No Offseason: The Athletic Women's Basketball Show
Episode: The End Of Year Women's Hoops Mailbag
Release Date: December 29, 2023

1. Player of the Year Criteria and Anissa Morrow's Inclusion

The episode kicks off with a discussion about the criteria for the Women’s Basketball Player of the Year, specifically addressing whether the award should emphasize offense, defense, or a player’s overall impact. Sabrina Merchant references her recent article on top Player of the Year candidates and addresses a question regarding Anissa Morrow’s omission.

Sabrina Merchant (02:51):
"I think there's too much emphasis placed on offense, and defense is overlooked when it comes to the best player of the year awards."

Chantel Jennings (08:15):
"Defense is tougher to evaluate because the data isn't as accessible, making it harder to appreciate a player's defensive prowess fully."

Ben Pickman (06:17):
"I think we haven't gotten into the thick of conference play, where many players can make significant moves. Omitting Anissa Morrow doesn't necessarily exclude her from the conversation."

Despite Sabrina’s initial omission of Morrow, the hosts agree that defensive contributions are undervalued in Player of the Year discussions, citing players like Cameron Brink and Hannah Hidalgo who excel defensively.

2. Transfer Trends and Big Ten Choices

The conversation shifts to player transfers, particularly questioning the lack of transfers to the Big Ten conference, using Iowa as a focal point.

Ben Pickman (11:37):
"I've been trying to understand why a center wouldn't want to transfer to a high-profile program like Iowa. It often comes down to established relationships and familiarity with coaching staff."

Chantel Jennings (13:02):
"Transfers like Sedona Prince moving to TCU illustrate the importance of personal connections and recruiting dynamics over purely conference prestige."

The hosts explore how transfer decisions are influenced by factors beyond conference strength, such as personal relationships and the strategic fit within a team.

3. Caitlin Clark and the Olympic Team Prospects

A significant portion of the episode delves into whether superstar Caitlin Clark will secure a spot on the Paris Olympic team.

Sabrina Merchant (15:01):
"Caitlin Clark is likely to make the Olympic team due to her extensive track record with USA Basketball and her potential to become a foundational star for the team."

Ben Pickman (16:52):
"While Thailand Clark is a standout, the committee faces tough decisions with limited roster spots and a crowded pool of talented guards."

Chantel Jennings (18:20):
"Players like Aaliyah Boston have strong credentials, but Team USA's frontcourt depth might make it easier to include Boston over Clark, due to positional needs."

The discussion acknowledges Clark's eligibility and her impressive resume but highlights the competitive nature of Olympic team selection, contemplating how her role might fit within the existing team dynamics.

4. UConn's Season and Media Attention

The hosts critique the disproportionate media focus on UConn despite their mixed performance this season, comparing it to teams like Marquette.

Ben Pickman (21:36):
"UConn's legacy and history amplify the scrutiny they receive, even when their current performance might not justify the extensive coverage."

Chantel Jennings (23:55):
"While teams like Marquette have strong metrics, UConn's storied program naturally attracts more media attention, which can overshadow other deserving teams."

Sabrina Merchant (25:21):
"UConn's scheduling against top teams ensures they remain in the national conversation, despite facing challenges this season."

The discussion underscores how legacy and historical success influence media narratives, often leading to UConn receiving more attention than other teams with comparable or better performance metrics.

5. WNBA Point Guard Needs: Atlanta Dream

Transitioning to the professional level, the episode examines the Atlanta Dream's search for a point guard in the upcoming WNBA free agency.

Sabrina Merchant (27:09):
"Atlanta could benefit from a veteran point guard like Skylar Diggins Smith, who offers offensive upside despite some risks associated with her recent playtime."

Ben Pickman (29:03):
"Atlanta’s GM has shown a willingness to make significant moves, and with ample cap space, the Dream could aggressively pursue an ideal point guard to complement their talented roster."

The hosts assess the free-agent market, highlighting potential candidates and strategic moves the Atlanta Dream might undertake to bolster their guard position, emphasizing the team's financial flexibility in the offseason.

6. Spotlight on Charlize Ledger Walker

Charlize Ledger Walker from Washington State receives attention for her under-the-radar performance this season.

Sabrina Merchant (31:53):
"Charlize is an exceptional pro-style point guard, excelling in the pick-and-roll and demonstrating strong shooting abilities. Despite playing in a less prominent conference, her talent makes her a standout candidate for mock drafts."

Ben Pickman (33:57):
"Her background, including her family's athletic legacy in New Zealand, and her consistent performance make her a formidable presence on the court, often frustrating opposing coaches."

The discussion highlights Walker’s technical skills and her impact on the game, advocating for greater recognition despite her team's lower national profile.

7. Reflections on 2023's Biggest Stories

As the year wraps up, the hosts reflect on the most impactful stories in women's basketball for 2023.

Ben Pickman (37:33):
"2023 was the year women's basketball truly exploded in visibility. The tournament saw unprecedented interest, even from those unfamiliar with the sport."

Sabrina Merchant (38:44):
"Asia Wilson emerged as a generational talent, establishing herself as perhaps the best player in the world and shaping her legacy within the sport."

Chantel Jennings (40:14):
"Apart from individual performances, the camaraderie and teamwork among the hosts themselves enhanced the reporting experience, making collaborative coverage more dynamic."

The hosts agree that 2023 saw a surge in interest and growth in the sport, with standout performances and increased media coverage driving engagement.

8. Reporters’ Memorable Moments

The episode concludes with the hosts sharing their favorite moments from the year.

Ben Pickman (40:14):
"Recording the podcast during the Final Four in Dallas was a career highlight, experiencing firsthand the electrifying atmosphere and the intensity of top-tier competition."

Sabrina Merchant (41:30):
"Covering the Iowa vs. LSU Final Four game was unforgettable, witnessing the high stakes and the significant post-game discussions surrounding team dynamics and player performances."

Chantel Jennings (42:37):
"Interacting with colleagues and building a strong reporting team has been rewarding, enhancing the overall coverage and enjoyment of the season's events."

These personal anecdotes emphasize the rewarding experiences of covering high-profile games and the importance of teamwork among the hosts.

9. Personal Recommendations and Wrap-Up

In the final segment, the hosts share personal reflections and recommendations for listeners.

Ben Pickman (45:27):
"Currently watching 'Welcome to Wrexham' Season Two and rereading Anne Lamott's 'Bird by Bird,' which offers invaluable insights into writing and life."

Sabrina Merchant (45:48):
"Recommended reading includes Katie Barnes' story on Aaliyah Gayles' recovery and the novel 'Tomorrow, Tomorrow and Tomorrow,' which explores themes of friendship and video games."

Chantel Jennings (44:05):
"Enjoying solving a 1500-piece jigsaw puzzle and reading light, non-sports-related essays for relaxation."

The hosts conclude by expressing gratitude to their audience, teasing upcoming content for the new year, and encouraging continued support and engagement with their coverage of women's basketball.

Notable Takeaways:

• Player Evaluation: Emphasis on balancing offensive and defensive contributions in Player of the Year discussions.
• Transfer Dynamics: Personal relationships and strategic fits influence transfer decisions more than conference prestige.
• Olympic Prospects: Caitlin Clark is a strong candidate for the Olympic team, highlighting the depth of talent in women's basketball.
• Media Focus: UConn's legacy affects media attention, sometimes overshadowing other competitive teams.
• WNBA Strategies: Atlanta Dream's proactive approach in securing a point guard could significantly impact their future success.
• Emerging Talent: Charlize Ledger Walker exemplifies the hidden gems in women's basketball, deserving more recognition.
• Year in Review: 2023 marked a substantial increase in visibility and interest in women's basketball, driven by exceptional performances and expanded media coverage.

The episode offers a comprehensive overview of the current landscape in women's basketball, blending analytical discussions with personal insights and reflections from seasoned hosts.