
Why MAGA (and the rest of us) can’t seem to let the Epstein files go.
Loading summary
Donald Trump
President Trump said his administration would release.
Dan Friedman
The Epstein files, but now he says those files are a hoax.
Donald Trump
Make some noise if you care about.
Dan Friedman
The Jeffrey Epstein scandal. Everybody cares. Trump adding, I don't want their support anymore.
Brooke Gladstone
MAGA has found its fault line. From WNYC in New York. This is ON the media. I'm Brooke Gladstone.
Michael Olinger
And I'm Michael Olinger. But where's the line between healthy skepticism and conspiracism?
Donald Trump
People who have engaged in conspiracy theories feel like their theories have been vindicated and thus they are very excited.
Brooke Gladstone
Plus, how the films of Michael Douglas inadvertently trace the origins of today's masculinity crisis.
Dan Friedman
He became an avatar for these changes that men were going through and it seems like maybe it was a bit of a burden to act out an entire nation's sickness.
Michael Olinger
It's all coming up after this.
N/A
OnTheMedia is supported by Dell. Introducing the new Dell AI PC. Powered by the Intel Core Ultra processor, it helps do your busy work for you so you can fast forward through editing images, designing presentations, generating code, debugging code, summarizing meeting notes, finding files, managing your schedule, responding to your co workers, long emails, leaving all the time in the world for the things you actually want to do. Get a new Dell AI PC starting at $699.99 at Dell.com AI PC how those ahead Stay ahead. WNYC Studios is supported by City Meals on Wheels, providing home delivered meals and connection for 22,000 homebound older New Yorkers across the five boroughs. Learn more@citymeals.org From WNYC in New York.
Michael Olinger
This is on the Media. I'm Michael Ohinger.
Brooke Gladstone
And I'm Brooke Gladstone. So at one point we thought we really wouldn't have to go there, or at least all the way there. But at this point, it seems perversely contrarian not to because in all our years of scrutinizing the MAGA movement, we've never seen such division in its ranks.
Donald Trump
Breaking news overnight about the Jeffrey Epstein files and the conspiracy theories officially being rejected.
Brooke Gladstone
So first, the chronology, which began on July 6th in the evening with an Axios story, but took off on the 7th when everyone else jumped in.
Donald Trump
Overnight, the FBI and Justice Department releasing 11 hours of footage they say helps confirm notorious financier Jeffrey Epstein died by suicide in his Manhattan jail cell in 2019 awaiting his sex trafficking trial. According to a memo detailing the findings investigators found the video showed no one.
Michael Olinger
Entering the area in the overnight hours.
Donald Trump
Before Epstein was found unresponsive. But perhaps the biggest investigators say they found no incriminating client list of Epstein's, no credible evidence that Epstein blackmailed prominent individuals, and no evidence that could predicate an investigation against uncharged third parties.
Brooke Gladstone
A bonfire that had blazed steadily for years, fed by the hot breath of Donald J. Trump. His sacred vow to expose the Democrats yawning depravity with suddenly a conflagration and then an inferno. The because as president, he didn't come through Exhibit A. Attorney General Pam Bondi on FOX back in February, one of the things that.
Donald Trump
You alluded to, and this is something Donald Trump has talked about, the DOJ may be releasing the list of Jeffrey Epstein's clients. Will that really happen?
Dan Friedman
It's sitting on my desk right now to review. That's been a directive by President Trump.
Brooke Gladstone
But on July 7, she shut it all down. On the 8th at a Cabinet meeting with Bondi and the President. This from a reporter who seems to know it won't go well.
Michael Olinger
So can you say why there is a minute missing from jailhouse tape on the Nancy?
Brooke Gladstone
Yeah, sure, if I could.
Donald Trump
I just interrupted.
Brooke Gladstone
Sure.
Donald Trump
Are you still talking about Jeffrey Epstein?
Brooke Gladstone
The President was having none of it.
Donald Trump
I mean, I can't believe you're asking a question on Epstein at a time like this where we're having some of the greatest success and also tragedy with.
Dan Friedman
What happened in Texas.
Donald Trump
It just seems like an desecration for.
Brooke Gladstone
Him, a desecration for the opposition, an opportunity. The next day, Democrats and some Republicans vociferously demanded the promised release of the Epstein files and have been doing that pretty much every day ever since. On Tuesday, Maryland Democrat Jamie Raskin rankled by the conspiracy fueled investigations into philanthropist George Soros, asked why don't we have.
Donald Trump
A hearing about the continuing suppression and cover up of of the information in the Epstein files? Because President Trump, Attorney General Bondi and their allies in the DOJ and FBI repeatedly claimed in public that the Epstein files have the names of power elite actors involved in human trafficking and sexual abuse of minors with convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein. And they promise to release all the information in the name of maximal transparency. Remember that they said this would be the most transparent administration in the history of the United States. But now they're shouting nothing to see here.
Brooke Gladstone
Oh, there are plenty of Democrats, but not just Democrats, lots of prominent Republicans too among them.
Michael Olinger
It's just a red line that it.
Dan Friedman
Crosses for many people.
Brooke Gladstone
The redoubtable Georgia Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene.
Dan Friedman
Jeffrey Epstein is literally the most well known convicted pedophile in modern day history.
Michael Olinger
And I really think people deserve transparency on that.
Dan Friedman
And it's not wrong to continue to push for it and ask for it.
Brooke Gladstone
And Missouri Senator Josh Hawley in high dudgeon.
Donald Trump
This is one of the worst human trafficking rings in American history run by this scumbag. And I think the more we know about it, the more we get out there, the better it is.
Brooke Gladstone
And House Speaker Mike Johnson in mild discomfort.
Donald Trump
You should put everything out there and let the people decide it. I mean, the White House and the White House team are privy to facts that I don't know. I mean, this isn't my lane.
Brooke Gladstone
And plenty of those online influencers like Infowars, Alex Jones, the kind of people the President has always relied on. But when it came to calming the restive MAGA minions who lived online, they weren't much help.
Donald Trump
The reason that you are seeing this deep sixed is because the CIA with the Mossad and MI6 was running Epstein and it was an official US government operation.
Brooke Gladstone
Here's the nation's most popular podcaster, Joe Rogan. Like, look, where's the Epstein files?
Michael Olinger
Can't find them.
Brooke Gladstone
Don't exist.
Donald Trump
Like they can get away with man. Yeah.
Brooke Gladstone
And here's far right flamethrower Jack Posobiek.
Donald Trump
I will not rest until we go.
Michael Olinger
Full Jan6 committee on the Jeffrey Epstein files.
Brooke Gladstone
And one time Trump dinner guest, the anti semitic white supremacist Nick Fuentes.
Donald Trump
You.
Michael Olinger
You, you suck.
Donald Trump
You are fat.
Michael Olinger
You are a joke. You are stupid.
Donald Trump
This entire thing has been a scam. We are gonna look back on the MAGA movement as the biggest scam in American history. And the liberals were right. We will see Trump as a scam artist.
Brooke Gladstone
The President tried to shut it down. Of course he did. But he couldn't make some noise.
Dan Friedman
If you care about the Jeffrey Epstein.
Brooke Gladstone
Scandal, Megyn Kelly, and one of Trump's favorite podcasters, Charlie Kirk, at a Turning Point USA event last Friday.
Michael Olinger
Raise your hand.
Donald Trump
If it matters a lot to you, raise your hand. So every hand of 7,000 people.
Brooke Gladstone
The next day, the President took to truth social writing in part quote, they're.
Donald Trump
All going after Attorney General Pam Bondi, who is doing a fantastic job.
Michael Olinger
We're on one team MAGA and I.
Donald Trump
Don'T like what's happening. We have a perfect administration, the talk of the world, and selfish people are trying to hurt it all over a.
Brooke Gladstone
Guy who never dies.
Michael Olinger
Jeffrey Epstein, according to one report.
Donald Trump
Get this. Trump personally called Charlie Kirk and then Kirk and others. I certainly softened their tone.
Brooke Gladstone
Charlie Kirk on his show Monday.
Michael Olinger
Honestly, I'm done talking about Epstein. For the time being, I'm going to trust my friends, the administration. I'm going to trust my friends in the government to do what needs to be done. Solve it. Balls in their hands.
Brooke Gladstone
Charlie Kirk on his show Tuesday.
Michael Olinger
Let me be clear. I'm not trusting the government. I'm trusting individuals that you too also trust. You guys are all fans of Dan Bongino and Cash Patel. We are trusting that they heard you, they heard me, and they are working to fix this.
Brooke Gladstone
The President's knickers are clearly in a twist because polls suggest that the recipients of so much of his beneficence, his respect and adoration, proved so unworthy when he pulled the rug out from under them. I'm talking about the MAGA base, or part of it anyway, he wrote this week in a Truth Social post that quote by past supporters have bought into this bull stuff, hook, line and sinker, adding, let those weaklings continue forward and do the Democrats work. Don't even think about talking of our incredible and unprecedented success because I don't want their support anymore. So there I added that. So as I write this Friday, there's a Wall Street Journal piece about a birthday letter to Epstein with Trump's signature and a doodle of a naked woman surrounding the that reads in part Happy Birthday and may every day be another wonderful secret. Trump's name is scrawled in marker where the pubic hair would be false, malicious and defamatory. He asserts, I never wrote a picture in my life. It's not my words. In fact, he's known to doodle. He personally begged Rupert Murdoch, who owns the Journal's parent company, News Corp. Not to print the story or risk his wrath. He intends to sue. Funny the role played by Murdoch here. His own Fox News Channel is barely covering the Epstein story and is silent on the Journal scoop. Murdoch's fortune was hammered by one defamation case when Fox lied about voting machines, and yet for now, he's standing firm. Not so for some of our legacy media. This week, cbs, whose owner Paramount Global needs Trump's OK for a long sought merger, said it's canceling Stephen Colbert's top rated late show for financial reasons. And it's true the late shows are no longer big money makers. It's also true that lately Colbert's been joking about CBS paying Trump $16 million to settle what's widely seen as a baseless complaint against 60 Minutes. Colbert on Monday, my parent corporation, Paramount.
Michael Olinger
Paid Donald Trump a $16 million settlement.
Dan Friedman
Over his 60 Minutes lawsuit.
Donald Trump
As someone who has always been a proud employee of this network. I and I don't know if anything.
Michael Olinger
Will ever repair my trust in this.
Donald Trump
Company, but just taking a stab at it, I'd say $16 million would help.
Brooke Gladstone
Meanwhile, the president has asked Bondi to secure the release of grand jury transcripts from the Epstein case, which courts are loathe to do. And that certainly will be redacted to protect the victims at least, and maybe not just them. So far, I've seen no commentary that predicts any revelations. It seems like a Hail Mary, an attempt to distract from all the irreconcilable narratives he's propagated. First, that the files would take down the rotten, rapacious deep state. Then that the files don't actually exist. Then that they were fakes written by Obama or Biden or whoever. And finally, that the whole thing is so boring, why would anybody care? But they do care. The worldview that he crafted, where his followers have a community and a role, is roiling. It'll take a mighty suspension of disbelief, a Herculean rewrite, to make sense of this, if they even can.
Michael Olinger
Coming up, what even are the Epstein files?
Brooke Gladstone
This is OnTheMedia.
N/A
OnTheMedia is supported by Dell introducing the new Dell AI PC. Powered by the Intel Core Ultra processor. It's not just an AI computer, it's a computer built for AI. That means it's built to help do your busy work for you, so you can fast forward through editing images, designing presentations, generating code, debugging code, running lots of apps without lag, creating live translations and captions, summarizing meeting notes, extending battery life, enhancing security, finding that file you were looking for, managing your schedule, meeting your deadlines, responding to your co workers, long emails, leaving all the time in the world for more you time and for the things you actually want to do. Get A new Dell AI PC starting at $699.99 at Dell.com AI PC how those ahead Stay ahead.
Donald Trump
Add a little curiosity into your routine with TED Talks Daily, the podcast that brings you a new TED Talk every weekday. In less than 15 minutes a day.
Dan Friedman
You'Ll go beyond the headlines and learn.
Donald Trump
About the big ideas shaping your future. Coming up, how AI will change the way we communicate, how to be a better leader, and more. Listen to TED Talks Daily. Wherever you get your podcasts.
Brooke Gladstone
This is ON THE media. I'm Brooke Gladstone.
Michael Olinger
And I'm Michael Olinger. When we talk about the Epstein files, what exactly do we mean?
Dan Friedman
Well, first of all, there's tons of files that are out there in the FBI's fold.
Michael Olinger
Julie K. Brown, investigative journalist, speaking here on CNN.
Dan Friedman
Hundreds and hundreds of pages, files that you can click on and you can look at.
Michael Olinger
Her reporting in the Miami Herald, which identified some 80 survivors, helped spur a new investigation into Epstein in 2018. Over the past week or so, she's appeared on several podcasts and TV shows to discuss the Epstein files, what's secret and what's public or partially public. In the case of the FBI vault, that client list, the one that was supposedly on Pam Bondi's desk and then wasn't. Brown doesn't believe the client list exists and that sometimes people confuse it with Epstein's contact list, his black book, compiled by his accomplice, Ghislaine Maxwell.
Dan Friedman
Trump is in there.
Brooke Gladstone
A lot of phone numbers, including the.
Dan Friedman
Important people, were on there, as well.
Brooke Gladstone
As other, you know, celebrities.
Dan Friedman
But Epstein was sort of a social climber, and part of that was him just meeting somebody and saying, I want to put you on my Rolodex kind of thing. So there's no evidence that the people that were on that phone directory were.
Brooke Gladstone
Involved in his sex trafficking? Perhaps some of them were, but we don't know that.
Dan Friedman
But there's tons of other material that we don't know about.
Michael Olinger
There are the records from the prosecution of Ghislaine Maxwell, which have largely remained sealed. Then there are the flight logs from his private jets. Some logs are public, but others are still held by the Federal Aviation Administration. There are the mostly redacted files from the US Marshals, which inspected his planes when they made international trips. There's secret evidence reviewed by two grand juries, plus records uncovered by the US Virgin Islands, which filed a civil racketeering case against Epstein. And of course, there are the records related to Epstein's Manhattan prison death, which was ruled a suicide by city and federal officials.
Dan Friedman
We don't have his autopsy, for example. We know that his brother doesn't believe.
Brooke Gladstone
That he committed suicide.
Dan Friedman
We know that there were cameras that weren't working. I think that it's not a conspiracy to be skeptical when you find that the government really isn't releasing everything or they're keeping some things secret.
Michael Olinger
All of this might seem like perfect grist for the mill for congressional Democrats, but Dan Friedman, in a piece for Mother Jones, cautions the opposition not to indulge in the conspiracy at the heart of the Epstein story.
Donald Trump
Senator Ron Wyden tweeted last week after this news broke about Bondi. Given the evidence my investigators have seen, this reeks of a cover up Another example is Democrats on the House Judiciary Committee asked in a letter in which they also asked for former special counsel Jack Smith's investigation, the results of his investigation to Trump's retention of classified files at Mar A Lago. They also said, we would like evidence mentioning or referencing Donald Trump in the Epstein files. Those are a couple examples. They aren't overt, but they do sort of raise the suggestion that Trump is implicated and that's the reason that he is not releasing the files.
Michael Olinger
You took note of what that letter from Jamie Raskin cited as evidence that there is Epstein material incriminating Trump.
Donald Trump
Right. What they cited was Elon Musk tweeting that Trump is in the Epstein files. That is the real reason they have not been made public. And the point that I would make is that Elon Musk has lied about all kinds of stuff. He said lots of crazy things. So there's no good reason to think Musk is telling the truth on this issue. And we should be pretty skeptical of things that Musk tweets, especially in this case when he deleted the tweet and apologized for it.
Michael Olinger
But on Monday, House Democrats tried to push an amendment that would force the Justice Department to release the so called Epstein files. It was subsequently blocked by House Republicans. Here's Ro Khanna, who brought the vote.
Brooke Gladstone
It's not just about knowing who's being.
Donald Trump
Protected, the rich and the powerful in terms of who had interaction with Jeffrey Epstein.
Michael Olinger
It's the sense that people have that.
Donald Trump
The government is too beholden to certain.
Michael Olinger
Interests who have their thumb on this scale. Is there nothing to what Ro Khanna is saying here?
Donald Trump
I think Democrats are going to point out that Attorney General Bondi and President Trump are hypocrites on this issue, that they're not doing what they said they were going to do. I wouldn't want to be out there saying that they shouldn't be doing this sort of basic politics of trying to force a vote on this thing. The point I would make is it just seems like there's a low probability that these files are going to turn up evidence of criminality by Trump.
Michael Olinger
I guess I'm curious to hear how you know that. Julie K. Brown, the reporter who helped reopen the case against Epstein in 2018, has identified the potential existence of many, many records that have not received scrutiny from the public or the press. So how are you so certain that you know what is or is not in those records?
Donald Trump
Well, let me be clear. I don't know. I don't know what are in those records. Julie Brown doesn't know what are in those records. So we're looking at what are the chances. And I think a big point is that these files were in possession of the Justice Department not just for the last few months, but during the entire Biden administration under Attorney General Merrick Garland. So if there is evidence of Trump committing crimes in there, that means that Garland and the Biden administration also covered up that information. So that's conceivable. It's just improbable.
Michael Olinger
It feels like this is not just the first scandal to really divide his most faithful supporters. It also feels like a topic that has inspired dissatisfaction and suspicion from both parties. Recent polling from CNN shows that a growing share of Americans really are not satisfied with the answers this administration is giving on the Epstein files.
Donald Trump
Look at this. You get 43% of lean GOP. That's Republicans and independents who are dissatisfied. Just 4% satisfied. My goodness gracious.
Michael Olinger
CNN's polling analyst Harry when you only.
Donald Trump
Have 4%, that is with Donald Trump on a particular issue, that is ridiculously low. I've never seen anything quite like it. How about lean Democrat, 60% dissatisfied. Compare that to 3% who are satisfied again, 4%, 3% Republican, Democrat. You rarely ever see this type of agreement.
Michael Olinger
Doesn't that mean that there's a solid case for members of Congress to push for more disclosure, especially considering that it really is the secrecy and misinformation around the Jeffrey Epstein case that is likely inspiring so much of the conspiratorial thinking?
Donald Trump
I think that Republicans have formed a circular firing squad. There is no doubt on this issue, and they do not need Democrats to get them there. They are fighting tooth and nail with each other, and Democrats don't have to egg them on to get them to do it. In fact, Trump, we've seen in the last few days has made a ridiculous argument, which is that Democrats are the ones who concocted this. This is a hoax, he said. It's like the Russia, Russia, Russia hoax, and Democrats are behind it. And Republicans should not fall prey to this because this is an issue that Democrats are pushing. It seems possible that if Democrats lean in too hard to making assertions that aren't going to be borne out about what these files may reveal, they will sort of play into the argument that Trump is making. And that will help, I think, kind of align Trump's MAGA base with him. We've seen that happen before on other issues, certainly with the Russia scandal. Ultimately, Trump supporters became very convinced that it was Democrats who had concocted this issue and not that it was a real issue that needed to be looked at.
Michael Olinger
Basically what I hear you saying is that you agree that this story is newsworthy, but you're cautioning lawmakers and pundits to stick with the facts. The evidence that we do have, and there is evidence that I think continues to make this story only stickier. Wired just reported this week that according to analysis of the metadata, there are three minutes missing from the video that Trump's Justice Department released surveillance footage that purported to show that no one entered into his his prison cell. Do you really think that he's not covering something up?
Donald Trump
I think there's no question that he sounds like he's hiding something. We just can't assume it's because he is personally implicated, as tempting as that is. The Wired report, these are facts reported by Wired. It's a great piece of reporting. But Hank Johnson, the congressman from Georgia who made a song about releasing the Epstein tapes.
Brooke Gladstone
Epstein died by suicide. Believe that.
Donald Trump
And you must be blind. You've been telling us you released the file, but where are they? Johnson says in that song, everyone knows that it wasn't suicide, and everyone doesn't know that that's not actually the case. It is, at best, very unclear and fairly persuasive that he did, in fact, end his own life.
Michael Olinger
I had to look in the comments when that video came across my for you page, and it was like an interesting mixture of cringe and celebration of that song, which I think shows a split among Democratic voters about how they feel about this story themselves.
Donald Trump
There is joy out there. People think it is so great to see Trump get his justice. Or it's for pushing a conspiracy theory about Epstein and claiming he was gonna reveal it when he became president. And Pam Bondi and Kash Patel, the head of the FBI, too, and now being exposed as liars and hypocrites because they can't produce what they said they were going to produce. And I certainly wouldn't suggest the Democrats should not enjoy what they can about that or even point out that they're lying. If Hank Johnson falls into saying he knows for a fact that Epstein was murdered, that's where you get Democrats sort of diving into these conspiracy theories in a way that I think can come back to bite them when they turn out not to be borne out, at least not to be proven. Yeah.
Michael Olinger
In your piece, you say that this could potentially turn out like the Steele dossier.
Donald Trump
Yeah, I think that's a risk. I think there is a parallel. People had read in the Steele dossier that there was some tape of Trump with prostitutes in Moscow and somebody peed on the bed, and that turned out not to be real, it would seem. And I think there was a feeling that the credibility of anyone connected to it, and certainly people have made this attack on Mother Jones and other media publications, as well as on politicians, was diminished because this tape isn't real. And Trump is trying to run the same play that he ran with the Russia scandal. The truth was that Trump was aware that the Russians were helping his campaign in 2016, it seems, and he didn't try to stop them. And then that scandal became defined by what was there a pee tape? Was the Steele dossier accurate? Which was not. And then Trump used that to say the whole thing was a bunch of bs. So, clearly what he's trying to do here is to say that Democrats are pushing a false statement into switching sweep away the entire scandal and to sweep away the fact that he himself said that the Epstein files needed to be released by claiming that Democrats are the ones ginning this up. You know, it's just good practice to stick to the facts if you're a Democratic lawmaker, if you're a journalist, if you're anybody else.
Michael Olinger
As I understand it, when you wrote this article calling for some caution from Democratic lawmakers, you got a negative response from some of your readers. What did you hear?
Donald Trump
Many of my readers said, you must be on the list, too. There's no other explanation for you writing this. Or maybe you think Obama is on the list and you're covering for Obama or Bill Clinton. People called me a pedophile for writing the story. Another thing that I also heard back was the argument that there may not be anything there but Democrats should make this argument because it drives a wedge between Trump and his supporters, and his supporters seem very mad at him and nothing else has worked, so they might as well try this. I think there are a lot of other issues out there where there is a great deal of personal and professional failures by Trump that Democrats, to a certain extent, are putting aside when they're focusing on Epstein. Trump has let down his supporters who he promised he wouldn't cut Medicaid. The big beautiful bill cuts a trillion dollars out of Medicaid. The Trump administration has cut funding for fema. They cut funding for the National Weather Service. His corruption, the fact that his family and him are enriching themselves by doing deals in Qatar with the United Arab Emirates, with sovereign wealth funds in the Middle East. And these are companies that Trump still owns that are benefiting from these deals, which appear intended to gain favor with him. He got $16 million for his library from Paramount because Paramount seemed to believe that was the price they needed to pay to get their merger with Skydance approved. And so they settled a ridiculous lawsuit that Trump never would have succeeded in, which he filed against CBS News. And Trump can benefit from his library. He can take his salary. He can use the plane that the Qataris gave to the library. Elizabeth Warren, the senator from Massachusetts, this week released a report on the library. And one of the reasons it hasn't gotten much attention is because of the Epstein thing. So those are issues where there is really far more evidence of wrongdoing by Trump that is consequential and had a negative effect on his supporters and other Americans.
Michael Olinger
Here's where I would usually thank Dan Friedman and we'd end the segment. But when the Wall Street Journal article about the alleged Trump Epstein birthday message broke late Thursday night, we decided to call him back the next morning. Dan, thanks for coming back on the show. This is unusual for us.
Donald Trump
No problem. I'm happy to do it.
Michael Olinger
When we spoke yesterday, Dan, you said it was highly unlikely that there would be any more information about Trump and Epstein to emerge from the so called Epstein files. Does this Wall Street Journal story change anything for you?
Donald Trump
It is certainly an indication of something sketchy going on. What I would say is you could argue this is evidence of criminality, this Wall Street Journal report, but it's still a little short of what we were talking about, which is the speculation that there are pictures of Trump committing sex crimes, basically, or videos or something like that. What it does is offers a pretty compelling explanation for why Trump has been acting so defensive and making up absurd stories like his assertion that former President Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton wrote the quote, unquote, Epstein files in some effort to smear him. Why would he say that other than if there was evidence of him committing a crime in those files? Well, here's an example. Perhaps he was aware of something like what the Wall Street Journal has reported and was concerned about a very bad looking note that he sent to Jeffrey Epstein, which does imply something quite untoward. He wouldn't go to jail for this letter is what I'm trying to say.
Michael Olinger
I think the thing I'm struggling with here is I agree that caution is the right mode in the middle of a developing story, especially for elected officials and journalists. I'm struggling to find the right way to talk about something that looks so bad but does not meet a very high bar of criminality in court.
Donald Trump
I know exactly what you mean. I am struggling with how to characterize this. And I have to be honest, I made an argument about Democrats don't take the Epstein bait, and they did take the Epstein bait and it seems to be working out for them.
Michael Olinger
You do think it's working out for them?
Donald Trump
Well, I mean, I think the Epstein issue is working out for them so far. And obviously I don't think a lot of Democrats are taking the advice, let's not speculate about what might be in there. I think people, including elected members of Congress are speculating wildly and I think it's kind of unavoidable given what has happened in terms of the Wall Street Journal report, in terms of Trump's reaction to it, in terms of Trump's bizarre lies, downplaying the so called Epstein files. It's difficult to tell people to be cautious in how they go about talking about this issue. But I still would stand by the argument that elected members of Congress should stop short of opining on what they think is in there in terms of criminality by Trump.
Michael Olinger
How should news consumers evaluate this news while sticking to the facts and not buying into the variety of conspiracy theories out there?
Donald Trump
I think that people who have engaged in speculation about Epstein that we could call conspiracy theories feel like their theories have been vindicated and thus they are very excited. But it is more important than ever when we're talking about an issue where really a lot of the key facts are still shrouded in secrecy. The grand jury transcripts that Trump said he's going to unseal haven't been unsealed yet. There's all kinds of files. We don't know what's in them. We don't know exactly what went on between Trump and Epstein. So I think it's more important than ever to stick to the facts and to be cautious and humble in what we think we know to be true about Trump and Jeffrey Epstein.
Michael Olinger
Dan, thank you very much.
Donald Trump
Thank you.
Michael Olinger
Dan Friedman is a senior reporter at Mother Jones. This is on the media.
N/A
OnTheMedia is supported by Dell. Introducing the new Dell AI PC powered by the Intel Core Ultra processor. It's not just an AI computer, it's a computer built for AI. That means it's built to help do your busy work for you, so you can fast forward through editing images, designing presentations, generating code, debugging code, running lots of apps without lagging, creating live translations and captions, summarizing meeting notes, extending battery life, enhancing security, finding that file you were looking for, managing your schedule, meeting your deadlines, responding to your co workers, long emails, leaving all the time in the world for more you time and for the things you actually want to do. Get a new Dell AI PC starting at $699.99 at Dell.com AI PC how those ahead Stay ahead.
Donald Trump
Add a little curiosity into your routine with TED Talks Daily, the podcast that brings you a new TED Talk every weekday. In less than 15 minutes a day.
Dan Friedman
You'Ll go beyond the headlines and learn.
Donald Trump
About the big ideas shaping your future. Coming up how AI will change the way we communicate, how to be a better leader and more. Listen to TED Talks Daily. Wherever you get your podcasts.
Michael Olinger
This is ON THE media. I'm Michael Loewinger.
Brooke Gladstone
And I'm Brooke Gladstone. Data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention show that men over 75 are at higher risk for suicide than any other group. Young boys are also more likely to experience mental, emotional, behavioral or developmental problems than girls their age. They're less likely to graduate high school or pursue pursue higher education. And men's participation in the workforce is declining too. Experts describe the phenomenon as a crisis of masculinity. Maga calls it something else.
Michael Olinger
There's an outright war on men in this country.
Brooke Gladstone
Charlie Kirk, the founder of Turning Point.
Michael Olinger
Usa men are aimless and they are.
Donald Trump
Treated as second class citizens. Do you think the war on masculinity in the War on Boys is a freaking accident?
Brooke Gladstone
Dan Bongino, the FBI's embattled deputy director.
Donald Trump
There is nothing the socialist loves more than a population obsessed with weak, non masculine men not willing to defend their country, their families and their kids.
Brooke Gladstone
The critic Jessa Crispin was mulling that rhetoric and the mounting data when she embarked on a binge of Michael Douglas movies in the 80s and 90s. And she realized that the actors roles actually trace to the origins of today's masculinity crisis. Crispin's the author of what Is Wrong with Patriarchy? The Crisis of Masculinity and how, of course, Michael Douglas Films explain Everything.
Dan Friedman
I was reading a lot of press from the mid-80s to sort of late 90s and I often saw him being referred to as a sort of symbol of a new masculinity. And I thought that was very funny because when I watched his movies he was always wide eyed and waving his arms around and yelling about something or other. And so I just thought, what if I take the idea that Michael Douglas is a representative of a new masculinity very seriously in order to look at what masculinity that was emerging in this time was really all about.
Brooke Gladstone
So in the 80s, we're seeing the rise of, well, frankly, fiercely right wing media that condemned feminism. People like the AM radio host Rush Limbaugh.
Donald Trump
Feminism was established so as to allow unattractive women easier access to the mainstream of society.
Brooke Gladstone
But Michael Douglas characters didn't hate feminism. He saw himself as a good guy. But we saw in his condescension and in his fragility, that wasn't quite true.
Dan Friedman
A lot of the vitriolic right wing rhetoric around feminism really gave cover to a large segment of men who just didn't want to get involved. Right. Who just didn't think that this had anything to do with them. The Michael Douglas figure conceptualizes himself as the center. He doesn't have to adapt to a changing world. The world should adapt to him.
Brooke Gladstone
So let's get to some specifics, starting with his two biggest hits of the era, Fatal Attraction and Basic Instinct. And a warning, countless spoilers ahead, but come on, These movies are 40 years old. Fatal Attraction features Douglas as an attorney who has a steamy affair with an editor played by Glenn Close. But Close then simply will not go away.
Donald Trump
I just want to be a part of your life. Oh, this is the way you do it, huh? Showing up at my apartment. What am I supposed to do?
Dan Friedman
You won't answer my calls. You change your number.
Donald Trump
I mean, I'm not going to be ignored.
Brooke Gladstone
Dan, her character stalks him, threatens his family, boils that rabbit.
Dan Friedman
I mean, it's a very sort of vile little film if you really get into the sexual politics, because there's always been the disposable woman for the man who is successful. There's the mistress, the sex worker, there's the courtesan. The reason why women who were mistresses were disposable is because they didn't have the right to own property. Right. They didn't have access to education or to their own income streams.
Brooke Gladstone
Women couldn't have their own credit cards until the 70s.
Dan Friedman
And so if somebody who has a lot of resources or the ability to threaten you, you have to do what they say, which is to shut your mouth. And if you don't, there's a threat of not just scandal, but also death.
Brooke Gladstone
And in this case, the marauding mistress isn't taken out by the man. She's murdered by his wife. Yes, that's a kind of tension we often see set up. The raging feminist versus the trad wife. These wives. And the wife certainly in this movie isn't just protecting her home. She's also striking back at the feminist's seeming contempt.
Dan Friedman
There was definitely a backlash to the development of the no fault divorce. Women were afraid that this would make women like them, upper middle class, vulnerable because then their husbands could leave them without warning. This is a legitimate fear. But no fault divorce dropped women's suicide rates. It helped lower the rates of domestic violence that ended in homicide.
Brooke Gladstone
One point which really surprised me is that the notion of midlife crisis, the man buying the motorcycle and looking for a younger woman to have an affair with, was rewritten. The midlife crisis was experienced by the woman who was much more likely to leave the marriage than the man.
Dan Friedman
Yeah. So beginning in 1980, no fault divorce was being rolled out state by state. Approximately two thirds of these divorces were instigated by women. They faced really serious consequences. Right. Their income dropped. They had mostly the custody responsibilities at the time. They would still rather suffer all of these things than to stay married to their husbands. I think the midlife crisis fantasy was a cover for men to protect their egos. Like, you can't fire me. I quit. Because so much of media was run by men, they reinforced it with these movies about the midlife crisis guy running off into the sunset with a 21 year old secretary in a sports car.
Brooke Gladstone
Who coined the term a woman journalist?
Dan Friedman
Gail Sheehy, actually.
Brooke Gladstone
Ah, passages.
Dan Friedman
Yes. In the. In the book passages, she was describing a change that women were going through once their children became less dependent on them. It would set off this kind of searching moment of, is this all that there is?
Brooke Gladstone
Where does that leave Michael Douglas, though? In Fatal Attraction, he's trying to recreate.
Dan Friedman
A kind of masculinity that no longer exists that says, I can cheat on my wife and when I'm done with this woman, then she'll just disappear and.
Donald Trump
Why don't you just hit me? You're so sad, you know that, Alex? Lonely and very sad.
Brooke Gladstone
Don't you ever pity me, bastard.
Donald Trump
I'll pity you. I'll pity you.
Brooke Gladstone
You'll leave you sick.
Donald Trump
Why?
Dan Friedman
Because I won't allow you to treat.
Donald Trump
Me like some slut you can just.
Brooke Gladstone
Bang a couple of times and throw in the garbage. Let's move on to Basic Instinct. Here he plays a detective charged with bringing a crime novelist played by Sharon Stone to justice, since she appears to be offing her lovers one by one. Basic Instinct, you've said, basically comes down to a sweater. In a way.
Dan Friedman
Yes, yes. The sweater that started this whole book. Honestly, you know, it was a pandemic. And so I was Watching Basic Instinct a lot, and it's just such a good. It's such a good movie. And this sweater that Michael Douglas wears. Maybe the most upsetting sweater in cinematic history. He's going to the club to meet Sharon Stone and all of her friends. He's investigating her, but they do, like, weird flirtation. In the interrogation scene right before the club.
Donald Trump
You never tied him up? No. Johnny liked to use his hands too much.
Brooke Gladstone
I like hands and fingers.
Donald Trump
You describe a white silk scarf. And in your book.
Dan Friedman
I've always had a fondness for white silk scarves.
Donald Trump
They're good for all occasions. But you said you like men to use their hands, didn't you? No, I said I like Johnny to use his hands. I don't make any rules, Nick. I go with the flow.
Dan Friedman
So he's going to seal the deal with Sharon Stone by wearing a sweater to the dance club? It's not just any sweater. It is a V neck, olive green. The V is just too deep. Clearly made with synthetic fabric. And so you can just tell what it's gonna smell like the next day. Sweat, cigarette smoke and spilled beer. And he's like, this woman's gonna go home with me. Despite the zero effort that he's put into his looks, the way that he talks to her, the way that he dances. He doesn't have to think about any of it.
Brooke Gladstone
Sharon Stone, the character she plays, is very successful. She lives in a house that is sleek and beautiful. She wears beautiful clothes.
Dan Friedman
It's not just that she looks amazing. She's always on the shoreline with the waves crashing against the cliffs. And every time you see Michael Douglas at home, he's falling asleep in a recliner with the TV still on, right? He goes to work and it's fluorescent lighting. They're drinking coffee out of Styrofoam cups.
Brooke Gladstone
You sound a little bit like a snob. Why do you focus on this cheap garbage that he lives in?
Dan Friedman
There's such a suspicion within Basic Instinct that the men have toward anything that is beautiful, soft, pleasurable. And I think that it's a kind of paranoia built into this moment where women had the power to create. Create things on their own. It used to be we had dandies in masculine culture, artists and poets. But now, as women take space in the public realm, there's this paranoia about, am I going to be mistaken for being a sissy for being gay?
Brooke Gladstone
So now's a good time to move to the category of Michael Douglas films, the economic actor. Starting with the movie Wall street, where he plays the hugely Successful, unabashedly amoral banker Gordon Gekko.
Donald Trump
Greed, for lack of a better word, is good. Greed is right. Greed clarifies, cuts through, and captures the.
Brooke Gladstone
Essence of the evolutionary spirit, the admirable qualities that once defined American manhood. You wrote, hard work, loyalty, ethics, they no longer have value. Only money matters. Like when Trump said during his first campaign when challenged on paying hardly any taxes, that's because I'm smart.
Dan Friedman
So Wall street was released in 1987. In 1980, you have the first real financial reform in the banking industry in decades with the Monetary Control Act. What it does is incentivize speculation over long term investment.
Brooke Gladstone
Taking things apart.
Dan Friedman
Yeah, by basically stripping businesses of assets and selling it off for parts. This is why we don't have local newspapers anymore. No one faces any consequences for the bad decisions at the time. And they continue the process of deregulation without creating any systems of oversight. This creates the foundation for the 2008 economic crash that affected the whole world.
Donald Trump
You're not inside, you are outside. Okay? And I'm not Talking about some $400,000 a year working Wall street stiff, flying first class and being comfortable. I'm talking about rich enough to have your own jet 50, $100 million, buddy, a player.
Brooke Gladstone
Talk about how Wall street commented on the impact of this change across generations.
Dan Friedman
Yeah, you have a couple different father figures in Wall street, and then you have this young man who's basically trying to figure out which father he's going to become. Like, you know, the young man's played by Charlie Sheen. The father who raised him is working class, but he's built a stable existence for himself and his family. He's a union man. The rug is being pulled out from under his feet by men like Gordon Gekko. He's a representative of this sort of new financial system. And so he does insider trading, and he does all of these unethical, illegal acts in order to attain wealth, but it works.
Brooke Gladstone
So in 1996 comes the movie disclosure, which I think can be distinguished as the one you find most reprehensible. Here we watch a man getting passed over for a promotion for a stereotypically undeserving woman. She is using her looks to get the job that he deserves.
Donald Trump
She said you sexually harassed her. She harassed me.
Brooke Gladstone
Get back here when you finish what.
Dan Friedman
You served or you're dead.
Donald Trump
Do you hear me?
Dan Friedman
You are dead.
Donald Trump
We just have to hope he's smart.
Brooke Gladstone
Enough to see he doesn't have any options. You wrote it's a film not meant to entertain or to enlighten, but to rant loudly at you up close, the spittle misting your face as you try to turn away.
Dan Friedman
It is the 1990s, and out of every story that they could possibly tell, they are making a movie where Michael Douglas is victimized by his female boss. And ultimately he has to punish these women in order to put the world right. And the world is only right when Michael Douglas is in charge.
Brooke Gladstone
Now that's your least favorite film in the Michael Douglas catalog. But your favorite character that he plays is in the Game. You say it's the only time that you felt real tenderness towards a Michael Douglas character, is the only time that he plays vulnerability in a real way on screen.
Dan Friedman
So in the Game, Michael Douglas plays a finance guy again, but this time he is playing essentially the son of the last patriarch. His father dies by suicide and he, as the eldest son, is tasked with replacing his father within the family. He takes over his father's business, takes over his father's home, takes on his father's social responsibilities. He doesn't have a sense of self outside of his father's identity. And so his brother buys him this game that is an all immersive experience to force Nicholas to figure out who he is by stripping his father out of his identity.
Brooke Gladstone
What do you get from the man who has everything?
Donald Trump
Consumer Recreation Services call that number why they make your life fun.
Dan Friedman
It leaves him in a state of having to admit that he doesn't know who he is, what he wants, what he has to contribute, and he's left in a really vulnerable place as a result. There are definitely times where Michael Douglas is put into a position of vulnerability in these films where he's being stalked, chased by the police, persecuted in some way. But the Game is the only movie that pushes him past hysteria or self defensiveness.
Brooke Gladstone
How does this speak to the current moment?
Dan Friedman
Patriarchy used to tell men what the world wanted from them. It wants you to make money, it wants you to have a family, it wants you to get an education, it wants you to be respectable. This is how you're supposed to dress, this is how you're supposed to behave, and this is where you're supposed to go to work and all of these other things. Now that's no longer really true. Just because you fulfill old expectations for what a man's life is supposed to look like, that doesn't mean you're automatically rewarded. So what you see are men struggling to figure out what other roles can they play. And there's a nostalgia for the patriarchy because at least then they were told what to do.
Brooke Gladstone
It's kind of like the nostalgia for the Cold War, right? Things made sense.
Dan Friedman
Yeah, things made sense. This was the bad guy. We were the good guys, right? And our flourishing was America's flourishing. Now, you can be other things, but men see that as threatening. The uncertainty creates anxiety rather than excitement. I mean, look at Jordan Peterson, for example, right? He's a man who has been telling men that their problems are essentially rooted in contemporary madness. Feminism or Marxism or trans rights, Right. That they don't have to adapt their understanding of themselves. It's everybody else who is wrong. And so you don't have to think about what masculinity is supposed to be for. We just have to keep being who we are. And it's everybody else who has to change.
Brooke Gladstone
Michael Douglas, we shouldn't confuse here the roles he played with the man himself, right?
Dan Friedman
I'm not really interested in who Michael Douglas is as a person. If he's a bad person, a good person, it doesn't matter, because what matters is the work that he was doing. And I think that he became, you know, probably unintentionally, a kind of vessel for these very specific changes that Americans and men specifically were going through. And it seems like maybe it was a bit of a burden to kind of act out an entire nation's sickness. But I appreciate his contribution.
Brooke Gladstone
Jessa, thank you so much.
Dan Friedman
Thank you.
Brooke Gladstone
Jessa Crispin is the cultural critic and author of the new book what is Wrong with Patriarchy? The Crisis of Masculinity, and how, of course, Michael Douglas films explain everything.
Michael Olinger
That's it for this week's show. On the Media is produced by Molly Rosen, Rebecca Clark Callender and Candice Wong.
Brooke Gladstone
Our technical director is Jennifer Munson with engineering help from Jared Paul. Eloise Blondio is our senior producer, and our executive producer is Katya Rogers. On the Media is a production of WNYC Studios. I'm Brooke Gladstone.
Michael Olinger
And I'm Michael Olinger.
N/A
Since WNYC's first broadcast in 1924, we've been dedicated to creating the kind of content we know the world needs. Since then, New York Public Radio's rigorous journalism has gone on to win a Peabody award and a DuPont Columbia Award, among others. In addition to this award winning reporting, your sponsorship also supports inspiring storytelling and extraordinary music that is free and accessible to all. To get in touch and find out more, visit sponsorship.wnyc.org.
Podcast Summary: On the Media
Episode: MAGA Fractures Over Epstein. Plus, What Michael Douglas Movies Tell Us About Masculinity
Release Date: July 19, 2025
Host/Author: WNYC Studios
Hosts: Brooke Gladstone and Michael Olinger
Overview: The first segment delves into the internal divisions within the MAGA movement concerning the Jeffrey Epstein files. Initially, former President Donald Trump pledged to release these files, claiming they would expose deep-seated corruption and abuse by powerful individuals. However, he later retracted this promise, branding the files a "hoax," which has led to significant friction within his support base.
Key Discussions:
Initial Promise and Retraction:
Division Within MAGA:
Demand for Transparency:
Conspiracy Theories and Skepticism:
Impact on Trump’s Support Base:
Notable Quotes:
Insights and Conclusions: The Epstein file controversy has exposed rifts within the MAGA movement, challenging Trump's influence and causing significant dissatisfaction across political lines. The administration's inconsistent messaging has not only fueled conspiracy theories but also eroded trust among supporters, highlighting the precarious balance between transparency and political maneuvering.
Overview: The second segment examines the portrayal of masculinity in Michael Douglas's films and how they reflect and influence the contemporary crisis of masculinity. The discussion highlights how Douglas's characters embody evolving societal expectations and the resulting identity struggles faced by men today.
Key Discussions:
Cultural Critique by Jessa Crispin:
Analysis of Key Films:
Fatal Attraction (1987):
Basic Instinct (1992):
Wall Street (1987):
Disclosure (1994):
The Game (1997):
Societal Implications:
Notable Quotes:
Insights and Conclusions: Michael Douglas's filmography serves as a poignant commentary on the transformation of masculinity in modern society. Through his diverse roles, Douglas encapsulates the tensions between traditional expectations and the evolving identity of men, highlighting the internal and external conflicts that contribute to the current masculinity crisis. These cinematic narratives not only reflect societal anxieties but also influence the discourse on gender roles and expectations.
Final Thoughts: This episode of On the Media provides a comprehensive analysis of two distinct yet socially relevant topics: the fracturing of the MAGA movement over the handling of the Epstein files and the exploration of masculinity through Michael Douglas's cinematic portrayals. Brooke Gladstone and Michael Olinger adeptly dissect these issues, offering listeners deep insights into the interplay between politics, media, and cultural narratives.
Donald Trump:
Brooke Gladstone:
Dan Friedman:
Dan Friedman on Masculinity:
Note: Timestamps correspond to the transcript provided and indicate the approximate time each quote appears within the episode.