No Offseason: The Athletic Women's Basketball Show
Episode: Does Napheesa Collier's Injury Impact the WNBA MVP Race?
Release Date: August 12, 2025
Introduction
In this episode of No Offseason, The Athletic’s dedicated hosts—Zena Keita, Chantel Jennings, Sabreena Merchant, and Ben Pickman—delve deep into the ongoing WNBA season, focusing prominently on the MVP race. The conversation is sparked by the significant injury to Napheesa Collier and its potential ramifications on the race for the coveted Most Valuable Player title.
MVP Race Overview
As the WNBA season surpasses its halfway mark, the hosts assess the landscape of the MVP race, traditionally dominated by forwards such as Nafeesa Collier and Asia Wilson. The discussion revolves around what attributes make a player a viable MVP contender and who currently stands out in the competition.
Ben Pickman highlights Asia Wilson's remarkable performance:
"Asia Wilson is on top, top, top. If you've heard that commercial, it's accurate. 32 points, 20 rebounds in Sunday night's matchup against the Connecticut Sun. Unbelievable performance."
[03:07]
Recent Performance and Injuries
A significant portion of the episode addresses the impact of injuries on key players, particularly focusing on Napheesa Collier’s absence following an ankle injury sustained on August 2nd. Chantel Jennings elaborates on the severity of the situation for the Indiana Fever:
"Sidney Coulson's injury was pretty evident from the moment you saw it. She had her knee buckle in front of the Indiana bench... it's hard to speculate, but at this point in her career, an ACL tear means she's out for the season."
[04:25]
The discussion extends to other injured stars like Angel Reese and Brianna Stewart, emphasizing how these absences are reshaping team dynamics and the overall MVP conversation.
Impact on Teams
The hosts analyze how the injury to Collier and others are affecting their teams' performances. Sabrina Merchant points out:
"Playing winning basketball, being in games where teams constantly are trying to beat you, where you have the target on your back is a harder task than playing for a team that's just trying to make the playoffs."
[28:31]
This sentiment underscores the importance of team success in MVP considerations, as players on leading teams often have an edge due to the visibility and impact of their performances.
Other MVP Candidates
Beyond Collier and Wilson, the episode explores other prominent MVP contenders:
-
Alyssa Thomas of the Phoenix Mercury: Recognized for her versatility and leadership, Sabrina Merchant emphasizes her stellar season.
-
Alicia Gray of the Atlanta Dream: Celebrated for her defensive prowess and scoring ability, Gray emerges as a strong candidate.
-
Kelsey Mitchell of the Indiana Fever: With her team頴
ongoing struggles due to injuries, Mitchell's individual performance stands out as a potential MVP material.
Sabrina Merchant states:
"Alyssa Thomas sort of just like I feel like the engine really captures a lot of what Alyssa Thomas does... She's running the offense, emotionally lifting the team."
[38:53]
MVP Criteria & History
The hosts discuss historical trends in MVP voting, noting that forwards have predominantly secured the award in recent years. Chantel Jennings adds:
"If you want to win MVP, probably should be named Brianna Stewart or Asia Wilson. They have won five of the last seven MVP awards."
[22:46]
Furthermore, the conversation touches on the importance of durability and team success, referencing how the WNBA lacks an official games-played requirement for MVP eligibility.
Cases for MVP
Napheesa Collier
Despite her injury, Sabrina Merchant makes a compelling case for Collier:
"She's the best player on the best team. Her team is 27-5... averaging 23.5 points, seven and a half rebounds, 1.8 steals. Her efficiency is off the charts."
[28:31]
Collier's dominance on both ends of the court and her leadership are highlighted as key factors that bolster her MVP credentials.
Asia Wilson
Conversely, Ben Pickman presents Asia Wilson’s strong case:
"Asia Wilson's on of the Aces, her net rating is 28.4 points better per 100 possessions... the most of any player in the league who has played at least 100 minutes this season."
[29:47]
Wilson's ability to elevate her team's performance significantly when on the court positions her as a formidable MVP contender.
All-WNBA Team and Other Considerations
The discussion also ventures into potential All-WNBA Team selections and other noteworthy performances. Sabrina Merchant underscores the impact of burgeoning players like Kelsey Mitchell, who has emerged as a consistent and effective guard despite her team's challenges.
"Kelsey Mitchell is another player to watch... she's had a career high in points and her versatility has been impressive."
[37:19]
Conclusion
As the season progresses, the MVP race remains fiercely competitive, influenced heavily by player performances, team success, and the unfortunate injuries that have sidelined some of the league’s brightest stars. The hosts agree that the MVP conversation is far from settled, with proving grounds still ahead in the latter half of the season.
Ben Pickman encapsulates the uncertainty:
"This is going to be a tough year again. I can feel it. I can feel it."
[46:50]
The episode concludes with an invitation for listeners to share their thoughts on the MVP race and engage with the ongoing discussions surrounding the WNBA season.
Notable Quotes:
- Zena Keda:
"What makes someone a contender for this coveted title? And who makes the cut for our shortlist?"
[02:30]
- Chantel Jennings:
"Being on the number one seed... is a harder task than playing for a team that's just trying to make the playoffs."
[25:41]
- Chantel Jennings:
"It's hard to separate those two segments when you're thinking about this conversation and her candidacy."
[33:55]
This detailed summary captures the essence of the episode, highlighting key discussions on the MVP race, the impact of injuries, and the emergence of new talents within the WNBA. Notable quotes are integrated to provide authenticity and depth, ensuring that readers receive a comprehensive overview even without listening to the full episode.