Podcast Summary: Normal Gossip – “Forks Out with Tracy Clayton”

Host: Rachel Hampton
Guest: Tracy Clayton
Date: November 26, 2025

Episode Overview

This Thanksgiving-themed episode of Normal Gossip features host Rachel Hampton and returning guest Tracy Clayton diving into a reader-submitted, family-driven gossip story. Blending comedic commentary, sharp observations, and their trademark wit, Rachel and Tracy break down a juicy “holiday heist” involving a highly-prized family recipe, cabin drama, and long-awaited, sweet revenge.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Kicking Off: Catching Up & Personal Gossip Updates

• [05:16] Tracy recounts a real-life Valentine’s Day dating fiasco:
  • She went on a date with a man whose voice uncannily resembled Andre 3000 (her “husband” in her heart).
  • After their restaurant date, he offered to drive her to meet friends. He became annoyed after a couple of wrong turns and told her, “sweetheart, I don’t have time to be driving you all around the city like this.” [09:55]
  • Tracy immediately asked to be let out of the car, and he complied, leaving her on a deserted, cold street corner at night.
  • Her friends joked about impersonating police to teach him a lesson; even Tracy’s therapist (jokingly) encouraged the idea.
  • Tracy recently ran into him again at the same bar, where he attempted to rewrite the story, displaying what they call “the surplus of audacity” that some men seem to possess.

    Tracy: “I am a gog. I am aghast. I’m like, I know he's not talking to me, right?" [13:43]

Memorable Quotes

• Rachel: “I feel like they must keep the audacity where the rest of us keep common sense because they don't seem to have a whole lot of that.” [14:55]
• Tracy: “[Saying 'I'm sorry'] must be a poison pill to some men.” [15:44]

2. Main Gossip Story: The Thanksgiving Sweet Potato Pie Heist

[17:55] Rachel leads into this episode’s centerpiece—a whodunit about a missing family pie.

a. The Family & The Sacred Pie

• Lex (the "friend of a friend") joins her boyfriend Tyler’s family for Thanksgiving at their Michigan cabin. Tyler’s family fiercely guards a generations-old maple sweet potato pie recipe, only one person per generation knows it. [20:22]
• The pie is legendary, credited with winning church contests and even “securing four engagements.”

b. Introducing the Players & Family Dynamics

• Tyler’s mom Linda is the competitive matriarch and the only one who makes the pie for holidays.
• Tyler's siblings: Amber (the baby, brings her girlfriend and a Great Dane named Rufus) and Jordan (the middle child).
• Classic family stereotypes and power dynamics are explored, especially the “middle child” syndrome, with both hosts reflecting on their own family roles. [22:44]

c. The Backstory: A Grudge Is Born

• Years back, young Jordan was teased by his whole family for eating pie slowly; while he sat in his room, the family ate his saved slice. He cried and “vowed revenge.”

  Rachel: “It is my belief that middle children are made, not born. And this is one of those moments that makes Jordan.” [25:18]

• Rachel and Tracy muse on childhood grievances and how such experiences can have lasting effects. Tracy shares her own lifelong grudge over a Halloween scare from her brother. [28:04]

d. At the Cabin: The Setup

• The group’s arrival leads to a spat over sleeping arrangements (Jordan gets the couch), and Amber’s unapproved pet causes tension with Linda.
• Linda lays down strict rules for Rufus; Amber didn’t even ask permission to bring him, showing “baby of the family energy.”

  Tracy: “If I’m mom, I’m like, you don’t get any pie. That’s it.” [31:35]

e. The Night Before Thanksgiving: Pie Goes Missing

• Linda bakes the pie (filling the whole cabin with tantalizing smells), and sets it to cool overnight.
• Family members scatter for evening activities—pool, hot tub, cornhole—leaving the pie unattended. [38:10]
• When Linda returns, the pie has vanished. At first, the family suspects forgetfulness, but after 30 minutes of searching, it’s declared a “missing pie.” [40:29]

  Tracy: “Looking for a pie for 30 minutes is so the noodles to me.” [40:29]

f. The Investigation: Accusations and Theories

• Linda eagerly leads a full-on investigation, grilling each person about their whereabouts—except the dog, who becomes suspect number one.
  • Amber’s girlfriend is outraged at the notion Rufus is a criminal; Linda’s dislike of dogs is clear.
• Tensions rise as Amber’s girlfriend accuses Linda of being the saboteur; speculation abounds, but no consensus. [46:01]

g. The Shocking Return: Pie With a Hole

• Thanksgiving morning, the pie reappears in the fridge—except there’s a perfectly round circle missing from the center. [50:05]
• Suspicions shift; everyone speculates. Should they eat the mysterious pie? Tracy says she would, but only after someone else tries it first. [52:16]

h. The Showdown: Dinner Accusations

• As the family enjoys dinner, accusations fly in all directions: Tyler, Amber, Lex, and even Linda are all accused as possible pie-nappers.
• Lex reveals Tyler’s story about the childhood pie incident to the family, but Jordan clarifies: “it was Tyler that took the first bite.” [55:11]
• The circle finally closes as Jordan, at dessert, reveals himself as the culprit: “I already have my piece.” He produced the missing pie-circle, triumphant, declaring years of patient revenge.

  Jordan: “For years, I bided my time... You ruled me out, even when I left you such an obvious—the middle of the pie for the middle child.” [59:08]

i. Reflection & Debrief

• Tracy and Rachel gleefully analyze the reveal, praising Jordan’s schemes and debating who the true “villain” is (everyone who wronged Jordan as a child).
• Casting moments: Tracy imagines Nia Long as Linda if this story were a movie. [60:26]
• Updates: Lex did get to taste the pie and later married Tyler, but Amber and her girlfriend broke up over the episode. Jordan, meanwhile, gets to tell the story every year now, because, as Rachel says, “revenge is pretty fucking sweet.” [62:32]

Memorable Moments & Quotes

• Tracy (on being wronged):
  “This has healed me somehow. Amazing. Oh, amazing.” [58:36]
• Jordan (the reveal):
  “Have any of you heard the expression that revenge, like pie, is best served cold?” [59:03]
• Rachel (summarizing):
  “Revenge is pretty fucking sweet.” [62:32]
• Tracy (about familial grudges):
  “What a wholesome case of revenge. I would have only liked it better if Jordan framed Tyler specifically.” [61:02]

Important Timestamps

• [05:16] Tracy’s Valentine’s Day date story
• [17:55] Introduction of the main gossip story (The Thanksgiving Pie)
• [25:18] The origin of Jordan’s grudge
• [38:52] The pie goes missing
• [40:29] Linda declares the pie missing
• [41:24] The official investigation begins
• [50:05] The missing pie’s return—with a hole
• [55:11] Plot twist: Tyler’s role in the original incident revealed
• [58:36] Jordan’s confession and revenge
• [62:32] Final updates—the fate of the family post-pie-heist

Tone & Takeaways

• The episode is playful, witty, and full of affectionate family roasting. Both host and guest embrace the spirit of raucous, harmless drama. They celebrate both the joy and pain of family traditions, the persistence of childhood slights, and the delicious vengeance that can come from patience.
• Vivid, cinematic storytelling and excellent guest chemistry make the episode especially engaging—think Agatha Christie meets Thanksgiving potluck.
• Underneath the laughs, the story’s warmth underscores how even the pettiest family grievances can become the sweetest family lore.

For New Listeners

This episode exemplifies what Normal Gossip does best: transforming an ordinary anecdote into a suspenseful, hilarious, and emotionally resonant portrait of family. Even if you don’t know any of these people, you’ll find yourself basking in the delicious, relatable cringes and comebacks of the Thanksgiving pie heist.

Want More?

• Subscribe or send your own gossip to Normal Gossip.
• Support the show or catch more real-life tales of strangers’ drama at Normal Gossip's website.

End of Summary