Transcript
Mickey Jo (0:00)
The holidays are coming and I've got.
Commercial Announcer 1 (0:02)
A Boost Mobile gift just for you. Aww, for me, Anna? Yes, Anna, you deserve a gift. The Boost Mobile unlimited plan is just $10 a month for the first two months, then $25 a month forever with unlimited data, talk and text. It's a gift. Thanks, Anna. Anytime, Anna.
Commercial Announcer 2 (0:19)
The holidays are here and the best gift is for you. Offer valid@boostmobile.com after your first two months. You'll pay $25 a month unless you go online or call to cancel. Requires autopay Every year I tell myself I'm going to start holiday shopping early. And every year I wait until the last minute. But this time I actually nailed it. I sent Omaha Steaks gift boxes to my family and they were a hit. There's something about opening that box. Those beautifully cut, perfectly aged steaks, the juicy burgers, even the cozy comfort meals. My dad called me the next night to rave about his ribeyes. Said it was the best steak he's ever grilled. Honestly, I think Omaha Steaks might be my new go to gift. It's thoughtful, it's delicious, and it shows up right at your door, perfectly packed and ready to impress. Save big on gourmet gifts and more holiday favorites with omaha steaks. Visit OmahaSteaks.com for 50% off site wide during their Sizzle all the Way sale and for an extra $35 off, use promo code Holiday at checkout terms apply. See site for details. That's omahasteaks.com code holiday hear that?
Commercial Announcer 1 (1:28)
It's holiday cheer arriving at Ulta Beauty with gifts for everyone on your list. Treat them to fan favorite gift sets from Charlotte Tilbury and Peach and Lily. Go all out with timeless fragrances from ysl, Ariana Grande and Carolina Herrera. And you can never go wrong with an Ulta Beauty gift card. Head to Ulta Beauty for gifts that make the holidays brighter and even more beautiful. Ulta Beauty gifting happens here.
Mickey Jo (1:58)
So I've been reviewing theatre full time for a few years now and I've been traveling around the world seeing shows in half a dozen countries across three continents. I've seen the same show twice in one day in two different countries. I've woken up and seen 10 shows in a single day before. But right now I'm going to attempt one of my biggest critical challenges to date. I am about to review every show currently on Broadway, including the ones I have never seen. Let me explain. Oh my God. Hey. Welcome back to my theatre themed YouTube channel. Or hello to those of you listening to this on podcast platforms. My name is Mickey Jo and I am obsessed with all things theatre and I'm also not currently here, by which I mean I have filmed this in advance of heading to New York to go and see as many Broadway and Off Broadway shows as possible for a couple of weeks, with all of that content to arrive soon wherever you are seeing or hearing this. But in the meantime I prepared some content for you to enjoy in my absence, including today's in which I'm going to attempt to tell you the best and worst thing about every show currently on Broadway. Now, not all of these will be shows that I have previously seen. Some of these answers might be a little bit tongue in cheek, but some of them I think are entirely accurate and it might be details about the material, it might be details about the theatre going experience or the wider cultural context of the show. You will have to stay tuned and find out. But as always I am hugely interested in what you say in the comments. Feel free to agree or entirely disagree any of the points that I make here. And if you really want to feel free to share your own version of this list in the comments section down below. What is the best and worst thing about each of these Broadway shows? Now, if you enjoy this and for some reason haven't already subscribed to my theatre themed YouTube channel, what are you doing? Feel free to hit subscribe and turn on notifications or go follow me on podcast platforms. In the meantime, in 30 minutes or less, hopefully, Here is the best and worst thing about every single show on Broadway. Okay, so I have a list here which I'm pretty sure contains every single show that is currently playing, whether it is open, whether it's in previews, if it's on Broadway right now, I'm about to talk about it. So for no particular reason we are going to do this in reverse alphabetical order which means we are starting with Wicked, currently playing at the Gershwin Theatre. Now the best thing about Wicked on Broadway is Defying Gravity. I think Defying Gravity is the defining moment of Wicked, the musical on stage. It's still maybe the best Act 1 finale that there is. Certainly I think the best one that there is on Broadway right now. That's an incredible experience in the theater. The worst thing about Wicked on stage is that Wicked the movie now exists across two parts and was able to flesh out the story and these scenes and these characters. So now when we go back and see it on stage, we're going to long for those moments that they found on film and the nuance that they found. And the whole thing is going to feel a little bit faster because it is. Next up, Waiting for Godot. The best thing about Waiting For Godot is that by all accounts it seems like they are finding a slightly more playful route through it and using characters of Bill and Ted and sort of subverting the iconic status of Keanu Reeves and Alex Winter in order to reframe the story a little bit. The worst thing about Waiting for Godot, I'm sorry, Samuel Beckett, is that it's Waiting for Godot. Next up, Two Strangers Carry a Cake Across New York. The best part of Two Strangers Carry a Cake Across New York is it's the kind of story we don't see on stage very much. It's this little intimate, honest, charming, heartwarming, down to earth sort of cinematic love story between these characters set on the charming streets of New York. The worst thing about Two Strangers Carry a Cake Across New York is every time I see it, it makes me want to go and eat cake. Or the fact that I want to know what happens to these characters after the show and I don't get to because they haven't written a sequel. I need to see the show. Two strangers call each other six months later to discuss how everything's getting on. Next up, Stranger Things, the First Shadow, currently playing at the Marriott Marquis Theatre. The best thing about Stranger Things, the first Shadow is the stage effects and the really awe inspiring and genuinely frightening stuff that they are Achie leaving. It's the best version of that show because they tinkered with it a little bit post West End. I would say the worst thing about Stranger Things, the First Shadow as a stage play is it doesn't really expand that much on the universe we already knew because it's within the constraints of the TV show. And when you do a prequel, these characters that you are taking, they can't discover too much because they don't know that much already in the TV show. So without retconning a lot of detail, it's hard to create a new story when you're moving backwards in time. So it pretty much just tells us everything that we already knew about the backstory of the Stranger Things world. Six the Musical the best thing about six the Musical is the way that its casting allows for these different performers to come in and make the show their own. This is why to this day, I think it's still the show I've seen the most times because it's just like going back to see a band that you love. In concert, except for the fact that the lineup is different every single time, and they always bring in phenomenal talent. But from one show to the next, the Aragon or the Cleaves or the Seymour that you see could play and sing the role completely differently. The worst thing about six the musical on Broadway, I would say the American accent can be a little bit jarring, but once you get past that, it's not that big a deal. Maybe it's the fact that it's inherently a little bit insubstantial. Like, it is a kind of a concert vibe. There is still a narrative, there are still characters. It is still teaching you a meaningful lesson, especially to young people. But it's one of the lighter Broadway shows that you could go and see. Next up. Oh, this one's easy. Rob Lake Magic with special guests, the Muppets. The best part of this that I have not seen yet is the Muppets, who I love. And the worst part of this is the fact that it features magic, which I have had an incapacitating fear of since childhood. I love the Muppets and I have an irrational fear of magicians that's quite personal to me. Apologies to Rob Lake. Sorry to that man. Next up, we have Ragtime. Oh, my gosh. The best thing about Ragtime is it's one of the greatest book musicals ever written. It's that particular sequence of four or five songs in a row that are just increasingly epic bangers because you have wheels of a dream out of new music into to something else. It's this string of, like, relentlessly great and extraordinary and huge songs all in a row, which allows for these extraordinary performances. The worst thing about Ragtime, and I will say with this production specifically, is the tendency to want to let the score and the material simply speak and sing for itself, and the reluctance to give us a fully staged production. I love the score. I love the script. I would also love a set. Then we have the Queen of Versailles, which I have not seen yet. The best thing about the Queen of Versailles is that show. Renee Scott is back on Broadway in a musical for the first time in over a decade. Standing by for Kristin Chenoweth. The worst thing I think about the Queen of Versailles is existing in this exact political moment, telling the story of someone who is endeared to President Donald Trump. And a story of extraordinary wealth at a time when a great many people around the world are struggling and suffering in poverty. Next up, we have the Outsiders. The best thing about the Outsiders is the sequence in the second act when they Fight in the Rain. The staging of that is absolutely extraordinary. Really fantastic. Worth going to see the show just to see that moment. The worst thing about the Outsiders is the way that the script still sort of feels as though it's behaving like a book. And we have all of these moments of narration when you have enough characters on stage and you have the capacity to simply write dialogue and to simply write scenes instead, we are still behaving a little bit like we're a book. Next up, Operation Mincemeat. The best thing about Operation Mincemeat is probably the Dear Bill moment, performed by Tony Award and Olivier Award winner Jack Malone. This part of the show, in the middle of the first act that goes from zany, silly comedy to heartbreaking emotional sincerity and depth and pathos, taking everyone by surprise. The worst thing, perhaps about Operation Mincemeat, this isn't about the London production. If it was, I would talk about the pricing structure. The worst thing about the Broadway production of Operation Mincemeat, I don't think too British can be a shortcoming. Maybe it's the sound design at the Golden Theatre. Maybe it's a combination of the Britishness of it with the sound design at the Golden Theatre and the fact that a majority of audience members might be struggling to understand the words that are being said which are very important to the comedy of the show. Speaking of comedy, next up, we have O Mary, currently playing at the Lyceum Theatre. The best thing about Omar on Broadway is the ingenious casting by the incredible team working on that show, this succession of brilliant and completely varied stars. Playing the role of Mary Todd Lincoln. After original star and writer Cole Escola, Betty Gilpin, Titus Burgess, Jinx Monsoon, now Jane Krakowski. It's unhinged, it's campy and it's fantastic. And it's keeping audiences like me helplessly returning to the show time after time after time. The worst thing about oh Mary, I think, might be the fact that we don't get more musical numbers and we have a madcap musical medley at the end. But they have a tendency now to cast a lot of musical theater powerhous performers. I want to hear Jinkx Monsoon singing more songs. I want to hear Titus Burgess and Jane Krakowski singing more songs. Then hold on to your mothers. Over at Studio 54, we have Oedipus. The best thing about this production of Oedipus is how utterly captivating and thrilling it is as we count down in real time to this damning, redefining revelation and this Unspeakable horror framed powerfully in a completely familiar modern context and navigated by these two extraordinary performance that was like three great things packed into one. It's an incredible adaptation. The worst thing about it is, I think it's going to call itself a revival of a classical play by which it is clearly inspired, but which it has entirely adapted by Robert Icke, that is, and to which it bears no resemblance of language, only of structure. And the fact that Sarah Snook on stage reading the Importance of Being Earnest by Oscar Wilde almost word for word, counts technically as a new play, and this counts technically as a revival is baffling to me. Next up, we have Moulin Rouge. The best thing about Moulin Rouge, there's a close second, which is the design of the whole thing and particularly the exterior design of the theatre, I think is just gorgeous. But the best thing about Moulin Rouge is the opening of the second act. And that backstage romance sequence and Sonya Tyre's choreography. It is show stopping at a time that the show has only just restarted. I would definitely call this the strongest Act 2 opening in all of Broadway. And the worst thing about Moulin Rouge might be the of songs that are packed into it, some of which draw a little bit of laughter, which render the show occasionally a little insincere. Specifically, let's say the worst thing about Moulin Rouge on stage as a musical is the fact that they got rid of One Day I'll Fly away from the film and instead had her sing Katy Perry's Firework. And you know what? Close runner up to this as well is the fact that they don't cast Satine age appropriately, that they have all of these old men around her being like, remember how we were children together and you can't be a prostitute forever. Often to a woman in her 20s who looks sensational. So you can have that one for free. Moulin Rouge. Just a couple things to consider. What do we have next? Oh, here comes the controversy. MJ the musical on Broadway at the the Neil Simon Theatre. I believe the best thing about mj, which I've only seen once in my life in the West End, is the choreography by Christopher Wheeldon and the way that the show builds these numbers and its relationship to dance and how celebratory it is of dance and the way that it unpacks Michael Jackson's artistic and emotional relationship with dance and choreography and all of his different inspirations. I thought that was just brilliant. The worst thing about mj, I'm gonna get some comments on this one is the way the show deliberately focuses in on a moment in Michael Jackson's life leading up to, but not including the start of the serious allegations against him so that it doesn't have to address it. It's a sort of impossibly unavoidable elephant in the room. Speaking of which, we have maybe Happy Ending, my favorite musical on Broadway playing at the Belasco Theatre. How can I give you just one best thing about maybe happy Ending? My gosh, I think a lot like Two Strangers. It's the originality of the story, the way that it feels small. But the best thing, no, the best thing about maybe Happy Ending is the fact that I can recommend it to just about anyone. I think the humanity of this story transcends all kinds of identity or demographic or age. I think old and young alike will find something to recognize in this like perfect date night, perfect for families. Go see with your parents something hugely charming about maybe Happy Ending that just about any audience member has the capacity, I think, to fall in love with. The worst thing about maybe Happy Ending is, and I'm going to frame this a slightly different way because it's an indictment on the industry is.
