Nero Wolfe: The Case of the Deadly Sellout

Host: Adam Graham
Release Date: September 24, 2024
Duration: 30 minutes
Transcript Timeframe: [01:28] to [38:02]

Introduction

In this gripping episode of Old Time Radio Nero Wolfe, host Adam Graham presents "The Case of the Deadly Sellout", a compelling mystery that delves into the shadowy world of professional boxing and the high stakes behind match-fixing. As always, Adam Graham provides insightful commentary, enhancing the listening experience for both longtime fans and newcomers.

Plot Overview

The story unfolds with Celia Lawson seeking the expertise of the renowned detective Nero Wolfe to locate her missing prizefighter, Pepe Gato. The disappearance threatens to derail Pepe's promising career, especially with an upcoming high-stakes match against Mellish, the title contender.

Key Characters

• Nero Wolfe: The brilliant and reclusive detective known for solving complex cases from his New York City brownstone.
• Archie Goodwin: Wolfe’s charismatic and street-smart assistant, who often takes the lead in field investigations.
• Celia Lawson: Manager of the prizefighter Pepe Gato, desperate to find him after his sudden disappearance.
• Arnold Lawson: Celia’s husband, whose alibi becomes a crucial point in the investigation.
• Jerry Fay: A mysterious figure whose involvement complicates the case further.

Detailed Summary

[03:23]
The episode kicks off with a phone call to Nero Wolfe's office, introducing a mysterious plea for help. Celia Lawson explains that her client, Pepe Gato, failed to show up for a crucial boxing match, raising suspicions of foul play. Wolfe, intrigued by the potential complexity of the case, agrees to take it on with Archie's support.

[05:18] - [07:03]
Archie provides a detailed account of the situation, highlighting that Pepe hasn't been seen for four days despite rigorous searching. Wolfe suggests inspecting Pepe's apartment at 206A Rathbun Street, identifying it as his penthouse. Wolfe emphasizes the importance of checking Pepe's wardrobe for clues:

Nero Wolfe: "If his clothes are missing, Mr. Rainey, it would indicate that he left voluntarily and deliberately for whatever reasons he may have had."
[12:00]

[14:00] - [16:15]
Upon inspecting the penthouse, Archie and Celia discover an exquisite ladies' hat, leading Wolfe to Madame Yeta, the hat's creator. Wolfe instructs Archie to interview her, which uncovers that the hat belonged to Mrs. Larson, Arnold Lawson's wife. This revelation shifts the focus of the investigation towards the Lawson household.

[17:01] - [19:44]
Archie confronts Arnold Lawson, uncovering inconsistencies in his alibi. Wolfe's interrogation techniques shine as he pieces together the timeline and motivations, suggesting that Arnold may have had both financial and personal reasons to harm Pepe Gato. The tension escalates when Wolfe receives a cryptic call from Jerry JERI, who hints at an upcoming auction connected to the case.

[21:00] - [23:00]
At the auction, Archie engages with Jerry Fay, who reveals vital information about the murder of Pepe Gato. Through a sharp exchange, Archie deduces Jerry's possible involvement, further tightening the web of intrigue. Wolfe orchestrates a confrontation with Arnold Lawson, who becomes increasingly agitated under scrutiny.

[25:00] - [28:00]
Wolfe masterfully maneuvers the conversation to expose Arnold's motives and inconsistencies. The discovery that Celia's mother had been dead for ten years throws a wrench into Arnold's alibi, leading Wolfe to conclude that Arnold had a direct hand in the murders to protect his wife and financial interests.

[29:00] - [31:01]
The climax sees Wolfe and Archie confronting both Arnold and Celia, unraveling the layers of deceit. Wolfe's logical prowess and Archie's keen observations culminate in the resolution of the case, ensuring justice is served.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• Nero Wolfe on Taking the Case:

  "I'm fascinated by the thought of anyone misplacing a prize fighter. They're usually quite large, aren't they?"
  [03:59]

• Archie Goodwin on Payment:

  "I got a phone, Mr. Wolf. And there he was, Mr. Wolf, under the old canvas awning."
  [14:54]

• Wolfe on Marital Devotion:

  "It's known as marital devotion, Archie. I suppose you realize, Mr. Lawson, that in shielding your wife, you're aiding and abetting a murderer."
  [25:15]

• Climactic Revelation:

  "Jerry Fay saw you in the act. And when she was about to divulge your identity to Archie, you killed her too."
  [28:45]

Insights and Analysis

Character Dynamics:
The interplay between Nero Wolfe and Archie Goodwin remains a highlight, showcasing their complementary skills—Wolfe's analytical mind and Archie's investigative prowess. Their dialogue is sharp and engaging, keeping listeners invested in the unfolding mystery.

Plot Construction:
"The Case of the Deadly Sellout" exemplifies classic detective storytelling with its intricate plot, red herrings, and a satisfying resolution. The theme of deception within personal and professional spheres adds depth to the narrative.

Thematic Elements:
The episode explores themes of loyalty, betrayal, and the lengths individuals will go to protect their interests. The boxing backdrop serves as a metaphor for the fight between truth and deceit.

Conclusion

"The Case of the Deadly Sellout" offers listeners a quintessential Nero Wolfe experience, blending suspense, clever dialogue, and intricate plotting. Adam Graham's adept presentation, coupled with the stellar performances of Sidney Greenstreet and the supporting cast, make this episode a standout in the Old Time Radio Nero Wolfe series. Whether you're a fan of classic detective stories or new to the genre, this episode is a must-listen for its timeless appeal and masterful storytelling.

Additional Host Commentary

Towards the end of the episode, Adam Graham reflects on the nuances of portraying Nero Wolfe outside his usual brownstone setting:

"One reason why they might be having him leave so often is it does show how the Nero Wolfe novels are different from other detective stories almost in one way have a divided detective, the body and the brain going separate ways and the body reporting back to the brain."
[33:01]

He also engages with listener feedback, acknowledging suggestions for future episodes and potential expansions of the podcast's repertoire, indicating a commitment to evolving and catering to the audience's interests.

Closing Remarks

For fans eager to dive deeper into the mysteries of Nero Wolfe or explore other classic detective tales, Adam Graham's Old Time Radio Nero Wolfe podcast is an invaluable resource. Don't forget to follow the podcast on Radio Detectives Twitter and Facebook for updates and new episodes.

Notable Advertisements Skipped:

• Fred Meyer Thanksgiving Feast Promotion ([00:00] - [00:30])
• Geico Car Insurance Ads ([00:30] - [02:51], [02:51] - [03:23], [32:27] - [32:57], [38:02] onwards)

Produced and Directed by Edwin Fadiman and J. Donald Wilson. Starring Larry Dobkin as Archie Goodwin and Sidney Greenstreet as Nero Wolfe.