Dave Smith (5:12)
Okay, so now that I won that debate, what's like, yeah, it's like, it's such a weird thing because you're like, well, here's the thing. I'm. I'm not an authority on too many things, but even Douglas Murray would concede that I'm an expert on me. So, like, I win this one. What do you got next? But I will say, and this is something maybe, maybe it does something I need to, like, think about more saying, but there is something where, and I don't know, this. This does make sense to me in my mind, and I've felt this way for many years, but there is something where, like, look, obviously I'm at this point, I'm very well known for being a pretty outspoken critic of the government of Israel, as well as, you know, the Israel lobby, broadly speaking, including the neoconservatives and AIPAC and the whole thing, you know, and so I'm, I'm known for that. And I'm also a Jew. And I also, like, my grandfather's whole portion of the family comes from Germany, and my grandfather escaped Nazi Germany and the rest of his whole family got killed there. And so I've gotten, over the years, I guess, just from being me. I. I get it from, you know, all sides. So I've. I've interacted with people who are like, you know, whatever you would call Holocaust deniers, who are like, oh, you're full of. That never happened to your family. And I've interacted with people who are claiming I'm a Holocaust denier. It's, It's. It's weird to get both. I will say what Alex Berenson does actually does piss me off substantially more than the people who even really deny the Holocaust or the People who really. Because there's something about, like, you know, arguing that you think a historic event didn't happen even if it happened. It always, to me seemed like, okay, you could. You could argue. It's like it's silly or it's ignorant and they're wrong. And certainly you could argue there's malice behind that. There's. It was. It was a. Christopher Cantwell in Michael Malice's book when he interviewed him, who said he asked him, like, if he denied the Holocaust. And he said, he goes, nah, you know, it probably happened. He goes, everyone I've ever met who. Who says they don't think the Holocaust happens, wish it. Wish it would happen. So, like, he's basically saying, like, everyone who doesn't think it happens sure does seem like they'd like it to happen again. Now, I don't know if that's exactly true. I think he was being kind of tongue. Tongue in cheek. But I do. There is something particularly about people who, like, level that accusation at me based on absolutely nothing. It's like, seems like a particularly fucked up thing to tell a Jewish guy whose family died, you know, from the Nazis to be like, you are downplaying how bad the Nazis were. And it does. I would say maybe I should grow out of this. But I did say this. Rob put me and Alex Berenson on a text message right after this all went down this morning. And I did just. Alex Berenson was like, well, do you want to debate this tomorrow? And started laying out, like, how he feels. And this is after he called me a Holocaust denier. And I literally just said. He said something like, I don't usually give up private text information, but this seems fairly harmless, and I just want to be tr. Like, honest about this. But he said, like, he goes, just so you know. You know, I've also been critical of the Israeli government, and I've also been getting some flack about it and blah. And this is after he just publicly called me a Holocaust denier. And I just went. I went, alex, I don't give a fuck what you say or what you've been called. If we were in person right now, I promise you, we wouldn't be having a debate, but I'm in. See you tomorrow. Just so you know, that's the energy I'm bringing. So, like, that was just what I said to it. But, like, am I crazy to just be like, dude, that's like, I don't know. It's like, I think I said this years ago, and some of The. Some of the groipers pulled this up and were giving me shit about it, but I said, look, dude, you don't call a Jew a Nazi or a Nazi a Jew. Those are always fighting words. That's the most offensive thing you could say to those two groups. You know, and there's something about someone like Alex Berenson, particularly someone who I've met. You know, I wouldn't say I know him well, but I've met him, we've messaged before, and I've gone out of my way to. To defend in situations where he was being unfairly smeared. And I defended him both on the Joe Rogan show and on the Tucker Carlson Show. Me and you have said on this show endless nice things about him and his. His coverage of COVID He really was great during COVID This doesn't change any of that. But just, I mean, Rob, honestly, I want your opinion here. And you can feel free to, you know, we disagree twice a year. You could feel free to make this one of those times. But, like, don't. Is this, like, a little bit crazy? So Alex Berenson and just so everybody sees this. So Sarah Fields, who I don't know and I don't follow. I don't know how this tweet ended up in my timeline, but I just saw it in response. She's a Republican state delegate, so she tweeted. This is how the conversation starts. She tweeted, you cannot be conservative and pro choice. That was her tweet, which I do, you know, is a debatable point, but it. It certainly is debatable that she's correct. I. I could see a strong argument for that. You know, it makes some argument that you're not really conservative if you believe in abortion. You could argue that, like the mean. I'm just coming up with an argument for her. I don't know exactly what her argument would be, but perhaps something that, like, the foundational value of conservatism is Christianity, and the foundational principle of Christianity is the sanctity of life. You know, you could make an argument that you can't really be a conservative in. Unless you're pro life. Or in her words, you can't be a conservative and pro choice. So I quote, tweeted that and said, and you cannot be pro life and pro war. They're just kind of building on what she's saying, but you really can't. You know, there's. There's a lot of things that. Now, look, I guess if you want to be really technical, Here, this is a tweet. Okay. You could, I suppose, be pro a purely just defensive war where innocent people aren't getting killed like you. You could support fighting back against the Red army as they invade the United States of America or something like that. But anyway, you know, my, A lot of people, you know, you could be, you could be pro life and pro death penalty without contradicting yourself. You could say that, like, everybody has the right to life and then you forfeit that right when you're convicted of a heinous crime or something like that. But you really can't like, support what Israel's doing to Gaza and claim you're pro life. It's just too ridiculous. If you're, if you're saying that, like everything that the pro life advocates, and by the way, I'm pro life, I'm not knocking it, but everything that they argue in every single debate, that every pro choice pro life debate ever is like, no, look, you just can't kill a baby. That's that that option has to be taken off the table. And there's a very strong argument for that. Now they, Then, you know, the pro choicers will try to go to these, like, rant, well, what if she's raped and it's incest and it's this and which is, you know, fair enough. Like the, there are extreme examples like this and then the pro lifer has to contend with that. But you can't support a policy where tens of thousands of babies are going to be killed because you say it's worth it to get Hamas in order to do that and still maintain it. Anyway, that's what this started off of. Now you might be wondering, Rob, how does that lead to Alex Baronson claiming I'm a Holocaust denier? Like, so, yes, this took just as much of a left turn for me as it seems like for you. So I, So then Alex Baronson quote, tweeted me and said, said the man who thinks Aitz was a spa and unit 731 was a cool sushi place. So he literally just comes out and just goes, says the guy who thinks Auschwitz was the spot. Says the guy who's a Holocaust denier. So then, you know, I, okay, it was literally, it must have been in the middle of the night. I woke up. I don't. One of my kids woke up and I, I went to the bathroom and then I saw this tweet and so I just responded and I said, hold on one second, let me just see what I said. I said, hey, Alex, thanks For being so great on Covid, it's okay that you're a retarded liberal on everything else. I thought that was a reasonable response. At two in the morning. What time was this that I got? 2:15am you know, I was out of a sleep. That was just what I came up with, which I did not, you know, think that much of. And then this morning, Alex Berenson starts tweeting more at me about this. And then it becomes clear that what he's saying is that the same old thing that I. He can justify calling me a Holocaust denier because I said Daryl Cooper wasn't denying the Holocaust in his comments. So therefore I'm also a Holocaust denier because I said that Daryl Cooper wasn't downplaying the Nazi atrocities when he, quote, unquote, was. So that's what that. But then this, I. I just thought this was crazy. This is actually what took it to the level of me being furious. Like, I'm glad I'm not going to see Alex Baronson today, because I'd probably do something immature. Alex Berenson, who has half a million fucking Twitter followers, tell me if you think this is crazy. Rob, I do want your opinion on this. He pins that tweet calling me a Holocaust denier. That is now his pinned tweet is, says the man who thinks Auschwitz was a spa. Is that not kind of crazy? Like, that's a. That's a wild line for somebody who, you know, who has, like, you know, has defended you. Like, we know each other. Like, he's messaged me to be like, hey, thanks for having my back on that show, or whatever. You know what I mean? Like, that type of shit. That's kind of crazy to say. I'm going to advertise to my half a million followers that this Jewish guy is a Holocaust denier. You know, and by the way, when I throw the Jewish thing in there, I'm not saying it'd be just as shitty to do that to somebody who's not Jewish. I'm not saying that. Like, it should be more off limits to say that about a Jew than a non Jew. Everybody should have a right to have whatever views they want to have and to not be smeared. And in this despicable way. It's just like, it is a particularly, like, offensive thing to claim. Like, you're. You're basically saying, like, oh, you. You are defending the people who slaughter your people. Like, downplaying that is a particularly, like, egregious thing to say, especially when you can't back it up with. So anyway, Rob, I'm curious your thoughts, and I'm also weird. I don't think I've ever gone into a debate like this before where I'm like, well, what the fuck are we even debating here? All right, guys, let's take a moment and thank our sponsor for today's show, which is ProtonMail. ProtonMail is an email service by Proton designed to replace your Gmail account for all of your important stuff so you can have a more secure emailing experience. ProtonMail is a great way to start all over again. Your, your Gmail is probably like mine, buried with thousands of messages from the past. And you can keep using your Gmail for garbage, but use ProtonMail for the important stuff. Proton always have a freemium version and you can later change to a paid product if you're convinced about the product. But for right now, you can go create an account for free. Check them out. ProtonMail. All right, let's get back into the show. What is this?