Park Predators: The Loner

Host: Delia D'Ambra
Release Date: April 8, 2025

Introduction

In the gripping episode titled "The Loner," investigative journalist and park enthusiast Delia D'Ambra delves into a chilling case that unfolded along the Appalachian Trail's remote stretches. This episode uncovers the harrowing story of Robert Mountford Jr. and Susan Susan Ramsay, two hikers whose lives were tragically cut short, and the ensuing investigation that unearthed unsettling truths about their assailant, Randall Lee Smith.

The Missing Hike: Disappearance of Robert and Susan

[00:00 - 10:30]

Delia sets the scene along Dismal Creek, near the Appalachian Trail’s Wapiti Shelter on the Virginia-West Virginia border. On Friday, May 29, 1981, the disappearance of Robert Mountford Jr. (27) and Susan Susan Ramsay (26) raised alarms. Both were experienced hikers staying at a hostel in Pearisburg, Virginia, but they failed to return as expected. Delia highlights the National Park Service's warning about the potential dangers on the trail, emphasizing that "acts of kindness and trail magic are so common on the AT that it's easy to forget you could encounter someone who does not have your best interest at heart or who may even seek to harm you" (04:15).

Search and Discovery: A Grim Find

[10:31 - 25:00]

Authorities launched a comprehensive search on Saturday, May 30, covering 32 miles of the Appalachian Trail. By Sunday, May 31, the remains of Susan were discovered near Wapiti Shelter, and Robert's body was found the following day. The decomposed bodies suggested foul play, though initial evidence was scarce due to the state of decomposition. The discovery led to heightened fear among hikers and prompted the Appalachian Trail Conservancy to warn travelers to avoid the dangerous section near the shelter.

Unraveling the Investigation: Randall Lee Smith Emerges

[25:01 - 45:00]

The investigation took a significant turn when authorities identified Randall Lee Smith, a 27-year-old man from Pearisburg, Virginia, as the prime suspect. A crucial piece of evidence was a bloody fingerprint found inside Susan's camera, which matched Randall's prints (32:45). Searches of his residence uncovered disturbing items, including photos of naked women and blood-stained clothing, further implicating him. Despite Randall’s initial evasion, authorities eventually located him near Myrtle Beach, South Carolina, after he abandoned his pickup truck containing a note referencing the murders.

Legal Proceedings: Guilty Plea and Controversial Sentencing

[45:01 - 1:10:00]

Randall was extradited back to Virginia and faced charges for both murders. His defense team contested the admissibility of critical evidence and his mental competency, but medical evaluations confirmed he was fit to stand trial. On March 23, 1982, Randall pleaded guilty to two counts of second-degree murder, receiving concurrent 15-year sentences. This lenient sentencing sparked outrage among the victims' families and the hiking community. Robert Mountford Sr. expressed his discontent, stating, "My brother won't be back in seven and a half years. Susan Ramsay won't be back in seven and a half years. Is that justice?" (1:05:30).

Parole and Further Violence: Randall's Early Release and Subsequent Attack

[1:10:01 - 1:50:00]

Despite vehement opposition from the victims' families, Randall was granted parole in 1996 after serving 15 years. In 2008, Randall resurfaced near Dismal Creek and attacked two friends, Scott Johnston and Shawn Farmer, mimicking the murders of Robert and Susan. The attack left both men critically injured, but they survived. Randall fled but was eventually apprehended after a high-speed chase, only to die from injuries sustained during his arrest.

Aftermath and Reflections

[1:50:01 - End]

The episode concludes by reflecting on the lasting impact of these events. Scott and Shawn, the survivors, continue to grapple with their physical and emotional scars. The families of Robert and Susan found some solace in Randall's apprehension and eventual demise but remain troubled by the initial leniency of his sentencing. Delia underscores the importance of vigilance in natural settings, reminding listeners that "sometimes, the most beautiful places hide the darkest secrets."

Additionally, Delia pays tribute to Robert and Susan, highlighting their contributions and vibrant personalities. A poignant tribute to Susan reads:

"Sisu was taken from us far too early, even as she was just blossoming into full womanhood in her time on this earth. However, she touched so many lives and gladdened so many hearts. It is no coincidence that she died while in the act of helping people. It's what she did. She was, as her epitaph proclaims, a ray of sunshine."

Notable Quotes

• National Park Service Warning:
  "Acts of kindness and trail magic are so common on the AT that it's easy to forget you could encounter someone who does not have your best interest at heart or who may even seek to harm you or who may even seek to harm you."
  — National Park Service (04:15)

• Robert Mountford Sr. on Sentencing:
  "My brother won't be back in seven and a half years. Susan Ramsay won't be back in seven and a half years. Is that justice?"
  — Robert Mountford Sr. (1:05:30)

• Warren Doyle on Judicial Outcome:
  "Did Bob and Sue plea for their lives? Did Randall E. Smith give them a bargain? Shame on the murderer. Shame on our judicial system. One knifes the living, the other knifes the survivors."
  — Warren Doyle (1:12:45)

• Appalachian Trail Conference Director:
  "I think the memory will linger, certainly, perhaps that's not bad. It will encourage people to be cautious, but it doesn't indicate that the trail itself is an undesirable place to be."
  — Appalachian Trail Conference Director (1:07:20)

• Jenny Ramsey on Parole:
  "I am worried by the thought of Randall roaming the streets again as a free man."
  — Jenny Ramsey (1:25:10)

Conclusion

"The Loner" is a haunting exploration of how pristine natural landscapes can harbor unimaginable darkness. Delia D'Ambra masterfully navigates through the complexities of the Robert and Susan case, shedding light on the vulnerabilities hikers face and the profound consequences of judicial decisions. This episode serves as a sobering reminder to remain vigilant and compassionate, ensuring that the legacies of those lost are honored and remembered.

Stay Connected with Park Predators:
Visit parkpredators.com for a complete list of source materials and follow us on Instagram @arcpredators for updates and behind-the-scenes content.

This summary is intended to provide a comprehensive overview of the podcast episode "The Loner" from "Park Predators." For an in-depth understanding and emotional narrative, listening to the full episode is highly recommended.