Episode 652: Jean Harris and the Murder of Herman Tarnower (Part 2)

Summary

Morbid Podcast Episode 652: Jean Harris and the Murder of Herman Tarnower (Part 2) – Summary

Introduction In Episode 652 of Morbid, hosted by Elena and Ash from the Morbid Network | Wondery, the narrative delves deeper into the tragic and tumultuous relationship between Jean Harris and Dr. Herman Tarnower. This second part continues to unravel the complexities that led to the infamous murder, highlighting Jean's career struggles, mental health challenges, and the events culminating in the fatal confrontation.

Background Recap At [05:19], Ash summarizes Part 1, recounting Jean Harris’s upbringing, her unsuccessful first marriage, her close but deteriorating relationship with Dr. Herman Tarnower, and her increasing reliance on Desoxin for chronic back pain. The foundation is set for understanding the emotional and psychological state that plagued Jean.

Peak and Struggles in Jean’s Career At [06:16], Elena and Ash discuss Jean's role as the headmistress of an elite private school. Despite her professional success, Jean's position was mentally and physically taxing. Ash quotes Jean's dedication: “My work day begins at 8am and lasts until I drop” ([07:17]). This relentless schedule, combined with the stress from her failing relationship with Tarnower, exacerbated her mental health issues.

Deteriorating Relationship with Dr. Tarnower At [07:43], the hosts explore the strain in Jean and Herman’s relationship. Jean’s involvement in honing Tarnower’s Scarsdale Diet book introduced further tension. Jean’s dissatisfaction with the ghostwriter’s initial manuscript led her to rewrite the entire book herself, demonstrating her commitment and the depth of her emotional investment ([10:00]-[10:45]).

Escalation of Mental Health Issues At [18:16], the conversation shifts to Jean’s worsening mental state. As her relationship with Tarnower deteriorated, so did her mental health. Colleagues noted drastic changes in her appearance and behavior, highlighting her growing instability ([19:23]-[19:57]).

The Confrontation and Murder At [22:46], the hosts detail the events of March 10, 1980. Jean, overwhelmed by withdrawal symptoms and emotional turmoil, decides to confront Herman. She arrives at his New York apartment with a loaded .32 caliber handgun, intending to end her life. As she attempts to discuss her feelings with Herman, tensions escalate:

• Initial Encounter: [27:55] Ash recounts how Jean enters the bedroom unannounced, hoping to rekindle their relationship. Herman, disinterested and tired, rebuffs her attempts ([27:56]-[28:16]).

• Conflict and Shooting: [31:00] The narrative describes Jean’s frantic actions as she tries to use the gun to kill herself, leading to a physical struggle. Herman, reacting violently, disarms her, resulting in the accidental discharge that fatally wounds him ([36:00]-[37:19]).

Aftermath and Investigations At [37:19], the transcript covers Jean’s inconsistent accounts of the shooting. Initially claiming it was accidental, later testimonies and the autopsy revealed discrepancies:

• Autopsy Findings: At [44:42] Ash cites Dr. Lewis Rowe’s autopsy report, which found four bullets in Herman’s body, contradicting Jean’s statement of having shot him twice.

Trial Proceedings At [47:50], the hosts discuss the challenges faced during the trial:

• Jury Selection Issues: The high-profile nature of the case, combined with public familiarity with the Scarsdale Diet, complicated jury selection.

• Prosecution vs. Defense: At [48:35] Ash explains that the prosecution framed the case as one of jealousy and rage, presenting Jean’s unstable mental state as motive. Conversely, the defense argued for accidental shooting amidst Jean's struggles with mental illness, though forensic evidence undermined this claim.

Verdict and Sentencing At [54:02], the episode details the jury’s unanimous decision to convict Jean of second-degree murder after finding her testimony inconsistent with the medical evidence. Jean was sentenced to 15 years to life at the Bedford Hills Correctional Facility, where she later worked on programs to aid other inmates.

Legacy and Reflection At [56:53], Elena and Ash reflect on the case, expressing sadness over the tragic outcome. They emphasize the importance of emotional support and the devastating impact of unresolved mental health issues.

Notable Quotes

• Jean Harris on her professional commitment: “My work day begins at 8am and lasts until I drop.” ([07:17])
• Prosecutor George Boland on the motive: “Mrs. Harris, desperately unhappy over the loss of Dr. Tarnauer's affections and resentful of his relationship with a younger woman, entered his home unannounced and unexpectedly and intentionally shot him, causing his death.” ([49:05])
• Juror Marion Stevens on the verdict: “If her intent was suicide, the actions that took place that night should have worked out.” ([54:32])

Conclusion This episode of Morbid paints a poignant picture of Jean Harris's descent into despair and the tragic murder of Herman Tarnower. Through detailed recounting and critical analysis, Elena and Ash shed light on the interplay between personal turmoil and professional obligations, ultimately leading to a dark and irreversible outcome.

Final Thoughts At [58:00], the hosts close the episode with a somber reflection on the case’s sad conclusion, reinforcing the importance of addressing mental health and emotional distress before they lead to tragic actions.

---

Note: Times are referenced as per the provided transcript for accurate citation of notable quotes.

Transcript

[Elena]

Hey weirdos. Before we dive into today's twisted tale, let me tell you about a place where the darkness never ends. Wondery. It's like stepping into a haunted mansion where the floorboards creak with ad free episodes and early access to new episodes lurks around every corner. So come join us if you dare. Morbid is available one week early and ad free only on Wondery. You can join Wondery in the Wondery app or in Apple Podcasts or Spotify.

[Ash]

You're listening to a Morbid Network podcast.

[Unknown]

Let Audible expand your life by listening. Explore over 1 million audiobooks and exclusive Audible originals that'll inspire and motivate you all in one easy app. Tap into your well being with advice and insight from leading professionals and experts on better health, relationships, career, finance, investing and more. Maybe you want to kick a bad habit or start a good one. Speaking of, I'm actually listening to the Secret on Audible. I love that title so much and 10 out of 10 recommend the soundscaping is pristine. Get advice and insight from leading professionals and experts on health, relationship, career, finance, investing and more. There's so much opportunity to learn and more to imagine when you listen. Start listening today when you sign up for a free 30 day trial at audible.commorbid have you ever grown tired of searching for your favorite movies and TV shows across numerous streaming accounts? It's so frustrating to have all your favorite shows live across multiple logins and apps.

[Ash]

I'm like trying to watch one show.

[Unknown]

I'm like wait, what's my login here? On Prime Video though, you can add over 100 subscriptions like Macs, Apple TV plus and Paramount plus all in one app. Experience the convenience of having your favorite subscriptions in your Prime Video account with one login and one password. There's a hundred more premium and specialty subscriptions to unlock a world of movies, TV and sports all in one app. Super duper easy to not have to log in to like 45 different streaming services. Check out subscriptions on Prime Video.

[Elena]

Hey weirdos. I'm Elena, I'm Ash and this is Morbid.

[Ash]

Yo, I feel like we should have body slammed at the end of the day like a a dude bro. Yeah, I like that. Like metaphorically.

[Elena]

Metaphorically.

[Ash]

I don't know.

[Elena]

I like that.

[Ash]

So overtook me. What's up?

[Elena]

So lots is up. Lots is up, lots is down. Lots is all around we that's what.

[Ash]

I was gonna say. I was gonna finish it and I was literally gonna say lots is all around.

[Elena]

You even did the all around with your Head.

[Ash]

Bring it around.

[Elena]

So once again, very cool thing that happened was hanging out with Andrew McMahon. Wild 16 year old me, screaming. Literally can't handle it.

[Ash]

Screaming.

[Elena]

But he's very rad and it was very nice of him and we appreciate him. And so a really, really cool thing as well has already happened for you.

[Ash]

Guys if you're on Wondery.

[Elena]

Yeah. For everyone in general.

[Ash]

We just can't say who it is.

[Elena]

Because we'll never understand it. But we're here. Everyone got it. It's a bonus episode. It was on top of your regular episodes. It already happened for you. But guys, it hasn't happened for me yet. So can you tell me how it went?

[Ash]

Everyone just commented on the eventual post that comes up. It was great.

[Elena]

It went so well.

[Unknown]

It was a great.

[Ash]

Elena, you had so much fun.

[Elena]

I did. I know I did.

[Ash]

And Ash, you had fun too.

[Elena]

You know what? Right now I. I feel it now and I'm like, wow.

[Ash]

You feel it? Kind of.

[Elena]

I had so much fun. It was an. It was fun. It was lovely. It was exciting.

[Ash]

It was grand.

[Elena]

It was so grand. It was incredible. It's something. I was meteoric. It was meteoric. I like that. Yeah, it was great.

[Ash]

I think like a religious experience, you know.

[Elena]

I hope you guys fucking loved it.

[Ash]

I know you did, of course.

[Elena]

Because I know you guys and I know this is like right up your wheelhouse. I don't think it's up your wheelhouse. I think it's in your wheelhouse. I think that's how it goes.

[Ash]

Could be both.

[Elena]

I got weird with it, which is kind of on brand right now. For what?

[Ash]

Careful.

[Elena]

What is going on?

[Ash]

Careful. So back it up.

[Elena]

I'm not. I'm not.

[Ash]

Yeah.

[Elena]

I think in. I think in like a week or so I can properly, like, talk about it, you know, and mention what it actually is. And actually to make sure that I can, because I want to, like, be excited with you guys and like you to be able to hear the excitement in real time. We're gonna record the intro to that episode that comes out after it, right after we record this, that exciting bonus episode.

[Ash]

And then we'll get into the episode.

[Elena]

So that we can properly capture the state I'm in.

[Ash]

It's gonna be interesting.

[Elena]

It is.

[Ash]

I don't know if you'll be capable of recording.

[Elena]

I know.

[Ash]

Anything after that. I'm very excited. Yay.

[Elena]

In case you couldn't tell. But it's gonna be really fun. You guys can look forward to it, I swear. And. Yeah. And we have Some good cases coming up. We got some good stuff coming up. Yeah, it's all good.

[Ash]

Well, right now we're in part two of Gene Harris and the murder of Dr. Herman Tarnower.

[Elena]

This has been a ride so far just in terms of everything, how the ups and downs and the turns and the. Yeah, this feels. This is like an epic drama.

[Ash]

It is an epic drama. It's giving, like soap opera. Yeah, a little bit.

[Elena]

It for sure is, you know.

[Ash]

So in part one, we heard all about Gene's upbringing and how it would obviously later affect her man picker.

[Elena]

Her man picker.

[Ash]

Her man picker. Her picker. How her first marriage didn't work out. How everybody hated Jim.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

And how she was so close to a second chance at marriage with Dr. Herman High Tarnhower. But how that all ultimately unraveled. Then, of course, we got into how she started relying on desoxin, a prescription form of methamphetamine, you know, the one that was for her chronic back pain. And how that was really starting to change her personality and shift her way of thinking.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

And then, of course, we got into Dr. Tarnower's relationship with his girlfriend Lynn, and how that kind of lined up with some pretty scary and strange harassing phone calls that were leaving Gene quite paranoid.

[Elena]

Yeah, understandably.

[Ash]

Yeah. Now let's get into part two. At the same time that her relationship with Dr. Tarnauer seemed to be basically reaching a pretty bitter end, Jean was at the peak of her career, which you.

[Elena]

You would have hoped would have kind of taken. Taken all that energy. I know, but it's not always that easy.

[Ash]

No. And I think where she was in a mental state, it just wasn't possible for her to really, like, relish in that.

[Elena]

Sometimes it's hard to disengage.

[Ash]

It is. Exactly. So as the headmistress of one of the nation's most elite private schools, like I was saying in part one, she regularly attended galas and dinner parties with some of the nation's wealthiest families, and she was invited to SPE education conferences around the country. In a letter to Hai in 1977, she wrote, My work day begins at 8am and lasts until I drop.

[Elena]

Damn.

[Ash]

So it's like she was at the peak of her career, but it was also really taxing. Yeah. On her physical health and her mental health, for sure. And her relationship with. With high is taxing on her mental health.

[Elena]

Yeah. And it's like sometimes having that busy of, like, a professional life can, like, distract you a little bit, but it doesn't you know, the second you come out of it, it all comes crashing.

[Ash]

Down and you're burning the candle at both.

[Elena]

Exactly.

[Ash]

Not healthy.

[Elena]

Precisely.

[Ash]

So, like the Thomas School, the Madeira school had also been struggling in the mid-70s, including an incident. This is fucking awful. Where a mentally ill man abducted and sexually assaulted one of the students. He left her tied to a tree on campus and she died from exposure. Holy shit. Yeah. It's something we're definitely going to look more into.

[Elena]

That's horrific.

[Ash]

Yeah. Well, it was this incident that eventually led the previous headmistress to retire. You can imagine why. Opening the job for somebody new who could, you know, revitalize the school. One of the board members later said of their search for a replacement, we wanted someone womanly.

[Elena]

Like, a woman? Is that what, like.

[Ash]

What are you.

[Elena]

What are you talking about?

[Ash]

Cool.

[Unknown]

That's.

[Elena]

We wanted someone womanly.

[Ash]

What?

[Elena]

What? That's all. I guess that's the requirement.

[Ash]

Well, Gene was womanly. She met all the board's criteria for an ideal headmistress.

[Elena]

Wow.

[Ash]

But the job proved far harder and like I was saying, way more emotionally taxing than she had anticipated. And adding to her stress was the additional work that she had taken on in order to help high with a diet book that he was actually contracted to produce about his popular Scarsdale Diet. This is like a high protein, low carb method of weight loss. And despite its immense popularity at the time, the diet, the Scarsdale Diet, has since been labeled a pretty good example of a fad diet where you would lose a great deal of weight when you first did this, but you would, once you stop dieting, you just gain the weight back because it's not sustainable.

[Elena]

Yeah. I have feelings about diets for the most part.

[Ash]

I do, too. It's a very unhealthy industry. I don't care. Don't come at me.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

Nevertheless, it's my opinion. It's my opinion. Nevertheless. Though in the late 1970s, Dr. Tarnower's diet was extremely profitable and publishing houses across New York were just clamoring to publish his first official book.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

Diet book. So in late 1978, his diet really wasn't more than just a one page eating plan that he was giving out to patients who wanted to lose weight. But his publisher hired ghostwriter Sam Sinclair, author of more than two dozen self help books, to develop that one single sheet into a several hundred page book.

[Elena]

Damn.

[Ash]

I feel like you're gonna find this part interesting.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

Sinclair was given six months to produce the entire book.

[Elena]

Whoa.

[Ash]

But when Jean read the first draft of what he'd produced. She was shocked by really how unethical and actually poorly written the book was.

[Elena]

Oh, no.

[Ash]

Her opinions led. Obviously, she's a woman with opinion, so that's not great. In this time.

[Elena]

No, not in that time.

[Ash]

A lot of tension started to, you know, unravel between herself, Dr. Tarnauer, and the ghostwriter Sinclair, to the point where she offered to rewrite the entire manuscript herself.

[Elena]

Wow.

[Ash]

She was like, this is so bad that, like, I'm gonna do it all and make it better and I'm not. She wasn't, like, she wasn't a writer. Damn. You know, like, obviously she's a very. She's a trained professional when it comes to, like, being a teacher and that kind of thing. So she can write, I'm sure, but like, she proves herself.

[Elena]

Holy.

[Ash]

Yeah. Under any circumstances, rewriting Dr. Tarnauer's book would have been a huge time commitment. But considering that Jean also had a very demanding full time job, it seemed pretty unrealistic.

[Elena]

And unnecessary.

[Ash]

And unnecessary. Yet somehow she managed to pull off the impossible and produced a respectable final draft for the publisher on time. Wow. Yeah. Read the whole thing over.

[Elena]

I'm just like, why'd you do that? Like that. That's very impressive.

[Ash]

But, like, I think she just was like, this is shit. And it can't go into the world with High's name on it. And I love him so much, so I'm gonna help here. And I think she probably thought, like, I'm gonna do this for him and prove.

[Elena]

Oh, 100. That's all it is.

[Ash]

It's like, but girl, she's in a constant loop of trying to prove her words.

[Elena]

I feel it's so.

[Ash]

The Complete Scarsdale Medical Diet by Doctored Herman Tarnauer and Sam Sinclair. Yeah, I think y'all mean Gene Harris, but okay. Came out in late December of 1978 and it was an immediate success. Of course, all the credit really went to Dr. Tarnauer alone, instead of the group of doctors who had really created the book at the Scarsdale Medical Group. Or Gene Harris, who literally wrote the entire book.

[Elena]

That's gross.

[Ash]

Yeah. Yet for Gene, writing the book was never about money. It was an opportunity to prove to High that she was still of use to him and worth keeping in his life. So when he offered to pay her $2,000 for her work, she was deeply hurt and immediately left New York and returned to Virginia. Me, I would have taken that cash.

[Elena]

Yeah. And get the fuck away.

[Ash]

Two weeks later, she received a check from Dr. Tarnauer along with a note that read, for reasons that I cannot explain, it is imperative that I make all book disbursements at this time. I am enclosing a check for $4,000 that I hope you will accept. So he wanted to pay her for this. This was a professional exchange in his mind. And for her, it's like it was proving her love for him.

[Elena]

Exactly.

[Ash]

Her work on the book was a labor of love, something to show him how much she valued him. And he basically dismissed that and treated it like it was a service that could be bought, which it is.

[Elena]

That's the thing.

[Ash]

But that's not that. That was not her intent and why she did it.

[Elena]

I also. And just to. Just to flip this on its head. Did she tell him this is a labor of love for me?

[Ash]

I don't know.

[Elena]

Because if you don't express that to someone, then they are going to look at it as a professional thing and treat it as such. If you don't express things to people, they can't read your damn mind.

[Ash]

That's the thing.

[Elena]

So there is that whole thing where it's like, yes, I'm sure it was a labor of love for her, but if you do not express that, no one's going to know it.

[Ash]

Yeah.

[Elena]

So you got to say it just to look at it from both sides.

[Ash]

Yeah. No, it's important.

[Elena]

He was paying her for the book because she did a service.

[Ash]

Yeah. And I don't know if she did. I don't think they were great communicators. That's the thing.

[Elena]

I don't think there's a lot of communication. So it's a lot of assuming somebody's going to understand my intention here.

[Ash]

Yeah.

[Elena]

And that never works out.

[Ash]

No, it doesn't.

[Elena]

You got to be pretty upfront with people.

[Ash]

Well, and this was. This was a pretty big turning point.

[Elena]

In their relationship, I imagine.

[Ash]

She wrote to him, you have said to me so many times, I never ask anything of you. I never ask anything of anyone. But, my dear, that isn't true. For starters, you ask every woman to be as incapable of love as you are.

[Elena]

Wow, that was a good line.

[Ash]

Reads upon, reads upon, reads in here. And giving her a check for the work high reminded Jean yet again that their relationship had become purely transactional. But still, she couldn't let go of their relationship. It was almost like she became addicted to him.

[Elena]

Oh, 100%.

[Ash]

Almost as addicted as the pills that he'd been prescribing her. And now she was stuck in this terrible position of being totally emotionally reliant on a man who really didn't want anything to do with her. Pretty clearly.

[Elena]

Yeah. And at that point it's like if he is being clear that like nothing is coming of this.

[Ash]

Yeah.

[Elena]

You gotta walk away.

[Ash]

Yep.

[Elena]

Then it. Then it does become on you that you're not letting it go.

[Ash]

And I do think it got to that point.

[Elena]

And that's the thing. It's like there, there's. There's times when. And again, I don't know what the interactions were or anything like that.

[Ash]

No. None of us.

[Elena]

He was. Because it's shitty when someone's pretending that they're still alluding that there might be something there. Of course that's gonna leave you with a little string of hope.

[Ash]

Of course.

[Elena]

And when you're in that position of desperation and you love someone and you're, you know all that, you're gonna take anything as a little string of hope. So you don't know what kind of things were dangling in front of her. But it does sound like he was at least attempting to communicate that this is a transactional relationship now. And at that point you need to do the work. To get away.

[Ash]

Yeah.

[Elena]

To like walk away.

[Ash]

Yeah.

[Elena]

Because it's been made clear, you know.

[Ash]

Yeah. It really has.

[Elena]

It's. It's. It's just one of those things. If he's not making it clear. I get why you're hanging on to hope. Because when you're in that position, nothing's logical.

[Ash]

Yeah. But none of.

[Elena]

Kind of sounds like it's being made clear.

[Ash]

It. Yeah. And none of this is logical.

[Elena]

Well, that's. I was going to say. And even that's not logical.

[Ash]

No. Yeah. Oh, there's so many things to take care of every single day. Like you gotta wake up, you gotta do your breakfast, you gotta. Luckily I don't have kids. I don't know how you people with.

[Unknown]

Kids do it because then you have.

[Ash]

To make like 47 more breakfasts. It's a lot of things going on.

[Unknown]

We have to manage our stress as people. You know how you can do that? Start your morning with ritual stress relief. This product uses first of its kind technology to support the body's natural cortisol response so that you can take on the daily juggle.

[Ash]

I absolutely love ritual.

[Unknown]

I actually take their symbiotic plus gut health. It's like a prebiotic and a probiotic in one. You know your girl has tummy issues, but not really anymore. I feel like it's really helped me Be if I'm being blatantly honest, a little more regular. They also have other great things. Their Stress Relief bio series technology is designed to optimize the release of a trio of clinically studied ingredients to help the body manage stress. Guys, the juggle is real. Don't just respond to stress. Get ahead of it with stress relief from Ritual. Get 25% off your first month at Ritual.com morbid start Ritual or add stress relief to your subscription today. Today that's ritual.commorbid for 25% off. This show is sponsored by Better Help.

[Ash]

I feel like I am a super.

[Unknown]

Lucky gal because I really have such a great support system around me. I got my husband, first of all. He rocks my socks. I got my cool ass sister. I got Mikey, you know him. I got a lot of supporters in my corner. But it wasn't always like that. I didn't always feel that way. And when I didn't, therapy was a great support system for me. Think about your favorite leaders, mentors and idols. They don't always have all the answers, but they do know when to ask questions questions or seek support from their community. In a society that glorifies hyper independence, it's easy to forget that we're all better when we have a support system behind us. Therapy can be a source of support. Like I said, for any area in your life. It's time to shift the focus from doing it all to knowing that we're better when we actually ask for help. I have benefited from therapy so much in my past. I love therapy. I'm a big proponent of it. I think everybody should try it. It just helps to have a little chit chat every now and again with somebody who doesn't have a horse in the race. Build your support system with better help. Visit betterhelp.commorbid today to get 10% off your first month. That's BetterHelp H E L P.commorbid.

[Elena]

Well.

[Ash]

Throughout the later years of the 1970s, Jean's relationship with Dr. Tarnauer began to crumble at a pretty rapid rate. He was just seemingly replacing her with his younger lab assistant, Lynn. By the end of the decade, her emotional distress and her drug dependency at this point had really started to distort her thinking. She was profoundly depressed, very lonely. She was struggling with anxiety on a daily basis and it was all showing. And not only in her personal life, but her professional life too.

[Elena]

That makes that's so sad. She unraveled because outside of this man, she has so much worth. She does you know?

[Ash]

Yeah, absolutely. One colleague said sometimes she was a very beautiful woman. At other times, she looked like a haggard, skinny old woman all hunched over. And she also started having, quote, unquote, spells of anger and other bizarre behaviors where she would lash out at people for, like, a lot of the times. No reason. Her co worker said anything could set her off. It needn't be a major crisis. She really didn't like the girls, meaning the girls at the school where she was headmistress.

[Elena]

That's not cool.

[Ash]

In fact, at one point, she became so irrationally frustrated with their lack of respect for cleanliness that she banned oranges from the campus because the girls always left their peels. Their orange peels laying around instead of tossing them. So she was like, okay, no more oranges on campus.

[Elena]

That's some headmistress.

[Ash]

Which I'm also like, who? Like, isn't there somebody above you that you have to get, like, approval from?

[Elena]

Can you ban oranges from a school?

[Ash]

Don't oranges fall under, like, free something?

[Elena]

Yeah, you know, free something. Free orange, free citrus, you know, But.

[Ash]

But that just shows, like, how irrational and irrational her thinking was. Yeah. By the end of 1980, the entire affair had started to take a toll on actually everybody involved, and, of course, Gene in particular. At the end of January, her contract with the school was renewed and she received a substantial raise, which was good.

[Elena]

Wow.

[Ash]

But in private, she told her secretary, she, quote, felt like packing a bag and getting the hell out of there.

[Elena]

Yeah, it sounds bad.

[Ash]

Yeah. The comment was understood to indicate that she was burning out, but in truth, things were far worse than really anybody even knew. In late February, she spent Jean spent 10 days traveling on the west coast in a fundraising and recruitment effort for the school. And during that trip, she ran out of dysoxen.

[Elena]

Oh.

[Ash]

When she got back to Washington in the first week of March, she immediately called hi. Who promised that he would send more. But any relief she felt was quickly undermined when he also told her that he had decided not to bring her as his companion to an upcoming Heart association banquet. He said she was still invited to attend, but Lynn was also invited to attend.

[Elena]

See, in here, it's like he's being clear.

[Ash]

Yeah, this is clear. It's cruel to say.

[Elena]

It's very clear what he's saying, but it's also like. So you were bringing her.

[Ash]

Yeah, he had asked her.

[Elena]

So it's like. And then said, that's unclear. Like, you know, like, it feels like it's flip flopping.

[Ash]

I think revoking the invitation probably came from her state at that time. Yeah, I think he was like, you are clearly not doing well. And like, yeah, I don't. Like, you can still come if you want. Like, I think he was trying to let her down easy, but it was probably one of those things where it was like, you can come if you want because I invited you, but, like, you don't.

[Elena]

Up to you.

[Ash]

Yeah. When? And like I said, when Hai had initially asked her to accompany him to the banquet like he did, Gene took that invitation to mean that things between them were returning to normal, of course. So his decision to attend the banquet alone now not only felt like a rejection of her as a companion, but also an indication that she was now on equal ground with Lynn. Because, Lin, he wasn't going with Lynn, but she was invited to come if she wanted to. Oh, yeah. And she always believed that Lynn was nothing more than High's mistress, which meant that she probably, like Gene herself, probably was at this point, too.

[Elena]

Damn, you know.

[Ash]

So his rejection was an absolute shock to Gene, which is interesting. But rather than react in the moment, she simply said she'd call him back, and she abruptly hung up the phone. In the days that followed, she seemed to operate on autopilot, meeting with difficult parents and students, a lot of whom were confrontational. It's a very, you know, elite school. And by then, desoxin had completely left her body, and the symptoms of withdrawal were starting to set in.

[Elena]

Oh, no.

[Ash]

Among other things, she was feeling even more depressed and despondent, and her ability to cope with her declining mental health pretty much evaporated.

[Elena]

Oh, this is really sad.

[Ash]

It's very sad. On the evening of March 9, after spending days unable to reach high, and he hasn't sent a prescription. He's basically just, like, ghosting her.

[Elena]

Oh.

[Ash]

She sat down to write her lover a letter. She said, I am distraught as I write this. Your phone call to tell me you preferred the company of a vicious, adulterous psychotic was topped by a call from the dean of Students 10 minutes later and has kept me awake for almost 36 hours. What I say will ramble, but it will be the truth. And I have to do something besides shriek with pain. This is a quote. I haven't played the slave for you. I would have never committed adultery for you. But I have added a dimension to your life and given you pleasure and dignity as you have me. I've watched you grow rich in the years where we have been together. And I have watched me go through moments where I was Almost destitute. And now that thieving slut has the run of your home and you accuse me of stealing money and books. The many things your whore does openly. And obviously you now have the cruelty to accuse me of. Wow. Yeah. Which if you think about the letters that we read between them in part one, obviously they're like love letters. And this is clearly not a love letter. But even just like her way of thinking, you can tell, is completely distorted.

[Elena]

Oh, 100%.

[Ash]

Like, she is angry. This is rage coded.

[Elena]

This is like that thieving slut calling her a whore. It's like, what?

[Ash]

I'm not a doctor, but she seems a little manic here.

[Elena]

Yeah, she seems like there's. I mean, clearly, because she's going through withdrawal symptoms. This is not going to end her right mind. Like, she is not in a normal state of being. Like her homeostasis here.

[Ash]

Exactly. And scary in the end. She's talking about Lynn, basically. Like, she thought that I. It's a little unclear because it almost seems like she saw, like. Because he was saying, lynn is invited to the banquet and so are you. And I think she thought they were on the same playing field. And then I don't know if there was like another call that happened where he was saying, like, no, I'm still with Lynn.

[Elena]

Yeah. Or like, I am taking Lynn kind of thing.

[Ash]

It's a little unclear, but she. She's focusing a lot of anger at Lynn.

[Elena]

Yeah. And it's like, don't focus it on the gal.

[Ash]

Focusing on the guy.

[Elena]

But not how you do, apparently.

[Ash]

No, no. Well, that's like a small excerpt because this letter went on for pages and pages as Gene poured out every ounce of anger and resentment that she felt toward High and Lynn over the previous five years. She had a lot to say, but she still indicated that all she wanted was to spend as much time with High as she could, which is very. No. Now, she planned to send the letter by registered mail to ensure that he would receive it. But then she got a better idea. She would drive the five hours from Washington to New York to deliver it to High in person.

[Elena]

Yeah. This has gone far beyond.

[Ash]

Yeah. What it should have gone far beyond. By the morning of March 10, Gene had been withdrawing from methamphetamine and painkillers for days. And she was severely sleep deprived as well. So to say that she was not in her right mind would actually be a serious understatement.

[Elena]

Oh, yeah, she's dangerous right now.

[Ash]

She is. To herself.

[Elena]

I was gonna say to herself and everyone around Her? Yeah.

[Ash]

She had spent 14 years devoting everything she had to her job and to Herman Tarnauer. And now she was just starting to feel like she was being pushed out of both. It felt to her. She later said, that, quote, the last of her support systems had now been knocked out from under her. So that morning, she called her secretary and told her to cancel all her appointments for that afternoon. And then she called High and actually managed to get through to him. And she said, hi, it's been a bad few weeks. I'd like to come up and talk to you for a few minutes. And he said he was having dinner guests that night. Oh. And that it would be better if they could shot the following day. But she insisted, and he relented and said, fine, come see me tonight.

[Elena]

Oh, boy.

[Ash]

Neither Herman Tarnauer nor anybody else knew it, but Gene Harris had come up with a plan. And I just want to give a trigger warning for suicide here. She purchased a.32 caliber handgun a few days earlier. After seeing High one last time, she planned to walk a short distance to a little park that she liked near Hai's house. And there was a pond in the park that she actually always liked to sit by. And she decided that would be the place she wanted to go to end her life.

[Elena]

Oh, man, that's sad.

[Ash]

Very, very sad. Before leaving, she actually finalized her will, and she wrote a letter of resignation addressed to the board of directors at the Madeira School. And then she got in the car and left Washington, bound for New York. So it was late, almost 11 o'clock at night, when Jean finally got to Dr. Tarnower's apartment. A student had actually given her flowers earlier that day, so she thought, hi might like to have them. So she grabbed that bouquet of flowers and the gun before exiting the car and going up to the apartment. Inside, it was dark, and it seemed that Hai and his housekeeper Suzanne, had already gone to bed. So Gene climbed the stairs, called softly out to hi. But got no response. And quietly, she entered the bedroom where she found him sleeping. And she whispered to him as she fumbled with the wall switch to turn the light on.

[Elena]

This is already very scary that she just, like, walked into his bedroom.

[Ash]

Yeah.

[Elena]

While he's sleeping.

[Ash]

Yeah.

[Elena]

It's just gonna flick the light on. That's literally my worst nightmare.

[Ash]

Immediately jarring.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

So when the light came on, Hai was just waking up. So he's rubbing his eyes and he's like, what the. And despite his giving in to seeing her that night, he told her at that point that he Was tired and he didn't want to talk in the middle of the night. Like, yeah, probably smart.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

But Jean just sat down on the edge of the bed, hoping that her continued presence would rouse him. But hi was like, yeah, cool, I'm going to go back to sleep.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

So she just started chatting casually. And according to her, he said, jesus, Gene, just shut up and go to bed. Which, like, I can kind of understand.

[Elena]

I'm going to be honest that I probably wouldn't be as nice like that. I'd be pissed.

[Ash]

I'm a horrible person when I just wake up. Like, Drew is like, you're so mean when you first wake up. Or like you're not quite, quite awake. I. I think I would say worse possibly.

[Elena]

I definitely. And if you're saying I'm going to like, I was asleep and you woke me up by walking in my room and flicking the light on and then just talking at me and I tell you to leave, I'm going to sleep and you just keep talking. Yeah. I'm gonna say shut up and go to bed.

[Ash]

And like talking about nothing. Just casually sitting there on the edge of my bed talking. Come on, stop it.

[Elena]

That's also how you know that she is very much not. Not. She's not clearly here because this is not logical behavior.

[Ash]

And it's not logical and it's not characteristic for her.

[Elena]

No.

[Ash]

Like from.

[Elena]

Based on everything seems over the top.

[Ash]

Yeah. So not wanting to sleep, Jean went into the primary bathroom to gather a few of her things that she intended to give her daughter in law. It had always been the responsibility of High's housekeeper Suzanne to remove Jean's things when she left and replace them with Lynn's clothing and vice versa when Gene was coming.

[Elena]

That's up.

[Ash]

Which like, think of that job being like, oh, let me.

[Elena]

Let me take this woman's one mistress's stuff out. And that's up.

[Ash]

Yeah, that's super up.

[Elena]

That's really fucked up. It's up of him to do that. And it's up of him to have a woman that works for him do that to two other women. Yeah, like that's. That's a lot of manipulation.

[Ash]

Again, it reminds me of Richard and his housekeeper that was in love with him.

[Elena]

Yep.

[Ash]

So not saying that his housekeeper was in love with him. She wasn't. But Jean was surprised when she switched on the light and found the room filled with somebody else's clothing. The realization that that clothing and that jewelry all around belonged to Lynn seemed to cause something to snap inside of Jean, Yeah. So now she was irrationally angry, like irate, and grabbed a handful of clothing and other items and stormed back into the bedroom. She threw the items at at high on the bed, but overshot and ended up sending several of the heavier items crashing through one of the bedroom windows.

[Elena]

Yeah, I don't know. This has escalated to a point also.

[Ash]

I'm like, what did you throw between clothing and jewelry that it crashed through a bedroom window?

[Elena]

Was it like shoes or something? Maybe, but also you gotta hum those shoes at a window to get em to go through.

[Ash]

Yeah, that's the thing.

[Elena]

I don't know if this was simple overshooting of the bed. I think it was humming as hard as you can.

[Ash]

I think so too.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

And this whole version of events is Jean's version of events, obviously. So we're gonna have to kind of step in every now and again and say like she said, that happened. But we probably.

[Unknown]

We all have routines that bring us calm in a chaotic and often scary world. For me, it's arming my SimpliSafe home security system when I'm heading out every.

[Ash]

Morning or locking up each night.

[Unknown]

That simple step does more than just protect my family and home. It gives me peace of mind. With SimpliSAF safe, I sleep more soundly and I leave the house with way more confidence. It's amazing how one small push of a button can have such a big impact. I'm obsessed with Simply Safe, and I think you will be too. With Simplisafe, millions of Americans enjoy greater security and peace of mind every time they arm their system. Traditional security systems only take action after somebody has already broken in and that's too late. Simply Safe's Active Guard outdoor protection can help prevent break ins before they even happen. Though I love so many things about SimpliSafe, one more great feature they have that I absolutely love above is a panic button. You can put it anywhere in your house. I suggest putting it somewhere in your bedroom. And you can go to sleep every night knowing that you can hit that button. Gosh forbid anything happens. Visit simplisafe.commorbid to claim 50% off a new system with a professional monitoring plan and get your first month free. That's simplisafe.com morbid there's no safe like simplisafe. Are you looking to take control of your life? One way to do that is to check Goodrx and finally stop overpaying for your prescription medications. With Goodrx, you can find big savings on your prescriptions for everything. From GLP1 medications to remedies for your allergies and so much more. Using GoodRx is free and easy to use. Just search for any prescription on the GoodRx website or app, get your coupon and show it to the pharmacist. Check Goodrx to save up to 80% at pharmacies near you, including Walmart, Walgreens, CVS, Publix, Albertsons, Kroger's and many more. And remember, Goodrx works whether you have insurance or not. And even if you do have insurance, GoodRx could beat your co pay price. That happens to me more often than not.

[Ash]

So I always check Goodrx before I.

[Unknown]

Go to the pharmacy and then I.

[Ash]

Flash that little coupon.

[Unknown]

I say, oh, I'm saving money. I'm gonna spend that on something cooler. For simple smart savings on your everyday prescriptions, check goodrx go to goodrx.com morbid that's goodrx.com morbid.

[Ash]

So by that point, Hai was out of bed and very angry and apparently slapped Jean hard across the face, which sent her retreating into the bathroom. Up, she said. Yeah, super. Up, she said. He was angrier than she had ever seen him and when he entered the dressing room adjacent to the bathroom, he hit her again, just as hard as he had the first time. During the four hour drive to New or the five hour drive to New York, Jean had envisioned one last romantic moment with High where she would say goodbye and then go to the park. According to her, and in her mind the whole thing had been so romantic and peaceful, but now things had fallen apart so quickly and none of it, it was going according to her plan. Yeah, so she said later that she yelled at him and this is, this is so bleak and sad and awful. Hit me again, High. Make it hard enough to kill me.

[Elena]

Oh, this is awful.

[Ash]

Yeah. But rather than hit her again, he just looked down at her with disgust and told her to get out. So she hesitated for a moment and then she stood up and started walking toward the bedroom door, she said, intending to start her walk to the park, but when she reached the edge of the bed, she said it occurred to her that her entire plan had already unraveled. So it made no difference whether she went to the park to end her life or if she just simply did it right there and then in his bedroom. So she said to him, according to her, never mind, hi, I'll do it myself. And she grabbed the gun from her handbag and placed the barrel to her temple again. Given the Outcome of this incident. We only have her description of the events to go by, but until her death in 2012, she did maintain that what happened next was entirely accidental.

[Elena]

I'm just. And obviously, there's a little bit of a reason, I guess. I don't. I don't know why you would have the gun on your person.

[Ash]

Yeah. Like, why you would even take it in there if you were planning just to go to the park.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

I don't know if maybe she was planning to leave her car and walk. And walk over, but even still, you could walk out to your car and grab your. Grab the gun. Yeah.

[Elena]

I just think.

[Ash]

And, like, she had to valet possibly.

[Elena]

I think. I just think walking into his home with a loaded gun, the way things have gone and the tense moments you have had together and, you know, this being, oh, the middle of the night where you're gonna flick on his light and wake him up. I don't know if having a gun with you is sending the right message.

[Ash]

You know, I would say probably not.

[Elena]

So I feel like it's strange that she was able to just grab that gun out of her purse. But who knows?

[Ash]

It gets stranger. Okay, so apparently, according to gene, when hai saw the gun in her hand, he jumped toward her from behind, which knocked the gun away from her head and caused it to discharge. When she turned around, Hai was standing there with a shocked look on his face, and he shouted at her, look what you've done, While holding up his bloody hand. In the webbing where his thumb connected with his right hand, there was a bullet hole where blood was just pouring out. So they stared at each other for a few seconds, and then high walked to the bathroom. And gene could hear the water running, which makes my hand radio.

[Elena]

I literally my whole body. I was like.

[Ash]

Like, starting to rinse that off.

[Elena]

I'm just like, oh, that makes my legs hurt for some weird reason.

[Ash]

That's interesting.

[Elena]

I don't know.

[Ash]

Maybe it's, like, a thing in your brain.

[Elena]

I think it is.

[Ash]

But also, this guy's a doctor, and he just got shot in the hand.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

Like he's going to be insanely angry.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

Or you would assume. Yeah. So with high out of the room, Gene said she began frantically looking for the gun on the floor, hoping that she'd find it and end her own life before he came out of the bathroom. So she dropped to her hands and knees, and she could see the gun under the bed. And she said she just reached it and was raising it to her head again when hai's arm came at her from the side and wrenched it out of her hand for the second time.

[Elena]

Time.

[Ash]

They sat across from each other just staring at each other for a short time. And then hi reached over for the phone to call his housekeeper, Suzanne. Okay, so for the most part, Gene's recollection of the night's events appear to be pretty clear and somewhat supported by the evidence, like some of them. But when it comes to what happened after High reached for the phone, her version of events became cloudy and left investigators with a lot of questions.

[Elena]

Okay.

[Ash]

According to Jean, she must have tried to reach for the gun again because she recalled physically fighting with Hai. And during that attack, she was struck in the face again. And during the struggle, she fell back on the bed with Hai on top of her, and she felt something poking her stomach. She assumed it was the barrel of the gun, so she squeezed the trigger and heard a loud bang as the gun went off. But to her surprise, she didn't feel any pain. Hai then slid off of her, and without thinking, she jumped off the bed and ran toward the bathroom, knowing that she needed to shoot herself again or he was definitely going to get the gun from her for a third time. So Hai was on his knees by the side of the bed, and when Jean stopped and looked at him, she didn't understand why he stopped chasing her. But without giving it much thought, she raised the gun to her head, took a deep breath, and pulled the trigger. She said. She said the gun made a clicking sound, but nothing happened. And then she looked down and saw that all of the chambers were empty. She ran to the bathroom, and she started rummaging around in her pocket for more bullets, which. So she had more bullets, which is strange to me.

[Elena]

So how many. How many chambers are in this gun? Two shots have gone off. Correct.

[Ash]

According to Gene. We'll get there.

[Elena]

Because, like, yeah, you just threw two in there.

[Ash]

No.

[Elena]

No.

[Ash]

So she ran. And again, why do you have more bullets? If you were planning on just shooting yourself, you would have just taken that loaded gun. In my opinion, you would have just taken that loaded gun with you. I would have left it in the car, probably. Like, I'm not. I don't want to put myself in these shoes, but I don't think I would have brought the loaded gun in to say goodbye to High, and I.

[Elena]

Definitely wouldn't have extra bullets that I brought with me as well.

[Ash]

No, that the extra bullets makes no sense. But once she found the extra bullets, it occurred to her she didn't know how to load or Unload the gun, she said, which. That. So how, like, do you buy a loaded gun? Does that make any sense?

[Elena]

I. I'm not positive about this, but I don't think you do.

[Ash]

I don't think so either.

[Elena]

I'm fairly certain you don't. I'll look it up just to be sure, but I'm. I'm like, what?

[Ash]

I would think you wouldn't. I'll keep going while you look it up. Feel free to interrupt me. So she banged the gun on the side of the bathtub, hoping to dislodge the empty shells. But all she succeeded in doing was breaking the cylinder from the gun, which meant at that point, it was useless.

[Elena]

You cannot buy a loaded gun.

[Ash]

I didn't think in the United States, that makes sense.

[Elena]

I didn't think so either, but I was like, I don't want to claim that I know this for sure.

[Ash]

I don't. You never know if maybe, like she said to the person, I don't know how to load this. Can you load it up for me? And, like, they did something illegally, but I don't know.

[Elena]

It's. I'm gonna go with no on that.

[Ash]

I would go with no on that, too, but. But at this point, she remembered exiting the bathroom and telling Hai that the gun was broken. And she said, it's probably dead. And he. She said, he replied, you're probably right. And he slowly climbed into bed and covered himself with a blanket. Then, according to Jean, it was then that she realized Hai was injured. His coloring was off, and he looked absolutely exhausted. So she decided she needed to go get help. So she ran down the stairs into the dark. And she could hear Suzanne talking to someone in the dining room. But she paid no attention to what she was saying outside. She said that she remembered there was a payphone down the street about a quarter mile away. So she jumped in her car and raced in the direction of the phone. Which is strange to get in your car and leave the scene, huh? As she neared the phone, a police car sped up behind her with its lights flashing. So she made a U turn and started heading back toward the house with the police car obviously following very closely behind her. And when she reached the driveway, she jumped out and shouted to the officer, hurry up. He's been shot. Hut when they entered the house, Suzanne was standing by the stairs. And she. When she saw Jean, she shouted, she's the one. She did it, Gene. Suzanne and the officer went upstairs to the bedroom, where they found Herman Tarnauer on his knees beside the bed. Slumped against the side table, one bloody hand still reaching for the phone. So when she said, he got into bed and he put a blanket over himself.

[Elena]

I don't think now he's kneeling on the.

[Ash]

Yeah, I don't think that happened. With Suzanne's help, the officer laid high down on his back and then went down to his car to get an oxygen tank. Jean lay across the bed, just caressing Hai's face as he lay on the floor, struggling to breathe, and asked him. Oh, hi. Why didn't you kill me? A Short time later, Dr. Herman Tarnauer died from a severed artery caused when a bullet entered his chest. So he just bled out.

[Elena]

I. I have some questions.

[Ash]

Several questions, huh? So Jean never denied that she had shot High. But from that point forward, her story about the night's events would change a number of times.

[Elena]

That does not shock me because it needs a little work from that first one.

[Ash]

At first, she told detectives at the scene, quote, there was a fight and the gun went off. In his testimony in court, officer Daniel O'Sullivan recounted his questioning of Gene for the jury. According to O'Sullivan, Jean, quote, asked the doctor to kill her, meaning Dr. Tarnower. And the struggle then resumed, and several shots were fired. Several means more than two.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

In fact, Gene had told the officer, he wanted to live. I wanted to die. I've been through so much hell with him. I loved him very much. He slept with every woman he could. And I've had it. The next morning, the news of the murder broke on the front page of the New York Times. And in the article, Police Chief William Harris is quoted as saying, we found a revolver in the glove compartment of her car, and she made certain admissions. Okay, so she put the.

[Elena]

She threw it in the glove compartment.

[Ash]

Yeah. In her frenzy of going to get some help again. That doesn't make sense to me.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

He stopped short, obviously, of providing any details as to what Gene had admitted to. Later that day, she was booked on a charge of second degree murder, a charge which her lawyer strongly objected to. The lawyer, Joel Arnau, told reporters, nothing I've heard would. Would apply to intentional homicide.

[Elena]

Okay.

[Ash]

Which. It's gray.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

I don't know.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

The story of High's murder, though, obviously was one of the most scandalous things to hit the front page in a long time. He was one of the most well known and well respected doctors in the country at the time. And it seemed like he'd been killed by a jealous lover who also came from high society. Now, like I said earlier, Jean Stuck to her story. And she sort of. She stuck to her story in the way that she maintained that it was an accident.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

But the other aspects of the story didn't make sense. Like you and I have kind of touched on. According to Jean, she did shoot high in the hand and one time in the stomach, thinking that she was shooting herself. But when Dr. I think it's Lewis Rowe performed the autopsy the next day, he noted that Dr. Tarnower had been struck by four bullets. Yeah, four.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

One in the upper interior chest wall, one in the hand, one in the right arm, and one in the shoulder.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

So that doesn't even really make sense for. If he's on top of her and she feels the gun poking her stomach.

[Elena]

That was my. He wouldn't question.

[Ash]

Shot in the stomach if they're. If they're belly to belly like you would imagine they would be.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

Or even really, like they could have been groin to belly. If he's a bit taller than her.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

You know, like, but for his chest.

[Elena]

To be at her stomach.

[Ash]

That doesn't make a lot of sense.

[Elena]

That doesn't make any sense.

[Ash]

If he has climbed on top of her like she said.

[Elena]

Yeah, no, none of that makes sense. And the amount of bullets that were shot. Yeah, I don't. I. I don't believe her story.

[Ash]

I don't either. I don't either.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

So it was the bullet that entered near his shoulder that likely killed him. According to the autopsy, the bullet had entered the right chest cavity, fracturing three ribs. The fractures had caused the laceration of the pleural lining. The bullet had traveled in a downward trajectory on the surface of the lung, causing a great deal of hemorrhaging. And lung tissue, it continued downward, perforating the diaphragm and the front part of the right kidney where it was recovered.

[Elena]

Damn.

[Ash]

So he.

[Elena]

It really went banged around in there.

[Ash]

Yeah. Yeah. The autopsy directly contradicted Gene's story. Like.

[Elena]

Yeah, to me it's. I mean, it's black and white. There it is.

[Ash]

Not only had High been shot two more times than she had even told police, but he'd also been shot in multiple locations, including one wound that indicated the shooter had actually been standing over him.

[Elena]

Downward trajectory.

[Ash]

Exactly. Dr. Rowe concluded Dr. Tarnower's wounds are not consistent with a struggle over a gun between a left handed woman and a right handed man.

[Elena]

Yeah, I mean, I believe that. Forensic pathologist.

[Unknown]

This show is sponsored by Liquid iv. You gotta show yourself some love every day. Personally, not every single day. Do I do this, but my guilty pleasure lately has just been buying up a ton of sweatshirts. I love me a crew neck.

[Ash]

Love looks different for everybody.

[Unknown]

Especially when it comes to all the ways that you can treat and celebrate yourself. You know how else you can give yourself a little gift? Gift yourself the everyday indulgence of extraordinary hydration from Liquid IV. Powered by Live Hydro Science. Visit liquid I.com and fall in love with flavors like the zesty new hydration multiplier sugar free raspberry lemonade. And use code morbid to save 20% off your first order. I'm obsessed with Liquid IV. I actually have one every single morning. I've been a yoga girly lately, so, you know, got to stay hydrated. All you gotta do is you fill up your water bottle, rip your little stick of Liquid IV open, pour that in, shake it up.

[Ash]

I love shaking. It makes me feel fancy. I don't really know why.

[Unknown]

Break the mold and own your ritual. Just one stick and 16 ounces of water hydrates better than water alone. Treat yourself to extraordinary hydration from Liquid IV. Get 20 off your first order of Liquid IV when you go to LiquidIV.com and use code Morbid at checkout. That's 20 off your first order with code morbid@liquid IV.com Foreign.

[Ash]

Finally went to trial in late November of 1980. The prosecution and the defense immediately ran into problems selecting a jury. Not only had a lot of people heard about the scandal in the paper or on the news, they were also familiar with the Scarsdale diet. And many prospective jurors had even tried it.

[Elena]

Oh, man.

[Ash]

So that really puts a wrench on tanks at all. Then there were the details of the case itself. In 1980, a love triangle between three society people wasn't really something a lot of Americans understood or condoned for that matter. And just as important was the fact that Dr. Tarnauer was Jewish and Jean was not. As her lawyer put it, this relationship crossed religious lines. And there was a good chance that some jurors might seek to punish Gene for that. Wow. Which it's like, that's. I don't even know why that would come to play.

[Elena]

I didn't even think think of that as a possibility. I was more like, oh, it was in the papers. And then people have tried the diet.

[Ash]

That's all I thought is like, he's a really popular doctor. A lot of people know him. The diet, that's high society. But the fact that he's Jewish and she's not plays a role in this. Is like, get a grip. We gotta do better.

[Elena]

Get a grip. Touch some grass, everybody.

[Ash]

I'm like, how about she's a person and he is two and one of them got murdered?

[Elena]

Yeah. How about, like, we look at the fact facts here?

[Ash]

So when the trial began in earnest a few weeks later, the prosecutor, George Boland, presented the case to the jury as one of simple jealousy and rage. And, you know, I kind of agree with this case. Unfortunately, he theorized that, quote, Mrs. Harris, desperately unhappy over the loss of Dr. Tarnauer's affections and resentful of his relationship with a younger woman, entered his home unannounced and unexpected and intentionally shot him, causing his death. Death. I mean, that's pretty much what happened.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

In support of that theory, one witness after another was called to testify as to Jean's psychological state in the days leading up to the shooting. Tarnower's housekeeper, Suzanne Van der Vrecken, which. That's a really funny name.

[Elena]

Vander Vrecken.

[Ash]

Van der Vrecken.

[Elena]

That's a great last name.

[Ash]

She kept meticulous diaries documenting all the drama that went on in the house.

[Elena]

We love a girly who keeps a diary for us. Yes.

[Ash]

That's a receipts queen.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

To me, that screams Gemini.

[Elena]

I love that. That does feel like a Gemini move.

[Ash]

We love a goddamn drama and we love a goddamn receipt.

[Elena]

We love it.

[Ash]

She told the jury she, quote, maintained the diaries to keep track of what she served at the doctor's dinner parties, but they also contained information about who was staying at the house on particular evenings because it was her job to keep track of that. What, she had to know when to switch things over. I love that. And I think she just laughed.

[Elena]

I think she just liked the tea. Yeah.

[Ash]

But the defense argued the opposite, telling the jury that Jean shooting of Dr. Tarnauer was accidental. I don't know how you accidentally shoot somebody four different times, at least one of them being in a downward trajectory.

[Elena]

I. Yeah, that doesn't make sense. You're gonna have. I don't think I can be convinced that you can accidentally shoot someone four.

[Ash]

Times and to lie about the amount of time.

[Elena]

Yeah, that's shady.

[Ash]

It's shady. So they argued, though, that she had gone to his house to say goodbye and had fully intended to take her own life after that. But the situation escalated, and the two ended up in a physical struggle. The press hung on absolutely every word of every witness, but none were more captivating than Jean herself.

[Elena]

Oh, boy.

[Ash]

Yeah. She proved to be a crucial, if somewhat problematic witness for the defense, on one hand, she was able to adequately explain the stress that she had been under, the multiple stresses at the time, and her state of mind leading up to the shooting. And when she managed to get her version of events out in a way that supported everything she'd claimed.

[Elena]

And which I. You do have to take into account that there's clearly some psychological break.

[Ash]

Yeah.

[Elena]

Chemical imbalance happening here, which obviously does not make it okay.

[Ash]

No.

[Elena]

But it does need to be taken into consideration with like, what her state of mind was here.

[Ash]

I don't necessarily think she had a fully laid out plan for anything that was gonna happen that night. I think she probably thought that she would take her life at some point because she wrote her resignation letter to work and finalized her will.

[Elena]

Yeah, that.

[Ash]

That's telling to me.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

But then on the flip side of that, she came with a loaded gun and extra bullets.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

You only presumably need one bullet if you're gonna kill yourself.

[Elena]

I wonder if this was always gonna be a murder suicide.

[Ash]

Yeah.

[Elena]

And that she just didn't get to the other part.

[Ash]

Yeah, I think that's highly possible.

[Elena]

Either backed out of it or didn't have the time to do it.

[Ash]

Yeah. Because the whole jealousy angle of like, if I can't have you, nobody will and I can't live without you.

[Elena]

To me, this looks like a pretty murder suicide that was watched.

[Ash]

Yeah. Yeah, I think. I think you're very much onto something there. But on the other hand, many observers found Jean to be, quote, sad, humorous and cutting. She had spent so many years. Yeah, humorous is an interesting adjective there. I'm like sad and cutting. Totally.

[Elena]

Yeah. But like humorous.

[Ash]

Okay, that's interesting. But she had spent a lot of years among the wealthiest of society and had adopted a lot of their behavior. She was very cold, very distant on the stand. And her behavior, as she described it, was often difficult for many people to empathize with. Equally challenging was the so called Scarsdale letter which Jean had written to hi. Before driving to New York. Among other things, the letter made Jean look pretty petty and vindictive. Yeah. Which ultimately then supported the prosecution's theory that she killed out of jealousy, unfortunately.

[Elena]

Yeah, it does.

[Ash]

It very much does. Because remember I read an excerpt of that that was. It was pretty ages and pages long.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

Yeah. So when the case finally came to an end in mid February of 1981, the jury was instructed that they were to decide whether Gene was guilty or innocent. And if they decide the former, they could choose between a charge of manslaughter or Second degree murder. According to one of the jurors, Marie Jackson, she said, we never considered the lesser charges. We stuck on the murder charge, and that's all we talked about.

[Elena]

Whoa.

[Ash]

Which you can kind of understand.

[Elena]

Yeah. I mean, it does seem like she came there with a gun.

[Ash]

That's the thing. A loaded gun at that.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

The defense had based their argument largely on the fact that Gene was suffering from mental illness at the time. But the jury actually found that difficult to believe. And remember, this wasn't a time where they would have been like, oh, my God, she's on meth. They would have been like, oh, she's on a prescription that.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

You know, like, we don't know a lot about.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

You know, Jackson told a reporter, we thought some people might have thought that she was crazy when she did it, but there was no psychiatric testimony about that, so we couldn't do it.

[Elena]

Yeah. They should have brought something in.

[Ash]

I know. I don't know why they wouldn't.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

In the end, though, it was a reenactment of the shooting that ultimately brought the jury to you. A unanimous decision. After 48 hours of deliberation, the jury emerged and found Gene Harris guilty of second degree murder. Ultimately, it was her own testimony and, of course, like I just said, the reconstruction of those events that night that swayed them. Juror Marion Stevens said, if her intent was suicide, the actions that took place that night should have worked out.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

Which I agree with.

[Elena]

It doesn't make sense to the jury.

[Ash]

Exactly. It didn't make any sense that Gene would have had multiple opportunities to end her own life. Life. But somehow ended up killing Dr. Turn. Tarnauer Ford after shooting him four times.

[Elena]

Exactly. That's the thing.

[Ash]

It doesn't add up. Another juror said, if she never would have got on the stand, I guess I would have had to reconstruct in my mind what happened. But here I had Gene Harris telling me what did happen.

[Elena]

Oop.

[Ash]

So it's like she kind of sealed her own Faith.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

On March 19, she appeared in court for sentencing, where she was given 15 years to life for the murder of Dr. Herman Tarnauer. And when asked if she had anything to say on her own behalf, she told the judge, I did not murder Dr. Tarnower. I loved him very much. No one in this world feels his loss more than I do. I am not guilty. You and Mr. Bolan, the prosecutor, have arranged my life in such a way that I'll be in a cage for the rest of it, and with irons on My hands every time I get out. That's not justice. It's a travesty of justice.

[Elena]

Whoa. I just mean that's a pretty, I think, heavy statement.

[Ash]

I think if you kill someone, you should go to jail for it.

[Elena]

Yeah. You made a.

[Ash]

For a little while.

[Elena]

Big old mistake, girl.

[Ash]

Despite the anger and bitterness that she felt around her sentencing, she did. Ultimately, she was said to have made the most of her time at the Bedford Hills Correctional Facility. She was there for 12 years. She worked in the parenting center while she was incarcerated, teaching parenting class classes to the inmate mothers and helping them build skills that they would need to get their kids back after they were done with their sentences.

[Elena]

Wow.

[Ash]

And she also worked in and started programs that would help other inmates learn skills to help them find work when they were released, including getting a high school diploma or college degree.

[Elena]

Damn.

[Ash]

And in the meantime, she appealed her sentence and applied for clemency until she was eventually paroled in 1993.

[Elena]

Whoa.

[Ash]

She died of natural causes on December 23rd, 2012, at the age of 89.

[Elena]

Damn.

[Ash]

And that is the story of the murder of Dr. Herman Tarnauer and Gene Harris. Who said murder?

[Elena]

A twisty tourney. Damn.

[Ash]

It's just sad. It's just really, really sad.

[Elena]

It's really sad because I think.

[Ash]

I think she snapped a little bit, but actually, I didn't even think about. I don't know why that didn't occur to me that it was probably a murder suicide.

[Elena]

I. That. That I completely agree was like. That's what it reads to me.

[Ash]

When I first went through this, I. I was like. I think she snapped when she got into the bathroom and Lynn's clothes were there.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

And that's when she killed him. But I think you're right.

[Elena]

She. Yeah.

[Ash]

That could have been her plan all along. That's why she had all those bullets.

[Elena]

Yeah. Because she was like, who knows how long. How many bullets it's gonna take to kill him.

[Ash]

Yeah.

[Elena]

And then I need one leftover.

[Ash]

Yeah.

[Elena]

So it just makes sense. You're not going there to take your own life with a purse full of bullets. No, I just don't.

[Ash]

And a loaded gun.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

Yeah. I think that makes a lot of sense.

[Elena]

I think.

[Ash]

I think you're pretty right there.

[Elena]

Yeah.

[Ash]

It's just really sad.

[Elena]

It's really sad.

[Ash]

And it's like, none of this really ever had to happen if you just moved on from him.

[Elena]

Yeah. You know, like, it was just. And he was.

[Ash]

I think he was somewhat of a womanizer, but I don't Think he deserved that ending?

[Elena]

No, I don't think he deserved to die. I think it's like he. He was doing what he had always done and that's. People had let him do it for a long time.

[Ash]

So she let him.

[Elena]

And then she kind of let him do it as well. Until she didn't.

[Ash]

Yeah.

[Elena]

And yeah, it's really, it's sad. None of that had to happen.

[Ash]

No, literally none of it at all. And it started like, so I know.

[Elena]

Sounded like such a.

[Ash]

Like a great meet cute.

[Elena]

A beautiful love affair. At first I was like, wow, I'm rooting for you two kids.

[Ash]

Yeah. But then it pops off really quick.

[Elena]

Yeah. Crazy.

[Ash]

So that's the story. We got some more stuff coming your way. Some very exciting stuff. Especially this girl over here. Her eyes just lit the up.

[Elena]

Hell yeah.

[Ash]

I think it's already happened. But you know, we told you about it in the beginning.

[Elena]

Yeah. But we'll record right after so you can get the full feeling.

[Ash]

Yeah. And with all of that being said, you guys, we hope you keep listening.

[Elena]

And we hope you keep it weird.

[Ash]

But not so weird that any of this takes place. No, you just gotta, you gotta get out when it's time to go, babe. Yeah.

[Elena]

Get out of there.

[Ash]

Yeah. Hit the road, girl. Hit the road, Gene.

[Elena]

That's right.

[Ash]

Don't you come back.

[Elena]

No. Sa.

[Ash]

If you like morbid, you can listen early and ad free right now by joining Wondery plus in the Wondery app.

[Unknown]

Or on Apple podcasts.

[Ash]

Prime members can listen ad free on Amazon Music. Before you go, tell us about yourself by filling out a short [e-mail] survey.

[Unknown]

Are you captivated by the dark and mysterious world of true crime? Wondery offers you the ultimate true crime experience with early access to new episodes, exclusive content and a seamless ad free listening journey with Onery. Plus, you'll get access to hundreds of podcasts, including more than 50 true crime series. Like Dr. Death, the shocking true story of a trusted surgeon who brought unimaginable pain and suffering to his patients. This was not an operation that was performed.

[Ash]

This was attempted murder.

[Unknown]

And there's Morbid, the hit podcast that's a light hearted nightmare. With Wondery plus, you get access to exclusive bonus content too, allowing you to dive deeper into the cases you love. Like in Suspect, where an ordinary Halloween party turned into a terrifying murder mystery that left its mark on the community.

[Elena]

This case is one of those roller.

[Unknown]

Coaster rides where it's like, no, he did it for sure. No, he for sure he did it. Each story is crafted to keep you enthralled, revealing the complexities and motivations behind every crime. Subscribe to Wondery on the Wondery app, Apple Podcasts, or Spotify. Today, unlock the door to a world of true crime like never before with Wondery. Plus, the best true crime stories are always at your fingertips.