of future tragedy and even death. Break it down. Sam Knight. Welcome to the Breakdown.
- [05:18]
A
Thank you for having me.
- [05:19]
B
I am a huge fan of all things New Yorker, so I'm very excited to get to Talk to you. I feel like you're a celebrity in my mind. I'm gonna hold up an uncorrected proof of. Of the Premonitions Bureau, which, when we got this, I was so excited, not only to read it, but for the opportunity to get to speak with you and really, really appreciate you coming and talking to us.
- [05:43]
A
It's a real pleasure.
- [05:45]
B
There's one thing that I wanna open with. Seeing patterns where they do not exist is something called apophenia. Finding meaning where there is none is a sign of madness. Making connections in what we see, hear, or dream is actually how we think. Finding a pattern no one ever has is genius. Your book takes us directly into the belly of this beast between madness and not only genius, but the possibility that people may have abilities to see into time in a way that we do not understand in any materialist way. Talk about how you. How you found out about the Premonitions Bureau.
- [06:34]
A
I'm a magazine writer. You know, that's what I do. And this was a while ago. This was probably 10 years ago. And I'm normally kind of working on assignments that I'm, you know, pretty into, but I like to have a kind of a really sort of thorny, tricky project in the background. Do you know what I mean? That just sort of takes longer, and I kind of chip away at it. And I just finished one of those stories. And so I was kind of in the market for something new. I think I was a bit stuck. And I saw online somewhere, like, a call for short stories. And I'm a nonfiction person, but I thought maybe it would be, like, good, good for me to try and write a short story. And so I had an idea for a short story. And the idea for the short story was this is just the idea. It would take the form of a letter, and the letter would be written by someone who had had a premonition. And it would sort of take the form of impossible knowledge, right? So the idea was that someone was going to be building, like, a big incinerator or some industrial thing on the edge of a town, and this knew that some very specific component that they could never have known about was going to go wrong. And I kind of had this idea for this short story. And I think at heart, because I'm like, a nonfiction person, my response to this was to go to the British Library, where I do a lot of work, and just to order up loads and loads of books about prophecy and premonitions. And so I was there in the library with this huge stack of Books mainly from the kind of late 19th century, early 20th century, kind of spiritualism movement in sort of Victorian times and kind of first 20 years of the 20th century. In amongst them there was a sort of later compendium of like weird stuff from the 20th century. And it had this description of the Premonitions Bureau. It wasn't much, it was just like a couple of paragraphs, but it was called, you know, British Premonitions Bureau. I just immediately responded to that as an idea and a thing and I started pulling the threads of it. It's not a known story, right? It had a moment in kind of 1966, 1967, where it was sort of made the BBC news and was in the newspapers and kind of made a splash. But it's not a known story. And I just started kind of scratching and kind of unpeeling it. But it sort of. I don't know whether you guys think about this, but the process of where ideas come from is quite mysterious to me. And I sort of haven't resolved really in my mind why I had the idea or how I found it, but that's how I found it.
- [09:35]
C
And if someone is listening and they're like, premonitions, bro, maybe I kind of understand what that means just by the words being connected. Like how do you describe it to someone who has never heard of it before?
- [09:47]
A
I describe it as an attempt to collect the dreams and forebodings of the British public on a mass scale and to try and detect patterns in those sort of dreams and warnings with the aim of somehow stopping disasters from happening.
- [10:12]
B
The notion was that for 18 months, right, there was a bureau that was headed in large by this Dr. Barker, right. And there were other psychiatrists. The notion was, what if we take seriously what we dismiss routinely as the ravings of lunacy, and in particular people who have been hospitalized for what we now would say is paranoid schizophrenia, nervous breakdown. Most of the things that people predict do not come true. But what the Premonitions Bureau was trying to figure out was how many of the things that are predicted do come true. And what does it mean really about the nature potentially of the human mind to be able to access things that are not in this timeline. That's what's so fascinating.
- [11:05]
A
Yeah. And to do it in an open ended way so they kind of realized that you could create. All these books that I was looking at in the library are these amazing, creepy collections of premonitions that came true. But what happens if you just do an open ended experiment and just like send them in and we'll kind of count them up at the end of the year, at the end of 18 months, and kind of see how many of those turned out to be the case.
- [11:27]
B
I think it was the first call. There was a call, a coal accident. Right. The Aberfan tragedy.
- [11:35]
A
Yeah.
- [11:36]
B
Describe what the tragedy was and describe what information came out of it when these psychiatrists said, anybody think about this before it happened?
- [11:49]
A
Aberfan, the disaster there in kind of October 1966, is kind of in sort of British and particularly sort of Welsh public memory, is still like an astonishingly nightmarish thing that happened. And people talk about it and still. And it kind of clutches at you. Wales, huge kind of coal mining part of the UK, and for 100 years, huge amounts of coal taken out of the ground and they would just pile up the waste of these things on hillsides. It kind of seems unbelievable in retrospect, but they would literally just dump the stuff on top of hillsides surrounding these villages where people lived. And they didn't test the ground or the weather or like, where would be a smart place to put these things. And one day in October 1966, one of these piles of coal waste, which was just gigantic, I think, contained enough coal waste to fill, you know, St. Paul's Cathedral in London, like, one and a half times over. Just a huge volume of quite fine tailings and kind of bits of like, discarded coal that had been rained on for weeks and weeks and weeks, suddenly dislodged and just rushed down the mountain and buried a school and killed 116 children, as well as 20, 30 people from the village.
- [13:17]
B
And this is like a picture of volcano like that I picked. When I read this, I pictured Pompeii, you know, like a. A mountain essentially, of coal is rushing into this village and it buries a school and kills all these people.
- [13:33]
A
And it's the children of the guys who've dug out the coal and who've been piling it up on the hillside and have been saying, are we sure this is a good idea? John Barker, who's the kind of protagonist of the book, is a psychiatrist at a mental Hospital about 100 miles away, just on the border between England and Wales. And he, like everybody else in the nation, hears the kind of the news reports coming out from this and the next morning, so it happens on a Friday, he rushes to the village and starts talking to people. And in his kind of notes of this encounter, he kind of knows that he's sort of out of place. I mean, it's a kind of. It's this awful kind of tragedy in a. In a kind of isolated, you know, this is a working class mining village, has just had the worst day that anyone has ever had in it. And suddenly the nation's press, the Royal family, the Prime Minister, everyone's showing up. Do you know what I mean? Outsiders were not welcome. And he knows that he's on uncertain ground, but he, he's a complicated character, which is obviously why he's interesting to write about. But he, he hangs around and he starts talking to people and he starts uncovering these stories, particularly among the children who didn't want to go to school that day and told their mom that they'd had a dream and there was something black that came over the school or they drew a picture that eerily kind of pictured the scene that happened or that they kind of overslept for the first time in their life on that day and were kind of bundled out of school and sort of shoved down the street to school and then, and then promptly buried. And he started collecting these, these testimonies and, you know, and it remains a, you know, impossible question. One of the, you know, wonderful people that I spoke to for the book was a photographer called Chuck Rapoport, who's an American photographer for Life magazine, went and kind of just lived in Aberfan for about three months after the accident and took really extraordinary kind of haunting series of photographs. And he said that people in the village broadly fell into two camps. There were the people who said this was always going to happen. We told the mine, this is ridiculous. I mean, the coal tip number seven, which was the one that slid down the mountain, was on top of a watercourse like it was on the map. Do you know what I mean? It just couldn't be more so. You had the sort of half of the vil were just like, this was a disaster waiting to happen. And then he had the other half of the village which was just like, you know, all the language that we're familiar with unprecedented came out of a blue sky. No one could have predicted this would happen. You know, it's a similar response to kind of disasters that we hear like whenever they happen. But the village sort of fell into these sort of, these two camps. And obviously, you know, and often kind of children, you know, they just see through the bullshit. They knew it was, you know, they've been mucking around on the tip. They knew that it slid in bad weather. Do you know what I mean? There's a million reasons why you can come up with rational prognostications of this disaster. But Barker is intrigued by these warnings, these kind of. And he is a publicity interested person and his work has already kind of featured in the British press for one reason or another. And so from Aberfan, he calls the science editor of the London Evening Standard, which is a pretty major newspaper in those days, you know, three quarters of a million circulation in London, and says, will you put out a story saying, did you have a premonition of the Aberfan disaster? And his thinking is that it's a pretty singular thing. You know, you can have dreams or bad feelings about kind of various disasters, but the particular configuration of Aberfan is, you know, quite striking. So they put out this national call for premonitions. A week after the disaster. You can see this kind of clipping in sort of 1960s newsprint. It's a kind of amazing reminder of how these ideas kind of come and go over time and they get a few hundred responses. And it's the concreteness and the interestingness of those premonitions that then lead on to the forming of the premonitions bureau proper.
- [18:01]
B
I'm going to read just a couple of them so people have an idea. And also Barker posited the existence of what was called a pre disaster syndrome. Keep in mind also, and I'm sure this came up in your research for the book. And also when we think about it, these are reports that we either are going to trust the veracity of or we're not going to. But for the purpose of his research, he was taking people's reports. Two nights before the disaster, a 63 year old man was standing by a machine. He's trying to buy a book. It was like a machine where I guess you put it in and the book comes out. He said he looked up and he saw the word Abervan written as if suspended in white lettering against a black background. In Plymouth, the evening before the coal slide, this woman had a vision of an avalanche of coal rushing down a mountain. This is the night before. And she said at the bottom of the mountain was a little boy looking terrified to death. A man in Kent was convinced for days before the accident that there would be a national disaster. On Friday, he said, it came to me as strongly as might come the thought that you have forgotten that it was your wife's birthday tomorrow. And there's more. There's a woman who was bothered all week by a smell, earthy and decaying, which she recognized as the smell of death. An hour before the Disaster. She said to her colleague, do you smell anything weird? And he said, no. Fifteen minutes after the school was buried, she jumped up and he jumped up. There's something going on with these kinds of reports and the question is, how many coincidences, right? Can you count before you say, maybe there's something else going on?
- [19:52]
C
Mind Bialik's breakdown is supported by Comm.
- [19:55]
B
Anyone else feeling like this year is flying by way too fast? That where did the time go? Anxiety is real. It can leave you feeling scattered and behind. Calm gives you permission to slow down even when everything else is speeding up. Calm is the number one app for sleep and meditation, and it's here to help you feel better. If you're feeling like you could use some support navigating life's ups and downs, get the relief you need with calm. Sessions like guided meditations to help you work through anxiety and stress, boost your focus, build healthier habits. Sleep stories, sleep meditations and calming music can help you drift off to restful sleep quickly and naturally. Also grounding exercises. I've been really getting into these to help you reset and relax when you're feeling overwhelmed. Expert led talks to help you handle grief, improve self esteem, improve relationships. The Calm app puts the tools you need right in your pocket. So stress and anxiety relief is always within reach. Calm has over 2 million 5 star reviews and can help you stress less, sleep more, and live mindfully. Calm your mind, change your life. Calm has an exclusive offer just for listeners of our show. Get 40% off a computer premium subscription at com.com break this is an amazing value. Go to c a l m.com break for 40% off. Unlimited access to. Com's entire library.
- [21:05]
C
Com.com break and tell. Com. You heard about them from us. My balance breakdown is supported by Incog.
- [21:16]
B
Guess what? Your personal data is everywhere online and that makes you an easy target for identity theft scammers.
- [21:22]
C
Oh yeah.
- [21:23]
B
Websites legally publish and profit from your info. It's not paranoia, it's true. Your name, your home address, even court records. Once it's out there, it's fair game for stalkers, identity thieves, or anyone with bad intentions. Last year alone, data breaches skyrocketed by over 200%. That means your private details could already be floating around. Shady directories, AI summaries, people search sites waiting to be exploited. That's where Incogni comes in. They hunt down your exposed personal data. Not just from data brokers, but from across the entire web. Directories, search results, company databases. Gone. Their custom removals feature takes it Even further. Send them a link and your dedicated privacy expert will handle the takedown. Whether it's a random court record or a sketchy people search profile, they will make it disappear. Reduce your risk of scams and identity theft, protect your privacy, reclaim your online solitude. All in just three steps. Create your account, give one time authorization, and let Incogni do the rest. Remember, they can't harm you if they can't find you. Add up to three emails, addresses and phone numbers to uncover even more hidden profiles. With the unlimited plan, you can send in any link and watch it vanish. Plus, it's risk free. Cancel anytime, get your money back within 30 days if you're not satisfied. Scammers are getting smarter, but with Incogni, you're one step ahead. They're the only data removal service independently verified by Deloitte. Because your privacy deserves proof, take your personal data back with incog. Head to incog.com mayim use the code mayim m a y I m to get 60% off an annual plan.
- [22:51]
C
That's code mime@incogni.com mime mayimbialix breakdown is supported by Incogni.
- [23:00]
B
Your personal data is everywhere online, and that makes you an easy target for scammers. Websites legally publish and profit from your info. Your name, home address, even court records. Once it's out there, it is fair game for stalkers, identity thieves, or really anyone with bad intentions. Last year alone, data breaches skyrocketed by over 200%. That means your private details could already be floating around. Shady directories, AI summaries and people search sites waiting to be exploited. That's where Incogni comes in. Incogni hunts down your exposed personal data, not just from data brokers, but from across the entire web. Directories, search results, company databases. Gone. Their custom removals feature takes it even further. Just send them a link and your dedicated privacy expert will handle the takedown. Whether it's a random court record or a sketchy people search profile, they'll make it disappear. Reduce your risk of scams and identity theft, protect your privacy, and reclaim your online solitude. All in just three steps. Create your account, give one time authorization, and let Incog do the rest. Remember, they can't harm you if they can't find you. Add up to three emails, addresses and phone numbers to uncover even more hidden profiles. With the unlimited plan, you can send in any link and watch it vanish. Plus, it's risk free. Cancel anytime or get your money back with within 30 days if you're not satisfied. Scammers are getting smarter. But with Incog, you're one step ahead. They're the only data removal service independently verified by Deloitte. Because your privacy deserves proof. Take your personal data back with incog. Head to incog.com mayim and use code mayim m a y im to get 60% off an annual plan.
- [24:30]
C
That's code m a y I m@incog.com.
- [24:34]
A
Mime barker and you know, and to be fair, kind of fairly, the journalist who he's working with at this point, both kind of leap on these, on these reports coming in, you know, obviously kind of thinking that they're only scratching the surface here.
- [24:51]
B
If there were a pre disaster syndrome and there's, there's many, many examples of this, we're just taking the aperfan one as the first. If there is some sort of pre disaster syndrome. The idea, this is how you described it, is that there are people who are human seismographs. They have in particular not just emotional or, you know, kind of cognitive notions, but they have physical, somatic, bodily sensations ahead of important or emotional events. And you said it's not unlike twins who say that they can feel the other's pain even if they're hundred miles apart. This notion and you know, the reason that we're so fascinated with you and the Premonitions Bureau is we speak with people all of the time, fortunately, who have experiences where one of the things they describe after a near death experience is the ability to cut through time in ways that we don't think about. And we've spoken to people who have specific premonitions about plane crashes, about disasters. And yes, they're not always right, but what they would say is maybe there's another timeline that we haven't accessed yet that they are tapping into. What would you say from your research and from your understanding might be happening in terms of this sort of difference in timeline that some people may be tuned into.
- [26:22]
A
So I'm not going to, I'm not going to dodge it, but I do, I want to say something that was sort of important to me in the sort of, the writing and the sort of reporting of this story was that it was really important to remember like when it was happening and who Barker was and the context in which he was working. So Barker was the deputy superintendent of a large hospital with about a thousand profoundly mentally ill people. In that place during the 19th century, asylums were built in every county in England and people were locked up. People were locked up for, you know, for being a mute or you know, for having what we recognize now as profound learning disabilities. People were just put away. And he was working in this hospital with 250 patients of his own kind of outpatients across rural Shropshire and rural Wales of basically untreated serious mental illness, like the first antipsychotic drugs began to be dispensed in Britain in 1955. So he's grown up and trained as a psychiatrist where you're fairly powerless. And he studied and qualified in a time of kind of leucotomies and just awful treatment for psychosis and serious mental illness. And he's on the cusp of a government program to shut down these mental hospitals and treat people in the community and on the cusp of pharmaceuticals and on the cusp of curing people. And he's seeing kind of amazing stuff every day. He's seeing people who haven't spoken for 40 years speak. Do you know what I mean? He's seeing people who have not been outside in a decade go out and interact with the world and be able to kind of talk and converse and see their families. So he's working in a field that is full of kind of change and possibility. And I always, like, was trying to, when I was writing the book, picturing him like he's just done the ward rounds. They've just taken the locks off the doors, They've just taken the railings down. He's trying to get jazz bands in. They're trying to open the windows. They're trying to give everyone their own locker. They're trying to stop them wearing uniforms. You know, I mean, he's. This is the. The. The kind of. The hard yards of kind of mental illness treatment that he is doing. And then he turns to his list of premonitions that have kind of come in that day or that week. And it's not the craziest thing he's heard in the last 10 minutes. Do you know what I mean? He's just open in a, you know, in a way that I think is. Is quite hard to sort of reach back to. Do you know what I mean? That kind of atmosphere of sort of change and possibility. I should also say that Barker's kind of clinical interest in these cases, to start with, is the idea of whether you can be frightened to death. So if someone tells you that you're going to die, does that make it more likely to happen? And he was following the footsteps of a guy called Walter Cannon at Harvard Medical School who was kind of studying curses and the kind of reactions of the Adrenal system and all stuff that has been more or less entirely borne out by neurology and kind of modern science in terms of, like, the relationship of sort of what you're kind of thinking in your mind and then the kind of physiological consequences of that. All of that kind of. Barker, I think, was intuitively smart and on the right track.
- [30:12]
B
Instead of the placebo, it's the nocebo effect. And Barker's fascination with. I mean, he was a very, very strange man, but his fascination with it was, if someone tells you you're gonna get sick, does that make you more likely to get sick? And what ended up happening in his life? If someone tells you you're gonna die, do you die?
- [30:33]
A
Yeah. So this is. This is his kind of entry point into these premonitions and into this kind of sense of. Of kind of foresight and seeing things having impossible knowledge or kind of seeing things before they occur to kind of like wend epically back to your kind of. Your question. In the first place, I feel like I'm torn between is this something that a small subset of people somehow have access to, or.
- [31:08]
C
Or.
- [31:10]
A
Is this about a shared consciousness and kind of how groups of people are with each other? I tried to sort of, in the book, kind of write a little kind of potted, like, British history of prophecy kind of thing and just loved reading about, like, the Western Isles of Scotland in the 16th and 17th century, where kind of second sight and premonitions were just totally routine and just totally normal. And it was just part of living in a community that you could see what would happen on the other side of the island. If a friend of yours got kicked by his horse, you'd know something would happen. You'd go and help them out. And that was just how the collective mind worked in that place. And people would lose the ability when they moved away from the islands, and it would get it back again when they came back to the islands. In my own kind of personal kind of reckoning with these questions, I. I'm sort of more drawn to those ideas than sort of fully escaping time, which I find problematic.
- [32:17]
B
It is problematic. And, you know, you talk about William James, one of the founders of modern psychology. He said that the conscious mind has a specific present. Like we are conscious of something and we are in this timeline. But the unconscious may have a different relationship to time. I mean, that is one of the kind of scientific conversations about this, right? Is there a different timeline? And if you're not bound to this physical body, right. If you're not bound to the conscious material present is this other realm which, you know, quantum physics would describe as just a field. It's just a field, right? An undulating, moving particle wave field. You know, does that wave then have a relationship of time. That is completely different than anything we would fathom? I mean, that would, in theory, explain people with near death experiences, for example. Who say that they're witnessing things or seeing things after these experiences. You know, what is this ability? And what's the difference between that and insanity? And I think that's the other thing, that, you know, you sort of tackle here. You know, Jonathan and I, we really. We live at this kind of intersection of science and spirituality. We know that they overlap. The question is where? And what's the nomenclature around it? But we've spoken to people who otherwise are living a very normal, whatever life. And one day they start hearing voices. That are directing them to send messages to humanity. They are not meeting any clinical criteria. For any of the diagnoses that we know exist in that big book. Right? I think we're up to 6 DSM 6. They don't meet any criteria for paranoid schizophrenia. They are functional in all of their capacities. They do not qualify for anything that in previous generations, people would be hospitalized for. So our question is, is there either some other diagnosis, right. That Barker was focusing on that we just didn't know. Or is it possible that there is a sensitivity. And in our culture, right, we name it this and we. We place them here. But a thousand years ago, 5,000 years ago, are these people shamans? Are they prophets? I don't know.
- [34:42]
A
So one of the sort of phrases that kind of goes off in my head when you're saying that is. Is the playwright, a British playwright called J.B. priestley. Who wrote a kind of series of plays in the 1930s. That kind of play around with time. One's called Time and the Conways. One's called An Inspector Calls. And they're all questioning sequences and how time works. And he was obviously kind of influenced by quantum physics. And all the things that you mentioned. And he wrote this book in the early 1960s called man and Time. And he wrote this nice phrase where he said that we are living in the most impoverished version of time that we've ever had. You know, just people in the past had a better intuitive grasp. Of what this thing was and how varied it was. And the kind of. The strict kind of materialist interpretation is so meager compared to it. He described it. He compared it to a rope. He was like, we know that it doesn't work at the kind of subatomic level and we know that it doesn't work at the planetary level. And we're just, it's like shredding at both ends and we're living in the middle and you're telling me like it works here.
- [35:59]
C
Mayim B. Alex Breakdown is supported by Bubs Natural.
- [36:02]
B
Getting older hit harder than you expected. I know it did for us. From stiff joints in the morning, recovery from the gym, taking longer hair, thinning nails, breaking dry skin that's lost its glow. Aging can really suck, but it doesn't have to. Luckily, Bubs Naturals Collagen Peptides are here to help you turn back the clock. Starting in your mid-20s, your collagen production actually starts to naturally decline. That's where Bubs Naturals Collagen Peptides comes in. BUBS helps restore collagen levels closer to what your body naturally had in its youth. So your joints feel stronger, your hair and nails grow healthier and your skin looks smoother. Collagen is the most abundant protein. It's often referred to as the glue that's holding us all together.
- [36:40]
C
I want extra glue to hold me together. That's why I use Bubs and I found a really big difference. I'm actually very impressed.
- [36:47]
B
You are bouncing back faster after workouts. It's allowing you to play more, which is great.
- [36:51]
C
I'm actually bouncing specifically I'm doing a lot of jump training and it's helping.
- [36:55]
B
A lot more bouncing. No complaining about joint pain. Bubs is different than other collagen products with no junk, zero sugar sweeteners or fillers. They're third party tested and NSF certified for sports, sport and Whole 30 approved. You know it's clean and trustworthy. Bubs is sustainably sourced from grass fed pasture raised cattle and dissolves seamlessly in coffee, water or smoothies without taste or clumps. They have over 100000 happy customers and were voted 2024's Best Collagen by Health.com Bubs Naturals also sells electrolyte supplements, MCT oil creamer and more. Live better longer for a limited time only. Our listeners are getting 20% off at Bubs Naturals by using Code Break at checkout. Just head to Bubs Naturals.com use code BREAK and you're all set. After your purchase they're going to say where'd you hear about us? Please support our show. Tell them we sent you.
- [37:46]
C
My ambulance Breakdown is supported by our place.
- [37:48]
B
You know most nonstick cookware Guess what still contains harmful toxins?
- [37:53]
C
Oh no.
- [37:54]
B
A study by the Ecology center in California found that 80% of of nonstick pans still contain Teflon. That's a PFAS which can be released into your food, your home and your body. We've talked about that a lot here on Mind Biologics Breakdown. Also, a brand new study published in the Science of the Total Environment found that a single scratch on a nonstick coated pan can release approximately 9,100 plastic particles. Our Place though makes high performance toxin free cookware. Their products are made without forever chemicals like PFAs and PTFEs so you can cook confidently without wondering what's in your pan besides what you're cooking. Our Places Cookware set will upgrade your kitchen in one fell swoop like it did to ours. The set includes two multifunctional Always Pans and two Perfect pots in mini and full sizes that replace a bulky, expensive stack of cookware. It's time to get rid of it folks. I also love the Perfect Pot. It's my favorite. I use it to cook soup with just four pieces. You can can sear, saute, fry, bake, boil, roast, steam and so much more. Save 150 bucks on the Cookware set with the bundle and save option. Their other standout products include the Wonder Oven, a revolutionary air fryer and toaster oven that's sold out eight times. Made from stainless steel and glass, offering an eco friendly, high performance cooking experience. Also, the always pan, our place's iconic bestselling 10 in 1 pan. You could get rid of 10 things and just use this one. From braising and searing to frying and baking, it does it all while minimizing the need for excess oil. Plus the Always Pan Pro, the first nonstick pan with zero coating made from pure titanium for unbeatable durability with a limited lifetime warranty.
- [39:30]
C
I love that pan. It is really. It's the only pan I use nowadays.
- [39:34]
B
You're all about titanium. This is cookware that's designed for performance and built to last. Their products are even trusted by Michelin star chefs. Our Place is having their biggest sale of the year right now. Save up to 35% sitewide now through January 12th. Head to fromourplace.com to see why more than a million people have made the switch to Our Place Kitchenware. And with their 100 day risk free trial, free shipping and free returns, you can shop with total confidence.
- [39:58]
C
Shop Our Place Holiday Sale right now. No code needed. This episode is brought to you by NBA on Prime. This Tuesday at 8:30 Eastern. It's the Emirates NBA Cup Championship game on Prime. This year's quest for the cup has been building to this. The championship game live from Las Vegas. Not a Prime member sign up for a 30 day free trial to get started today. The Emirates NBA Cup Championship game this Tuesday at 8:30 Eastern only on Prime. Restrictions apply. See Amazon.com amazonprime for details on the question of.
- [40:39]
A
People having experiences, but no other sort of clinical disorders or kind of labels that you want to give it. One of the things that I really wanted to do in the book was to, was to write about the Premonitions Bureau like I would write about anything else. It just struck me that kind of reporting about the occult or supernatural or experiments of this nature are just, there's just often in their description a kind of tacit framing of this is either bogus or this is so real it's the realest thing you've ever heard. Do you know what I mean? And it comes with an agenda. And I'm a magazine writer, I'm a reporter. I just wanted to write this as a piece of kind of social history. And as I was sort of doing that reporting, you know, I was often thinking about the way we write about the, you know, the major religions or kind of other kind of inexplicable kind of aspects of how we interact with reality or things beyond reality. And we, and we treat those like with a sort of dignity that respects the experiences of people who are undergoing those things. And that's kind of often not the case with this kind of writing and reporting. And I think that Barker, problematic and questionable as he was in lots of ways, was a good doctor. And it's striking, kind of just looking in people sending in their premonitions, just glad to have someone to send them to and to have an outlet.
- [42:17]
B
Well, I think that's actually a really important point and it's one that touches more on the sociological components of these conversations which Jonathan and I are in as podcasters in the 21st century. Right. What deserves to be spoken about? What are people afraid to hear about? And especially from the materialist perspective, what feels so indescribable and impossible that we will do everything we can to ridicule it and push it away, which is the least scientific thing to do. I want to give another great example and, and this one is really special. Alan Hencher was one of the seers of the Aberfan Coal tragedy. In the spring of 1967, he called Dr. Barker again and he said, I've seen a plane crash that's gonna happen over mountains. Now, what's interesting to me, Hencher's premonitions began after he suffered a head injury in a car crash in his mid-20s. So I'm very interested in a traumatic brain injury that leads to paranormal experiences and psi abilities. Not because I think it proves, oh, we're going to find the region of the brain that makes you crazy, but more because when part of the brain is damaged, what else opens up? For all we know, what was damaged or compromised was an inhibitory component. And now the truth, whatever truth is right, is allowed to come free. He said, There are 123 people. I have chills right now. Before I even finish the sentence. There are 123 people, possibly 124. He was telling this to Dr. Barker, who made notes on the call. It was 6am on March 21st. 30 days later, everyone. A passenger aircraft carrying 130 people attempted to land in Cyprus in bad weather. 124 people died. I will say two more people later died. I would be doing a disservice to, to Sam if I didn't mention that, however, this guy Hencher was experiencing something not once, not twice, but many times that in my opinion, does not need to even be perfect. Even if he got it wrong by 10 people, even if he got it wrong by all the people, and all he said was a play. To me, that's enough to think about. What was going on with Alan Hencher.
- [44:54]
A
No. And he's this unhappy, stressed figure in the book because these premonitions are accompanied by pain. They're accompanied by, like, very strong headaches and a feeling of stress. And he wants it to be over. And then when the event happens, this feeling lifts and. And he obviously feels a mixture of kind of guilt and relief when that happens. Two minutes ago, describing Barker as a good doctor. I would say that Barker was a bad doctor in his treatment of Henscher because he's so excited about what's happening there that he kind of goads him and provokes him and lets him know that other people are doing good predictions too. And he's not respectful of what Henscher is going through when he's sort of having these experiences.
- [45:49]
B
Hencher also had a severe headache an hour after a significant train crash in 1967 that he did not know had happened. And here also enters Ms. Middleton, another startlingly accurate, pretty consistent predictor that was involved with Dr. Barker. Can you tell us a little bit about some of what she was like and what her experiences were.
- [46:17]
A
Look, I'm so thrilled to have a chance to talk about Ms. Middleton. So she was a music teacher in North London and she was born in the US to English parents and they moved back to the UK during the depression 1933 and her family on her father's side had been quite prosperous and, and kind of run away with his girlfriend Annie from Paris and so being disowned by the family. So they're kind of like coming down in the world into sort of suburban London in the 1930s. And Ms. Middleton, she'd kind of been a child dancer, child kind of child performer in Boston and was forced to settle for a, a fairly anonymous life as a music and dance teacher in the front room of her parents house in Edmonton in North London. But she did this with kind of great verve and great style and sort of tried to sort of cut this kind of glamorous figure. And she had premonitions throughout her life. She experienced them as a child. She was taught by a piano teacher and was kind of convinced that he was, he wasn't well and was hassling and hassling her parents to kind of get in touch with him. And it turned out that he had, he'd committed suicide. And that was how the kind of family knew she was kind of, she described it like kind of knowing the answer in a spelling test. She would just see, see words, see numbers, see stuff before it happened and, and she never worked as a psychic, she never kind of practiced, she never made any money out of this. She never kind of hustled and she like Hencher kind of experienced physical sensations. On the morning of the Aberfan disaster she experienced a kind of suffocating feeling that was kind of witnessed by her euphemistically described lodger. And then she became kind of one of the Barker's again, kind of eager correspondence and I kind of came across the name of Ms. Middleton and I looked up her will which you can do in the UK and I saw who was the kind of the executor of her will. She didn't have any kids and it was one of her pupils who used to study music with her. You sometimes get this as a reporter. You ring someone up totally out of the blue. There's no way that they could know. Do you know what I mean? I ring this wonderful woman, Christine Williams and it's literally like she's just been waiting for the phone call for 20 years. She was just like, oh yeah, hi, here we are, here we are like. And so Ms. Middleton died in 1999 and her house was a mess. She had like 14 cats. The place was like, not in a good way. And this lovely woman, Christine, who lived around the corner from her, spent a year clearing the house and. But whenever she came across something that she thought was kind of meaningful, she just put it in a box and kept. And she just had this like, box in the attic that just sat there for like 20 years. But she was just so calm. She was just like, I knew, you know, I knew someone would come like one day to write about Ms. Middleton because she was one of these people. And then when we were sort of doing the reporting, we obviously got to know each other a bit and I was putting the book together, like a photo would go missing. She'd just be like, don't worry, Ms. Middleton's got this. It will just turn up. And it will always turned up. She just had this like this sense of like, connection with Ms. Middleton, sort of. It was, it was like a very kind of, sort of rather kind of beautiful aspect of the, of the reporting. I've had this with other stories where if you're writing about a very particular dimension of a person, I think it's really important to write about them in the round. Do you know what I mean? And just kind of try and give a sense of them as a person before you give a sense of them as someone who might have these levels of perception or whatever. I don't know.
- [50:26]
B
I think that's also the way sort of Dr. Barker chose to see people. Because I think that some of the complexity here is that if you as a doctor or as a journalist are experiencing phenomenal, impossible things, how do you paint a larger picture which I think actually provides so much more of the context for understanding this person?
- [50:51]
A
I don't know, she's just the definition of a weird cat lady, but she also wasn't a weird cat lady, do you know what I mean? And that's how she would have been written anyway. This is. So that was Ms. Middleton. And you refer to the Charing Cross train accident, which for me, as, you know, maybe I've just done this to sort of protect myself, but to dodge the kind of gravity defying kind of implications of all of this. I suppose my sort of position as the writer of this story has been to try and accurately describe what it was like to be part of a group of people who really believed for a moment that they could, like, that they could see the future. And I tried to write about the Premonitions Bureau. A bit like an island in the Western Isles of Scotland in the 17th century. This was a community of people who were like onto something and let's just describe the circumstances of that, of how that happened and kind of. And leave it there. So maybe that's just for me to sort of protect my mind from where some of this stuff leads to. But that Charing Cross train accident for me is the single most inexplicable one in the book. I don't know how you sit down in your kitchen on a Wednesday morning and write down on a piece of paper that there's going to be a train crash and it's going to involve Charing Cross and you put it in the post on a Wednesday and it happens on a Sunday night. For me, it's the one that I just can't square away. And with Hencher, who's on a shift because he's a switchboard operator at the post office, the train comes off the tracks at 9:15 and he's just like in agony at 9:15 in the sickbay at the post office place. This one is tough for me.
- [52:42]
B
Everybody needs different levels of convincing, Right. And for other people, they didn't need that one to say, I know that you can cut through time like a seven layer cake. Right. For Sam, it took that. For others, that's not enough. Just like there's unity in the universe, right. There's one gravity, there's, you know, one rule for things. We don't create different realities. Whatever's happening with that accident, I believe is potentially able to happen for any of these other examples, it's the same thing.
- [53:21]
A
Yeah.
- [53:22]
B
One of the most kind of powerful visions that Ms. Middleton had was specifically about Dr. Barker's death. And this is a very eerie, very spooky turn of events. And it does get its due in the discussion of nocebo. What is the influence of negative information? And we've spoken with Dr. Amir Raz about the power of the mind, about placebo and also nocebo. But there's more recent research from the lab of Dr. Ellen Langer. And what Ellen Langer discovered is if you tell people they have diabetes, their bodies will start behaving as if they had diabetes. And I'm not saying that's her specific research, I'm saying this is the umbrella that it falls under. If you tell people that they're old and that their bodies are going to deteriorate, their bodies get old and deteriorate and there's a tremendous power of the Mind to be able to modulate physiological processes, immune properties, things that we previously did not think the mind would have control over, like that. So when we think about something like this, and especially Dr. Barker's fascination with can you be. Can you. Can you die of fear? Or as Jonathan and I were talking about it, can you literally be scared to death? When I think about. And the example that, that you talk about is as long as we have hope, we struggle to keep surviving. And there's some very famous rat experiments that, that you talk about that, that kind of prove this. And, you know, think about any. Any relationship you've been in that you wanted to have it end. If there's any hope, you just keep it going. Right? What is now unfamiliar tends to be inadmissible and is therefore not accepted, even despite overwhelming supportive evidence. Thus, for generations, the Earth was traditionally regarded as flat, and those who opposed this notion were bitterly attacked. Right. There are all of these shifts in our paradigm that are constantly happening. I mean, Dr. Barker died not the way Ms. Middleton said that he would die, but he. It was a strange death. And there were many cases that he was fascinated with of people who died of routine surgeries at the age that they were told that they would die. What might be going on here? And what did you find?
- [55:50]
A
So, as I said, kind of, Barker was in Aberfan originally because he was interested in news reports of a boy who had escaped from the school but had died of fright and died of fear. And so aberfan happened in 1966. But in 1963, as you referred to, there was a case reported in the British Medical Journal of a woman who was admitted for a routine gynecological operation at a small hospital in Labrador in Canada. Surgery went well, everything was fine. And then an hour afterwards, she went into. She kind of had an adrenal hemorrhage and she died. And the doctors were, you know, totally, totally, totally mystified. And she'd confided in a nurse, she was 43, that she'd been told as a kid by a fortune teller that she would die when she was 43. And it was a week after her 43rd birthday. She was like. I think she was a mother of five, she living at, like, a tough rural existence in Labrador at the time, physically fit, physically well, but seized by fear and dies. And the doctors wrote about this in the British Medical Journal and just said, like anyone else had some reports like this. And Barker, you know, hungry, avaricious researcher that he was caught onto this and sort of Took up the case and went around kind of collecting reports of this and wrote a book called Scared to Death, collating these reports with the workers of Walter Cannon and kind of where the kind of state of knowledge was at the time about the sort of physiological and kind of neurological kind of basis for these things. Hencher rings him up in the middle of the night one night and is like, I've got a prediction. And Barker's like, okay, what is it? Let me get my piece of paper to write it down. You know, is it another plane? And he's like, no, it's you. And when he thinks of Barker, he just thinks of black. He thinks of him surrounded by kind of by darkness and he thinks that something's gonna happen to him. And he says, do you have a, do you have gas mains at your house? He says, no, I don't. I live in the countryside. He's like, what color is your car? He's like, it's a dark green car. He's like, ah, not feeling great about that. And Barker the next morning writes a memoir. And you know, this was the sort of memo that I found in the, in the, in a, like in an envelope in the, in Cambridge University Library. And, and it says, you know, Hencher has been right about Aberfan, he's been right about the plane crash. Like, is he, is he right about me? It's an extraordinary kind of document because if you're me sort of researching this story kind of 50, 60 years after, I was unsure whether he was a kind of buttoned up British mid century intellectual, observing this all with kind of dispassion and sort of objective curiosity. But no, he was entirely kind of emotionally implicated in it. And you can sense in this document both his fear and his enormous curiosity.
- [59:11]
B
Well, the first thing I thought of also is in the screenplay version of this, were they trying to kill him? Meaning if you have this power to see certain things and also we don't know really the nature of whatever might be ailing you if you insert this idea into anyone's head. You know, I wonder, if he wasn't the doctor, would it have been someone else? Or was this meant for the person they were closest to? And I'm not saying there's anything insidious in it. You know, I'm not trying to make it a nefarious story. However, we're dealing with people who, we don't really understand the full nature of what they're experiencing. And part of me was like, were they just messing with him? And then he died, you know, so.
- [60:02]
A
He lived with this warning for some time. So this kind of happens in the spring of 1967, and then towards the end of the year, the Charing Cross train crash happens. And that gets a lot of publicity. And Barker publishes his book, Scared to Death. And I should say that he's doing this kind of over the objections of everyone at his hospital and in the kind of regional health board. And everyone is telling him that he's making a terrible mistake. Everyone's telling him it's embarrassing and he's pushing ahead. There's just a level of kind of risk taking and a kind of heedlessness.
- [60:48]
B
Which is characteristic of every great genius.
- [60:52]
A
He's pushing it. And Hencher watches him on TV and he writes to him again. He said, I watched you on tv. There's a kind of blackness around you on the tv. Like, I'm not feeling good about this. And then. And then Barker, because he's. Because we're allowed to question his judgment, you know, writes to Middleton and is like, do you think I'm going to die? And Middleton is like, well, I kind of. Until you mentioned it, I hadn't really thought about it, but actually. And then she starts having these dreams about her mother. And when she says her mother visits her in a dream, this kind of normally kind of symbolizes a death. And she's on holiday with her mother. And then, like, Barker's getting in this car with her mother and driving away. She's having these just really dark dreams about. So he's getting this kind of ramping up of warnings in the spring of 1968. The thing that we haven't talked about is that there is then this kind of unspeakable disaster at Barker's own hospital.
- [61:45]
B
Okay, should we go there now?
- [61:47]
A
Let's go there now.
- [61:48]
B
Okay, so this is 1968, in the beach ward.
- [61:51]
A
Yeah.
- [61:52]
B
And it was a terrible fire, And I believe 24 people died. And here's the thing. If a bunch of people who claim to be precognitive tell you there's gonna be a fire, what do you do if you work in that hospital? And Hencher described this when he was asked about, what is it like to have this kind of information? He said, we have to undergo the torment of knowing that whatever we say, however long we pray, that when we receive, we have the problem of deciding whether we should tell what we've received. Because if we don't and it happens, we cannot be believed and so suffer equally by the knowledge that we're Doing something that could be of public use. But he said it creates even greater stress mentally to your nervous system to constantly be in this place of, if I say something, they'll think I'm crazy. If I don't say something and it happens, I could have prevented it. If I say something and it doesn't happen, I'm screwed anyway. So there were people who said, does anyone smell smoke? And the nurses were like, nope, you're just crazy. And people were saying, there's going to be a fire, there's going to be a fire. And they just said, no, there was a fire.
- [63:13]
A
You know, in a way, it kind of. It comes back to abovan in. And I would argue with many kind of terrible disasters, when you kind of. When you read the inquiry, when you read the person kind of who sort of mapped it all out, it's just. It's just inevitable, right? I mean, this hospital where. And this was the only locked female ward. So people were kind of. People were still in Victorian cells with kind of. I mean, it's incredible, with stable doors, you know, with the top that opens and the bottom that doesn't. Ironically, those were the women that survived because those doors kind of protected them from the smoke. But this was the kind of last locked corner of the hospital. They'd had a new fire alarm system, but that no one knew how to work it. There hadn't been a fire drill in four years. They had this unbelievably complicated, like, telephone system that you couldn't even, like, call the fire department. You had to, like, call someone else and wake them up at home, and they would call the fire. You know, just. It's. It's. It's like horrendously sort of obvious that it's going to happen. And as you say, even when it's happening, you've got patients coming down the stairs, going, by the way, our room's on fire and they're being told to go back to bed. I mean, it's just sort of. We don't need, like, precognitive abilities, like, at this point. But I think that for Barker, this is just. It's just mortifying. It's mortifying on every level. He's already feeling that he's stepping outside of his lane with his research. He's obviously feeling like they've failed these patients. He's been spending the last year and a half trying to send elderly, basically manageable patients back to their families and finding it incredibly difficult to discharge people from hospital. It's a kind of Institutional crisis, which is sort of overlaid on his own kind of personal, professional journey, which is obviously a bit of a high wire act. Plus, you know, every couple of months, someone tells him he's gonna die. It's a kind of crescendo of noise at that point in his life.
- [65:36]
B
I had a strange feeling in my.
- [65:38]
C
Stomach yesterday about this interview. Don't worry, Sam, you're gonna be fine.
- [65:43]
B
No, I had a strange feeling in my stomach, you know, like it might have been gas, it might have been indigestion, but it was definitely a feeling I've never felt before. It wasn't one that I've associated. And I didn't even tell Jonathan this. I called my mother because I had this crazy thought in the back of my head that in the same way that she was connected to her mother in ways that she sometimes physically would get senses that something was wrong with my grandmother and was accurate, I was like, what if this feeling is trying to tell me something about my mom or the. A person that I'm tethered to that way? So I didn't say that to my mom, God bless her, because she's, you know, the age that she is. But I literally called and I was like, hi. And I half expected her to be like, I'm in the hospital. But that's not what she said. She said, oh, I just got back from a walk and I had a bagel and this, that. Oh, my friend this, and I, I'm gonna go see Greece on Sunday. And that was it. And so what I thought to myself, though, is either I'm crazy to be thinking that this might be an association. I'm correct. In another timeline that hasn't happened, you.
- [66:56]
C
Had a lot of gluten in grease, and that's awful. And it hurt your stomach.
- [67:02]
B
No, but. But it occurred to me also, as I was simultaneously preparing to speak about this book, that we want to know things with tremendous certainty. I want to know that every time I have an intuition or I have a feeling that it's correct. And that's the only kind of information that many people are comfortable with. The uncomfortableness that you write about is all of these places in between. And that's actually where most of us live. That's where most of us live. Even the people who are envisioning. Elizabeth Crone, who was struck by lightning, saw the Sully Sullenberger crash. She saw an airplane upside down on the water and timestamped it, right? Why? Why would you see an airplane upside down floating on the water? It's a very specific notion. It doesn't mean that she always has to be right. It means that there's an opening in which many of us believe that there is accuracy. I'm curious, what changed for you as you were working on this book in terms of what you thought you believed and maybe what you believed when you were done with your research?
- [68:07]
A
I think two things changed for me. I think the first thing that changed for me, and I think I kind of. I knew this at a. In a sort of vague way, but not in a specific way, was just how rooted prophecy and premonitions and ideas of shared consciousness were in the Britain that I live in. Do you know what I mean? In my culture. Do you know what I mean? You've referred to shamans or healers or kind of. It's easy to exoticize this, do you know what I mean? And say that it happens in other cultures or other ways of thinking, but it happens in. In my way of thinking. And that kind of doing the research and kind of putting together a sort of a timeline which you obviously, this kind of see this peak in spiritualism and sort of contact with the dead in the kind of the First World War in the 1920s, kind of dramatic periods of technological change and kind of social crisis in the uk and then you kind of see it again in the 60s when the premonitions bureau was happening. It's arguable. Are we in a similar period now? You know, just sort of, for me, just like, just doing the work gave me more kind of knowledge and certainty about how this is just a kind of a thread in our culture. You know, there's. I write some stuff in the book about people in the Blitz in London. You know, as many people in London during the Blitz believe in the supernatural as they did in Christian ideas of heaven or death. Do you know what I mean? This is just. This is in our minds. And I suppose kind of when you do this kind of reporting or you're just sort of talking to people about what you're working on. And yes, this is sort of anecdotal, but I also think it's more than that. It's just how many families contain a story like this? And they are the most rooted, pragmatic, like unbelieving people, and they live with a story like this in their family. It's like. It's in my family two generations back, you know, my grandmother, who was a kind of a refugee from China and Russia, was, like, joined by her mother when she was dying. You know, even Though they were thousands of miles apart or telling my friend, you know, I'm writing this book about this thing. Oh yeah, I actually can't do that stuff. Stuff because I was like with my dad once on the plane and his like, he was just like on a plane waiting to take off to go on holiday and his dead mother just like walked down the aisle.
- [70:54]
B
Okay, hold on.
- [70:55]
A
Do you know what I mean? You're just like, like all of these, all of these just families just like to just hold these secrets in them. Do you know what I mean? This is not an inexplicable knot. And they just go about their daily business and, and this is sort of happens over time and over time and over time.
- [71:12]
B
So something is happening. Something is happening. We just, we don't know unless it follows a formula and unless it has an equation that goes with it, we don't know what to do with it. So we push it away.
- [71:25]
A
Yeah, so I, so I, so I live in England, as you can tell. And when I was doing the book, I did a. To do some events and podcasts and things like this. And I was moving house and one of the. And you get an email and it says, oh, look, can you do this interview? And I'm like, yeah, sure, fine. I was like, really, really busy. And it was kind of a heat wave here, which is unusual. And I was like unpacking boxes in the basement of our house. And this was about sort of 7 7pm UK time, and I really hadn't been concentrating at all. I'm literally surrounded by these boxes. My phone goes. I'm like, oh, Christ, I forgot to do this thing. And I like, answer the phone and it's Australia. And I say, oh, hi, hi. And they're like, yeah, you ready for the interview? And I'm like, yeah, sure. Can you just remind me, like, what this is again? Is this like a recorded thing or a live thing? And he's like, oh, no, this is live. We're going on the radio. And I was like, okay, great. And what's the. Is it like an interview? He's like, no, it's a call in, mate. And I'm like, okay. And what, what time is it in Australia? He's like, it's 4 o' clock in the morning. I was like, okay, great. We're doing a live 4am Australian radio phone in. And fucking hell. The calls at 4 o' clock in the morning on Australian radio about people's family premonitions, experiences. Like, hot damn. It was just like, it was unbelievable. And it was just, and they were screen, they were screening the callers, but the people that were coming through with their stories. There was a woman who called and she worked in a small office in a government department and had just an incredibly vivid dream that her boss had died in a small plane accident. And she didn't really like her boss and she was coming into work and just didn't know what to do. Like a sort of HR situation and you know, the boss dies in like a small plane flash like three days later. Do you know what I mean? She just lived with this ever since. You know, people. Obviously the most common reported one is, you know, a family member dying, you know, hundreds of thousands of miles of part. And you just know. Incredibly kind of vivid description from a woman who going out on a date with her husband, desperate to go, really looking forward to it and just couldn't leave that. Just pouring with tears, just couldn't leave the house. And it was because her brother had died in the Philippines or kind of somewhere hundreds of miles away at that moment. These things. I spent kind of an hour on the phone with people just calling in, as I say, the witching hour of kind of of Australia, just telling you these stories in the most matter of fact way you can imagine. And so anyway, so these are the things that have sort of changed me. They're just kind of, you know, unarguable kind of information in a way.
- [74:14]
C
I'm curious if, you know, your perspective on people telling those stories. They're not looking for validation that they were real. It's their experience. They're really looking for acknowledgement. Right. Like to share and to know that other people are also experiencing something like that, to feel less alone. What's your experience of them?
- [74:36]
A
Since writing the book, you know, I'll get emails from people and often the feelings that I feel like I'm picking up on are the kind of less intense versions of the Alan Hencher feeling, which is this doesn't give you responsibility. Do you know what I mean? People feel very guilty and feel very kind of loaded with this information because they don't know what to do with it because it won't be believed. They feel like they feel like a duty to do something with it and yet there's nowhere to put it. And so I do kind of write back to people or just tell people you are allowed to just let this go, but the way you don't have to do anything with it because it's not on you to solve this. When you say they're Looking for validation. I don't think they're looking for validation. They're often looking for relief or looking for a place to be lightened. The way my mind goes is you then think about established religious rituals where there is a place for these things to happen. You know, you're allowed to sit in a box in the corner of the church and tell your weird shit to the priest, and it goes away. You know, like, as humans, like these experience, like, we have places for this.
- [76:01]
B
I'll go back, forgive me, pre Christianity or Catholicism, you know, the prophecy of the Old Testament, which, when I was taught these things, no one ever included the most important piece of information about prophecy in the Old Testament. They were visions, they were dreams. Meaning, I was picturing like, who are these raving lunatics walking around? Which you could still say, they're raving lunatics. But the notion that there was a group of people who had dreams that were so powerful that someone thought to record them, right, and call them prophecy, that is very interesting to me. And it shows a historical connection that we have with the things that people experience about a timeline that is not the one that we're living in, that they somehow are projecting into. And, like, it was always their death and destruction is coming, you know, like. Like no big shocker. Which, you know, for certain communities, it doesn't take a precognitive person to be like, I think they're gonna try and kill you again. They're gonna come for you. Like, it's gonna happen. But even that notion that there was a cultural conversation around it. These are prophets who are receiving something, yes, divine. But I don't know who's to say what the definition of divine is, right? It's something from outside of this realm that I can access. Something that Dr. Barker organized in 1965 at the Charing Cross Hotel. He got a group of people together to try and see if he could understand from a more kind of, you know, quantitative perspective what's going on. People who prescribe to know the future. Clairvoyants, astrologers, card readers. He gathered them all together to see if he could find patterns, get information. One of the things he asked was, can I learn to do this? And one of them said, it's too late. And there are people that we've spoken to who have definitely have access to realms that I don't understand and that I can't explain. But one of the things that many say is that we all have the ability to tap into this. And by this, you could say, oh, the Akashic Records is something for thousands of years that traditions have said there's a field of consciousness that exists. And if you drop into this place and many people get there with meditation, many people get there with other transcendental experiences and psilocybin and things like this, that you can tap into this information in a way that it just sort of exists out there. What is your take on these kinds of abilities? Do you think that it's something that we all have the ability for and we're just not tapping into it? Is it something that's for a select few or is it somewhere in the middle?
- [78:55]
A
Barker gets these fortune tellers together and asks them, he's doing his kind of scared to death research. And he says, and he asks them kind of in your sort of code of practice as a, as a palm reader, you know, do you tell someone if you think they're going to die? And they have sort of differing answers to this? And, and it was, it was precious to me because the audio of these interviews kind of survives. So I was kind of able to, to hear Barker kind of do his questioning. And there is this kind of very moving conversation with this Irish clairvoyant where, where Barker says, you know, what about, you know, what about me? Do I have this, do I have this gift? Can I, can I get involved? And, and, and, and, and, and the clairvoyant says, you know, as you said, no, you're too late. I'm going to add to your sort of list of people or circumstances where people are able to sort of access a field of consciousness or some of these questions. I do sort of hold to the idea of, and this is kind of influenced by writing about the British spiritualist movement and the kind of turn of the 20th century. Is the idea of a sort of a life unlived or a kind of a rupture in the terms of the loss of someone close to you or the loss of a child, or a sense of a kind of interrupted path being then the trigger or the gateway, or if you're a kind of ardent materialist, a kind of an explanation for people sort of reaching for something that isn't there. I kind of, and I feel that in this conversation with Barker, you can hear him, this kind of dual side of him, where he is a serious scientist and a good doctor, and yet he wants to kind of break free of all the confines that that represents at that time. And there is a kind of a life unlived for him. And I kind of, I don't know where this kind of adds to the conversation. But I do feel that where there is that kind of, as I say, a life unlived or a kind of a deep yearning, that stuff can kind of arise from that.
- [81:23]
B
Sam, it's really such a pleasure to get to talk to you. I love this book so much, and every character just really came to life. So I'm sorry I don't have the proper cover to show, but the premonitions. A true account of death foretold. Sam Knight, thank you so much for being with us.
- [81:41]
A
Thank you for having me.
- [81:46]
B
Some might say I had a premonition that when I read this book that we would know much more about it now than we did when I first read it. Because when I first read it, we were just at the start of talking about psi phenomenon. It wasn't really even like a part of this podcast that way.
- [82:02]
C
We had to mature and evolve in order to talk about this book.
- [82:05]
B
But the notion that he's describing things from a very particular, you know, moment in. In the late 1960s, also, Ms. Middleton predicted Bobby Kennedy's assassination and some people might be like, well, that wouldn't take a genius, blah, blah. But along with all of her other premonitions, the day before he was shot, she called the premonitions Bureau three times to say, an assassination is coming, it's coming, it's coming. And then he was killed at midnight that night. We know so much more about the. Also the neuroscience of what it means to have different timelines. Right. That you're tapping into. We've talked to so many people who have precognitive abilities, who have premonition. I mean, even the telepathy tapes I thought of. Telepathy tapes is full of stuff about premonitions and people who know that people died. And like, what is that about? Especially in nonverbal communities, like, wow, what.
- [83:05]
C
Does it mean from a neuroscience perspective to have different timelines?
- [83:08]
B
I don't have a definitive. We know that this is true because. But many, if not all of the conversations we have had with theoretical physicists have talked about what probability means. What does it mean for our brain to be comprehending different probabilities? What does it mean for us to be calculating our reality based on what we see and based on what we think we're experiencing in this space time continuum.
- [83:36]
C
Remember when I walked into the podcast studio before it was the podcast studio, and I met myself from another timeline and then I got scared and I ran out?
- [83:44]
B
Yep, a premonition. Let us hear.
- [83:47]
C
There we go.
- [83:50]
B
The Stuff about two different people that he worked with. Predicting his death freaks me out. Freaks me out. Because it's also possible that there are people who have premonitions who have precognitive abilities who also suffer from other challenges mentally. That's not impossible. It's not really one or the other. This is all like a spectrum of. Of functioning. It's a spectrum of integration with the real world and the ability to distinguish. Right. What is fantasy, what is generated and what is downloaded. The way these people describe it, this is downloaded information.
- [84:29]
C
The thing about premonitions versus intuition is also very hard, right. Because intuition is often in the moment. How do I navigate a certain situation?
- [84:37]
B
And I don't think it's fact based. It's not like 124 people will die.
- [84:43]
C
Not fact based at all. Fact in that, oh, I shouldn't do something or I should go some other way. It's like these nudges versus premonitions. And I think about specific Allison Dubois show. Like, that was the character's name. It was with Patricia Arquette, who was a detective. And she was. Well, she wasn't a detective, but she was helping detectives solve crime through her psychic ability. And I believe it was based on a real person. The problem is always like, the detectives are like, well, it's not accurate enough and you're getting. Getting false positives. And if we do everything you say, then it's going to be. And so she's always getting it in symbols and small little doses and forms. And like, what do you do with all this information when there are false false positives? Do you shut down the bridge? Do you not go as a speaker to an event? Like, if you think that there could be an assassination in the next however many days, like, sure, if it's the next day, it becomes very inconvenient to follow all the messages. And yet if you don't follow some of them and you don't know which ones to follow, well, then catastrophe strikes.
- [85:51]
B
And some people might say, well, if there's premonitions of all these things, why aren't there premonitions of positive things? There actually is an answer. The notion is that when there is distress, when there is tragedy, it vibrates at a different frequency. So that people who are picking up on this are picking up on something somehow.
- [86:11]
C
There's a disturbance in the force.
- [86:13]
B
There is a disturbance in the force. There is something that has a quality to it that draws attention in ways that, like, I have a premonition, you're gonna order ice cream. It doesn't. Unless you're lactose intolerant, in which case that could be a very critical situation.
- [86:29]
C
That can be a big disturbance.
- [86:30]
B
It can be a very big disturbance. I really, really enjoyed speaking to Sam and very. I know we are going to get a lot of comments on this topic. I know it.
- [86:44]
C
If you have a story of a premonition, let us know on substack and in the comments on this episode. We're fascinated. I'm fascinated by how he describes that all of these stories are living in, in almost all of our families in some way. And you talk about it. The Hungarian grandmother. That's right, the Eastern European grandmother. The nana who could heal or sense things or knew things before they happened.
- [87:13]
B
Look, there's people far more skilled than you and I in talking about this. I think part of it is the renaissance, the intellectual renaissance brought forth a real rejection of folk wisdom and mysticism and all those things because we are now advanced. We have advanced to a certain place and in many cases that was true. Like, who knew that washing hands before you put them inside someone's body to do surgery could prevent infection, right? But there are so many advances that we needed. However, what got left behind was a potential wisdom, insight, heart to our experience. That is still there. It's still there. It's everywhere.
- [87:56]
C
Well, I appreciate you finding this book for us and I'm sure everyone else does as well.
- [88:02]
B
From our breakdown to the one we hope you never have. We'll see you next time.
- [88:05]
A
It's Maya Bialix Breakdown. She's gonna break it down for you. She's got a neuroscience PhD or two non fiction and now she's gonna break down. So break down. She's gonna break it down.
- [88:23]
B
Another day, another major event tariff and a new random zit. Strange. Times like these can lead to extra stress which can lead to unpredictable breakouts. The good news is that Mighty Patch original shrinks the look of pimples in just one use. That's a pretty good deal for your skin and your wallet. Shop mightypatch at all major retailers.
- [88:45]
C
Hey, Ryan Reynolds here for Mint Mobile. You know one of the perks about having four kids that you know about is actually getting a direct line to the big man up north. And this year he wants you to know the best gift that you can give someone is the gift of Mint Mobile's unlimited wireless for $15 a month.
- [89:01]
B
Now you don't even need to wrap it.
- [89:03]
C
Give it a try@mintmobile.com Switch upfront payment.
- [89:06]
B
Of $45 for a three month plan equivalent to $15 per month. Required new customer offer for first three months only. Speed slow after 35 gigabytes if network's busy, taxes and fees extra. See mintmobile.com.