From Obsession To Murder: The Girlfriend Who Couldn't Let Go - Shayna Hubers

Summary

---

Murder, Mystery & Makeup

Episode: From Obsession To Murder: The Girlfriend Who Couldn't Let Go - Shayna Hubers

Host: Bailey Sarian
Date: January 20, 2026

---

Main Theme & Purpose

Bailey Sarian delves into the tumultuous story of Shayna Hubers, a young woman whose extreme obsession with her boyfriend, Ryan Poston, ended in his murder. Dubbed "the Kentucky Jodi Arias," Hubers' story weaves together themes of manipulation, jealousy, toxic relationships, and the question of self-defense versus calculated homicide. Bailey delivers the story in her signature irreverent, empathetic style, blending meticulous case research with candid, comedic commentary.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. The Beginning: A Picture-Perfect Couple?

[01:37 - 09:00]

• Shayna Hubers, 19, was seen as attractive and intelligent—a psychology student and occasional model.
• Ryan Poston, a 29-year-old attorney, discovered Shayna via a Facebook photo and pursued her.
• Their initial connection was electric and long-distance, with frequent weekend visits.
• Ryan’s family and friends described the relationship as “picture-perfect” on the outside, but cracks soon formed.
• Ryan struggled to break up with Shayna, feeling guilt and wishing not to hurt her, whereas Shayna painted the relationship as headed for marriage.

2. Red Flags and Escalation

[09:00 - 13:48]

• Shayna claimed emotional and physical abuse by Ryan to friends; one incident involved her showing bruises after an alleged altercation.
• Ryan considered ending things, especially after meeting and planning a date with Audrey Bolt, "Miss Ohio."
• Shayna’s mother sensed something wrong after a late-night phone call and drove hours to check on her daughter—a sign of ongoing volatility.

3. The Night of the Murder

[13:48 - 16:55]

• After being dropped at Ryan’s condo by her mother, Shayna called 911 at 8:53 PM on October 12, reporting she had shot Ryan in self-defense.
• On the call, Shayna recounted:

  "I killed my boyfriend in self-defense." – Shayna Hubers [14:03]

• Her story shifted repeatedly, citing various forms of physical confrontation.
• Disturbingly, Shayna told the dispatcher:

  "After I first shot Ryan, he started twitching, so I shot him again... enough to make sure he was dead because he was twitching so bad. I didn’t want him to lay there and twitch." – Shayna Hubers via 911 Call [16:55]

• The dispatcher pressed her on details, noting inconsistencies.

4. The Interrogation: Bizarre Confessions

[21:24 - 27:11]

• At the station, after requesting an attorney, Shayna continued talking unprompted, describing their relationship and defending her actions.
• Notable moment:

  "I gave him his nose job he wanted." – Shayna Hubers [21:56]

• Bailey’s live reaction underscored its disturbing absurdity:

  "She gave him the nose job he always wanted. Shut up. Why would she... why is she talking?" – Bailey Sarian [22:41]

• Shayna rambled about bruises, academic deadlines, her period, and jail hygiene—frequently shifting moods and topics.
• She seemed more concerned with her legal situation and personal inconveniences than the gravity of her actions.

5. Interrogation Room Oddities

[28:26 - 30:27]

• Alone in the interrogation room, Shayna sang, danced, and admitted to the crime audibly to herself.

  “Yeah, I did. Yeah, I did. I cannot believe I did that.” – Shayna Hubers [29:47] “Oh, I’m a good actor.” – Shayna Hubers [30:22]

• Bailey was stunned:

  “Do people not realize that they're being... I thought it’s like common knowledge. You're being filmed.” – Bailey Sarian [29:55]

6. The Investigation Unfolds

[30:27 - 38:27]

• Autopsy revealed Ryan was shot six times; some shots were fired at close range and at a downward angle, conflicting with Shayna’s story.
• Shayna’s digital footprint revealed she had researched “Miss Ohio” and “how to unlock a house door with a bobby pin” within days and hours of the murder.
• Message logs uncovered obsessive behaviors: Shayna sent Ryan dozens of texts per day, fabricated situations, harassed him using fake numbers, and accessed his social accounts to monitor or sabotage his interactions with other women.

  “She was really giving Stepford wife energy.” – Bailey Sarian [38:27]

• Friends found her drama entertaining at first, but some became exasperated, encouraging her to move on, to no avail.

7. The Toxic Back-and-Forth

[38:27 - 48:41]

• Friends and family provided further insight:
  • Christy (a dentist and Shayna’s close friend) once reached out to Ryan out of sheer frustration with Shayna’s fixation.
  • Ryan’s texts to friends at times revealed emotional burden and, at moments, violent or dark humor (“...I told her I wouldn't be too surprised if that happened, but it would only be if I didn't have anything better to do.” – Ryan to Shayna [no timestamp]).
• Both displayed unhealthy behaviors, but the imbalance and escalation from Shayna were clear.

8. The First Trial

[48:41 - 63:50]

• Trial (April 2015): Shayna pled not guilty, sticking to a self-defense claim.
• Crucial evidence: She called her mother first, then 15 minutes later, called 911.
• Jailhouse witnesses testified Shayna joked about the murder, boasted of her intelligence, discussed learning from the Jodi Arias trial, and openly strategized about her defense.
• Friends read aloud texts where Shayna explicitly joked, “when I go to the shooting range with Ryan tonight, I want to turn around, shoot him, and kill him and play like it’s an accident” [approx 56:51].
• The prosecution argued calculation:

  “She grabbed the gun from the table, shot Ryan twice while he was sitting down... shot him four more times before his body fell to the floor.” – Prosecutor’s account [63:50]

• Jury found Shayna guilty. She received 40 years with the possibility of parole after 20.

9. The Appeal & Retrials

[63:50 - 67:30]

• A mistrial was declared when it was discovered a juror was a felon (not permitted to serve).
• While awaiting a new trial, Shayna married another inmate, Unique Taylor, further raising questions about her motives.
• After delays and denied motions (including attempts to suppress interrogation footage), the second trial began in August 2018.

10. Second Trial: New Details, Worse Outcome

[67:30 - 72:00]

• Shayna testified, this time focusing on sexual coercion and emotional abuse by Ryan.
• Despite shifting strategies, the prosecution’s reenactment convinced the jury: guilty of first-degree murder, this time sentencing her to life in prison (eligible for parole after 20 years).
• Shayna quickly filed for divorce from Unique after her life sentence.
• In 2020, further appeals based on media coverage and evidence admissibility were denied.

11. The Aftermath & Legacy

[72:00 - End]

• Shayna remains incarcerated, ineligible for parole until 2032.
• The case prompted legal reform in Kentucky: the introduction of interpersonal protective orders for dating violence victims.
• Bailey’s final thoughts: the case marks a tragic intersection of obsession, toxicity, and preventable violence.

  “The sad truth is that we may never really know... what happened that night. It’s clear the relationship was toxic, and Shayna was completely obsessed. Ryan was like an F boy, but that doesn’t mean he deserved to be murdered.” – Bailey Sarian [75:10-end]

---

Memorable Quotes & Moments

• “This woman... she had it all. A hot bod... Except the one thing she could not control: her obsession.” – Bailey Sarian [01:37]
• “I shot him right here. I gave him his nose job he wanted.” – Shayna Hubers [21:56]
• “Do people not realize that they’re being... I thought it’s like common knowledge. You’re being filmed.” – Bailey Sarian [29:55]
• “She was really giving Stepford wife energy, you know, which isn’t bad if that’s what you want to do, but... Ryan never really did anything sweet like that for her.” – Bailey Sarian [38:27]
• “The sad truth is that we may never really know what happened that night... Ryan was like an F boy, but that doesn’t mean he deserved to be murdered.” – Bailey Sarian [75:10]
• “I cannot believe I did that... Oh, I’m a good actor.” – Shayna Hubers, alone in interrogation [29:47–30:22]

---

Important Timestamps

• 01:37 – Main story introduction and description of Shayna and Ryan’s first encounter.
• 09:00 – Red flags in the relationship and Ryan attempting to move on.
• 13:48 – 911 call: Shayna confesses, conflicting details emerge.
• 21:24–27:11 – Interrogation tape: unusual behavior and confessions.
• 29:47–30:27 – Shayna’s odd solo behavior in interrogation room.
• 38:27 – Bailey discusses digital evidence and the obsessive nature of Shayna’s actions.
• 48:41 – The trial, testimony from jailmates, and evidence of premeditation.
• 63:50 – Prosecution’s reenactment, guilty verdict, and sentencing.
• 67:30 – Appeal, retrial, and increased sentence after second guilty verdict.
• 75:10 – Bailey’s reflections and contextual legal changes (“interpersonal protective order”).

---

Overall Tone & Style

• Bailey’s voice is witty, empathetic, and sometimes irreverent, but she treats the underlying tragedy with seriousness.
• She emphasizes the “exhausting” nature of Shayna’s fixation and the destruction it wrought, while also acknowledging the complexity of both parties’ behavior.
• The episode balances true crime detail with commentary on social dynamics, law, and personal safety, ending with a call for compassion and vigilance around stalking—especially for men.

---

Summary Takeaway

Bailey Sarian’s episode paints a chilling, exhaustive portrait of how unchecked obsession and manipulation can spiral into lethal violence. The Shayna Hubers case, rife with digital breadcrumbs, legal twists, and a barrage of red flags, ultimately asks listeners to consider the importance of boundaries, the warning signs of toxic relationships, and the limitations of the justice system in protecting would-be victims before it's too late.

---

If you or someone you know is being stalked, harassed, or feeling unsafe in a relationship, don’t hesitate to reach out for help.

Transcript

[Bailey Sarian]

This episode of Murder Mystery and Makeup.

[Sponsor Voice]

Is brought to you by Progressive Insurance.

[Bailey Sarian]

Fiscally responsible financial geniuses, monetary magicians. These are things people say about drivers who switch their car insurance to Progressive and save hundreds. Because Progressive offers discounts for paying in full, owning a home, and more. Plus, you can count on their great customer service to help you when you need it. So your dollar goes a long way. Visit progressive.com to see if you could save on your car insurance, Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates. Potential savings will vary. Not available in all states or situations.

[Sponsor Voice]

Let's do the 60 Second Savings Challenge. Step 1 Download Rocket Money. Step 2 Link your accounts and see every subscription you're paying for. Tap one you don't use and cancel it. That's money back every month. Step three, create a financial goal. $50 every paycheck. Or let the app automatically move small amounts of cash. When you can afford it in a week, you'll forget you set it up. In a month, you'll see real dollars piling up. In a year, you'll be shocked at how much money you've saved. Upload an Internet or phone bill and let Rocket Money try to lower it. You only pay if they find you savings. On average, Rocket Money members can save up to $740 a year when using all the app's premium features. Users love the app with over 186,000 five star ratings. Make saving money the resolution you actually keep. Start the 60 second savings [e-mail] cancel. That's rocketmoney.com cancel rocketmoney.com cancel.

[Bailey Sarian]

Hi, friends. How are you today? Hey, my name is Bailey Sarian and today is Monday, which means it's murder mystery and makeup Monday. If you're new here. Hi, my name is Bailey Sarian and on Mondays I sit down, I talk about true crime story that's been heavy on my noggin and I do my makeup at the same time. Today's story. Today's story. Today's story will stress you out. Not really. Well, it will. I don't know. We'll see. Because listen, they called this woman the Kentucky Jodi Arias, which, if you're familiar with Ms. Jodi Arias, then you know. Okay, we're already off to quite the start. So this woman, she's young, she's smart, she's ambitious. And honestly, it seemed like she. She had it all. A hot bod. She was gorgeous. Except the one thing she could not control. Her obsession. Shana Hubers wasn't just in love. She was consumed. When her boyfriend Tried to leave. She wasn't just gonna let him walk away. Oh, no, she was not. No, she was not. Now, what followed was like a dark cocktail of jealousy, manipulation, and violence that left everyone asking, like, was this a desperate act of self defense or a cold execution? Trust me, the interrogation tapes, the bizarre behavior, the never ending trials. You are not going to believe how wild this case is. Okay, let's get into it. Let me tell you about Shayna Hubers. Okay? 19 year old Shayna Hubers, she was attending the University of Kentucky and she was pursuing a degree in psychology. Now, she was considered, you know, fun college girl, and I guess she also did some modeling on the side. She was good looking. She had beauty, she had brains. She had big, beautiful eyes. Brunette hair, a fit bod, great smile. She was given Teresa Barbie, kinda. So in 2011, some friends of hers, they posted like pictures from their spring break trip onto, like, their Facebook, you know, so they're like. And in one of those pictures, Shayna and her friends, they were, you know, in their little black bikinis, posing on like a nice balcony, you know, just looking all hot. Yeah, post that onto Facebook. Right? So that caught the attention of this guy named Ryan Poston. Now, he must have been friends with whoever posted it. Okay, so he sees this picture and he's like, ooh. So ryan, he was 29 years old and he was like working as an attorney in Cincinnati. So he was kind of like a big wig. He even had his own legal practice. So he sees this picture of Shayna on Facebook and he was like, I'm gonna send her a friend request. And he sure did. He sends her a friend request, and then Shayna accepts because, like, Ryan, he wasn't bad looking. She was like, into him. I mean, between the eyebrows, the hair, and every photo of him, he's giving like this smoldering stare. He never smiled. It's just always like, you know, he was kind of giving me like young Christian Bale and American Psycho. Does he though? It doesn't matter. We're moving on. He had to stare. So Shayna, she accepts his friend request, and then the two of them, they're like sending flirty messages back and forth, and it's like, nothing major. It's just like, oh, my God, you're hot. Oh, my God, you're hot. It's hot. Yeah. You know, a few months go by, and then Ryan, he goes to a party at the University of Kentucky. Now, his cousin Carissa, she invited him to come to this party. So he's like, okay, I'm down. So he ends up going to the party, right? And he realizes that his cousin is actually good friends with that hottie from Facebook, Shayna. I know, I was like, small world. Or was it a planned meet? Cute, I don't know. So he realizes this and he's like, hey to his cousin Karissa, like, introduce us, you know. So Carissa, she introduces them and then the two hit it off immediately. I guess it was like from then on, Ryan would drive two hours from his condo to Shayna's apartment almost every single weekend. And when Shayna had graduated, I guess like that following year, she would make the drive to his condo in Highland Heights, Kentucky. From the outside, it seemed like Ryan and Shayna were in, you know, a new happy relationship. Plus they're both good looking, so everyone's like, oh well, living the dream. Or so it seemed, you know, because we're here. According to Ryan's friends, he started to express that like he was losing interest in Shayna, but he was having a hard time breaking up with her because he was like, he was too nice and he didn't want to hurt her feelings. But Shayna, you know, she had like a very different take on their relationship. She would tell people how happy she was with Ryan and would talk about how the two of them, you know, they were going to get married. They were. It was just like a. It was perfect. Carissa, you know, Ryan's cousin said that Shayna would like always say she couldn't wait to be related to her for real. But I guess there were times when Shayna would mention to others that like, Ryan was a little abusive towards her, mostly emotional. But there were times when it got physical, I guess. There was this one night where Shayna went to the neighbor's condo and she was crying, saying that Ryan had grabbed her and like, I guess thrown her to the ground. And her arm was like all red. So the neighbor believed her and told her, like, report it to the police, you know, and like fricking leave him. But, you know, Shana just decided to leave, let it go. Throughout their relationship, Ryan would bring Shayna with him to like a lot of his family events, big and small. And on October 11, 2012, Ryan actually invited Shayna to go with him to his parents house to watch the live vice presidential debate. So they go, you know, great. While they were there, I guess Ryan at some point pulled his stepdad aside and he wanted to get his advice on how to handle ending things with Shayna because he actually had met someone else that he was like really excited to get to know. So Ryan told his stepdad all about this woman. He said, well, I have a date tomorrow night with somebody who I'm like really excited to meet. You know, she's beautiful, she's tall, she's blonde, and she's Miss Ohio. Literally. Miss Ohio. Yeah, apparently he and Ms. Ohio at the time, her name was Audrey Bolt. They had been messaging and texting for like months and they were finally planning to meet. So Ryan was like all excited about it. Plus she's gorgeous. She's gorgeous, you know, looks like a Barbie doll. He seems to have a type. But he was sharing all this with his stepdad. And yes, he was talking to Miss Ohio while he was still quote unquote with Shayna, you know. Okay. Now according to Ryan's stepdad, he told him like, look, just let Shayna down easy and be respectful. But overall, according to his stepdad, he said that Ryan seemed like really excited about this potential new love interest. So after the debate ended, Ryan and Shayna, they had left his parents house and they went back to his condo. Now it was said that the two of them got into some kind of argument around 3 in the morning. Now I guess, you know, whatever happened, Shayna was so upset. She ended up calling her mom again at 3am and her mom answers, good for her. Telling her like that she was having chest pains and just like she wasn't okay. Sharon, her mom, when they're on the phone, she can kind of, she could tell something was different, like something was off and you know, she had those mom spidey senses kind of tingling in her brain. Sharon later said that she was worried about her daughter's well being because I guess Shayna told her her mom that Ryan had guns just laying like all around his place and would sometimes just like shoot random things inside. Like he would just I guess pick up one of his guns and like shoot at a book that was sitting on the shelf. I know, could you imagine being there? Downstairs neighbors, you already got to deal with the people who are always like friggin wearing clogs all the time at like 2am and now you got like someone randomly shooting upstairs anyways. So I guess he would do that. I'm just like, who does that? So after that phone call, Sharon, she ended up driving two hours from Lexington to Ryan's condo, you know, to go check on her daughter again. It's like freaking 3am or something. So she gets there really early. When she got there, the two of them decided to leave his place and. And just, like, spend the day together, I guess. Sometime later that day, Ryan had texted Shaina, quote, I think I need some time by myself this weekend, Shayna. And Shayna replied, I'll be by later to get some bath items and head to the Marriott. Meaning she was gonna, like, go get her stuff and then just get out of his way and go stay at a hotel. Today's episode is brought to you by.

[Sponsor Voice]

IQ Bar, our exclusive snack, hydration and coffee sponsor. IQ Bar protein bars, IQ Mix, hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious, low sugar brain and body fuel you need to win your day.

[Bailey Sarian]

Listen, it's a new year and maybe.

[Sponsor Voice]

Your New Year's resolution, or maybe just.

[Bailey Sarian]

In general, you're like, look, I gotta take care of myself a little bit better, you know?

[Sponsor Voice]

Listen, that's where IQ Bar comes in to save the day. IQ Bar products are packed with clean, delicious ingredients that support physical and mental performance. Things like magnesium and lion's mane. And something I really appreciate. Their products are clean, label, certified, and free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients. Now, my personal obsession, the one that I love.

[Bailey Sarian]

Ooh.

[Sponsor Voice]

My favorite IQ Bar is Banana Nut Pudding protein bar. Now, I love banana nut bread.

[Bailey Sarian]

I love it.

[Sponsor Voice]

The IQ bar tastes just like banana bread, but there's only 2 grams of sugar in it. So, yeah, the New Year's gives us all a chance to reset, but that doesn't mean you have to bail on your goals and your resolutions. Maximize your brain and body's potential with IQ bars, protein bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees. Their ultimate sampler pack includes all three. And right now, IQ Bar is offering our special podcast listeners 20% off all IQ Bar products, including the ultimate sampler pack, plus free shipping to get your 20% off. Text makeup to 64,000. Text makeup to 64,000. That's makeup to 64,000. Message and data rates may apply. See terms for details.

[Bailey Sarian]

So Shayna's mom, she had dropped her off at Ryan's condo and then headed back home. Just Hours later, at 8:53pm on October 12, Shayna called. Campbell County 91 1.

[911 Dispatcher]

Campbell County 91 1. Ma', am, I have. I have. I killed my boyfriend in self defense. What did you kill him with? I got a loaded gun in the house. Can you tell me where the gun is right now? My gun is in the house. Where at, though? Ma'?

[Bailey Sarian]

Am?

[911 Dispatcher]

Tell me where it's at. I laid it on the bookshelf. Where are you? I'm standing about 10ft from his dead body. Okay, Are you sure that he is dead? He's dead, man. He's completely dead.

[Bailey Sarian]

Hey, at least she confessed. Case closed. So Shayna then asked the dispatcher, like, are the police gonna arrest me? You know, am I gonna be under arrest? And when the dispatcher couldn't give her a straight answer, Shayna just blurted out, like, I mean, I'm not a murderer, ma'. Am. I just killed him in self defense. Shana told a dispatcher that Ryan had attacked her and tried to, like, throw her out of the house. She said when she tried to grab her things, he was standing right in front of her, grabbed a gun, and she took it from his hand, and then she pulled the trigger. The dispatcher asked if she needed an ambulance because, like, you know, it sounded like she was attacked as well. Shayna did say she had. She was thrown against the couch, you know, so do you need an ambulance? Do you need an ambulance? Shayna said, no, she did not need an ambulance. She didn't have any injuries. So then the dispatcher asked, like, if there was a history of domestic violence between the two of them. And Shana said, yes. So at this point, you know, the true first responders when it comes to cases or shit, like, this is always the dispatcher. Now, the dispatcher usually is talking to sometimes the killer, and their job is to try and get them to kind of like, keep talking in a way, get some clarity here, you know, while you. While you have them. So the dispatcher is trying to do just that. She's trying to get clarity on the situation because, like, it's not really making sense at first. Shayna told the dispatcher that Ryan tried to throw her out of the house. And then she said he threw her across the room to the floor. And now she was saying that he threw her into the couch. So the story was just like, which is it, ma'? Am? Ma', Am, which is it? And then Shayna, like, mid call, still crying and all that, you know, she kind of, like, has a moment where she snaps out of it. And on the call, she almost sounds annoyed because apparently she could hear an echo on the call, and it was, like, really bothering her. So she tells the dispatcher, and when.

[911 Dispatcher]

I reached around to try to get my thing, he.

[Shayna Hubers]

I can hear myself echoing in the background, ma', am, it's just his phone system. His phone system has got a delay.

[911 Dispatcher]

And he pushed me down from the.

[Shayna Hubers]

Door all the way to the couch.

[911 Dispatcher]

When they come here, they'll see how.

[Bailey Sarian]

Far that is okay. I don't know. Just a little. It's just those little things where you're like, okay. Then she goes back to, like, telling the story and crying and stuff. It was just kind of a little weird, strange moment, you know? Now listen, listen, listen. Shayna then reveals something, like, even more disturbing on the call, okay? She said that after she first shot Ryan, he started twitching, so she shot him again. And the dispatcher was like, I'm sorry. You shot him a couple more times after that. And Shana, she was like, yeah, it's not funny. She was like, enough to make sure he was dead because he was twitching so bad. I didn't want him to lay there and twitch. So the dispatcher was like, so you shot him instead of calling 911? And Shayna was like, yeah, I did, because I knew he was gonna die anyway. Okay, what do you say to that? That's something like when people go hunting and they want to put an animal out of their misery and they shoot them, you know? But, like, I don't think that applies here, ma'. Am. So listen, after this, you know, the police get to Ryan's condo quick, and they immediately arrest Shayna. So Officer David Fornash Jr. Showed up, and he went into Ryan's condo to check out the scene of the crime. Now, when he first got in there, you know, he described Ryan's place as like a pretty normal bachelor pad. When you first walked into the door, it's like the living room area. And then if you went to the right, it's like a hallway that leads to the spare bedroom and the bathroom. And Ryan was using this area as, like, his closet. It was full of suits, ties, and tactical gear. And then behind the living room was the main bedroom and the kitchen. And then next to the kitchen is, like, the dining room area and the dining room area. That's where they found Ryan's body on the floor next to the dining room table. So noted at the police station, Officer Fornash, he explained to Shayna her Miranda rights. You know, you have the right to remain silent. You have the right. I don't really know what they have, but, you know. Yeah. So he reads her her rights, and he had her sign a waiver saying that she understood her rights. Now, while signing this waiver, Shayna made it clear she wanted an attorney. So Officer 4 Nash said, you know, okay, I won't ask you any questions, but I still need some answers from you for, like, the general paperwork that they have to fill out. Like, what's your full name, your date of birth, blah, blah, blah, you know, so Officer four Nash, he's like, taking this information down, you know, and while doing so, Shayna, she just, like, starts running her mouth. She starts talking, and she's talking all about her and Ryan's relationship. Now she starts telling the officers in the room like he was abusive and that, you know, she. She had to defend herself. Now, again, because she asked for an attorney, the officers that were in the room, they were not allowed to ask any questions, but they still. They let her keep talking. Now listen, here at Murder Mystery Makeup, we were able to get, like, all of the documents, the footage, everything regarding this case thanks to Highland Heights Police Chief Bill Birkenhauer. And he oversaw the case and he even testified in trial. So he sent us, like, friggin everything. So we have some of the interrogation footage. I've seen clips of it here and there when I was, like, researching it, but I haven't seen this one. So we're gonna watch it because apparently it's bizarre.

[Police Officer]

Okay, you want to contact an attorney, correct?

[Bailey Sarian]

Oh, yeah.

[Police Officer]

Okay.

[Shayna Hubers]

Something like that.

[Police Officer]

Okay, that'll work. All right, now just hang tight and drink your water. Okay.

[Shayna Hubers]

And I shot him in self defense because he's done stuff before where I've hit my head on a headboard.

[Police Officer]

Okay.

[Shayna Hubers]

And could have died.

[Police Officer]

Okay, well, that's. That's the kind of questions I was going to ask. I can't ask you these questions. Okay, but when you. When you make the statements, that's fine, but I can't ask you any questions because you. You want an attorney.

[Shayna Hubers]

I do want an attorney.

[Police Officer]

Okay? So I can't ask you any questions at all.

[Shayna Hubers]

I'm not a malicious person. Like, I'm not somebody that's ever done this. Like, I was. Anyone that knows me, like any character witnesses, even his own family, would say, I'm a nice, good person. He had put his arm across the table, and there's a lamp. And he had put his arm across the table and had it in my face and was screaming at me at the top of his lungs after he had thrown me around the room. One of our last conversations we had that was good was that he wants my best friend, who's a dentist, to do his veneers and once to get a nose job. Just that kind of person. And I shot him right here. I gave him his nose job he wanted. He was physically violent with me and throwing me around the room.

[Bailey Sarian]

She gave him the nose job he always wanted. Shut up. Why would she she. Why is she talking? I mean, like, it's good she's talking, you know, but like, what are you fighting, you crazy room?

[Shayna Hubers]

All the way into the dining room, all the way into the living room, back into the dining room. His obsession with guns killed him, you know, but for some reason, there is, like, this peace because I know that I didn't. I didn't do anything out of, like, malicious intent. If someone else was in the room and they watched it go down, they would have been like, good for her. She was beaten out or thrown around the room. Like, I don't have any marks, but I was thrown around the room. I probably do. On my legs. Actually, I was thinking about that. I probably do have some bruises. My shoulder hurts.

[Bailey Sarian]

Have you seen that Michael Jackson meme where he's like, my shoulder hurts.

[Shayna Hubers]

My shoulder is dislocated, literally. I'm in pain all the time.

[Bailey Sarian]

It's giving me that right now.

[Shayna Hubers]

Think he grabbed me by the shoulder. It feels like sore. But as long as you keep telling me everybody know I've been here. No.

[Bailey Sarian]

No.

[Shayna Hubers]

Probably would have badly, badly hurt me. I don't know if people would have killed me. But he about me, and I know I've killed him. I don't know if anyone will ever want to marry me if they know that I killed a boyfriend and helped him. It's not funny, but no, it's not. Me sitting here like, oh, I hope Ryan's family doesn't hate me. Their son is an abusive shit. Their son beat a girl who weighs 85 pounds less than him and drug her around his house. Pulled me by the ponytail of my hair. He deserved it. Hell has no fury like a woman's porn. Never believed it until now. I have two papers due money that I haven't submitted. I don't know if that's even gonna matter now. If you go to jail, are you allowed to keep your phone and, like, keep contact with your something? My cell phone? I don't think so.

[Bailey Sarian]

Yeah.

[Shayna Hubers]

Worst time to be on your period. I tell you what. Now here's a good question.

[Bailey Sarian]

Pausing there because circling back to our Clara Harris episode, I still can't get over that, like, crime of passion situation. What was it? Passion of crime. Sudden passion crime. If she would have said I was on my period and I killed him, whatever. I bet you in Texas she could have, you know? You know what I'm saying? Anyways, she's not in Texas, though.

[Shayna Hubers]

If I had to go to jail, can you shower there or do you just get really Dirty. I think they let you shower there. Really?

[Bailey Sarian]

Yeah.

[Shayna Hubers]

Pretty sure I have to shower in front of people. Oh, shit.

[Police Officer]

Oh, my God. Here's what's gonna happen right now, Shayna, okay? With everything that we have, we're gonna. I'm gonna charge. I'm gonna have to charge you with murder, okay? For right now and right now. Yeah, well, we got until you go to court and stuff and they decide what they're gonna do with it.

[Bailey Sarian]

Okay?

[Police Officer]

But what we're gonna do is through the search one, we're gonna need your clothes. Officer Lane's gonna be in here and she's gonna help you take the clothes off and you're gonna put them in bags.

[Shayna Hubers]

What degree murder?

[Police Officer]

There's no degree.

[Bailey Sarian]

Okay, well, you know, what are we gonna say about that? Well, I don't know. She said a lot, huh? And they just let her keep talking and good thing they did. I think that one line though of just like, she gave him the nose job that he always wanted. That's. That's up, girl. Like, did you really just say that? Jeez Louise. I think we all assume, like if you went through something really traumatic like that and like you just like you, you in self defense, like killed someone, I guess we all in our mind have an idea of how you would behave. And I don't think that's it. You know what I'm saying? I don't think that's. I don't think that's it. I don't think that's how you do it. But okay, girl, you know that moment when you put on a cute outfit.

[Sponsor Voice]

But it feels off because you may not have the right undergarments for the situation? I don't know, just thought, yeah, it's happened. Sometimes the wrong undergarments can just mess.

[Bailey Sarian]

With the whole vibe.

[Sponsor Voice]

Which is exactly why skims can change everything for you, baby. Listen, skims is a game changer when it comes to underwear.

[Bailey Sarian]

Until I got my first pair, I didn't realize that the underwear you put.

[Sponsor Voice]

On in the morning actually can define how confident and comfortable you feel all day. It's so comfortable. One of my personal favorites from skims is their fits everybody. Lace tanga. Not only are they cute, the fabric is so soft and comfortable. I just walk around with no pants on.

[Bailey Sarian]

What can I say?

[Sponsor Voice]

I worn and washed mine so many times, they haven't stretched out, faded. It's great. So if you're tired of your underwear drawer wreaking havoc on outfits, that should just work for you. Trust me, skims changes the Game from.

[Bailey Sarian]

The very first layer.

[Sponsor Voice]

Shop my favorite bras and [e-mail] after you place your order, be sure to let them know we sent you select podcasts in the survey and be sure.

[Bailey Sarian]

To select my show in the dropdown menu that follows.

[Sponsor Voice]

It's.

[Bailey Sarian]

It's always nice, you know? And if you're looking for the perfect.

[Sponsor Voice]

Gift for your valentine or for yourself, the Skims Valentine shop is now open.

[Bailey Sarian]

Now listen. Apparently every time she was left alone in the interrogation room, she would start acting again. Kind of odd for someone who just went through a very traumatic experience. I've seen some clips of this online when I was doing my research, but again, we got some, like, extra footage, so let's watch this clip together. Shayna in the interrogation room alone. She barefoot. She should just sing in the church choir. She killed him.

[Shayna Hubers]

Yeah, I did. Yeah, I did. I cannot believe I did that.

[Bailey Sarian]

Do people not realize that they're being. I thought it's like common knowledge. You're being filmed. Does she think no one was gonna catch that? Yep, I did it. I killed him. What else did she say? Oh, I'm a good actor. Do you think no one is watching you? Like, are you fucking Lily?

[Shayna Hubers]

Can you.

[Bailey Sarian]

Oh, now she's a dancer. Oh, okay. I forgot. All right. She's dancing, she's snapping her fingers saying, yep, I did it. I can't believe I did that. Great. You just gave the police everything they needed right then. And like, what are you doing? So basically, with all the stuff she said, because that was just a little tiny bit of it, with all the stuff she said, how she's acting, police are thinking this most likely is not self defense. You know, this is probably just straight up murder. A lot of things are not adding up with her story at this point. Shayna was officially charged for the murder of Ryan Poston, and her bond was set for like, $5 million. And she didn't have that kind of money, so she remained in custody throughout the investigation. So with Shayna behind bars, the police investigation focused less on did she do it? And more on why did she do it. Shayna said from the very beginning it was self defense, but the police needed proof if that was true or they needed proof that it was premeditated. Now, the autopsy report showed that Ryan was shot a total of six times. Yeah, so he was shot in the face, his head, his chest, his side. The coroner also found gun residue on Ryan's body, which meant that some of the. The shots were fired at a very close range. Now, on Top of that, some of the bullets entered his body at, like, a downward angle, which would suggest that Shayna was standing over him. Self defense. Where, you know, the coroner later testified that Ryan was most likely sitting down when the first shot was fired, which was very different from what Shayna originally said. Remember on the 911 call, she said that he was standing in front of her when she took the gun from him and she pulled the trigger. So, you know, they have their theories and all that stuff, so their investigators are still looking for more. And they looked into Shana's Internet. So search history, you know, that can say a lot about a person. I always think about mine. I'm like, oh, my, oh, my, oh, dear. My Internet. Okay. But anyways, they look into Shayna's Internet search history, and they came across some pretty interesting searches. Just two days before killing Ryan, it appears that Shayna had Googled Ms. Ohio. Audrey Bolt, the woman that Ryan was supposed to meet up with. Yeah, Shayna had googled her. And it's unclear how she found out about Miss Ohio. It becomes clear later on. But you know what girls do? It's like, you find out maybe someone is your. Your boyfriend or ex boyfriend's dating someone new. So you go into the. Your friend's chat and you're like, oh, my God, like, look it, he's dating so and so. And you guys. So she did that. Shayna, like, brought it up in her friend's group chat. You know, like, look at this is who Ryan is, like, dating now. And Shayna's friends were like, oh, my God, you know, you look so much better than her. She's not even a real blonde. Oh, my God. Just doing what friends do. Later on I mentioned, but we know that Shayna, she had access to his Facebook and she was reading his messages. So I'm assuming that she saw the messages between him and Miss Ohio and, like, that's when she googled her and stuff. But yeah, investigators didn't technically know that she was in Ryan's Facebook at this point. Now, another suspicious Google search Shayna made just an hour before calling 911 was how to unlock a house door using a bobby pin. Hmm. What are you using that for? Why don't you know, it's all speculation here. It doesn't really say anything, but it also is like, you know, Mm hmm. Just not a good look. Nellis and the police, they ended up reviewing over 50,000 text messages, 20,000 Facebook messages, and, like, photos sent between Shayna and Ryan. And they came to the conclusion that these two had a very toxic on again, off again relationship. Okay. It was a lot. Now, the text messages between Shayna and Ryan, they were all over the place. I mean, one minute they would be arguing, the next they were discussing, like, what to eat for dinner. Shayna would text Ryan almost every single day asking what he wanted for dinner, Whether she was cooking it at, like, his place or she was ordering it in, anything. Even if she went out with, like, friends and stuff for dinner, she would send him a picture of, like, the menu and be like, babe, do you want something to eat? I'll bring it home for you. It was a lot. But she always made sure that he had, like, a warm meal waiting for him when he got home. Which doesn't sound bad or anything, right? Like, okay. And if he ever forgot something at home, like his wallet, let's say he went to work, he forgot his wallet. Shayna, she'd, like, bring it to his office for him and be like, do you want me to bring you lunch? You know, whatever. She was always, like, on call all the while. Like, she would be at his condo doing her schoolwork and then, like, cleaning his place, doing his laundry, doing the most. She was. She was really giving Stepford wife energy, you know, which isn't bad if that's what you want to do. But, like, in the text messages and all of all the messages, Ryan never really did anything sweet like that for her. Seemed like he was never thinking about, what do you want for dinner? Like, nothing. It was always from her. And then, like, whenever their relationship was not good, not in a good spot, they'd be fighting. Ryan would be so quick to, like, put her in her place. Yeah, one time there was like this one text message where he told Shayna, honey, it's not a real relationship. It's just exclusive, non touching of other girls. What? Excuse me? And I guess Shayna replied to that, saying, it is a real relationship or I'm not in it. She was all talk. She was still in it. Which is kind of like a dick thing to say, huh? Yeah, just non exclusive touching of other girls. What? You know, at one point, Ryan, he wanted. He wanted out of this relationship. And he tried to really negotiate with her, their breakup, hoping that, like, Shayna would accept it if she got to look like the dumper instead of the dumpee. He texted her, you can tell people you broke up with me. You know, I won't say anything bad about you. Don't worry about the key. Just throw it away. At times, messages would escalate to, like, shayna, stop texting me. I no longer have the patience to deal with you, like in all caps. I'm turning off the phone and padlocking the door. Unsubscribe. You know, like, he was just freaking done. He just sounds like an asshole. But like, listen, Shayna was okay. She was kind of doing a lot. Turns out she would be texting him multiple times a day, back to back. Now I'm not talking like one or two times, you know, she would be sending 20 to 100 texts at a time. Huh? Yes. One of my personal pet peeves is like, when someone's texting you and it'll be like five back to back texts. And it's like, couldn't you just have sent that as one text? It drives me crazy. But anyways, could you imagine 20 to 100? Oh, I would fucking lose it. Anyway, she was texting him all the time. She's complaining about how he treated her. She would be calling out his behavior, essentially having an argument with herself because he wouldn't even be replying to most of her messages. Like, there was this one day, Shayna texted Ryan a long ass paragraph about how she was feeling left out because he had planned on hanging out with his friends after work instead of hanging out with her. Shayna texted him saying, it kind of hurt my feelings that you didn't even want to see me after your events are over at night this weekend. I haven't even seen you in over a week. Aside from last night, that part, it made me giggle. I was like, aside from last night, I just feel like you're going out with these people when you could go out with me after. And I kind of felt excluded. I understand that I can't go to the show. I. But I didn't see anything wrong with seeing you after. And it, like I said, made me wish I was invited over or out with you after. I really just wanted to have a good weekend with you, even if I only saw you tomorrow night after the show. She was saying a lot, a lot. I haven't seen you in over a week. Aside from last night. Sorry, that's just so funny to me. During one of their rocky periods, Shayna had gotten a new cell phone number and she pretended that she was a new client interested in Ryan's legal services. Because, remember, Ryan was an attorney. He was working as an attorney. So she gets this new number and she decides, like, to call his office pretending to be a client. Then she starts texting Ryan for urgent assistance. But instead of keeping the Like, I'm just a client story going. She instead just started, like, crashing out on him. She sent him texts insulting his intelligence, insulting his looks, insulting his performance in bed. She was texting him like, you have a small dick. Lol. Your teeth are jacked up, and you're a bad lawyer. He was like, oh, God. Reading them. You're just like, this girl is fucking idiot. Now, obviously, Ryan was super confused because he had no idea who this person was. He asked like, a couple of times in the. In the text exchange, like, who is this? But he couldn't get an answer. But I will say, based off of his responses, he kept it very professional given what was, like, being thrown his way. He was just like, okay, ha ha, I'll give him that. When I was going through all the documents and, like, evidence that Chief Bill Burkenhauer had sent over to us, I came across this email that Shana had sent Ryan some months before this weird catfish moment happened. Now, the email itself was long, but there was one line that really stood out, so saying, quote, it's sad that I just wanted anything to talk to you and be acknowledged, even if I had to come across as a client to get noticed. Essentially, this email was her apologizing to Ryan for pretending to be a client. And again, this email was dated before the text messages of her pretending to be a client. So I was like, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. Did this happen? Did she do this before? Has she done this before? And she was just doing it again? Either way, she did that. Okay, either way, whether it was once, twice, three times, we don't know, but she was pretending to be a client and just would harass the shit out of him. Listen. Exhausting. Okay? Now, the day of Ryan's murder, Shayna had sent him, like, a bunch of long ass text messages, pretty much just talking about anything and everything she could to get his attention. In these texts, she was told him, like, she was diagnosed with high blood pressure and heart disease and that she was really stressed out about a dying family member just going on and on, like, and the doctor's giving medication. This is the medication. It's. I'm just so stressed just going on and on like, she's trying to get him to bite. You know what I'm saying? She's trying to get a reaction from him. But he didn't reply to any of it, and instead he asked for some personal space. And while the text messages between Shayna and Ryan were a lot, messages between Ryan, Shayna and their friends, co workers, whatever, were actually More telling, Shayna's messages told a story of obsession, deceit, and honestly, straight up harassment, in my opinion. There's a friend of Shayna's. Her name was Jasna. Now Jasna lived in the same town as Ryan, and at one point Shayna told Ryan that she had moved in with Jasna. But then, you know, when the. You go through her, her texts, it seems that wasn't the case. Shayna had texted Jasna, if Ryan ever tries to talk to you on Facebook about where I'm at, don't respond and don't accept his friend request. Haha. He thinks I've stayed with you all this time when I haven't. Haha. Who gives a fuck? He's a dick and abusive. I'm so done with his shit. Will you do that for me if he contacts you? Lol. Because I think he's onto me and thinks I'm being shady. Girl, you are being shady. You are being very shady. She's being exhausting. Ryan. Oh God, she's got Ryan over here thinking like, wow, where are they? What are the odds? I guess we live in the same town now. Shit. But the reality was Shayna hadn't moved in with this friend. She was actually driving two hours to Ryan's town. And then she would stay at a like, hotel or a friend's house, hoping Ryan would call and ask her to come over. She, like, just wanted to be close by just in case she was on call. There were times when Shayna would apparently be like at his condo or whatever, you know, and she would ask if she could borrow his laptop to write a paper for school. And of course, while she's on his laptop, she would log into his Facebook and from his account she would go and like her own photos, then block women he was flirting and slash or messaging with. Okay. And then she would like, message Jasna about it. Just bragging like, haha, block that hoehh. So again, I think that's how she. She found out about Miss Ohio. Now listen, a lot of her friends found it, you know, all this drama kind of funny and entertaining. Remember, they're in their 20s, so it's like f him and like, it's, you know, your early 20s, you don't really realize that it's. It's stalker crazy behavior. So a lot of them are just kind of like, lol, whatever, finding it entertaining. But there were a few of Shayna's friends who were actually trying to get her to like, snap. Snap back to reality, girl. Okay? Get over him and move on. It was said that Shayna did try to date other people, but usually she would do it as a way to like mention it to Ryan to make him feel jealous. You know, she'd be like, yeah, I was with that guy Bobby last night and he like wants to hang out or whatever and he wouldn't even react. There was this one guy where Shayna tried to date him, like more seriously. And her friends were all very supportive of this. They're like, oh my God. Good. Finally, like, maybe this will help you move on. This guy is a great guy. Just try it, Shayna. Just try it. But look, Shayna, she just could not let go of Ryan.

[Sponsor Voice]

January flies by, February creeps up, and then suddenly it's the same old story.

[Bailey Sarian]

You want to start a business, you're too intimidated, you'll do it later.

[Sponsor Voice]

I don't know, you'll do it later. Or having so much time has turned into having zero time. None of it makes sense. While 2026 can be the year you rewrite your story and finally launch. And there's one move that makes it all real. Shopify. Shopify gives you everything you need to sell online and slash or in person. Millions of people have already started using Shopify. Not just first time business owners. Household names like skims are using it too. With Shopify, you can easily build your dream store. Choose from hundreds of templates that you can customize to match your brand. Shopify even offers AI tools that help you to edit product photos and write product descriptions. It just makes the setup easy. Super fast marketing is built in too. You can create email and social campaigns. And as you grow, Shopify grows with you. Your company can handle more orders, even expand to new markets, all from the same dashboard. So don't let February roll around with the same old dream still sitting on the sidelines. No, start your business with Shopify in 2026 and become what you're meant to.

[Bailey Sarian]

Be and try something new.

[Sponsor Voice]

Just try it. Just try it. For once. Just do it.

[Bailey Sarian]

Just try.

[Sponsor Voice]

In 2026, stop waiting and start selling with Shopify. Sign up for your $1 per month trial and start selling [e-mail] makeup. Go to shopify.com makeup. That's shopify.com makeup. Here's your first this new year with Shopify by your side.

[Bailey Sarian]

Asmr. Listen. One of Shayna's closest friends, her name is Christy. Christy was the dentist Shayna referenced in the interrogation video. I mean, did she clearly reference Christy though? She just mentioned like teeth in the interrogation video. Anyways, Chrissy's a dentist, okay? And listen, her and Shannon were close, and they would text all the time. And at one point, Chrissy had gotten, like, so freaking annoyed with Shayna's text messages venting about Ryan that she decided to just reach out to him directly, saying, ryan, Shayna is more upset than usual. She loves you. I have three patients scheduled at 8am so for the love of Christ, can you call her and tell her you love her? Like, she was freaking over it. She's just in the middle of it. But Ryan also, like, you know, when investigators are going through all the messages and everything? Like, it showed that Ryan, he had a little dark side too. Like, he had an angrier side that not a lot of people saw. Like, there was this one night where Ryan was out at a bar, and he ran into one of his ex girlfriends. So he, like, started texting Shayna about it, and he said, quote, I think she's afraid I'm gonna kill her and everyone she knows. I told her I wouldn't be too surprised if that happened, but it would only be if I didn't have anything better to do, okay? Then a year later, he texted Shayna again, talking about his ex girlfriend. He texted Shana, she's terrified of me. One of the reasons she originally started dating me was because she was very aware that I would have killed her ex girl boyfriend at the drop of a hat, and no one would have ever found his body. That's why she dated you. Well, you know, listen, I'll say this, and this is not great, but I will say sometimes when you're younger, in your 20s, and you're like, oh, my God, he'd do anything for me, you think that's, like, super impressive. So I'm imagining, like, Shayna and probably his ex were both like, oh, my God, wow. He would do anything for me, you know? Do you know what I'm saying? Either way. It's unclear how Shayna responded to these messages, but they continued to date, so it wasn't concerning to them, the ex and her. Well, obviously the ex, because she got out of it. The investigators also read some messages where Ryan had admitted to a friend that he was struggling with pills. He told his friend that his depression medication wasn't working for him. Saying. Saying, the stuff they put me on fills me with rage. From what I can tell, he messaged a different friend that same night, saying, quote, he took three Ambien, three Xanax, a Kalanopin, and eventually a shot of vodka. I Laid down to sleep at 12, and I estimate I finally fell asleep at 4:30. I was honestly concerned that I was going to kill myself, but I had to be in court at nine. Three Ambien, three Xanax, Kalana pin. What the. And then he had to be in court. Could you imagine if he was, like, representing you? You hired him as an attorney and he shows up like that? Well, obviously he's struggling with something during this time, like when all these messages were going on and stuff. He was actually going through, I guess, a very stressful legal battle with an example business partner. And apparently it was filling him with rage. He messaged a co worker of his saying, I want this piece of bleep destroyed. He bleeped it out. Bury him neck deep at low tide, throw darts at his head, wait for high tide to roll in so I can stomp on his head while he's drowning. I want to rig explosives to everything I see, and there's nothing I want more than to just scorch the effing earth and leave this entire city in a pile of burnt rubble. Because my brain has a trip wire in there somewhere, and if it snaps, I worry about what would happen, bro. So he, too, seemed to be struggling with some issues there, too. You're allowed to be angry and stuff, you know, that doesn't mean you deserve to die. Let's be fair here. Ryan even said to a friend that maybe being a sociopath is the way to go. Yeah, that's always the answer. Huh? It sounds like he was taking a bunch of medications and, like, maybe they just. They weren't. Well, obviously he's taking a bunch of medications, really, but, like, they weren't finding the right combination for him that was working, Obviously, with all this evidence. The police wrapped up their investigation and it was time to move forward, forward with the trial. Finally, two and a half years after Shayna's arrest, her trial finally started on April 13, 2015, in Newport, Kentucky. She was now 24 years old. I know, I. I forget how young she is. 24. She was 22. Yeah. And she pled not guilty to Ryan's murder. She was sticking with her story of self defense. On day one, the prosecution played the interrogation video and the 911 call for the court. They then called Police Chief Bill Birkenhauer to the stand, and he revealed that Shayna had not immediately called 911 after shooting Ryan. This was new news to me. She actually called her mother first, and then about 15 minutes later, later, she called 911. In the interrogation video, Shayna admitted that she actually considered fleeing the scene, but her mom advised her to just call the police and tell the truth. And the police call log actually showed that Shayna's mom, she called 911 to make sure that Shayna had called 911. So at least her mom was, like, not trying to let her get away with it. You know, experts testified about everything from blood spatter to how they believed Shayna used the murder weapon, which was a SIG Sella.380 semi automatic handgun. Mouthful, huh? But she used that to kill Ryan. But some of the most interesting testimony came from some of Shayna's jailmates. Oh, yeah. You know, while she was in jail, she was talking. Of course she was talking as she.

[Sponsor Voice]

Was talking a lot.

[Bailey Sarian]

One woman, her name was Cecily Miller. She testified that Shayna joked a lot about the shooting in jail, even telling that, like, that nose job joke over and over again. She just thought it was hilarious. She said that Shayna openly talked about her legal strategy and how she was going to get away with it, and that Shayna believed she was just way too smart to plead insanity because she had the IQ of Einstein, according to Shanna. So she was going to plead battered wife syndrome. This is what the Cecily lady was saying. Then another jailmate, Holly Nivens, she testified that Shayna's original story, like, when they first met, was that Ryan had mentally and sexually abused her. But over time, her story changed, you know, of course it did. So her story changed to now making it sound like she knew exactly what she was doing. And again, like, she was almost bragging to Holly about killing him. Holly also testified that Shayna was taking notes on the Jodi Arias trial. Yes, it was airing at the time. And that she was kind of, like, using it as a guide for what to do and, like, what not to do in the courtroom. I did a whole murder mystery and makeup episode on Jodi Arias, if you remember, or if you want to watch that one. A lot of similarities here, but while Jody's trial was happening, I guess they were, like, showing it in the rec room at the jail Shayna was in. So she'd be watching, like, taking notes. She was inspired. And then a third and final jail mate took the stand. Her name was Donna Dooley. And she testified that Shayna told her on the night of the murder, they were sitting. This was a quote, like, they were sitting at the kitchen table, and he had sat his gun on the table. She told me she picked up the gun and said, what would you do if I. And then he smirked and she shot him. Now, this version of Shayna's story kind of fits with what the forensics experts had been saying, that Ryan was sitting down when he was killed. So then Ryan's downstairs neighbors, Vernon and Doris west, they were called to testify about what they heard that night. They said they never heard any, like, fighting or arguing, but around 8:30pm they heard a woman crying out on the balcony. And then about 15 minutes later, it sounded like she had, like, gone back inside. Then, I guess they heard two gunshots followed by four more shots, and then what sounded like a body hitting the floor. My mind was like, did they call the police? Because if you look at the police records, their names didn't show up. But maybe you're just overlooking, maybe they did. Or maybe they're just like, nah, that's our crazy neighbor again. I don't know. But that's what they heard that night. That crazy neighbor, he's always shooting stuff. Carissa, remember Ryan's cousin, she testified about some of the texts she got from Ryan where he was expressing his frustrations. He texted her saying, quote, this is getting to be restraining order level crazy. She's shown up at my condo, like, three times and refuses to leave each time, end quote. Now, during this time, when this whole situation went down, in order to get a restraining order and against someone in Kentucky, you either had to be living with the person or be married to them. So there's no record that, like, Ryan was trying to get a restraining order. But I just thought it was interesting that even if he did want to, Kentucky wouldn't have even allowed it because they got some funky ass law over there. Carissa also testified, saying that he texted her, quote, she came to my place on Sunday morning, and I literally had to pick her up and throw her into the hall, end quote. So she's, like, talking about these text messages. She also mentioned on the stand that there was a time where Shayna took her phone to call Ryan because he was ignoring Shayna's calls, and she knew that, like, he would pick up the call if it was Carissa calling. So again, just further telling the court that Shayna was freaking obsessed and Ryan was obviously bothered by it. So Shayna's lawyer focused on showing the jury that Shayna and Ryan's relationship wasn't as negative as the prosecution was making it seem. Okay, there were several texts between the two of them that were completely normal and loving and even sometimes, you know, spicy. You know, they're like, look, nudes. See, they loved each other. But the big question her lawyer asked the court was, if things were so bad, then why did Ryan invite Shayna over to his parents house the night before he died? And in my mind, I'm like, how is that helping our self defense case? I. I don't. Okay. And then it gets worse, okay? Because Shayna's lawyers, they then call to the stand Christie, Shayna's friend, who was also a dentist, because investigators had found some very interesting text between the two of them. So Shayna had texted Christy 10 days before the murder, saying, when I go to the shooting range with Ryan tonight, I want to turn around, shoot him, and kill him, and play like it's an accident. Yeah, Shayna had texted that to Christy, but Christy swore up and down that it was nothing more than a joke. Like, she was very team Shayna. I think that's why they brought her to the stand, to show, like, she's funny. Ha ha, ha ha. See, everyone? She was just kidding. Christy said they were just kidding. I think that's what they were trying to do because I was there here. Like, how does that help? That does not help. But then there was another text message, and this was sent two days before the murder. Shayna texted Christy saying, quote, ryan has been begging me to ask if you could do his veneers. Please fuck them up and make him ugly so he'll never get another girl. I hate him again. I was like, how is this helping her case? I don't know. Shayna did not take the stand, but. But a clinical psychologist that was, like, working with her in jail, took the sand, testified about her mental state, saying that she was struggling with PTSD from the shooting and was like, waking up in the middle of the night screaming, which is just telling the court, like, see? Regret, I don't know. And then going on to say that Shayna had an IQ of 125, which is. Is above average, but not Einstein level. I guess Einstein's IQ was around, like, 160. I hate when people brag about their IQ. It's like, who gives a shit? You're in jail, so obviously you're not that smart. Okay? If you were that smart, you would be out, like, doing math on a freaking whiteboard. You're in prison. The psychologist also told the court that he diagnosed Shayna with two disorders, Bipolar disorder and personality disorder with narcissistic features. And he talked about her history of alcohol and prescription drug abuse as well. Then on April 23, the closing arguments were made. Shana's team told the court that she was just defending herself against Ryan under Kentucky's stand your ground law, and that, yes, she may have been obsessed with him, but that doesn't mean she was a murderer.

[Police Officer]

Ow.

[Bailey Sarian]

The prosecution argued that Shayna was just a freaking liar. Okay? And they brought out the blood stained table and chair from Ryan's kitchen. What do you call that? What do you call that area you sit in? Dining room. They brought in the blood stained table and chair from his dining room, and they reenacted what they believed happened that night. So in their version, they believe that Shayna grabbed the gun from the table, shot Ryan twice while he was, like, sitting down. He fell forward. He was twitching. And then she shot him four more times before his body fell to the floor. Floor. That's what they think happened. So the jury went and, you know, did their deliberations, and five hours later, they came back with a verdict. Shayna Hubers was found guilty. And on August 14, 2015, the judge sentenced Shayna to 40 years in prison with the possibility of parole after 20 years served. Now, listen, you're about to click out of this video, but it's not over. No. No, it's not. It keeps going because you think, oh, okay, great. Case closed. The end. Nope. Nay. Nay. It's only just begun. Right after sentencing, Shayna's lawyers, you know, they started to prepare an appeal. While reviewing court records and footage, one of her attorneys realized they recognized a face in the jury box. They're like, hey, I know that guy. Turns out one of the jurors in Shayna's original trial was actually a convicted felon from a case that these lawyers had handled over a decade earlier. Meaning one of the jury members on Shayna's original trial was a convicted felon. Now, this might not seem like a big deal, but this is exactly what Shayna's team needed, because a convicted felon cannot legally serve on a jury. So with that discovery, the judge declared a mistrial, granting Shayna a brand new trial. Oy. Now, obviously, this is very exciting news to Shayna. She's like, yay. So she sat in jail waiting for her next trial date. Jail life didn't seem too rough for Shayna. In 2016, she met the love of her life. She fell in love with another inmate named Unique Taylor, who is a trans woman. They dated for, like, two years. And then the couple, they applied for a marriage license through the Campbell county clerk's office. But when days went by and they got no response, Shayna she reached out to the local news station saying that she and her fiance were being discriminated against for not receiving their license. Now, the news station agreed to do, like, an interview and met with Shayna at the jail. While the reporter tried asking about her upcoming retrial, Shayna, she dodged those questions and she steered everything back to her marriage request. Now, eventually, the journalists asked what many people were thinking, like, is this just a ploy for sympathy? And Shayna insisted, no, no, no. It's all about love. We just want to be together. But listen, it's the timing. The timing was raising some eyebrows because during this time of her, like, her interview and everything, LGBTQIA plus rights were dominating the headlines with several discrimination cases making major news, really. And there was also a major Supreme Court case that was happening at the same time. So it was making her interview feel less like a coincidence and more like a strategy. So after the interview aired, the clerk's office clarified the situation, saying that they had actually never denied Shayna's request. It had only been, like, a few weeks, and they simply. They just hadn't been. They hadn't processed it yet. So they. They were like, yeah, that. Okay. And literally, like, not long after the license was granted, and on June 7th of 2018, 27 year old Shana Hubers married 41 year old Unique Taylor. So now married, Shayna once again prepared to step back into the courtroom. So Shayna's team pushed to have the trial moved. They were arguing that her reputation was already destroyed and finding, like, a fair jury would be impossible. They also were trying to suppress the. The interrogation footage, saying that her rights had been violated. Now, these motions, they drag things out, okay? But ultimately, the judge denied them both. So on August 14, 2018, the trial actually starts. Opening statements are made, much of the same evidence and witnesses from the first trial returned, but this time, Shayna took the stand herself. Oh, yes, she did. She sat up there looking all. You know, when they come looking all, like, humble with, like, a cardigan and like, I could never. Not I. She was giving that. Her testimony focused a lot on her and Ryan's sex life because she said that this was where their relationship really fell apart. She testified that whenever they had sex, she really struggled with reaching an orgasm and that Ryan was kind of an asshole about it. According to Shayna, Ryan would bring up her past sexual traumas and, like, blame her for not being able to have an orgasm. And she's explaining to the core like, you know, he. It made her feel bad. He was like, it was verbally abusive. Shayna also testified that Ryan would basically bribe her into, like, doing certain sex acts. Listen, I believe this because he seems like this type. He promised to Shayna to post 10 pictures of them together on Facebook, give her more affection, and communicate with her more if and only if she agreed to a threesome. This is what she's saying in court. And according to Shayna, she went along with it. She went along with that deal because all she wanted was his love. Let me get this lip liner on. Hold on. Closing arguments felt like deja vu. The prosecutor even dragged out the blood stained table again and did, like the whole reenactment. And again, just after five hours of deliberation, the jury came back with their verdict. Guilty of first degree murder. But this time, they recommended she receive life in prison. Her team really shouldn't have pushed for an appeal because they ended up getting a worse outcome for her. Before handing down his judgment, the judge said to Shayna, your actions that evening were grossly violent and indeed intentionally calculated to cause his death. And then he sentenced her to life in prison with the possibility of parole after serving 20 years. Now listen. A few months after being sentenced to life, Shayna filed for divorce from Unique, and it was granted. So was it for show? I don't know. But she was quick to do that. It was like, Damn. Okay. In 2020, Shayna's lawyers had filed yet another appeal, saying the media coverage was like, way too heavy and certain evidence should have been tossed out. But at this point, again, it feels like they're just grasping at straws. And the appeals court upheld the conviction. So where are they now? Shayna, she is now 34 years old and she's serving her time at a maximum security prison outside of Lou's. Louisville. Louisville, Kentucky. You guys are gonna roast me, how you say it? Louisville. Louisville. Louisville. She's in prison there. Okay. And she won't be able to apply for parole until September of like 2032. That's it. Listen. Hi. Yes. And that, my friends, is the exhausting freaking story case of Shayna Hubers. The so called Kentucky Jodi Arias. A woman whose obsession and need for control just turned deadly. Was it self defense, like she said? Or was it the ultimate punishment for like a boyfriend who just like wanted to leave, you know, at the end of the day, Ryan poston, he was 29. He was 29 years old. You know, he had a future, friends, family, everything. And that was all taken from him because of. For wood, because of Shayna. And it just left like the people who loved him the most with such a major loss, you know, it was just sad. I mean, the sad truth is that we may never really know what. What really, like, what happened that night. Like what. How it all went down. It's clear the relationship was toxic, and Shayna was completely obsessed. And, yeah, Ryan was like an F boy, a little boy, but that doesn't mean he deserved to be murdered. And remember how I mentioned that Kentucky law where it's like, you couldn't get a restraining order unless, like, you live together or whatever? Well, in 2016, Kentucky passed a law creating what's called a interpersonal protective order. It's basically like a restraining order, but specifically for victims of dating violence, stalking, or sexual assault. It can prohibit contact, require the abuser to stay away, and if they violate it, they can be arrested. You know, it's. It's some improvement because like I mentioned earlier, you. You only had to be married or living together, so that's changed. But you and I know that, like a lot of the times, restraining orders don't even. They don't even work. Sometimes people don't really even follow them. Whatever. But it's. It's some improvement. Bailey, just say that. Yes. Anyways, we made it. Thank you so much for hanging out with me today. I hope you have a good rest of your day. Be safe out there. If you are being stalked or harassed, don't be afraid to reach out and ask for help. Especially you men talking to you, because sometimes you guys feel like you don't want to. You know, you can handle it, whatever. But you also can reach out if you need help. And you should. Wow, Bailey, that was motivational. I know. I'm trying. I hope you have a good rest of your day. Make your choices. Be safe out there. I'll be seeing you guys later. Goodbye. From taco night in Tulum to sushi in Tokyo, make every bite rewarding with gold from Amex. Wherever you dine. 4 times. Membership rewards points at restaurants worldwide are piling up. Learn more@american express.com Explore-Gold terms and points cap apply.

[Sponsor Voice]

So you're running out of closet space. But the good news is you don't need to stop shopping. You just need to start selling with the RealReal. The RealReal is the world's largest and most trusted source for authenticated luxury resale. Whether it's that mini bag that can't even fit your phone or those boots you never fully broke in, the RealReal handles everything from photography and copywriting to shipping and pricing. So you can just sit back, get paid, and make room for things that actually feel like you. And with 10,000 plus new arrivals every single day from top designers like Prada, Celine, Louis Vuitton, and Loewe, all for up to 90% off retail, you're bound to find something perfectly on brand to fill that extra closet space with. Plus, only for the month of January, you can earn up to $550 extra when you sell. Make room for what feels like you go to therealreal.com to start selling and earn up to $550 extra to keep shopping. That's therealreal.com terms apply.