Murder, Mystery & Makeup: A Psychotic Alaskan Love Triangle Turned Deadly? The Twisted Case of Mechele Linehan

Hosted by Bailey Sarian | Released on June 10, 2025

Introduction to the Case

In this gripping episode of Murder, Mystery & Makeup, Bailey Sarian delves into the enigmatic and tragic case of Kent Lepink, whose untimely death in the remote town of Hope, Alaska, set off a cascade of suspicion, betrayal, and unanswered questions. The episode meticulously unpacks the tangled relationships and the subsequent legal battles that ensued, all while Bailey's signature blend of true crime storytelling and personal insights keeps listeners engaged from start to finish.

Background of Michelle

The story begins with an introduction to Michelle Hughes (later referred to as Michelle throughout the episode), born in 1973 as the youngest of two daughters in a military family. Her early life was marked by frequent relocations, eventually settling in New Orleans. At age 12, Michelle experienced familial upheaval when her parents separated. Staying with her mother, she faced the loss of her father shortly thereafter, coinciding with a diagnosis of scoliosis—a condition that required spine surgery and the implantation of a metal rod to correct her posture.

Notable Quote:

Bailey Sarian [00:00]: "Michelle, you know, she struggled, and she ended up leaving home at a young age."

Michelle’s Early Adulthood and Relationships

Leaving home at a young age, Michelle moved to New York at 16 (with her mother's permission) to pursue a potential modeling career, although details about her success in modeling remain unclear. In New York, she became involved with Pat Gianti, a 27-year-old, forming a relationship that lasted approximately three years before she left him. By 1994, Michelle relocated to Anchorage, Alaska, where she worked as a pole dancer at the uniquely named Great Alaskan Bush Company.

During her time in Alaska, Michelle maintained multiple relationships concurrently:

• Scott Hilke: A traveling salesman who proposed marriage to Michelle in Thanksgiving 1994. Their relationship became strained as Scott's job kept him on the road, leading to infidelity on Michelle's part.
• John Carlin II: A single father who generously showered Michelle with gifts, including an extravagant $11,000 engagement ring.
• Kent Lepink: A man from Michigan with a troubled past, including embezzlement from the family business, whom Michelle later proposed to in 1996.

Notable Quote:

Bailey Sarian [04:00]: "She was busy keeping her options open. So Kent, he. He's the suspicious one."

The Love Triangle and Kent's Murder

By 1996, Michelle was entangled in a complex web of relationships:

• Engaged to both John Carlin and Kent Lepink.
• Still maintaining a connection with Scott Hilke.

On May 2, 1996, Kent Lepink was found dead—shot three times—in Hope, Alaska. The discovery was made by two electrical workers servicing a remote communication tower. Investigators found incriminating items on Kent's body:

• A checkbook from a shared account with Michelle.
• A life insurance change of beneficiary form dated a week prior.
• Multiple items related to Scott, including business cards and a hotel reservation.

Further complicating the case, an email from Michelle to Kent requested $3,200, citing personal issues, and expressed frustration over Kent's alleged substance use. Despite these indications, toxicology reports revealed no substances in Kent's system, raising suspicions about the email's authenticity.

Notable Quote:

Bailey Sarian [09:30]: "Kent also had several things relating to Scott, who Michelle was, like, kind of dating."

Investigation and Unraveling Evidence

Investigators pursued multiple leads:

• Michelle's Alibi: Claimed to be with Scott in Lake Tahoe during Kent's death, which was initially verified.
• John Carlin’s Involvement: Further scrutiny revealed John's son, John IV, had seen John Carlin purchase and wash a gun post-murder, eventually linking it to a .44 Desert Eagle traced back to the original seller.
• Laura’s Testimony: A friend named Laura alleged that Michelle was a manipulative individual inspired by the movie The Last Seduction, suggesting she could orchestrate a murder-for-money scenario. However, inconsistencies arose when Laura's diary contradicted her testimony about watching the movie with Michelle.

Kent's father, Kenneth, became a suspect due to his motive stemming from Kent's past embezzlement and financial disputes, though this angle remained unresolved.

Notable Quote:

Bailey Sarian [17:57]: "Case closed. Lock her up. I say Justice."

Trials and Legal Battles

John Carlin’s Trial:

• Prosecution's Case: Asserted that John lured Kent to Alaska at Michelle's behest. Introduced testimonies from John's ex-wife Julia and John IV, who implicated John's direct involvement.
• Defense's Strategy: Attempted to shift blame to Michelle, arguing no concrete evidence tied John directly to the murder beyond circumstantial connections.
• Verdict: John Carlin was found guilty of first-degree murder and sentenced to 99 years in prison on April 3, 2007.

Michelle’s Trial:

• Pre-Trial Challenges: Media sensationalism labeled Michelle negatively, complicating jury selection and public perception.
• Prosecution's Case: Relied heavily on Laura’s testimony and the letter from Kent implicating Michelle, alongside contrived emails suggesting her manipulative nature.
• Defense’s Strategy: Highlighted inconsistencies in witness testimonies, particularly Laura’s false claim about the movie, and showcased Michelle’s emotional reaction to Kent’s death as evidence of innocence.
• Verdict: After a brief jury deliberation, Michelle was also convicted of first-degree murder, receiving a 99-year sentence.

Notable Quote:

Bailey Sarian [29:10]: "At sentencing, Michelle also received 99 years in prison."

Appeals and Aftermath

Michelle’s legal team mounted an appeal, contesting the admissibility of Laura’s flawed testimony and the speculative nature of Kent’s letter. Additionally, they argued that Michelle's portrayal as an exotic dancer biased the jury against her. In February 2010, the appeals court overturned Michelle’s conviction due to faulty evidence, ordering a retrial.

As investigations resumed, new suspicions emerged regarding Kent's father, Kenneth, who had both motive and opportunity. Furthermore, revelations surfaced about the lead detective's potential conflict of interest—his attempts to publish a book on the case possibly influenced the pursuit of convictions against Michelle and John.

Unable to substantiate sufficient evidence against Michelle under the new scrutiny, prosecutors decided against re-indicting her.

John Carlin's narrative met a tragic end when he was murdered in prison in October 2008. His conviction was eventually overturned in 2015, posthumously clearing his name and highlighting the persistent uncertainties surrounding Kent's death.

Notable Quote:

Bailey Sarian [38:29]: "Nobody knows what really happened to Kent Lepink."

Conclusion and Lingering Mysteries

The case of Kent Lepink remains shrouded in mystery, with multiple parties—Michelle, John Carlin, Scott Hilke, and possibly Kenneth Lepink—all entangled in a web of deceit and unresolved motives. Despite the legal battles and shifting allegations, the truth behind Kent's murder remains elusive, leaving both the characters within the story and the audience grappling with unanswered questions.

Bailey Sarian wraps up the episode reflecting on the complexities of the case, emphasizing the lack of closure and the enduring impact on those involved.

Notable Quote:

Bailey Sarian [39:10]: "At the end of the day, it's sad. Like, poor Kent, his murder. Like, what happened."

Final Thoughts

This episode exemplifies Bailey Sarian's adept storytelling, weaving intricate narratives with emotional depth and critical analysis. Listeners are left pondering the elusive nature of truth in complex human relationships and the often flawed pursuit of justice.

Note: Timestamps correspond to key moments in the transcript, providing listeners with anchor points for notable quotes and discussions.