Money Rehab with Nicole Lapin

Episode Title: When Renting Makes More Sense Than Buying
Date: December 9, 2025

Episode Overview

In this episode, Nicole Lapin challenges the conventional wisdom that “renting is just throwing money down the drain” and explores the real financial math behind renting vs. buying a home. Nicole breaks down common misconceptions, provides data-driven comparisons, and highlights the often-overlooked costs of homeownership—while making the case that renting can be a smart, valid financial strategy for many people, especially in today’s economy.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Debunking the “Renting is Throwing Money Away” Myth

• Nicole’s stance: She finds the idea that “renting is just throwing money away” to be one of her “least favorite opinions in personal finance.”
  • “I want to roll my eyes every single time I hear that.” (04:17)

2. The Case for Buying a Home

• Building Equity: Mortgage payments theoretically build wealth through ownership; “Each mortgage payment you make chips away at the loan balance and over time you own more and more of your home. And then after 30 years…you own your home. The end.” (04:37)
• Tax Benefits: Interest on mortgages can be tax-deductible. “I do love a tax deduction where I can get it.” (05:13)
• Fixed Payments: With a fixed-rate mortgage, monthly costs can remain constant, providing predictability over rising rents.

3. The Hidden Costs (and Risks) of Homeownership

• Transaction Costs: “There are closing costs when you buy and when you sell, which can run 6 to 10% of the home's value.” (05:33)
• Ongoing Expenses: Property taxes, home insurance, maintenance, repairs, possibly HOA fees.
• Interest and Opportunity Cost: The biggest surprise for most—how much you actually pay in interest.
  • “If you buy a $500,000 home and you put 20% down with the current average interest rates, you’re going to be paying over $400,000 on interest alone. So your $500,000 house will actually cost you more like $900,000.” (05:53)
  • In the first 5 years of a typical mortgage, very little equity is built—most payments go towards interest: “After five years... you'll only pay down $26,000 in principal.” (06:15)

4. Comparing Investments: Stocks vs. Real Estate

• Return on Homeownership: Historically, U.S. home prices have appreciated “about 4.5% per year... That’s good, but it's not S&P 500 good.” (07:00)
• Stock Market Performance: S&P 500 averages about 10% per year over the long run, which can lead to substantial differences over time.

5. The Math: Renting and Investing vs. Buying

• Rent vs. Buy in Los Angeles Example:
  • Average rent: $3,000 per month
  • Average mortgage: $5,000 per month
  • “So let’s say you rent. You’re saving $2,000 a month… After 30 years, you'll have $5.7 million. Meanwhile, if you bought a $500,000 home...after your 30 year mortgage is paid off, your home will appreciate to about $1.9 million...With interest, you'll have paid over $900,000 for your mortgage, which means that your margin is a lot lower than if you would have invested. You'll have profited around a million bucks. In the case of investing 2k a month and renting…you'll have spent $820,000 but made $4.9 million in profit.” (08:18)

6. When Does Buying Make Sense?

• Nicole’s Criteria:
  • If you plan to stay in the home for the long term (ideally, 5-7 years or more).
  • If your total cost of ownership is close to or less than renting.
  • If local rents are rising much faster than costs would be with a fixed-rate mortgage.
  • If homeownership provides personal stability and satisfaction: “That can be priceless. Buying a home is not just a financial decision, it’s a lifestyle decision.” (09:30)

7. The Value of Renting

• Flexibility and Lower Risk: "No surprise repair bills, no new roof to replace, no foundation cracks, no property taxes...those are all your landlord’s problems." (09:55)
• Lower Insurance: Renters insurance costs much less.
• Renting as a Valid Strategy: “Rent is paying for a service... without a long-term commitment and usually a lower financial burden.” (10:30)
• Optionality: Renting gives you “options. And in finance, optionality is very powerful.” (11:25)

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On the myth of rent as wasted money:

  “We don’t say that we’re throwing away money when we buy groceries, right? Rent is paying for a service—the service of having a place to live without a long term commitment and usually a lower financial burden.”
  — Nicole Lapin (10:17)

• On the real costs behind the mortgage:

  “The interest on the mortgage is a piece of all of this that blows my mind the most. If you buy a $500,000 home… you’re going to be paying over $400,000 on interest alone.”
  — Nicole Lapin (05:53)

• The power of opportunity cost:

  “If you had a dream of this $500,000 home being something you could flip really quickly and turn a profit on in a few years...the math there is not mathing.”
  — Nicole Lapin (06:33)

• On the flexibility of renting:

  “Renting is not wasting money, it’s buying you options, and in finance, optionality is very powerful.”
  — Nicole Lapin (11:25)

Timestamps for Key Segments

• 04:13 — Nicole introduces the episode and the myth she wants to debunk.
• 04:37 — The traditional case for building equity through home ownership.
• 05:33 — Unpacking the real costs of homeownership.
• 05:53 — Shocking math on mortgage interest.
• 06:15 — How little equity is built in the early years of a mortgage.
• 07:00 — Historical returns: real estate vs. stocks.
• 08:18 — Head-to-head: LA rent vs. buy math simulation.
• 09:30 — When home buying does make sense (Nicole’s checklist).
• 10:17 — Renting buys a valuable service, not just “wasted money.”
• 11:25 — Renting provides powerful financial optionality.

Summary Takeaway

Nicole Lapin methodically dismantles the outdated notion that renting is financially irresponsible, showing that, when all costs and opportunity risks are considered, renting can provide greater financial growth, flexibility, and peace of mind for many. She advocates for making informed decisions based on your own circumstances—not social pressures—and reminds listeners: renting is not a failure or a stopgap, but often the smartest choice.

Contact Nicole:
Want your money questions answered? Email moneyrehab@moneynewsnetwork.com to be featured on the show.

Follow for more:
Instagram: @moneynews
TikTok: @moneynewsnetwork

End of Summary