Podcast Summary: Rivals in a Tight Embrace: Russia, China, and the Central Asian Chessboard
New Books Network – September 28, 2025
Host: New Books

Overview

This episode of the Nordic Asia Podcast (a series on the New Books Network) presents an incisive analysis of the longstanding and evolving geostrategic contest in Central Asia, focusing on Russia’s and China’s shifting roles. The speaker (Speaker B) provides a richly detailed historical and contemporary overview, mapping out the region’s unique diversity, its status as a crossroads of empires, the legacy of both Soviet and Chinese policies, and the new dynamics of economic corridors, security alliances, and infrastructural competition. Through a mixture of narrative, context, and current affairs, the episode explores how Russia and China both cooperate and compete in shaping Central Asia’s destiny amid broader global transformations.

Key Discussion Points and Insights

1. Historical Background and Geography

• Central Asia as a “Land Between Empires”

  • Its history as a crossroads for ancient trade, empire-building, and cultural exchange, highlighted by the Silk Road.
  • Deep ethnic, linguistic, and cultural diversity (Iranian, Turkic, Mongolian heritages).
  • Quote:

    “Roads move goods, roads carry ideas. Roads shape identities, trade and transit.” (02:21)

• Empires Drawing Borders

  • Systematic border-drawing and redrawing by Russian and Chinese empires, starting with the Treaty of Nerchinsk (1689).
  • Notable moments include the “unequal treaties” era and Russia’s conquest of Central Asian khanates (19th century).

2. The Great Game and Soviet Era Legacies

• 19th- and 20th-Century Geopolitics

  • Detailed recounting of “the Great Game” – the rivalry between British and Russian empires for influence.
  • Soviet period: Industrialization, creation of national republics, and border engineering.

• Sino-Soviet Rivalry

  • The 1969 Ussuri River clashes and the “Sino-Soviet Split”—ideological and territorial conflict.
    Quote:

    “The 1960s winter emery split—the Sino-Soviet split is ideology, but also territory... Clashes flared at Djenbao Damasci on the Ussuri and in Xinjiang.” (07:48)

3. Post-Soviet Independence and New Power Dynamics

• 1991 Onwards: Five New States

  • The break-up of the USSR led to the emergence of Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, and Uzbekistan.
  • Both Russia and China reshaped their approaches: Russia trying to maintain security and migration ties; China entering carefully with capital and infrastructure.

• Emergence of Regional Multilateral Platforms

  • Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO): Security to economic focus; expansion to include India, Pakistan, Iran, Belarus.
  • Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU): Russia-led common market with recent expansion (Iran FTA, UAE, Mongolia, and India tracks).

4. China’s Ascendancy and the Belt and Road Initiative

• Belt and Road Initiative (BRI)

  • Launched in 2013, targeting infrastructure, connectivity, and economic integration.
  • Focus shifts over time: more quality, green, and smaller projects in the 2020s, but a recent rebound in “resource-packed deals.”
  • Noteworthy infrastructure: China–Kyrgyzstan–Uzbekistan railway (CKU), a Russia-bypassing link accelerated in September 2025.

  Quote:

  "By May 2025 more than 100 governments had signed the Memorandum of Understanding. Participation ebbs and flows... Africa and Central Asia [are] major destinations." (14:55)

5. Current Rivalry and Cooperation: The Four Main Platforms

• Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO)

  • Shift from security drills to finance/connectivity (SCO Development Bank, digital payments, Baidu).
  • Quote:

    "Useful for Central Asia's corridors and for Russia China push on de-dollarized trade." (12:05)

• Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU)

  • Russia’s leverage on tariffs, standards for Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan; recent expansion with Middle Eastern actors.
  • China aligns some BRI projects with EAEU rules when convenient, but often bypasses.

• BRICS

  • Expanded club (now 10 members including energy players like KSA, UAE).
  • BRICS pushes non-western finance, local currencies, with both Moscow and Beijing jockeying for leadership.
  • Quote:

    "BRICS now has a large economic footprint and is tasting non-western financing and local currency use, which shapes energy, trade and financing options for the wider global south." (13:33)

• Belt and Road as “Physical Layer”

  • Corridors, capital, standards forcing Central Asian choices on routes, partnerships, and regulatory alignments.

6. Modes of Competition and Cooperation

• Where Moscow and Beijing Align and Diverge:

  • Security: Cooperation within SCO (joint drills, intel sharing)
  • Economy: Russia prefers EAEU primacy; China seeks direct infrastructure, financial, and digital links.
  • Transport: Competing corridors—Russia-centric vs. China’s CKU/Middle Corridor.

• Settlement Systems and Digital Infrastructure

  • Push toward yuan settlements, joint payment systems, and deployment of China’s Beidou navigation tech.

  Quote:

  “BRICS…compete [for] leadership leverage. China scale trade finance NDB weight; risk turning BRICS into a China-led project. Russia leans on BRICS to show parity and avoid overreliance…” (16:45)

7. Rising Multipolarity and Central Asian Agency

• Central Asian States Maneuvering for Multi-Vector Foreign Policy:
  • Not just balancing Russia and China, but engaging Turkey, Iran, the US, EU, and others.
  • Multifactoral foreign policy: “choosing about unities, not sides, building counterbalances, playing with interdependencies.” (11:18)

8. Recent Developments and Outlook

• Impact of the Ukraine War (2022–present)

  • Central Asian states distance themselves from Moscow politically, while pragmatically maintaining economic ties.
  • China–Russia trade surges as Moscow seeks new markets, China wants energy security.

• Key Stress Tests for the Future (Three Futures to Watch):

  1. Power of Siberia 2 Pipeline: Pricing, timing will reveal leverage.
  2. Rail Corridor Competition: Whether China’s CKU or Russia’s favored routes gain real capacity.
  3. Security: Russia’s ability to remain the regional security provider versus China’s expanding low-profile presence.

  Quote:

  "Cooperation seems in the headlines. Rivalry. Write the notes. Borders on paper are tidy. Borders in the field, across passes, deserts, and rail yards are negotiated every day in Central Asia." (18:24)

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• “Roads move goods, roads carry ideas. Roads shape identities, trade and transit. Other region's original superpowers. A theme that returns in every era.” (02:21)
• “For ordinary people, it means new governors, new taxes, new rail lines. The everyday weight of empires. Empires draw borders, empires move markets. Empires rename places.” (05:08)
• “Independence unlocked infrastructural geopolitics together with the internal multi trajectorial transition. Nation-building and searching for the future passes.” (09:09)
• “The result, a partner rivalry across energy, transport, security, finance, soft power. This is displayed in different ways, of course, by Moscow and Beijing. And Central Asia sits between two giant, developing the art of saying yes.” (10:51)
• “All four platforms reduce less than leverage, but BRI adds the physical layer… Moscow and Beijing cooperate to widen the lane, then compete over ownership, standards, pricing power, and narrative.” (17:50)
• “Central Asia is now focal arena of the international actors amid deep shifts in power balances and rules. It is a fast moving environment with open-ended trajectories, multiple internal and external agents and situational theories where interests intersect.” (19:04)

Timestamps for Important Segments

• 00:13–06:40: Historical overview – Silk Road, Empires, Russian and Chinese expansion, The Great Game
• 06:40–09:10: Soviet and post-Soviet transitions, rise of five independent states
• 09:10–12:20: Development of regional organizations: SCO, EAEU, BRICS, BRI
• 12:20–15:00: Deep-dive on the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) and current projects (CKU railway)
• 15:00–17:50: Current rivalry and cooperation mechanisms — corridors, finance, digital projects
• 17:50–19:04: Future stress tests and the centrality of Central Asia’s role

Final Thoughts

The episode paints Central Asia as a region of perpetual flux; a chessboard where Russia and China continually recalibrate the mix of rivalry and partnership, while Central Asian states learn the “art of saying yes” to all suitors, maintaining strategic ambiguity and flexibility. The region’s future is shaped by the ongoing evolution of multilateral organizations, shifting infrastructure routes, and overlapping spheres of influence, in a dynamic that is as much about pragmatism as it is about power.

Recommended for listeners interested in:
Geopolitics, Eurasia, Russia-China relations, Central Asian studies, international relations, energy and infrastructure politics.

For further reading, consult the book discussed and follow the New Books Network for more in-depth interviews with authors and experts.