Monsters Among Us – Episode S19 Ep27: Seeing Double, Doppelgangers, and Other Mysterious Twins: Volume 2

Release Date: July 15, 2025
Host: Derek Hayes | Audioboom Studios

Dive into the spine-chilling world of doppelgangers and mysterious twins in this episode of Monsters Among Us. Host Derek Hayes guides listeners through a series of first-hand accounts where individuals encounter their eerie doubles, blurring the lines between reality and the supernatural. Below is a detailed summary of the key stories shared by callers, complete with notable quotes and timestamps to capture the essence of each haunting experience.

1. Calypso’s Michigan Encounter with an Imposter [03:49]

Calypso recounts a terrifying story shared by her late mother about an encounter with a doppelganger pretending to be her father. Moving from Alabama to Detroit, her mother faced a nightmarish experience when an entity resembling her alcoholic father appeared with "a look of fright" and acted aggressively.

Calypso (04:44): "And he grabbed up a belt off the floor and swung at my mother. My mom managed to avoid the hit and she grabbed her socks and she took off running."

This encounter left her mother terrified, prompting questions about the true nature of the apparition and its intentions.

2. Carrie’s Doppelganger Sightings in California [07:57]

Carrie from McKinleyville, California, shares unsettling experiences of seeing her best friend and her partner driving a vehicle identical to theirs, complete with distinctive stickers. When she confronted them, her friends denied being outside, causing Carrie to question her perception.

Carrie (08:12): "I saw you guys. I swear to God, I just saw you guys."

Additionally, Carrie mentions regularly seeing a man resembling her father, heightening the episode’s theme of familiar figures turned sinister.

3. Seth’s Maryland Party Mix-Up [14:43]

Seth from Maryland narrates a seemingly normal college house party that took a bizarre turn when a stranger mistook him for another "Seth" with similar physical traits. This confusion led to humorous yet eerie interactions, leaving Seth and his friends pondering the possibility of multiple doppelgangers sharing the same name.

Seth (16:03): "It was like a glitch in the matrix, just a funny coincidence."

4. Danny’s Paranormal Dog Incident in Nevada [17:31]

Danny from Reno describes a perplexing experience where his dog, Betty, behaves oddly by repeatedly entering and exiting the house without explanation. Security footage revealed no unusual activity, suggesting the presence of an unseen entity.

Danny (19:45): "If she's been out here this whole time, what did I let in before?"

5. Shayla’s Louisiana Gown Apparition [31:08]

Shayla Jones from Elm Grove, Louisiana, shares her encounter with a ghostly figure dressed in a long, blonde gown. Initially seeing the apparition herself and later witnessing it through her friend Morgan, the experience left her questioning whether she was seeing a doppelganger of herself.

Shayla (31:30): "I saw a lady in a gown... the same person that I saw was also seen by my friend."

6. Rob’s Virginia and Connecticut Ghost Stories [34:23]

Rob from Virginia details multiple paranormal experiences:

• Colonial Connecticut House: Observes his mother disappearing into a hallway wearing a white shawl, only to return without it, indicating a possible spectral presence.

  Rob (34:55): "But it wasn't my mother. It was different."

• Virginia Apartment Building: Hears the sounds of neighbors who had moved out six months prior, including the footsteps of a young child.

  Rob (35:20): "I still heard those running footsteps until we moved out."

• Second Thanksgiving in Connecticut: Witnesses a shadowy figure emerging from a closet, blending into the room in a fleeting moment.

  Rob (36:00): "The shadow of a man moved along the wall... it walks through the television into the shadows."

7. Jessica’s Self-Doppelganger in Arkansas [39:25]

Jessica from Bentonville, Arkansas, experiences the unsettling sight of herself driving away in her car while she was actually at home. This encounter left her grappling with the possibility of seeing her own double.

Jessica (40:10): "I saw myself sitting in the driver's seat... it was me."

8. James’s Canadian Mother Doppelganger [41:59]

James from Canada recounts a peculiar incident where his mother called him while she appeared to be inside the bathroom. Upon knocking, she denied leaving her bath, suggesting the presence of a ghostly double.

James (42:30): "She was smiling an extraordinary smile, but she didn't respond."

9. Kelsey’s Haunted Church Experiences in Virginia [46:49]

Kelsey shares eerie occurrences at her childhood church, including:

• Youth Group Game Interruption: During a "Killer" game, she and her friend witnessed a youth leader suddenly appear pale and disappearing mysteriously.

  Kelsey (48:15): "We turned around and saw our youth leader... she was completely gone."

• Choir Practice Apparition: Sees a black shadow pass by the window and subsequently blacks out, leaving her confused and worried.

  Kelsey (49:40): "I saw that black mass pass and then I blacked out."

10. Lenny’s Memory Glitch in Pennsylvania [53:54]

Lenny shares a puzzling experience involving a childhood memory of a book titled "Stranger with My Face," which he couldn’t locate online until recently, leading him to ponder the nature of memory and reality.

Lenny (54:20): "It's like a glitch in the matrix."

11. Anonymous Caller’s Texas Doppelganger Nightmare [57:37]

An anonymous caller from Texas delivers a harrowing tale of encountering his girlfriend’s doppelganger during a house move. Over several nights, he describes intense interactions, including arguments, unexplained phenomena like "pixie dust," and a mysterious entity altering his surroundings.

Anonymous Caller (58:12): "They’re still here at my house right now. What I’m calling about are doppelgangers."

This incomplete account leaves listeners on edge, eager for further updates to unravel the terrifying mystery.

Conclusion

Throughout this episode, Monsters Among Us delves deep into the unsettling phenomenon of doppelgangers, presenting a diverse range of experiences that challenge the boundaries between the known and the unknown. From familial imposters to self-reflective doubles, each story adds a layer of intrigue and fear, inviting listeners to ponder the existence and intentions of these mysterious counterparts.

Derek Hayes aptly captures the essence of these encounters, leaving the audience with lingering questions about the true nature of doppelgangers and their place in the paranormal landscape. Whether it’s misunderstood coincidences or genuine supernatural phenomena, the testimonies shared this episode ensure that the mystery of seeing double remains as compelling as ever.

Keep it spooky!