Modern Love Podcast Summary
Episode: Peter Gallagher’s Marriage Advice? Don’t Get Divorced
Host: Anna Martin
Release Date: May 22, 2024
Introduction
In this special episode of Modern Love, celebrating the 20th anniversary of the beloved New York Times column, host Anna Martin welcomes actor Peter Gallagher for an intimate conversation about love, marriage, and enduring relationships. Known for his versatile roles—from portraying flawed characters in the late '80s and '90s films like Sex, Lies, and Videotape and American Beauty to the beloved Sandy Cohen in The O.C.—Peter Gallagher shares personal anecdotes and profound insights into maintaining a long-lasting marriage.
Celebrating 41 Years of Marriage
Anna Martin introduces Peter Gallagher by highlighting his evolution from playing scheming characters to embodying the role of a devoted husband and father. She notes, “It's just so clear he really loves his family” ([02:53]).
Peter Gallagher humorously acknowledges the milestone, saying, “God, it sounds so embarrassing when you're in show business. But, yes, it's true” ([03:07]). He reflects on the rarity and fragility of long-term marriages, emphasizing that celebrating such anniversaries publicly can be “dangerous” as it might inadvertently lead to “six months later, they're on the rocks” ([03:31]).
When asked for marriage advice, Peter delivers a straightforward response: “Don't get divorced” ([04:16]). He elaborates that sustaining a marriage involves embracing uncertainty and trusting one’s instincts, stating, “There's very little certainty about anything in life... hope you're going in the right direction” ([04:22]).
Meeting Paula: A Love Story
Anna delves into Peter’s personal love story, recalling how he met his wife, Paula Harwood, during their freshman year at Tufts University. Peter recounts their first encounter on a stairwell, describing Paula’s vibrant style and his immediate, albeit unspoken, attraction:
“She was in this spectacular hair and this tight turtleneck thing and a disco belt and tight corduroy bell bottoms and platform shoes... And I looked like, you know, he had just left 8th grade gym class or something like that.” ([05:24])
Despite the initial lack of interaction, Peter spent years trying to connect with Paula, often visiting the cafeteria to make her laugh—a trait that remains a cornerstone of their relationship ([07:00]). Their marriage proposal was unconventional, occurring during a torrential rainstorm en route to a friend’s wedding. Peter narrates the spontaneous and heartfelt moment:
“She said, you can ask my parents. Oh, well, yeah. No. And I did. And then I wrote her dad a long letter about how I would take care of her, and he didn't have to worry. And we got married.” ([08:14])
Reading the Essay: "Failing in Marriage Does Not Mean Failing at Marriage"
Peter reads Joe Blair’s essay, which poignantly explores the complexities of sustaining a marriage through trials and tribulations. The essay narrates Joe’s experiences of temporary separations, conflicts, and the enduring love that ultimately reunites him with his wife, Deb. Themes of forgiveness, self-love, and unwavering commitment resonate deeply throughout the piece.
Reflections and Insights
After the essay, Peter shares his reflections, drawing parallels between Joe’s experiences and his own marriage. He emphasizes:
“There's a power and a truth to this and a humanness to this. I feel like I was with Joe where he was and the places he described so well, but it was sympathetic with where I was inside about how I feel about Paula, my wife.” ([21:34])
Peter discusses the importance of self-forgiveness as a foundation for loving others. He recounts a pivotal moment when he considered ending his relationship with Paula but ultimately recognized that his issues were personal and not tied to her:
“You will find it. It's your issue. An issue that you will have regardless of who you're with.” ([26:58])
This realization took decades to internalize, underscoring the long-term commitment necessary for a successful marriage.
Advice on Maintaining a Successful Marriage
When asked about making a marriage last, Peter reiterates the simplicity and depth of his earlier advice:
“Don't get divorced.” ([04:16])
He elaborates that sustaining a marriage requires embracing the uncertainties and continuously listening to one’s inner voice. Peter likens marriage to a vibrant, ever-evolving garden that needs care and attention rather than a static entity.
Redefining Marriage
Turning back to Joe Blair’s essay, Anna highlights Joe’s redefinition of marriage—not as a transactional relationship but as an ongoing journey of self-love and mutual support. Peter concurs, explaining that loving oneself is essential for genuinely loving another:
“I think it begins with forgiveness. I think you have to begin to forgive yourself...” ([25:56])
He shares a personal anecdote about how his mother advised him to work on his own issues before seeking to change a partner, a lesson he embraced decades later to reinforce his marriage with Paula.
What Success Looks Like
When prompted to describe a successful marriage, Peter shares a heartfelt vision:
“We woke up on this beautiful day in this wonderful city and we found just about everything funny. And she laughed. She had a lightness. I just felt very lucky.” ([29:41])
This encapsulates a relationship filled with joy, mutual respect, and gratitude—qualities that have sustained Peter and Paula for over four decades.
Conclusion
As the episode wraps up, Peter humorously clarifies the significance of the date, confirming the authenticity of their 41st anniversary celebration. Anna acknowledges the depth of their conversation, expressing gratitude for Peter’s openness and wisdom.
“I was kidding about today being our wedding anniversary. No, I'm serious. It's real. It's real.” ([30:11])
The episode concludes with Anna thanking Peter and Teasing future episodes, celebrating Modern Love’s enduring legacy of sharing real-life love stories.
Notable Quotes with Timestamps
- Peter Gallagher: “Don't get divorced.” ([04:16])
- Peter Gallagher: “There's very little certainty about anything in life... hope you're going in the right direction.” ([04:22])
- Peter Gallagher: “She was way, way, way, way cooler than I still... it was just powerful.” ([06:24])
- Joe Blair’s Essay Read by Peter Gallagher: “Failing in marriage does not mean failing at marriage... Still alone, waiting, and still in love.” ([10:46] – [21:34])
- Peter Gallagher: “I think you have to begin to forgive yourself...” ([25:56])
- Peter Gallagher: “We woke up on this beautiful day in this wonderful city and we found just about everything funny. And she laughed. She had a lightness. I just felt very lucky.” ([29:41])
Final Thoughts
This episode of Modern Love offers a profound exploration of what it takes to sustain a loving marriage over decades. Through Peter Gallagher’s candid storytelling and his reflections on Joe Blair’s essay, listeners gain valuable insights into the resilience, forgiveness, and unwavering commitment required to nurture a lifelong partnership. Whether you’re navigating your own relationship challenges or seeking inspiration for enduring love, this episode provides both heartfelt narratives and practical wisdom.
Subscribe and Listen:
Unlock full access to New York Times podcasts and explore a wide range of topics by subscribing at nytimes.com/podcasts or on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.
This summary is intended for informational purposes and reflects the content of the Modern Love podcast episode featuring Peter Gallagher.