Podcast Summary: Part Of The Problem

Episode: Thoughts from the State of the Union
Host: Dave Smith
Release Date: February 26, 2026

Episode Overview

In this solo episode of Part Of The Problem, Dave Smith gives an in-depth, unapologetically libertarian analysis of Donald Trump’s sixth State of the Union address. He reviews the speech both politically and personally, breaking down Trump's rhetoric, tactics, and the substance (or lack thereof) of the messaging. Dave covers the political showmanship, shortcomings, and what these reveal about the current state of American government and broader societal norms. He pays special attention to foreign policy—particularly the lead-up to war with Iran—and critiques Trump’s approach to border security, economics, culture war topics, and Congressional corruption.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Grading Trump’s Performance

[01:50 - 04:30]

• Dave gives Trump’s State of the Union a political grade of “C”: not a disaster, but not helpful.
• Trump did not lose his core supporters nor regain lost ground with independents or young voters.
• The State of the Union is one of the rare moments to “reset things or present something in a compelling way,” and Trump failed to do this.

“It wasn't a disaster… I don't think he helped himself any… The moments like that are an opportunity to be creative... He, from my opinion, did none of that.” – Dave Smith [03:27]

2. The Decline of the State of the Union & Showmanship

[04:30 - 09:20]

• Critique of forced, repetitive standing ovations, comparing them to “North Korea style political” theater.
• These speeches have devolved into “cliché slogan talking points” across all presidents, with Trump being particularly bad due to speech length and lack of creativity.
• The “boring, brutal” two-hour runtime is notable, especially coming from Trump, who brands himself as a showman.

“The dynamic, it's always bad enough... is that the constant forced standing ovations… there's something very bad about our society… It’s just dumbed down, so silly.” – Dave Smith [06:00]

3. Substance: Border, Economy, and Political Optics

[09:38 - 16:00]

• Trump opened strong on immigration, but Dave thinks he didn’t milk this winning issue enough.
• Suggests that the speech should have drilled down on border policy as the only legitimate Trump achievement to “milk more out of.”
• Trump’s speech pivoted too soon to “rah-rah America” fluff, including an extended and awkward focus on hockey and sports.

“I would have… said that the first thing you talk about should be the border, but you should spend 20 minutes on it, not just like a mention.” – Dave Smith [12:15]

4. Notable Rhetorical Moments & Viral Clips

[13:27 - 17:38, 25:44 - 26:48, 30:27 - 32:01]

• Classic Trump: Used campaign-style boasting: “People are asking me, please, please, Mr. President, we're winning too much…” [13:27]
• Congressional Insider Trading: Calls out Pelosi and Warren on insider trading:

  “Let's also ensure that members of Congress cannot corruptly profit from using insider… They stood up for that. I can't believe it.” – Trump [16:42]

• Culture War: Child Transitioning: Gets applause for denouncing “transitioning children against parents' will”:

  “Surely we can all agree no state can be allowed to rip children from their parents arms and transition them to a new gender against the parents will.” – Trump [25:44]

• Immigration/Standing Ovations: Trump crafts a viral moment by asking:

  “The first duty of the American government is to protect American citizens, not illegal aliens.” [30:27]

  • Most Democrats remained seated, which Dave saw as a major PR win for Trump:

    "It's like, this was Trump. In my opinion, this was his moment of the speech." – Dave Smith [32:01]

5. Critique of Trump’s Proposals & Lack of Delivery

[17:38 - 25:44]

• Dave points out Trump’s recycled tactic from 2016—criticizing others for inaction—now falls flat because Trump himself hasn’t delivered after six State of the Union addresses.

“You have this idea of how… we could pay the lowest [for prescription drugs]. Where's that been?... If you haven't implemented it now, what does anyone… think?" – Dave Smith [22:15]

6. The Limits of Culture War Victories

[26:48 - 30:27]

• Points out that issues like “woke” excesses and child gender transitioning are no longer hot-button—much of the country has moved on and rejected those extremes.
• Trump is “going back to his last win,” with little new to say.

7. Democrats’ Tactical Blunders

[32:01 - 39:52]

• By refusing to stand for basic “America first” applause lines, Democrats handed Trump valuable optics.
• Dave draws parallels to Democrats’ ill-advised hand-raising in the 2019 primary that haunted them in the general election.

“Are the Democrats bad at politics? …It just makes you look bad. It's really just—the Democrats are really just like classless and stupid.” – Dave Smith [32:56]

8. Economic Messaging Misfire

[42:41 - 44:11]

• Trump claims prices are coming down, echoing Biden’s old rhetoric, which Dave says is clearly disconnected from public experience.

“That is a losing message… you’re telling them that prices are coming way down when they're not feeling that because that's not true.” – Dave Smith [44:11]

9. Foreign Policy Segment: Iran and War Propaganda

[51:08 - 66:20]

• Dave spends significant time demolishing Trump’s war narrative against Iran:
  • Refutes Trump’s claim that Iran killed “32,000 protesters,” showing the numbers are fabricated and lack evidence.
  • Lays out how propaganda (missiles, nukes, “number one sponsor of terror”) mirrors Bush-era Iraq War justifications.

“When people get up and they just fucking say Dick Cheney shit, I'm gonna fucking call them out for that. This is total bullshit. Total war propaganda. Absolute nonsense.” – Dave Smith [59:26]

• Explains that Iran is not a threat to the US or Europe, has repeatedly denied seeking nuclear weapons, and has historically combated (rather than aided) Sunni terrorist groups.
• Critiques the “peace through strength” doctrine, explaining its post-Reagan track record is actually “permanent militarism.”

“Turns out what you get when you have record high military budgets is permanent militarism, not peace. What a shock.” – Dave Smith [66:20]

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On the overall tone and creativity:

  “For Donald Trump… supposed to be… the showman. It just seems… there’s a real lack of creativity.” – Dave Smith [08:45]

• On standing ovations:

  “There’s something about the constant forced standing ovations that I do think says… something very bad about our society… it’s just so dumbed down, so silly.” – Dave Smith [06:15]

• On Trump’s “winning” rhetoric:

  “We're winning so much that we really don't know what to do about it… But now we're winning too much. And I say, no, no, you're going to win again.” – Donald Trump [13:27]

• On Trump repurposing his own past arguments:

  “That was a really powerful thing. And for the same reasons… it’s really not very powerful anymore… this is your sixth State of the Union, Mr. President.” – Dave Smith [21:10]

• On Democrat missteps:

  “He made it so simple. He goes, stand up if you agree that your job is to prioritize US citizens over people who illegally entered our country. And you're gonna all sit there for that. God damn, man. Are the Democrats bad at politics?” – Dave Smith [32:46]

• On Iran War Rhetoric:

  “This is George W. Levels of fucking war propaganda… it's really kind of up there with the most despicable things you can do.” – Dave Smith [53:10]

Important Timestamps

• [01:50] – Dave’s initial political grading of Trump’s speech
• [06:00] – Critique of the State of the Union as political theater
• [13:27] – Trump’s “winning too much” speech moment
• [16:42] – Trump calls out Congress on insider trading
• [25:44] – Culture war red meat: “transitioning children without parent’s consent”
• [30:27] – Highlight moment: “protect American citizens, not illegal aliens”
• [42:41] – Trump’s questionable claims about the economy and prices
• [51:08] – Trump’s Iran propaganda (false “32,000 protester deaths” claim)
• [59:26] – Dave’s rant on recycled war lies and propaganda
• [66:20] – Debunking the “peace through strength” myth

Tone & Takeaways

• Tone: Sarcastic, sharp, and exasperated with both parties but especially infuriated by bipartisan foreign policy hawkishness and empty gestures from politicians.
• Takeaways:
  • Trump’s State of the Union was underwhelming and displayed more recycled rhetoric than substantive vision or political innovation.
  • Democrats repeatedly fumble basic optics, playing into Trump’s hands.
  • Culture war and “outsider” messages are running out of steam.
  • On foreign policy, Trump is repeating Bush-era propaganda, pushing toward an unpopular war with Iran using dishonest statistics and recycled scare tactics.
  • The State of the Union has become a “dumbed down” spectacle reflecting the unseriousness of American political elites.

For More:
Catch Dave on the road or at comicdavesmith.com for tour dates.
Subscribe to partoftheproblem.com for early access and bonus episodes.