Morbid Episode 621: Fan Favorite – Bobby Mackey's Music World

Release Date: November 25, 2024 | Host: Ash and Elena | Knowledge Cutoff: 2023-10

Introduction

In this special Thanksgiving edition, Ash and Elena revisit one of their most beloved episodes, delving deep into the eerie history of Bobby Mackey's Music World, a nightclub infamous for its haunting legends and tragic past. The hosts set the stage for a gripping tale filled with true crime, paranormal activities, and the resilience of those involved.

The Birth of Bobby Mackey's Music World

Bobby Mackey, a seasoned country singer and railroad employee from the tiny town of Concord, Kentucky, decided to settle down after over a decade of traveling. In 1978 [08:16], he opened Bobby Mackey's Music World in an old roadhouse on Route 9 in Wilder, Kentucky. The location was ripe with history, having previously served as a slaughterhouse and meatpacking plant since 1850.

Ash introduces Bobby's humble beginnings:

"Bobby told reporters, 'In my mind's eye, I could see it all. I could see the crowd, I could see people dancing. So there was nothing going to stop me. I had to have the place.'" [10:24]

Despite the seemingly perfect setup, the property was rumored to be haunted, a fact Bobby was initially oblivious to.

Tragic Beginnings: The Murder of Pearl Brian

In 1896 [11:21], the history of violence at the location took a dark turn with the gruesome murder of Pearl Brian. A 22-year-old woman from Indiana, Pearl was decapitated near Fort St. Thomas, less than a kilometer from the abandoned slaughterhouse. The investigation revealed that Pearl was drugged with cocaine by her alleged lovers, Scott Jackson and Alonzo Walling, who intended to induce a miscarriage. When their attempts failed, they murdered her to eliminate any trace of the pregnancy.

Elena reflects on the brutality:

"If you loved this girl enough to have a relationship with her. My God." [15:37]

The mysterious disappearance of Pearl's head fueled local legends, with theories ranging from occult rituals to simple disposal in the deep well used during the slaughterhouse operations.

Ownership Changes and Growing Haunted Legends

Over the decades, the property changed hands multiple times. In the 1950s, under mob control, it became The Latin Quarter, an illegal gambling den notorious for its violence, including several murders in the parking lot [19:04]. By the 1970s, it briefly functioned as a Hard Rock Cafe, attracting a rougher crowd and continuing its legacy of unrest [19:49].

Ash summarizes the tumultuous history:

"It was a lot has gone down. So after signing the papers that made it official, the Mackies were at the club, like, kind of cleaning out all the decorations [...]" [22:56]

Each iteration of the establishment seemed to attract its own set of troubles, cementing its reputation as a haunted locale.

Paranormal Activities and Carl Lawson’s Role

In 1978 [24:00], Bobby and his wife Janet began preparing the club for its grand opening. Shortly after, they encountered Carl Lawson, a former employee of the Hard Rock Cafe, who introduced himself as someone knowledgeable about the club's dark past. Carl quickly became integral to the operation, sharing his experiences and suspicions of lingering malevolent spirits.

Ash introduces Carl’s early interactions:

"He introduced himself as Carl Lawson, and he explained that he had worked at the Hard Rock before it shut down..." [30:48]

Despite Janet's unease with Carl's presence, his insights proved valuable as supernatural events escalated. Janet experienced terrifying encounters, including apparitions and physical attacks, which Bobby initially dismissed to protect his business.

Escalation of Haunted Incidents and Exorcism Attempts

As the supernatural activities intensified, Carl discovered Johanna's diary hidden beneath a loose floorboard in the basement [55:06]. Johanna, a former showgirl, had a tragic love story involving forbidden romance and murder, tying back to the club’s dark history. Her spirit, along with others, seemed restless and unwilling to move on.

Ash narrates the diary discovery:

"Carl found the diary of Johanna, a former showgirl... as he read through the diary, the pieces of her life started to come together." [55:29]

Desperate to rid the club of its haunting presence, Bobby enlisted the help of Reverend Glenn Cole, a Pentecostal minister. The initial exorcism attempts were met with resistance from the spirits inhabiting Carl, leading to intense confrontations and further disturbances [76:17].

Elena captures the tension:

"I was so terrified because I thought I was going to lose my baby." [42:00]

The exorcism sessions were arduous, involving physical manifestations and psychological torment, ultimately leading to a temporary cessation of the hauntings. However, signs of the spirits' lingering presence hinted at unresolved conflicts [77:50].

Legal Battles and Publicity Stunts

In the 1990s, the haunted reputation of Bobby Mackey's Music World gained widespread attention, culminating in a lawsuit filed by Junior Costigan in 1993 [87:17]. Costigan claimed he was assaulted by a ghost in the men's bathroom, leading to one of the most unusual legal defenses—a motion to dismiss written in poetic verse.

Ash highlights the lawsuit's peculiarity:

"As follows. Give me some bongos. The PLF claims in his petition he was assaulted by an apparition injured by a ghostly nemesis on Bobby Mackey's premises..." [88:37]

Although the case was dismissed due to Costigan's failure to appear in court, it propelled the nightclub into the spotlight, overshadowing its country music roots with its supernatural allure. Bobby eventually embraced this shift, capitalizing on the hauntings to attract tourists and paranormal enthusiasts [90:03].

Embracing the Haunted Legacy and Current Operations

By the late 1990s, Bobby Mackey's Music World had fully integrated its haunted legacy into its business model. The establishment became a hotspot for ghost tours, paranormal investigations, and even overnight sleepovers, alongside its regular music performances [91:23].

Ash concludes the transformation:

"By the late 90s, he seemed actually like a lot more accepting of the paranormal activity surrounding the nightclub." [90:26]

Today, the club continues to operate at its original location on Licking Pike, offering patrons a unique blend of live music and eerie encounters. While Bobby maintains skepticism about personal hauntings, the establishment remains a legendary site for both country music lovers and thrill-seekers intrigued by its storied past.

Conclusion

Episode 621 of Morbid Network's "Morbid" podcast provides an enthralling exploration of Bobby Mackey's Music World—an establishment where music and the supernatural collide. Through meticulous research and engaging storytelling, Ash and Elena uncover decades of tragedy, hauntings, and the indomitable spirit of Bobby Mackey himself. This episode not only highlights the dark history of a single location but also delves into the broader themes of belief, skepticism, and the human desire to find meaning in the unexplained.

Notable Quotes:

• "I can tick so many boxes with just one delicious shake." – Ash [00:00]
• "Bobby told reporters, 'In my mind's eye, I could see it all. I could see the crowd, I could see people dancing. So there was nothing going to stop me. I had to have the place.'" – Ash [10:24]
• "If you loved this girl enough to have a relationship with her. My God." – Elena [15:37]
• "I feel different. Something in me has changed." – Carl [78:30]
• "This establishment is purported to be haunted. Management is not responsible and cannot be held liable for any actions of any ghosts or spirits on this premise." – Ash [90:28]

Further Listening

For those captivated by the haunting tale of Bobby Mackey's Music World, consider exploring other episodes of Morbid for more true crime and paranormal history. Join Wondery Plus for early access and an ad-free experience on the Wondery app or Apple Podcasts.