Loading summary
Alayna
Hey, weirdos. Alayna here. If you're looking to kick back and relax with morbid, Wondery is the way to go. It's like having a cozy seat in our haunted mansion. No ads, just you and early access to new episodes. You can join Wondery in the Wondery app or in Apple podcasts or Spotify.
Ash
You're listening to a morbid network podcast. We get support from Amazon Prime. Hey, weirdos, you know what's literally the most amazing thing ever? Amazon Prime. Listen up, because this is gonna bl Blow your minds. With prime, you get faster than lightning delivery on, like, everything. We're talking millions of items. Literally everything you could ever want or need. But wait, there's more. There's more than everything you could want or need. Prime Video lets you binge all those shows we're obsessed with, and Amazon music has all the bops for your next dance party. I have been ordering a little bit on prime lately. I had to get some earplugs the other night because my husband was a snorri. Snore snorin. And I said, please send them to me the very next day. And they did. That was great. Loved that. Whether you're a total book worm, a gaming fanatic, or you just really like trying new things or sleeping through the night without your husband snoring waking you up, Prime's got your back. Ebooks for days, free in game goodies, and everything you need to make your next DIY project from streaming to shopping. It's on Prime. Visit Amazon.com prime to get more out of whatever you're into from the creator of Think Twice, Michael Jackson. Listen to the new Audible original Final thoughts Jerry Springer. Once known as the king of trash tv, Springer was the notorious talk show host whose wild daytime program transfixed audiences everywhere. Join Springer's personal and professional life as the ratings soared and the reviews soured. Here, revealing interviews about the choices we make and the regrets we may have. Listen to the new trashy and true Audible original Final thoughts Jerry Springer by going to audible.com Springer hey, weirdos. I'm Ash.
Alayna
And I'm Alena.
Ash
And this is morbid.
Alayna
This is morbid. More bad. I don't know. We had to run out of. Out of the. We literally just ran out of the house. We had to run out for a minute, and when we came back, Mikey had cleaned the entire studio and lit candles and the vibe in here is.
Ash
Just a zillion times better.
Alayna
So. Right. It was like the greatest thing in the entire world. I feel so relaxed.
Ash
No I feel so much better. I'm ordering Panera as we speak. And it's about to. This vibe today is about to go crazy.
Alayna
It's immaculate.
Ash
Immaculate.
Alayna
I'm also feeling. I'm feeling very much in the slasher summer vibe.
Ash
Me, too.
Alayna
Because I want to live in it.
Ash
I think it's been so, like, gloomy.
Alayna
Yeah.
Ash
And a little bit chilly, which is nice.
Alayna
Oh, yeah.
Ash
And you've been wearing, like. We've all been wearing comfy sweatshirts and. Yeah. We put our yegs in our yeggings and it just feels spooky.
Alayna
Yeah. And I keep getting. I mean, TikTok's always feeding me my. My vibes.
Ash
Halfway to Halloween.
Alayna
The Halfway to Halloween and, like, slasher summer, kind of.
Ash
I'm getting a lot of that. I think because you keep saying it in my presence.
Alayna
It's getting. But I'm not mad. In such a mood for it. Yeah. Like, I need it.
Ash
Yeah.
Alayna
I'm craving it. And now I want to watch all the things, like the summer slasher things. I want to read all the summer slasher things.
Ash
I just watched a pretty good one, actually, at your recommendation for Scream. For Scream, we're going to be recording it today, so it'll be out like a couple of weeks. But it's called Hell of a Summer. It was really good. Yeah. It's a 2025 one, I think. There's a couple movies that are called Hell of a Summer. Brand new, but it just came out in April. It was funny.
Alayna
It was.
Ash
I thought it was fun.
Alayna
It looked fun when I saw it. That's why I haven't watched it yet. But it, like, that's why I suggested it to you. Because when I saw it, I was like, that's got the vibes.
Ash
Yeah.
Alayna
It feels like it's, like, campy, Literally.
Ash
It is campy in. In every sense of the word, campy.
Alayna
Like fun slasher, where you can laugh and also just kind of, like, bop along to it. I love those kind of things. Yeah.
Ash
I suggest it definitely go to Scream and listen to our episode to get our full opinion.
Alayna
Yeah. I'm excited to watch it.
Ash
Let's go, girl.
Alayna
But yeah, I'm trying to think if there's any more fun if you're looking to pre order the Butcher Game in paperback, because paperbacks are great. Who doesn't fucking love a paperback? You know what I mean? You can put that shit anywhere. You can put it in your back pocket.
Ash
I love when you say that. You can put a paperback anywhere. I don't know, it's just a crazy.
Alayna
You can literally put it anywhere.
Ash
But you're not wrong.
Alayna
It's easier sometimes to carry in like a bag or. People love to shove a book in their back pocket.
Ash
Do they?
Alayna
Yeah, I've seen it a lot. Jess Mariano used to do it in Gilmore Girls.
Ash
Big Jess move.
Alayna
I think that really laid the groundwork for me that people do that.
Ash
I think that, I think that imprinted on your soul.
Alayna
I don't think anyone else does.
Ash
I was like, I don't think I've ever seen anyone put a book in their back pocket. And actually I feel like that would make. I feel like that would make you pretty angry.
Alayna
Yeah, I wouldn't.
Ash
I can't even dog ear a page without you dogging on me.
Alayna
Well, I'm also, I'm a hardcover girl, so it's like this. Honestly, I have no business commenting on a paperback conversation.
Ash
But you can comment on your own.
Alayna
But I can give you a paperback that I wrote. There you go. So like, there you go.
Ash
There you go. Take it.
Alayna
And you should definitely pre order it and grab it. You can pre order it anywhere you want to. You feel in your soul that you want to buy a book. Whatever bookstore or book outlet feels right to you and feels lovely to you, do that. I support it. Especially smaller indie bookstores. They're like the best.
Ash
I love a small indie bookstore.
Alayna
And if you need like a list of them, you can go to thebutchergame.com and there's like a little list of. It'll bring you to different places. But yeah, go do that because you really want to catch up on the story. Because who knows why?
Ash
Who knows what's coming down the pike?
Alayna
Who knows why you might want to catch up on this story?
Ash
I don't, I don't know anything.
Alayna
Who can be sure who, you know, knows question mark? I don't know. Maybe, maybe hang on to that information. Maybe, you know, I don't know. But go catch up on it. And a paperback is a great way to do that.
Ash
It's true.
Alayna
So, so let's go girls.
Ash
Let's g o o o o o Bo Boop.
Alayna
So today we're going to be, we're going to do a two parter here.
Ash
Too bad.
Alayna
And it's just because it's like a lot going on. This is a wild one. This is the mad bomber of New York. Okay, it did happen in the 1940s, but like, just because it happened in the 1940s doesn't mean it's not an insane story.
Ash
In fact, it might make it more insane.
Alayna
It might make it. And I think it does. This is a very interesting one. Any New Yorkers, I wonder if you guys, like, know about this, have heard about it, maybe family members told you about it. It's seems like New York was really put through it during this.
Ash
Oh, man.
Alayna
So this started, it was in the fall of 1940, when an employee of the Consolidated Edison Company in Manhattan discovered a bomb in the company's main offices. Shit. Along with a note that said, con Edison Crooks. This is for you.
Ash
Oh, damn.
Alayna
The bomb was discovered before it detonated and no one was harmed. That's good. But a year later, the company received a second bomb, followed by a note to the NYPD where the bomber announced that he was going to make no more bombs for the duration of World War II. But then he would begin again after the war ended.
Ash
So this motherfucker's playing a long game.
Alayna
Oh, yeah. Playing. You don't call him the Mad Bomber for nothing. No, the Mad Bombers. It was literally a reign of terror on New York. It lasted for a long time. Remember, this is the fall of 1940. He was not. He ends up being captured, luckily. So don't worry, New York, good news. But he was captured in 1957.
Ash
Oh, wow.
Alayna
It was a lot. And when they finally got him, him as a person and his motives didn't make a lot of sense to New York.
Ash
It's always interesting when that happens.
Alayna
Yeah. They lived in fear of what was going on here. So in the early afternoon of November 18, 1940, the desk sergeant at the 20th Squad of the NYPD received a call from a very anxious employee of. Like we mentioned before, the Consolidated Edison Company. Con Ed, we'll call it.
Ash
Oh, no.
Alayna
On West 64th Street. According to the caller, one of the Con Ed employees was on a break when he noticed a little, you know, wooden toolbox just sitting unattended on a window ledge on the second floor. I'm glad he thought this was a little weird, because if he had just ignored it, it would have been a big problem.
Ash
Can you imagine finding a fucking bomb on your. No, you're just on lunch.
Alayna
You're just on lunch and you're just.
Ash
Trying to get away from everybody.
Alayna
Yeah, you're just trying to take a minute away from your fucking job, and.
Ash
Then you have a bomb on your.
Alayna
Floor and you're like, now I have to report a bomb.
Ash
That's a lot.
Alayna
I just wanted to have my egg salad sandwich, you know?
Ash
That sounds good.
Alayna
It does so when the man approached the toolbox, he saw that it contained a four and a half piece of iron pipe which was capped in both ends, which, like, immediately not good. And when he looked closer at it, he found a small piece of paper wrapped around it. So this person unwrapped the paper. Damn.
Ash
Which is brave as fuck. Pretty brave and like, ballsy.
Alayna
Don't do that. Yeah, like don't do that.
Ash
If ever you find a strange looking.
Alayna
Thing, don't touch it. Just put a box and found a. On that piece of paper, he found that it was a note written in neat block print that read, con Edison Crooks. This is for you. A second line of text underneath was written in a coarse gray substance apparently. And it read, there is no shortage of powder boys. And the note was simply signed fp.
Ash
So was he saying powder boys or was he saying boys? There's no shortage of powder.
Alayna
I think powder boys. Powder boys. So I think he's calling these bombs maybe powder boys. Oh, it's like a pipe bomb. Gotcha, gotcha, gotcha, gotcha. The implications of the note obviously sent the employee into a full panic. He carefully set the toolbox down on the windowsill because remember, this man is now holding this pipe bomb.
Ash
Fuck.
Alayna
And he ran it. Luckily it didn't detonate and he ran to the phone and called the police. Later, when the note was tested, it was discovered that the second line of text was written in gunpowder.
Ash
Oh.
Alayna
Which was the same substance that was packed into the pipe. Hate that. Powder boys. At the time, though, the NYPD officers who responded to the call had no idea what they were actually dealing with here. Although bombings or threats of bombings had kind of increased across the city throughout the first half of the 20th century. Just with, like, advancement of people knowing how to make these things. Yeah, those matters were handled by the bomb and forgery squad. Obviously there's like a specialized thing. So it's like when you have a group that's specially trained to do this stuff, the regular patrol officers are like, I don't really know what to do with this bomb.
Ash
Yeah, call in the special guys.
Alayna
Yeah, they had. So when they were called in, they had to report this explosive device to that specialized squad. And they had to wait hours for the bomb and forgery squad to arrive. Which I'm like, I feel like that.
Ash
Squad should be a bit more prompt.
Alayna
That's the thing. That's how I feel. I feel like they should be. Maybe those, like, you gotta have one foot out the door at all times.
Ash
Kind of squad like you're an emergency responder. Pretty much so.
Alayna
And you're very. I feel like timeliness is next to godliness in that scenario.
Ash
When it comes to bombs, I'd say.
Alayna
When it comes to two bombs, you know, because, like, I. You don't know when that's gonna go off.
Ash
You don't.
Alayna
So, like, waiting.
Ash
You want to get there before it does.
Alayna
Yeah. So waiting hours feels risky. Hours.
Ash
I'd be pissed if it took them, like, 25 minutes. I'd be hours.
Alayna
Yeah. I'd be pissed that just the regular patrol officer showed up. I'd be like, I did say this is a bomb.
Ash
Well, it's like, obviously you can evacuate, and, like, hopefully they did.
Alayna
Yeah.
Ash
But then you also have a whole building on your hands.
Alayna
Exactly.
Ash
And then that if that does explode and the building falls down, you got a whole mess to cle up.
Alayna
And people could get. People could get hurt.
Ash
Like, so many things could happen.
C
We all want to be the best version of ourselves. And, of course, fitness is a key component of that. The folks at Anytime Fitness, well, they see all you strivers out there striving, and they have the expertise to help you optimize your efforts inside the gym and out. If you are actively pursuing your goal to be fit and strong, not just for bigger muscles, but for a bigger, better life, Anytime Fitness has everything you need to do just that. They have all the equipment you need, plus easy anytime access to more than 5000 global locations. Anytime Fitness helps you train to be a stronger, more confident, more badass version of yourself. With expert coaching to help you optimize your personalized training, nutrition, and recovery plan. Get started today@anytime fitness.com that's anytime fitness.com looking to refresh the style in your home? Here at Mathis Home, we can help you find exactly what you need during our spring style event. Whether you're looking for a rustic farmhouse classic or modern and eclectic, we have all the latest looks that will leave your home feeling brand new. Whatever your style, we can help you find it at the lowest price, because not only do we want you to feel good in your home, we know that to earn your business, our prices have to be the best. So come to the spring style event at your furniture superstore, Mathis Holm.
Alayna
So when they did finally arrive at the Con Ed building, the lead detective on the bomb squad confirmed that what they found was indeed a, quote, infernal machine, which was a homemade explosive device, quote, maliciously designed to explode and destroy life or property.
Ash
But it still hadn't gone off yet.
Alayna
It still hadn't gone off. Now, unlike more sophisticated devices that, you know, use electronic components, a bomb that you're probably thinking in your head right now with the wires and shit, the Infernal Machine, which is one of the scariest names for something great band name. I literally was just going to say there has to be.
Ash
I'm gonna Google it.
Alayna
Infernal Machine. Has to be a pantheon. Yeah. It is a very crude, very volatile explosive that could be triggered by a number of things. Like this is not an electronic explosive. So it's not like somebody's just waiting or they, you know, set it to go off at a certain point. It's like it gets triggered by random things.
Ash
It's a band.
Alayna
I knew it had to be.
Ash
Yeah, it's a band.
Alayna
Good on you for making that. Cause that's a great banding.
Ash
Yeah, absolutely.
Alayna
Also, the pipe bomb couldn't be deactivated in like a traditional sense, like a regular bomb, but instead it had to be just detonated in a controlled setting. Like they just had to explode the bomb in a controlled area.
Ash
The.
Alayna
Because in like a regular bomb there's a way to detonate it or to like deactivate it with like electronically and shit.
Ash
Yeah, yeah.
Alayna
This one's just like a very crude fucking infernal machine.
Ash
So where do you go?
Alayna
So I don't really know. I think they have to. They go to like clearings to do these things because sometimes it still has to be done. Like they have to find places to do these things even now. So they really have to go to like places obviously where there's absolutely no chance that somebody could be hurt by this. Damn. The squad knew that the bomb had already been handled by the employee who had reported it. So they knew it wasn't triggered by, you know, moving it from its position. And after clearing the building, one of the squad members donned a suit of body armor and used a five foot grabbing pole. And he turned the device over, looking for any kind of timing device or other potential triggers.
Ash
That's so scary.
Alayna
Yeah. He didn't find anything. And getting no result from poking at it and, you know, handling the device. They were fairly certain it was not triggered by movement. And the pipe was retrieved, placed inside a bag. The bag was made of woven steel cable because that like, that's how they transport bombs.
Ash
Yeah.
Alayna
And it was taken out to the containment truck and taken to a secluded area where it was inspected and ultimately submerged in motor oil.
Ash
Why?
Alayna
Apparently, and this is very interesting, motor oil was believed to clog up any moving parts that might trigger the device.
Ash
Oh.
Alayna
Which I'm like, how did you guys figure that out?
Ash
Yeah, that's interesting.
Alayna
Was the test that made that. That a thing?
Ash
I mean, it is very thick, so I guess that makes sense.
Alayna
Viscous it is. So once they were confident that the bomb was a dud, investigators transported it back to headquarters for analysis. Now, inside the pipe, technicians found a large amount of gunpowder and several typical bomb components, including a flashlight bulb, a battery, and a steel spring, as well as a cough drop.
Ash
What?
Alayna
Which no one could explain why that cough drop was there, used or unused. I don't know if that was right. I don't know if they could tell if that was a used cough drop or not, but, yeah.
Ash
What?
Alayna
A cough drop. Why? No one knows to this day.
Ash
That's bizarre.
Alayna
Despite having all the right parts and a cough drop to boot, it was clear it was getting a little bit of something extra. Extra.
Ash
Just a little spice. Maybe they wanted it to, like, smell good.
Alayna
Yeah, I guess. I don't know. I have no idea. But despite having all the right parts, it was clear to experts that the bomb had been incorrectly assembled by a very amateur person and was never in danger of exploding at all.
Ash
Well, that's good news.
Alayna
Yeah. But while there may have not been any imminent danger, the threat was very real. And investigators needed to identify the maker of the device before he improved on his technique.
Ash
I was gonna say before he got better.
Alayna
Yeah. And struck again. Yeah, because if they do it once, of course they could do it again.
Ash
Well, especially if he knows it didn't go off.
Alayna
Yeah. Now he's gonna be pissed. Now, in 1940, Consolidated Edison was one of the largest employers in Manhattan with thousands of employees, many of whom worked in the building where the bomb was found. Also, as the primary supplier of electricity for the whole region, the company served millions of customers. That's basically. It was clear that whoever left the bomb had clearly a grudge with this company. But that fact alone didn't narrow the pool of suspects down at all. Because, remember, we got thousands of employees and millions of customers.
Ash
Yeah.
Alayna
Now, further complicating the whole thing was the fact that Con Ed was a conglomerate of several smaller companies operating under, like, one umbrella, all operating in different parts of the city. Okay, that means that even if police did want to take the time to comb through all their administrative records, it could have been literally years before they found anything that could help them if they found anything at all.
Ash
Right?
Alayna
So because of that, the incident report was written up and Filed, and no one really gave it a thought.
Ash
The bomb incident report.
Alayna
Yeah, they were just like, well, that happened now. In late September, 1941, nearly a year after this first bomb was discovered at the Con Ed building, passerbys noticed something strange lying in the road a few blocks away from the Con ed building at 4 Irving Place. It was stuffed inside a red wool sock with a 4 inch length of pipe with both ends capped.
Ash
Okay.
Alayna
Just as they'd done before, police officers called the bomb squad and the device was removed and determined to be a dud.
Ash
Damn, this guy sucks.
Alayna
Then it was taken back to headquarters for analysis. There was no note with this one. But to the members of the bomb squad, the device was immediately recognizable as being the work of whoever had left the bomb at Con Ed the previous year.
Ash
Was there another cough drop inside?
Alayna
They found the same ingredients as the previous bomb, all assembled in the same way. And another cough drop.
Ash
Called it.
Alayna
Cough drop.
Ash
What?
Alayna
Cough drop? Number two.
Ash
Does he ever say why.
Alayna
We'Re at a loss?
Ash
God damn.
Alayna
Now, given that the bomb was assembled the same exact way as the previous one, including the weird fucking cough drop.
Ash
I was gonna say random ingredients and.
Alayna
All, like, that's the thing that's really nailing it. And then it was discovered around the corner of the Con Ed building. Investigators were like, yeah, this is the same guy. Equally disturbing was the fact that a year had passed and the bombers still appeared intent on bombing the Con Ed building. That's commitment.
Ash
Yeah.
Alayna
This time, though, they theorized that he had been on his way to the building and was interrupted or maybe diverted and chose to drop the explosive in the street and abandoned his plan.
Ash
Okay.
Alayna
Within days of finding the explosive in the street, letters started arriving at the Con Ed headquarters as well as newspaper editorial desks, hotels and department stores around the city. The letters were pretty short, pretty vague, mostly alluding to, you know, quote, dastardly deeds and ghoulish acts that the power. Power company had committed and demanding, quote, justice for wrongs perpetrated against the writer of the notes and others. These notes were mostly hand printed in that same, like, very blocky handwriting. But that. Some were typewritten, though, like there was. It wasn't consistent throughout.
Ash
Okay.
Alayna
And the clauses were all separated by dashes rather than commas or periods.
Ash
Okay.
Alayna
All the notes were written on the same plain white paper. There was no identifying information about the sender other than the initials F.P. and many contained allusions to or outright threats of another bomb coming a few months later on December 7, 1941, the Japanese attacked the Pearl Harbor Military Base in Honolulu, Hawaii. I'm sure we all know about that.
Ash
That's where I was born.
Alayna
This effectively drew the American military into World War II. Not long after that attack on Pearl harbor, the usual round of recipients of FP letters received a new note. Although the latest letter included the usual vague threats and, you know, claims of injustice, the sender also seemed to understand that with the entire country preoccupied with the nation's, you know, now forceful entry into a world war, there was very little chance that he was going to get the kind of attention that he was so craving here. So he was like, you know what? I'm going to let somebody else have their moment right now. He said, I will make no more bomb units for the duration of the war. My patriotic feelings have made me decide this later. I will bring the Khan Ed to justice. They will pay for their dastardly deeds.
Ash
Like that doesn't feel very patriotic.
Alayna
Yeah, that feels pretty rough.
Ash
It's killing your fellow man.
Alayna
To everyone's surprise, though, he remained true to his word. And there were no other bombs or letters from FP in the years that followed.
Ash
Interesting.
Alayna
The war raged on across Europe and the nation's attention was. Obviously, he was right. They were consumed by fighting.
Ash
Yeah.
Alayna
And New York forgot kind of all about FP and his grudge against, you know, the whole Con Ed building and employees and company as a whole. But fp, he was not giving up on this mission.
Ash
He was lurking.
Alayna
Yeah. And he did not have any intention of being forgotten. Just before 5:30pm on the afternoon of March 29, 1951, the peak of rush hour at Grand Central Central Station, an explosive device detonated.
Ash
Oh, no.
Alayna
In a cigarette urn placed outside the entrance to the Grand Central Oyster Bar. It sent sand, cigarette butts and other debris floors flying in all directions. Oh. Despite being placed on one of the lower levels by track 27, there were no passerbys when the bomb went off. Wow.
Ash
That's.
Alayna
No one was hit.
Ash
That's amazing.
Alayna
Inside this pipe bomb, he had packed nuts and bolts in there, too. Oh, wow. Which is what, like, some of these fuckers do. Like, the Boston bombing is one of the ones that obviously sticks out very much sticks out to us. They put all this like, fucking horrific shrapnel in it to get the most damage.
Ash
Yeah.
Alayna
So since the bomb had already detonated by the time the police came to Grand Central Station, there was no need for the bomb squad. But investigators still had little evidence to work with and initially attributed the incident to boys or pranksters, y' all. I'm sorry. I know tight bomb is not pranksters.
Ash
Yeah, I was. I don't know about all that.
Alayna
Yeah. The remains of the device were turned over to the bomb squad for analysis. But nearly a decade had passed since the bombs were discovered. Discovered at the Con Ed building at this point. And this time, no one recognized the pipes and their various components because it had kind of gone out of everyone's minds. Even if someone had recalled the bomb discoveries back in 1941, it's unlikely they would have made, you know, the connection here. Because this latest bomb, one, it went off, Right? So that's different from the other two. It also contained no gunpowder, but instead contained just one.25 caliber round that was rigged to a mechanism that would discharge at a predetermined time and it would send the shrapnel out in all directions. So he has obviously upped his game.
Ash
Right? It is remarkable that nobody was walking by. Yes, especially like you said, like peak traffic time at Grand Central.
Alayna
It's amazing. Right next to track 27. I can't believe that nobody was hit. Veterans on the bomb squad, however, would likely have recognized one thing.
Ash
A cough drop.
Alayna
One cough drop contained in the pipe.
Ash
I just googled it and I couldn't find anything about why he did that. Why?
Alayna
No one knows why. But by that time, it had been disintegrated with the rest of the internal components, so they wouldn't have been able to see it anyways.
Ash
Oh, yeah. Why are there ridges on Reese's peanut butter cups? Probably so they never slip from her hands. Could you imagine? I'd lose it.
Alayna
Luckily, Reese has thought about that.
Ash
Wonder what else they think about. Probably chocolate and peanut butter.
Alayna
Last year, Law and crime brought you the trial that captivated the nation. She's accused of hitting her boyfriend, Boston police officer John o' Keefe, with her car.
D
Karen Reed is arrested and charged with second degree murder.
Alayna
The six week trial resulted in anything but resolution.
Ash
We continue to find ourselves at an impasse.
Alayna
I'm declaring a mistrial in this case. But now the case is back in the spotlight, and one question still lingers. Did Karen Reed kill John o' Keefe.
Ash
The evidence is overwhelming that Karen Reid is innocent.
Alayna
How does it feel to be a cop killer, Karen? I'm Kristen Thorne, investigative reporter with Law and Crime and host of the podcast Karen the Retrial. This isn't just a retrial. It's a second chance at the truth. I have nothing to hide. My life is in the balance, and it shouldn't be.
C
I just want people to go back to who the victim is in this.
Ash
It's not her.
Alayna
Listen to episodes of Karen the Retrial exclusively and ad free on Wondery. But we know that it was there because we know it's the same guy.
Ash
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Alayna
So the bomb at Grand Central failed to achieve much notice by the police or the press because they were kind of chalking it up to like. Which I'm like, what kind of fucking team?
Ash
For real.
Alayna
And the second bomb that detonated after this one, because there was another one, didn't receive a lot of attention either. It detonated inside a phone booth in the basement of the New York Public Library.
Ash
I would call that a big deal.
Alayna
Yeah. Like the one at Grand Central Station. The second bomb caused no injuries, luckily. That's good. And barely registered with anyone earning a few paragraphs. Pretty deep in the pages of the New York Times that day.
Ash
But wouldn't everybody be like, hey, it.
Alayna
Seems like, why are the two bombings.
Ash
Like, could be related?
Alayna
But still, this time the bombings were different. They didn't cause much damage or harm to anyone. But that was only because no one had been unfortunate enough to be around when they went off. If they were, it would cause massive damage. Had anyone been near either when they detonated, they would have. I don't think they would have survived. I really don't. It would. It would be very lethal. That meant that although the police didn't know it at the time, FP had become, like, we were just talking about, more skilled and sophisticated as a bomb maker. In the decades since he had started doing this, which makes sense.
Ash
He's obviously been studying how to do this for years, which, like, why the.
Alayna
Is he still doing this? And in August, FP struck again with another bomb at Grand Central Station. A little past 9pm on the night of August 27, a bomb went off in a phone booth on the west concourse. Like the earlier bombs, this one caused some damage, but no injuries.
Ash
I know this is remarkable.
Alayna
It is remarkable. The Grand Central bomb was followed a few weeks later by another bomb, this one placed in a phone booth in the lobby of the Con ed offices.
Ash
At 4 Irving Place, if that doesn't raise some eyebrows.
Alayna
Yeah, the bomb exploded and caused some damage to the lobby, but because it was detonated at 6:15am the only person in the building was a night watchman, and he wasn't in the lobby when it went off. So it's missing like any. It's like, really remarkable because it's not.
Ash
Like he's Doing that on purpose. Like, you were the first one when he came back again was high traffic time. He's putting them in phone booths. Like. Yeah, it's not like he's going out of his way to. Yeah, that's the thing. He's also putting shrapnel in them. So obviously he does want to keep damage.
Alayna
And like you said, he's putting them in places where people would be. Yeah, they just happen to not be there. It's, like, really wild. So. Yeah. In fact, the damage had been so minimal and mostly confined to the phone booth, the night watchman didn't even bother to call the police right away and waited several hours before even reporting it.
Ash
Okay, that's a bad plan, because there could be more.
Alayna
Yeah, that's wild.
Ash
Where there's one bomb, as we find out, there's many.
Alayna
So the bombs all were pretty similar in their construction. So one investigator or a few investigators were believing that they probably were constructed and placed by the same individual. But because the bombs at Grand Central, the public library, and Con Ed appeared to have been detonated at the. At a time when they were like. Because that's the thing. It's like he put them in places where people would be, but he detonates them at times where people won't be there or not a lot of people will be there. Like 6:15am but what about the high traffic one? That's the one. It's like that one, you know, that stands out. Yeah, that one stands out. But a few of the other ones, it almost looked like they were almost put to cause because there's, like, conflicting ideas here. Because it's like there's shrapnel in them. It looks like there's clearly a. They're wanting to hurt someone. But then the times that a lot of them are placed or detonated, I should say, are interesting.
Ash
Okay.
Alayna
You know?
Ash
Yeah.
Alayna
Because it's. It is crazy that they're not getting anyone.
Ash
Right.
Alayna
Like, they're not hurting anyone.
Ash
Right.
Alayna
Investigators assumed because of this that maybe it was like a prank and they were detonating it on purpose when people wouldn't be there to cause damage and, like, chaos, but not hurt anyone.
Ash
Okay.
Alayna
So they were so convinced that the bombs were the work of an adult prankster that they were reluctant to provide any details to the press, saying it would just build up the ego of the nut who did it.
Ash
Okay. I guess I.
Alayna
Which, like, sort of get that. I can kind of see where they're coming from. And again, this is like the 1950s. So, like, you know, yeah, a little different. Regardless of what they told the press in private, investigators on the bomb squad were at least somewhat concerned of the bombs. Like, investigators are kind of like they're at odds a little bit of what this actually is. In each case, the bombs did get slightly larger and more sophisticated. So again, this is kind of showing or suggesting that, like, the bomber who is doing this is really learning as he goes and he's like keeping up with his, you know, of trying to figure out how to do this better and better, and he's getting better at it. And in the report on the second bomb at Grand Central Station, the technician wrote, quote, this is a well constructed mechanism. It shows considerable advance in technique as compared with the earlier bombs. Also, because the bombs were clearly created in place by the same person, it was impossible for the bomb squad to ignore the reality that they were dealing with a serial bomber. And it was only a matter of time before someone was going to get hurt. Regardless of whether that's the intention or not, it's gonna happen just the way that this all.
Ash
Yeah, like, works.
Alayna
A month later, on October 22, the bomber struck again, this time in a bathroom at the Paramount Theater. Fortunately, the bomb was discovered before it was detonated. Oh, that's good. And the bomb squad was able to disassemble it without much trouble.
Ash
But that right there, that there was intense.
Alayna
It feels like there was an. Well, once you realize who he is, you're like, okay. Like the other devices, the bomb was constructed with a roughly 4 inch long pipe containing a.25 caliber shell. With that mechanism, small amount of gunpowder. At the time, roughly 3,500 patrons were in the theater one floor above watching a show. Wow. So this would have caused massive casualties or at least massive damage. Yeah. And so that one was like, oh, shit. So just as police were investigating the scene at the Paramount, the editor of the New York Herald Tribune received a letter by special delivery. Inside was a letter written in block lettering that said, bombs will continue until the Consolidated Edison Company is brought to justice for their dastardly acts against me. I have exhausted all other means. I intend with bombs to cause others to cry out for justice for me.
Ash
But you're not telling anybody what happened.
Alayna
You're not telling anyone what happened. You're gonna hurt someone, so no one's gonna see you. And now you want these people that you're trying to harm or inconvenience at the very least, to cry out for you. That's what I mean.
Ash
Your thinking is a little scattered.
Alayna
Motive isn't making a lot of sense. The note confirmed that FP had planted the bomb at the Paramount, but it also made reference to a second bomb in a telephone booth at Penn Station. Oh, shit. It said, if I don't get justice, I will continue, but with bigger bombs.
Ash
Okay.
Alayna
Police spent hours searching Penn Station, but found no sign of a bomb anywhere on the premises and eventually abandoned the search in the early morning hours. While they may not have discovered a second bomb, the bomber had made their intentions and motivation pretty clear in the letter, which was published in the Herald Tribune the next day. With the publication of the letter, the NYPD had to end that whole theory of, like, maybe there's just pranksters and we don't want to feed their ego. Like, they had to end that whole thing, the series, the city clearly had a serial bomber on their hands, and he was clear that he intended to continue this reign of terror until he got what he wanted, which no one really knows how to give him that.
Ash
Because nobody knows what happened.
Alayna
Like, I want them held. I want justice for their dastardly deeds against me.
Ash
Which were what?
Alayna
And you're like, cool, cool, cool. Can you tell us what those were so we can bring them to justice for it?
Ash
Name them.
Alayna
Name them.
Ash
Name them.
Alayna
Name them. So the letter made clear at least that the bomber had some connection to Con Ed. But again, who the fuck are you, right? Like, it didn't help to identify the sender. If anything, police found themselves right back to where they were a decade earlier, with a suspect list of millions of employees, former employees and customers. In the absence of facts, evidence, anything concrete that they could use, wild theories started to emerge, including the suggestion that the bomber was operating on a lunar calendar, which led the NYPD to increase manpower during the full moon.
Ash
They said, it's witches.
Alayna
They said, it's werewolf.
Ash
They said, them. Them witches be out here. Them werewolves are who in Holland.
Alayna
They said, oh, that's just Jacob Black. Don't worry about that.
Ash
They said, bella, where you been, loca?
Alayna
They said, bella, where the hell you been, loca? That is one of the most diabolical lines in literary history.
Ash
Or is it the most genius?
Alayna
I said diabolical. I didn't say bad. I just said diabolical. Also, there's just quick little side, because we are who we are. And that reminded me of it. If you're looking for a really funny TikTok to watch, let me bring it up.
Ash
Have you touched it?
Alayna
No, I haven't. And I meant to tell you about.
Ash
You're telling the masses before you tell.
Alayna
Your sister, you should all follow this person because she is very, very funny. And what she's doing is she does recreations of what it's like to be in the boardroom during the making of all the Twilight movies.
Ash
Oh, my God, that's iconic.
Alayna
Her name is Ellie Collins following right now, and it's her, like, thing on TikTok is E L L I E Collins. Like C O L L I N with four S's. She is so fucking funny. And all the things that they go through with those movies, you will just sit there and be like, what the fuck were we doing?
Ash
I just followed her.
Alayna
I love it. I love it so much. So go check her out. She's really funny. She also did a whole series of all of Taylor Swift's exes listening to her new songs as they came out.
Ash
Oh, I think come up on my for you page before she did. Look familiar?
Alayna
She's real funny. Yeah, but. Yeah. So, Bella, where the hell you been, loca?
Ash
Where the hell?
D
Hey, weirdos. If Ash and Elena's episode on Ken McElroy left you wondering how someone could become so cruel, manipulative, and untouchable, you'll want to hear my psychological breakdown of this case. On my podcast, Killer Psyche, I examined the twisted mindset behind McElroy's reign of terror. How he exploited fear, used charm as a weapon, and turned an entire town into his victims. Understanding what made him tick is exactly the kind of insight I bring on Killer Psyche, where I use my experience profiling criminals for the FBI to uncover what drives people like Ken McElroy to become predators. So if you're curious about the mind behind the mayhem, join me for an inside look at the psychology of a man who got away with everything until he didn't. Follow Killer Psyche on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts.
Alayna
So. Well, they. So they. They put more people on. On the full moon because you got to try everything, you know, you should.
Ash
Just have more people on the full moon all the time. It'd just be crazy.
Alayna
People be wild in them.
Ash
We're a huge percent water.
Alayna
It's true. There you go. We're a huge percent.
Ash
We're a huge percent water. It'S like 86 or something. I don't know.
Alayna
It's pretty impressive.
Ash
It's huge.
Alayna
It's pretty impressive how water we are.
Ash
You know, we do be a lot of water.
Alayna
Are we the ocean? I don't know. So the tides are within. While they. While they seemed willing to entertain any theory at this point, regardless of how serious it seemed, investigators in the NYPD and on the bomb squad knew the type of panic that a serial bomber would. Was going to instill in the public.
Ash
Yeah.
Alayna
And they just wanted to stop him because now people are. It's going to be hard for people to live their lives normally here, especially.
Ash
In New York City.
Alayna
And they didn't care what the method was. They just wanted to stop this guy.
Ash
That's not great.
Alayna
In early November, police arrested 56 year old former Con Ed employee Frederick Eberhardt in connection with a hoax bomb that was sent to Con Ed a few weeks earlier.
Ash
Okay.
Alayna
Based on his employee file, Frederick fit the profile of the man investigators were looking for. The district attorney told reporters he had been sending simulated bombs around the city the past few months.
Ash
Rude.
Alayna
Yeah. During his arraignment on November 7, the prosecution alleged that Frederick had sent a package to Edwin Jennings, the head of personnel at ConEd, which contained what Jennings believed was another pipe bomb. But when they inspected it, the pipe contained nothing more than white sugar. Oh. According to company records, Frederick was fired by con ed in 1948 for, quote, stealing material and was tried and ultimately acquitted. Following his acquittal, Frederick sued con ed for $75,000 in damages, alleging false arrest. And the case was still pending trial at the time. Despite him being a very strong suspect, his wife loudly protested his arrest and was very against him being admitted to Bellevue for evaluation, saying, quote, this arrest is an outrage. He never sent those things. He couldn't hurt a fly.
Ash
Oh.
Alayna
If the NYPD hoped Frederick's arrest would put an end to the bomb threats of the recent months, they were very disappointed very quickly.
Ash
So were they scapegoating him a bit?
Alayna
Just a few days after Frederick's arrest was announced in the papers, the bomb squad received an anonymous call reporting that bombs had been planted at the Capitol Theater on Broadway and a Roman Catholic church on East 28th Street.
Ash
Oh, no.
Alayna
While the bomb squad found no bombs in either location, later that evening, a pipe bomb was detonated at the IRT subway station in Union Square, sending shrapnel through a row of metal lockers. Once again, no one was hurt.
Ash
This is bizarre, isn't it?
Alayna
Bizarre.
Ash
It's incredible.
Alayna
Wonderfully bizarre that no one's getting hurt here. But like, bizarre.
Ash
Yeah. Wild.
Alayna
And fp. He wasted no time claiming credit. Sending a letter to the editor of the Herald Tribune, he said to Herald Tribune editors, have you noticed the bombs in your city? If you are worried, I am sorry. And also, if anyone is injured, but it cannot be helped, for justice will be served. I am not well. And for this, I will make the Con Edison sorry. Yes, they will regret their dastardly deeds. I will bring them before the bar of justice. Public opinion will condemn them for. Beware. I will place more units under theater seats in the near future. Oh. It was clear from the recent bombings that Frederick Eberhard was not the bomber. And on May 15, 1952, a court dismissed the charges against him, which forced the NYPD to admit that there was still very much a serial bomber loose somewhere in the city. So the bomber struck three times in 1952. Once in a phone booth at the Port Authority Bus Terminal and twice at the Lexington Theater. At the Lexington Theater, it was bombs left under random seats. It was in the second bombing at the Lexington on December 8, that someone was finally injured.
Ash
Oh, no.
Alayna
A woman sitting in the same row where the bombs were placed during a showing of Everything I Have Is Yours was struck by flying shards of metal shrapnel, and it caused several lacerations on her feet and legs. Oh, but she did live.
Ash
That's good.
Alayna
But, like, what a horrible thing to happen.
Ash
You're just sitting in a movie theater.
Alayna
Yeah. During this period, the NYPD and the investigators on the bomb squad were releasing little, if any, information to the public about the bombings. So.
Ash
Which is like, maybe they should have and maybe people wouldn't have gone to the movies.
Alayna
Exactly. So the details of the bombings between 1952 and 1954 are kind of limited.
Ash
Okay.
Alayna
On March 10, 1953, smack dab in the middle, a bomb was planted in one of the seat cushions in the 6,000 seat Radio City Music Hall.
Ash
Oh, shit.
Alayna
Ever heard of it?
Ash
Yeah, Paige and Hannah sold that shit out. Bitch.
Alayna
Yeah, the same one. The spectators were about halfway through the movie when the bomb went off.
Ash
Oh, my.
Alayna
Causing panic and chaos among this very large crowd. At the request of the nypd, the incident was minimized by the press the following day, with several papers ignoring it altogether. Radio City Musical.
Ash
The fuck? How do you ignore that?
Alayna
The Herald Tribune, who had received many of the bomber's letters, referred to the bomb as, quote, the work of a psychopath.
Ash
Fair.
Alayna
While others used, like, very dismissive language to kind of minimize the danger.
Ash
I would say that was pretty fucking dangerous.
Alayna
A few months later, when a bomb exploded in a luggage locker at Grand Central Station in early May, a police spokesperson was similarly dismissive, telling the press, quote, the culprit was a mental case in search of publicity.
Ash
It's like, yeah, but bombs Keep going off in various locations. So maybe we should do something and find that person.
Alayna
It's like, my friends, I'm not here debating what's happening in his noggin.
Ash
Yeah.
Alayna
I'm here saying that, like, he's setting off bombs around the city. So, like, maybe just stop that.
Ash
Right.
Alayna
Instead of just being like, oh, it's just a nut.
Ash
It's just cray cray.
Alayna
Yeah. He's a fucking brilliant nut who's making scary, dangerous bombs that have hurt at least one person.
Ash
Right. And it's shocking that they haven't hurt anybody else.
Alayna
The minimal press coverage was an offense to the bomber, too. And it's like, they should have thought of that, that this guy is looking for attention. Clearly. And I know that. It's like, it's a hard line to walk. That's the thing. It's kind of like, you know, Zodiac and, you know, Jack the Ripper. It's like, when they're looking for the attention, you don't want to give it to them, but you also don't want to set it off anymore. So it's like. Like, I can't say that I would know how to handle this, you know, as, like, an investigator and what to.
Ash
Tell the press and especially, again, during this time period.
Alayna
Exactly.
Ash
This is a very new type of mind they're dealing with.
Alayna
Exactly. And he. So he started sending outraged letters to the editorial departments of the city's major papers.
Ash
That's scary.
Alayna
In a letter to the editor and staff of New York Herald Tribune. Unless sloppy or no reporting is corrected about bombings, public will get information by way of Moscow. Get this into your heads. The Consolidated Edison Company will be brought to justice. All of my physical, mental, and financial sufferings will be paid for in full. You know that bombs are getting bigger. So far, the hand of God has spared everyone from death or serious injury. Believe me, I know. In the press now and then, I am called a bad name. Just what name fits you? People who denied me the purchase of space to tell my story. You, who are too yellow to print the facts which concern the safety of so many. I'm bewildered by your attitude. I can only respond with more and larger bombs. Every day that passes means a day closer to another bomb.
Ash
Yikes. He's scary.
Alayna
It's very scary. And upping the ante and, again is not telling anyone what the fuck happened and how they can fix it. Yeah. And he's literally saying, like, the hand of God has spared people from not getting hurt.
Ash
That wasn't my intention. Right.
Alayna
Which like he was kind of alluding not to that before, but now he's just being like, oh, that's just happenstance. Yeah. Which is scary.
Ash
And it almost sounds like he, like he went to them and tried to get his story about what happened at, at the con place out and they said no.
Alayna
Yeah. Which is like strange because I'm like.
Ash
What the fuck do we find out.
Alayna
What happened to him? We find out. So we'll find out more in part two. We're actually going to stop there because if there's going to be butt head after that letter to the New York Tribune there, the Herald Tribune, it's another year that passes without any new bombs.
Ash
Interesting.
Alayna
Yeah. And then it does return.
Ash
Oh no.
Alayna
So we're going to talk about that in part two. All right. Yeah.
Ash
This is an interesting case. I haven't heard anything about this one before.
Alayna
Yeah, this is a very, very interest strange. And yeah, it's so strange. Like, and it's like it almost seems like the plot of a movie instead of like a real thing that happened. But I, I really am curious if like any of you are from New York or like you know have, are like native New Yorkers who have like family that were around at this time. I'd be curious to hear if they, they'll tell you like what it was like.
Ash
Yeah, yeah.
Alayna
To be around because it's like like my mom was like living in Boston with girlfriends when the Boston strangler was tooting around and those stories in like an apartment together y his route and.
Ash
They had like things in place. I think we talked about it in the episode too Deter him like tin.
Alayna
Cans, like aluminum cans on top of each other in front of the door so that if it opened it would fall over and alert them.
Ash
Cuz their apartment door she said you could open with like a credit card.
Alayna
Credit card.
Ash
Yeah.
Alayna
Yeah. It was like that janky.
Ash
It's crazy.
Alayna
So I'd be, I. I'm curious to see if any of you can get any like cool stories out of family members. Let us know.
Ash
Yeah. And if you want to write them in, we would love to share them.
Alayna
Feel free.
Ash
Let us know if we have permission.
Alayna
Yeah, definitely. Wow.
Ash
I'm very interested to hear part too.
Alayna
Very interesting story.
Ash
So with that being said, we hope.
Alayna
You keep listening and we hope you keep it weird.
Ash
But that's weird that you don't write in your stories if you have them because now I'm so into do it. Bye bye.
Alayna
Sam.
Ash
If you like morbid, you can listen early and ad free right now by joining Wondery plus in the Wondery app or on Apple Podcasts. Prime members can listen ad free on Amazon Music. Before you go, tell us about yourself by filling out a short survey@wondery.com survey.
E
Inspired by the hit Wondery podcast Against the Odds comes the gripping guidebook how to Survive against the Odds Tales and Tips for Animal Attacks and Natural Disasters. This might just be the most important book you'll ever read. Go inside life or death situations where everyday people survived nature's most extreme scenarios and learn how you can too. In these tales, you'll hear about the grit, willpower and know how needed to endure shipwrecks, alligator attacks, earthquakes and more. You'll learn from experts, including top doctors, about what happens to your body and mind in life threatening situations. Plus important tips on what to do and equally important, what not to do when faced with a situation that is truly against the odds. Go to www.survivalguidebook.com to get your copy of how to Survive against the Odds today or visit your favorite bookstore.
Podcast Summary: Morbid Episode 678 - The Mad Bomber of New York (Part 1)
Release Date: June 5, 2025
Hosts: Alayna and Ash | Morbid Network | Wondery
In Episode 678 of Morbid, titled The Mad Bomber of New York (Part 1), hosts Alayna and Ash dive deep into the chilling tale of a serial bomber who terrorized New York City from the 1940s into the early 1950s. This two-part series unravels the intricate details of the bombings, the persistent fear they instilled in the city, and the elusive nature of the bomber known as FP.
The story kicks off in the fall of 1940, when a Con Edison employee discovers a pipe bomb in the company’s main offices on West 64th Street. Alongside the bomb was a cryptic note:
Alayna (07:31): "Con Edison Crooks. This is for you."
Ash (07:32) reacts with shock, highlighting the severity of the threat. Fortunately, the bomb did not detonate, sparing lives but sowing seeds of fear.
A year later, in 1941, a second bomb is received with a peculiar message:
Alayna (07:50): "There is no shortage of powder boys."
This note, written in what was later identified as gunpowder, indicated a menacing intent to continue bombings post-World War II.
Upon each bombing, the NYPD's Bomb and Forgery Squad was alerted. However, the response times were frustratingly slow, with Ash expressing:
Ash (11:18): "I'd be pissed if it took them, like, 25 minutes. I'd be hours."
The bombs were crude, resembling homemade devices without sophisticated triggering mechanisms. Despite the evident threat, the vast number of potential suspects—ranging from Con Edison employees to disgruntled customers—made the investigation arduous.
In March 1951, during rush hour at Grand Central Station, another bomb detonated in a cigarette urn. Miraculously, no one was injured due to the timing and placement:
Alayna (24:05): "Despite being placed on one of the lower levels by track 27, there were no passersbys when the bomb went off."
This incident marked an escalation in the bomber's tactics, incorporating lethal shrapnel to maximize potential casualties. Yet, the bombs continued to fail in causing harm, leaving the city baffled.
As the bombings persisted, letters from FP became more frequent and threatening. One notable letter included:
Alayna (47:40): "Unless sloppy or no reporting is corrected about bombings, public will get information by way of Moscow."
In an attempt to quell the threats, the NYPD arrested Frederick Eberhardt, a former Con Edison employee. However, his subsequent acquittal and denial only deepened the mystery:
Ash (41:08): "Yeah."
Alayna (42:02): "If the NYPD hoped Frederick's arrest would put an end to the bomb threats of the recent months, they were very disappointed very quickly."
FP continued his reign of terror, sending more bombs and escalating threats that kept the city on edge.
Throughout the bombings, media coverage was minimal, often downplaying the incidents to avoid giving FP the attention he craved:
Ash (45:37): "It's like, my friends, I'm not here debating what's happening in his noggin."
This lack of coverage only fueled public anxiety, as the true extent of the terror was veiled from the masses.
As the episode concludes, Alayna and Ash highlight the unresolved nature of the case, setting the stage for Part 2 where they will delve deeper into FP's motives, eventual capture, and the aftermath of his actions.
Alayna (48:34): "We're going to talk about that in part two."
Listeners are left with a sense of anticipation, eager to uncover the remaining layers of this haunting true crime story.
Stay tuned for Part 2 of The Mad Bomber of New York as Alayna and Ash continue to dissect this perplexing case, exploring the depths of FP’s psyche and the relentless pursuit to bring him to justice.