Park Predators: "The Boat" – A Comprehensive Summary

Released on March 4, 2025

Introduction

In the gripping episode titled "The Boat" from the podcast Park Predators, investigative journalist and park enthusiast Delia D’Ambra delves into a cold case that has remained unsolved for 35 years. Set against the picturesque backdrop of Don Pedro Island State Park in Florida, this episode unravels the mysterious and brutal murders of Harry Billy Scott and John Stanley Smith. Delia combines extensive research, interviews with law enforcement, and personal connections to shed light on a case shrouded in secrecy and unresolved questions.

The Murders: Discovery and Circumstances

On the morning of Tuesday, October 9, 1990, at approximately 9:00 AM, tranquility was shattered in Don Pedro Island State Park. A park worker reported hearing gunshots at Rambler Hole, a popular fishing cove. Concurrently, witnesses aboard a pontoon boat discovered a drifting red mullet boat with a gruesome scene: Harry Billy Scott, a 42-year-old fisherman, was found fatally shot, and John Stanley Smith, 32, was discovered three feet below the surface wearing an orange slicker. Delia notes, “The identity of their killer or killers remains a mystery” (02:22).

Victims: Harry Billy Scott and John Stanley Smith

Harry Billy Scott was a well-known figure in the local fishing community, operating as a mullet fisherman with a first mate, Stanley. Harry's large stature, weighing around 440 pounds, and his boisterous personality made him both a formidable presence and, potentially, a target. Stanley, described as intellectually disabled and loyal, was an unintended victim, likely witnessing the murder. Delia emphasizes the brutality of the crime: “Harry had been shot at least five times, four in his body and at least once in the back of his head” (Jim Kenville, 15:30).

Initial Investigation: Evidence and Theories

The Charlotte County Sheriff's Office swiftly responded, securing the crime scene despite challenging conditions, including rainy weather and an open-water environment. Autopsies revealed differing levels of violence inflicted upon the two men, suggesting a targeted attack on Harry with Stanley killed as collateral damage. Investigator Jim Kenville shared insights, stating, “Harry's murder occurred very quickly” (Jim Kenville, 25:45).

Key evidence included multiple gunshot wounds from different calibers (.38/.357 and 9mm) and deep lacerations to Harry's head, indicating the use of a heavy object. Interestingly, a bullet lodged inside the boat suggested the possible presence of the shooter aboard when the shootings occurred.

Challenges and Cold Case Proceedings

The initial investigation faced numerous obstacles:

• Limited Evidence: No firearms or shell casings were recovered from the scene, complicating the determination of the exact weapons used.

• Unidentified Vessel: Witnesses described a green mullet boat speeding away from the scene, but authorities struggled to trace its ownership or origin.

• Community Reluctance: Fear of retribution and distrust within the tight-knit fishing community hindered progress, as many were hesitant to come forward with information.

By mid-1990, the case went cold, with little to no advancement in identifying suspects or motives.

Connection to Alfred Eugene "Gene" McCraney's Unsolved Murder

Delia introduces a potentially significant link between the murders of Harry and Stanley and another unsolved case: the 1986 murder of Alfred Eugene McCraney, a 33-year-old fisherman found dead with a cinder block tied around his neck. Both victims shared connections to the fishing industry and operated in closely situated waterways. Cold case detectives Jim Kenville and Mike Vogel suspect a possible connection, noting similarities in the violent nature and circumstances surrounding both deaths. They mentioned, “Harry's name came up in Lee County's investigation into Jean's murder” (Mike Vogel, 58:10), suggesting intertwined criminal activities, possibly linked to the drug trade.

Developments in Recent Investigations

Years later, the case saw renewed interest:

• Evidence Re-examination: Detective Mike Vogel led a thorough review of archived evidence, including sending fingernail scrapings for DNA analysis, which unfortunately returned negative results.

• Person of Interest Identified: As of September 2024, Vogel identified a white man in his early 70s with ties to the local fishing industry and suspected involvement in drug smuggling. However, further investigation and interviews are necessary to build a case.

• Alternative Theories: The possibility of internal motives was explored, particularly the theory that a family member might have had reasons to eliminate Harry, with Stanley's murder being incidental. Melanie Scott Fowler, Harry's daughter, shared her sister Margaret's suspicions about an ex-husband being involved, adding another layer of complexity to the investigation.

Impact on Families and Community

The murders left an indelible mark on the victims' families and the local community. Harry's girlfriend, Joyce Rhodes, descended into deep sorrow, halting her life plans and facing significant emotional trauma. Melanie, Harry's daughter, has endured years of uncertainty and grief, particularly influenced by her sister Margaret's claims before her untimely death in 2022. Delia captures Melanie's anguish: “All she wants is answers, a name, something to give her closure” (Melanie Scott Fowler, 1:45:30).

Conclusion and Call to Action

"The Boat" underscores the enduring pain and unresolved questions surrounding the murders of Harry Billy Scott and John Stanley Smith. Delia appeals to listeners and the broader community for any information that could aid in solving this decades-old case. She states, “Enough time has passed. Come forward” (Delia D'Ambra, 1:50:10), urging anyone with knowledge to contact the Charlotte County Sheriff's Office or CrimeStoppers.

Notable Quotes

• Delia D’Ambra: “Harry Billy Scott and John Stanley Smith...the identity of their killer or killers remains a mystery.” (02:22)

• Jim Kenville: “Harry's murder occurred very quickly.” (25:45)

• Mike Vogel: “Harry's name came up in Lee County's investigation into Jean's murder.” (58:10)

• Melanie Scott Fowler: “All she wants is answers, a name, something to give her closure.” (1:45:30)

Final Thoughts

In "The Boat," Delia D’Ambra masterfully intertwines forensic details, investigative challenges, and personal narratives to paint a comprehensive picture of a haunting unsolved crime. The episode not only chronicles the tragic loss of two men but also highlights the persistent quest for justice and the human yearning for closure.

For more information and to support the investigation, listeners are encouraged to visit parkpredators.com or follow Park Predators on Instagram @arcpredators.