Podcast Summary: Mike Birbiglia's Working It Out – "Pete Holmes and Mike Make the Definitive Christmas Movie List"
Introduction
In a special holiday episode of Mike Birbiglia's Working It Out, comedian Mike Birbiglia welcomes his longtime friend and fellow comedian Pete Holmes to discuss and debate their favorite Christmas movies. Released on December 23, 2024, the episode delves into a spirited conversation where Mike and Pete argue, share insights, and ultimately compile their definitive top five Christmas movie list.
Discussion of "The Best Christmas Pageant Ever"
The episode kicks off with Mike introducing Pete's recent role in the new movie, The Best Christmas Pageant Ever, starring alongside Judy Greer. Mike shares his positive experience watching the film with his family, noting, “I watched it with my family. We loved it” ([00:06]). Pete humorously downplays his role, saying, “I laughed meekly, which is very in tone with the season” ([03:03]), highlighting the film’s blend of humor and heartfelt moments.
Analyzing "Home Alone"
Pete and Mike delve into the beloved classic Home Alone. Mike initially places the movie on his list but hesitates due to its violent undertones. Pete expresses his ambivalence, stating, “It doesn't have to be Christmas. It just so happens to be Christmas” ([08:02]), and critiques the film's repetitive violence despite acknowledging its status as a great Christmas movie. They discuss how the film balances humor with serious themes, ultimately deciding whether it deserves a spot in their top five.
Exploring "A Family Stone"
Pete introduces his top pick, A Family Stone, praising it as “a perfect Christmas movie” ([12:52]). He describes it as a tearjerker that beautifully captures the complexities of family dynamics during the holidays. Mike, who hasn’t seen the movie yet, is intrigued and agrees to watch it, acknowledging Pete’s strong endorsement: “It's my number one” ([12:52]).
Celebrating "Elf"
Both comedians express their fondness for Elf. Pete commends the film’s pure and serious take on the Santa Claus mythos, noting, “They play it as a drama” ([19:36]), which allows Will Ferrell’s comedic talents to shine. Mike adds, “It's a classic” and shares his extensive experience watching it over 15 times, reaffirming its place on their list: “Santa here” ([15:51]).
Debating "Love Actually"
The conversation shifts to Love Actually, where Pete offers a critical perspective. He appreciates the movie’s ensemble cast and nostalgic elements but points out its tonal inconsistencies and inappropriate content for family viewing. Mike acknowledges the film's cult status but remains skeptical about its inclusion in a family-friendly top five list: “I don't even think it's going to be on our list” ([26:07]).
Considering "Die Hard"
A heated debate arises over whether Die Hard qualifies as a Christmas movie. Pete challenges the notion, urging that the Christmas setting is integral to the film’s appeal: “I think it would be 17% less good if it wasn't at Christmas” ([24:44]). Mike defends his support for the film, emphasizing its thematic connection to the holiday spirit despite its unconventional categorization.
Reflecting on "It's a Wonderful Life"
Mike and Pete discuss the timeless classic It's a Wonderful Life. While recognizing its cultural significance and enduring quotes, Pete critiques the film’s propagandistic message promoting staying in one’s hometown. Mike appreciates the movie’s sentimental value but contemplates its relevance in modern times: “If you have a line that is that seminal in popular culture… I just think, like, that's an example of the kid did it wrong, but wrong is right” ([39:43]).
Highlighting "The Muppets' Christmas Carol"
Pete champions The Muppets' Christmas Carol as an exceptional adaptation of Dickens' tale. He praises its faithful rendition, stellar cast featuring Michael Caine, and the seamless blend of humor and heart: “It's a fantastic, perfect adaptation of that story” ([41:03]). Mike concurs, appreciating the film’s ability to resonate with audiences of all ages.
Finalizing the Top Five List
After extensive debate and personal anecdotes, Mike and Pete finalize their definitive top five Christmas movies:
- Elf
- The Muppets' Christmas Carol
- The Best Christmas Pageant Ever
- A Family Stone
- Die Hard
They acknowledge differing opinions, particularly regarding Die Hard and Love Actually, but ultimately agree on their selections based on personal preferences and thematic relevance.
Additional Discussions
Beyond movie debates, Mike and Pete share humorous exchanges and personal stories. Pete recounts his experience of watching Die Hard with his family, highlighting the film’s blend of action and holiday spirit. Mike reflects on his own holiday traditions and how they influence his perspective on Christmas movies.
Conclusion and Charity Highlight
Wrapping up the episode, Pete and Mike discuss their holiday-themed comedy bits and share a heartfelt moment about the importance of inclusion and the true spirit of Christmas. They conclude by promoting their chosen charity, Homeboy Industries, emphasizing the episode’s theme of giving and community support.
Notable Quotes:
- Mike Birbiglia at [00:06]: “We argue it out. We figure out our top five. We burn each other a little bit.”
- Pete Holmes at [03:03]: “I laughed meekly, which is very in tone with the season.”
- Mike Birbiglia at [08:02]: “I thought you were great and I thought Judy was great.”
- Pete Holmes at [12:52]: “It's my number one. It's the family stone. It's a perfect Christmas movie.”
- Pete Holmes at [24:44]: “I think it would be 17% less good if it wasn't at Christmas.”
- Pete Holmes at [41:03]: “It's a fantastic, perfect adaptation of that story.”
Final Thoughts
This episode of Working It Out offers a delightful blend of humor, personal anecdotes, and insightful critiques as Mike Birbiglia and Pete Holmes navigate the festive landscape of Christmas cinema. Whether debating the merits of action-packed classics or heartfelt family dramas, their camaraderie and differing perspectives provide an engaging listen for comedy enthusiasts and film lovers alike.