On Our Third Date, I Asked for a Joint Bank Account

Wed Nov 12 2025

Janene Lin loathed the moment when the dinner bill would hit the table. When her date would pay, she felt like her love was for sale. Splitting the bill felt like no one had anything at stake. Most of the time, she would pay the bill herself, but that left her feeling uncared-for. So Janene prepared a pitch: On her next date, her third with a man named Aodhán, she would ask to open a joint bank account. On this episode of Modern Love, Lin tells our host, Anna Martin, why this risky move felt like the best solution, how Aodhán reacted and what it taught her about what money means to her and her family. This episode is adapted from Janene Lin’s essay The Woman Who Always Paid for Dinner. Here’s how to submit a Modern Love Essay to The New York Times. Here’s how to submit a Tiny Love Story. Unlock full access to New York Times podcasts and explore everything from politics to pop culture. Subscribe today at nytimes.com/podcasts or on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.

Summary

Podcast Summary: Modern Love – “On Our Third Date, I Asked for a Joint Bank Account”

Episode Overview Modern Love host Anna Martin explores an unconventional approach to the perennial dating question of “who pays?” with essayist Janine Lynn. Janine catches Anna—and most listeners—off guard with her story: on her third date, she proposed opening a joint bank account. Together, they dive deep into the cultural, familial, and emotional undercurrents that make paying the bill so fraught, why Janine opted for a radical solution, and what happened next. The conversation expands to how money and love intertwine, the meaning behind financial rituals, and why talking openly about money could be a relationship superpower.

Main Discussion Points & Insights

The Fraught “Who Pays?” Moment in Dating

Anna's Dilemma: Anna confesses her least favorite part of dating is when the bill arrives, describing the awkwardness of every possible option, from the “slow reach” for the wallet to debating if she should Venmo her date. (00:41)
Universal Tension: Janine agrees the moment is anxiety-inducing and complicated by underlying gender roles, pride, and perceptions of power. (02:43)

Janine’s Relationship with Paying and Money Rituals

Slapping the Table: Janine describes her intense compulsion to claim the bill—“My hand slapped the table, laying claim…like my life depended on it.” (03:22)
Rooted in Family Dynamics: Janine traces her intensity to childhood memories at big Chinese family banquets, where relatives fiercely fought to pay—sometimes physically. She recalls sneaking money into an aunt’s pocket under the table. (07:12)

“My cousins and I would take bets on who would win. Like it was a wrestling match or battle royale.” – Janine Lynn (07:02)

Deeper Meaning: The “ritual” was more than competition—it was rooted in care and face-saving, especially when relatives couldn’t afford the lavish meal. Her family would secretly repay whoever “won.” (07:47)

“But underneath it all is this kind of invisible checks and balances...we’re all performing this ritual because we all want the right and the privilege and the honor to win that moment.” – Janine Lynn (08:19)

The Stress of Always Paying—and Being Unseen

Never Fought Back: Janine explains how continually paying—without even a symbolic fight—left her feeling uncared for. “Are people noticing? Are people caring?...Are people asking...am I okay to pay this bill?” (10:14)

Why Splitting or Being Paid For Didn’t Work Either

Splitting the Bill: Felt transactional and disconnected: “It just felt like, you go your way, I’ll go my way. Like, we don’t have to see each other again.” (11:50)
Letting the Guy Pay: Felt unnatural and wrong; she worried it implied obligation—or that her “love is for sale.” (10:50)
No Winning: Anna observes there’s “kind of no way to win”; Janine agrees, which led to her creative solution: “That’s why the only solution in my mind was the joint bank account.” (12:28)

The Radical Proposal: Joint Bank Account on the Third Date

Origin of the Idea: Janine was fed up with paying and wanted to force a transparent conversation about money. She jokes that people do much more complicated things to test compatibility—like getting a pet or moving in—than simply opening a bank account. (13:33)

"At the time, it was easier to close a bank account than to cancel a gym membership." – Janine Lynn (14:25)

The Plan: Both would deposit equal or proportional amounts monthly to cover dating expenses—less than she was already spending. (16:28, 17:03)
Acknowledging the Risks: Janine worried about being taken advantage of, so she kept initial deposits manageable, “$250...felt like an okay amount to lose if this thing turned into, whoa, a guy taking off with my money.” (17:57)
Willingness to Lose: The risk was worth it: “$250 lost, but knowing that this guy was definitely not someone I was ever going to marry was worth the money.” (18:29)

The Pitch—and the Third Date

Low Expectations: She admits the date, “Adon,” was not her type, making the ask feel lower stakes—but pitching the idea was highly vulnerable. (20:51, 21:08)
What Was at Stake: For Janine, the pitch was a bold act of self-revelation, bringing together her Chinese heritage and desire for care. “I was finally bringing all the stuff that I felt like I was hiding to the person...” (22:06)

The Big Moment—How the Date Reacted

Live at the Table: Janine waits until the bill comes, then lays out her family ritual and joint account proposal. Adon thinks it must be a joke, laughing until he realizes it is not: “His body language said it all...he crossed his arms...leaned back like he was trying to get away.” (26:40)
Emotional Fallout: Janine speeds through her logic, feels anxious and self-conscious. In the end, she simply pays the bill as usual. (28:17)
Aftermath: “He’s probably going to ghost me. I’m never going to see this guy again.” (28:18)

The Shocking Yes

Adon’s Text: Days later, Adon texts: “Hey, let’s meet at a bank in San Francisco and open this account.” (29:59)

“That’s basically a sext to you at this point.” – Anna Martin (30:07)

At the Bank: Janine changes to a convenient bank for Adon, guided by both kindness and strategy. Adon seems hesitant, spends a long time reading terms and conditions, but signs. (32:28, 34:59)
How It Felt: Getting the debit cards was exhilarating and validating—a symbol she’d finally asked for what she wanted and received it. (36:18)

What Happened Next—And What It Meant

Instant Relationship Clarity: They never had a “defining the relationship” conversation—the joint account was the test and commitment rolled into one. (38:24)
Spoiler: They’re married, together for nine years, with multiple joint accounts now. (39:18)

“The only time we ever talked about it again was when we closed that account to open another joint bank account with better benefits.” – Janine Lynn (39:28)

Adon’s Reason

The Real Motive: Years later, Janine learns Adon’s decision was less about being swept off his feet by her proposal, and more about needing to build credit as a new immigrant in the US. (41:14)
Mutual Needs Met: The key takeaway: each had needs, and supporting each other’s needs (even if not fully understood) became the template for their enduring relationship.

“When we express what’s important to us, both are working towards helping each other achieve those things. And that has been our recipe for success.” – Janine Lynn (43:11)

Notable Quotes & Moments (with Timestamps)

“It was a bonkers idea...that moment when the bill comes is so fraught, is so anxiety-driven. And there’s so many layers and complexities to that moment.” – Janine Lynn (02:43)
“In my brain, I said, if he pays, I’m gonna kill him.” – Janine Lynn reliving her internalized ritual (03:22)
“[At Chinese banquets]...my cousins and I would take bets on who would win. Like a wrestling match or battle royale.” – Janine Lynn (07:02)
“They gave me money and asked me to crawl under the dinner table and sneak money into her pocket. Like a reverse pickpocketing.” – Janine Lynn (07:12)
“Are people noticing? Are people caring? Are people asking the question, am I okay to pay this bill?” – Janine Lynn (10:14)
“That’s why the only solution in my mind was the joint bank account.” – Janine Lynn (12:28)
“You don’t need to be radically transparent...it’s just like, let’s just talk about our relationship to money and what that means for us and what that meant for our families, because that’s who we inherited it from.” – Janine Lynn (44:12)
“When we express what’s important to us, both are working towards helping each other achieve those things. And that has been our recipe for success.” – Janine Lynn (43:11)
“Well, you know, when you open a joint bank account on your third date, like, everything’s on the table from there on out.” – Janine Lynn (46:09)

Key Timestamps of Major Segments

00:41 – Anna describes the “fraught bill” moment.
02:37 – Janine admits people think her idea is bonkers.
07:12 – The family ritual: fighting to pay the bill, crawling under the table with cash.
10:14 – Realization of feeling unseen and uncared for.
12:28 – “The only solution was the joint bank account.”
17:03 – Janine’s calculations and rationale for the proposal.
20:51 – Why the pitch was so vulnerable.
25:27 – The live play-by-play: Janine proposes on Date 3.
29:59 – The shock text: “Let’s meet at the bank.”
36:14 – They leave the bank with new joint debit cards.
39:18 – Update: Married, nine years together.
41:14 – The real reason Adon said yes: he needed to build credit as a new immigrant.
43:11 – The relationship “recipe for success”: honoring each other’s needs.
44:12 – Janine’s advice: It’s not about “full transparency,” but about open conversation.
46:36 – Janine’s advice for Anna’s first date: “Call out the moment and say, ‘How do you feel about it?’”

Tone and Takeaways

Conversational, Insightful, Honest: Both host and guest are candid, warm, and humorous while sharing very personal perspectives on something often left unsaid in dating.
Deeply Personal, Universally Relatable: The story is rooted in Janine’s unique mix of cultural inheritance and personal experience, but resonates for anyone who has wrangled with “the check” or the intertwining of money and intimacy.
Encourages Boldness and Openness: Both advocate for being authentic and courageous about your needs—a message that transcends the context of dating and checks.
Reframes “Romance”: The episode challenges conventional ideas of romance, suggesting true intimacy can mean helping each other meet unspoken needs—even if, on the surface, it’s about joint checking accounts.

If You Missed the Episode... This is a thoughtful, unexpectedly moving investigation into what happens at the intersection of money, culture, pride, and love—and how sometimes, the most unromantic gestures are the ones that build enduring intimacy.

Transcript

Betterment Advertiser (0:00)

Don't just imagine a better future. Start investing in one with betterment. Whether it's saving for today or building wealth for tomorrow. We help people in small businesses put their money to work. We automate to make savings simpler. We optimize to make investing smarter. We build innovative technology backed by financial experts. For anyone who's ever said, I think I can do better, so be invested in yourself. Be invested in your business. Be invested in better with betterment. Get started@betterment.com Investing involves risk performance, not guaranteed.

Janine Lynn (0:34)

Love now. And did you fall in love last fella?

Snack Enthusiast (0:36)

I love her love, but stronger than.

Janine Lynn (0:38)

Anything for the love love and I.

Anna Martin (0:41)

Love you more than anything there's to love love. From the New York Times. I'm Anna Martin. This is Modern Love. Let me tell you about my least favorite part of a date. It's the moment the bill hits the table. Regardless of whether the date's been good, the date's been bad. When that bill comes, I'm frozen. I don't know what to do. I'm like, should I do the slow reach for the wallet, hoping the guy slaps that Amex down? Do I just let him throw the card down and then get sort of offended? Cause it's like, do you think, I can't pay for this? It's just a vodka soda. Should we split it? Which is always kind of weird. Should I Venmo him?

Janine Lynn (1:23)

Should I Venmo him?

Anna Martin (1:24)

It's like, oh, God, every option is so undignified. But today I'm talking to a Modern Love essayist who had an unexpected solution to that exact problem. Here is what she did. On her third date with a guy, she proposed they open a joint checking account. And I have to say, even though that sounds quite extreme, her reasoning actually started to convince me. Here's our conversation. Janine Lynn, welcome to Modern Love.

Janine Lynn (2:00)

Thanks for having me.

Anna Martin (2:01)

Anna, I want to tell you that I am talking to you on an incredibly fortuitous day because I have a date tonight. And I know that when the check comes, we're going to do that horrible, weird little dance where I, like, reach for the wallet, but I'm looking at him. Who's going to pay? Should we split it? Da, da, da. And when you were dating and facing this question, you did something I've never heard of anyone doing ever. You asked a guy to open a joint bank account on your third date. I have to know. Do people freak out when you tell them this?