Mind Pump: Raw Fitness Truth

Episode 2711 — Should You Do Cardio Before or After Weights?
Hosts: Sal Di Stefano, Adam Schafer, Justin Andrews, Doug Egge
Date: October 22, 2025

Episode Overview

This episode tackles one of the most hotly debated questions in fitness: Should you do cardio before or after weights? The Mind Pump crew dives deep into programming strategies, physiological adaptations, personal coaching stories, and practical advice for athletes, regular trainees, and trainers. The discussion seamlessly weaves science, experience, and relatable anecdotes, while also coaching live callers on advanced training volume for highly active clients, ex-athlete mindsets, and safe testosterone protocols.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

Cardio vs. Weights – Which Comes First?

• It matters and depends on your primary goal:

  • Sal Di Stefano (04:37): “If you want endurance, do cardio first. If you want muscle, do strength training first.”
  • Adam Schafer (05:05): “The biggest difference on whether you maintain that muscle or lose that muscle, especially once you start introducing cardio, is that you are in maintenance—is no longer the same because now you’re introducing more training.”

• Adaptation Principle:

  • Your body gives the strongest adaptation to the stimulus done first in a session.
  • Sal (08:51): "Your body has limited ability to recover and adapt. Piling more stress on takes away from ability to recover/adapt. Also, adapting in one direction (like muscle size) takes away from another (like endurance)—that's a general physiological truth.”

• The Rationale for Training Order Based on Goal:

  • Muscle/Strength Focus:
    • Do strength training (weights) first, then cardio. Prioritize muscle gain for aesthetics.
  • Endurance/Athletic Performance Focus:
    • When endurance is the goal (e.g., prepping for sports season), some sessions might start with cardio/sprints, especially in short “conditioning windows.”

• On Combining Both (Concurrent Training):

  • Sal (11:55): “You could build tremendous changes in endurance in a short period of time, but you got to be smart—just piling more on more can create injury risk, especially in young athletes.”
  • Justin (17:07): Sometimes “breaking the rules” is needed when you have specific priorities, like putting shoulders first in workouts for women seeking better delts.

Programming & Recovery Nuances

• Calorie Intake & Deficit/Surplus Considerations:

  • Adam (05:52): “Doing [cardio or weights] in a calorie surplus makes as much—if not more—of a difference than either arguing whether it should be done before or after.”
  • Surplus helps build muscle and sustain performance; deficit is mainly for fat loss.

• Recovery Limits:

  • Sal (07:51): “More training isn’t always better. You have to give your body space to recover and adapt; more is not always more.”

• Body Part Priority:

  • Whatever you “train first” gets most of the adaptation (e.g., hit weak points at the start of a workout).

Live Coaching Highlights

Nicole (Maryland/Colorado): Managing Training Volume for Super-Active Clients

Starts at 59:31

• Her Dilemma: Clients in Colorado ski, mountain bike, etc., 3–4 days a week for hours, making standard gym training volume too much.
• Mind Pump’s Advice:
  • Use correctional exercises and focus on injury prevention.
  • Use a dynamometer (grip strength tool) pre-session to gauge recovery and readiness objectively.
    • Sal (62:02): "Have them squeeze the dynamometer in their non-dominant hand before every session; adapt workout intensity based on their score."
  • Prioritize subjective feedback and err on the side of less volume; sometimes "one or two strength exercises, plus mobility," is plenty for super-active people.
  • Communication: Be a confident leader even if clients expect “hard” workouts—performance improvements in their sport is the value.
  • “Lead with confidence,” Sal says (68:15), “Trust me right now, and I promise you, you'll never have to ask for it again.”

Brad (Virginia): Ex-Athlete Plateaus, Cardio/Weights, and Program Hopping

Starts at 73:12

• His Journey: Ex-college athlete, knee injuries, lost weight with cardio, plateaued, then gained muscle on MAPS Aesthetic (weights only).
• Main Question: Is there novelty in cardio, and can switching modalities drive results (e.g., bulk with no cardio, cut with cardio)?
• Advice:
  • Cardio and weights both have a place, but don’t chase the scale—focus on health, mobility, and sustainable progress.
  • Adam (79:52): “Your battle is wrestling with your athletic mind. You judge intensity by your old athlete standards—sometimes not feeling crushed is the sweet spot.”
  • Justin (83:24): “Sharpen movement quality—focus on mobility. Make yourself ‘able-bodied’ again to be ready for future sport/rec activities.”
  • Recommendation: Focus on mobility, possibly using the MAPS Performance program.

James (Connecticut): TRT Protocol Confusion, Bloodwork, and Health

Starts at 87:22

• His Issue: Started TRT via Transcend after low T and pre-diabetic markers; saw improved energy, weight, libido, but endo says his test is now “off the charts” (>1500 ng/dL); what to do?
• Advice:
  • Results like high testosterone vary based on shot timing (how many days since last dose).
  • Adam (94:15): “It's very individual—everyone has a sweet spot. Too high may give sides (acne, gyno); too low feels like crap. Work with your doc to gently lower dose and retest.”
  • Bodybuilder-level doses aren't dangerous short-term but aren't optimal for longevity or health. Knowledgeable, individualized dosing is key.
  • Sal (96:48): “Having testosterone that’s too high in a fit person is probably healthier than being too low. But you want that happy medium.”

Science-Backed, Experience-Grounded Observations

• Sprints vs. Steady-State: Sprinting is protective for muscle (fast-twitch fiber use), whereas long-duration endurance work can sap muscle if excessive or combined with calorie deficits.
• Movement Efficiency: Being more efficient (better technique) reduces energy drain (“movement efficiency is an underrated stamina hack”—Sal, 19:41).

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Sal on Training Order:
  “If you want endurance, do cardio first. If you want muscle, do strength training first... Your body will generally prioritize the one you put most energy toward—which is the one you do first.” (08:51)
• Adam on Calories & Adaptation:
  “The biggest difference... is that you are in maintenance—no longer the same if you’re adding more training. So pumping the calories is probably one of the most important things.” (07:01)
• Justin on Young Athletes:
  “I’m way more interested in preventing injury than maximizing every little bit of performance.” (11:09)
• Sal on Programming for Performance vs. Aesthetics:
  “Most people don’t train for performance, they train for aesthetics... If you just want to look good, prioritize strength over stamina.” (09:54)
• Nicole’s Coaching Backbone Moment:
  “The hard part for me is keeping a backbone... It’s not aligned with what they expect... we need to do mobility, chill, and fix the imbalances first.” (65:48)
• Mind Pump's Wisdom:
  “Nobody wants to follow someone who seems like they don’t know where they’re going.” (68:30)

Segments & Timestamps

• Cardio then weights, or weights then cardio?
  04:37 – 13:00
• Coaching youth & athletic conditioning: “Hell Week” and old-school vs. new-school methods
  11:55 – 19:41
• Bodypart prioritization & programming flexibility (MAPS Muscle Mommy example)
  17:07 – 18:39
• Movement efficiency, load management, and modern athletic programming
  19:41 – 22:23
• Separating cardio/weights entirely (different days or training blocks)
  21:35 – 23:47
• Red light therapy, sauna, “biohacks”
  35:04 – 37:28
• TRT anecdotes, dosage, side effects, and health debate
  38:15 – 47:01
• AI, chatbots, and manipulation in future society
  46:03 – 55:55
• UK online speech arrests, free speech, and societal change
  56:16 – 58:17
• Live caller #1 — Nicole on training programming for highly active clients
  59:31 – 71:04
• Live caller #2 — Brad on cardio/weights & ex-athletic mindset
  73:12 – 86:34
• Live caller #3 — James on TRT protocol confusion and health
  87:22 – 100:49

Tone and Takeaways

• Language & Tone: Straight-shooting, a mix of scientific and conversational, peppered with self-deprecating humor, encouragement, and empathy—especially in stories about clients and personal struggles.
• For Trainers & Advanced Trainees: Adapt training to the “total load” your client faces, not just what happens in the gym. Use both subjective and objective measures (like dynamometer grip strength) to gauge readiness.
• For Everyone Else: Set training priority based on your primary goal. Don’t get lost in program minutiae—start with foundational health benchmarks, not the scale or “athletic” intensity. Be wary of overtraining, especially if you’re highly active or coming from an athletic background.

Summary

This episode breaks down the question of cardio vs. weights with unvarnished honesty, shares nuanced strategy for athletes and regular trainees, delivers science-backed coaching insights, and presents authentic stories from the field. The answer: It depends on your goal—but whichever comes first in your session (or training block) gets the body’s main adaptive focus.

Programs should be tailored: for muscle/strength, do weights first; for endurance, do cardio first. For those leading very active lives, less gym volume is usually more. For those using hormone therapy, individual responsiveness trumps arbitrary dosing.

Above all, the Mind Pump team urges: Train smart, not just hard. Know your “priority” in every session—and lead with confidence, whether as a trainer or as your own coach.

Find Mind Pump at:
Instagram @mindpumpmedia
Maps Fitness Programs
Podcast website