A manhunt and search for a motive in Minnesota

Summary

Summary of "A Manhunt and Search for a Motive in Minnesota"

Podcast: Post Reports by The Washington Post
Hosts: Colby Ichowitz & Patrick Marley
Release Date: June 16, 2025

---

Introduction

In the June 16, 2025, episode of Post Reports, hosts Colby Ichowitz and Patrick Marley delve into a chilling incident in Minnesota involving the targeted shootings of state lawmakers and their spouses. This detailed summary encapsulates the key points, discussions, insights, and conclusions from the episode, providing a comprehensive overview for those who haven't listened.

The Tragic Attacks

Sequence of Events

The episode opens with Colby Ichowitz outlining the harrowing events that transpired over the weekend:

Colby Ichowitz [00:02]: "Today we are learning more about the man who allegedly shot two Minnesota lawmakers and their spouses over the weekend. One couple died, the other survived."

Patrick Marley provides a vivid description of the suspect's appearance and tactics:

Patrick Marley [00:32]: "He was dressed as a law enforcement officer wearing a tactical vest and body armor, carrying a handgun and a flashlight and wearing that same hyper-realistic silicone mask."

Details of the Attack

Patrick Marley breaks down the timeline of the attacks:

Patrick Marley [02:06]: "This all began at 2am on Saturday when a shooter went to the door of State Senator John Hoffman and shot Hoffman and his wife Yvette. (...) He then went to the homes of two other state lawmakers and then went to the home of a fourth lawmaker, State Representative Melissa Hortman. He shot both Melissa Hortman and Mark Hortman and they have died."

The assaults sparked a massive 43-hour manhunt, the largest in Minnesota's history, culminating in Belter's arrest in a rural area southwest of the Twin Cities.

Profile of the Suspect: Vance Luther Belter

Personal Background

Patrick Marley provides an in-depth look into Vance Luther Belter's life:

Patrick Marley [06:26]: "Vance Belter is 57 years old. He's married, has five children. He lives in a rural part of Minnesota outside the Twin Cities called Green Isle. (...) He was working in funeral services and had on-call jobs related to organ donation."

Religious Beliefs

Belter's devout Christian faith played a significant role in his life:

Patrick Marley [07:54]: "He became a born-again Christian at age 17. (...) 'I met Jesus when I was 17 years old and I gave my life to him. And about four months after that I met the Holy Spirit and was filled with the Holy Spirit and I just wanted to tell everybody about Jesus.'"

Social Circle and Behavior

Conversations with Belter's roommate, David Carlson, revealed a man whose friends were baffled by his actions:

David Carlson [09:37]: "I love you guys. I made some choices and you guys don't know anything about this, but I'm going to be gone for a while."

Carlson expressed confusion and disbelief:

David Carlson [12:09]: "I don't understand it. I can't. But my feelings right now, I feel rage and upset with him."

Political Affiliations and Motives

Despite some claims linking Belter to Democratic affiliations through a workforce development board, his friends refuted any political motivations:

Patrick Marley [19:00]: "Bolter was on a workforce development board that included dozens of people. (...) People close to the governor say that he didn't know Bolter. It's a pretty routine appointment to a board that doesn't get much attention."

The Victims

Melissa Hortman

A prominent progressive leader, Melissa Hortman had a significant impact on Minnesota politics:

Patrick Marley [04:30]: "Melissa Hortman was a central figure in Minnesota politics for a long time. (...) During her time leading state legislature, Melissa Hortman and other Democrats put a focus on securing abortion rights and codifying that into the state constitution."

John Hoffman

State Senator John Hoffman was also a long-standing figure committed to liberal causes:

Patrick Marley [06:03]: "State Senator John Hoffman had also been in state politics for a long time and was part of the majority when Democrats controlled all of state government that was able to advance these liberal causes that were so important to the party at the time."

Investigating the Motive

Evidence Found

Authorities discovered flyers for anti-Trump protests and a list of potential Democratic targets in Belter's vehicle:

Patrick Marley [13:09]: "Police say it's clear that there was a political element to the motivations here, but we don't know more precisely what those were."

Absence of a Clear Manifesto

Despite findings, Belter did not leave behind a traditional manifesto:

Patrick Marley [13:09]: "They say that this also included, like, may have been a notebook, that it also included his thoughts on various issues. But they stress this is not, quote, a 'traditional manifesto.'"

Public and Political Reactions

Condemnation Across the Spectrum

The attacks have been universally condemned, though responses vary:

Patrick Marley [17:39]: "The attacks have been condemned by officials from both sides."

President Trump's Statement

While criticizing Governor Tim Walz, President Trump emphasized justice:

Patrick Marley [17:39]: "Donald Trump took to his social media platform, Truth Social, to say that this would be investigated and charges would be issued that they would deal with this to the fullest extent of the law. He said, 'Such horrific violence will not be tolerated in the United States of America.'"

Political Tensions and Misinformation

Some Republicans have attempted to link Governor Walz to Belter without substantive evidence:

Patrick Marley [19:55]: "This has taken a grip in some corners of the right-wing ecosphere, and that's filtered into some members of Congress."

Broader Context of Political Violence

Increasing Trends

The episode situates the Minnesota attacks within a troubling rise in political violence:

Patrick Marley [21:11]: "We've certainly seen a terrible spate of it in recent years. (...) many Democratic secretaries of state, some Republican secretaries of state, faced all kinds of death threats."

Public Acceptance of Violence

A notable shift in public sentiment towards political violence was highlighted:

Patrick Marley [22:17]: "By 2023, the number had jumped to 23%. So nearly a quarter of Americans were willing to accept that idea that political violence is acceptable in some situations."

Impact on Democracy

The increasing polarization has tangible effects on societal interactions:

Patrick Marley [23:31]: "I mean, you see it in your social media feeds, you see it on cable news. You see it in your daily interactions. Just this intensifying sense of politics that it's always existential."

Conclusion

The Post Reports episode underscores a distressing trend of politically motivated violence in the United States, exemplified by the Minnesota manhunt and shootings. Despite thorough investigations, a clear motive remains elusive, highlighting the complexities of addressing such acts within a highly polarized society. Public officials' responses reflect a bipartisan repudiation of violence, yet underlying tensions and misinformation continue to fuel divisions. This incident not only marks a tragic loss of life but also serves as a stark reminder of the fragile state of democracy and the urgent need for reconciliation and understanding in a divided nation.

---

Notable Quotes

• Patrick Marley [00:32]: "Again, he was dressed as a law enforcement officer wearing a tactical vest and body armor, carrying a handgun and a flashlight and wearing that same hyper realistic silicon mask."

• Patrick Marley [02:06]: "He shot both Melissa Hortman and Mark Hortman and they have died."

• Patrick Marley [07:54]: "I met Jesus when I was 17 years old and I gave my life to him."

• Patrick Marley [10:53]: "David Carlson said he's just absolutely baffled and stunned by this, that he never saw any violent tendencies in Bolter and does not know what might have motivated him."

• Patrick Marley [13:09]: "Police say it's clear that there was a political element to the motivations here..."

• Patrick Marley [22:17]: "Just 15% of people accepted that proposition in 2021, but by 2023, the number had jumped to 23%."

---

This summary provides a comprehensive yet concise overview of the podcast episode, capturing the essential elements and nuanced discussions surrounding the Minnesota manhunt and its broader implications on political violence in America.

Transcript

[Colby Ichowitz]

Today we are learning more about the man who allegedly shot two Minnesota lawmakers and their spouses over the weekend. One couple died, the other survived. The suspect, Vance Luther Belter, was arrested last night after a two day manhunt. In a press conference held by the FBI today, we learned more details about the alleged extent of his planning. Law enforcement officials said Belter had stalked his victims, posed as a police officer and tried to conceal his identity by covering his face.

[Patrick Marley]

Again, he was dressed as a law enforcement officer wearing a tactical vest and body armor, carrying a handgun and a flashlight and wearing that same hyper realistic silicon mask. Again, the images as you can see on the screen are haunting.

[Colby Ichowitz]

It seems like the targets were Democrats and supporters of abortion rights. A federal law enforcement official said, quote, these were targeted political assassinations. From the newsroom of the Washington Post, this is Post Reports. I'm Colby ekowitz. It's Monday, June 16th. Today, a conversation with reporter Patrick Marley. He joined us from Minnesota this morning where he's been covering this story since the attacks. Early on Saturday, he breaks down what we know about the shootings, the suspect and how this incident fits into a wider pattern of political violence in America. Also, just a heads up, Patrick and I learned later in the day that the suspect's name is pronounced Belter, not bolter. So apologies in advance for that mispronunciation. Patrick, hi, I know you've been out reporting this story all day and all night. Walk us through what we know about the attack on these Minnesota lawmakers. How did this all begin?

[Patrick Marley]

This all began at 2am on Saturday when a shooter went to the door of of State Senator John Hoffman and shot Hoffman and his wife Yvette. Police responded, the two were alive and taken to the hospital. He then went to the homes of two other state lawmakers and then went to the home of a fourth lawmaker, State Representative Melissa Hortman. He shot both Melissa Hortman and and Mark Hortman and they have died. Police arrived there as that was happening and witnessed him shooting Mark Hortman and the shooter retreated into the home. Police searched for him but he escaped. And that kicked off a 43 hour manhunt, the largest manhunt in Minnesota state history. At that house, police saw that the shooter had been driving a vehicle that looked very much like a police vehicle. The shooter they found had presented himself as a police officer at both residences. He was wearing a rubber mask, a face mask. At at least one of the homes. They found weapons in his car and they searched for him for the next Day and a half recovered vehicles along the way and found him in a rural area near his home, southwest of the Twin Cities. They were able to apprehend him. They had him crawl through the mud to them after they had, you know, surrounded him and located where he was. He's been arrested and charged with murder and attempted murder.

[Colby Ichowitz]

So, Patrick, obviously there's a lot to discuss here, especially the alleged shooter's motives. But first I really wanted to learn about the victims. Can you first tell me about Melissa Hortman? She was the former speaker of the state House. She was killed Saturday along with her husband, Mark.

[Patrick Marley]

Melissa Hortman was a central figure in Minnesota politics for a long time. She's a progressive, but a pragmatist. The Democrats in Minnesota controlled all of state government for a short period, and she was speaker during that time. They passed universal school lunches, so every kid in Minnesota got free lunch at school. That got a lot of national attention when Governor Tim Wall signed that. During her time leading state legislature, Melissa Hortman and other Democrats put a focus on securing abortion rights and codifying that into the state constitution. That was especially important for them after the Supreme Court ruling that overturned Roe v. Wade. They secured abortion rights, expanded family medical leave. And then in this session, they have split government. And the Republicans in the legislature wanted to roll back health insurance for undocumented immigrants. That's a policy that Hortman supported. But she voted for that to prevent a potential government shutdown. And, you know, her supporters say that really speaks to the type of person she was, that she was willing to make compromises even when she didn't really like the compromise to put the state's interests ahead and prevent a breakdown of the state government.

[Colby Ichowitz]

And then what about John Hoffman? He was the other state lawmaker targeted, and he was shot and survived his attack. Tell me a little bit about him.

[Patrick Marley]

State Senator John Hoffman had also been in state politics for a long time and was part of the majority when Democrats controlled all of state government that was able to advance these liberal causes that were so important to the party at the time.

[Colby Ichowitz]

And, Patrick, I know you've been doing a lot of reporting about the suspect, Vance Bolter. What have you learned about him and his life so far?

[Patrick Marley]

Vance Boulder is 57 years old. He's married, has five children. He lives in a rural part of Minnesota outside the Twin Cities called Green Isle. But he has a second home that he stays at in Minneapolis. He rents a room from a friend a couple nights a week so that he can stay there when he's working on call jobs in the Twin Cities and has an unusual history for work. He touts himself as having a security company, like a home security company that will patrol neighborhoods with armed guards. But his best friend says that that is a business that never really got off the ground and it was more an ambition than an actual company. And at the same time to pay the bills. He was working in funeral services. He was working for a couple of funeral homes in the Twin Cities and most recently, according to his friend, had an on call job in the Twin Cities to recover eyes from dead bodies for organ donation.

[David Carlson]

Oof.

[Colby Ichowitz]

And I had also read, Patrick, that he was, you know, maybe a born again Christian, right? And that he had spent time in Africa kind of trying to spread Christianity there. What do we know about kind of his religion?

[Patrick Marley]

His Christian faith was very important to him. He said in one of his sermons in Africa that he became a born again Christian at age 17. That he met Jesus is the phrase he used and soon afterward was filled with the Holy Spirit. I met Jesus when I was 17 years old and I gave my life to him. And about four months after that I met the Holy Spirit and was filled with the Holy Spirit and I just wanted to tell everybody about Jesus. He was so moved by this. He wrote his testimony, he printed it and turned it into pamphlets. He said he went door to door and shared it with people. He preached publicly. His close friend says that the friend had left for army basic training and when he returned had found this completely transformed individual, that he had dramatically and 100% changed his life and that, you know, 40 years later, his Christian faith remains very important to him.

[Colby Ichowitz]

Patrick, you've mentioned a few times this friend of the suspect, who is he and what other kinds of insights has he shared about Bolter?

[Patrick Marley]

Yeah, on Sunday I met with David Carlson, Bolter's roommate, and he has been talking over the weekend to law enforcement and to reporters. In one remarkable moment on Saturday, he read to the Star Tribune and some other reporters text message that he had received from Vance Bolter after these shootings.

[Unnamed Friend]

I love you guys. I made some choices and you guys don't know anything about this, but I'm going to be gone for a while.

[Colby Ichowitz]

Sorry.

[Patrick Marley]

Take your time.

[Unnamed Friend]

Maybe dad shortly. So I just want to let you know I love you guys both and I wish it had gone this way.

[Patrick Marley]

And then on Sunday, I and a small group of other reporters met with Carlson and learned a lot more about Vance Bolter and his time living with David Carlson, who described himself as Boulter's best friend and someone he'd known since fourth grade.

[Unnamed Friend]

Since I was 12, probably fourth grade, fourth grade, forever. We've been friends.

[David Carlson]

Yeah.

[Colby Ichowitz]

Patrick, did you ask him or did any reporters ask him about what the potential motivations for this attack might have been, what his politics were, why he might have, you know, been going after Democratic lawmakers?

[Patrick Marley]

David Carlson said he's just absolutely baffled and stunned by this, that he never saw any violent tendencies in Bolter and does not know what might have motivated him. He said he didn't talk about politics a lot.

[Unnamed Friend]

You know, sometimes politics would be on the tv, but he would never really was never really anything that was in depth conversation about, just comments, you know.

[Patrick Marley]

Another roommate said that Bolter was not a big conversationalist. He did complain about some national Democrats. He said that Bolter didn't like Nancy Pelosi, the former speaker and current congresswoman from California. He didn't like Tim Walz, the governor of Minnesota and who had been the vice presidential nominee. But he described these as sort of ordinary complaints that one might have. He said Bolter had voted for Trump and wasn't Trump's supporter. And, you know, there have been some things on social media trying to portray Bolter as a Democrat. And Carlson said that's ridiculous. He would be insulted if someone called him a Democrat.

[Colby Ichowitz]

And what did Carlson say, if anything, about his mental state?

[Patrick Marley]

He said that he didn't recognize him as having going through a mental health crisis, though at the same time, he said anybody who would do what he's alleged to have done must be in some kind of mental distress. He said he had seemed down in recent months. He had gone on a trip to Africa that he had hoped would bolster some of his business plans and that they didn't seem to be coming together and that he seemed a little down about that, but that he also said, you know, he was stable, he had his family, he had a job. So, you know, he was really trying to process what he saw as a very unexpected series of events.

[Unnamed Friend]

I don't understand it. I can't. But my feelings right now, I feel rage and upset with him.

[Colby Ichowitz]

And at this point, Patrick, have police found any evidence that would point to a possible motive?

[Patrick Marley]

So it doesn't look like he has much of a social media background that would, you know, give us insight into his thoughts or what might have motivated him? Police at the Hortman residence, when he escaped from them, they recovered his vehicle, which was styled to look like a law enforcement vehicle. And they found in their flyers for the no Kings protests, which raised concerns that he might target people at those events. These are the anti Trump protests that occurred over the weekend and they recovered this list of dozens of names of potential targets, dozens of Democratic lawmakers or Democratic officials or abortion rights supporters. And so the the police say it's clear that there was a political element to the motivations here, but we don't know more precisely what those were. Police say that this also included, like may have been a notebook, that it also included his thoughts on various issues. But they stress this is not, quote, a traditional manifesto, that you think of a manifesto as sort of a succinct documentation of one's thoughts or ideology, that he may have scribbled notes here and there about what he was thinking, but that it's not this cogent argument that he's put forward. So, you know, what we really want to know is what, what exactly was in that? We, we hope that that would give us some insight into what motivations were in play.

[Colby Ichowitz]

After the break, how this incident fits into a period of political violence in our country. We'll.

[Unnamed Advertiser]

These days, everything's getting more expensive. Groceries, gas, prescriptions. So when it comes to your meds, finding ways to save really helps. That's where Goodrx can come in. Goodrx lets you check prices for prescriptions, whether it's for allergies, heart health, diabetes or even pet meds. And sometimes you can save up to 80% before you even head to the pharmacy. It's easy to use. Just search your prescription on the website or app and show the free coupon to your pharmacist. You can use it at over 70,000 pharmacies, including CVS, Walgreens, Walmart and more. Allergy meds are expensive, so I look to Goodrx to save me money. And you should, too. Remember, Goodrx is not insurance, and you don't need insurance to use it. In some cases, the Goodrx price might even beat your copay, beat high prices at the pharmacy and save up to 80%. With GoodRx, go to goodrx.com reports. That's goodrx.com reports.

As the temps start rising, I feel that familiar urge to refresh my closet. But I'm not wasting money on pieces I'll only wear once or just for one season. Quince changes that their clothes are timeless, lightweight, and far more elevated than anything else. At this price, it finally feels like my wardrobe matches my standards. By working directly with top artisans and cutting out the middlemen, Quince gives you luxury without the markup. And Quince only works with factories that use safe, ethical and responsible manufacturing practices and premium fabrics and finishes. For me, a linen shirt is a wardrobe staple, especially for the humid D.C. summers. But quality linen at an affordable price is hard to find. The ones from Quince are made from 100% European flax linen, so so they're lightweight, breathable and get softer every time it's worn. Exactly what I want in a summer shirt. Give your summer closet an upgrade with quints. Go to quince.com reports for free shipping on your order and 365 day returns. That's Q-U-I-N-C-E.com reports to get free shipping and 365 day returns, quince.com reports.

[Colby Ichowitz]

Patrick, we talked before the break about how these attacks, how they were targeting Democrats and abortion rights supporters. There were even flyers for Saturday's anti Trump protests in the suspect's vehicle. How then have public officials and President Donald Trump himself responded to these attacks?

[Patrick Marley]

The attacks have been condemned by officials from both sides. As of Sunday, Donald Trump had not called Governor Tim Walls as far as we knew, and he had actually gone on to disparage the governor, calling him a terrible governor and grossly incompetent person wouldn't commit to whether he would call him. At the same time, Donald Trump took to his social media platform, Truth Social, to say that this would be investigated and charges would be issued that they would deal with this to the fullest extent of the law. He said, quote, such horrific violence will not be tolerated in the United States of America. But these attacks have been condemned by many Republicans at the national level and in Minnesota. And I think that the Democrats are focused more on the political dimension of this than the Republicans have been so far.

[Colby Ichowitz]

I am wondering if you could explain something. So I've seen on parts of the Internet, people are saying now that Bolter was a Democrat, that this was some kind of Democrat on Democrat violence. Where is that coming from?

[Patrick Marley]

Bolter was on a workforce development board that included dozens of people. It's a low profile, unpaid position. He was appointed to that board initially by a Democratic governor, Mark Dayton, and then he was reappointed to it by Tim Walls. And so some Republicans have seized on that as a sign that he is a Democrat. But his friend David Carlson said that that was not political position, that it had nothing to do with political views. People close to the governor say that he didn't know Bolter. It's a pretty routine appointment to a, you Know, board that doesn't get much attention.

[Colby Ichowitz]

And so people are trying to somehow tie Governor Walz to the suspect.

[Patrick Marley]

Yes. I mean, you know what things are like in the online environment that people can advance ideas and they can fester quickly and spread even though they don't have any basis.

[Colby Ichowitz]

And they've been elevated by some prominent people I've seen, like Senator Mike Lee from Utah was sharing some social media posts that seem to be making those connections.

[Patrick Marley]

Indeed. I mean, this has taken a grip in some corners of the right wing ecosphere, and that's filtered into some members of Congress.

[Colby Ichowitz]

I mean, political violence in this country, it's not new. We've had attacks against politicians for decades. But in the past year, I feel like we've seen a lot of politically motivated violent behavior. Like the attack on Democratic Gov. Josh Shapiro's home in Pennsylvania. I actually spoke with the governor last week about that attack. Then there were the dual assassination attempts of President Trump. How is political violence? Does it feel like political violence has increased or changed over time in this country or in recent months or years?

[Patrick Marley]

I mean, we've certainly seen a terrible spate of it in recent years. Like you mentioned, the two assassination attempts on Donald Trump. We saw a lot of this after the 2020 election and the false claims that the election had been stolen. You know, many Democratic secretaries of state, some Republican secretaries of state, faced all kinds of death threats and, you know, ordinary frontline election workers had to sometimes vacate their homes because of death threats. And you've seen that filter through the political system where I think state lawmakers and other politicians are on edge in a way that ordinarily would not be the case.

[Colby Ichowitz]

I mean, and then there was also, Patrick, of course, January 6th, which was a massive, politically violent moment in this country where people were coming to the US Capitol rioting, saying that they wanted to hang the vice President of the United States.

[Patrick Marley]

A perfect example. We've seen a change over time in Americans willingness to accept political violence as a viable solution. You know, there was a poll by the Public Religion Research Institute and Brookings Institution in which people were asked if, quote, true American patriots may have to resort to violence in order to save our country. Just 15% of people accepted that proposition in 2021, but by 2023, the number had jumped to 23%. So nearly a quarter of Americans were willing to accept that idea that political violence is acceptable in some situations.

[Colby Ichowitz]

I mean, Patrick, your day job is as a democracy reporter. You've been covering issues around our democracy for many years now. So you've been steeped in this idea about the state of division and polarization in the country. Where does this moment, what you've been reporting on this weekend in Minnesota, how does that fit into the kind of larger picture of our democracy?

[Patrick Marley]

I mean, I hate to say it, but you hear about situations like this, and there's a combined sense of utter shock and a sense of inevitability. I mean, people see it every day just how incredibly divided they were. I talked to a brother and sister who were near the site of one of the shootings. They were in town on the day of the shooting for their niece's graduation. And they said, you know, they had a loving family, that everyone got along, but that they just avoided politics when they got together because people had become so tense. So I think we see, you know, you see it in your social media feeds, you see it on cable news. You see it in your daily interactions. Just this intensifying sense of politics that it's always existential. It's always, you know, take it to the extremes and no faith or confidence that someone with differing views might have pure motivations. And it's bursting out in terrible ways and too often in violent ways.

[Colby Ichowitz]

Patrick, thank you for taking the time while you are reporting on the ground there in Minnesota, and we'll continue to be following your reporting.

[Patrick Marley]

Thank you, Colby, for having me on the show.

[Colby Ichowitz]

Patrick Marley is a national reporter for the Post. He's based in the upper Midwest. That's it for Post reports. Thanks for listening. If you're looking for the latest updates on the big news of the day, check out our morning news briefing. The Seven. We bring you the seven stories you need to know about every Weekday morning by 7am you can listen to it wherever you listen to podcasts. Today's show was produced by Rennie Stranovsky with help from Laura Benchoff. It was edited by Ariel Plotnick and Maggie Penman. It was mixed by Shawn Carter. Thanks to Gina Harkins. I'm Colby Ichowitz. We'll be back tomorrow with more stories from the Washington Post.

[David Carlson]

Think about why you listen to podcasts. It's like having a friend who makes you think or can help you wind down right. Well, the Washington Post has a lot of people you can turn to at any hour. You can read the most important and interesting stories. We can help you cook something delicious, give you advice on a tricky friendship. Rave about a movie or book that you shouldn't miss. When you become a Washington Post subscriber, you have a companion for whatever part of your day needs it most. Get it all for just $4 every four weeks. That's for an entire year. After that, it's just $12 every four weeks. Cancel anytime. Go to washingtonpost.com subscribe. That's washingtonpost.com subscrib.