Annie Murphy: From Crying in the Pacific to Manifesting a Schitt’s Creek Movie

Summary

Podcast Summary: "Annie Murphy: From Crying in the Pacific to Manifesting a Schitt’s Creek Movie"

Podcast Information:

• Title: Not Skinny But Not Fat
• Host: Amanda Hirsch
• Guest: Annie Murphy
• Release Date: July 1, 2025

---

Introduction

In this vibrant episode of "Not Skinny But Not Fat," host Amanda Hirsch welcomes actress Annie Murphy—the Emmy-winning star beloved for her role as Alexis Rose in "Schitt's Creek." The conversation promises an engaging blend of Hollywood insights, personal anecdotes, and heartfelt discussions, making listeners feel as if they're hanging out with their best friends in Hollywood.

---

Amanda’s Pop Culture Commentary

Before diving into the main conversation, Amanda shares her thoughts on current pop culture, touching on topics like Justin Bieber's recent name change to Lil Bieber, Katy Perry and Orlando Bloom's split, and the ubiquitous presence of reality TV. She humorously critiques Bieber's social media activity and speculates on the reasons behind celebrity break-ups, providing a relatable and candid perspective on the ever-evolving entertainment landscape.

Notable Quote:

“Justin Bieber changed his name to Lil Bieber on Instagram and he has been posting lately a lot of stories... I will just say about the name change on Instagram, like, that's never been a good sign.”
— Amanda Hirsch [01:36]

---

Introduction of Annie Murphy

Amanda enthusiastically introduces Annie Murphy, highlighting her down-to-earth personality and her iconic role in "Schitt's Creek." She emphasizes Annie's versatility, intelligence, and effortless coolness, setting the stage for an engaging and heartfelt conversation.

Notable Quote:

“She's sweet. She's down to earth. She was wearing fake Chanel, which I loved. We talk about everything from Schitt's Creek. A reboot, her new projects, her take on fame, everything she's been into lately.”
— Amanda Hirsch [01:36]

---

Fashion and Sustainability

The conversation kicks off with a light-hearted discussion about fashion choices. Annie showcases a pair of socks and sandals, sparking a playful debate about trends and sustainability. Both host and guest share their frugal approaches to fashion, preferring quality and experiences over fleeting trends.

Notable Quote:

“I'm doing a Chanel knockoff in a sock and sandal at night. This is just where we're at.”
— Annie Murphy [07:39]

---

Working with Nicole Kidman and Cast Dynamics

Annie delves into her experience working alongside Nicole Kidman on "Nine Perfect Strangers." She describes Kidman as an "intangible, otherworldly presence" and praises her ability to bring depth and emotion to each scene. Annie also highlights her camaraderie with co-star Murray Bartlett, portraying him as the epitome of optimism and positivity.

Notable Quotes:

“Nicole Kidman... she was so excited to have you. She's an at. She was an avid watcher of Schitt's Creek.”
— Amanda Hirsch [09:51]

“Murray is so fascinating to me because he is the most rose colored glasses human being I have ever met.”
— Annie Murphy [12:24]

---

Filming Experiences: Austria and "Kevin Can Wait"

Annie shares vivid anecdotes from filming in Hallstatt, Austria, describing the picturesque town and the unique challenges of shooting on location. She recounts memorable moments, such as riding the funicular with Murray and the unpredictable weather during filming.

Notable Quote:

“We had a... Just me and Murray riding a funicular all day long in Austria.”
— Annie Murphy [12:07]

Amanda inquires about the filming process, leading to discussions about the immersive environment and the emotional depth of their performances.

---

The Impact of "Schitt's Creek"

Annie reflects on the profound impact "Schitt's Creek" has had on her life and its fans. She expresses gratitude for being part of a show that provided solace during challenging times, emphasizing its timeless nature and universal appeal.

Notable Quotes:

“Schitt's Creek is one of those shows that's like, this got me through a mental health crisis... Something that has provided some relief and some joy to people when they need it.”
— Annie Murphy [23:18]

“It's a timeless show that people reference and will remember forever.”
— Amanda Hirsch [23:18]

---

Personal Struggles and Mental Health

The conversation takes a more personal turn as Annie opens up about her battles with depression and anxiety. She discusses the challenges of finding the right medication, the impact of the pandemic on her mental health, and the importance of seeking help. Annie emphasizes the non-linear journey of mental wellness and the ongoing nature of her struggles.

Notable Quotes:

“I know that I'm gonna have to be on antidepressants for chunks of time throughout my life.”
— Annie Murphy [45:14]

“It's like existential stuff, like, just being overwhelmed a lot of the time by, like, dying and losing people that I love.”
— Annie Murphy [43:56]

---

Aspirations and Future Projects

Annie shares her aspirations to explore new genres, particularly horror, and portray diverse characters such as a grieving widow in a historical setting. She speaks passionately about her desire to live multiple lives through acting, showcasing her commitment to versatility and growth in her craft.

Notable Quote:

“I haven't been in a horror movie. I'd love to do that. I also want to play like, a grieving widow in 1806...”
— Annie Murphy [43:02]

---

Fun Anecdotes: Meeting Kate Winslet and Backstreet Boys

Adding a touch of humor and camaraderie, Annie recounts her memorable encounter with Kate Winslet at the Emmys. The story of Annie spontaneously visiting Winslet's "house by the sea" and their budding friendship highlights Annie's adventurous spirit and genuine connections within the industry. Additionally, she shares her long-time admiration for the Backstreet Boys, detailing her interactions with members AJ McLean and Brian Littrell.

Notable Quotes:

“She cooked me this frittata and... drove me back to the train station because she was on her way to pick up her little boy... She's the coolest woman.”
— Annie Murphy [51:47]

“The level of obsession that I had with the Backstreet Boys, like, I fell in love... All he needed to do was take the microphone and call me down and I'd be his wife forever.”
— Annie Murphy [55:38]

---

Conclusion

Amanda wraps up the episode with heartfelt thanks, encouraging listeners to watch "Nine Perfect Strangers" on Hulu and reiterating the enduring legacy of "Schitt's Creek." The conversation leaves listeners with a deeper understanding of Annie Murphy's professional journey, personal resilience, and the genuine friendships that enrich her life.

Notable Quote:

“Please note that this episode may contain paid endorsements and advertisements...”
— Annie Murphy [60:17]

---

Key Takeaways:

• Annie Murphy's versatility as an actress extends beyond her iconic role in "Schitt's Creek," showcasing her ability to tackle diverse genres and complex characters.
• Personal resilience in the face of mental health challenges highlights Annie's strength and vulnerability.
• Genuine connections within Hollywood, exemplified by her friendships with Nicole Kidman and Kate Winslet, demonstrate the supportive nature of her professional relationships.
• Aspirations for future projects indicate Annie's desire for continuous growth and exploration in her acting career.

This episode offers a candid and comprehensive look into Annie Murphy's life, both on and off the screen, making it a must-listen for fans and those interested in the human stories behind Hollywood's brightest stars.

Transcript

[Amanda Hirsch]

So obviously we all know what Venmo is, but maybe you don't know. The Venmo can be used for more than just paying your friends back. You can use Venmo in so many ways, and one of them is the Venmo debit card. Yes, that's right. You heard Air, Venmo has a debit card. So this debit card lets you spend your Venmo balance in so many ways. You can Venmo this, you can Venmo that, you can Venmo everything. I'm saying, like, if you shop for it, you can pay for it with this. With the Venmo debit card, I can Venmo this. Mic that I'm speaking into, the headphones that are in my ears, the rent for my apartment, my coffee. I mean, just everything. It's so exciting. It's so great. The Venmo debit card unlocks all new ways to use Venmo. So imagine you get back money on Venmo for drinks that you paid for your friends, use that balance and pay for your Uber home. You sold a pair of shoes, use that balance, buy new shoes. Not to mention, this debit card is chic and it comes in a bunch of vibey colors, so you can pick one that matches your esthetic, which we love. Venmo Everything with Venmo Debit card. Visit venmo me/debbit to learn more and sign up today. Venmo purchase restrictions apply. The Venmo MasterCard is issued by the Bancorp Bank N.A. pursuant to license licensed by MasterCard International Incorporated. Card may be used everywhere MasterCard is accepted.

[Annie Murphy]

The following podcast is a Dear Media.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Production welcome back to the Not Skinny But Not Fat podcast. I'm your host, Amanda Hirsch, and I still can't believe that I get to chat with some of my favorite stars on my very own podcast, where you'll feel like you're just talking with your best friends in your living room. Foreign how are you on this lovely Tuesday morning, afternoon, evening, wherever this episode is catching you? Maybe you don't listen on Tuesday. Maybe it's Wednesday. Maybe it's Thursday. Maybe it's Friday, maybe it's Saturday, maybe it's Sunday. Maybe it's Monday. Maybe. I don't know. But this summer, I don't know what's happening. I do not know what's happening. It is 69 degrees right now in New York. Yesterday was 105. I'm not complaining. I am observing. I perhaps am concerned about the climate and the environment, but I'm Rolling with it. I just don't think for people that complain about it being too cold in New York or not even too cold, like not hot enough yet. Like today, 69 people would be like, where's the summer? It's June. And I'm like, new York isn't meant for 80 to 100 degree weather because we are a concrete jungle, as Alicia Keys said. And you know, if I'm in Portofino, like, yes, give me 80 degrees. If I'm in Turks and Caicos, make it 85. In New York City, when, you know, people are walking down the street, there are buildings, there's pollution, there's like hot dog trucks and, and, and, and halal food. You know, like, we don't need it to be steamy. Okay, that's like, that's my shit. That's my TED Talk. That's like what I'm saying. So, yeah, I'm good. I'm good with the 69. Anyway, before we get into today's episode, just some something on my mind. You know, Justin Bieber changed his name to Lil Bieber on Instagram and he has been posting lately a lot of stories, whether it's screenshots of conversations with friends or, or, or other stuff. Things with Baby Jack, which like, we love to see. Very cute. He literally though is, oh my God. First of all, Baby Jack playing inside an Amazon box is so Normie coded. Like they, like, we all have said it. People with kids, like, you'll buy your kid a gazillion toys, what do they want to play with a fucking box? Like, that's just what it is. So I love those Normie moments. I'm just wondering if like the excessive, excessive posting and name change is anything to worry about, which I, I want to support the viewers so bad. And I don't. I, I think it's obviously ev. If they are going through a hard time, the last thing you want is people to be like talking about it, speculating about it. Like that's what they have had to deal with their whole relationship. Like divorce, rumor, all this. Now they have a baby. Like, we don't want to put that energy towards them. I will just say about the, the name change on Instagram, like, that's never been a good sign. And I'm not talking like if I change from that skinny but not bad to Amanda, I'm talking like, you know, Kanye changing his name, Britney Spears changing her name. And by the way, I know like non famous people that have changed their name and it was. If they did that you knew, like, it wasn't good. Okay. Like, I. I just know. Okay? I just. No, I just know, you guys, so that's that. The other really big news in pop culture is that Katy Perry and Orlando Bloom have called it quits. You know, they have a baby. It's sad. They've been together for a while. They stood the test of Hollywood time for a while. Katy Perry has been on not to blame her. Who knows? Maybe he did something, but he's less in the media and less in the public eye. So I don't know. But she's just been on this other journey, so maybe she's changed a lot. You know, maybe she's not the woman that he met, maybe he's not the man that she met. But. But she just seems like, you know, people do constantly evolve. But, you know, the space thing, there are literally headlines that say that the thing was like, the final straw, which is kind of crazy. Like, imagine sitting down little Daisy and being like, so remember Mama went to space with Gail King and Lauren Sanchez? Yeah. Daddy didn't like it. Also, Orlando Bloom. And I've heard this from sources, from people. Like, he's super, like, woo, woo. Like, he's super, like, goop. You know, he's super goop, irl. So maybe he truly didn't like that. He's like, you are polluting. We're not into it. Anyway, let's get into today's guest. She's someone that you know you love. And yes, she's just as cool as you'd imagine. It's Emmy winner, Canadian queen, and the hilarious, iconic Alexis Rose from Schitt's Creek. Oh, David, it's Annie Murphy. She's not just a little bit Alexis, okay? She's way more than that. She's sweet. She's down to earth. She was wearing fake Chanel, which I loved. We talk about everything from Schitt's Creek. A reboot, her new projects, her take on fame, everything she's been into lately. She's really smart, she's really funny, and she's just, like, effortlessly cool. So enjoy. Here's Annie Murphy. I love this little, like, situation.

[Annie Murphy]

A little sock and sandal.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah. You. Or is it like a stylist?

[Annie Murphy]

No, this is me.

[Amanda Hirsch]

I love it.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah, this is me.

[Amanda Hirsch]

I wonder, like, what the Internet would think.

[Annie Murphy]

We can ask them.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah, I know. I'm into it. But is it a Gen Z thing? Like, what's that?

[Annie Murphy]

Sure as hell no.

[Amanda Hirsch]

I'm not Chanel. Is it Chanel?

[Annie Murphy]

No, they're not. They're like, 30 knockoffs.

[Amanda Hirsch]

I love you. I love you.

[Annie Murphy]

I'm doing a Chanel knockoff in a sock and sandal at night. This is just where we're at.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Love it. You're on a hit fucking show and you're wearing Sandy. Sock and sandy. Which, like, looked like. Like, look how I would be, like, Chanel.

[Annie Murphy]

Well, that's what I hope that. That's what I hope happens with these.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Because you don't believe in spending a lot of money on, like, trends.

[Annie Murphy]

Well. Or anything.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Or anything.

[Annie Murphy]

Or shoes.

[Amanda Hirsch]

You know, shoes in general.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah, Shoes in general.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Okay. Because it's like, you know, the row jellies.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

So that's a perfect example to me of, like, a trend that's not worth, no offense, American Ashley, like, love you forever. $700 for the plastic versus you could get them on Amazon for $20. And by next year, we're going to be like, we can't believe we wore the jellies. But you didn't spend the 700.

[Annie Murphy]

Right. And I do feel like, like, I went to China many, many years ago, and they were like, oh, this is the, you know, Yves Saint Laurent factory. And it's also the Gap factory. And it's also the Forever 21 factory.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Seriously?

[Annie Murphy]

Those are not exact.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Right, yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

Stores.

[Amanda Hirsch]

But that's the gist.

[Annie Murphy]

Brands. But that's the gist.

[Amanda Hirsch]

And you're just like, yeah, like, what are we doing?

[Annie Murphy]

What are we doing here?

[Amanda Hirsch]

So even when you started making money working, you still were not spending it?

[Annie Murphy]

Not spending it on. I like. I like to spend on experiences like.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Like what? Like travel.

[Annie Murphy]

Traveling.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

And, like, eating great food.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Food. And, like, food is the one thing that. It's like, the limit does not exist, like, for some reason. Anything else. Like, I just got my nails done, like a fancy Russian manicure. And it was like, I mean, no, it's grown out. Because that's how frugal I am that I'm, like, getting every last bit of. It's. It's worth.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Like, you're not supposed to go this long. But it was, like, $150, which is very different than, like, a regular manicure. I was like, this is so expensive. And I was having this conversation with myself meanwhile, like, everyone that follows me gets it. Like, the world is getting it. It's not like the elite is, like, everyone gets it now. Okay.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

And I was like, why am I okay with, like, ordering food for whatever amount of money spending? Like, just, like, food just doesn't count, you know?

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah, I know.

[Amanda Hirsch]

It's kind of money. Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

It's on a completely different list.

[Amanda Hirsch]

It is, it is. I'm so happy you're here. You're out with nine perf strangers right now, which is a hit. So good. Nicole Kidman. What was that? She's obsessed with you, by the way. Did you know?

[Annie Murphy]

No.

[Amanda Hirsch]

She said it. I. I saw it on Tick Tock. She said she was so excited to have you. She was so excited to work with you. She's an at. She was an avid watcher of a Schitt's Creek.

[Annie Murphy]

She. I did. I did know that. I didn't know that.

[Amanda Hirsch]

It's hard to picture her, like, kicking back to Schitt's Creek.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah. Like a big wood. Just some. Some snacks. Yeah, some snacks.

[Amanda Hirsch]

And her slippers on, like, cracking up at.

[Annie Murphy]

It was truly wild to work with Nicole Kidman.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

Cause she really is kind of this, like, intangible, otherworldly presence.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Right.

[Annie Murphy]

When she does scenes, she does every take completely differently, so you never know what's coming out of that face and body.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Wow. So watching her is like an experience.

[Annie Murphy]

It really is. Speaking of, like, kicking back with snacks, I wish I could have just done that.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

Cause it's. It's a sight to behold, for sure.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Was it a cool. Like, when you found out that you were going to be doing this? Like, how excited were you about that?

[Annie Murphy]

I was so excited. Well, it was post, you know, pandemic, post strike, post, all the things. And I just felt so lucky that I had a job to begin with.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

And then, you know, knowing that it was Nicole Kidman, Murray Bartlett had already signed on. Christine Baranski had already signed on. It was going to be shot in Germany, so I knew it was going to be like a, you know, a really cool adventure.

[Amanda Hirsch]

You're seen with him, by the way, with Murray in the lift, when you're. When you're, like, not afraid to die or something.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah, we had a. We had a. That was a. Just.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Was that in a real lift? Was that happening?

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah, that was real. It's in this little town called Hallstatt in Austria, which is, I think, one of the most Instagrammed places. It's this little, like. It's a beautiful storybook town around this alpine lake.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Wow.

[Annie Murphy]

And the funicular. We just rode that all day long, like, up and down. That's what it's called. I didn't know it till now.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Okay. Sounds.

[Annie Murphy]

Really. Sounds made up.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

The funicular, which is what I call the.

[Annie Murphy]

The lift the lift.

[Amanda Hirsch]

That's a funicular.

[Annie Murphy]

That's a funicular, yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

The Murray with him.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah. So it was just me and Murray riding a funicular all day long in Austria.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Were you scared? Do you have a fear of heights?

[Annie Murphy]

No, I love. I. I loved it. And just like, the weather kept changing as we were going up and down.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Oh, my God. It probably was so crammed with, like, a camera. People inside that thing.

[Annie Murphy]

Cozy.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah. But working with Murray was just like, he's. Murray is so fascinating to me because he is the most rose colored glasses human being I have ever met in my life. Like, right out of the gates, we met and I said something within the first 10 minutes of, like, well, we're all gonna die. And he was like, do you think about death alon? And I was like, yeah, I think about it 270 times a day. Like, would be normal. Yeah, he's like, funny. I never really think about it. And I was like, give me your blood. Like, give me whatever makes you like, I want this.

[Amanda Hirsch]

So how doesn't he think of it? Literally had a whole episode in the Last of Us. Like, where were you, Murray?

[Annie Murphy]

Well, I know, but you killed it.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Like, where were you? Not getting anxiety from that.

[Annie Murphy]

I know, but then he. He is so. He's like just the cheeriest, most optimistic guy. And then he starts acting and just pulls out, like, anger or sadness or whatever, and it's just like he can access it so beautifully and then just like, shove it all down again.

[Amanda Hirsch]

He's amazing. That's so cool.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Do you love that an episode? Because I think by the time this comes out, like, the point is right now, when we're recording, they're like four episodes out. Or three or four. Maybe the. Maybe the fourth one is like, today.

[Annie Murphy]

It's Wednesday. It is.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah, totally. So do you like that when it, like, drops once a week, or are you more of a binge?

[Annie Murphy]

I like to gobble it up.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

You know, I like to sit on a couch for eight to nine hours and gobble it up.

[Amanda Hirsch]

And gobble it up. So would you wait? Like, till. Till they're all out?

[Annie Murphy]

I would wait. Although, you know, that said, I. I was like the most eager beaver with White Lotus.

[Amanda Hirsch]

And speaking of White Lotus, you know that people are kind of comparing nine Perfect Strangers and White Lotus in. In a way.

[Annie Murphy]

I mean, different casts, different locations.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Right, right. But some sort of vibe of, like, rich people.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Mostly meeting in some.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Meeting in some, you know, obscure spot and having experiences.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah, there's. Yeah, there's an overlap. And Mari and Marie.

[Amanda Hirsch]

And Mari Anne Marie. And speaking of, like, the binge versus watching once a week. You're a reality TV fan. Like, people might not know it's bad. Is it below deck and 90 day?

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah. But now it's like, what, the floodgates have opened?

[Amanda Hirsch]

Mormons?

[Annie Murphy]

No, it's Housewives now. And I was holding out so hard. I was like, I. For whatever reason, like, I will not deign to watch the Housewives. And then I think I was shooting in Boston. It was like a Boston and then Munich thing. It's like when I'm alone and away from people I love, and I'm just like, well, this is gonna make me happy.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

And it doesn't. But it, like, it's company. It's great. Terrible company. So I just did New York.

[Amanda Hirsch]

I did New York from the beginning.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Like Jill Zarin.

[Annie Murphy]

I don't know why they recast it.

[Amanda Hirsch]

You're like, that was perfect.

[Annie Murphy]

It was.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah, you're right.

[Annie Murphy]

It was. It was so bad. It was perfect. It was so.

[Amanda Hirsch]

I can't believe you started from the beginning. Recently, like Alex and.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Fucking that whole thing.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah. But now I've done Salt Lake City. I'm. I've done Miami. I. I've done.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Wow.

[Annie Murphy]

What am I on now? Jersey.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Jersey. From the beginning. Like, you're starting season one, episode one. Wow. Wait, so are you gonna, like, lean into, like, new franchises? Like Rhode island is gonna happen?

[Annie Murphy]

Probably.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

You're in it.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Wow. And what's your fave?

[Annie Murphy]

Probably Beverly Hills.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Beverly Hills. Which you also.

[Annie Murphy]

New York.

[Amanda Hirsch]

So when did this. Because you said it used to be. No. So did it start in the past, like, year?

[Annie Murphy]

No, it was so I was shooting a show called Kevin Can Fuck Himself in Peak Pandemic Boston, where we weren't even allowed to hang out with our castmates. So it was so solitary and winter time, and I was just like, I think it's time. And that's when it started. So, like, three years ago. And now look at me. I'm like, how many hours? How many hours in.

[Amanda Hirsch]

How many hours in. You can. I mean. You know what I mean? Right now we have Love Island. That's on. I haven't.

[Annie Murphy]

I can't.

[Amanda Hirsch]

And that's every day an episode. I think there's, like, one day off, so you can, like, just breathe air. But it's every day, and everybody watches it. And you're like, how are we all finding aside from all our other shit and all our other tv?

[Annie Murphy]

And then you Think about all of the things that you should be do. Like, I'm always like, I don't read enough. And, like, I need to watch more documentaries, which I do. I need to read and I need to watch documentaries. I need to do all those things that make me feel like I'm a good, better person. And I. I just can't. I'm. It's just.

[Amanda Hirsch]

I'm like, no, I just, like, read like the first book in. In a long time, and I'm feeling really show offy about it. I mentioned was. Oh, my God, no, come on. Housemaid. Housemaid. But, you know, the only reason it, like, it's not a smart people book. Sorry to the author. It's literally a like, a person that watches Housewives book. Like, it's that, like, gritty and like, just. That wouldn't happen. But I felt. Well, I saw it. I was on vacation. I saw it. Like, they put books out because.

[Annie Murphy]

Oh, was it like an airport book?

[Amanda Hirsch]

It was a hotel room book.

[Annie Murphy]

A hotel room book.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

Okay.

[Amanda Hirsch]

And I was like, how cute would I look by the pool reading this? Like, even if I wasn't really, like, someone take a picture, you know, and then I got into it and I was, like, shocked. And I mention it every day, but I think you need to be like, a different sort of relaxed, like, for a book and tv, you could just like, pop out.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah. And your brain can just be there at all.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Exactly.

[Annie Murphy]

But you still feel comforted.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Exactly.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

But also, I think, like, even though you said didn't make you happy, like, it is escapism at its finest. It is, you know, and made you not think of, like, Boston coronavirus.

[Annie Murphy]

All this.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Be right back after the break. You guys know how I feel about reality tv. I know how we all feel about reality tv. We like it. Like, we really like it. We live for it. If it doesn't involve a dramatic confession, a chaotic dinner party, or someone storming off in full glam, like, we're simply not interested. So let me put you on to something. We all know and love Hulu, but we really need to give Hulu the freaking credit that it deserves for being the destination for reality TV right now. And the best part, you don't have to go hunting across different apps. Hulu's got it all. The drama, the tears, the chaos, everything. The Kardashians, the secret lives of Mormon wives. Got to get out. Vanderpump Villa. Hulu has reality TV covered. If you're into glamour and romance. Things are heating up on Hulu. Catch new seasons of Project Runway and Bachelor in paradise, which I want to get back into watching this summer. Coming soon. There's also an all new reality TV series called Love Thy Nader starring the Nader sisters lebrooks. Plus, don't miss an all new season of Love island uk streaming only on Hulu. There's so much great reality TV on Hulu, it's almost too real. Next time you need your reality TV fix, go to Hulu. Hulu gets real. So yes, the rumors are true. I have become into fitness. I have been changing the way I eat. I have been into my wellness mostly for vanity reasons, but also like yes, you've seen the protein rage online. You've seen people eating beef for breakfast. Okay, I know, but let's understand like why like before I got into this new way of living, I was just eating like a breakfast that didn't even have any protein in it. That won't work. So I've had to add protein powder into my daily routine. Listen, every scoop of this protein powder that I use, Clean Simple Eats has 20 grams of protein. So I'll either throw it in a smoothie or I'll top off my yogurt with it and it's so good. I love Clean Simple Eats. Their protein powder is always grass fed with no seed oils or artificial ingredients. It's third party tested, non GMO and gluten free. I love the chocolate flavor. I'll make like a hot cocoa with it at night which is really, really good. They also have a clear protein powder which is all the hype right now. It's the pink burst flavor and it's so cool. It tastes like a melted pink starburst and it literally never stays in stock. It's super refreshing. It' light and it's also 20 grams of protein. Visit clean simple eats.com and use code not skinny20 at checkout for 20 off your first order. That's clean simple eats.com. the code is not skinny20 for 20 off your first order. Link is also in the show notes. You're welcome. If you guys know me, you know I am obsessed with quints. I love quints. I'm so happy that I know about it. I'm so happy it wasn't gate kept from me. I actually found out about quince even before I started working with them because I was looking for like a good pair of linen pants. I remember when I went to the US Open a couple years ago and I just got such a great pair from Quinn. So affordable white linen pants Perfect for the summer months and for all those summer looks. And yes, it is more affordable than other places you could get that. You know the same stuff. It's crazy because they use like the same factories that like, these huge designers or retailers use, but they just save you, like up to 8, 80% because they don't have a physical store. You can get, like I said, 100 European linen shorts and dresses from $30. Luxe swimwear, Italian leather sandals, and so much more. I actually posted the other week like, this bag and then like, literally found a dupe. Equins. I have a nursing cover that I found that was like a hundred dollars. I found it's dupe at Quinn's for $40. Like, you're not compromising on the quality. I promise you that. Give your summer closet and upgrade with quince. Go to quince.com not skinny for free shipping on your order and 365 day returns. That's Q-U-I-N-C-E.com not skinny to get free shipping and 365 day returns. Quince.com not skinny.

[Annie Murphy]

I'm Alex.

[Amanda Hirsch]

And I'm John. And we're your gracious, gracious, gracious hosts of Give it to me Straight. We're a husband and wife duo and your new best friends who unapologetically caught all your red flags. Every Tuesday, we answer your burning questions about dating problems, marriage issues, family drama, basically any disaster that's happening in your life that you want our opinion on. It's a new form of therapy that.

[Annie Murphy]

You didn't know you needed.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Whether you're single, cuffed up, or just here for the drama, we're always here to give it to you straight. And we're back. A lot of people's comfort show is Schitt's Creek a show you were a fucking star of.

[Annie Murphy]

Hanks. Yeah, one of them. Yeah. I mean, knowing that Schitt's Creek is one of those not only, like, entertainment level, but one of those shows that's like, this got me through a mental health crisis. This got me through losing somebody I love. Like, the Office is that show to me, and so I know how special that is and how important that is. And so I just feel so lucky to be a part of something that has provided some relief and some joy to people when they need it.

[Amanda Hirsch]

And that is, like, ever lasting. Yeah, it's like a timeless show that people reference and will remember forever. You know, I read that when, before you got the audition, you were about to quit, you were burned the house burned down. Like they were $3. Like all these things happened right before.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah. It wasn't as pretty cocktail of things. Yeah. My apartment had just burned down because LA fire or. No, no, it was Toronto.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Okay.

[Annie Murphy]

They still don't know what happened. It was like, it could have been light refracting through a vase improperly. It could have been faulty wiring. But the fire was so intense and my deck was petroleum based. Like the material that the boards were made out of were petroleum based. And so as soon as fire or water hit it, it just exploded. So basically, yeah, I had no apartment, I had no money, and. And it was just kind of constantly.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Did you have insurance or like, how does that work? Was it rented or yours?

[Annie Murphy]

I. It was bought, but like so far from paid off anyway, so it was just. It was like a. It was shitty and I was auditioning a bunch, but it was always kind of whittled down to me and another girl and it was always the other girl that got the phone call. And. And so I. I really was like, I think this is. I think this is all of the indication that I need. That I need to pivot. And like, what was your plan? I don't know.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Oh, a bar?

[Annie Murphy]

You thought that was my short term. Like, I guess I'll work at the bar downstairs.

[Amanda Hirsch]

But you went to college for theater. Oh, for theater. So, yeah. So you were like, I can do movement.

[Annie Murphy]

You want to watch me roll around on the ground?

[Amanda Hirsch]

Were you a theater girl, like, in college? Yeah, because I've been around theater people. Sorry, that's a crazy. Yeah, like your sneeze is like. I just remember that, like sneezing, even a sneeze was like. Like, like that sort of thing. Like, can I tell you, the college.

[Annie Murphy]

Theater people, I was not one of those people. Only because I fucking hate loud sneezes so much. Like, it. I don't know what it, you know, people have. I can't remember what.

[Amanda Hirsch]

I'm one of those people. You would fucking hate me. My husband apologizes to people on the street. He's like, sorry. So sorry. Sorry. But I'm not doing it theatrically. It just happens loudly.

[Annie Murphy]

Cover your face.

[Amanda Hirsch]

I do. And my nose.

[Annie Murphy]

I. There's a. There's a. There's something that people have that when they hear people chew, it's like. That's what it is.

[Amanda Hirsch]

You have that.

[Annie Murphy]

No, but I have that with sneezes.

[Amanda Hirsch]

So whatever that is, you do. Like, you're.

[Annie Murphy]

You get the ick ricochets through it feels like I'm Shooting a gun and it's like kicking.

[Amanda Hirsch]

So how do you sneeze? Like super dainty.

[Annie Murphy]

I go like that with like. Sometimes it doesn't even make that you're.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Literally like holding it in so bad even when you're alone.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah, sometimes I, sometimes when I'm alone, I, I.

[Amanda Hirsch]

You let one out, you're like, I.

[Annie Murphy]

Let it go and it does feel really good.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Have you ever like smelled someone sneeze? No. I have. You guys. It's weird.

[Annie Murphy]

That's disgusting to think about.

[Amanda Hirsch]

I've smelled. I've been in the closed car with like somebody that sneeze and then I was like, what is that metallic? Like, it was just not breath. It was like a sneeze smell. This is weird, you guys. Thank you.

[Annie Murphy]

Do you have weird smelling and like sensory?

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah, yeah, I do, I do. Okay. Okay.

[Annie Murphy]

Okay.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah, I do.

[Annie Murphy]

And by weird, I mean unique.

[Amanda Hirsch]

I do. I, I have this thing like I'll walk by somebody on the street that I assume smells okay. Like, like it looks like very dirty.

[Annie Murphy]

Oh.

[Amanda Hirsch]

And like they probably smell okay. And instead of not breathing, I'll take.

[Annie Murphy]

The deepest breath, puff it in.

[Amanda Hirsch]

I'll fit and puff it. I'll walk into a bathroom, see streaks on the toilet.

[Annie Murphy]

You won't get down there, will you?

[Amanda Hirsch]

I.

[Annie Murphy]

You won't get right down there. Tell me, please tell me.

[Amanda Hirsch]

I will be like, that's so disgusting. Probably like I will accidentally wanna. I'm so. Oh, you know what it is? I got to see. I don't need therapy. I'm just so curious. That's what I am.

[Annie Murphy]

Do you do that with nice smells too?

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah, yeah, I'll smell like, like, you know, the rich looking men on the street. I'm dying to know what they smell like.

[Annie Murphy]

And about just like a flower or something or like, or like fresh rain on freshly cut grass. Any of that.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Or just human content maybe like, oh my God. I literally, I'm like Dexter or something. Like smelling. I'm like the Charlie guy with the hair.

[Annie Murphy]

Well, there are people who can smell like cancer and Parkinson's and things like that. Hey, hey.

[Amanda Hirsch]

They can. Yeah. People not dogs.

[Annie Murphy]

People not dogs.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Okay, back to you.

[Annie Murphy]

Sorry.

[Amanda Hirsch]

So people not dogs. People not dogs. No, I can't.

[Annie Murphy]

That's a cute podcast. People not dogs.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Sometimes the dumb bitch voice that I do to imitate myself, you realize sounds.

[Annie Murphy]

Just like you instead.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Correct. But also I wonder because you did the dumb bitch ditzy voice for Alexis for so many years now that you imitate a dumb bitch. Do you do the same voice?

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Okay.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah. Yeah, I do.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Like, how fun for you that you got to do that, you know?

[Annie Murphy]

Great. And it's so easy. Like. Like, you don't have to, like, put any energy into anything.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Did you get stuck in it after a day?

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah, I would. I would have to shake it off.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Going home, because it's really not you. Like, you really. No one would say, like, that you, as Annie, have, like, a Valley girl. Would you call, like, Valley girl?

[Annie Murphy]

Valley girl? Like, vocal fry. Yeah, vocal fry.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Ha. Can suck it. Okay. It's all people taking personally.

[Annie Murphy]

Don't.

[Amanda Hirsch]

But it's so fun. Like, that's what I say about a voice like that. Like, it's so fun.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

It's so much more fun than just, like, speaking normally to me. So I put it on sometimes, you know?

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah. Lean into it, dude.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Life is short.

[Annie Murphy]

Life is short.

[Amanda Hirsch]

So. But when you did the audition, did that come naturally to you, or did you have to work on that a lot?

[Annie Murphy]

When I auditioned, I actually auditioned for Stevie as well, which is the role that Emily Hampshire plays. So I tested for both Alexis and for Stevie.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Which one did you want?

[Annie Murphy]

I felt like I was gonna get Stevie because Stevie felt more like me.

[Amanda Hirsch]

You? Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

And I'm so glad I got the part that I did. Cause it was a character.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Wait, but that's so funny that an actor auditions for both characters that are, like, polar opposites.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah. And I changed my. I thought I was. Oh, my God. This is such such a fucking actor thing to do. I changed my nail polish color.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Was it the same day, though?

[Annie Murphy]

Yes. I had, like, 20 minutes in between.

[Amanda Hirsch]

And I went, so what did you do, Alexis? What? Pink.

[Annie Murphy]

Pink. And I think Stevie was like. I think I even chipped it. I think it was, like, a purple, and I, like, chipped it.

[Amanda Hirsch]

No, you didn't.

[Annie Murphy]

Chip. What a loser. I know you did.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Genius, though.

[Annie Murphy]

It didn't work for Stevie. It didn't work for Lex.

[Amanda Hirsch]

It worked for Alexis.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

And do you remember the feeling of after the $3 and the house burning and all the things.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

And getting the.

[Annie Murphy]

Yes, it was. I mean, Dan was such an about it, too, because.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Were you friends at that point?

[Annie Murphy]

No, I didn't know him at all. He. Because I tested, and then literally three weeks passed. And you know that every minute of every day, I'm just like.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

Checking the phone or calling my agent to be like, just tell me. Don't want me. Just tell me that they passed. And so three weeks later, and I got a call from Dan and he was like, hey, just wanted to thank you so much for all the. All the effort and all the time that you put in. Yeah, we really appreciated it so much. And that's what people say when they're about to be like, fuck you.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

We went with someone else.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

And I was like, okay, thanks so much. And then. And I was signing off the call and he was like, just one quick thing. Do you wanna play my sister on the show? I'm sure I cried. It was like kind of a blackout, like, situation. Cause it changed my whole life. It really changed everything.

[Amanda Hirsch]

But do you love that he did that?

[Annie Murphy]

I do now in the moment, I was just like, please put me out of my misery. This is, you know. Cause you picture it. You come so close to a thing and you start picturing it and you start living it. And then to have that be like, like.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

But. Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Wow, that's so special. And did you become, like, really close filming it?

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah. I mean.

[Amanda Hirsch]

I mean, the way he talks about you, everything I've seen both of you present in or. Or anything, he's like, just obsessed with you.

[Annie Murphy]

We. I can't wait for him to watch this. No, no. We fell into, like, a sibling dynamic right away. So we got to. We knew how to, like, get at each other and we had so much fun and so many giggles. And I miss. I miss that cast.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah. It was. So how many years did you film? Like six. Wow. Yeah. And you got to be. To live at home.

[Annie Murphy]

I got to live at home.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

Roll out of bed. And I was in hair and makeup.

[Amanda Hirsch]

In 15 minutes, like, which is unique, right, for an actor and going to.

[Annie Murphy]

Like, watch Eugene and Catherine work every day.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Did you break a lot?

[Annie Murphy]

Katherine made me break so much. But you do. You get to a point where you just have to kind of, like, shove it down. Because if you break every time she's funny, no one's gonna get any.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Right. Because she's so fucking funny for me, I think. And I literally found a compilation of. Of it online and, like, put it on my feed so I can, like, watch it when I'm sad. Is just her saying, baby, like, that's my all time.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Do you have an all time.

[Annie Murphy]

No, no. It's too. There's too much. There's two. She's such a absolute goddamn chameleon. Genius woman. I could watch her work. Have you watched the studio?

[Amanda Hirsch]

I didn't yet.

[Annie Murphy]

You didn't yet? Okay.

[Amanda Hirsch]

I have to do one show at a time. It's like one, like, serious Show.

[Annie Murphy]

That's fair.

[Amanda Hirsch]

So I'm doing your Friends and Neighbors.

[Annie Murphy]

Oh, I haven't watched that yet.

[Amanda Hirsch]

It's really good.

[Annie Murphy]

Okay. That's a Jon Hamm one.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Jon Hammond and Amanda Pete, who like, love her. She's Canadian. Can I make up that she's Canadian? She's not. But she's seen the first movie.

[Annie Murphy]

I'll take it.

[Amanda Hirsch]

And Olivia Munn. So good. But the studio is. What? She's in it. Catherine.

[Annie Murphy]

She's in it.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah. Okay.

[Annie Murphy]

In all her glory.

[Amanda Hirsch]

We'll watch it for her.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Did you get to improvise?

[Annie Murphy]

Not really. We like. We shot to script always. And then if someone had an idea we could like pipe up for a button at the end of a scene that usually hit the cutting room floor immediately. But sometimes like I. My proudest one. Well, I think I. Did you get murdered first for once? I think that was it.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Oh yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

And then I did. It's like a witch's house in here, David. But I like out of six seasons, I think that's oh really the extent of it.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Oh my God. It seems like because you guys are so good and had such a flow, it seemed like everything is just like off the fucking cuff, you know?

[Annie Murphy]

I know.

[Amanda Hirsch]

I saw that you. I don't know if you're saying this for jokes is. I hope not that you would really want there to be a movie.

[Annie Murphy]

Of course I would want there to be a movie.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah. A Schitt's Creek movie.

[Annie Murphy]

Oh my gosh.

[Amanda Hirsch]

I can see it. Like I can see it. And I love that you said movie and not like reboot or not like reunion. I love that you said movie because that's what we should be manifesting.

[Annie Murphy]

Will you help me?

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah. What can I do on it?

[Annie Murphy]

Oh, I don't know. I'm I'm just. Again, speaking of waiting by the phone.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah. Really, like, do you annoy them? Like, who do we have to annoy?

[Annie Murphy]

I think Dan.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

What in it is not making him want to do it.

[Annie Murphy]

I think, I mean he's a very like. He's a real perfectionist. And I think it just has to be. It can't be like movie for the sake of a movie. I think it has to be like.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Like the plot has to be really perfect.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah. It's a perfect kernel of an idea.

[Amanda Hirsch]

There are probably like a thousand different ways this could go.

[Annie Murphy]

I mean we're all gonna be in an old folks home if he. If he dawdles any longer.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

It's not a motel. It's a retirement residence.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Is everyone down? I as far as I know you guys, fingers crossed. We'll be right back after the break. Like I said, I will be watching Bachelor in Paradise this summer. Bachelor Nation fans have been anxiously awaiting the highly anticipated season 10 of Bachelor in Paradise. And the beach is finally back open. I used to live for Bachelor in Paradise. Okay, this is. I used to watch and be like, like, why am I, you know, this is the best part of the Bachelor franchise is paradise. Like on the Bachelor, you have to wait through the dates through this here. It's like bunch of people making out, getting down. That's what I want. I want it hot, I want it dirty. I want it messy. Okay, Jesse Palmer is going to be coming back as your beloved host. And don't worry, Wells Adams is back as everyone's favorite bartender. Newcomer to paradise bachelorette, former bachelorette Hannah Brown will be making her debut as the head of Paradise Relations. She'll help plan special experiences for those romantics on the beach. They're shaking up things even more. This is actually crazy, you guys. The young singles are going to be joined by golden Bachelor and Bachelorette alumni Crashing the beach. That's crazy. Both bold and gold singles will shoot their shot at love this season. And it's all taking place in one spot. A new tropical oasis, Costa Rica. So, you guys, you gotta catch new episodes with me of Bachelor in Paradise. Mondays at 8, 7 Central on ABC. And you can stream it the next day on Hulu. Okay, listen up. This is one of those things that I wish I knew about sooner. Built Rewards. If you're paying rent every month and getting nothing for it, you are absolutely doing it wrong. Okay. Built is the only rewards program that lets you earn points on rent. Yep. Actual points without any fees. You can use those points to travel, shop, or even put them toward a future home. There is no cost to join. And just by paying rent, you unlock flexible points that can be transferred to your favorite hotels and airlines, a future rent payment, your next Lyft ride, and more. When you pay rent through Built, you unlock two powerful benefits. First, you earn one of the industry's most valuable points on rent every month. No matter where you live, who your landlord is, your rent now works for you. Second, you gain access to exclusive neighborhood benefits in your city. Built neighborhood benefits are things like extra points on dining out, complimentary post workout shakes, free mats or towels at your favorite fitness studios, and unique experiences that only Built members can access. And when you're ready to travel, Built points can be converted to your favorite miles and hotel points around the world, meaning your rent can literally take you places. So if you're not earning points on rent, my question is, what are you waiting for? Start paying rent through Built and take advantage of your neighborhood benefits by going to join built.com not skinny. That's join Built J O I N b I l t.com not skinny. Make sure to use my URL so they know that I sent you. Join build.com not skinny to sign up for Built today. If you run a business, a side hustle or you're just someone who does a lot from your phone, listen up. Because this is a game changer. It's called Open Phone. Open Phone gives you a dedicated business number that lives right on your existing phone. You can call, text, send voice notes, auto reply, even set up business hours. And everything stays completely separate from your personal life. Whether you're running a podcast like me, a small business, you're managing partnerships, or you're just tired of mixing work with your group chat chaos. Open Phone makes you look like you've got your life together, even if you don't. Open Phone is the number one business phone system that streamlines and scales your customer communications. With Open Phone, your team can share one number and collaborate on customer calls and text texts like a shared inbox. That way a teammate can pick up right where the last person left off, keeping responses times faster than ever. So whether you're a one person operation drowning in calls and texts, or have a large team that needs better collaboration tools, Open Phone is a no brainer. Open Phone is offering my listeners 20 off your first six [e-mail] not skinny. That's open Phone. O P E N P h o n e.com not skinny. And if you have existing numbers with another service, Open Phone will port them over at no extra charge. Open Phone, no missed calls, no missed customers. Go to openphone.com not skinny and get 20 off your first six months. And we're back. Was it right after Schitt's Creek that you did? Kevin can have himself more or less.

[Annie Murphy]

I yeah, I booked the job in like 29 at very end of 2019. So we, it got pushed obviously because of ye olde pandems.

[Amanda Hirsch]

But wow, you really, really lived that pandems.

[Annie Murphy]

Like oh yeah, oh yeah. But we, we shot Kevin like we started shooting September 2020. So it was, we were all masked, testing every day, not allowed to hang out outside of work like it was, it was not a great time to be working.

[Amanda Hirsch]

That's for sure. Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

And it was such a unique show in that, like, it was like sitcom Y. And then also a drama when you were kind of alone.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah, it kind of. The premise was awesome. I. The. I loved the pilot of that show so much. And because it is sitcom world, when she's with her husband and then when she's by herself, it's like kind of Breaking Bad Y. Like, really beautifully shot drama.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

And I met my best friend on that show. Mary Hollis, who plays Patty, is.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Oh, yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah, she's. It was a weird and wild time.

[Amanda Hirsch]

But were you. Oh, you were. You said earlier you weren't allowed to hang out, like, outside of. So even with her, like, even though you're a friend, you would break the rules.

[Annie Murphy]

We're living in the same, like, apartment complex, and so you have to have some kind of human interaction.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

You know, you're sitting alone with your thoughts, watching hours and hours of Housewives. Like, you need to break that up a little bit.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Right. Did you like playing, like, going from Alexis and getting to have, like, fun and comedy to something a little bit darker at times?

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah, I really. I think for myself, I really needed to prove to myself that I could do something that wasn't like. And this character is so Kevin can fuck himself. It's like this kind of low, lower class, Bostonian housewife. And so I. It was a real. It was a good challenge for me to.

[Amanda Hirsch]

And with nine perfect strangers too. It's like completely different for you.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah, I try to do. I think I got into acting to live as many lives as I possibly could in this one life.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

So I've been trying to do a whole, you know.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Do you have any, like, dream genre that you haven't touched yet?

[Annie Murphy]

I wanna.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Screamed yet.

[Annie Murphy]

No. I haven't been in a horror movie. I'd love to do that. I also want to play like. Like a grieving widow in 1806. Like, wandering around on a. On. On the shore, you know, like in a big dress. Like, I'd love to do that.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Putting it out there, everybody.

[Annie Murphy]

Let's manifest that.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Because you talked about the Corona a bunch.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Was it? Because I know you also discussed your mental health before and, like, getting depressed and going on meds, which is great that you've been so open about it. Was that during the pandemic?

[Annie Murphy]

Oh, that's all over the place all the time. That comes and goes.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

Like a real asset.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Since you were younger or I'd say.

[Annie Murphy]

Like kind of mid-20s. It started really popping up.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

Popping up.

[Amanda Hirsch]

It's like, depression or anxiety?

[Annie Murphy]

Both. A nice little. A nice little cocktail. Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

What was the catalyst for you? Do you remember?

[Annie Murphy]

I mean, it can. It's. I think about, like. I think it's kind of. It's like existential stuff, like, just being overwhelmed a lot of the time by, like, dying and losing people that I love and not spending enough time with those people while I have the ability to spend. And, you know, like, life stuff, of course, adds to that. To that little recipe of things.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Right.

[Annie Murphy]

But it really just pops up and stays for, like, undisclosed amount of time, and then you kind of, like, get out of it a bit, and you find the happiness and you find the light and. But, you know, it's gonna be like, hey, guys.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah, I'm back.

[Amanda Hirsch]

That's why whenever I talk about it, I. Because I suffer from anxiety, whenever I talk about it, I always make sure to say, like. Even if I'll say, like, I'm okay now, I'm always like, parentheses, you know?

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Because you just. First of all, you're like, anxiety, depression, gods. Like. Like, don't. I didn't jinx it. Okay. I said it was okay now.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

I didn't say forever, and I didn't say anyone coming on my back, but I always want to make sure that I'm like, no. And it could. It could pop up, and.

[Annie Murphy]

And I. I know that I'm gonna. I'm a person who's gonna have to be on antidepressants for chunks of time throughout my life.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Do you try to get off of them, or.

[Annie Murphy]

I. I do, but I know that's not.

[Amanda Hirsch]

But why?

[Annie Murphy]

I know it's stupid, but is it.

[Amanda Hirsch]

No, no. I'm genuinely wondering, like, is it because you have a relationship with it where you're like, I should. I should. I. Could I need to be okay without it?

[Annie Murphy]

No. No. I think. I think it is important to get on the right one and stay on the right one. But I haven't found the right one. And I feel like my sex drive goes away on the ones that I've been on. There's, like, no sex drive, and there is this, like, strange dissociation from emotion, and I feel like I would almost rather cry a lot than not be able to. You know what I mean?

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah. You still haven't found the right one.

[Annie Murphy]

I still haven't found the. The right.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Oh, that's annoying to go through the. The ones.

[Annie Murphy]

But. But it is that kind of slippery slope of, like, I'm feeling fine now. I should Just go off my beds like.

[Amanda Hirsch]

And then it's funny. Then you're like, no, you're feeling fine now because, because of your. Yes, I've done that before. But also then it's the, the fucking. Sometimes you're like, was that, is it placebo? Am I not feeling fine? Because I know that I went off of it. You know, it's a whole fucking mind fuck.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

With Nine Perfect Strangers though. It's a book we talked about reading before. Did you read it? Yes.

[Annie Murphy]

But season one and two are like. Season two is not a book.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Right. Did you read though, the one for the season one? One asks again. She asks again.

[Annie Murphy]

I thought it was clear.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah. So what's the last book you read?

[Annie Murphy]

Well, I'm currently reading Demon Copperhead by Barbara King Solver, which is really good. Yeah, really good.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Sounds like not anything that like Demon Copper. Like, what does that mean?

[Annie Murphy]

It's loosely based on David Copperfield's.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Okay, loosely.

[Annie Murphy]

Very loosely. But it's, it's, it's awesome.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Huh? Well, the show was very like, woo. Woo. A little bit like Hollywood can be Woo. Hell yeah. Have you done. Well, you're like in fake Chanel's, so I'm assuming you don't do like a lot of woo, but have you done any like really Hollywood thing that you remember or that you did for the experience? Salmon sperm facial?

[Annie Murphy]

Word. Oh, God, no. No, I did. I did tixel. A tixel treatment on my face. Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

But it just, just. I think it, I think it did a nice thing, but I also looked like I had been barbecued and stung by like an entire swarm of bees for eight to 10 days.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah. Didn't realize what kind of a. What is it for like a laser?

[Annie Murphy]

I don't, I don't know any of that. It's supposed to take your wrinkles away.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Did it so you feel like it did it?

[Annie Murphy]

I think it took like a wrinkle, 1/60 of my wrinkles away.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Was it a one time thing?

[Annie Murphy]

No. You have to. It's like you buy a package and now I have to go back to do it. I'm overdue and I'm just like, I don't, I don't want to.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Every time you get the barbecue.

[Annie Murphy]

Yes. And it's in kind of grid patterns.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Oh, wow. Okay.

[Annie Murphy]

It's kind of badass looking after a while, but.

[Amanda Hirsch]

But you feel silly doing it.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Okay. But I'll look into it.

[Annie Murphy]

But then the other Hollywood thing, which it's not a woo woo thing. It's just an experience that I had recently where I was at this party, and they had hired human beings to play marionette, to be marionettes for entertainment, and these poor people. And then they'd hired bartenders to have a puppet. Okay. It was the Nine Perfect Strangers premiere, which was a blast. It was so fun, but it was just very. It was very Hollywood. And the bartenders that they hired, who, you know are all aspiring actors, too, had to have a puppet on their hand while they were mixing drinks. And you were only allowed to converse with the bartender through the puppet.

[Amanda Hirsch]

So if you looked at them, they'd be like.

[Annie Murphy]

And I was just sitting there, like, in the darkest of dark corners, because that's where I am drawn to.

[Amanda Hirsch]

You find the party. Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

Like a glass of wine in a dark corner. I was just like, this is. This is the most Hollywood thing.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

And I. I don't. I feel like I need to go.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah. It was too much of the year.

[Annie Murphy]

It was too much.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Oh, my God. Do you live in la or do you.

[Annie Murphy]

No, I'm in Toronto.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Okay, so that keeps you, like. Yeah, you know, marionette free.

[Annie Murphy]

Free. Yeah, for the most part.

[Amanda Hirsch]

So not only Nicole Kinman was excited to work with you, you met Kate Winslet. We're so excited. You. I read that you got her number.

[Annie Murphy]

I got her number, and then I went to her house.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Wait, first of all, at what point in the relationship did you ask for the digits?

[Annie Murphy]

We drunkenly exchanged them the night we met.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Where'd you meet?

[Annie Murphy]

We met at the Emmys.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah, and when you won?

[Annie Murphy]

No, when we presented a couple of years ago. A few years ago, I guess. And I. She went. Dan Levy then had like, an after party at his house, and she was like, oh, yeah, I'll definitely be there. And we're like, kate Wendell's not fucking coming to this. And late in the night, like 12:30 at night, we were doing karaoke, and Sarah Levy was singing what's Going on and what's going.

[Amanda Hirsch]

That one. What a good karaoke song.

[Annie Murphy]

So good. And she's so good at singing. And all of a sudden, there's like, another voice that joins in during the chorus. And we look over, and it's Kate Winslet just, like, traipsing through the front door, ready to go. And we hung out that night and just kind of clicked. And she was like, if you're ever in London, just, like, come to my. She calls it her house by the sea. She's like, come to my house by the sea. And I was Like, I'm gonna be in London in two weeks. And she's like, come to my house by the sea. So I did.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Wait, so you were like, hey, did you think about it? Was it like texting a guy? Like, yeah, I was like, I probably.

[Annie Murphy]

Shouldn'T text her and go to her house by the seat. Right? Is that. She probably didn't mean it. Cause we had been drinking.

[Amanda Hirsch]

But you were like, but I have to.

[Annie Murphy]

But I can't not go to Kate Winslet's house by the sea. And so I texted, and she is so sweet and so earnest. Like, she genuinely meant, please come to my house by the sea. And so I did. I took the train to her house by the sea.

[Amanda Hirsch]

By yourself?

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah. And she came out and. And she, like, welcomed me with open arms. She'd bare feet, like, messy bun. And she cooked a frittata from eggs that. That her chickens had hatched. She hatched the eggs? Yes.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

She had just gotten a bunch of eggs and cooked me this frittata and. And then drove me back to the train station because she was on her way to pick up her little boy from.

[Amanda Hirsch]

No. That's so romantic.

[Annie Murphy]

From school.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Fucking Kate Winslet.

[Annie Murphy]

Get out of here. And she.

[Amanda Hirsch]

She's the coolest. Huh?

[Annie Murphy]

She's the coolest woman.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Like, not Hollywood. Not Hollywood vibe.

[Annie Murphy]

Hates it.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

Lives in a house by the sea in England.

[Amanda Hirsch]

So you call it a house by the sea, too. You're like, if she called it a.

[Annie Murphy]

House by the sea, that's what it is.

[Amanda Hirsch]

I'm never not saying that.

[Annie Murphy]

But she's just so cool and beautiful and smart and down to earth and all, like, just. I. I was just like, can I be. I just want to be you. I want to be you so bad. I want to be your friend. Want to come to your house by the scene so much.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Have you maintained the friendship?

[Annie Murphy]

I text her sometimes.

[Amanda Hirsch]

That's nice. Gotta maintain it.

[Annie Murphy]

Gotta. If you. If you have K. Winslet's number, you gotta make the most of it.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Like, happy birthday and stuff.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah. And like, I loved your way to go. And make that feminist empowering speech that kind of really chill.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Wait, it's so funny that you say that because, like, like, literally, like, every day, there's a feminist empowering speech by Kate Winslet that shows up on. On my feet.

[Annie Murphy]

I text her a bunch, I guess.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

You're looking.

[Amanda Hirsch]

You're like. Like, I saw one again. You're so good. You go, girl. What I remember from you, like, a. A couple years ago, you did a video with AJ McLean from the Backstreet Boys. That it, David. Right. And you are a Backstreet Boys girly dude. So it wasn't just like, you made a video with the backstory boy like you were. Because you're. What. What year are you born? 87.

[Annie Murphy]

You said 80. You said 90. That's so cute and sweet.

[Amanda Hirsch]

But 80. 87. 86.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

So that was the backstory boy. I mean, I'm 88, so that's like. We have Backstreet Boys.

[Annie Murphy]

How dare you? How dare you. 88.

[Amanda Hirsch]

But it.

[Annie Murphy]

It was. It was crazy.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Your Backstreet Boy.

[Annie Murphy]

He was my second.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Who was the first?

[Annie Murphy]

Brian.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Shout out. Me too. And why? And why? No offense, Ryan, but what were we? Like, that's.

[Annie Murphy]

He kind of looked like a tiger or something.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Like, there needs to be, like, those old buzzfeed. Like, what it means about you.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Like, if you, like, based on who your Backstreet Boy was, like, why did I go for Brian?

[Annie Murphy]

I think he was a little bit safer than aj Like, I felt like he could probably take care of me.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

Better.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah. But AJ Was too. So it's like, I might go this.

[Annie Murphy]

But then you want the that.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Like, guess who we didn't was in our one or two Nick. Which means. I know what that Kevin is hardcore Kevin now. I'm like, Kevin is number one now.

[Annie Murphy]

Number one.

[Amanda Hirsch]

And Howie. Shout out Howie. You know, really hope he's well. So AJ number two. You meet your number two.

[Annie Murphy]

I mean, my number two. But guys, like, I would any backstreet. The level of obsession that I had with the Backstreet Boys, like, I fell in love. Brian was my first love. And I remember going to their concert in grade seven or eight or something like that, and being in the nosebleeds and feeling like I was going to go fucking insane because he was there and I was here, and he didn't know that I was there, but we were in love, and he was mine, and he didn't. And I didn't know how to communicate to him that, like, I was just right here.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

And all he needed to do was take the microphone and call me down and I'd be his wife forever.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

Anyway, I met AJ and I flashback.

[Amanda Hirsch]

He found out that you were a fan. Or was it the other way around?

[Annie Murphy]

He.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Because you were in a trailer. Was it his trailer?

[Annie Murphy]

Yes, it was. I got to go on his bus.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Oh, you went on his bus?

[Annie Murphy]

On his bus. I think I had already bought tickets to the concert, obviously. And then there was, like, an invite, I guess they kind of do, like, fancy people in the city. Do you want to go to this concert? Fancy. And then it was like, AJ would like to invite you to the concert. And I was like, I already have tickets. I don't need. I won't be needing AJ's tickets. And then we exchanged numbers somehow, and he was like, come. Just, like, come backstage after the show. And I was like. And I did. And again, we text sometimes now.

[Amanda Hirsch]

No, shut up.

[Annie Murphy]

And my best friend from my oldest friend, Beck. We were. We've been friends since grade four, and we still like, every time I get a text from aj, I screen around. Just kidding. I don't.

[Amanda Hirsch]

So. But it. Was it his idea to do the Ill David or yours? Yes. Oh, it was okay.

[Annie Murphy]

Yes. He had watched Schitt's Creek. I think he's watched it like, six. Six times or something. He's like a Die Hard.

[Amanda Hirsch]

He's a Die Hard.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

So. Because I'm sure so many people say that line to you, but when AJ did, it was fine. But when other people do, it is a little bit annoying at this point.

[Annie Murphy]

A little bit. A little bit.

[Amanda Hirsch]

A little bit.

[Annie Murphy]

But what I've realized, because it's very kind of like, do it. Like, do the thing. Do your thing. And sometimes you're deeply depressed, and you're like, I just don't want to do this.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

But what I did, I have realized, is that. But I think more often than not, it's people wanting to do it themselves.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

And so I kind of go like, let's do it together. 5, 6, 7, 8. And then often I just don't. And let them do it. And that usually, like, scratches an itch for them. Sometimes I join in, and you're like.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Only if you're aj.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah. Only for my number two man, aj.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Well, I was saying this at the beginning, but we have to share with people, because I was like, I. Which is so funny, because I don't. Like I said. I think in my mind, I was like, tell her, like, you're a fan. When I saw you at the Rangers game in. At the. At the suite. At the MSG suite, guys. Sorry. Which I went to a hockey game, which I do not deserve to be. Like I. I was. Whenever I get invited to a suite, I'm going. I'm just. It doesn't matter what's happening. You're an actual hockey fan.

[Annie Murphy]

Yes.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Because you're Canadian. Makes sense.

[Annie Murphy]

Go sends Ottawa Senators.

[Amanda Hirsch]

So that day was Rangers.

[Annie Murphy]

It was Rangers versus Sens. Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

So she gets invited. So the way it works is, like, you get invited by the. The ma. Msg.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

So. And you come in the. In the. In the Senators.

[Annie Murphy]

I.

[Amanda Hirsch]

But were you booing, too?

[Annie Murphy]

No.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Okay. I added a lamb.

[Annie Murphy]

No.

[Amanda Hirsch]

So you're. So you were the. The. The other teams.

[Annie Murphy]

The other team. The. My team.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Sorry.

[Annie Murphy]

Stuff.

[Amanda Hirsch]

But. And you're not allowed.

[Annie Murphy]

No. And, like, of course you're not. You're a guest of the Rangers. Of course. You're basically against your brain, you idiot.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Guest of the Ranger.

[Annie Murphy]

Air guest of the Rangers. And I didn't realize that I was on. Like, they have the cameras that zoom in so close. I didn't see one camera around me. So the Sens were. When they scored a goal, I was like. And then I had been on national television.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah. It became news.

[Annie Murphy]

It became news. And then a security guard came over, and they were like, you have to take your hat off. And so I did. And then I had a. I think they gave me a Rangers hat, which I happily put on. And the Rangers are also so great.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

But it. It was a faux pas. It was.

[Amanda Hirsch]

And now I know you've learned.

[Annie Murphy]

I've learned my lesson. And I hope to be invited back one day.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Did your friends. Because I remember you were with, like, a few friends. Like, did they. Were they, like. I mean, that must have been such a funny situation to be in.

[Annie Murphy]

It was.

[Amanda Hirsch]

And then that would be something I would do. Like, not get it. Like, I totally get why your brain was like, I'm watching a game. I like this team. Let me just wear, like, their merch, you know?

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah. But then the. The sense kept scoring, and so I had to be like, sit on my.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Hand and you're, like, a huge hockey fan.

[Annie Murphy]

I mean, huge is a bit much, but, like, I love a good hockey game.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

The no teeth situation.

[Annie Murphy]

Love a man with no teeth.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Not a nick for you. Turn on. Okay. I feel that. Aj, Brian, No Tea Boys. Yeah.

[Annie Murphy]

Yeah. Toothless men. Toothless men. Yeah.

[Amanda Hirsch]

Annie. Thank you so much for coming on. Everybody go watch nine Perfect Stranger on Hulu. Thank you guys so much for listening to this episode of Not Skinny but Not Fat. Follow me on Instagram at Not Skinny but Not Fat. Subscribe to the podcast so you don't miss any episodes. Rate the podcast that you love so much on Apple Podcast and write a little review. If you tell me you did, I'll give you a big virtual Smoocharoo. Thank you guys so much for listening, and I'll see you next Tuesday.

[Annie Murphy]

Please note that this episode may contain paid endorsements and advertisements for products and services. Individuals on the show may have a direct or indirect financial interest in products or services referred to in this episode.