Modern Love Podcast Summary

Episode: If You Want This Kind of Love, Don’t Expect It to Be Easy
Release Date: March 5, 2025
Host: Anna Martin
Guest: Samaya Mushtaq

Introduction to Samaya's First Marriage

Samaya Mushtaq shares her journey of seeking a traditional, emotionally stable marriage within her Muslim community. Growing up, she envisioned marrying a "nice Muslim man" with whom she could raise children in a harmonious environment.

Key Points:

• Early Marriage Expectations:
  “I grew up hoping to marry a nice Muslim man... much more [than just a joyful union].” (01:10)

• Feelings of Emotional Void:
  As Samaya progressed through medical school and her marriage, she felt an increasing emotional disconnect. Attempts to communicate her vulnerabilities were met with indifference, leading her to suppress her feelings.

  “These moments where I was really vulnerable... just breathe.” (02:10)

The Decision to Divorce

Facing constant emotional strain and feeling unsupported, Samaya made the difficult choice to divorce. She describes this period as a "death by a thousand paper cuts," highlighting the gradual erosion of her emotional well-being.

Key Points:

• Emotional Struggles:
  “I couldn't trust anything I think or feel... shame.” (05:32)

• Finalizing the Divorce:
  After multiple separations and failed attempts at couples therapy, Samaya resolved to end her marriage despite feelings of selfishness and fear.

  “Somebody has to call the time of death and I just had to do it.” (07:31)

Embracing Single Life and Seeking New Love

Post-divorce, Samaya experienced a newfound sense of possibility and excitement about her future. She began exploring the dating world with a clearer understanding of her needs and desires.

Key Points:

• Rediscovering Joy:
  “It felt like I had possibility again... it was exciting.” (08:30)

• Navigating Online Dating:
  Samaya discusses the challenges and stigmas of online dating post-divorce, emphasizing her preference for Muslim-specific apps to find a compatible partner.

  “It's just so reflective of some of the stigma still that that's a filter.” (10:05)

Meeting Mahmoud: A New Beginning

Samaya meets Mahmoud, a fellow medical resident, through a Muslim dating app. Their immediate connection and shared values laid the foundation for a deep and meaningful relationship.

Key Points:

• First Impressions:
  “He has this ability when he's listening to you to make you feel like he's really just taking it all in.” (16:20)

• Early Relationship Dynamics:
  Samaya highlights Mahmoud's attentiveness and genuine curiosity about life, contrasting it with her previous marriage.

  “He was being affected by what you're saying.” (16:43)

Marital Challenges and Growth

Shortly after their marriage, the COVID-19 pandemic posed significant challenges. Working in high-stress medical environments, Samaya and Mahmoud found solace in simple, shared activities that strengthened their bond.

Key Points:

• Pandemic Struggles:
  “We really had to just hold onto each other.” (21:15)

• Parenthood:
  Becoming parents further deepened their connection. Samaya praises Mahmoud's presence and nurturing nature as a father.

  “He's just so present with the kids. It's his biggest source of joy.” (22:29)

Mahmoud’s Mission to Gaza: A Test of Love and Commitment

A turning point in their relationship arises when Mahmoud feels compelled to volunteer as a wound care doctor in Gaza amidst escalating conflict. This decision tests their marriage, bringing forth themes of duty, sacrifice, and unwavering support.

Key Points:

• Decision to Volunteer:
  Samaya grapples with the fear of losing Mahmoud but ultimately supports his altruistic drive.

  “Loving humanity, loving service... to serve community and to serve humanity.” (29:35)

• Emotional Toll:
  The uncertainty of Mahmoud’s safety during his mission leads to profound anxiety and fear for Samaya.

  “There was just so much uncertainty... you don't know.” (34:10)

• Communication During Separation:
  Limited and sporadic communication underscores the tension and emotional strain of their prolonged separation.

  “I'm trying to get out as soon as possible.” (37:07)

• Reunion and Gratitude:
  Upon Mahmoud’s safe return, both express deep gratitude and acknowledgment of each other's support and courage.

  “I want to thank you for being so supportive of this.” (39:49)

Reflections on Love and Resilience

Samaya concludes by reflecting on the nature of deep, meaningful love. She emphasizes that such love requires patience, selflessness, and a willingness to endure hardships together.

Key Points:

• Advice on Deep Love:
  “Don't expect it to be easy... Your service builds a love like this.” (41:11)

• Personal Growth:
  Samaya advises balancing fear with hope, suggesting that embracing hope can lead to a brighter future despite uncertainties.

  “Fear is one way of looking at the future... hope can prevail.” (41:00)

Closing Thoughts

The episode encapsulates Samaya Mushtaq’s poignant journey through marriage, divorce, new love, and the ultimate test of her relationship with Mahmoud. Her story underscores the complexities of love, the importance of emotional support, and the strength required to sustain a deep and resilient partnership.

Notable Quotes:

• “I had to make a decision, go through that tunnel of anxiety and fear and shame and get to the other side.” – Samaya Mushtaq (02:33)
• “This love does not follow [the path of ease and instant gratification].” – Samaya Mushtaq (41:41)
• “It was like somebody has to call the time of death and I just had to do it.” – Samaya Mushtaq (07:31)

Additional Information

For those interested in exploring Samaya Mushtaq's full story, her Modern Love essay is available here (link in show notes).

Produced by: Sarah Curtis and Emily Lang
Edited by: Gianna Palmer
Executive Editor: Jen Poyant
Fact-Checking: Enna Alvarado
Production Management: Christina Josa
Theme Music: Dan Powell
Original Music: Alicia Be Itub and Rowan Nimisto
Mixing: Daniel Ramirez
Studio Support: Matty Masiello and Nick Pittman
Special Thanks to: Larissa Anderson, Behemoth Chablani, Nell Galogly, Jeffrey Miranda, and Paula Schumann
Column Edited by: Daniel Jones
Projects Editor: Mia Lee

Subscribe to Modern Love on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or visit nytimes.com/podcasts for more episodes.