The Forever Culture Wars

Summary

---

Reconstruction: The Unfinished Promise

Episode: The Forever Culture Wars

Date: July 16, 2026
Host: Malcolm Gladwell (Higher Ground Audio)

---

Overview

This episode explores how American popular culture has shaped, distorted, and suppressed the legacy of Reconstruction, fueling "forever culture wars" around history, memory, and race. Host Malcolm Gladwell examines how media—from early films like The Birth of a Nation to Disney’s Song of the South and cartoons—has promoted racist myths and perpetuated Confederate nostalgia, while also spotlighting the counter-narratives Black creators have brought forth. Through conversations with comedians, scholars, and President Barack Obama, the episode investigates why it's so hard for America to let go of these images, the cultural amnesia surrounding Reconstruction, and the ongoing backlash that prevents a true reckoning with its unfinished promise.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. The Power of Media in Shaping Historical Memory

• The Birth of a Nation (1915): This landmark film, praised by then-President Woodrow Wilson as "history written with lightning" (01:18), massively influenced public perceptions of Reconstruction by portraying Black lawmakers as buffoons and glorifying the Ku Klux Klan.
  • Quote: “Most of the black characters in the Birth of a Nation were performed by white people in blackface makeup and wigs, and they acted outrageously...ridiculous, historically inaccurate, and very effective.” – Malcolm Gladwell (01:55)
• The film sparked protests (notably by the NAACP) but also revived the KKK, becoming a cultural template for white supremacist mythmaking.

2. Pop Culture as a Battleground for Race Narratives

• Recurring Themes: Every new entertainment medium—from radio (Amos and Andy) to Technicolor films (Gone with the Wind)—has perpetuated blackface and Southern nostalgia.
  • Quote: “For a long time, every new medium in American popular culture got a boost from Confederate nostalgia channeled as blackface.” – Malcolm Gladwell (03:10)
• Counter-Narratives: Black creators like Oscar Micheaux responded with films like Within Our Gates (1920), directly challenging white supremacist stories by highlighting Black agency and violence against African Americans.

3. Enduring Stereotypes: From Song of the South to Mammy Two Shoes

• Song of the South (1946): Disney’s adaptation presents a nostalgic, naturalized view of the plantation, minimizing the desire for legal rights and equality.
  • Quote: “So that’s the danger of the Song of the South...it shows this sense of not just nostalgia, but it’s very naturalistic...so black people are innately tied to land, to nature, to the plantation.” – Manisha Sinha (16:30)
• Mammy Two Shoes in Tom and Jerry: The "mammy" trope persisted in cartoons long after its era, repeatedly redubbed and reanimated, yet consistently failing to address its racist origins.
  • Quote: “Mammy Two Shoes was voiced by Lillian Randolph...she’s not Mammy Two Shoes anymore. She’s Ms. Two Shoes...before you assumed she was the housekeeper for a white family. Now she’s a single lady in a Tyler Perry film...” – Wyatt Cenac (23:31)

4. The Absence—and Importance—of Reconstruction in Cultural Memory

• Cultural Erasure: While minstrel shows and nostalgic films took up much cultural oxygen, Reconstruction itself is rarely remembered or referenced.
  • Quote: “Reconstruction wasn’t a failure. It was more radical than the birth of the United States...but it doesn’t mean that it wasn’t a glorious moment of American history.” – Manisha Sinha (25:55)
• The lack of visible narratives around Reconstruction impedes Americans’ ability to imagine more equitable futures.

5. Reckoning—Or Not—with Racial History

• Contemporary Backlash: Recent efforts to erase or sugarcoat uncomfortable history (e.g., removing the word ‘slavery’ or images of violence) reflect enduring resistance to reckoning with white privilege and Black struggle.
  • Quote: "We're in a moment where feeling bad about yourself or feeling bad about American history is on scale. Like, I want to get rid of the word slavery...because if this thing happened in the past, then what does it mean about my privilege in the present?" – Manisha Sinha (20:51)
• Changing IP (intellectual property) around racist media (like Song of the South and Splash Mountain) often means cosmetic rebranding, not true accountability.

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

| Timestamp | Speaker | Quote/Description | |-----------|---------|------------------| | 01:18 | Malcolm Gladwell | "President Wilson…loved the Birth of a Nation. He described it as writing history with lightning and called it terribly true." | | 03:51 | Wyatt Cenac | “If you’ve never seen [The Birth of a Nation], good for you. It’s over three hours long. It’s kind of like a Marvel movie of racism.” (Audience laughter) | | 14:30 | Lillian Randolph (Uncle Remus) | "[Imitating Uncle Remus] Why, you said there was a tale about Burr Rabbit not coming back to his briar patch." (Sample of Song of the South’s speech) | | 20:02 | Wyatt Cenac | “There is a strange symbolism that a ride whose origins were rooted in a movie romantically fantasizing about the days of slavery and white supremacy now must be reimagined by the first black Disney princess.” (referring to Splash Mountain/Tiana's Bayou Adventure) | | 25:49 | Salamishah Tillet | “I mean, the IP of slavery is so strong in this country that we keep finding new ways to reboot it.” | | 33:22 | Barack Obama | “What you see in the backlash to Reconstruction is the degree to which you never changed hearts and minds coming out of the Civil War. There wasn’t the sort of...restructuring of the understanding that Southern whites had about what their privileges and rights were and how their society should be organized.” | | 36:00 | Barack Obama | “The progress that we’ve seen over your lifetime and mine in creating a multiracial democracy, that stuff sticks...We have evidence of that better version of America. We have evidence of it. We’ve seen it.” |

---

Important Segments & Timestamps

• 00:03 – 03:10: Malcolm Gladwell introduces Jim Crow laws, The Birth of a Nation, and its legacy.
• 03:31 – 05:14: Wyatt Cenac’s comedic critique of The Birth of a Nation and introduction to the conversation with Salamishah Tillet.
• 05:14 – 10:34: Salamishah Tillet, Manisha Sinha, and Kai Wright discuss how pop culture and film shape perceptions of Reconstruction.
• 14:01 – 20:42: Discussion of Song of the South, the “Uncle Remus” character, and Disney’s complicated legacy.
• 20:42 – 26:22: Exploration of “Mammy” stereotypes, Tom and Jerry, and the broader erasure of Reconstruction from American memory.
• 32:08 – 37:32: Epilogue/coda: Gladwell and Barack Obama reflect on the persistence of Reconstruction’s legacy and the necessity of hope and endurance in the struggle for multiracial democracy.

---

Episode Tone & Language

• Reflective, critical, and at times sharply satirical (especially Wyatt Cenac's segments).
• Candid, with both scholarly gravitas and humor.
• Consistent effort to center Black voices and perspectives, and to honor the complexities of historical memory.

---

Conclusion

In "The Forever Culture Wars," Malcolm Gladwell and his guests reveal how the popular culture of each generation has fought to define Reconstruction and the broader story of American belonging. Through racist portrayals rooted in the Lost Cause mythology and the nostalgia for a white-supremacist past, media has both reinforced false narratives and incited violence, complicating national memory. Yet, the episode also celebrates those who fought to create counter-narratives and insists that real progress, while embattled, should not be forgotten. President Obama’s closing words urge listeners to resist despair, recognizing that the embers of Reconstruction’s promise continue to burn, pushing America onward in its journey toward a truly multiracial democracy.

---

Transcript

[Malcolm Gladwell]

As America entered the 20th century, Jim Crow laws took hold across the South. They mandated segregated schools, segregated workplaces, restaurants and hotels. Voting and holding public office became difficult, if not impossible, for black citizens in many Southern states. We heard in the previous chapter how historians during this era cast the accomplishments of Reconstruction as. As a big mistake. They argued that black people were not and had not been able to handle the responsibility of holding public office or building new schools. But historians weren't the only ones making this argument. In the early 1900s, new forms of media also denigrated the accomplishments of Reconstruction, especially a film called the Birth of a Nation, based on the novel the Klansmen. At a time when most films were only a few minutes long, the Birth of a Nation clocked in at more than three hours. It was a blockbuster. In March 1915, President Woodrow Wilson assembled family and friends in the east wing of the White House to watch the Birth of a Nation. The title placards assured viewers that they would be seeing, quote, historical facsimiles. Most of the black characters in the Birth of a Nation were performed by white people in blackface makeup and wigs, and they acted outrageously. One of the movie's most notorious scenes claimed to show what Reconstruction did to the South Carolina legislature in 1871. Picture a state house filled with black lawmakers acting like buffoons. They put their bare feet on desks, wave around turkey drumsticks, and make eyes at white women in the galleries. The whole scene, much like the rest of the movie, somehow manages to be ridiculous, historically inaccurate, and very effective. Effective because President Wilson, a Democrat from Virginia and also the former governor of New Jersey, loved the Birth of a Nation. He described it as writing history with lightning and called it terribly true. Members of the NAACP picketed the film, at one point drawing a rally of thousands in Boston. But to little avail. The film became a de facto recruitment tool for a newly revived Ku Klux Klan. I'm Malcolm Gladwell, and this is Reconstruction, the Unfinished Promise. The fact is, for a long time, every new medium in American popular culture got a boost from Confederate nostalgia channeled as blackface. In the early 1930s, Amos and Andy became radio's most popular show, with two white men playing black characters. And then there was Gone with the Wind, the early Technicolor film drenched with nostalgic depictions of the antebellum South. So television, movies and other forms of entertainment have been used to promote blackface. But entertainers can also respond in kind, like the comedian Wyatt Cenac.

[Wyatt Cenac]

So this is gonna be like a late Night television show for your ears. You remember television. It was like a giant iPhone that respected your privacy.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

A while back, he took to a stage in Brooklyn for a live taping of a show he's been developing. It's called Everything Is Racist with Wyatt Sinek.

[Wyatt Cenac]

D.W. griffith's film the Birth of a Nation is a movie that most film scholars and critics agree is horribly racist. If you've never seen it, good for you. It's over three hours long. It's kind of like a Marvel movie of racism. The world is under attack, but instead of aliens, it's black men who attempt to conquer the state of South Carolina and its white women. Like the Avengers movies. It's gonna take a bunch of white guys and one lady forming a team to save the day. They even give their squad of white supremacist superheroes a name, the Ku Klux Klan. It is a terrible movie. They blew most of the special effects budget on blackface. And the big battle scene at the end is just the KKK intimidating black people not to vote. It's as if Thanos used that glove of his and just snapped it for voter suppression. The film, it actually led to a revival of the KKK because just like a comic book movie afterwards, people want a cosplay.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

Like a lot of good performers, Wyatt does his research. And one of the people he talked with was the Pulitzer Prize winning writer and critic, Salamisha Tillet. The conversation was so fascinating and funny and informative. I wanted you to hear it as well.

[Salamishah Tillet]

When we think about pop culture as a concept, it's often regarded in an unserious way. And I'm curious, in your work, how much does the popular culture of a particular time overlap with we see politics and history?

[Manisha Sinha]

I definitely think the period after Reconstruction is the period in which you see a real clamping down on, not just the political and legal gains that come about at the end of the Civil War, but you see, it's a real cultural battlefield. And I think for the south, you know that expression that the north won the war, but the south won the peace. What that means is like, clearly with the rise of Jim Crow, that is a kind of legal way in which the south wins the peace, Right? But then you have all these other ways in which this idea of Southern rule, Southern reign, almost a Southern victory, emerges in the wake of loss. So through monuments, through minstrelsy, and then the emergence of movies. There's so many problems with Birth of a Nation, but it's a film that, like, traffics in multiple Stereotypes. So one, you know, the myth of, like, the black male rapist and that character Gus, who, like, is chasing this white woman and she literally just jumps over the cliff. And then the Klan. I mean, the Klan's like, the savior in the films.

[Salamishah Tillet]

Yeah. So I saw it in college.

[Manisha Sinha]

Okay. I saw it in high school.

[Kai Wright]

Oh, wow.

[Salamishah Tillet]

Okay.

[Manisha Sinha]

No.

[Salamishah Tillet]

All right.

[Kai Wright]

Wow.

[Salamishah Tillet]

All right, you win then.

[Manisha Sinha]

All right, well, how did you see it in college?

[Salamishah Tillet]

So I took film studies classes in college.

[Manisha Sinha]

That makes sense.

[Salamishah Tillet]

And then. Yeah, it was shown as. This is an amazing movie.

[Manisha Sinha]

Yeah.

[Salamishah Tillet]

Yeah. I'm curious. You saw it in high school. What was your.

[Manisha Sinha]

So we would. We had this, like, every week, or maybe, let me say, once a month, they would show, like, classic films, and we'd be in the big auditorium. So we saw, like, I guess not the full length version of Birth of a Nation, but we saw a portion of it, and it was horrifying because, like, these things were not given context. None of them were given context or, like, big debriefings. And I'm also one of four black kids in my class, so it was just so traumatizing to watch Birth of a Nation in 1992, the year that, you know, LAPD officers are found out guilty for beating Rodney King. So it's a. It's a really hot, hot year.

[Salamishah Tillet]

Yeah, well, and this came out in 1915. And I'm curious if you could talk a little bit about what the reception was like at the time.

[Manisha Sinha]

Yeah. I mean, it's a film that's based on Thomas Dixon's the Klansman. I mean, it was a hit. There was no other way of describing it. This is where, like, the idea of pop culture being important is because something can be so seductive as a kind of sensory, aesthetic experience, then what's put into that is important. And so in this case, you have this, like, provocative thing that emerges. American film, and it's also on the backs of black people.

[Kai Wright]

Well.

[Salamishah Tillet]

And it still gets celebrated to this day.

[Manisha Sinha]

You know, I mean, it's this idea. This is. It's a peculiarly American thing that slavery and democracy are simultaneously twinned to each other in our founding of a country. And so it doesn't mean that we can't have technological innovation and also be racist. It's not like they're two independent things. And so I think that's why, you know, someone's like, Birth of a Nation's a great film. Oh, yeah. And it happened to be racist versus, like, Birth of a Nation is a great film, and part of its greatness was it's like white supremacist, like, logic. You know what I mean? Like, you could say that.

[Salamishah Tillet]

Yeah.

[Manisha Sinha]

You know, and, like. And that's terrible. But also, you can also understand that it did do important work cinematically, but that black people being subjugated was part of that cinematic evolution.

[Salamishah Tillet]

Right.

[Manisha Sinha]

So I always think it's, like, important to understand that, like, even as popular as these representations are, that as artists and as creatives, that people are always trying to come up with counter narratives and tell different stories of black life, even if the repression feels as strong as it does with, like, the popularity of something like Birth of a Nation, like, I guess we think of as, like, the big grandfather of American, African American film. Oscar Michaud, Sure. He has within our Gates his first kind of big film in 1920. And he's responding to Birth of a Nation. And the way he responds is showing how violent the Klan and how violent white supremacy is and how white northerners should actually be open to black people being equals to them. And the south is the aberration, as opposed to black citizenship being the aberration. So there's all this, like, battle going on and an agency that black people are showing, despite the fact that these myths and stereotypes are so powerful and potent.

[Sponsor/Ad Voice]

One thing I've been very fortunate to do in my life is travel, political events, music festivals, and, of course, big sporting events. It really never gets less exciting. Kelly and I love going to live concerts, but the hardest part is always finding a place that actually feels like home in the middle of all that energy. And that's why listing your space on airbnb makes so much sense, especially when something big is happening in your area. You've got people coming in who don't just want a place to crash. They want to feel like they're a part of the neighborhood, even if it's just for a few days. If you've got an extra room or even your whole place available while you're away, it can really be an easy way to earn some extra income. And Airbnb gives you tools to make it simple to list your space. I always think about it like this. When I travel, the places I remember most are the ones that felt personal. Your home might be worth more than you think. Find out how [e-mail] host Summer's my favorite. Everything just feels a little more relaxed. The days, the pace, the way people carry themselves. And I take the same approach to how I dress. I'm reaching for pieces that feel easy, look good, and don't require a whole decision. That's why I keep going back to Quint's. They focus on well made essentials. Breathable linen, soft organic cotton, the good stuff that just become the pieces you reach for all season. Their tees are beyond soft. The lightweight cotton sweaters are perfect when the sun goes down and their breathable European linen pants and shirts started just $34. I picked up a 100% organic cotton mesh stitch sweater Polo in beige and it's basically become my uniform. Goes with everything, feels like a T shirt but actually looks like I put in some effort. Everything at Quint's is priced 50 to 80% less than similar brands because they work directly with ethical factories and cut out the middlemen you're paying for quality, not the brand markup. And it's not just the clothes. Quince has you covered for home travel, everyday stuff too. It's become one of those go to spots I just trust make your summer wardrobe easier. Go to quints.com reconstruction for free shipping on your order and 365 day returns. Now available in Canada too. That's Q-U-I-N-C-E.com reconstruction for free shipping and 365 day returns. Quince.com reconstruction

[David Remnick]

we are in uncharted territory

[Evan Osnos]

Staff writer Evan Osnos on the New Yorker Radio Hour.

[David Remnick]

I think all of us right now are trying to make sense of an avalanche of news every day, and there aren't very many places where you can go and understand how something looks in the grand scope of history and context. That's what I come to the New Yorker for.

[Evan Osnos]

I'm David Remnick, and each week my colleagues and I try to make sense of what's happening in this chaotic world, and I hope you'll join us for the New Yorker Radio Hour.

[Kai Wright]

While Oscar Micheaux may have used his films of the 20s to respond to Birth of a Nation, this disagreement continues on movie screens every generation. Hollywood seems to accidentally on purpose make a film that wonders aloud if ending slavery was a big mistake. Take Disney's Song of the South. For those who've never seen it, the movie's from 1946. It's set during Reconstruction and is basically about a white boy who gets a babysitter named Uncle Remus.

[Lillian Randolph]

Why? You said there was a tale about Burr Rabbit not coming back to his briar patch.

[Voice Actor (Uncle Remus)]

Oh, bless my soul child, I sure did. And if I don't tell you about him, you won't pester me till I does.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Now, to be clear Uncle Remus is a former slave, and in the movie,

[Kai Wright]

this is how he remembers that time.

[Voice Actor (Uncle Remus)]

Twas a long time ago. And in them days, everything was mighty satisfaction. The criminals, they was called closer to the folks. And the folks, they was closer to the critters. And if you'll excuse me for saying so, twas better. All right. Yes, sir, honey.

[Wyatt Cenac]

The folks, they was closer to the critters, which. Closer to the critters. Technically, during slavery, he would have been 2/5 critter and 3/5 folks, but not really the point. Not surprisingly, that movie is not on Disney. For all the shame that exists today, though, that movie won Disney an Oscar for Best Original Song with Zippity Doo Dah James Basket. He actually got an honorary Oscar for playing Uncle Remus. He was the first black man to win an Oscar. And I will say, watching the movie today, it's hard not to see Uncle Remus as a guy with severe ptsd.

[Voice Actor (Uncle Remus)]

Now, that's the kind of day when you can't open your mouth without a song jump right out of it.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Whenever he's reminded of the horrors of slavery, he just disassociates into a magical animated world with cartoon bluebirds.

[Manisha Sinha]

Song of south is such a, for lack of better word, a hit for a very long period of time. And it does show this sense of not just nostalgia, but it's very naturalistic. Like, you have, like, the birds coming and so that. So black people are, like, innately tied to land, to nature, to the plantation, and that what's being passed on over the generations and over time is this myth that black people don't want legal rights, they don't wanna be treated equally, that they wanna have this kind of paternalistic relationship with white people and they wanna be back in slavery.

[Salamishah Tillet]

Right? Yeah.

[Manisha Sinha]

Yeah. Through a kid's kind of story.

[Salamishah Tillet]

Yeah.

[Manisha Sinha]

So that's the danger of the Song of the South. It's also like, you know, if we think about, again, the south winning the peace through monuments, minstrelsy and through movies, blackface. Minstrelsy in the mid 19th century with white actors corking their faces and playing blackface. That was one version of showing how black people were inferior and making fun of the way that they speak. And so then when he gets to Song of the south, what Uncle Remus is, in many ways is it's not minstrelsy proper. Right. People aren't painting their faces. But the way in which the richness and the versatility of black Southern speech is still being made fun of. Right. Is another form of Minstrelsy, or maybe the afterlife of minstrelsy in American film. And so it's, you know, all these. The ways in which a film could be both valorized, like Academy Award winning, but also so dangerous in how we're understanding the south, black people's lives in the south, black people's freedom in the present.

[Wyatt Cenac]

While Disney has worked very hard to keep people from seeing the movie, it hasn't stopped them from trying to have their racist cake and profit off it, too. Zippity doo dah has long been a staple in ads for Disneyland and in shows. Here's a remix that the company actually produced. Don't nod your head to it.

[Sponsor/Ad Voice]

Got a nice beat.

[Wyatt Cenac]

It doesn't. And it's also. It's weird to think that the song is sampling a recently freed slave and he's probably still not getting paid. The Disney ride, Splash mountain, opened in 1989, and it was inspired by the movie Song of the South. And it removed or reshaped most of the references to slavery. Like, there was no animatronic Uncle Remus, thank goodness. But the characters of Brer Rabbit and Brer Fox and Brer Bear were there. And those characters were derived from African folklore that enslaved people used to communicate with one another. But when you see them in an amusement park, they become cartoon characters to be monetized and exploited. In 2020, Disney finally decided they'd shut down Splash Mountain. The ride, but they didn't demolish it. It's been rebranded as Tiana's Bayou Adventure. Yeah.

[Voice Actor (Uncle Remus)]

Yeah.

[Wyatt Cenac]

That is. Yeah. The ride is essentially the same, but because there are no mountains in New Orleans, they had to get creative in trying to make the structure of the mountain fit the story of the Princess and the Frog. And so, like, you all have been in New Orleans, it's a flat city. So they turned Splash Mountain into a salt dome.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

Yeah.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Cause you know when you think of New Orleans, you think of the salt domes. I will say there is a strange symbolism that a ride whose origins were rooted in a movie romantically fantasizing about the days of slavery and white supremacy now must be reimagined by the first black Disney princess. Like Tiana couldn't have gotten something new. She just had to sage the shit out of that place and hope for the best. Like so many black people in this fixer upper of a country,

[Salamishah Tillet]

I'm curious why it feels so hard to let these things go or even just to properly reckon with them.

[Manisha Sinha]

Yeah, well, I think we're in a moment in which that idea that it makes people feel bad about themselves. I mean, it's like a weird thing because it's. We're like, in a moment where, like, feeling bad about yourself or feeling bad about American history is on scale, right? Like, it's like, I want to get rid of the word slavery, or I want to get rid of these images of a African American man who's whipped because I don't want to feel bad that this thing happened in the past. Because if this thing happened in the past, then what does it mean about my privilege in the present?

[Kai Wright]

And while that's a question that gets wrestled with in the present, it's also one that others have wrestled with before. In the attempt to protect our comfort, history gets packaged and repackaged in ways that can make the racist imagery even more pronounced. When I was a child, I spent a lot of time watching cartoons like Tom and Jerry, which, like Song of the south, debuted in the 1940s. Tom the House cat and Jerry the mouse were the main characters, but every now and again, they'd be joined by a woman whose presence felt problematic to me. Even as a kid, all you saw were her slippered feet and occasionally her hands, but you heard her voice.

[Lillian Randolph]

What's going on in here? Why, you overstuffed Pekingese hound, you.

[Wyatt Cenac]

She eventually became known as Mammy Two Shoes because she sounded like a mammy and all you saw were her two shoes. Mammy Two Shoes was voiced by Lillian Randolph, an actor who's best known for playing a housekeeper named Annie in the holiday classic It's a Wonderful Life. Here she is in 1976, discussing Tom and Jerry with Chuck Schaden on a Chicago radio show.

[Lillian Randolph]

You know Tom and Jerry?

[Barack Obama]

Yes.

[Lillian Randolph]

It was my voice.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

That was you. Your legs made the.

[Lillian Randolph]

My legs and big feet. Oh, listen, the funniest thing, I saw that cartoon in Japan you did with a Japanese woman doing. I laughed, I'm telling you.

[Wyatt Cenac]

And it wasn't just Japan. The character was also redubbed in the US in the 1960s when the cartoons began making their way to television, because I guess some people thought, hey, that might be offensive. So they not only re dubbed the character,

[Lillian Randolph]

what's going on here?

[Wyatt Cenac]

In some instances, they reanimated the character entirely. And then in the 90s, she became black again. But they hired the comedian Thea Vidal to redub her voice to make her sound less offensive.

[Manisha Sinha]

My goodness, what's going on in here? Why, you overstuck Pekingese dog, you.

[Wyatt Cenac]

She's not Mammy Two shoes anymore. She's Ms. Two Shoes before, you assumed she was the housekeeper for a white family. Now she's a single lady in a Tyler Perry film who just got home from the law firm and was looking forward to a nice glass of Pinot while she catches up on Love Island.

[Kai Wright]

I have memories of seeing and hearing the multiple versions of Mammy Two Shoes on my television. It was always a little jarring because I was never sure which version of

[Wyatt Cenac]

the character I might get.

[Kai Wright]

It felt like content being quickly and sloppily repackaged rather than some way to address why the animators at the time thought it was amusing to depict a domestic worker as a mammy. Was it because that's how they truly saw domestic workers in a moment when many of those black women were taking the picket lines to fight for fair wages?

[Manisha Sinha]

The 40s is such a really important political moment because it's the beginning of the modern civil rights movement.

[Salamishah Tillet]

Yeah.

[Manisha Sinha]

So that's why these images are, like, so strange, because even as they're popular, they're, like, retrograde at the same time. You know what I mean? Like they're holding on to something that no longer exists. But the images are necessary to prevent the cultural and political gains that people are demanding for at that time.

[Salamishah Tillet]

Right. Thinking about Disney and sort of their connection to all this, obviously they made Song of the south and then at some point realized oops and hid it in their vaults.

[David Remnick]

Yeah.

[Salamishah Tillet]

But it very much kept making money because of things like the Splash Mountain ride and the song Zippity Doo Dah. And it allows people to create new memories and false narratives around the ride and the song without actually engaging in the origins of it.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Yeah.

[Manisha Sinha]

They're building on a kind of archive or history of previous popularity and they're just kind of, you know. What do we call it today? It's like, the IP is so strong.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Sure.

[Salamishah Tillet]

Yes.

[Manisha Sinha]

The IP is so strong for those minstrel folktales, so that they.

[Salamishah Tillet]

I mean, the IP of slavery is so strong in this country that we keep finding new ways to reboot it.

[Lillian Randolph]

Yeah.

[Manisha Sinha]

But then I guess I wanna talk about the absence of Reconstruction in cultural narratives and what that has probably done to our imagination. Reconstruction wasn't a failure. It was more radical than the birth of the United States. And so we can think about it as something that was unfully realized, but it doesn't mean that it wasn't a glorious moment of American history.

[Kai Wright]

And it becomes easy to miss seeing what could have been when it's obscured by the imagery of folks like Mammy Two Shoes, Uncle Remus and and a bunch of white dudes in grease paint storming the Capitol.

[Manisha Sinha]

I'm thinking in particular, like when Ta Nehisi Coates collection of essays, We Were Eight Years in Power came out. Do you remember that? Yeah, I immediately thought he was referring to the Obama years, but in fact he was referencing or quoting black elected officials at the end of Reconstruction. And so even in that like moment in which I'm thinking we're bemoaning the end of a particular era, it just shows like how little or how few references we have in our everyday vernacular about Reconstruction. Because of the way in which these minstrel shows or these movies take up so much oxygen, so much air, we lose this really beautiful and potentially compelling moment of equality in this country. And if you can't remember something, how do you imagine it, right? How do you make it even better?

[Malcolm Gladwell]

What Wyatt Sinek spoke of on stage ending conversation with Salamisha Tillet very much calls to mind what Jelani Cobb talked about in our previous chapter, that history is argument without end. The Birth of a Nation still has legions of fans, and the arguments about it will probably keep going long after you and I are gone.

[Wyatt Cenac]

Yeah, I don't know what's going to happen next, but I appreciate you all going on this little ride with us. All right, thanks everybody. Have a good night.

[Sponsor/Ad Voice]

Whether you're exploring your current fascinations or discovering new ones, Audible has all the stories that'll introduce you to your most fascinating self. Tap into a whole new world of heated conversations with a saucy romantasy series, become your friend group's sci fi expert on the latest blockbuster book to screen adaptation, or find unexpected reveals through the exclusive episodes of a viral true crime podcast. However you choose to listen, Audible keeps you fascinated so you can be just as fascinating. Audible all in one easy app with plans now starting at $8.99, you'll get access to over 1 million audiobooks and podcasts, including trending bestsellers, the hottest new releases and exclusive podcasts you won't find anywhere else. Sign up now to become a member and get any audiobook every month, plus exclusive podcasts. Plans now start at $8.99. Audible be fascinated, Be fascinating.

A lot of history doesn't reach us through textbook. It reaches us through movies, songs, cartoons, things we absorbed while we thought we were just being entertained, and the versions of events that gets embedded in culture is often the one that was easiest to sell, not the most complete. The same thing happens with the news. Depending on where you read it, you might get two completely different accounts of the same event and most of us never see both versions side by side. I experience this daily with types of media I consume. My algorithm is tailored to my own perspective and oftentimes my worldview is reinforced rather than challenged. That's exactly what Ground News was built for. It takes a single story shows you how outlets across the entire spectrum are covering it so you can see past the spin and get to what actually happened. They also have a blind spot feed that surfaces the story one side of the media is barely touching. So go to groundnews.com RC that's G R O U n D n e w s.com RC for 40% off unlimited access Vantage plan Subscribe yourself or send it as a gift to someone who's tired of being spun. Use my link groundnews.com RC so you get the discount and so they know I sent you. Managing my finances used to take up real time. Like sit down with a coffee, open four different apps, trying to figure out where I stand kind of time. And I did it because I felt like I had to. But I dreaded it. That's not a system, that's just stress with extra steps. Rocket Money basically eliminated that for me. Everything's in one dashboard, checking, savings loans, investments with no manual logging or cross referencing accounts. I just open it and I know where I stand. And while it's doing that, it's also tracking every subscription coming out of your accounts. Anything you don't want, you can cancel right in the app. A few taps done. They've helped users cancel over $880 million in subscriptions. A lot of that is just stuff people signed up for and forgot about. What used to take me an hour now takes minutes. Rocket Money is a personal finance app that helps find and cancel unwanted subscriptions, monitors your spending, and helps lower your bills so you can grow your savings. Let Rocket Money help you reach your financial goals faster. [e-mail] Reconstruction that's RocketMoney.com Reconstruction RocketMoney.com Reconstruction

[Malcolm Gladwell]

and now for a little epilogue. Actually, epilogue is not the right word because I hope it's clear by now that the story of reconstruction never really ended. So let's call this coda. I mentioned at the beginning that I find it all too easy to despair about how the hard won efforts of reconstruction hit such a wall. We've heard about the violent backlash, the misrepresentation and insults, the Jim Crow aftermath that ruined lives for generations. But President Barack Obama also reminded me, convinced me that the World we live in now owes everything to this era that it left embers which still burn today.

[Barack Obama]

There's no question that you and I sitting here, yes, having a conversation about Reconstruction would not have been happening in

[Malcolm Gladwell]

1880, but reconstruction is. It's not a tentative step. It is one step forward and then one.

[Barack Obama]

Like a really big step back, a

[Malcolm Gladwell]

really several steps back, a couple of steps back. The intensity of that is what's so. And it's the amount of violence, and it's almost a second Civil War.

[Barack Obama]

Well, it is. What you see in the backlash to Reconstruction is the degree to which you never changed hearts and minds coming out of the Civil War. There wasn't the sort of not just defeat militarily, but also a restructuring of the understanding that Southern whites had about what their privileges and rights were and how their society should be organized. And so they effectively retreated for a while, and then they waited out the federal government and waited until the occupation ended, essentially, and then they reconstituted a version of their society that they preferred. And this is where the role of history comes in. How Reconstruction was depicted. The stories that were told in school books and in Birth of a Nation about how terrible these ignorant black people suddenly taken over government and assaulting our women and running down our economies and how we wrested it back. The whole Lost Cause mythology, which we're even now still reckoning with because you have all these monuments to the valor of the Confederate soldiers, the romance of Gone with the Wind. These are all things that we grew up in. But it had to do with a very specific cultural project which was to justify, solidify, rationalize the maintenance of a caste system. And that never fully went away.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

I have friends and family abroad all over the world. Perhaps you can imagine the kinds of questions I've been getting about the US of late. Perhaps you've been having those kinds of conversations yourself. All I can say in conclusion is one day I got to sit down with the first black president of the United States, and he said, do not give up. Do not despair.

[Barack Obama]

The progress that we've seen over your lifetime and mine in creating a multiracial democracy, that stuff sticks. I don't subscribe to the idea that because this has always been a theme in America, because we will often be disappointed by how American society responds to racial discrimination and injustice, because at any moment, that kind of caste thinking can flare up and be dangerous and violent and

[Voice Actor (Uncle Remus)]

cruel.

[Barack Obama]

That doesn't mean. Mean that we don't have evidence of that better version of America. We have evidence of it. We've seen it.

This has been reconstruction the unfinished promise, an audible original in partnership with the history channel. Produced by higher ground audio and pushkin industries. Hosted by malcolm gladwell. Our contributors were president barack obama, kai wright, manisha sinha, ashley c. Ford, kelly carter, jackson, kidada williams, jelani cobb and wyatt cenac. Executive producers for history were eli lehrer and mike stiller. Higher ground executive producers were nick white, mukta mohan and dan fearman. Jenna levin was creative executive executive producers for audible. Anne hepperman, glenn pogue, keith wooten and nick d'. Angelo. At pushkin, our producers were kalalea, daphne chen and gabriel hunter chang. Story editing by kai wright and julia barton. Additional editing by leela day. Robert glasper composed the theme music. Original scoring and sound design by cedric wilson. Mixing by jake gorski. Fact checking by angeli mercado. Pushkin's executive producer was jacob smith. Voice acting by yahya abdul mateen ii, samir wiley, jasmine batchelor, mckinley belcher iii, jack gilpin, eric jensen, eric lochtefeld, harold surratt, jonathan walker, kara young and alex barron. Casting by kelly gillespie. Special thanks to sarah nix, nina bird, lawrence, ben naddif haffrey, jake flanagan, corinne gilliard fisher, eric sandler, grace ross, christina sullivan and greta cohn and to inside projects and maggie taylor for marketing support. Many experts, academics and archivists lent us their time and help for this series. They include ed ayers, jordan t. Camp, sierra dixon, scott gack, christina heatherton, seth markle, the primus family, james townsend, fiona vernal, beverly gai, cheftal, david levering lewis, jane carr and the staff at the alabama department of archives and history, the alabama state university archives, hartford's connecticut state archives, and connecticut museum of culture and history. Additional thanks to don will and the staff at brick arts media in brooklyn, new york, head of creative development at audible kate navin, head of audible originals north america, marshall louie chief content officer, rachel giazza. Copyright 2026 by higher ground audio, llc sound recording copyright 2026 by higher ground audio.

[Tommy Vietor]

The headlines never stop, and it's harder than ever to tell what's real, what matters, and what's just noise. That's where Pod Save America comes in. I'm Tommy Vitor, and every week I'm joined by fellow former Obama aides Jon Favreau, Jon Levitt and Dan Pfeiffer to break down the biggest stories, unpack what they mean for the future of our democracy, and add just enough humor to stay sane. Along the way, you'll also hear honest in depth conversations with big voices in politics, media and culture like Rachel Maddow, Gavin Newsom and Mark Cuban that you won't find anywhere else. New episodes drop every Tuesday and Friday, with deep dives every other weekend. Listen wherever you get your podcasts, watch on YouTube or subscribe on Apple Podcasts for ad free episodes.