Mickey Jo (Theatre Critic and Content Creator) (3:05)
I'm thinking that I'm probably going to have titled this something like why Dylan Mulvaney Is Playing Anne Boleyn on Broadway. Or perhaps why six the Musical on Broadway cast Dylan Mulvaney. And if I have done that then and the short answer to that question is the two part process. Six the Musical on Broadway needed an Anne Boleyn and then they chose Dylan Mulvaney to play that role. The longer answer to the question is this entire video oh my God. Hey, welcome back to my theatre themed YouTube channel. Or hello to those of you listening to this on podcast platforms. My name is Mickey Jo and I am a theatre critic, content creator and pundit here on social media. I spend almost every day of my life seeing theatre and I spend every single day of my life talking about it. Which is what we're going to do right now. Because a Piece of Broadway Casting is making head headlines now. I actually shared some thoughts last week about a bunch of different casting announcements for a handful of different shows, and hours after I posted that online, six the Musical joined the conversation with some very exciting news about an entire new roster of queens joining the Queendom, AKA the Lena Horne Theatre on Broadway, where the show is approaching its sixth anniversary. That is depending on when exactly you start counting from, because the show had begun performances in March 2020 when all of the theaters on Broadway shut down amidst the developing situation. In fact, it was set to be six the Musical's opening night when the performance was cancelled. The show wouldn't have the chance to officially open for a little while, but a handful of other shows on either side of the Atlantic continue to celebrate their milestone anniversaries as if this period of closure didn't actually happen Anyway, Some original Broadway cast members are going to be returning to the show alongside some new faces, a couple of them well known faces, including the performer and songwriter Abigail Barlow. I keep trying to say Marlo, probably because I'm thinking of Annabel Marlowe, the sister of one of Six's co creators, Toby Marlowe, who also originated the role of Catherine Howard. Funnily enough, the role that Abigail is going to be playing, as well as performer and social media personality Dylan Mulvaney and Dylan's casting in the show in particular has unsurprisingly elicited some very strong responses, some of them so vitriolic that six's X account, which I just hate to say six's social media page on the app formerly known as Twitter, has had to resort to actually privatizing the page. Now, generally, whenever anything from the Broadway and musical theatre sphere spills out into the mainstream, I like to come on here because often the conversation that you see happening on social media and I did make the mistake of opening the app formerly known as Twitter earlier today, which I regretted almost immediately when my blood pressure spiked. The commentary that you often see and the reporting that you often see in the press by major media outlets tends to be wildly ignorant and misinformed. And so, as somebody who spends every day of their life speaking about this industry and its machinations with some level of insight and authority, I guess I thought I would come on here and clear up a little bit of misinformation. So we're going to talk about Dylan being cast in six on Broadway. We are going to talk about stunt casting and its implications in the current financial ecosystem within particularly the Broadway theatre industry. We are also going to talk about the wider anti trans bigotry that this has once again unearthed, as well as perhaps current and future prospects for trans and non binary performers in professional theatre. And for those of you simply curious about this from an industry standpoint, maybe we'll also talk a little bit more about what this means for six the Musical and why they might be pulling out such a bold casting move at this time. And I don't just mean Dylan. This entire roster is quite unlike the way they've been casting the show for the last few years now. As always, I will be sharing my thoughts with you. I am cautiously intrigued to hear yours in the comments section down below on the understanding that everyone is going to conduct themselves with a basic level of human decency and mutual respect. I am a champion of free speech. Theatre has always been a haven for subjective opinions, but virtually speaking, this is my house and you're going to take your shoes off at the door. What I mean by that is my comment section is not a space in which bigotry or transphobia are tolerated. So on the basis that we are now, hopefully all on the same page, let's carry on with this conversation and talk about why Dylan Mulvaney has been cast in six the Musical on Broadway. So, as we tend to do, let's zoom out on this entire thing. And bring in the well needed context. And we're going to talk about six the musical and the way the show has been cast historically in the approach that it takes to these characters who were real women, who all lived, who admittedly did not all live at the same time and form a Tudor pop group. Just in case anyone happened to be of the opinion that this was a steadfast documentary with handheld microphones and confetti cannons. But first, I think it would be beneficial for us to talk about Dylan, who I should point out, I have seen performing on stage on multiple occasions. I have met and spoken to her on many more occasions. I think I can call Dylan Mulvaney a friend at this point. We have mutual friends, we have interacted many, many times. And Dylan a few years ago became this mega popular social media influencer, content creator who was in real time, very publicly documenting her transition with a series that she titled Days of Girlhood. Sort of illuminating the contemporary transgender experience, but more so than anything else, finding joy and euphoria in what can be a very sort of fraught personal circumstance, especially in the current socio political landscape. The less said about which perhaps the better. I gather that we all have some level of understanding of what is happening right now to the transgender community on a global level. And if you don't, it's probably important that you find out. Key to this conversation though is that prior to this, Dylan had a background in musical theatre, had been a part of the national tour of the musical the Book of Mormon, a career which she recommenced a few years ago after finding huge newfound levels of fame and popularity, and amidst becoming sort of the de facto face of the trans community in the 2020s, some regrettable notoriety, but with the bud light of it all in the rear view mirror. Dylan appeared at cabaret performances. She starred in her own one woman show at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe, which more recently transferred off Broadway to the Lucille Lortel Theatre in New York. She has also appeared alongside established actors in concert production. She was part of a concert at the Savoy Theatre here in the West End before a bear took up residence. All of which, I hasten to point out, happened entirely without incident. Not only was there no discernible anti trans backlash to any of this, but there also didn't arise much of a conversation, especially with Dylan's being cast in that Drew Gasparini concert, about stunt casting or her not being qualified for the role that she was hired to portray. Worth noting, in each instance, Dylan was portraying herself or a non gender specific character Fast forward to this month, January 2026, when Dylan is announced alongside a handful of other performers to be joining the cast of six the Musical on Broadway playing the real life historic Queen Anne Boleyn. And there arises some conversation about this being indicative of historical inaccuracy as well as some transphobic conversation about opportunities within the theatre industry within Broadway being taken away from women who deserve them. At which point I think it would be helpful for us to fast forward about a decade or so to when six the Musical was first being developed. Now, the show's life started here in the uk, co written by students and friends Toby Marlowe and Lucy Moss. It began as a university production performed and produced students at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe, whereupon I believe it was noticed by producers who then further developed the show development, which eventually amounted to a return to the Edinburgh Festival Fringe in a professional production that bears some close resemblance to the show that you see today. It also happened to be the occasion when I saw the show for the very first time in a venue that was literally a giant purple inflatable cow. And the inherent anachronism of the piece notwithstanding, with the six wives of Henry VIII existing as a girl group within this sort of purgatorial yet contemporary space, performing a banging pop musical theatre score, it was immediately clear that each of these characters had been conceived with a deliberately modern sensibility and sort of vocally styled after various recognizable music icons. Catherine of Aragon seemed very much inspired by Beyonce, Anne Boleyn by Lily Allen, with other references in there to the likes of Britney and Ariana Grande and Alicia Keys and Rihanna and Adele. And though the show's script and lyrics were littered with witty historial trivia and the score even contained a nod to the Elizabethan melody of Green sleeves, it wasn't purporting to be any kind of a history lesson. What it was was right there in the lyrics, a histo remix. And the show quickly came to prominence with that cast from the Edinburgh Festival Fringe. What we then saw over the next few years was a very impressive rate of expansion for the show as they put out a concurrent UK tour with another set of Queens hiring more and more understudy and standby performers as the months went by to cover these very phys vocally demanding roles, a North American production was announced that eventually made its way to Broadway. The show began to appear on cruise ships. To date it has appeared in many countries. It is beginning to be translated into other languages. A Japanese language production recently happened. There is going to be a Spanish language production in Madrid later this year. It has gone from hit musical to undisputed global phenomenon in a way that few shows have since Hamilton. A big reason for which is the show's winning formula, which combines this dynamite score with all ages entertainment. And it's worth pointing out comparatively low running costs, the set being a single static one and the cast by definition being quite small. And one other key area of success that is worth pointing out is the malleable nature of the roles within the show. Each time that they would open a new production or bring in replacement casting or even have an understudy performer go on, their interpretation of of these six well known Tudor queens could look and sound entirely different to their predecessor or the principal performer who they were understudying. There was no sense of rigid continuity about how these queens ought to be portrayed, about the accent that they might have, about their skin tone, about their physical appearance, to some extent even about their vocal type. And it became clear very quickly as six rose to meteoric success, that diversity was going to be a big part of their approach and their cast, casting included, within which was an act of encouragement for trans and non binary performers to audition. And there have been, prior to the casting of Dylan Mulvaney, multiple non binary performers in productions of the show, empowering this story of historic womanhood and personhood to attain contemporary cultural resonance. So to recap, this is not really the first time that this has happened within this particular show, and ultimate exact historical accuracy has never been a principal concern of Six the Musical. So let's dig a little bit more into this and the conversation that has been arriving since Dylan was.