Ricky Kasso: The Acid King

Summary

Ricky Kasso: The Acid King – Podcast Summary

Podcast: Morbid
Hosts: Ash Kelley & Alaina Urquhart
Episode Title: Ricky Kasso: The Acid King
Date: January 15, 2026

---

Overview

In this gripping episode, Morbid hosts Ash and Alaina dive deep into the infamous true crime case of Ricky Kasso, a.k.a. "The Acid King," whose murder of Gary Lauwers in 1984 became entangled with the era’s satanic panic. With their signature blend of dark humor, thorough research, and empathetic reflection, the hosts dissect the sensationalized myths, the real-life tragedies, and the ripple effects of addiction, neglect, and hysteria.

---

Main Discussion Points & Insights

1. Setting the Tone: Everyday Joy and Heavy Topics

• Both hosts begin by acknowledging the darkness in current events and the power of finding small joys amid difficult times.
• They encourage listeners:

  “I really think it's important to find little joys because everything sucks so much.” (Alaina, 03:43)

• Light moments include stories about mundane happiness—like mopping with Pine-Sol or using foot masks—before shifting to the episode’s heavy true crime narrative.

2. Northport, Long Island: Setting the Scene

• The story unfolds in Northport, a quiet, idyllic community that became a focus for rumors of the occult and witchcraft.
• Ash highlights:

  “Given how popular the occult had become by the early 1970s, it was only a matter of time before that made its way to Long Island.” (Ash, 09:51)

• The hosts describe local legends, disappearing livestock, and the area’s proximity to the infamous Amityville murders, setting the stage for the panic to come.

3. Ricky Kasso’s Troubled Upbringing

• Ricky grew up in an outwardly typical household, but beneath the surface, pressure from his father centered around sports and achieving specific standards.
• Ricky’s early exposure to drugs is foregrounded:

  “One day in the fall of 1977, when he was in fifth grade, a friend's brother gave him a hit off a joint and the experience changed his life.” (Ash, 23:42)

• Drugs became Ricky’s escape and coping mechanism, with his use escalating rapidly through early adolescence.

4. Escalation: Addiction, Crime, and Alienation

• By age 13, Ricky was regularly using and dealing drugs, breaking into homes, and stealing—even from churches (“the body of Christ crackers”), showing increasing desperation (31:38–32:53).
• His relationships with family unravel; by 14, he is largely estranged, often living in woods or couch surfing.

5. Satanic Panic and Symbolic Identities

• The “Knights of the Black Circle,” a group of local misfit teens, became the scapegoats for Northport’s fears.
• Stereotypes were rampant:

  “People who were assumed to be involved in Satanism wore denim, drank, did drugs, listened to heavy metal music.” (Ash, 41:53)

• In reality, most “Knights” were just teens dabbling in counterculture to get attention or provoke, not actual practitioners.

6. The Precipitating Events: Grave Robbing & Further Decline

• Ricky’s behavior spirals: he and another youth rob a crypt for body parts, which Ricky claims (possibly facetiously) is for a satanic ritual (51:36).
• Police paperwork notes pentagrams and “hierarchies of hell,” fueling hysteria.

7. Gary Lauwers: Another Lost Youth

• Gary, once well-liked, falls into addiction and homelessness—mirroring Ricky’s path.
• Conflict is set: Gary steals PCP from Ricky, and, despite returning some, is viciously beaten and eventually threatened with death.

  “Ricky told Gary if it happened again, he would kill him.” (Ash, 58:52)

---

The Murder

8. The Night of Violence (June 19, 1984)

• Ricky, Gary, and others are partying in the woods, all consuming LSD.
• The situation turns dark:
  • Ricky antagonizes Gary, and a physical altercation ensues.
  • Ricky stabs Gary nearly 30 times, reportedly demanding he say “I love you, Satan” while Gary cries out for his mother (62:36–62:50).
  • The group buries him in a shallow grave and leaves.
• The aftermath is chillingly apathetic: Ricky brags about the murder and takes friends to see Gary’s body.

9. Discovery, Investigation, and Arrest

• The crime is eventually reported via an anonymous call (64:53).
• Initial law enforcement skepticism delays discovery; only after a nun reports a student’s concern do police look—finding Gary’s remains.
• Jimmy, Ricky’s close friend, confesses quickly; the narrative emerges that the killing, while discussed in “Satanic” terms, truly stemmed from drug-fueled paranoia and vengeance.

---

Analysis & Consequences

10. Media Frenzy and Satanic Panic

• Authorities and press hyper-focus on the ritualistic “sacrifice,” feeding national anxieties:

  “You've got a whole group of Satan worshipers. This was a sacrificial killing.” (Robert Dunn, 70:08)

• The real, deeply sad context—drug addiction and untreated mental illness—gets buried under sensational headlines.

11. Tragedies Upon Tragedies

• Ricky hangs himself in jail before trial (73:51).
• The only other major participant, Jimmy, is eventually acquitted; the truth of individual responsibility remains murky.
• Gary’s humanity is lost amid the noise, as is his family’s pain.

---

Notable Quotes & Moments with Timestamps

• On the importance of small joys:
  “It’s really important to find little joys because everything sucks so much.” – Alaina, 03:43

• Setting the scene for Northport:
  “It's like the quintessential bedroom community. …Just a quiet town where nothing terrible ever happened.” – Ash, 09:21

• Commenting on the absurdity of vacation announcements in the newspaper:
  “Who the fuck thought of that? …That was made by a criminal.” – Alaina, 33:43

• On Satanic Panic stereotypes:
  “People who were assumed to be involved in Satanism wore denim, all black clothing, drank, did drugs, and listened to heavy metal music.” – Ash, 41:53

• On the murder scene:
  “Suddenly, me and Albert heard Gary say, ‘I love you, Mom.’ …and then saw Ricky stab Gary in the back.” – Recap from Jimmy’s account, 62:12

• On media complicity in perpetuating myths:
  “In a press conference the next day…described the murder as nothing less than a sadistic, torturous, sacrificial killing. A satanic ritual murder. I was like, you had me until the very end.” – Ash, 71:22

• On reality versus myth:
  “The truth of Gary's murder has been completely forgotten. …the salacious rumors of Satanism and the occult remain to this day.” – Ash, 77:40

---

Important Segment Timestamps (MM:SS)

• Setting the mood & self-care chat: 01:27–08:08
• Case introduction (Ricky Kasso and Northport’s dark rumors): 08:43–13:43
• Grave robbing story & local urban legends: 11:44–16:09
• Early life of Ricky Kasso & family dynamics: 18:01–21:43
• Descent into drug use/crime: 23:44–36:12
• Satanic panic context and ‘Knights of the Black Circle’: 39:49–44:39
• Murder details – Gary Lauwers: 62:12–63:21
• Law enforcement/media reaction & aftermath: 64:53–71:02
• Trial, myth vs. fact, and closing reflections: 71:36–79:22

---

Tone and Delivery

• The hosts’ conversational, comedic banter adds levity without disrespecting the gravity of the crime.
• Memorable, offbeat analogies (e.g., “I measure garlic with my heart”; discussion of “the body of Christ crackers”) reflect their signature style.
• Deep empathy shines through, especially for the lost and vulnerable teenage victims.

---

Conclusion

Ash and Alaina deftly unravel the truth behind a crime that was sensationalized and mythologized throughout the 1980s, separating fact from fiction. Their verdict: this was not a ritual murder, but a grim product of addiction, neglect, and community failure. They urge listeners not to lose sight of the real tragedy—the lives destroyed by drugs and indifference—and remind all that, in the end, seeking truth is more important than indulging urban legends.

---

For further information, resources, and reading:

• Save Our Cemeteries
• [Rolling Stone article: “Kids in the Dark” by David Breskin]
• [Morbid Podcast – Full Episode Archive]

---

Fun Fact from the Hosts:
“The most pancakes flipped in one minute is 140.” (Ash, 79:36)

---

This summary is intended for listeners seeking a comprehensive, timestamped, and authentic recounting of the episode’s content, focus, themes, and highlights.

Transcript

[A]

This episode is presented by 20th Century Studios. Send help. From the twisted mind of Sam Raimi, director of the Evil Dead and Drag Me to hell, starring Rachel McAdams and Dylan O', Brien, comes a new film that begs the question, what would you do if you were stuck on an island with your terrible Boss in paradise? HR can't hear you scream. Only in theaters and 3D January 30th. Get tickets now. Considering earning a degree but haven't made your move? Missing the chance in 2026 could be, well, criminal. With over 200 online degree programs, Southern New Hampshire University could be the tip that you've been waiting for. Classes are career focused with no set times, and tuition rates are some of the lowest in the U.S. don't let this lead go cold. Visit Snhu. Edu Morbid to learn more. That's Snhu Edu Morbid. You can prepare for almost anything, except when a cold or flu hits you like an unexpected plot twist out. Alka Seltzer plus effervescent tablets are designed to deliver fast cold and flu relief. Just drop the two tablets in water and hear those bubbles bursting into action instantly ready to start. Providing cold and flu relief fast, perfect for when slowing down on sick days is not an option. Next time a cold or flu strikes, reach for Alka Seltzer plus cold and flu effervescent tablets. Nothing works faster for cold and flu symptom relief. Among oral OTC products, use as directed.

[B]

Hey, weirdos. I'm Elena.

[A]

I'm Ash.

[B]

And this is morbid.

[A]

This is morbid.

[B]

First thing I want to say is ice.

[A]

So hard times two.

[B]

Yeah, ice. That whole thing. It's absolutely tragic what happened to Renee. Good.

[A]

Yeah, she was murdered.

[B]

I, I, I have no words. I have no words. It's horrific what's happening, but the fact.

[A]

That we live in a place where a man can shoot a woman in the face in broad daylight over essentially nothing. That's scary.

[B]

Yeah. I think, I think we've all seen the videos. We've all seen it. And you know, I know what I saw.

[A]

Yeah. She was turning her car around.

[B]

I know what I saw. But one thing I do want to say is it's really hard right now to be happy about anything or find any kind of joy in anything. And I totally get that. But it's really important that you try to. It's really important. Like, even just little things. You know how I mentioned turn on some fucking soft jazz on that little old timey Bluetooth radio.

[A]

Yes.

[B]

In the morning shit like That I.

[A]

Saw one of those the other day.

[B]

Yeah, just make like any little thing you can find that makes it a little easier to exist.

[A]

Do you know what I found so much joy in the other day? I'm trad wifing so close to the sun lately.

[B]

Oh damn.

[A]

Mopping all my floors. I found. No, I'm not kidding. I found such fucking joy mopping my floors the other day. The smell of pine sold me.

[B]

Hey, whatever. Sparks joy. It sparks joy and makes the place clean.

[A]

Made the place clean. Smells good. Woke up this morning, still smelled like pine salt. And I organized my little beverage drawer. Ah. And a lot of people said ash, where are the fridge siggies? And I'm trying to give them up.

[B]

She's trying.

[A]

I'm really trying to give them up. I'm not going to tell you to give them up. I think you should still drink them.

[B]

Especially if it brings you joy.

[A]

If it brings you joy, crack open a cold one.

[B]

Do it. Because I'm. I'm being like. We're like we're joking about these silly like fridge cigarettes and everything. But I'm being very serious when I say I really think it's important to find little joys because everything sucks so much.

[A]

What's your.

[B]

I've seen a lot of people like saying like they feel really depressed and I get, we all get it. Like that's. And I just don't want. I don't want everyone falling into like not being able to find anything because then we'll all. Then it just really sucks.

[A]

Yeah, absolutely.

[B]

But, but so. And again little things.

[A]

What are you finding joy in aside from your radio? What's your newest joy?

[B]

My cooking. Cooking.

[A]

Meal prepping.

[B]

Yeah. I love it. Getting ready for the like that get. That gives me some sense of joy. And like I have my little notebook that I'm obsessed with.

[A]

I bought one.

[B]

See, you got to get yourself a nice notebook that. And it's got to be a notebook that if you're one of those people. Cuz I'm one of those people that was obsessed with planners forever. But you would buy a planner and every few months start it and then abandon it immediately.

[A]

I too am one of those people because it's pre planned out.

[B]

That's the thing. I'm. I'm here to tell you that it's not that you don't want to be organized or that you don't want like it's not you. It's not you. It's the planet.

[A]

It's not you.

[B]

And I think if that is you. Because that was me. Get yourself a plain fancy leather bound if you want or anything that you feel special about notebook. And then you can make it your own. And I swear to you, that changed my life.

[A]

Yeah, I really want to start junk journaling. I keep seeing tiktoks of people doing that and they put like stickers and they write calligraphy and they just like one page is like all the books they read and the next is like a calendar. Yeah. Like there's no rhyme or reason and that's how my brain works.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

If it's in a planner, it's like, what are you doing on Monday? What about Tuesday? Thursday, bitch, what's going on? And I'm like.

[B]

Feels a little too overwhelming. And then you can make your own little weekly. Like I make my own weekly plan thing on a page and then I control it.

[A]

Yeah, it's controlled.

[B]

I think it's important that control what you can control right now. It's my advice even. Who knows, maybe it'll work, maybe it won't. But that's all I got.

[A]

That's all you have for right now. I'm going to be so vulnerable right now.

[B]

Uh oh no, it's fine. I'm just kidding.

[A]

No, it's literally fine. I found joy in one of those foot mask things and I'm going to find joy when my feet start peeling.

[B]

Oh yeah.

[A]

I'm really excited.

[B]

If you guys haven't seen those, they're pretty great.

[A]

They look gnarly as hell. I showed it to Drew last night and he was like, that's going to happen to your feet?

[B]

Yeah. They're like little booties that. That have like this crazy lotion in them and you let them sit for a while. It's not. I don't love that part of it.

[A]

You don't love that part?

[B]

No. I did not like the feeling.

[A]

That makes so much sense. I love. It was so lovely. Cuz it's like a cold like.

[B]

Yeah, I did not like that.

[A]

It's not. It's like kind of liquidy a little bit.

[B]

Yep.

[A]

I liked it a lot.

[B]

I didn't keep it on for as long as I should have because I could not handle it.

[A]

I kept it on for an hour and a half.

[B]

That's wild.

[A]

How long did you leave yours on for?

[B]

Who knows? Probably 20 minutes.

[A]

And your foot still peeled your feet.

[B]

Cuz a few days later your feet will start to peel and then you have like baby's butt feet.

[A]

But it looks crazy.

[B]

It does.

[A]

I'm afraid for some reason I'm going to be. I'm afraid of my feet peeling like that. And I'm also afraid that they're. I'm going to be the one person it doesn't work on.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

I have such fear related to it.

[B]

The only way, really. Those are the two ways it will go.

[A]

Yeah. There's only two.

[B]

Hopefully it'll either peel or won't peel.

[A]

What if I just wake up with no feet?

[B]

Just peel off that. That's a lawsuit. So that. That I feel like you could win. There you go.

[A]

I could find joy in winning that.

[B]

Yeah. But. Yeah. What else has been going on besides.

[A]

Your book is out?

[B]

Oh, yeah, That's a big deal. Sorry, sorry.

[A]

Hey, everybody. I think you wrote another book.

[B]

There's a lot going on. It's hard to think of these things, but yeah, the Butcher legacy is out. It's out. It's about. It's ready to be pre ordered. Go get it.

[A]

There's still special editions, too.

[B]

There's still special editions. There's also signed editions at Barnes and Noble.

[A]

Signed editions.

[B]

And there's only a limited number of those and they're almost gone. So if you're looking for a signed edition, go to Barnes and Noble and get it because they will be gone.

[A]

And to find all of the links.

[B]

You can go to butcherlegacy.com comes out August 11th. You can pre order it now.

[A]

Perfect.

[B]

Perfect.

[A]

So books, feet.

[B]

Books, feet.

[A]

Joy.

[B]

Find some joy if you can. Fuck ice. And you know, here we are, everybody. Here we are. We love you.

[A]

Love you.

[B]

And we're in this together.

[A]

Together.

[B]

So here we are.

[A]

Here we are. Just a little quick side note for you guys going forward. So this New Moon bonus episode is going to be a little bit later than we said. We just need like a little more time to get it together. And going forward, we're going to be releasing all the bonus episodes on the last Friday of the month.

[B]

Yeah. So this one will be coming out on the 30th, January 30th. So it's just two weeks from now. It'll be coming out. So look forward to that because we're putting all the work into it and.

[A]

It'S going to be gr.

[B]

And we're excited for the rest of them.

[A]

I fucking love doing this little series.

[B]

Hell yeah.

[A]

I have a crazy case for you today.

[B]

You might as well.

[A]

I might as well.

[B]

Why not?

[A]

We are going to be talking about Ricky Casso, the Acid King. And I'm talking lsd. I'm not talking like Acid Puts people in barrels.

[B]

Yeah. Which is a. Honestly, an important distinction on this podcast.

[A]

Oh my God. I was. You took the words out of my mouth. I said, in a place of morbid, you must distinguish.

[B]

Because to be quite honest, when you first said that, I was like, oh.

[A]

Do you know, I saw that in your eyes. And that's why I differentiated.

[B]

We're really going for it.

[A]

I said, I'll tell you exactly what we're getting into. It's brutal.

[B]

I was gonna say it's probably still brutal, but just in a different way.

[A]

So let's talk about it. We're gonna talk about an area situated on Long Island's North Shore, about 50 miles from Manhattan called Northport. It's like the quintessential bedroom community. It was dotted with Victorian houses, ice cream shops, antique stores. I would have wanted to go there and bull around. Just a quiet town where nothing terrible ever happened.

[B]

Keith Morrison just walked right in.

[A]

Thank you. I really did a bad impression of him, but that was my attempt.

[B]

I mean, there's only one Keith.

[A]

OG Keith. But given how popular the occult had become by the early 1970s, it was only a matter of time before that made its way to Long Island.

[B]

I mean, good for the occult, you know?

[A]

Yeah, the occult, popularity, the. You're. The occult is a big part of this story. And also no part of this story at the same time.

[B]

Love that.

[A]

It's interesting.

[B]

That's interesting for sure.

[A]

So on November 13, 1974, you might remember, 23 year old Ronald DeFeo Jr. Shot and killed all six members of his family in Amityville.

[B]

I do remember that.

[A]

That's only about a half hour from Northport.

[B]

Wow. Okay.

[A]

To everybody's surprise, he later claimed that he was possessed by an evil entity at the time of the murders. You know, you remember, it really didn't do much to help his defense, but it did hypercharge the growing interest in the occult and the supernatural. And that had a lot to do with Ed and Lorraine Warren.

[B]

I'm sure. You know him. You know him?

[A]

Yeah. Within a few days, or a few years. Excuse me. Which, honestly, surprisingly, it wasn't a few days.

[B]

I'm surprised it wasn't hours.

[A]

Within a few minutes of the murders, the Warrens and other experts in the paranormal were on magazines, they were appearing on talk shows, tabloids all across the country, either promoting their services or warning about the increasing influence of the devil, the devil, on American culture. So the murder of the DeFeo family was obviously a huge moment that only added fuel to everybody's obsession with the supernatural, especially in the 70s and the 80s. But there had actually been rumors of an evil preference, evil presence on Long island even before those murders occurred. According to author Jesse Pollock, in the early 1970s, the villagers of Northport began to whisper about a coven of witches meeting inside the forest, holding midnight ceremonies after an evening of robbing graves.

[B]

Okay, aside from the robbing graves part, that sounds awesome.

[A]

I knew you were gonna say that.

[B]

Yeah. We gotta get rid of the robbing graves.

[A]

Yes. Don't rob the graves.

[B]

Don't do that. Jesus. That's actually. That's something that just happened. A little side quest.

[A]

Wait, that becomes another part of my story today. Tell me the big story.

[B]

Just came out. It happened in Pennsylvania. This guy. What the fuck is his name?

[A]

Tell me.

[B]

Jonathan Gerlock, I believe he had basically a hundred bodies, like parts of bodies, like hundreds of them. He had grave robbed forever. And he had them around his house. He was selling them. He was. He's. He's Ed.

[A]

Geek, I was just gonna say essentially.

[B]

He had like an online presence too, I guess.

[A]

Not an influencer.

[B]

And people didn't know that he was like doing this, but I think. What was his name? His name was like dead. Dead stuff Daddy or something like that. Something very.

[A]

If that's not exactly what his name was, I won't.

[B]

I don't even think it's that far off, to be quite honest.

[A]

Hold please.

[B]

I'm gonna look it up.

[A]

Hello?

[B]

It's a big deal. Like he was. Yeah, he wasn't. Like he was robbing graves. He was breaking into mausoleums to steal things. Like literally destroying mausoleums like crazy.

[A]

Are you sure you want a mausoleum? That's the.

[B]

So I mean, my mausoleum now I gotta upgrade the. It's gonna carry on the mausoleum, you.

[A]

Know, I'll ensure that. If you go first. Appreciate that happens. That's the one thing about being cremated that is maybe a little bit better. Like nobody can steal your body later. But that does happen because there's all those crazy stories about cremation where like you go in to get cremated and they don't even cremate your body. They just keep you.

[B]

Exactly. And then they just like sack you somewhere.

[A]

It's really terrible that you have to.

[B]

Like what happens after you die.

[A]

Like you kind of do, but, like, you're dead.

[B]

But this is awful. So there's more than a hundred human remains, some dating back decades or even centuries.

[A]

Centuries?

[B]

Yep. They said that he was selling some of these things online. Some of these remains included infants oh, that's so sad. He. I mean, he had. He. He. He admitted to stealing from at least 30 graves in, like, a nearby cemetery. There was corpses hanging from the ceiling in his house. Yeah. There was eight more bodies in a storage locker. He. He used. He, like, used tools, like, literally crowbars and to break into mausoleums, burial vaults, all kinds of things.

[A]

I feel like the scary thing about this, too, is it's like, I don't know how things are now as far as, like, laws go with grave robbing and that kind of thing, but remember that podcast that we listened to about the guy who worked at the crematorium, and it turned out that he was, like, no, Noble. Such a good show.

[B]

Please listen to that podcast.

[A]

But remember, when it came time to prosecute that guy, there was all these issues because they didn't really know what charges to bring against him.

[B]

It's so weird.

[A]

That was, like, way back in the. I think, like, early to mid 2000s.

[B]

It's. I don't know what. I mean, he's definitely being charged with stuff.

[A]

Did they say what he's been charged with yet?

[B]

I don't know. Yeah, I'm sure they have, but I don't. By the way, his name online was Dead Daddy, so I was not far off.

[A]

Oh, my God.

[B]

I told you I was not kidding. That was not me.

[A]

What was he putting online?

[B]

I think he just had, like, a lot of, like, what people were, like, art and stuff they thought was, but people were just thinking it was, like, spooky art. Yeah. Like, I mean, who knows how many people knew what was going on? But, like. Yeah, it's like, a big deal. It's like an ongoing thing right now. It's a very big.

[A]

And he was just arrested.

[B]

Yeah, he was just arrested. Literally with corpses hanging from the scene, like, it is straight up. Ed Gein.

[A]

That's, like, almost worse. Yeah, he just.

[B]

Hasn't that, like, murdered someone like Ed Gein, but, like, that's a mass. The amount. And the thing is, he was going like that. Like, some of the. Most of these cemeteries were being, like, kind of, like, abandoned, almost, like, not being kept up. And then some of them were, obviously. But, like, he was kind of going towards ones that were, like, vulnerable. Yeah, we gotta take care of cemeteries.

[A]

We absolutely do. They're really not well taken care of.

[B]

Yeah, like, it's a bummer.

[A]

I follow so many people that go and, like, clean up gravestones. I know. I love that thing. I know. It's awesome.

[B]

And I think there's a I donated to this, like, foundation to keep up cemeteries. And they. They've been keeping up cemeteries in New Orleans, like, trying to keep those going. Save our cemeteries.

[A]

Save our cemeteries. Oh, I donate. Yeah.

[B]

And you can donate to them. They do a lot of benefits.

[A]

That's really cool.

[B]

And they just. They're trying to preserve, like, historical cemeteries and any kind of. They just want to keep cemeteries, like, taken care of and safe.

[A]

Hell, yeah.

[B]

And you can find them atsaveour cemeteries.org.

[A]

That'S so easy.

[B]

Yeah, that's easy. So do that. Because especially with this going on, if you can even donate like a dollar or something to it just to. Clearly we need more being happening to our cemeteries to keep them safe.

[A]

Yeah, we need some upkeep because there.

[B]

Needs to be respect.

[A]

Well, I don't really know how to transition back.

[B]

Yeah, sorry. That just. It really reminded me that that's a big thing happening right now.

[A]

No, I'm glad to know you. That wasn't me saying, how dare you interrupt me. That was just like, damn, that's a hog heavy.

[B]

Here we go. Here we go.

[A]

He was gra. Grave robbing these witches who were probably just women hanging out. Probably weren't. Okay, but years earlier, the woods in Northport had become a popular lovers lane area with teenagers.

[B]

Oh, excuse me.

[A]

So the rumors of witchcraft in the woods were probably just an attempt to keep them from going out there. People were like, maybe don't park in the woods. Like, that's dangerous.

[B]

I mean, that's a good way to do it. Yeah.

[A]

But still, with fears of Satanism on the rise and the supposedly supernaturally motivated Defeo murders having happened nearby and pretty recently, the whisper rumors of the witches soon became a widespread local legend. So in the year since the murder of Gary ls, which we're going to talk about today, rumors and all these urban legends about the woods around Northport have multiplied and they've gotten all, like, mixed up in the game of telephone. Some people say it started all the way back in 1658 when goody garlic. Yep. A local practitioner.

[B]

Garlic.

[A]

Goody Garlic, a local occult practitioner, was charged with witchcraft and put on trial.

[B]

No.

[A]

That was the start of the North Port woods drama.

[B]

Listen to me right now. If somebody whose name is Goody Garlic tells you some shit, it's true. It's 100% true.

[A]

It's fact.

[B]

And you. You move with that information as if.

[A]

It is fact, you must listen.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

And if she was hanged, I'm done.

[B]

I'll. Revolution. Truly. Goody Garlic. Goody Garlic. We. We ride.

[A]

I essentially. Garlic. Like, I'd like to look into if I'm an ancestor.

[B]

I was going to say, because she's my ancestor.

[A]

Any recipe that calls for garlic doubled, tripled, quadrupled.

[B]

In fact, just the whole, whole thing.

[A]

I measure garlic with my heart.

[B]

Oh, absolutely. Especially Jarlic garlic and vanilla extract. You measure with your heart.

[A]

Vanilla extract. Two tablespoons.

[B]

Little tip from me to you.

[A]

Yeah, no, not really, but. So others connect the supernatural happenings to tortured spirits of former Native Americans who belong to the area first. And obviously, we're wrongfully killed.

[B]

Also valid.

[A]

Very valid. But whatever the case, rumors about the North Port woods would soon give way to an even more horrifying and very true story that would shake the residents of Northport for decades to come. So let's get into it. In the early 1960s, Richard Dick Cassa was teaching at Northport Junior High, and he met his future wife, Lynn, who was also a teacher. They dated for a few years. They got married in 1965, and their son, Ricky Jr. Who We're going to be talking about today, was born a couple years later in 1967. They had three more kids, all girls, shortly after Ricky. And to their friends and neighbors, they pretty much appeared to have an idyllic life. A home in a quiet neighborhood. They had reliable jobs. They had a happy family. They went to church every Sunday. What more could you ask for?

[B]

I was literally just gonna say that.

[A]

What more could you ask for? As a child, Ricky Jr. Was pretty ordinary. He was much like other kids. He liked to be outside. He. Which it sounds crazy now, but I think it was a little more popular. Like in the 60s and 70s. He spent a lot of time in the woods. He was collecting leaves, rocks, insects.

[B]

That was popular in the 90s, babe.

[A]

That's crazy.

[B]

We were in the woods all the time.

[A]

I grew up in the aughts when you could not be in the woods anymore. I'm surprised my mom didn't let me go in the woods because there was.

[B]

Killer clowns walking around.

[A]

Not until 2016, but damn, still. I know. I mean, we went to high school parties in the woods. That was. That was brief. But anyway, he got along well with his three sisters, but he got along the most with his youngest sister, Wendy. Family friend sue remembered Ricky loved Wendy. He would say, my Wendy. My little Wendy Lou A. He seemed to be like more than just a brother or protector. He was her closest friend. And this is so sad. He seemed to be the only person in the family who really paid any Attention to Wendy. Oh, Wendy seemed like she just got like the end of the stick.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

But it wasn't just his sister. Ricky was popular with. He had friends in the family's neighborhood in Northport. He would play football with them. Other sports out in the neighborhood. And for Dick Casso, his dad, the coach of the local high school football team, there was nothing that could have made him, made him happier than his only son showing a super strong interest in sports, especially football.

[B]

Sports.

[A]

Wendy said nothing else could compete with my father's love of sports. Not even his kids. Wow. Sports were his entire life.

[B]

That's the worst. Truly like that is the. As someone who genuinely enjoys some sports. Yeah, that's the worst.

[A]

I just started enjoying one sport. Yeah, basketball.

[B]

But shouldn't come before your kids.

[A]

It will never come before my kids. Yeah. But all of the Caso children had to play sports. They had no choice. And Dick was pretty explicit in his expectation that they had to win as well.

[B]

Oh, okay.

[A]

Like you, you sport and you win at sport.

[B]

You sport, you win. That's it.

[A]

Win, sport, sport, win.

[B]

Don't sport unless you're going to win.

[A]

Wendy said if you were, what you were doing wasn't related to sports. It wasn't important. No sport, no important.

[B]

No important.

[A]

No sport, no important.

[B]

That was their motto. Yeah. Tm. Tm.

[A]

So Ricky's interest in sports might have made his dad happy, but that didn't mean that he was particularly interested in playing them or that he was really even very good at any of the sports that he played. I feel like I'm saying sports so much.

[B]

Sports.

[A]

Sports. Go sports.

[B]

Go sports.

[A]

Ricky was pretty average in a lot of things that he did. He was a good brother, a good friend, a good neighbor. But when it came to things like school and sports.

[B]

Sports.

[A]

He put in a pretty modest amount of effort and got modest results.

[B]

All right.

[A]

You know, he did what he could. Got what he did.

[B]

You get what you put out. I suppose. Also the sports thing. I'm taking another turn. It's really quick, though. Do it. I don't know if I've mentioned this TikTok creator before, but you should go follow them. They're vintage recipes.

[A]

Vintage recipes? Yeah.

[B]

And he makes crazy ass vintage recipes. But he's the funniest person ever. And every time he does something like throw something in the air and catch it, he says sports.

[A]

I've seen him.

[B]

It makes me laugh every time.

[A]

And also, you say that a lot now, too. I do, yeah. Or you like that. I, in fact, don't like that.

[B]

I think it's the best thing in the world.

[A]

Dislike that.

[B]

I watch it. You'll love it.

[A]

I like his videos. Yeah. I think when you say it, it freaks me out. I don't know why. It's nothing personal. I still like it.

[B]

Wow. Carry on. I guess I don't like it.

[A]

So for Dick, the modest effort was fine when Ricky was like 8 or 10. But once he got into middle school, Ricky's like, ambivalence became a very big point of contention between them. One of Caso's Little league teammates said Dick used to scream and degrade his kid whenever Ricky didn't perform well.

[B]

So he was like, not great.

[A]

I feel like we've all seen that. Dad who you're like, they're in third grade.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

You're like, of competition that this is a relay race, sir. Like it's okay.

[B]

Like, really.

[A]

But while things at home were growing increasingly tense because sports, as Ricky got older sports, he started spending a lot less time at home and much more time looking for opportunities to escape his unpleasant life. One day in the fall of 1977, when he was in fifth grade, a friend's brother gave him a hit off a joint and the experience changed his life.

[B]

He's in fifth grade.

[A]

He was 10. My God, he was 10.

[B]

Lord.

[A]

So when he was high, everything felt better, more enjoyable. His life didn't seem as difficult. And at first he would just smoke occasionally whenever the opportunity presented itself. Which for a 10 year old was not that often, I would imagine. But I mean, it was the 70s.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

But by the time he was 12, his peers had also really developed an interest in smoking weed. Oh, no, I did not smoke weed that early. But soon, Ricky, I'm like, let's be explicit right now. It wasn't much later than that, but it was not 12. Damn, that was a tough life. But soon Ricky was leaving home early every morning to get high with his friends before school. And we're talking like sixth and seventh grade.

[B]

Oh my God. Babies.

[A]

I do remember kids, though, like doing that in like seventh, eighth grade.

[B]

Lord.

[A]

That is when it started scary. So for Ricky, who was constantly seeking an escape, smoking weed obviously led to experimentation with other drugs. And he managed to get his hands on what he and his friends thought was mescaline or mescaline, but what turned out to be acid or lsd. That, yeah, a little different.

[B]

Yeah. And he was young.

[A]

Yeah.

[B]

I mean, that's never something you want to be surprised with, I imagine.

[A]

But no, definitely not as a child, I Mean, mescaline would also probably be pretty bad. I'm pretty sure there's like.

[B]

I don't even know what that is.

[A]

What? I looked it up. I think there was. I think there's like peyote in it. Holy. I could be wrong. Let me double check. So I'm not giving you information about drugs.

[B]

Peyotes come up a lot in our lives.

[A]

No, I know that. Not in our lives.

[B]

But just to clear that up.

[A]

So there's.

[B]

Go watch the re watcher.

[A]

Yeah, it came up on the rewatcher. That's actually why I remembered that. So there's not peyote in mescaline, but it's similar. Like if the effects are similar to if you did peyote.

[B]

Peyote vibes. Peyote vibes, exactly.

[A]

Put that on a shirt. Got it. So he. They thought they were getting that kind of vibe and so they got lsd, which I would assume is kind of similar.

[B]

Yeah. I mean that. Yeah. From what little I know about those two experiences, I imagine they're kind of similar.

[A]

Yeah. I don't know. I never tripped.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

But his friend Mark Fisher told a reporter first time he tripped in seventh grade art class, he drawn. Yes. He'd drawn a dragon on the board and said it started to move. I mean, I was like, that's the most quintessential trip story I've ever heard in my life.

[B]

It's also very kind of adorable.

[A]

Yeah. In a weird way stories go, it's adorable.

[B]

I was in art class, I drew a dragon and the dragon moved. That's kind of awesome.

[A]

I wish you had been in high school, not seventh grade.

[B]

I wish you were not a child on acid at that moment. But like. But if you must.

[A]

I wish you were not a child on acid goes crazy.

[B]

But if you must be drawing a dragon and having it move, I suppose is the best case scenario, to be quite honest.

[A]

Facts.

[B]

Agree.

[A]

Agree hard.

[B]

This is pretty terrible all the way around.

[A]

It gets worse.

[B]

I'm just trying to find the joy.

[A]

Here you are, like you said at.

[B]

The top of this. Foreign.

[A]

Are you looking for relief from cold and flu symptoms this new year? I mean, who isn't With Gutter X, you can feel better for less. Save an average of 53 on flu treatments and get discounts on cold meds, decongestants and more for you and your family. You know that's all going to add up if you're not getting those discounts because we out here needing the decongestants. But guess what, Goodrx is free and it's easy to use. Just search for your prescription on the website or the app, compare prices, and get a free coupon to show your pharmacist. I feel like I roll up to the pharmacy with the golden ticket from Willy Wonka. I'm like, check this out. I got a coupon. Check Gutter X to save at over 70, 000 pharmacies nationwide, including Walmart, Walgreens, CVS, Publix, Kroger and so many more. Or get prescriptions delivered right to your door. Isn't that convenient? Goodr X is not insurance, but it works whether you have insurance or not. And it could be your insurance copay price. That happens to me all the time. For savings on cold and flu medications this new year, check goodrx go to goodrx.com morbid that's goodrx.com morbid.

[B]

Are you.

[A]

Starting the year with a wardrobe refresh? Oh, I love it. Quint has you covered with all the luxe essentials that feel effortless and look polished. They're perfect for layering, mixing and building a wardrobe that lasts. Their versatile styles make it easy to reach for them day after day. From soft Mongolian cashmere sweaters that feel like designer pieces without the markup to 100 silk tops and skirts for easy dressing up to perfectly cut denim for everyday wear, their wardrobe essentials are crafted to last season after season. I am a big fan of the cashmere sweaters and the silk skirts. I like to pair the silk skirts with the sweaters, but every now and again I'll just pair it with like an oversized sweatshirt and kind of like tuck the sweatshirt so it's like a comfy but chic look. That's the thing I like about Quince. You can dress it up or you can dress it down because I could just as easily put on like a really nice silk top and then it looks like I'm wearing a gorgeous silk dress. Honey, I'm ready to show up to any occasion I'm invited to. I love Quince and so will you refresh your wardrobe with quints? Don't wait. Go to quince.commorbid for free shipping on your order and 365 day returns. Now available in Canada too. Yay. That's Q-U-I-N C E.commorbid to get free shipping and 365 day returns. Quints.commorbid this is an ad by BetterHelp guys. 2026 is the year that I turn 30, which means I don't care what anyone thinks of me anymore. That is what I am letting go of to feel lighter in 2026 other people's thoughts about me. A new year is a new opportunity to feel lighter and you don't have to become a new person to do that. Signing up for therapy with better help can shine a light on what's been weighing you down and illuminate the possibilities for the year ahead. BetterHelp handles the initial therapist matching for you. All you have to do is take a short questionnaire to share your needs and your preferences. And thanks to BetterHelp's industry leading match fulfillment rate, they usually get your match right the first time. And if your match isn't the right fit, don't worry. Switching to a different therapist is super easy. Let BetterHelp provide you an unbiased perspective on your life so that you can head into the new year taking only what truly serves you. You can't step into a lighter version of yourself without leaving behind what's been weighing you down. Therapy can help clear your space. Sign up and get 10 off at betterhelp.commorbid that's BetterHelp. H E-L-P.commorbid. So in the eyes of a lot of his friends and his classmates, Ricky's drug use, especially during class, made him seem cool. We all remember that one kid.

[B]

It's not cool, kids.

[A]

Drugs aren't cool.

[B]

Drugs are bad.

[A]

I wonder if dare was a thing back then. I don't know when Dare started.

[B]

I don't know. Wasn't that like an 80s thing?

[A]

I think you're right. When did dare? Yeah, it might have been 90s, 1983.

[B]

Oh, there we go. Look at that.

[A]

I think you. It made sense that it was the 80s.

[B]

It feels like a very 80s thing.

[A]

I remember especially the, especially the logo dare so vividly.

[B]

I do too remember that big suitcase full of paraphernalia and pills.

[A]

I don't think anyone will ever forget the day that they brought like Vicodin.

[B]

Cocaine and heroin all like on that big like thing.

[A]

Yeah, like the suitcase.

[B]

And then they open it.

[A]

It's just right there, the cocaine package. Just like, holy. Like, oh my God, there's drugs in here. They were like, Ricky, his older brother says that drugs are cool. What would you say?

[B]

What would you say? What would not cool.

[A]

What would you tell him? And we, we did the pact. Yeah. And I signed that channel of people.

[B]

That broke that fucking.

[A]

I broke that pact. Not too many years later.

[B]

I, I kept that.

[A]

But you know what I. You can't sign under distress. That. I was probably just. That is signing under distress.

[B]

We weren't old enough to sign contracts.

[A]

Yeah, I was not legally bi.

[B]

Table.

[A]

Thank God. So people at first thought he was cool.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

His friend said, we had a sit out one time. Could you imagine a junior high sit out? Did it today.

[B]

Holy, man.

[A]

It's crazy.

[B]

Holy.

[A]

Soon, Ricky had become kind of like the de facto leader of a small group of boys who looked up to him, and they'd all get high together before, during, and after. At this point, there's high, high. Y' all high.

[B]

You're all high all the time.

[A]

So the thing was, for 12 and 13 year olds, money was scarce, and without it, there wasn't gonna be any drugs. So in order to support now, like a growing habit, which, like, we can joke, but now he's like, that's horrible.

[B]

Horrifying. Like, this is a horrifying situation that, like, literal children are hooked on acid at that point.

[A]

Yeah, it's bad.

[B]

This is gross.

[A]

So Ricky turned to petty theft, and he broke into a nearby church where not. He not only stole money from the collection box, but he even grabbed a box of the body of Crass crackers on his way out the door. He stole not only money, but the body of Christ. That's big.

[B]

That's. I mean, that's.

[A]

I'm also like, why would you choose those crackers? I've never had them, but I heard they're not good. Thinking maybe that's also coming up a lot in our life lately.

[B]

It is. What is going on right now?

[A]

Life is a simulation. We're plugged in somewhere.

[B]

Too much is coming up right now. But I was saying this, and you can feel however you want to feel about the body of Christ crackers. What are they communicating? Eucharist. Boom. Look at you. I didn't even do that Eucharist. I think it tastes terrible. That's just me. I think it tastes like water. Like a. I think it tastes like a stale. It's like when you have Covid and you bite into a sandwich and you can't taste it and it just tastes like water.

[A]

Yeah. Yeah.

[B]

I think it's just me, though.

[A]

I feel like he didn't steal those to eat. I feel like he had to have stolen them just, like, for shits.

[B]

But, like, why else are you stealing them?

[A]

Because, like. Like you're stealing the body of Christ from a church just for the.

[B]

Just for the thrill of it.

[A]

To be like, I took their crackers too.

[B]

I took the body of Christ.

[A]

What are they gonna do tomorrow?

[B]

What are they gonna do? I don't know. What are they gonna do tomorrow, you know?

[A]

I don't know.

[B]

What are they gonna do?

[A]

I don't know.

[B]

What did they do?

[A]

Earlier today, I said that if I was allowed to take the body of Christ back in, like, when I did go to church, sometimes I would just go if I could.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

If I was allowed to take the Eucharist, I would make the stallion it and go, like, try to get it on my tongue.

[B]

Because I feel like we were saying some older people don't do the hand thing where you put it in the hand. They just stick their tongue out and put it right on there.

[A]

Yeah, that's at all. I don't like that. I don't like experience. I would not want to be the guy giving it out either.

[B]

No, though.

[A]

Anyway, just in case. By the next year, Ricky's criminal behavior escalated to the point where he was not only stealing the body of Christ, but he was also breaking into houses and stealing from his neighbors, which is an unneighborly thing to do and really fucked up.

[B]

And it also shows a level of desperation that is very sad.

[A]

This is also just fucking insane. Wait until you hear this. Retired police officer Gene Romer remembered there was a newspaper back then called the Northport Journal. We used to call it the Criminal's Best Friend. Whoa. Because they would announce when locals would be going on vacation and how long they'd be gone. Who the fuck came up with that?

[B]

Who the fuck thought of that? Who did that? Why would you ever stand up? Who the fuck did that? Like, why? That's literally diabolical. No, it is. That was made by a criminal.

[A]

Absolutely. It had to have been.

[B]

And also, how the fuck do you know when I'm going on vacation and how long I'll be?

[A]

Well, that's the other thing I was like. People must have had to be like, oh, me and the Jones family are going to the Bahamas for seven to ten days.

[B]

I.

[A]

Why would you submit to that? I rebuke that. I rebuke that.

[B]

I do. No.

[A]

But now, armed with a schedule of locals vacations, Ricky and his friends could just be pretty sure they were in the clear to sneak into those houses, steal everything that they could to get drugs.

[B]

Here you go.

[A]

Without anybody even realizing that they'd been there.

[B]

Yeah. You might as well roll out the red carpet at that point, honestly. Let's go.

[A]

It just reminds me of Home Alone.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

So, unfortunately, Ricky's luck obviously eventually Ran out. And that was when he and some friends were picked up by police after breaking into a local house where they stole alcohol and silverware.

[B]

Oh, shitty.

[A]

Yeah. At first his parents. Exactly. At first his parents took.

[B]

I mean, I mean, he did not the people who weren't there.

[A]

Oh, yeah, absolutely. It was.

[B]

To be clear, I wasn't like, you had it coming that he was gonna steal your shot. You idiots.

[A]

Why would you tell them when you.

[B]

Were going on vacation?

[A]

No, Ricky. So at first his parents took the news in stride. They were like, you know, maybe it's just our son sewing his wild oats, you know, discretion, youthful beanes.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

But when they searched his room looking for the stolen items and they found a bong, their attitudes changed. Now, like, finding a bong in your kid's room is always pretty bad. But especially I think back then, it was even worse because parents were like, oh my God, I would imagine it would be so much worse back then.

[B]

I mean, personally, if I found one in my child's room now, it would be as worse, I think.

[A]

Yeah, I believe that.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

And as the accuracy. Yeah, I mean, if I find a bong in my kid's room, I'm gonna have like zero legs to stand on, but I'm gonna be so fucking angry. That's the thing that sucks. But a few years earlier, two local kids were killed in a car accident while they were driving under the influence. And in response, the town council approved the development of what was called Concepts for Narcotics Prevention. Cnp. It was like a church run center that served as an alternative to like dare because DARE didn't exist.

[B]

There wasn't. They didn't figure that amazing program out yet.

[A]

They did. They didn't get all the suitcase in order yet. But after finding the bong in Ricky's room, his parents were concerned obviously that he was developing a serious problem. So they brought him to CNP to see a counselor. He was 13 at this point, by the way.

[B]

13.

[A]

So he's like stealing from churches, breaking.

[B]

Into neighbors houses, dependent on drugs.

[A]

Like fully dependent on drugs. Scheduling sit outs with his friends in junior high, high, in school, before school and after school. Like, damn, it's bad.

[B]

Yeah, that's really bad.

[A]

So he showed no interest obviously in stopping or even slowing down his drug use. And when he was confronted about the bong, he told the CNP counselor, I like what I'm doing.

[B]

I mean, he's just telling it like it is at that point.

[A]

Well, and it's a, it's an escape for him, which Is sad. Like, if they had got a little deeper, they probably would have been able to figure out why he needed to escape from. Yeah, life.

[B]

You got to look at the root of the problem here, but I don't. 13 years old.

[A]

I don't think therapy was then what it is now.

[B]

I know. It's definitely.

[A]

Yeah. So the meeting at CNP marked a change in Ricky's relationship with his parents. He didn't go back to the center again, but they did make him attend therapy with a psychiatrist, even though he didn't want to, which was pretty good parenting, I would say. Again, especially for back then.

[B]

Yeah, that's, like, pretty big. Yeah.

[A]

Because, like, nobody was. Especially not sending boys to therapy.

[B]

No, definitely not.

[A]

Which is crazy. But Ricky refused to engage with the psychiatrist, and after a few sessions, the doctor was like, yeah, this is a waste of my time.

[B]

I can't just sit here and stare at him.

[A]

Yeah. He said Ricky was sabotaging the sessions, which, you know, like, it happens. I sabotaged a few psycho psychiatrics.

[B]

Like, have I been there? I don't know.

[A]

Yeah. But in the months that followed, Ricky's relationships with his parents started to decline even more so. And By Christmas of 1980, he was no longer living at home.

[B]

He's literally a child.

[A]

Yeah, he's like, 14 at this point.

[B]

So upsetting.

[A]

Instead, he just kind of, like, he would stay with friends, including his newest friend, Jimmy Triano. Like Ricky, Jimmy was also a heavy drug user, who by all accounts, was a, quote, failure at school to a degree you would not believe.

[B]

Whoa.

[A]

Yeah. According to his classmates, Jimmy had an I'm going to get you before you get me oh. Kind of personality. And he was constantly in trouble for breaking rules, getting into fights, being disruptive. Like, he sucked. And his parents tried to encourage him to adopt a better attitude by also taking him to CNP to see a counselor. But just like Ricky, he didn't take to the counseling. The senior counselor there said, though, Jimmy concerned me because, to put it simply, he had a problem seeing the difference between right and wrong.

[B]

Oh.

[A]

It wasn't just that. Like, Ricky was like, yeah, I like what I'm doing, and I'm gonna keep doing it, but it's probably improper. Jimmy was like, I don't. What's the issue?

[B]

Like, I don't give a. The. The I'm gonna get you before you get me thing is, it's definitely scary.

[A]

Yeah. Especially for, like, a 14, 15 year old.

[B]

Exactly.

[A]

So the closer Ricky and Jimmy got, the worse their relationship with everybody else got. Because I'm sure they developed that like, oh, it's. It's us against the world. Yeah.

[B]

Nobody gets us.

[A]

Nobody gets us. Yep. They encouraged each other's drug use and bad behavior. And whenever they got kicked out of their respective houses, they would hitchhike more than 200 miles to the castle's vacation cabin.

[B]

Damn. They would hitchhike 200 miles?

[A]

200 miles.

[B]

Wow.

[A]

Isn't that insane?

[B]

I can't believe they got out of that. Especially in the. Well, this was in the early 80s, I guess.

[A]

Early 80s, but still.

[B]

Still.

[A]

So pretty much every time that happened, they were picked up by the police and returned to Northport, where they would be returned to their parents and the cycle would just start all over again. This happened tons of times between 1980 and 1984. Ricky and Jimmy fell into what was arguably the worst possible crowd they ever could have found themselves associated with.

[B]

Cool.

[A]

The local drug dealers and teenage burnouts.

[B]

Oh, boy.

[A]

And during that time, their drug use escalated from weed and acid and now included pcp.

[B]

Oh.

[A]

Which, like that can get scary. Yeah. PCP is very much known for causing severe long term effects on users. At the time, the two boys had been associated with a group of teenage drug users who referred to themselves as the Knights of the Black Circle.

[B]

Wow. Yeah. That's so cool.

[A]

Yeah. Rock gone.

[B]

Wow.

[A]

So for years, this is really sad because remember, Northport has all these, like, whispers of like a cult happening.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

For years, farm animals and the occasional pet had gone missing in North Fort.

[B]

No.

[A]

Yes. Which fed the local rumors about Satanism and witchcraft happening in the area. And In December of 1981, some locals found the burned remains of a goat fetus on one of the stones, one of the stone chess boards in the park.

[B]

Come on, man.

[A]

Later, it would be revealed that an unhoused man had found the fetus in one of the fields of Northport. He was starving and desperate and he tried to cook it to feed himself, which is even sadder than what you would imagine.

[B]

Yeah, that destroys me.

[A]

But when it was first discovered, it was understood by many to be further evidence of devil worship in the area. And somebody reported to the North Port police that the Knights of the Black Circle were behind it. Ultimately, they were not. What happened is what I told you, but everybody was like, it must be the devil worship us.

[B]

And then it doesn't matter what the facts are, it's just, this is what I think. So this is what I'm going with.

[A]

Because then when they tell you the real story, everybody's like, oh, That's a cover up.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

And it's like. No, that's actually much more plausible.

[B]

No, that's literally what happened.

[A]

So there were never really any real means of identifying who was a devil worshipper, like, ever. But throughout the 1980s, as satanic panic was ever present in the U.S. satanism quickly became associated, as we know, with a very popular aesthetic or particular aesthetic. Excuse me. People who were assumed to be involved in Satanism wore denim, which is insane. Oh, yeah. Doesn't everybody wear.

[B]

Every time I see someone in denim, I'm like, trouble, trouble, Satan.

[A]

Or they wore all black clothing. They had long hair, probably, like dyed black hair. They drank, they did drugs, and they listened to heavy metal music.

[B]

Oh, this is very Paradise Lost.

[A]

It's so Paradise Lost. That's always what I think of whenever we talk about a case that involves Satanism, like, quote unquote. So in Northport, that criteria best described the kids who called themselves the Knights of the Black Circle. The discovery of the goat fetus, and they're being labeled as bad kids led to them being associated with Satanism. But most of the teenagers who were in that little, like, club weren't really into the occult at all.

[B]

Just the aesthetic.

[A]

Just the aesthetic. And, like, they were just using drugs. Yeah. Like, they weren't Satanists. They just had problems. So Jonathan McCuller said of himself and his friends in the Knights, we were the absolute last of the hippies. We were about peace, love and harmony.

[B]

Okay.

[A]

Not Satanism.

[B]

Yeah. Which actually, if you really look at Satanism.

[A]

Yeah, exactly.

[B]

It actually is about that.

[A]

So still, though, like, what they looked like that they listened to heavy metal music and they. It made the locals nervous.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

And that fear and anxiety was projected onto them as a whole.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

And he said, he goes, I guess it was because we were all a bunch of outcasts.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

Which was really sad. It really is like Paradise Lost.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

So while they mo. They may have been mostly harmless, that didn't mean that they were very big on the rules. Like, Ricky Casso and his friends the Knight spent a lot of time getting high, listening to music, and when they weren't doing drugs, they were selling them or getting into fights over drugs. And where you, like, who could sell drugs where Territory sounds great.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

It's all a mess. Even McCullough was willing to admit that the group sometimes went out of their way to antagonize the locals. He said the colors of. The colors of our jackets were demonic, and that was to freak people out. It had nothing to do With Satan, we just did that to repulse people, which we accomplished.

[B]

Valid.

[A]

I was like, what color is demonic? Yeah.

[B]

What is it just black, or is it black? Red.

[A]

So to Ricky Caso, who was already spiraling out of control, associating himself with the knights just made sense. They were outcasts in one way or another. They really like to get high a lot of the times. And some of them had expressed interest in the occult. Okay.

[B]

Which, like, in and of itself. That's not a bad thing.

[A]

In and of itself. Exactly. It's not a bad thing. And around that age, I think a lot of people express interest, like.

[B]

Yeah. Who wasn't a witch. Yeah.

[A]

I had a coven in third grade.

[B]

Hell, yeah.

[A]

And I literally got a phone call home about it, you know? But in Ricky's case, his interest was sparked innocently when he found a book on the occult at the local library. But according to his dad, it wasn't until Ricky reached his teens that his interests became somewhat concerning. Dick Castle later said the really bizarre, really deviant behavior started in the seventh grade, which makes sense. That's like. Yeah, really? When he got, like, super into drugs.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

From there, they said his interest in the occult only grew, and that scared both of his parents. Now, based on some people's memories, Ricky had a very strong interest in the occults and, like, stories, things like that. But it's really unclear how strong that interest was.

[B]

Okay.

[A]

Lots and lots of pretty innocuous things at that time were deemed to be, like, related to Satanism in the occult, especially through the lens of the older generation.

[B]

Yep.

[A]

And as devout Christians, Dick and Lyncasso probably interpreted a lot of those interests that were benign as being satanic.

[B]

Yeah, that makes sense.

[A]

But it should also be said that as a teenager looking for attention wherever he could get it, there's a very good chance that Ricky played up his supposedly satanic interests to get a reaction.

[B]

Out of people, which he basically said he did.

[A]

Yeah, exactly.

[B]

They did. Like the.

[A]

The knights did. One local said Ricky was of the devil. When he was on acid, he'd go back up into the dark woods up in Aztakia and he would talk to the devil. He said the devil came in the form of a tree which sprouted out of the ground and glowed.

[B]

Who said that?

[A]

A local.

[B]

Okay. Period.

[A]

Period. Period.

[B]

Wow.

[A]

Imagine. Believe Ricky. Imagine being described as. As of the devil.

[B]

Of the devil.

[A]

I'm kind of upset if somebody described me as of the devil. I think I might take that as a devil.

[B]

I'm sure I'VE been described as of the devil. Absolutely.

[A]

You have.

[B]

Positive of that.

[A]

Yeah. But. But don't you kind of take that as a compliment?

[B]

Yeah. Yeah. The devil has never come to me in the form of a tree.

[A]

No.

[B]

That I. I can't claim in the.

[A]

Form of something else.

[B]

No. I mean, I don't think so.

[A]

Okay. You're not sure?

[B]

Like maybe an X? Yeah.

[A]

Perhaps mine came in the form of my mom, so I got it.

[B]

So maybe there's that. Not a tree, though.

[A]

No, not a tree. I'd actually like that.

[B]

Yeah. Yeah. That's a lot less distressing. It is, you know?

[A]

So by 1983, Ricky's antics had led to him becoming an outcast. Even in his own friend group. By their own admission, they were the local outcasts. And now he was an outcast of outcasts.

[B]

Holy.

[A]

No bueno. So in response, he dove, obviously deeper into drug use, and he spent more and more time with Jimmy alone or just completely by himself. By that point, he was dangerously close to getting expelled from school because he had taken a teacher's checkbook from her desk and, like, threatened to use it, essentially, like he was going to steal her checkbook. He also had been deemed, and this is not a term obviously, that we use anymore, but that's what they said back then. He had been deemed emotionally handicapped by the school's district committee.

[B]

Wow.

[A]

They were like, he cannot be helped.

[B]

No.

[A]

At the same time, his parents were starting to look into other options for his education. But a lot of those would include him being sent away, essentially.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

In reality, a school experience with educating kids like him, like, with behavioral issues and drug issues probably could have helped him.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

But every time his parents would arrange for an interview, he would run away or he would find ways to dodge the appointment.

[B]

And at least they're trying.

[A]

Yeah, it does seem like they tried. I don't. Obviously, nobody knows what was going on in that house, but from everything we do know, it seems like they tried to get him help.

[B]

Help.

[A]

In late March of 1983, they reached the end of their wits with Ricky, and they went to the local police chief, Robert Howard, hoping that there was something the authorities could do to straighten their kid out, because they were desperate.

[B]

Damn.

[A]

So Chief Howard, he was like, yeah, of course I'll help you. And that month, Ricky was involuntarily admitted to South Oaks Hospital in Amityville for treatment and observation while he. This is really sad. And trigger warning for suicide. While he was at South Oaks, he tried to hang himself in the shower with a sweater. But he was discovered luckily, before any serious damage had been done. He also tried to run away at least five times and had to be tracked down by the police and brought back to the hospital. So he was released from South Oaks in May. And for a short time, things at the Castle house were quiet. But by the end of the year, his resentment toward his parents and just frustrations in general had returned. And so did his bad behavior. And this time it seemed like he was even meaner than he had been before. That's scary in one instance. And this is just like, it's so petty, but it's so mean. He covered his arms in ketchup and yelled for his mom and to come into his bedroom and yelled at her, look what I did. And for a minute she believed that he had cut himself and was like eating profusely. But when she realized it was only ketchup, he started laughing at her. And Lynn just started gathering all his shit and throwing it onto the front lawn. And she told him to get out.

[B]

Honestly, like that's, that's so up.

[A]

Yeah. And it's like, that's wild. I don't.

[B]

I can't imagine being in that position.

[A]

I can't imagine being in that position. I'm. It's easy to look at it from here and be like, you should never throw your kid out when they're like.

[B]

Yeah, we haven't lived that.

[A]

But we haven't lived that. We don't know what they were going through. And that is emotionally traumatizing, of course. So at that point she did kick him out.

[B]

That.

[A]

And he was like, okay, cool, see ya. And from that point forward, he basically just spent his time wandering the streets of Northport and couch surfing.

[B]

That's wild.

[A]

Yeah. By early 1984, 17 year old Ricky and whatever friends he had left could usually be found hanging out at the various cemeteries around Northport. The cemeteries were usually empty and there was also several crypts and obscured areas so they could use drugs without being caught or they could crash there if, like Ricky, they didn't have any home to go back to. Damn. And like they kind of had shelter, which is awful, in a mausoleum in a crypt. But they did. Around this time, Ricky started to spend a lot of time with 16 year old stoner Randy Guthler. Like Ricky. Randy was like a local misfit. He was a heavy drug user at 16 years old. And he spent most of his time getting high and causing trouble in October. So weird that you had mentioned this earlier and you had no idea that this was coming?

[B]

No.

[A]

Randy broke into one of the crypts and stole a skeletonized hand from a 54 year old gravesite.

[B]

What the.

[A]

And this kid's 16 years old. She kept the hand in a brown paper bag and just loved. Took any chance he could to show it off to the other kids and like horrify them.

[B]

What the.

[A]

A few weeks after he had just taken the hand from the site, he went back with Ricky to the cemetery where they stole the storm skull from the same grave site.

[B]

What?

[A]

This poor person, a couple of straight up douchebags. This person had been laying to in rest for 54 years.

[B]

Then these teenagers come and just pick apart his body. Jesus Christ.

[A]

Exactly. So the police ended up getting involved and they took the case very seriously. And in April, Ricky and Randy were arrested and charged with violation of a public health law. Which is so interesting. It's like I was saying earlier, like, I think they have to be kind of creative about charges for grave robbing.

[B]

I think now they have better charges. Charges for it.

[A]

I think there's definitely better ones. But even still, like, I think they could use some work because I assume.

[B]

Like desecration of a corpse and stuff should be.

[A]

Yeah, part of that, definitely. And I think even a grave, like disturbing a grave site is a. Is a charge, so. Not one to pass up the opportunity to defy authorities. When he was interviewed about the grave robbery, Ricky told detectives that he had procured the remains for use in a satanic ritual. Please. He's obviously just with them. Like I don't think he's really. He's just a mastermind of a satanic ritual.

[B]

No.

[A]

According to Detective Douglas Varney, though, when he was arrested, he was carrying satanic material, the pentagram, and a list of hierarchy in hell, names given the devil, such as Beelzebub and a whole group of Latin names.

[B]

Wow.

[A]

I said I'm sure.

[B]

He's probably so legit.

[A]

Definitely.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

Like he's like 17. I'm not that worried about it. I'm more worried about the fact that he's grave robbing and. Yeah, like 17.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

The hand was confiscated by the police upon their arrest and the following month the skull was discovered and everything was put back. So at the same time that Ricky was destroying his relationships and earning a reputation as one of Northport's most notorious satanists.

[B]

Wow.

[A]

Gary Lauwers was on his own decline, unfortunately. Once known among his friends as the type of guy that Everybody liked, by 1984, he had developed a somewhat serious drug habit himself and he had started stealing in order to support the drug habit. According to his friend Dan, Gary would do things for the moment. He wouldn't think about the next day what was going to happen to him. He totally somebody over and not think about the consequences of it.

[B]

Oh, not a good way to live.

[A]

Because his fun, his frontal lobe is not developed. Yeah, we're talking about all these people and it's like you think they're like 30 and it's like you're doing these serious, serious drugs and you are stunting the out of yourself because your brain isn't even finished growing yet.

[B]

Well, and it's like hearing about all these people that it's like, oh, they had a serious drug problem and they were going through this. And you think you're talking about like a 30 year old. Yeah, you're talking about a 16 year old, a 17 year old.

[A]

So sad.

[B]

This time of year gets so busy, guys, it's bonkers, it's bananas. We all know this. It's hard to make time for myself, let alone time for an entire workout. It's just not happening. But it is. Break through the busiest time of the year with the new Peloton Cross Training Tread plus. Powered by Peloton iq. Designed to make every single minute count, Peloton IQ personalizes your workouts, tracks progress, corrects form and gives real time insights to help you hit goals faster. Keyword with the swivel screen switch from a 45 minute run to a five minute stretch in one little spin. It's cross training reimagined for busy schedules. Let yourself run, lift, sculpt, push and go explore the new peloton cross training tread [e-mail] yeah, bam.

[A]

I'm not going to lie to you. My social battery is often running low and there's a lot of times where I'm like, I don't feel like going to that thing tonight. Like no, I don't want to go to that birthday party or I don't want to go to that dinner. But guess what? 9 out of 10 times when I go out, I'm happy I did because something cool happens or I meet a new fun person. Unforgettable memories are made when you're present and when you're connected, not distracted and exhausted. When your social battery is running low this holiday season, recharge with Liquid IV's energy multiplier Sugar free hydrating energy. It's scientifically formulated to support physical energy, hydration, focus, mood and social stamina. Just one stick and 16 ounces of water hydrates better than water alone with three times the electrolytes of the leading sports drink. I'm a huge fan of Liquid iv. In fact, I've been on a Liquid IV kick lately and I have particularly loved the sugar free hydrating energy kind. I really, really love the BlackBerry lemonade. If you mix that up and you put it in a fancy glass, it feels like you're having the most cutesy romanticize your life Delicious mocktail. I love to drink mine, especially after a workout or sometimes in the middle of the day if I just need a little bit of a boost or pre going out somewhere that I'm not sure I want to go out to and then whenever I go I'm like oh, I'm so glad I did this and that. I pre gamed with Liquid IV show up with better hydration and energy from Liquid IV. Zero sugar and zero crash, tear, pour and live more. Go to LiquidIV.com and get 20 off your first order with code MORBORT at checkout. That's 20 off your first order with code [e-mail] Life doesn't happen bi weekly, so why should Payday? The money you earn should be in your hands. And with Ernan, it can be. Earn in is an app that lets you access your pay as you earn it. Up to $150 a day with a max of a thousand dollars between paydays. Just download the Earn an app and start accessing your pay as you work. Any money you access, plus optional tips to help keep the app running, are automatically repaid from your next paycheck. I love Earnin. I'm obsessed with it. You know, sometimes you're running low, but you need to access your funds to get gas or to get groceries. You want to make a nice meal, you say, I'm getting the filet mignon because I got my pay early, baby. And you know you want to go to a movie. Tickets could sell out before payday, but not if you have Earn in because you get access to it before payday. Download earnin today, spelled E A R N I N in the Google Play or Apple App Store. When you download the Earn an app, type in Morbid under Podcast. Earnin is a financial technology company, not a bank. Access limits are based on your earnings and risk factors. Standard cash outs take one to two business days with no mandatory fees. Expedited transfers available for a fee. Tips are voluntary and don't affect the service. Available in select states. Terms and restrictions apply. Visit earnin.com for full details, download, earn and now and take control of your pay. So in the summer of 1983, Gary stole some money from his parents, who eventually just didn't know what to do with him anymore, much like Ricky's parents. And they kicked him out of the house, just like Ricky. Gary managed to find some places to stay. He kind of couch surfed. He also slept in various clubhouses around town, or he broke into the lumber yard and would sleep in one of the few abandoned buildings on the property.

[B]

So sad.

[A]

It really is like all the way around. 16 year old just roaming around town. Yeah, it's just awful. A few years earlier, Gary had started casually dealing drugs to support his own habit. And that's how he got to know Ricky Casso and Jimmy Toriano. So one night in April, Ricky and Gary happened to be at the same party together, and Ricky had passed out after a night of drinking. While Ricky was unconscious, Gary went through his jacket and stole 10 envelopes of PCP.

[B]

Jesus.

[A]

And then snuck out before Ricky woke up. A few days later, Ricky and Jimmy tracked Gary down and they said, we know you did this. And he admitted he did, but that he still had half of the envelopes, like he had five of the 10. So he gave back what was left and he promised to pay Ricky back for what was missing. But they beat him up regardless. He got a bloody nose, a black eye, and some cuts on his face.

[B]

Damn.

[A]

And according to his friend Michelle Devoe, Ricky told Gary if it happened again, he would kill him.

[B]

Whoa.

[A]

So by that summer.

[B]

Serious.

[A]

Very serious. By that summer, Ricky was mostly living in the woods and he had what most described as a serious addiction to PC.

[B]

Oh my God. He's living in the woods addicted to PCP.

[A]

Yeah, and he's like 17 years old. I also PCP, it feeds paranoia. Yeah, like people become insanely paranoid. Keep that in mind. He was regularly traveling to the Bronx in order to buy pcp. Friend Johnny Howard said it got dark after he started doing all the angel dust, which is pcp. He said, you don't want to do anything like that when you're really depressed because it's going to make it worse. If you smoke a joint of angel dust and read the Satanic Bible, it will amplify the feelings you presently have. So that was obviously bad. But if his addiction to PCP wasn't enough reason for people to keep their distance, the recent reports of his grave robbing were. Yeah, he really only had a few friends. If that left and they tried to Keep him grounded in reality, but he just wasn't there. So he spent most of his time alone. And he spent a lot of that time fixated on how he was going to get revenge against Gary for stealing from him.

[B]

Oh, boy.

[A]

And his rage is only growing throughout this whole period.

[B]

Not good.

[A]

So on the night of June 19, Gary and a small group of his friends were hanging out at a gazebo in Cow Harbor Park. He had plans later that night to go to the movies with his new girlfriend, Grace. But he also told friends that he was going to hang out with Ricky that night because he really wanted to repair their friendship. The plan seemed very strange to everybody who was there. They were like, ricky wants to revenge on you. Like, I don't think you should go hang out with him. He's really pissed at you, and he's pissed that you still haven't paid him back. So they were like, don't go with him. Hang out with us. Like, stay here. We're concerned about this. But Gary allegedly told them, it's okay, guys. I swear. It's fine. So shortly after that, Ricky and Jimmy arrived at the same park, where it was clear to everybody that they were tripping on lsd. Once he spotted Ricky, Gary approached and he handed Ricky $50 that he had owed him for the drugs, for the stolen drugs. But to his surprise, Ricky was like, no, I don't want the money. And instead, he opened his hand and offered Gary some of the LSD that he had, which obviously Gary accepted. And soon they were all tripping, and they seemed to be getting along just fine. At some point, Ricky, Jimmy, Gary, and another friend, Albert, decided to go to, like, this makeshift campsite in the North Port woods to continue drinking and listening to music and tripping. Nobody can be completely positive about what happened in the woods that night, what the actual truth is, because all we have are accounts from the two people who were involved or two of the people involved. But according to Jimmy, Jimmy Treano, they were all sitting around the fire, and he said, quote, ricky kept telling Gary to donate some of his clothes to the fire.

[B]

The.

[A]

Which is a weird way to put that and, like, weird thing to ask anybody to do. Desperate to be on good terms with the group, though, Gary was just doing what Ricky said, and he started throwing pieces of his clothing into the fire, which also. Remember, these kids are unhoused. Like, they don't have. Yeah, a lot of clothes. So that's sad in and of itself. A short time later, though, they started fighting Gary and Ricky. Jimmy later told the Police. Suddenly me and Albert heard Gary say, I love you, Mom. And when they look to see what was happening, they saw Ricky stab Gary in the back.

[B]

Suddenly he said, I love you, Mom.

[A]

I love you, Mom. Oh, Gary, try. This gets even worse. Gary tried to run away, but Ricky tackled him before he could get far. He then bit his neck. Like what? Insanely hard and started dragging him by the ankles back to the campsite. He then just started stabbing Gary over and over in the back, screaming for him to say, love you, Satan.

[B]

What the.

[A]

Which? Like he's on drugs.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

In response, Gary just kept repeating, I love my mom. Oh, which ruins you. Before finally saying, allegedly, I love you, Satan.

[B]

Holy. Yeah.

[A]

So Ricky stabbed gary Las nearly 30 times in the face, back and eyes.

[B]

Eyes, eyes.

[A]

Once he was dead, they searched his pockets and they found his wallet, which allegedly contained a list of the dignitaries in hell and instructions on how to conduct a satanic ritual.

[B]

Who knows if that's true?

[A]

I doubt it. It was about 3am by that point, and everybody wanted to get out of the woods. So they covered Gary's body with dirt, leaves and branches and then just started.

[B]

Walking out of the woods like no big deal.

[A]

Like nothing had ever happened. Like they had it that Ricky hadn't just stabbed somebody 30 times. That's more than 30 times.

[B]

That's wild. Yeah.

[A]

While Gary Lauer's murder was brutal and completely shocking in and of itself, what was even more shocking was that between the teenagers who committed and witnessed the murders and then those who heard about it, nobody really seemed to care that much or sympathize in any way.

[B]

That is so scary. The. The general apathy there is really scary.

[A]

It absolutely is. Ricky obviously couldn't help but brag to his friends about what he had done, because he's a piece of. He told two friends, I started kicking Gary's ass for stealing from me. There was this crow flying overhead, screeching. That was a sign from Satan. He was ordering me to kill Gary. So I pulled out my knife and I stabbed him once before he ran away. And he even went as far as taking other people into the woods to go see Gary's body to prove that.

[B]

He had done it. Yeah. Holy.

[A]

In the days before the murder, Gary had apparently made a few comments about leaving Northport. So when he wasn't around, all of a sudden, most people just assumed he had left town. It wasn't until July 1, almost two weeks later, that an anonymous call came into the North Port police regarding Gary's murder. Before hanging up, the Caller just said there's a body in the woods behind Gunther's tap room. That's it. To the officer on the receiving end, the caller sounded like a young woman, maybe a teenager, and he thought it was probably a prank. And as far as he knew, there was nobody missing in Northport. So seems like it was just a prank.

[B]

That's one thing you should always do as a member of law enforcement, assume that these things are pranks.

[A]

Yeah, just write it off.

[B]

It really. It works out.

[A]

Most don't go out and check.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

What's the point?

[B]

Why not? Yeah, why spend the resources?

[A]

Yeah, like, dude, yeah, My brother in Christ. Yeah, go take a peek. Just go. Just look. It could be a prank, but, you know, check it out.

[B]

Hey, whatever. Egg on your face.

[A]

Exactly. You'd rather be safe than to rather.

[B]

That egg on your face.

[A]

So things took a more concerning turn the next day when the head nun at Madonna Heights School, which. Imagine going to Madonna Heights School.

[B]

I know. I was gonna say in the 80s. It's pretty rad, especially in the 80s. I mean, height of Madonna.

[A]

Can you imagine?

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

Back to the story. The head nurse there, Sister Nun. Excuse me, Sister Mary James, reached out to the Northport police to report that one of her students, Jean Wells, had reported something shocking to one of the school counselors. According to Sister James, Jean had gone to the counselor after coming home from a weekend in Northwest Port, where she learned that one of her friends, Gary, had been murdered and buried in the woods. Officers went out to Gary's house, where his mother said that she hadn't seen him for a few weeks, but that wasn't that unusual. Still, the officers asked that she and Gary get in touch and let them know as soon as she saw him. So after leaving his house, the officers paid a visit to Gene's house. And Jean explained that she had gone into Northport for the weekend to visit her friend Karen, whose boyfriend, Jimmy Truriano, had been in the woods the night that Gary was killed. It was while all three of them were together that Jimmy casually mentioned Ricky Casso was keeping a low profile because he had killed Gary. And then Jimmy offered to take Gene out to the woods to see the body.

[B]

What the.

[A]

So they were all just being like, you want to go see?

[B]

You want to go check?

[A]

You want to go check it out?

[B]

Yeah, I can show you.

[A]

Okay, great.

[B]

Like, what the fuck? Like, that is some. Some cruel ass.

[A]

Absolutely. It is. It's unhinged.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

So the casual way that Jimmy was talking and even laughing about the entire Situation made Gene wonder if he was telling the truth. And she explained that to the officers. Detectives of northport were still skeptical of Jean's story. I'm like, this poor girl is in emotional distress.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

And she's, like, reaching out to anybody she can to be like, I. I'm pretty sure this is true.

[B]

Go look for this body in the woods. Like, that's. She's begging you. You.

[A]

So they waited until the next day, for whatever reason.

[B]

Like you said, my brother in Christ, what are you waiting for?

[A]

Like, when they got around to it, I guess. Jesus. And they went out to the area known as the aztikia woods. But it didn't take long for them to find exactly what they were looking for. About a hundred yards from the opening to the path that led into the woods, Detectives Roemer and mccready found one of the cadaver dogs Pulling on something buried in the dirt.

[B]

You don't say.

[A]

And when they got close enough to pull the dog away, they discovered the dog had been chewing on a bloody piece of human skin. Scalp.

[B]

Holy. Yeah, holy.

[A]

So it had rained heavily the night before. So when technicians arrived at the scene, they didn't have to work very hard to unearth Gary's remains From what was the very shallow grave that Jimmy and Ricky had buried him in. Honestly, calling it a grave is a.

[B]

Stretch, I was going to say, because they just keep showing people his body.

[A]

They keep showing people his body, and they hadn't really even dug a grave. They just covered him in about, like, hour. An inch of soil, leaves, and debris.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

At first, investigators did believe that Gary had been decapitated. Since his head had begun separated from his body. When he'd been buried a couple weeks earlier, it. I think they later determined that it was just decomp. But the rest of his remains were equally battered and brutalized. And that indicated that whoever had killed Gary had been very angry at the time. Yeah. So it took some time, but eventually, detectives managed to catch up with Ricky, Jimmy, and Albert on July 5, and they were all arrested on suspicion of murder. Not surprisingly, Ricky was defiant and basically refused to say anything. But Jimmy barely hesitated before telling investigators almost every last thing that had happened to Gary. He said Gary had stolen the 10 packets of PCP from Ricky A few weeks before the murder. And on the night of June 19, while he was high, Ricky stabbed Gary to death for it.

[B]

Jesus.

[A]

In his version of events, Jimmy let it slip that during their walk to the woods, Albert quietly mentioned to him that Ricky was planning on killing Gary. Once they got There. Holy.

[B]

So it was just completely planned and known? That's what no one stepped in?

[A]

Yeah, that's what they thought. This came as a shock to detectives who assumed that Gary had just been killed in a fit of rage. But if what Jimmy was saying was true, that meant that Gary's murder was premeditated.

[B]

Murder one, babe.

[A]

And that changes everything. Now, in his description of the events, Jimmy also mentioned that Ricky and some of the others and their squad, I guess, had expressed some interest in the occult and in Satanism. But he was also fairly explicit that the murder was related to Gary having stolen Ricky's drugs and that Ricky was also on drugs when Gary was killed.

[B]

That's the thing. I believe this is a very like grounded in a shitty reality kind of thing of like drugs.

[A]

Yeah, it's all, it all just leads back to drugs. Because even if they're talking about Satanism, they're high on drugs.

[B]

Exactly.

[A]

If they think they saw Satan, they're hallucinating. All on drugs. Yeah, it all goes back to drugs.

[B]

Like sober as a judge, people sitting here murdering people for Satan. For Satan.

[A]

No. Yeah, but still. Robert Dunn of the Northport Homicide Squad told reporters, you've got a whole bunch, a whole group of Satan worshippers. This was a sacrificial killing. They built a roaring fire in a field near the woods. I don't know what this is supposed to mean, but this is what they did. It's pure Satanism.

[B]

Well, that's. And just to be clear that like even if they were sober as a judge, killing someone, that's equally as bad. I'm saying like to, to pin this on like, well, they're Satanists and that's the reason it's like, no, you don't have to do that. This is as bad. They were all on drugs and they killed someone over drugs. Like it's, it's, it's bad either way. You don't need to add in Satanism element.

[A]

And that's, that's exactly the point, you know, is that why are you adding on Satanism when that poor kid was nearly decapitated? He had been stabbed so many times.

[B]

And for very stupid, like for drugs.

[A]

Yeah, it's like you said it, it just doesn't need the added layer. No, and it was, it was to like glorify this.

[B]

Not glorify this, but it makes it more salacious.

[A]

Exactly, exactly. So in a press conference the next day, Assistant District Attorney William Kean said they treated this Living and breathing 17 year old man as a sacrificial animal. They slaughtered and mutilated him. Which is true.

[B]

They did.

[A]

He went on to describe the murder as nothing less than a sadistic, torturous, sacrificial killing, a satanic ritual murder. I was like, you had me until the very end.

[B]

You're partially right there.

[A]

I was like, guys, it. Like, that's not the point that matters.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

Which was wild because, again, Jimmy just mentioned all the occult stuff in passing, probably when he was, like, probed about it.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

And told them the majority of this entire thing was over drugs.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

Like. Like not even the majority, just all of it.

[B]

That's what it was about.

[A]

All Ricky told the police was, I stabbed him. He got what he deserved.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

Which is nuts. He literally stabbed him in the eyes.

[B]

And to be that callous.

[A]

Yeah. I don't think that at that age, you start doing drugs when you're 10 and you get into PCP by the time you're, like, 13, you're gonna lose.

[B]

All that basic empathy, unfortunately.

[A]

So in the days after Ricky and Jimmy's arrest, guests, adults, and the press in Northport made a huge deal of the supposed satanic aspect of the murder, apparently completely unaware of the contradictory statements from Ricky's friends and associates. One friend told a reporter, I doubt they really were into Satanism. And most of the teenagers interviewed by the police and the press explained that Ricky had bragged about devil worship and occult practices, but nobody really believed his interest was anything more than him just trying to get attention.

[B]

Which I feel like if he really was a devil worshiper, whatever the hell they're trying to say he is, he would be doing that pretty quietly.

[A]

Exactly.

[B]

I don't think he'd be running around doing. If he's bragging about it and being like, ah, raising the devil and all that, he's doing it to get reactions.

[A]

Exactly.

[B]

That's basic human behavior.

[A]

Well. And I'm obsessed with this comment. Chief Robert Howard, who was the first one to actually try to help Ricky when his parents went to the authorities. He said it was a group of losers looking for something to make them special, to get attention. They got it.

[B]

Yeah. I.

[A]

That attitude is so red Foreman, because.

[B]

It'S so like, he's literally being like, yeah, we can sit here and sensationalize.

[A]

And pick hair like split hairs.

[B]

It's just a bunch of. They were trying to make a name for themselves. They got mad over drugs and they killed another human being. Like, that's simplistic as that.

[A]

Get lost in the minutiae, Kitty.

[B]

All the way around.

[A]

So on July 7th, Ricky Caso hanged himself in his cell with a bed sheet and what the medical examiner listed obviously as an apparent suicide, given his confession. And Jimmy Troiano's rookie had reason to believe that. And he probably would have, that if he was found guilty of murder and sent to prison, it would be for a very long time.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

The sheriff told the reporters he exhibited no undue stress and was treated as any other inmate. And Ricky left no note explaining his actions.

[B]

He wanted to get out of what he was going to get into.

[A]

I feel really bad for his parents.

[B]

Parents.

[A]

Yeah. And obviously what an awful parents as well.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

All of these kids. Parents.

[B]

It's just like. Oh, yeah. And his sister Wendy.

[A]

Yeah.

[B]

Who like he was close to. That's gonna be hard. It's awful to watch that evolution happen.

[A]

Yeah. And to live in a house too, that was probably so chaotic because of his drug use and behavioral issues. Like, I think she lost who her big brother was for a very small amount of time in her life.

[B]

For sure.

[A]

With Albert Quinones having been let go without charges. He was just there that night.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

And Ricky dead. That left only Jimmy Troiano alone to face trial for Gary's death. He did go on trial in early April of 1985, and by then the judge had ruled out any possibility that the murder was ritualistic or occult in nature. Instead, Jimmy was just being tried as an accomplice in Gary's murder. The jury was told that Jimmy held Gary while Ricky had stabbed him.

[B]

Damn.

[A]

The prosecution's entire case was based on the investigators belief that Jimmy had participated, however minimally, in the assault. And that made him culpable for murder. They said any statements made by Jimmy himself to the contrary couldn't be trusted, given his character, which you can understand. But still, both Jimmy and Albert testified that Jimmy never restrained Gary, never tried to prevent him from leaving the area. And the violence inflicted on Gary and the murder were entirely Ricky's doing.

[B]

Which is also very easy to do though, when Ricky is no longer here to.

[A]

Absolutely.

[B]

He can pin it all on him now.

[A]

Absolutely.

[B]

I'm not saying that's not what happened. It's just.

[A]

It's like that's why she's second guessing. That's why I set it up the way I did. Like when we first started talking about it. Unfortunately, I don't think we'll ever know the full truth of that night.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

The only truth that we do know is that Gary was viciously murdered. We don't really know exactly who did What?

[B]

Yeah, like we know, clearly Ricky was heavily.

[A]

Yeah, obviously he was there and I do think he stabbed him, but who knows what other people's input was. After more than 10 hours of deliberation, though, the jury ultimately sided with the defense and Jimmy was acquitted of the charges and allowed to leave a free man. All of the jurors refused to comment on what led them to an acquittal. All they said was, we all had a job to do and we did it well. It was a long deliberation and therefore you can conclude it was well thought out. Okay, so in his statement to the press, Jimmy's lawyer, Eric Nyberg was equally vague and just said there's proof of the defendant's guilt, but also reasonable doubt. I don't think anybody but God knows what happened that night.

[B]

Yeah, yeah. I mean, I also think the people that were there know what happened that night.

[A]

Yeah, exactly.

[B]

But sure, just.

[A]

God, yeah, for sure. In November of 1984, before the trial had even been scheduled, journalist David Breskin published an article called Kids in the Dark in Rolling Stone magazine.

[B]

That's spooky. It really is.

[A]

More than simply just coverage of Gary's murder, the article was a very lengthy interview between Breskin and several of the kids in and around Jimmy's circle.

[B]

Interesting.

[A]

Yeah. Unlike other national press outlets who did obviously mention the satanic and occult interests, but mostly stuck to the drug story, Breskin painted a picture of suburban teenagers gone wild abusing some of the scariest drugs on the streets at that point and engaging in dark religious practices. So the article poured gasoline on an already raging satanic panic fire, tm. And for a while, Ricky Caso became the new face of Satanism in America. An ordinary kid who slid far too easily into drug abuse, heavy metal music, and finally ritualistic murder. Unfortunately. And what's really. It just. It breaks my heart. The truth of Gary's murder has been completely forgotten.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

And nobody will ever really know exactly what happened that night except, like you said, the three people that were there. But obviously the salacious rumors of Satanism and the occult remain to this day, and everybody gets a little too focused on that.

[B]

Yeah. Once they're put into a story, it's hard to take it out. It is, because there's always going to be people that you can throw the evidence right in front of their face and they're going to say, no, Satan.

[A]

In my opinion, this was all drug.

[B]

It feels like it was very much drug fueled. And I'm sure there was like Satan shit being Thrown about.

[A]

Sure. They're teenage boys.

[B]

More for shock value than anything else. I don't think that they were. I honestly don't think they were, like, capable of organizing actual, like, religious practices here. I just don't see them, like, organizing, you know, ritualistic shit. I think they just did it to shock people. And it worked. People gave them what they wanted.

[A]

Nothing about the murder was. Looked ritualistic at all.

[B]

Yeah. You know, it looked like a brutal murder that someone who is not completely in their right mind would commit.

[A]

Exactly.

[B]

Yeah. Wow, that's really sad.

[A]

It is a really sad one.

[B]

Gary.

[A]

Poor Gary.

[B]

Because he.

[A]

Poor Gary's family, they.

[B]

The victim will get lost, lost in these kind of things when it gets too focused on, like, the salacious, like, Satanism and like, you know, ritualistic and all that.

[A]

Yeah.

[B]

Like, Gary will get lost, like, more and more as it goes.

[A]

Exactly. No, and it's sad because obviously Gary was having some kind of struggle. He was 16 years old and didn't live at home anymore.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

And was addicted to drugs.

[B]

You look it up, though. He looks like a baby.

[A]

Yeah.

[B]

He looks so young.

[A]

Yeah, it's awful.

[B]

It's really sad.

[A]

All of these kids were so young and like, like living the hardest lives. Yeah, it's awful. And it's time for a fun fact. And I think it's your turn to find a fun fact.

[B]

I thought it was your turn.

[A]

Is it my turn?

[B]

I'll take it.

[A]

The most pancakes flipped in one minute is 140.

[B]

Holy.

[A]

That's a lot of pancakes. I could barely flip one in a minute. I wonder what counts as a successful flip.

[B]

You know, I mean, it's got to be like a full.

[A]

Full flip around.

[B]

You can't have, like, edges, like, curled under or anything. It's got to be a full flip.

[A]

Yeah, that's what I would think.

[B]

Holy.

[A]

140.

[B]

I mean, good for you, person who did that.

[A]

Hell, yeah. Let's look up who did that.

[B]

That's pretty impressive.

[A]

Of course, it was an Australian. Australians do great things. Australian celebrity chef Brad Jolly, who, I don't know, flipped a pancake 140 times in a minute in Sydney, Australia, on February 21, 2012, setting the world record for most tosses of a pancake in one minute.

[B]

I think Robert Irwin did it. Probs. Yeah.

[A]

But also. Are you flipping like that? Sounds like he's just flipping the same pancake over and over.

[B]

Oh, that feels. If you're just flipping the pancake, I could do it.

[A]

But that feels a little bit easier than flipping a fresh pancake. You know what I mean? Like batter side over.

[B]

Oh. Because honestly, you really couldn't do it that way anyways. Because you. When you flip a pancake, you have to wait for it to bubble.

[A]

Oh, yes. We flipped the same pancake 140 times.

[B]

I mean, again, I'm not saying I could do it.

[A]

No, I'm definitely.

[B]

I'm not saying I couldn't. I couldn't do it.

[A]

We're gonna try that tomorrow and we'll get back to you.

[B]

We'll try it.

[A]

So we hope you keep listening and.

[B]

We hope you keep it. We.

[A]

But not so weird that you don't have a contest with your friends and family about flipping pancakes. Yeah, I want pancakes now.

[B]

Sam. Sa. Sam. Foreign. Hey everybody, it's Babs. I am so excited to tell you about Birch Lane, a brand that shares my passion for classic style and joyful living. Their classic furniture and decor helps you celebrate it all. From big holiday gift gatherings to everyday moments at home, each piece is carefully crafted and delivered fast and free so.

[A]

You can celebrate what matters most.

[B]

Shop my hand picked Birch Lane collection and more classic [e-mail].

[A]

Hi, I'm Angie Hicks, co founder of Angie. When you use Angie for your home projects, you know all your jobs will be done well. From roof repair to emergency plumbing and more done well. So the next time you have a home project, leave it to the pros. Get [e-mail].