Transcript
Herobread Advertiser (0:00)
Fall is all about cozy comforts, but when you're prioritizing your health, it's easy to feel like you're missing out. With herobread. You can enjoy all your fall favorites because they're made with herobread, sliced bread, loaves, tortillas, bagels, dinner rolls and more. Try their all new hero noodles with 12 grams of protein and just 80 calories, you won't believe. HeroBred's options have 0 to 5 grams net carbs and are high fiber from the taste and texture. They've even got small batch drops of indulgent favorites like the popular Hero croissant. And right now, Herobread is offering 10 off your order. Go to Hero Co and use code fall25 at checkout. That's fall25. All figures are per serving of HeroBread contains 2 to 18 grams of fat per serving. See the product nutrition panels on Hero Co for more information.
Mickey Jo (0:47)
Acast powers the World's best podcasts. Here's a show that we recommend.
Lexi and Nicole (0:54)
Are you a fantasy reader looking to cure your book hangover? Then welcome, welcome, welcome to the Fantasy Fangirls podcast. I'm Lexi, older sister and fantasy lore nerd. And I'm Nicole, younger sister and romantic at heart and we love exploring these stories, worlds and characters well beyond the last page. Fantasy Fangirls is not your typical book. Deep Dive Podcast when we say deep dive, we mean Deep Dive where every episode covers a stretch of chapters and is structured with five segments to easily follow along. We are currently deep diving Quicksilver by Callie Hart in the lead up to its highly anticipated season sequel, Brimstone. We're so excited. We hope you join us as we travel through the Quicksilver to dive deep into literary and character analysis, theories, lore, themes and so much more.
Mickey Jo (1:38)
ACAST helps creators launch, grow and monetize their podcasts everywhere. Acast.com Trisha Paytas is joining the Broadway Company of Beetlejuice Trisha Paytas is joining the Broadway Company of Beetlejuice Trisha Paytas is joining the Broadway Company of Beetlejuice. I say it three times, not as a reference to the show, but because because I'm still processing this information in real time. Oh my God. Hey, welcome back to my theatre themed YouTube channel. Or hello to you if you are listening to this fascinating news update on podcast platforms. My name is Mickey Jo and I'm obsessed with all things theatre, even when it's incredibly strange. I am a professional theatre critic and a content creator here on social media and today I bring you the bizarre news that Trisha Paytas, social media personality, shall we say, is going to be joining the Broadway tour stop of Beetlejuice, which has recently started performances at the Palace Theatre in New York. This is the national touring production which, like the national tour of Mamma Mia. Is playing a Broadway tour stop, this being a financial model that we are seeing more and more of, with the recent revival production of the Wiz being an interesting example. And within that model, the production is playing a limited run on Broadway. It is not going to be here for months and months and months. It is only arriving for a short holiday time window, creating a scarcity of tickets that presumably will make it a little easier to sell them. But to make sure that that they really do, we have a little bit of stunt casting involved in the show as well, in the form of Trisha Paytas. There is plenty to say about this. I have opinions and I'm sure that you do in the comments section as well. I'm going to try and look at this from every conceivable angle. We are going to talk about this casting. We're going to talk about whether or not I think it really matters, whether it's worth the outrage and more broadly, what this means for Beetlejuice and for Broadway. I don't have to tell you to share all of your thoughts in the comment section down below because I know that you will. But if you want to stay up to date with everything that I think about what's going on on Broadway and in the west and in the theater world globally, make sure to subscribe to my theatre themed YouTube channel. Go follow me on podcast platforms. I can't bear to wait another minute. Let's talk about Trisha Paytas in Beetlejuice. Now. In truth, this wasn't a total surprise. It had been rumored on social media, but it had been rumored on a platform that is wildly inconsistent when it comes to accuracy and journalistic integrity. So, you know, nice to see on this occasion that it wasn't entirely nonsense. And there is some history in the context of this piece of cast as well, because Trisha Paytas, who has done a lot on social media and whose existence and online career I struggle to summarize, though I also don't necessarily encourage you to google it, especially if you share an Internet capable device with a family member. But in recent years, Trisha Paytas has also emerged as a musical theater and Broadway super fan, and for a time she was deeply obsessed with the musical Beetlejuice. She was cosplaying and she was reenacting entire songs and scenes with multiple cats cameras dressing up as the different characters. More recently she appeared on Broadway in a one woman show at the St James Theatre, which sold wildly fast and then sold live stream tickets as well, which should have been an indication about the popularity of Trisha Paytas and the likelihood that she was going to try and return to Broadway in some other capacity. Evidently she can sell tickets. She can sell tickets to a Broadway house in New York and producers will have noticed that, and clearly they have. And if you're now thinking great, fantastic, popular social media star goes into show and helps it sell more tickets, just like Charli d' Amelio recently did in and Juliet, then the important clarification here is that Trisha Paytas, as well as being deeply controversial for many, many years, in many ways she still is is not explicitly and I'm really trying to think of a nice way of saying this talented. That is to say she is not a trained dancer like Charli d'. Amelio. From what we saw of her one woman show on Broadway, she is incredibly charismatic and very endearing. She has an effervescent personality. That's what her so popular on social media for so many years and so prolific. She's clearly determined and driven. She is not an extraordinarily gifted singer, but she's also before we get too upset about it, not playing a singing role in the show, let me tell you some more of the details from the press release that I have just received. This time when I open it, I won't fall off of a chair. Here we go. Trisha Paytas to join Beetlejuice on Broadway. She will be starring as Maxine Dean in beetlejuice for a three week limited engagement. So a only for three weeks of its larger run that is from Tuesday, November 4th through Sunday, November 23rd. With your next question perhaps being Mickey Jo who on earth is Maxine Dean? And I have not yet seen Beetlejuice. It has yet to make its way to the uk, though a West End premiere was recently announced for next year. Very exciting. But from a brief moment of Internet research I have discovered that Maxine Dean is a character who appears in one scene in the first act. She is something of a minor comedy character who is involved in in one of the show's iconic musical moments, but who doesn't independently sing in the context of the show. She is normally part of a featured ensemble track that plays multiple different roles. Trisha Paytas is only playing one of two or three depending on who you ask. How do they Describe her in the press release. Let's go with this. Trisha Paytas is a creator, podcast host, actress and vocalist, okay. Who over the past 18 years has helped shape online culture that she has and inspired a new generation of talented, okay. While building a following of over 20 million fans and 2 billion views on YouTube. Which apparently is all it takes to get a walk on role on Broadway. Imagine each of you convinces five of your friends to watch a few of my videos. We could be there. This could be Mickey Jo Theatre in Beetlejuice. I don't know that I'd make a compelling Maxine Dean, but I would do my best. Trisha is known for being versatile. Excuse me? Trisha is known for being versatile. She's done everything from lifestyle vlogs, asmr, mukbangs and cosplay to music videos, comedy skits and honest personal monologues. She's appeared in over 50 TV shows and movies including the Tonight Show, America's Got Talent, Modern Family and Celebrity Big Brother UK. In 2024, Trisha took her career to the stage with the Eras of Trish, a 30 plus city sold out live tour that was part concert, part storytelling, part drag show and full of her signature humor. It was a fun self aware look back at her many phases from her iconic early YouTube moments to being a pop singer, podcast host and mom of three. Then in 2025 she made her Broadway debut. This is the one I was telling you about with Trisha Paytas Big Broadway Dream, a one night benefit concert at the St. James Theatre that featured stars like Sutton Foster, Ben Platt and Rachel Zegler. The show was a dream come true and a nod to her love of musical theatre. And from that perspective I have to to a certain extent be happy for her. You have to be happy for anyone who is getting to achieve their dream and they've done this before. And this is a really egregious example and I am not holding this up next to Trisha Paytas and suggesting it's the same thing, but stay with me. They have done walk on cameo roles like this for Make a Wish Kids. I know, I'm not saying it's the same thing as Trisha Paytas, I'm just pointing it out. Another popular social media content creator, Kim Hale got a one night only role in Chicago on Broadway. Though truthfully I think that being the very talented dancer that she is, Kim Hale could have just been put into the show in an ensemble track. We've also seen this in the UK around the time of like comic Relief there's been various sort of charity adjacent promotional moments when celebrities have had walk on roles in often musical comedy shows, simply because those are the shows in which it's easier to pull off. It would be very hard to have somebody walk on in Hamilton and suddenly have to do the Blankenbuehler choreography. All of which is to say it's not completely unprecedented that this is happening. But my question before we get on to the Trisha Paytas of it all, which believe me, we will be circling aggressively back to, is did Beetlejuice need to do this? So this is what I think is really interesting to consider because like I said, the tour stop model is meant to be a more inexpensive one. You have these productions that have already been around the country. This tour, I believe is already reported to have recouped its investment, which Beetlejuice didn't do while it was on Broadway either originally at the Winter Garden Theatre or subsequently at the Marriott Marquee. Also worth pointing out that by this point in 2025 with Beetlejuice's third Broadway run, it's really had time develop a lot more of an audience and a lot more popularity as a cult hit musical Death Becomes her is thriving over at the Luntfontanne Theater. And tonally they do feel quite similar. Both of them owe a lot of their ongoing popularity to social media, virality and TikTok, which served Beetlejuice quite well in its early days, but not well enough to save it from eviction and then subsequently closure. Which is perhaps why there is a little bit of a nervousness around this third Broadway run. Both of the first two did not really end successfully. What is said about that in the press release is Beetlejuice had two unconventional, record breaking Broadway runs that brought a new and very engaged audience to Broadway via TikTok, YouTube and social media, playing to sold out standing room only audiences in 2019 at Broadway's Winter Garden Theatre on some occasions, and again in 2022 at the Marquee Theatre for a total of 679 Broadway performances. Beatlejuice the musical just finished a critically acclaimed record breaking 88 city tour. My gosh, that's a lot of cities. With one last Broadway resurrection at the legendary Pal Theater. Interestingly, its Broadway runs are all going to have been three years apart, so set your calendars for Beetlejuice's fourth Broadway run in 2028. Which theater is it going to? I hope it's the Lyric. Anyway, obviously as the run of the show progresses because grosses are made public on Broadway, we will see exactly how well it is selling, what the capacity looks like, what the average ticket price looks like, and how much interest there actually is in Beetlejuice. Because the online fandom and the noise of all of that and the social media buzz can sometimes offer a little bit of a smokescreen and it can suggest that there is more enthusia for the show than there actually is. Or at the very least, perhaps the enthusiasm that there is doesn't make its way to the box office in New York, because something going popular online is all very well, but you're going to be making a lot of fans who aren't local enough to go and see the show in the first place. Especially when you consider that They've just visited 88 cities worth of fans who have had the chance to see it considerably closer to home and to see the same production. Really, when you consider the version of the show that they had come to their local theater versus the Broadway one, I guess Trisha Paytas is the only sizable difference, because I believe the cast is otherwise the same one that's been on tour. And this is a phenomenon that we've seen as well. We've seen this in the UK when a show is very successful in the West End and then tours around and goes back to London and can't quite generate the same enthusiasm. Even when a show finishes a limited run in one place and then opens elsewhere, sometimes for whatever reason, they just can't get the fire started that was burning brightly where they just were. It makes little sense, but it can be difficult to try and transition an audience geographically. And obviously, although the grocers are on their way, what we don't have access to at this time that the producers do is data about the advance sales. And we could possibly speculate that they are foreseeing that Beetlejuice's Broadway return isn't currently selling as well as they might like. Although I do hear that this deal with Trisha Paytas to go into the show is one that has been talked about potentially for months, even since her Broadway concert at the St. James. And I recently spoke about the current financial landscape on Broadway and how challenged it is, particularly for musicals with really successful, well selling shows struggling to recoup. And the thing that consistently seems to be able to sell tickets is star casting. We are seeing it right now with Keanu Reeves and Alex Winter in Waiting for Godot. We saw it last season with Denzel and Jake Gyllenhaal and George Clooney and Sarah Snook and Kieran Culkin this is what does seem to be working on Broadway, so you can't blame Beetlejuice for seeing that happening around it and trying to emulate a little bit of that success for themselves. Whether they needed to I still can't really say. But obviously there is going to be a certain bump in ticket sales because of Trisha Paytas appearance. This is going to to a certain extent benefit them. I say that because I don't think that the number of people who were going to buy tickets who now won't specifically because of Trisha Paytas involvement will outnumber the people who are going to want to see her in Beetlejuice. Which brings us back to a conversation about Trisha and what I think of this.
