Mary Rose & the Battle of the Solent
Podcast: Not Just the Tudors
Host: Professor Suzannah Lipscomb
Episode Release Date: July 10, 2025
Introduction: A Looming Threat
Professor Suzannah Lipscomb opens the episode by setting the stage for one of England's most dramatic naval confrontations—the Battle of the Solent in 1545. This battle is not only remembered for the tragic sinking of the Mary Rose but also for the larger context of a formidable French invasion fleet threatening Tudor England.
French Aggression: The Invasion Fleet
Delving into the origins of the conflict, Professor Lipscomb explains how tensions between Henry VIII and François I of France escalated following Henry's invasion of France in 1544. François I, angered by these actions, amassed a substantial invasion force aimed directly at England.
Notable Quote:
"Francois had not stinted at all on putting his force into action."
— Dr. Dominic Fontana [06:49]
Dr. Dominic Fontana, a geographer from the University of Portsmouth and a long-time collaborator on the Mary Rose Maritime Archaeological Project, provides detailed insights into the composition of the French fleet. The invasion force comprised approximately 225 ships carrying 30,000 troops, including Mediterranean galleys from Italy and other regions. This massive assembly underscored the seriousness of François I's intent to seize the English crown.
Notable Quote:
"They brought galleys all the way from Italy...assembled an army of 30,000 soldiers on 225 ships."
— Dr. Dominic Fontana [12:02]
English Preparedness: The Mary Rose Takes Center Stage
In contrast to the French behemoth, England's defense relied on a fleet of about 80 vessels, including the renowned warship Mary Rose. Professor Lipscomb highlights the strategic challenges faced by Henry VIII, whose primary army remained engaged in France, leaving England to muster a less equipped and trained militia.
Notable Quote:
"Henry's kingdom really was hanging by a thread."
— Dr. Dominic Fontana [15:30]
The Mary Rose, a symbol of Tudor maritime ambition, was poised to play a pivotal role in repelling the invasion. Built at a significant cost, the ship featured broadside firing guns and was a testament to England's naval capabilities, despite being outnumbered.
The Battle Unfolds: Tactics and Turning Points
On July 19, 1545, King Henry VIII stood atop Southsea Castle in Portsmouth, overseeing the impending clash. As the French fleet approached the Solent, the English fleet remained anchored at Spithead, a strategic position making it difficult for the French to navigate the narrow waterways leading to Portsmouth and Southampton.
Notable Quote from Contemporary Source:
"He maintained his ground until night... the King's galleys... retired unto the haven after the ebb."
— Martin du Bellay [04:34]
The calm morning gave way to a crucial shift when a sea breeze enabled the English ships to maneuver. The Mary Rose, under the new command of Vice Admiral Sir George Carew, attempted to engage the French galleys with its powerful broadside.
The Sinking of the Mary Rose: A Tragic Turn
As the battle intensified, the Mary Rose took aggressive action against the French forces. Professor Lipscomb and Dr. Fontana discuss the circumstances leading to the ship's sinking. The Mary Rose capsized shortly after initiating her broadside, sinking rapidly within a minute or two.
Notable Quote:
"She will have let a lot of water directly into the gun ports, which would place water up high in the ship, pulling her over even further."
— Dr. Dominic Fontana [40:28]
Archaeological evidence suggests that the Mary Rose may have been struck by enemy fire or encountered structural issues during the maneuvering. Her final position, embedded in the soft mud of the Solent, preserved her hull and the remains of her crew, providing invaluable insights into Tudor naval warfare.
Aftermath: The Battle's Impact and Legacy
Despite the loss of the Mary Rose, the English fleet managed to withstand the French invasion attempt. The French fleet faced logistical challenges and internal deliberations, ultimately deciding against maintaining a foothold on the Isle of Wight due to insufficient supplies and the formidable English defenses.
Notable Quote:
"Claude d' Annabeau... suggested that it wasn't worth the expenditure of so much Christian blood."
— Dr. Dominic Fontana [52:39]
The unsuccessful invasion attempt weakened French ambitions and played a significant role in the subsequent peace treaty of 1546. The Battle of the Solent remains a testament to the strategic acumen of Henry VIII and the resilience of the English naval forces.
Concluding Insights: A Multifaceted Historical Event
Professor Lipscomb and Dr. Fontana conclude by reflecting on the complexity of the Battle of the Solent. The combination of extensive French preparations and the strategic defensive measures of the English created a dynamic and decisive confrontation. The sinking of the Mary Rose, while tragic, underscored the bravery and tactical prowess of Tudor England.
Notable Quote:
"We can never give an absolute total answer to anything, but what we can do is find out. And that is huge fun."
— Dr. Dominic Fontana [53:07]
This episode of Not Just the Tudors offers a comprehensive exploration of the Battle of the Solent, blending historical records with archaeological findings to paint a vivid picture of a pivotal moment in English history.
For more episodes and deep dives into fascinating historical events, subscribe to History Hit and enjoy hundreds of hours of original documentaries and ad-free podcasts.