
From Posts to Phone Calls: How to Book Pre-Qualified PI Leads
Loading summary
A
Hey there future vip. I'm Kinsey, your on site concierge for Pemcon. The personal injury Master Rhyme Conference, October 5th through the 8th. When you go VIP at PEMCON, you're getting the full experience, luxury accommodations included at the five star Phoenician resort. $250 in resort credit for the spa, golf course or wherever your mood takes you, a private VIP dinner and exclusive access to the biggest names in personal injury. Grab your VIP tickets while you still can at pemcon. That's P I M C O n dot O R G. See you this fall in Scottsdale.
B
Content is the foundation of everything we do.
C
Most attorneys are creating content, but they're not getting clients from it. Care Prior figured out why she runs James Publishing and they build books, social media referral systems and more stuff that actually brings cases in the door. This is exactly what David Craig did to own the trucking space. Books, content, referrals, all working together. And David's coming on Thursday to break down exactly how he built that empire. You're going to want to catch that one.
B
We'll print the books for you. You can certainly hand them out to prospects and clients who come in. Include them in a welcome kit, a shock and awe package.
C
This is Personal Injury Mastermind powered by Rankings IO and today we're going to unpack the tools that make these marketing pieces work without adding to your to do list. Let's go.
B
So for gosh, more than 40 years, James Publishing has been a traditional legal book publisher. So publishing law guides, practical guidance. We have library of about 100 titles. Every time there is a new addition, a new revision to that title, the majority of our customers automatically receive that update. And that has really allowed us to help small law firms grow in other ways. Content is the foundation of everything we do. We are a publishing house first on.
C
The publishing side, you know, and if there's an attorney listening, do you guys help them, you know, potentially ghostwrite and write a book and then do the publishing distribution to get it on the shelves or get it on, you know, the on demand publishing. Or is it just like, hey, we're, you know, the library Define kind of this, you know, the publishing side, the.
B
More substantive content, it's written by retired or very seasoned attorneys. Right. A lot of times they'd have a voice of experience. But then on the marketing side, we do ghostwrite marketing lead magnet style books and booklets for our firms. So you're trying to establish yourself as the authority, as the expert answer common questions. You may get from prospects and clients. Our attorney editors, you know, conduct an interview with you, certainly will provide a detailed outline. What distinguishes you, what types of cases are you really looking to bring in? Let's cover those topics. And then that's a book that the attorney owns. And it's a custom book, really kind of ghost written by us with the help of some interviews and some help from the attorneys.
C
Let's say that you've got a niche attorney, let's say a truck accident attorney, a Michael Cowan, Joe Free, David Craig, that wants a trucking book. I mean, there's many guys, there's many great trucking attorneys. Those are just some names that popped in my head. You know, maybe they want a trucking book that they can put on their website to kind of elevate their social proof. And then maybe they even want to mail it to any every prospect because it's a lower volume and they can actually send it to every single prospect. So is that something that would fall in line with the, with the, the assistance there?
B
That's exactly the goal. Right. And often, you know, attorneys will come to us, okay, we want an all encompassing, you know, personal injury, frequently asked question book, hundred page. It's like, okay, we can certainly do that. But to your point, it's really kind of niching down and let's, let's publish a series of titles in varying areas that of course match the types of cases that you're looking to bring in. And that's really what we're kind of rolling out with most of our firms. And then we help with the promotion as well. We'll print the books for you. You can certainly hand them out to prospects and clients who come in, include them in a welcome kit, a shock and awe package. But you know, we also help to really promote that book in a lot of different ways. So first of all, definitely on social media, we're creating full funnels to drive traffic to these lead magnets to these books that typically would live on the firm site. We'll actually even put some promotion behind, kind of optimizing their Amazon presence and then offering them as sort of just traditional lead magnets on their website in exchange for contact information. The digital version of the book is delivered instantly. And we're entering all of those folks into comprehensive follow up drip campaigns, text sequences that are also very customized, very tailored, so that we're kind of talking as directly as we can to that prospect's unique legal situation, unique need. So it's really full circle. It's not just about, I mean Certainly having the asset, having that book is highly valuable, but putting some promotion behind it can, can really be low hanging fruit for a lot of our clients. Maybe have an email list, you know, that you haven't, haven't sent anything to in, in years.
C
I gotta drill down the one phrase you said because I've heard this several times and I'm like, is this is common in legal. So you said the shock and awe package, right? So I remember talking to another attorney like, hey, you got these mailers that, these shock and op. I could just. First of all, what the hell is that? Do you guys make those? Like, like, what is it?
B
It sounds so cool, doesn't it?
C
Right? But it's like so specific in the legal space. They're like, shock and awe package. And like I've had multiple clients tell me this and it's like, no, it's a welcome package or an orientation package. But like, anyways, I'll let you know.
B
I mean, I would say it's a. Yeah, it's a glorified welcome package. Right? So something to, you know, instantly separate yourself from the competition. Just provide value to a prospect who. Maybe they're attorney shopping, right? Maybe they're not receiving any. They contacted five attorneys. You're the only one that is either, you know, delivering physical, an actual mails or, you know, actual physical package of, you know, a book, a welcome letter, you know, what to expect, you know, checklists, that kind of thing, or digitally. We will also, you know, deliver them. Deliver these shocking up packages. Delivery digitally. Excuse me, allowing, you know, obviously you don't have to pay for postage and the fulfillment, but same same concept, right? Instantly delivered. And it's just a way of setting, you know, setting you apart from the competition.
C
Even up is excited to announce their latest solution. AI Playbooks drive proactive case decisions with AI Playbooks by automatically flagging critical information across every case file, from intake to resolution. Even up is pioneering AI solutions tailored to help personal injury law firms save time, resolve cases faster, and consistently settle for more. Backed by $235 million in funding, they support over a thousand firms nationwide, from solo practitioners to leading PI firms in the country. Learn more today@evenuplaw.com Most agencies sell promises Rankings delivers proof. We've taken firms from invisible to number one in the toughest PI markets. While others are still scrambling to figure out ChatGPT. We're already optimizing for AI search. So your firm is the answer the clients see first. Don't wait while your competitors eat your lunch. Visit rankings IO and start dominating search today. Tell me about just top level what you guys do on the social side.
B
Yeah, so we really do offer a done for you social media package. What that means is we are posting 16 to 20 times a month for our law firms. And the foundation of those posts, really custom videos. For years we were shooting custom videos so remotely, right? So our attorneys would hop on monthly, maybe take 30, 45 minutes a month to jump on with one of our video directors again. We provide all the scripts. It's very collaborative, right. But we're, we're creating the scripts like I said. Our attorney editors who work on our law books are also drafting all of these scripts and then topics because sometimes that can be the hardest thing, like what the heck do I even talk about? What do I post? You have to keep fresh on an ongoing monthly basis. Big game changer for us. This past year has been really pivoting to more AI clone avatar videos. So up until really about six months ago, we weren't, we weren't comfortable enough with the technology to go to really offer the clone avatar option. Right. So we use hey Gen to create clones. We've created hundreds of clones for attorneys at this point, but there really is an art to it. You can't just, you know, hop on hey Gen, sit behind your desk, read a boring script and expect this amazing performance. I mean, your clone will be robotic and awkward because that's how the foundational footage kind of, you know, was collected. So there's really an art to it, but, you know, really a game changer for us because even though we felt like we had streamlined the process as much as possible, right? With the live shoots, you just show up to 30 minute monthly shoot. We're batch recording, collecting all the footage we need in that single shoot. We're providing the scripts, we're loading a teleprompter. You know, it, it was pretty painless. But getting attorneys just to show up to that darn shoot is a huge, huge hurdle, right? And pressing client matters always take precedence. You know, we understand that we've, we've worked with attorneys for many decades. We understand that the pressure is there. So then to have the option of creating a lifelike natural clone that you don't even have to show up for those monthly shoots. You approve some topics, you know, you look at some scripts, you don't have to get camera ready. I tell attorneys a lot of times your clone can actually perform better than you, believe it or not. You know, and you don't have to kind of dedicate to it. So, so that's really kind of the, the foundation of the program. Of course there's a lot of content that we're sprinkling kind of peppering in throughout the social media pieces. We're closely monitoring the views of all these videos. When one performs better than the others, we're boosting those top performing videos and really creating lead gen ads from those top performing videos gives us all that organic content, gives us a really nice kind of test, you know, okay, rather than like let's just boost everything or let's just arbitrarily pick some videos to boost now. This is what's already resonating. This is what you know is really helpful to your audience. Let's put a little bit of money behind that video, you know, really transform it into a lead generating ad and efficiently grow exposure on social.
C
I immediately when I was thinking of this, I don't know this for certain. I think Shannara has really stepped up their game and I think they've made a clone for Alex in some of the videos because I've seen him like jumping over cars and things. Like, I don't know that. It's amazing. So they're getting a lot of. I really encourage everyone to check out Shannara's social. They really stepped it up lately and it's, it's really funny and great.
B
Yeah, that's cool.
C
For success. Are you still seeing it more on the meta side from a legion perspective for the injury attorneys? Are you seeing the leads come in on TikTok, like just from the lead perspective, what channels are working most effectively there?
B
Yeah, yeah, yeah, definitely the meta side. Specifically Instagram is where we've been able to really kind of dial in the lead gen for our personal injury and gosh, probably 60, maybe 70% of our subscribers are personal injury firms. So we certainly have a pretty large subset there. But also we're kind of bringing in some offline referral techniques that have really helped kind of boost our social media. What I mean by that is we're actually building referral relationships for our firms. We actually will call potential referral sources in our law firms, area, fellow attorneys and non competing specialties, allied professionals, anyone who would commonly come across the type of client that you're looking for. And we're actually the matchmaker. So we're setting a phone appointment for our firms, for our attorneys with potential referral sources and really kind of taking some of that offline and then kind of full circle, creating some collaborative content on social that we can kind of then help keep the firms top of mind when that partner does have business to refer. So that referral piece has actually been really interesting. We've set more than a thousand referral partner appointments for our attorney subscribers. We really know we've kind of boiled it down to the most efficient, most effective core. Takes about three hours of work to set one appointment. In other words, about three hours of calling. So it's not as simple as just picking up the phone and hey, you know, you can want to jump on a referral partner call with you know, XYZ firm and then the referrals just start flowing in, right? There's a lot of, certainly a lot of callbacks, a lot of voicemails, a lot of getting through the gatekeeper so that we can access either the partner, you know, herself, himself or certainly whoever has access to the partner's calendar and then making sure that both parties actually show up to the appointment. It's a huge part of it. We kind of identify VIP referral sources, the most productive referral sources, and we're setting handwritten thank you cards, periodic tailored gifts, and then taking that, the social media piece to make sure that we're supporting our partners online as well.
C
You know, we mentioned like, hey, it's a truly done for you service and we're doing this. Having said that, what's the best chance a PI attorney has at succeeding if they do this? Do they also maybe contribute a little social? Do they engage on the comments of your most successful clients in this particular service? What are they doing? What's the extra sauce to really get it to work?
B
Well, we call it a done for you service. We want to take as much of the heavy lifting off of the firm's plate and but the firms that are truly successful, that are in kind of the top performing, it's all about their follow up and their intake process. When you're just not prepared, the firm just isn't prepared or doesn't have a system, doesn't have that foundation in place to accept the lead or to follow up with the prospect who might be super interested. But maybe they inquired at 2:30 in the morning, right? Because that's when they're scrolling on Facebook and that's when they're seeing the ad, but they have a great case. What are we doing to make sure that we can actually retain that client? So certainly the folks that have, you know, internal processes set up to kind of convert on those leads and we really try and support even in that area as much as we can, like this isn't working. Let's take a look at your intake. Like, let's audit. Let's mystery shop your firm. Gosh, I called at 2 in the afternoon and got a voicemail. You know what I mean? It's not. So what can we do to kind of, you know, coach them up and help them to fill some of those. Those gaps?
C
Yeah, you see that wanted case percentage less than 90%. It's like, guys, come on. We should be trying to hit 94, 95 and that stretch goals in 96. Yeah. There's a lot of money on the table when we do that. The. So that makes it. That makes a ton of sense for audience listening that wants to connect with you, that has more questions about James Publishing and everything you do. Where can they go to connect with you and learn more?
B
Yeah, thanks for asking. So jamesamplifier.com you can actually set a direct appointment with me. I love to hear from attorneys and I just love talking about this stuff. So even if you just love, like to connect, I'd love to chat.
C
Here's what you do next. Pick one thing, a book, a social strategy, a newsletter, and go all in with it. Build the systems around it. Make it work. And if you want to see this taken to the next level, David Craig is on the show this Thursday showing you exactly how he used this stuff to dominate trucking cases. Don't miss it. I'm Chris Dreyer. This is Personal Injury Mastermind. I'm out.
Podcast: Personal Injury Mastermind
Host: Chris Dreyer (Rankings.io)
Episode: 346. Bonus: Books Into Cases - Education Marketing for PI Firms w/ Kara Prior
Guest: Kara Prior (James Publishing)
Release Date: August 26, 2025
Main Theme:
This episode explores how personal injury (PI) law firms can turn educational marketing assets—especially books and content—into client-generating machines. Chris Dreyer and Kara Prior dissect the full-circle marketing playbook: from ghostwritten books and “shock and awe” welcome kits to cutting-edge social strategy using AI video and white-glove referral outreach. The focus: how to create authority, build trust, and generate consistent case flow without burdening busy attorneys.
[00:38 – 03:41]
[05:23 – 06:55]
[07:53 – 11:06]
[11:28 – 13:54]
[13:54 – 15:53]
“Pick one thing, a book, a social strategy, a newsletter, and go all in with it. Build the systems around it. Make it work.”
– Chris Dreyer [16:08]
This summary delivers the full value of the episode’s battle-tested PI marketing strategies, giving you actionable steps to turn books and content into actual cases—even if you never listen to the episode.