
Loading summary
A
Hi, friends. How are you today? My name is Bailey Sarian and today is Monday, which means it's murder mystery and makeup Monday. Hi. If you're new here. Hi, my name is Bailey Sarian and on Mondays I sit down, I talk about true crime story that's been heavy on my noggin and I do my makeup at the same time. So today's story, let me tell you, it's rough. It's real bad. We're talking about this guy. His name's Otis Toole. He was a serial arsonist, rapist, murderer, and self proclaimed cannibal. Between the early 60s and the early 80s, Otis, he had killed like allegedly over 100 people across at least like 26 states in the U.S. some of his victims were hitchhikers, teenagers and sex workers. Others were massage parlor employees, bank tellers, or like convenience store workers. Workers. This guy, he, he's wild. He like dismembered some of his victims and then like drove around in his car with the body parts. Yeah. And. And then at times he allegedly like drank their blood. So here we go with that, you know. So Otis, he actually committed many of his gruesome crimes with another notorious seizure serial killer. This is like a crossover episode. His name was Henry Lucas. Did we do an episode on him? I can't remember right now. But Henry Lucas is also like this crazy serial killer and him and Otis linked up and they were like allegedly lovers. On top of all that, there's a cult thrown into the mix. This one's got everything right. I know there's a lot going on, baby. And this is just the intro. Let's start with Otis, huh? So Otis Elwood Toole, he was born March 5, 1947, and he was raised in Jacksonville, Florida. It was said that his father, not a great guy, he was like an alcoholic. And he ended up leaving the family when Otis was just a kid, but not before causing his son Otis significant damage. Now, according to Otis himself, when he was just five years old, his father forced him to have sexual relations with his father's friend. If that wasn't enough, Otis mother, I guess also like abused him. She would dress him up in girl's clothing and then call him Susan. Yep. So mommy wasn't safe, Daddy wasn't safe. Safe. And then his older sister, she too wasn't safe because it was said, this is all according to Otis. He said that his older sister started having sex with him before he could even like really understand what was going on. And then I'm laughing because it's just you know, it's just because it gets worse because everyone's messed up, right? And then Otis's grandma, I guess she had added to all the abuse. So Otis grandma, it was said that she was a Satanist, and she called Otis the devil's child. Cute. I don't know, you know, like, I don't know, you know? Yep. All right, so instead of, like, teaching him how to be a kid, I don't know, just be normal, how to play, read, cook, show him love, she instead showed young Otis satanic practices and rituals and introduced him to one of her favorite hobbies. Grave robbing. Great. So I think between you and I, I think it's safe to say that Otis had a rough upbringing, right? And it's probably would be surprising if Otis grew up to be like, quote unquote normal after all these horrible experiences.
B
You know, when, like, you're just minding your own business, making coffee, scrolling, sitting, staring at the sky, doing your makeup, whatever. I don't know. And then suddenly your brain goes like, hey, what if you did something, like, really messed up? Or maybe you have some really, like.
A
Intrusive thoughts just come in, you know.
B
And you're just like. And now your whole morning or your day is kind of hijacked by a thought that you want it in the first place. Listen, if that's you, you're not alone. And there's actually help for that. That's where NOCD comes in. NOCD is the world's leading provider of OCD treatment, and they specialize in something called erp, which stands for Exposure and Response Prevention Therapy. It's the gold standard for treating ocd. And it's designed to help you stop fighting with those intrusive thoughts and start taking their power away. Their therapists actually get it. They know how real and disturbing those thoughts can feel, and they create a safe, judgment, free space to work through them. And listen, you can do it all virtually. It's covered by insurance for over 155 million Americans. And they even support you between sessions so you're not stuck kind of white knuckling it alone. Your brain will always serve you some weird, random, sometimes terrifying thoughts. And, you know, that's sometimes what brains do. But when those thoughts start running, the show taking over, you know, you don't have to live like that. No CD can help you shut down the endless mental what if loop and actually learn to work through it.
A
Trust yourself again and live.
B
Live your life. So if your brain's been playing True Crime Home Edition lately, go to nocd.com that's n o c d dot com, and get the right help.
A
So it was said that Otis had behavioral and, like, mental issues that were pretty obvious from an early age. He also had epilepsy, which caused him to have, like, some serious seizures. So when Otis was in school, he was diagnosed with intellectual disability because he had an IQ of 75. And, you know, I guess the average IQ score is anywhere from, like, 90 to 109. So he was just a little off, you know, during his childhood, Otis ran away from his home pretty often. And I guess he would just, like, run away, go find an abandoned house somewhere and just, like, sleep there. Yeah, I don't know. I mean, probably just a wild guess here, but I'm sure it was to get away from his psycho family. It's so sad, but when he was alone, this is when he. He liked to play with fire, you know, and he would burn things, and soon he just became an arsonist. He would say, from a young age, setting fires sexually aroused him. So Otis ended up dropping out of school in the ninth grade, and this is when he began visiting, like, local gay bars. And around the same time, as a teenager, he became a male sex worker. And he also, I guess, developed, like, an obsession with pornography. This is a side note. I mean, I'm sure we all maybe feel this way, maybe we don't. But I feel so bad for him. Like, he really just had a crappy upbringing, and he was not set up to be great guy. You know, it's just really sad. Two things can be right at the same time. He can be a really terrible person, and we hate him, and we can also feel bad for him. Like, there's nothing wrong with that. Now, according to Otis, he committed his first murder when he was just 14 years old. So at this age, he was picked up by a traveling salesman. And I guess this traveling salesman got a little forceful with Otis. We don't really know exactly what happened, but what we do know is that some kind of altercation happened, and Otis was able to, like, take over the guy's car and somehow get the guy out of the car. He takes over the car, runs the guy over with it. Guess he killed him. Otis would talk about this later in life, but at the time, he was never caught for this or, like, charged. So Otis, like, kind of just disappeared off the radar between 1966 and 1973. Some people believe that he was drifting around in the Southwest, like, United States at the time, but that's just what people believe. No One really knows. Then in 1974, he was considered a suspect in a murder case. But before he could be questioned by police, he actually ends up taking off to Boulder, Colorado. In September of 1974, Otis allegedly raided a massage parlor in Colorado Springs. So he goes into like this massage parlor, allegedly, and he goes in there and he like stabs and he slashed the throat of an employee. Her name was Yon Lee. He moved on to Lee's co worker and like raped her. Then he stabbed and shot her to death. I mean it was aggressive. It was, it was a lot. It was aggressive and angry and hate fueled. Like it was bad because then, then on top of that, he ends up setting them both on fire. Yeah, but listen, somehow yon Lee, she ended up surviving. Oh yeah. And you know, she was able to call the police and she gave a description of who her attacker was. She tells the police that it was this guy, like 6 foot 2, 195 pounds, clean shaven white man in a white pickup truck. And that's really all she knew. But what we know now is that it matched Otis's description. Unfortunately, at the time, like Otis was, he wasn't, he was never found. The next month, in October 1974, 31 year old Ellen, she was abducted in Pueblo, Colorado and she was found like shot three times in the head. Her body ended up getting dumped near the Oklahoma border. At the time it was unsolved. Like there was like kind of, they didn't know, they didn't have any leads on this. But then later on, like homicide detectives would link Otis to this crime. But at the time it was just kind of like, I don't know now, before police could get to him, he had left Boulder and he returned to Jacksonville, Florida in 1975. So while he's back in Florida, he started again working as, you know, a male sex worker. So this part is a little vague in his history because like he ends up meeting a woman and he ends up getting married to her in like January of 1976. She is 25 years older than him and not sure how they met, there's just not much known. But it was said like much later in life, Otis, he gave like interviews, whatever. So much later he said that he married this woman because he needed to or he wanted to hide his true sexuality. So he gets married to some woman. So in 1976, after he gets married, this is when Otis meets Henry Lee Lucas in a Jacksonville soup kitchen. Now just a few years later, like after this meeting, Henry would become one of like the most notorious American serial killers in history. And we'll probably never find out how many people Henry actually killed. But him and Otis were working together, really. So Henry had reached Jacksonville with, like, no money and nowhere to stay. So he had learned that there was, like, a religious mission that offered free food and housing, and that's where he met Otis. The two of them somehow just connected. They started talking, chatting it up, and they really seemed to hit it off because, like, after meeting for the first time, Otis invited Henry to come back to his place. Now, Henry and Otis, they would become lovers, I think many say, because of, like, based on, like, mutual attraction. And also they had. They had similar stories. They had a lust for killing. They also had, like, super messed up backgrounds and family history. So they just, like, really bonded and connected on all that. I mean, both Henry and Otis had been raised by abusive mothers who had forced their sons to dress as girls. Both had suffered sexual trauma before the age of 10. And by the time they met, both of them were already murderers. So they're like, hey, you like that shit? I like that shit too. And then they just, like, hit it off, and they're perfect for each other. So for Henry and Otis, killing was like, just a way for them to bond. You know, they talked about it openly. They would compare, not notes, and they would give. They would give each other tips, like, hey, I chopped off the head first, and then I went for, like, the feet and stuff. What about you? And like, I went for the feet and stuff, not the head. Like, you know, just notes. So at this time, Otis was living in a fairly small house, but he was sharing the house with, like, a bunch of people. It was Otis's mom, his stepdad, Otis's wife, Otis's niece and nephew, who were like 11 or 12 years old. And then Otis, so six people. And I guess the family was, like, quite used to Otis bringing strange men home from the mission to have sexual relations with. It wasn't unusual. It was normal. But what made it weird and inappropriate was, like, he would bring men back to his home to have sex with him, but also to have sex with his wife and his underage niece. Yeah, you know, Otis is one of those people who like, what do you call them when they like to watch? When they like to watch, you know what I'm saying? But when Otis brought Henry back to his place, it was a little different. He wanted Henry, like, all to himself. He didn't want to share. So he told his wife to go, to go, like, live with the neighbors, go Stay with the neighbors, you know, so he and Henry could have the main bedroom. I guess Otis felt like his wife was in the way. And honestly, he was getting a little jealous because she was trying to come in between him and Henry, you know, and Otis, he wanted Henry all to himself. Well, according to police records, shortly after Henry and Otis met, they spent their free time drinking and, like, cruising the highways looking for quote, unquote fun. Now, apparently their idea of fun, different than a lot of ours, they like to, like, rob, rob small convenience stores and banks. They stole money, food, beer, and I guess they just really enjoyed, like, terrorizing the staff of wherever they were robbing. Now, the two of them, they became bolder and more violent over time. Things progressed. Eventually their crimes became more brutal to the point where, like, if the person that they were robbing or harassing, if that person, like, resisted at all, they would just, like, they didn't think twice. They would just gun them down and then just leave them in, like, a pool of blood. So apparently Otis and Henry robbed, like, a small convenience store in western Georgia. I guess Henry had walked to the front counter, he pulled out a.22 caliber handgun and he held it to the temple of the female clerk. He then binds her with, like, a rope, then drags her to the back of the store while Otis went through the register. So I guess like the woman, well, naturally, you know, she's gonna. She's screaming. She's screaming and she's struggling and she's trying to get loose. And Henry tells her, like, if she doesn't keep quiet, he's going to have to shoot her. So I guess at this moment, she just obeyed. So Henry and Otis were like, dividing the money up. And that's when Henry noticed that the woman was trying to leave, loosen the ropes again. So he, Henry casually, like, walk to the back of the store and he just, again, doesn't hesitate, and he shot her right through the temple. Afterwards, while Henry loaded stolen cases of beer into their car, Otis took this opportunity to have sexuals with the woman's body. And I guess they did this a lot. Yeah, Otis and Henry seemed to be, like, competitive with one another, like they were trying to prove who was, who was more lethal, who was more bad. Just, just not great, these guys. Otis later bragged to police of one such incident.
B
When you're starting your own business, people love to call it a small business, but there's nothing small about it. Late nights, early mornings, you're doing it all alone. You're like, what the heck am I doing. There's a million decisions that somehow feel like, you know, they could really make or break your entire future. You're the boss, you're the marketing team, you're the customer service. And you're also sweeping the floors, you know. But listen, having the right tools can make all the difference. And that's why I love Shopify. Shopify is the commerce platform built for people who are juggling everything to keep their business running. They make shopping convenient for your customers no matter how they buy. Endless aisle, ship to customer, buy online, pick up in store. It's all simpler. Shopify POS helps you get returning customers with personalized experiences and first party data that give your marketing an edge when starting your own thing. Those little decisions, you know, they can feel huge. But with Shopify, you can have confidence that, you know, you're not just guessing because they have a system built to make everything easier, whether you're just starting or scaling up. Give your big dream, the platform it deserves. Get all the big stuff for your small business right? With Shopify, stop seeing carts going abandoned and turn those sales into Sign up for your $1 per month trial and start selling today at shop.com makeup go to shopify.com makeup shopify.com makeup while cruising.
A
On the i35 highway through Texas, they, Henry and Otis came across like a teenage couple walking alongside the road. I guess the couple's car had run out of gas and the and they were on their way to a gas station. So Otis and Henry, they see this couple and they pull over and Otis steps out of the vehicle and without even hesitation, just like, shoots the boy nine times in the head and his chest and then rolls his body into a tunnel under the road while Henry dragged the girl into the backseat of the car. So Otis drove the car, they take off and, you know, Henry's in the backseat, like, repeatedly raping the girl. Otis said that watching Henry have sex with, like, someone else made him angry. These two are just so fucked up. He's getting angry. He's driving the car. Otis. So I guess in a jealous rage, Otis stops the car. He dragged the girl out onto the road and then shot her six times and then just left while they drove back towards Jacksonville. Everyone they came in contact with in their eyes was like a potential victim. Drifters, women with car troubles, hitchhikers, they would all fall victim to this deadly duo. Usually when they committed a murder, it was like done in a very remote area where, you know, there were no witnesses. And if their car broke down or ran out of gas. Otis and Henry, they would just, like, steal another one, usually after murdering the driver. And then they would just jump in and be like, it's ours now. The two of them, if they stole a car, they would drive the vehicle to another state, dump it, and then hitchhike to, like, the next location. Henry said that he enjoyed killing women whose cars had broken down on lonely roads, Telling police that he considered. Considered them, quote, free lunch. What do you even say to that? What do you even say to that, huh? There was one victim that was found, like, dumped in a field. She was found, like, completely nude. She had been stabbed 35 times in the chest, the neck, arms, and the back. And they were, like, deep cuts that were made along the inside of her arms and from the middle of her chest to all the way down to the pubic bone. This is on, like, dark, you know. On top of that, both nipples had been cut off and removed. I would say, like, this guy's like, a truly a psycho. But I feel like psycho isn't even the right word for how dark these guys are. Maybe they really are children of Satan or whatever grandma called them. So according to police who pieced together their trail from, like, pay slips and discarded vehicles, they believe that Otis and Henry were responsible for up to four to five murders in each state before moving across state lines. The police believed that on, like, more than two occasions, the pair committed several murders in a single day. Now, cult, where does that come in? Let me tell you, because according to both Otis and Henry, while they were on their murder sprees, they were approached by a stranger who offered them a job. Now, the job was to, like, deliver stolen cars to various destinations. And I guess Henry wasn't really too interested in this. And he's like, no, I'm good. Like, he felt like it would just increase their chances of getting caught by the police. Like, they didn't need it. They were doing just fine without it, they said. After that, the stranger then made another offer. The stranger asked if they would be interested in contract killing for his quote, unquote organization. The stranger told them that they would be paid $10,000 for each execution. Well, after hearing this, now Henry and Otis, they were. They were interested $10,000. I mean, that's a lot of money, you know? And they figured that since they'd been killing for fun, they might as well just, like, get paid for it. The stranger said they would be hired on one condition. Otis and Henry had to join the organization's religion. So Henry asked, like, okay, what's this religion, you know. And the stranger told him that it was like a group and they called themselves the Hand of Death. And this group, they worshiped the devil. Now later on, Otis would kind of disagree with some of these meeting details, but apart from like their differences in their stories, they both swore that they did in fact join the Hand of Death. And also, side note, if you look up the Hand of Death and you go on like a deep dive trying to find information about it, you don't find anything about it, only when it's linked to this story. So, you know, I don't know, fishy. But look. So they end up joining, I guess several weeks like later they travel to Florida to meet the leaders of this cult. They end up meeting in an abandoned warehouse on Miami's waterfront. And the same stranger, whoever that stranger was, this same stranger met them and introduced himself as Dawn. When Don began to talk about the crimes that the two had committed in the past, Henry became a little suspicious about the situation and asked Don, like, how he knew so much about Henry and Otis. He's like, how'd you know how many crimes we've done? How do you know about me? And I guess at this point Don laughed and said that Otis had actually been working for him for years. So what was it? A, a setup? Henry told police years later that at the time he felt betrayed by Otis and he couldn't believe that, like he had been manipulated by him into joining the cult. So that night, in an abandoned spot in the Florida Everglades, Henry was inducted into the Hand of Death. Later he and Otis were taken deeper into like the Everglades on an airboat. I had to look this up cuz I was like, what's an airboat? What's a boat with those giant fans on the back of it? I'm laughing because I'm sure everyone knows what an airboat is. I just, I didn't. That's okay. Anyways, they went on a giant airboat and they, they get taken deeper into the Everglades and they were taken to an island where Henry would undergo quote unquote training. So Don had told them that from now on, Henry had to do everything he was told, no matter what. Like he had to obey. And once Henry proved himself, that's when he would officially be one of the members in the cult. So both men were then taken into a tent and Henry was told to wait for his assignment. So he's waiting there, like an hour goes by. Finally Don comes back and tells him that his target was in the next tent, and that Henry needed to, like, go into that tent and cut that person's throat. But he had to make sure that, like, it was a clean cut, because the cult peeps, the cult people, they would need the body later. So, armed with a knife, Henry and Otis went to the next tent. Otis went in first, and he, like, struck up a conversation with the male that was inside of the tent. Otis then lured the man to, like, a nearby beach with the promise of a drink. I guess Otis had, like, a bottle of whiskey or something with him, and he's like, hey, like, let's go have a drink and look at the water. He lures him out. Meanwhile, Henry is, like, waiting in the shadows. And when Otis hands the man the bottle, you know, he takes a swig, and he, like, tips his head back. That's when Henry comes running up, grabs the man hair, grabs the man's hair, and then in one quick swipe, he, like. Yeah. It was said that Henry was congratulated on a quick, clean kill. Again, we don't even know, like, if this story is true or not, where it's coming from or anything, because you can't find any evidence about any of this. Even investigators didn't find anything about this. So could be true, could be made up. But the fact that they had, like, similar details to the story, it sounds like it wasn't made up, but I don't know. No one knows. But later that night, Henry attended his first black mass mass, during which, like, the man that he had just killed was in, cooked, and eaten by everyone in the cult. So there's that. So in the weeks after that, Henry said that he was taught the finer points of kidnapping, arson, murder, and child abduction. He was also taught, like, the best way to prepare a human sacrifice. Around seven weeks later, Henry, I guess, completed his training and was ready to, quote, go to work. So then he and Otis set off on a road trip to the southern states to kidnap children. Yeah, they would kidnap children, and these children would either be used as, like, in sacrificial ceremonies within the cult, or they would be trafficked and sold on the gray market to wealthy families. According to Otis and Henry, they said that they had kidnapped multiple kids, from babies to teenagers, and they did horrible things. I left all the horrible things they did out. I. It's just. It's a lot. It's real bad. Police would later, like, search huge areas of the Florida everglades by boat and helicopter, looking for any kind of evidence they could find of this cult's existence. But they found nothing. They never did. Henry explained this by telling police that the cult was a nationwide conspiracy involving senior police officials and politicians. And they had the power to disappear if they wanted, wanted to. So yeah, they were hard to find. You know, allegedly after carrying out further tasks for this death cult, Henry was told like to just go back home and wait for further instructions. I guess though, at the time, like Otis decided to stay back and he was like, I'll meet up with you later. So Henry left and Otis stayed. Now, if this cult did in fact exist, and if Henry was paid handsomely for the crimes he committed, there was no evidence of like, his newfound wealth, you know, when he returned to Jacksonville. So In May of 1981, Otis's mother, Sarah, she, I guess had died of old age. And after her death, they took in like their niece, Otis's niece and nephew. So they take in the niece and nephew, the niece's name is Becky. And they decide to travel together, the four of them, to California during this like cross country road trip. They murdered people along the way. They caused chaos. They just did all the bad things you can think of. They were doing it okay. And like a lot of the times the niece and nephew would just be like waiting in the car for them. They're like, hey, we'll be right back. And they'd just be waiting in the car. I know, I don't know. We don't know if they knew what was going on. I'm assuming they didn't. I don't know, but it was fucked up. Oh, and I forgot to mention Henry and the niece, Becky, they were involved in like a little love situation. A relationship is what Henry would call it, but she was 12, so I don't think anyone would call it that. Anyway, during their cross country road trip, Otis got really sick and ended up having to be hospitalized. And then while he was hospitalized, Henry, he got arrested, he got caught for theft and he was in like thrown in jail. So the niece and the nephew, they were returned to their biological mother. This whole thing was just a shit show. I don't know what their plan was with the niece and nephew. Eventually both of the guys would return to Jacksonville, Florida, like when they got out from the hospital and from jail. And by 1983, the relationship between Otis and Henry, it had begun to fall apart. No one really knows why they, they fell apart, but they ended up going their own ways. They split up, see you later. And they just. Goodbye. Otis was left on his own, but that didn't stop him from Doing some wild shit. He ended up getting arrested in June of 1983 after he burned down two houses in Jacksonville, Florida. And while he was in custody, Otis ended up confessing to starting around 40 different fires in the last like two decades. He also confessed to starting a fire in Jacksonville, in a Jacksonville boarding house back in January of 1982. And in this fire it ended up killing like a 65 year old man. His name was George Sonberg. So he tells police that he was responsible for that. And Otis ends up signing a confession stating that he and Sonberg actually were in a sexual relationship. And after the two had gotten into like a big argument, Otis, he set his home on fire. And then he said after he started the fire he walked across the street and he just watched. He watched and he masturbated twice to the fire. Yeah, it was an interesting detail I thought I'd just throw in there. I don't know. A few days after Otis's arrest, Henry was arrested for unlawful possession of a firearm in Montaug County, Texas. Now once he was arrested this time he started boasting about like his murderous rampage that he and Otis went on. I don't know, maybe he was just like he was over it. Maybe he was just over it at first. When like word got back to Otis, he denied everything. He denied everything Henry was saying and any involvement. But once he learned that Henry was like talking to the cops and taking them on guided tours of like where their murder sites were at, I guess he wanted in and he started like backing up Henry's claims. By their count, Henry and Otis had murdered like 108 people, including 6 year old Adam Walsh. Does that sound familiar? It might sound familiar. Adam Walsh was the son of John Walsh. He became famous for hosting America's Most Wanted. It was in October of 1983 when Otis confessed to killing six year old Adam Walsh. And according to Otis, he had snatched the child from a Sears parking lot in 1981. So Otis said that after he decapitated the young boy with a machete. I know Otis drove around with the head in his car for so long that he actually forgot it was still in the car. And then once he realized it was still in the car, the car, he then tossed the head into a canal. Adam Walsh was perhaps like one of the most well known victims killed by Otis or Henry. His murder would result in like new child protection laws, plus you know, his father getting into television and also criminal justice. But it wasn't until 25 years later, in December of 2008 and like long after Otis had died that the police announced Otis as Walsh's murderer and ended up closing the case. Now when they closed the case, like people wanted to know like how they solved it. But the police, they didn't reveal like any new evidence or DNA evidence. The decision was reached when Otis's niece told John Walsh that her uncle confessed to the crime on his deathbed. So there were many questions about the credibility of Henry's and Otis, Otis's confessions. Some of the stories like the Hand of death cult were just almost like people just, you know, they were a little too incredible to believe. Both Otis and Henry seemed to find a lot of joy in boasting about their wild crimes. So maybe they were just good storytellers. I don't know. Some believe that the police could have just used Henry and OD to like clear up unsolved murders that neither of them had even been involved in and that I was like, oh I could, I could understand that, you know, just to say like this case is closed, it was them who did it. I haven't worn lashes like this in so long I can't see anybody. Now. If you want to block out all of your haters, just wear a fat lash. You won't be able to see them. There was one case specifically that I'm thinking out where they said it was Henry and Otis who did it. But that would mean that Henry would have driven his 13 year old Ford station wagon to cover 11,000 miles in one month or around like 370 miles per day to have committed like the crimes police attributed to him. And you know, apparently this would not be possible. So maybe there is some truth there when it comes to people saying like, you know, police had just put it on them. Who knows, I don't think we'll ever really know how many victims Otis and Henry had between the two of them. Remember in the intro I mentioned the cannibalism. Well, and that little cult situation. Well, In November of 1983, Texas Rangers taped a phone call between Henry and Otis. And at this time they were in prison, so they were just catching up like old friends. And during this call, Otis had asked Henry if he remembered the one time Otis wanted to have ribs and if that made him a cannibal. It's like asking for advice. Does that make me a cannibal? Then he asked Henry if he remembered how he, Otis liked to pour the blood out of his victims. So it's just like an interesting conversation that was caught. I guess a journalist came out to the prison to interview Otis. And you know, he found it to be like quite disturbing. This interviewer asked Otis if it was true that he ate young boys. And Otis responded that he had eaten his quote unquote. Share. He then went on to say how he kidnapped kids, put them in the trunk of his car and like drop drove them out to his place where no one would interrupt him. Otis even said that he had his own BBQ sauce. Yeah, he had his own barbecue sauce recipe that he used when cooking and eating people. He provided like graphic description of sexually assaulting boys, girls, men and women. How he like killed them, how he would remove their organization organs and remove their body parts. He just didn't hold back like some twisted gourmet chef. He went on to describe his human cooking ritual where Otis called the whole experience quote, damn tasty. When asked, Otis said that he and Henry probably killed and ate at least 150 people. I personally think him and Henry did some messed up stuff. I don't know if, if I can get behind 150 people because these two were, they were storytellers. So I think there's some truth in there. But that's just my feeling, you know, I. They could be telling the truth for all I know. Well, in 1984 Otis was convicted by a Florida court for setting a fire that killed 65 year old George son. In January of 1982 he was sentenced to death for George Sohlberg's murder. Otis was indicted a month later for the 1983 murder of 19 year old Ada Johnson. But Otis's death sentence was changed to life in prison for two reasons. One, because he gave many unreliable confessions and two, he had a low iq. Yeah, he was diagnosed with like a mental impairment. So later in 1991, Otis pled guilty to four more murders in Florida and received four more life sentences. Another crossover I didn't expect was that when Otis was at Florida's Rye Ford prison, guess who was next to him in the cell next to him? Guess. Guess. You'll never guess. Ted Bundy. Yeah, it's like all these characters are just getting together. It's wild. Otis eventually died from liver failure on September 15, 1996 at the prison. He was buried in a prison cemetery because nobody came to claim his body. Otis Toole claimed to have confused committed hundreds of murders. But again, the exact number of his victims remains uncertain due to the lack of concrete evidence and the dubious nature of his confessions. He was convicted of six counts of murder, but law enforcement officials believe that he was most likely responsible for, like, a lot more. That number is something we probably will never know. Like, there's no doubt that the abuses Otis was exposed to from a very young age shaped this freaking monster. He became, it seems, sex and flesh became, like, tangled up in the pleasure centers in Otis's brain. You know, it seemed to him a human appeared to have been like nothing more than a body of meat, alive or dead. And no one seems to know what to really believe about Otis. But what we do know for sure is that whether or not he was born with a twisted mind or his life experience shaped him into this demon, it doesn't change the fact that this guy left a trail of blood and death everywhere he went. This guy was awful, awful. You know, I left out a lot of the. Really, Cruise. There's. There's so many gruesome, awful details I left out because, look, no. So, yeah, but all we need to know is that these two guys were awful, awful people. And how do you even end that? I don't know. I hope you have a good day today. You make good choices and you be safe out there. Please, please be safe out there. And I'll be seeing you guys later. Goodbye.
Episode: Serial Killers, Cults, & Cannibals: The TWISTED Case of Ottis Toole
Host: Bailey Sarian
Date: August 19, 2025
Bailey Sarian dives into the deeply disturbing, chaotic life and crimes of Ottis Toole, an American serial killer, arsonist, and self-proclaimed cannibal. The episode also explores Toole’s partnership with fellow murderer Henry Lee Lucas, their alleged involvement with a satanic cult, confessions of cannibalism, and speculations around their numerous, possibly exaggerated, crimes. As always, Bailey brings her trademark blend of dark humor and empathy while unpacking one of the most wicked chapters in true crime history.
Extreme Childhood Abuse:
Mental & Behavioral Issues:
First Murder & Drifting:
Marriage as a Cover:
How They Met:
Escalation from Robbery to Murder:
Casual Brutality:
Cult Recruitment & Activities:
Alleged Black Mass and Cannibalism:
Plausibility & Police Skepticism:
Rampage Details & Victim Profile:
Doubts Around Confessions:
Prison Conversations:
Dubious Numbers:
Conviction & Sentencing:
Legacy & Lingering Questions:
In her signature style, Bailey Sarian weaves together the horrifying saga of Ottis Toole—his brutal upbringing, sadistic crimes, and his lethal connection with Henry Lee Lucas—leaving listeners disturbed, informed, and grappling with the fact that some of America’s darkest true crime stories are also the most convoluted. Bailey deftly balances gritty details with compassion and skepticism, prompting listeners to consider the impact of trauma—and the dangers of mythmaking in criminal history.
Listener reminder:
Stay cautious and be safe out there. “And how do you even end that? I don’t know. I hope you have a good day today. You make good choices and you be safe out there. Please, please be safe out there.” —Bailey ([44:40])