Podcast Summary: Morbid Episode 688: The Last Call Killer (Part 2)

Release Date: July 10, 2025
Host: Alayna and Ash | Morbid Network | Wondery

Introduction

In the gripping second part of "The Last Call Killer," hosts Alayna and Ash delve deeper into the harrowing case of Richard Rogers, a nurse whose seemingly ordinary life concealed a string of brutal murders targeting gay men. This episode meticulously unpacks the investigation, community impact, forensic breakthroughs, and the eventual conviction of Rogers, painting a chilling portrait of a predator lurking in plain sight.

Case Overview and Initial Investigations

The episode opens with Ash recapping part one, where four men—Peter Anderson, Thomas Mulcahy, Anthony Marrero, and Michael Sakura—were found dismembered in garbage bags across Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and New York City. All victims were last seen near piano bars in NYC, leading investigators to suspect a serial killer targeting the LGBTQ+ community.

Notable Quote:
Ash (03:12): "Peter Anderson, Thomas Mul, Anthony Marrero, and Michael Sakura were all gay men who had last been seen in or near piano bars in New York City."

Community Response and Growing Concerns

As the bodies piled up, local LGBTQ+ activist groups, spearheaded by Matt Foreman of the Gay and Lesbian Anti-Violence Project, mobilized to support the community and pressure law enforcement for action.

Notable Quote:
Ash (04:35): "Matt Foreman told a reporter for Newsday, 'It's a shame that we have to wait until there's a bona fide string of these instances before we can get any attention.'"

Breakthrough in Forensic Science

Years later, advances in forensic technology provided a new avenue for solving the case. In 1999, the introduction of Vacuum Metal Deposition (VMD) allowed investigators to recover previously undetectable fingerprints from the crime scenes.

Notable Quote:
Ash (10:13): "And that leaves a clear, distinct print that can then be used as evidence."

Richard Rogers: From Suspect to Conviction

The renewed investigation led to the identification of Richard Rogers, a nurse at Mount Sinai Hospital. Initially, Rogers was an unlikely suspect—well-liked, polite, and seemingly incapable of such heinous acts. However, forensic evidence, including fingerprints and palm prints, tied him directly to the murders.

Notable Quote:
Ash (12:12): "In 2001, he got a hit from the AFIS database in Maine. The prints match those collected from a suspect in a 1973 murder of a University of Maine student."

The 1973 Murder and the Failed Defense

Rogers' past revealed a violent incident in 1973, where he stabbed his neighbor Fred Spencer, allegedly in self-defense. Despite substantial evidence, Rogers was acquitted, a decision later scrutinized for potential biases, including the possibility of a "gay panic" defense.

Notable Quote:
Alayna (26:17): "It's homophobia."

Patterns of Violence and Additional Crimes

Further investigation unveiled a pattern of violence spanning decades. Rogers was linked to additional murders in Florida (1982) and Connecticut (1986), as well as an assault in 1988, where he drugged and assaulted Sandy Harrow with a date rape drug, Vercid.

Notable Quote:
Ash (34:48): "He woke up completely nude and was bound at his wrists and ankles with hospital ID bracelets."

The Arrest and Initial Interrogation

In 2005, allegations against Rogers culminated in his arrest. During interrogation, Rogers remained eerily calm, denying involvement despite overwhelming evidence. His demeanor contrasted sharply with the brutality of his crimes.

Notable Quote:
Alayna (39:25): "We literally know for an absolute fact that you did this."

The Trial: Overcoming Doubts and Securing a Conviction

Rogers' first trial in 2005 saw prosecutors present irrefutable evidence, including multiple fingerprints and eyewitness testimonies. Despite his earlier acquittal, Rogers was found guilty of multiple first-degree murders after a compelling prosecution dismantled his defense.

Notable Quote:
Ash (47:00): "It's the purpose of this sentence to do everything within my power to assure society you never walk free again and that you die in some hole in some prison without ever having freedom again."

Sentencing and Aftermath

In January 2006, Rogers received two consecutive life sentences, ensuring he would remain incarcerated for the rest of his life. The judge's stern remarks underscored the severity of Rogers' actions and the justice served for his victims.

Notable Quote:
Ash (47:00): "And hopefully society will find some modicum of justice in that because there's nothing else that I can do."

Reflection on the Community and Unanswered Questions

Hosts Alayna and Ash reflect on the profound impact Rogers' crimes had on the LGBTQ+ community, emphasizing the vulnerability of individuals navigating their identity amidst societal prejudice. They also ponder the chilling reality of how someone perceived as "lovely" could harbor such darkness, highlighting the importance of vigilance and support within vulnerable communities.

Notable Quote:
Alayna (49:14): "He's a true monster. And the fact that I didn't ever know about this guy is so upsetting."

Conclusion

"The Last Call Killer (Part 2)" serves as a poignant exploration of a serial killer's manipulation of trust and societal biases. Through meticulous research and empathetic storytelling, Alayna and Ash shed light on the intersection of forensic science, justice, and the enduring scars left on communities. The episode stands as a testament to the relentless pursuit of truth and the unwavering spirit of those seeking justice for the marginalized.

Key Takeaways:

• Advancements in Forensic Science: The VMD technique was pivotal in breaking the decade-old cold case.
• Impact of Societal Biases: Potential use of the "gay panic" defense influenced the initial acquittal of Rogers.
• Community Mobilization: Activist groups played a crucial role in advocating for victims and pressuring law enforcement.
• Justice and Closure: The eventual conviction of Rogers provided a sense of closure, albeit delayed, for the victims' families and the community.

Final Thought:
This episode underscores the complexities of solving serial crimes, especially those intertwined with societal prejudices. It highlights the importance of technological advancements, community support, and persistent investigative efforts in bringing perpetrators to justice.

For those intrigued by this case and seeking more nuanced discussions on true crime and history, "Morbid" continues to deliver in-depth, research-driven narratives with a touch of humor. Stay tuned for more episodes that unravel the darkest corners of human behavior.