WS MoreOrLess: Deaths in Gaza

Summary

---

More or Less – “Deaths in Gaza”

Podcast: More or Less (BBC Radio 4)
Episode Date: August 25, 2014
Host: Tim Harford
Co-presenter: Ruth Alexander

---

Episode Overview

This episode of More or Less investigates the contested statistics around civilian deaths in Gaza during the 2014 conflict between Palestinian militants and the Israeli military. With international concern about the high civilian death toll and questions about how casualty figures are constructed, Tim Harford and Ruth Alexander scrutinize the numbers, the methods behind them, and the controversies they spark. The episode focuses especially on the gender imbalance in reported casualties, the process of compiling statistics in wartime, and the inherent uncertainties and political sensitivities involved.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Context: Casualties in Gaza

• Background figures:
  • Between July 7 and August 20, 2014, a UN report estimated 1,999 deaths in Gaza due to the conflict.
  • UN: 70% are civilians; among civilian casualties, approximately 250 women, 450 children, 700 men.
  • On the Israeli side: 64 soldiers, 3 civilians killed.
    (01:00–01:43)

2. The Gender Imbalance & Its Implications

• Controversy: Why are so many more men than women listed among civilian casualties?
  • Some suggest this undermines claims of indiscriminate attacks by Israel, sparking criticism and speculation that some men listed as civilians may have been combatants.
  • Quote (Ruth Alexander):

    "It might be worth spelling out why the comment invites people to conclude that if Israeli attacks were indiscriminate, we wouldn't see far more men than women killed. We'd see roughly equal numbers." (01:53)

• An originally published BBC article hinting at this view was quickly edited to remove the contentious statement, with clarifications added later.
  (03:02–03:18)

3. Why More Civilian Men Than Women are Killed

• Expert Insight:
  • Matthias Benke, Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, explains:

    "Men will generally be more exposed. They will move around more. Even when they are in shelters, they will be staying outside, not inside the buildings, but in the hallways outside. They will go back and to check on their homes. They will go out to get food and water, whereas children and women will usually be more sheltered and protected." (03:27)

• Further Explanation:
  • Men may undertake riskier tasks, are more visible, and may be suspected of being fighters even if they are not.
  • Specific example from Gaza:

    "...this cafe is more or less man only during the evening hours... So many more men die because of the suspicion, I believe, than women." — Mahmoud Abu Rama, Almazan Centre for Human Rights (04:20)

4. Reliability of Casualty Figures

• Variability in Estimates:
  • UN: ~70% civilian casualties.
  • Israeli Defense Force: Estimates 50% but cannot confirm specifics.
• Methodology:
  • Matthias Benke details data gathering:
    • "They're gathered in partnership with a number of organizations... Palestinian, Israeli and international organizations that gather data, and we compile the information in a database... cross check and verify with data provided in the public domain ... On top of that we have a team on the ground also checking and cross referencing these figures." (05:26)
  • Figures are "subject to further verification, which we do as we go along." (06:00)
• Addressing Criticism:
  • UN does not rely solely on Gaza’s Ministry of Health stats (which is controlled by Hamas and does not differentiate between combatants and civilians); sometimes UN figures are even higher due to broader sources. (06:29)

5. The Challenges of Data Collection Amid Conflict

• Firsthand Difficulties:
  • Hagai Elad (B’Tselem, Israeli human rights group) describes the dangers and difficulties for independent verification on the ground:

    "Sometimes trying to drive over there could be dangerous, and sometimes being in a location in itself could be dangerous. So the confusion and the general intensity of the numbers are, I would say, the number one difficulty for us in analyzing the data." (07:25–08:11)

• Classifying Combatants vs. Non-combatants:
  • The social pressure complicates reporting:

    "Sometimes there's a desire. It's more courageous for someone to have died as a combatant for some families in other cases it's maybe there's a desire to show that the percentage of non combatants that died is high. So yeah, there will be pressures, no question about that." — Hagai Elad (08:24)

6. Why Absolute Certainty is Impossible

• Key Point: Despite best efforts at cross-checking and verification, counting the cost of war is always difficult and controversial. There are inevitable gaps and ambiguities in the record, increased by the fog of war and political sensitivities. (08:44–08:55)

---

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• "It might be worth spelling out why the comment invites people to conclude that if Israeli attacks were indiscriminate, we wouldn't see far more men than women killed. We'd see roughly equal numbers."
  — Ruth Alexander (01:53)

• "Men will generally be more exposed. They will move around more...They will go out to get food and water, whereas children and women will usually be more sheltered and protected."
  — Matthias Benke, UN (03:27)

• "...Many more men die because of the suspicion, I believe, than women."
  — Mahmoud Abu Rama, Almazan Centre for Human Rights (04:20)

• "They [casualty figures] are gathered in partnership with a number of organizations ... and we compile the information in a database that we run, which we also cross check and verify..."
  — Matthias Benke, UN (05:26)

• "Sometimes trying to drive over there could be dangerous, and sometimes being in a location in itself could be dangerous. So the confusion and the general intensity of the numbers are, I would say, the number one difficulty for us..."
  — Hagai Elad, B'Tselem (07:25–08:11)

• "Sometimes there's a desire. It's more courageous for someone to have died as a combatant for some families in other cases it's maybe there's a desire to show that the percentage of non combatants that died is high. So yeah, there will be pressures, no question about that."
  — Hagai Elad, B'Tselem (08:24)

---

Important Timestamps

• 01:00–01:43 | Presentation of casualty statistics
• 01:53–03:18 | Discussion about gender imbalance and public controversy
• 03:27–04:20 | Explanations for the male/female casualty differential
• 05:26–06:50 | Details on how casualty numbers are collected and verified
• 07:25–08:11 | B'Tselem on difficulties and dangers in collecting the data
• 08:24–08:44 | Societal pressures influencing data reporting

---

Episode Tone

• The episode is measured, analytical, and sensitive given the political and humanitarian weight of the topic.
• Tim Harford and Ruth Alexander use precise, cautious language, focusing on explanation rather than advocacy.

---

Takeaway

The episode reveals that wartime casualty statistics are painstaking but imperfect constructs, shaped by practical, social, and political constraints. Disproportionately male civilian deaths do not automatically reveal bias or misclassification; instead, they reflect patterns in activity and exposure amid conflict. Ultimately, the numbers must be handled with nuance, care, and an awareness of their limitations.

---

Transcript

[Tim Harford]

This is the short edition of More or Less, first broadcast on the BBC World Service.

[BBC Announcer]

Thank you for downloading from the BBC. For details of our complete range of podcasts and our terms of use, go to bbcworldservice.com podcasts

[Ruth Alexander]

hello and welcome to More or Less on the BBC World Service. We're your statistical guide to the numbers in the news and in life. And I'm Tim Harford.

[News Reporter]

The most intense fighting in Gaza since Israel launched its offensive has killed nearly 90 Palestinians today and 13 Israeli soldiers.

[Tim Harford]

At least 30 Palestinians are killed and hundreds more are injured after shells hit a UN school and a marketplace in Gaza. More bloodshed in Gaza as Israel promises to respond with crushing force after an Israeli soldier is captured.

[Ruth Alexander]

The number of civilians killed in Gaza during the conflict between Palestinian militants there and the Israeli military has raised international concern and condemnation. A United nations report estimated that between 7 July and 20 August this year there were 1,999 deaths in Gaza caused by the conflict. Of those killed, the UN estimate that 70% were civilians and and of those thought to be civilians, approximately 250 were women, 450 were children and 700 were men. The figures say the United nations are subject to change based on verification. The same UN report states that on the Israeli side, 64 soldiers have been killed and three civilians. Now, the fact that among the Palestinian civilian casualties there are nearly three times as many men as women has been in the spotlight. Indeed, an article on the BBC news website if the Israeli attacks have been indiscriminate, as the UN Human Rights Council says, it is hard to work out why they have killed so many more civilian men than women. Well, that's a comment that attracted controversy and a number of emails from listeners who've written to more or less directly. It might be worth spelling out why the comment invites people to conclude that if Israeli attacks were indiscriminate, we wouldn't see far more men than women killed. We'd see roughly equal numbers. And joining the dots, perhaps many of the men thought to be civilians weren't civilians at all. Now, none of that was explicitly said in the BBC article, but some critics have complained to more or less that that's what it was hinting at. And the Times of Israel, an online newspaper, ran an article citing the BBC's analysis in support of conclusions. All very sensitive stuff, needless to say. Well, Ruth Alexander's here to help me investigate. Ruth, before we get to the issue of what's happening in Gaza, what's the Latest on that BBC article?

[Tim Harford]

Well, that particular statement about how it's hard to square the UN's findings of indiscriminate attacks with the fact that more men than women had been killed.

[Ruth Alexander]

Yeah, that one.

[Tim Harford]

It's gone. The article's been edited to remove it. And a few days later, the BBC added a note about a series of clarifications, such as the inclusion of some possible explanations for why men were were disproportionately likely to be casualties.

[Ruth Alexander]

I spoke about this gender imbalance to Matthias Benke from the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for human rights on 19 August. Matthias was speaking from Ramallah in the

[Matthias Benke]

west bank, men will generally be more exposed. They will move around more. Even when they are in shelters, they will be staying outside, not inside the buildings, but in the hallways outside. They will go back and to check on their homes. They will go out to get food and water, whereas children and women will usually be more sheltered and prot.

[Tim Harford]

Other researchers have told us that men are usually over represented in counts of civilian casualties. In war, it can be about the tasks men undertake, how they socialise, and also that they may be, in general, more of a target, more easily mistaken for fighters. We've been speaking to Mahmoud Abu Rama from the Almazan Centre for Human Rights in Gaza, which is a Palestinian group that has researchers on the ground gathering information and statistics on who has been killed. He gave an example of an attack that hit a beach cafe where people were watching a World cup match.

[News Reporter]

Now, in a place like this in southern Gaza Strip, this cafe is more or less man only during the evening hours, at least. So you have many, many explanations. Our colleague was killed because he was on a motorcycle and the Israelis suspected him. So many more men die because of the suspicion, I believe, than women.

[Ruth Alexander]

So this idea that combatants are wrongly being counted as adult male civilian casualties, it's not necessarily true. Or at least the high male civilian death toll isn't strong evidence that a miscount is happening. There are several groups who are publishing casualty figures and their estimates vary. For example, the UN says that about 70% of casualties are civilian. The Israeli Defense Force has been reported as saying Civilian casualties are 50%. But when we called the IDF, they said they weren't able to confirm. Well, the UN numbers are seen as perhaps the most authoritative, but they're not without their critics. So how are they gathered? Here's Matthias Benker, the man in charge of them.

[Matthias Benke]

They're gathered in partnership with a number of organizations working in Gaza that are Palestinian Israeli and international organizations that gather data, and we compile the information in a database that we run, which we also cross check and verify with data provided in the public domain, whether that be the Ministry of Health, the idf, even the armed groups sometimes provide information on websites and other social networks about their dead. On top of that, we have a team on the ground also checking and cross referencing these figures. So it's quite a comprehensive process. We by no means claim that it's a final perfect figure. We stress very clearly that these are subject to further verification, which we do as we go along.

[Ruth Alexander]

Some people have criticized these figures on the basis that fundamentally, the source of the numbers is the Ministry of Health, and that's basically a Palestinian organization, it's controlled by Hamas. How would you respond to that criticism?

[Matthias Benke]

I would say, as I said before, that the Ministry of Health figures are one of our sources. It's certainly not the main source. For instance, the Ministry of Health does not differentiate in their figures between combatants and civilians. Furthermore, you will maybe have seen at times that our figures have actually been a bit higher than the Ministry of Health, because we have more sources to rely on.

[Ruth Alexander]

I wanted to press Matthias for further detail about how exactly his statistics are created and how these armed groups figure in the process. But he said he couldn't give any more information. Perhaps that indicates how politically sensitive these numbers are. There are several reasons the count of the dead may differ between organisations. Yes, there are, of course, politics. But these groups are trying to make sense of what's going on in the fog of war.

[Tim Harford]

Hagai Elad from the Israeli human rights group B'Tselem has researchers on the ground in Gaza, and he gave us a picture of how dangerous and how difficult their work is.

[Hagai Elad]

For instance, there would be news about the IDF ordering the evacuation of a certain Palestinian hospital in the northern Gaza Strip. So ideally, we would want our own researcher to go there and to see in his own eyes and to take pictures and to talk with the doctors there and independently tell us what is the situation on the ground. But sometimes trying to drive over there could be dangerous, and sometimes being in a location in itself could be dangerous. So the confusion and the general intensity of the numbers are, I would say, the number one difficulty for us in analyzing the data.

[Tim Harford]

And how easy is it for researchers collecting statistics on the ground to tell who was a fighter and who wasn't? I mean, they can ask people, but will they always get a straight answer? Here's Haggai Allard again.

[Hagai Elad]

Sometimes there's a desire. It's more courageous for someone to have died as a combatant for some families in other cases it's maybe there's a desire to show that the percentage of non combatants that died is high. So yeah, there will be pressures, no question about that.

[Tim Harford]

This is why they and the other groups we've spoken to say they do cross checks, they don't take what they're told at face value. But counting the cost of war is always hard and usually controversial.

[Ruth Alexander]

Well, thank you, Ruth. Please get in touch with your questions and your comments. Our email address is more or lessbc.co.uk our website is bbcworldservice.com moreorless there you can download as many episodes as you like. We'll be back on air at the same time next week. Until then, goodbye.

[BBC Announcer]

There are dozens of different podcasts now available from the BBC, including news, documentaries, science, business, arts and sports. For details of them all go to bbcworldservice.com podcasts.