Monsters Among Us: Season 19, Episode 28 - Men in Black, Swampy Sasquatch, and a Bluegrass Pterodactyl

Release Date: July 17, 2025

Introduction

In this spine-tingling episode of Monsters Among Us, host Derek Hayes delves into an array of paranormal encounters that range from spectral apparitions and UFO sightings to elusive cryptids and mysterious flying creatures. As always, Hayes invites listeners to step into a world where the supernatural intertwines with everyday life, offering both eerie tales and heartwarming experiences from witnesses across the United States and beyond.

Ghostly Guardians and Protective Spirits

Daniel Brown’s Eerie Encounter (03:15)
Daniel Brown from Sheridan, Indiana, shares a haunting yet comforting experience following the birth of his son. Approximately a week after his son’s arrival, the family began experiencing strange noises and apparitions. One night, Daniel woke to see a misty figure resembling his late grandfather Brown standing above his son’s bassinet. "It smiled and then vanished right in front of my eyes" (03:15), Daniel recounts. This apparition left him terrified but also heartened, suggesting a protective presence over his newborn.

Bonnie’s Guardian Angel (11:01)
Bonnie from Northwest Arkansas narrates a near-tragic incident where a guardian angel seemingly intervened to prevent a car accident. While waiting at a four-way stop, she felt an internal voice urging her not to proceed. Her foot became paralyzed just as a drunk driver sped through the intersection, accentuating her paralysis. Upon regaining control, Bonnie saw the frustrated driver and heard him whisper, "Thank you" (17:05). This experience reinforced her belief in guardian spirits watching over loved ones.

Pam’s Feline Phantom (24:01)
Pam from Southeast Texas shares a touching encounter with the spirit of her late cat, Cinder. Following the loss of a beloved pet, Pam felt her cat physically manifest on her bed, curling up against her and emitting a comforting purr. "We know she's here. They don't leave us, they love us..." (25:45) Pam’s story resonates with many pet owners who find solace in the idea that their animals watch over them even after passing.

UFO Sightings and Men in Black Mysteries

Corey’s Titusville UFO Sighting (05:54)
Corey from Titusville, Pennsylvania, recounts witnessing a classic UFO in 2012 while working at a knife company. Describing the object as "a stereotypical UFO" (05:54), Corey was initially the only observer, though the sighting was later reported in local newspapers. Despite extensive local UFO activity dating back to the 1950s, Corey’s 2012 encounter remains unexplained, adding another chapter to Titusville’s rich history of extraterrestrial sightings.

Jim’s Men in Black Encounter (38:04)
Jim from San Diego County shares a mid-1980s experience involving mysterious men in Black suits. While driving through Death Valley, Jim and his wife observed two and later three identical black Ford Crown Victorias driven by well-dressed men with "pasty complexions" (38:04). Given the proximity to Edwards Air Force Base and Area 51, Jim speculates these passengers might have been scientists or government officials, but the true nature of the encounter remains unresolved.

Chris’s Similar Men in Black Experience (41:34)
Reiterating Jim’s account, Chris from Texas describes following a convoy of three black SUVs with completely obscured windows and no identifiable markings (41:34). The vehicles mirrored Jim’s description, prompting questions about potential connections between sightings in different states. Derek Hayes highlights the possibility of these encounters being related, hinting at a broader phenomenon spanning multiple regions.

Elusive Cryptids and Bigfoot in Arkansas

Steve’s Bigfoot Sighting (50:43)
Steve from Louisiana recounts a formidable encounter with a Sasquatch-like creature in 1975 near Camden, Arkansas. Stationed at Fort Polk, Steve and his companions were armed when they encountered an enormous, 8-foot-tall, 700-pound hairy beast that roared and fled the scene after causing damage (50:43). This sighting coincided with other local reports from the mid-1970s, as documented in John Green’s The Apes Among Us. The prevalence of Bigfoot sightings during this period suggests a significant cryptid presence in the Arkansas region.

Historical Context and Parallel Sightings
Derek Hayes provides historical context by referencing newspaper reports from the 1970s detailing similar Bigfoot encounters in central Arkansas and nearby Louisiana. These accounts include multiple sightings of large, hairy creatures causing disturbances and being fired upon, though authorities often dismissed the reports. The convergence of these accounts around the same timeframe strengthens the credibility of Steve’s narrative and underscores the regional legend of Bigfoot in the American South.

Mysterious Flying Creatures and Pterodactyl Sightings

Russell’s Bluegrass Pterodactyl (60:56)
Russell from Cincinnati, Ohio, describes witnessing a massive pterodactyl-like creature with a wingspan of approximately 75 to 100 feet flying at 150 feet over Mammoth Cave (60:56). The creature, resembling traditional depictions of pterodactyls with "blue-gray leathery skin and bat-like wings," persisted in its flight path despite Russell’s attempts to deter it by singing. The sighting spanned several miles, leaving Russell convinced of its authenticity despite skepticism from those around him.

Comparative Sightings and Cultural Legends
Derek Hayes connects Russell’s experience to various legends and sightings, including the Ropen from New Guinea and historical photographs labeled as "thunderbirds." Additional accounts, such as a Reddit post from Western Kentucky, describe similar large flying entities with unusual flight patterns (63:20). These parallel stories suggest a recurring motif of giant prehistoric-like creatures inhabiting different regions and eras, blending folklore with personal testimonies.

Supernatural Phenomena and Unexplained Occurrences

Katie’s TV Glitch After Ghost Hunting Show (20:19)
Katie from Central Illinois recounts an unsettling experience where her television malfunctioned after watching a ghost hunting episode that frequently mentioned the "devil." The TV first glitched with demonic phrases, then completely shut off, leaving Katie and her boyfriend with a lingering sense of heaviness in their home (20:19). This incident raises questions about the influence of media on paranormal activity and whether such glitches are mere coincidences or manifestations of supernatural interference.

Maddie’s Magnetic Nighttime Sounds (27:41)
Maddie from Los Angeles describes hearing a loud, vibrating "wa wa wa wa" noise next to her ear after waking from a nightmare in 2024. Despite the intensity of the sound, only Maddie experienced it, leading to speculation about its origin. Derek Hayes suggests it could be related to alien activity or perhaps a mundane cause, such as a nearby substation reconnecting power, which can produce similar noises (31:03). Maddie’s experience illustrates the challenges in distinguishing between supernatural and natural explanations for strange auditory phenomena.

Conclusion

Season 19, Episode 28 of Monsters Among Us masterfully weaves together a diverse tapestry of paranormal experiences, from ghostly guardians and mysterious UFOs to elusive Bigfoot sightings and gigantic pterodactyls patrolling the skies. Host Derek Hayes not only presents these chilling tales with clarity and depth but also provides insightful commentary and historical context that enriches each story. For enthusiasts of the supernatural, this episode offers a captivating journey into the unknown, reaffirming that the line between reality and legend remains intriguingly blurred.

Notable Quotes:

• Daniel Brown: "It was very eerie to see that figure looking down at our son... it looked like my grandpa Brown" (03:15)
• Bonnie: "Bonnie, don't go." (11:01)
• Pam: "We know she's here. They don't leave us, they love us..." (25:45)

Join the Conversation

Listeners are encouraged to share their own supernatural experiences by calling in at 888-608-NIGHT or emailing their stories to monstersamongus@podcastmail.com. Whether it’s encounters with elusive creatures, unexplained phenomena, or heartwarming ghostly visits, Monsters Among Us is the perfect platform to share and explore the mysteries that linger just beyond our perception.

Produced by Derek Hayes | Copyright Red Grow Media