June 19, 2026

Today's Reading: John 18:1-14

Daily Lectionary: Proverbs 22:1-21; John 18:1-14

“So Jesus said to Peter, ‘Put your sword into its sheath; shall I not drink the cup that the Father has given me?’” (John 18:11)

In the Name + of Jesus. Amen.

Whenever Peter is involved, I usually end up cringing, feeling embarrassed on his behalf, or trying to justify his choices (because I see myself in them). Here’s the thing. Peter always seems to try. He walks out of the boat and onto the water to Jesus…only to look down and start to panic. He declares that Jesus is the Christ…and then suggests that Jesus shouldn’t go to the cross. He’s so sure that he is going to boldly claim his connection to Jesus…only to deny Jesus three times (just like Jesus foretold). And here, in this moment in the garden, he ‘tries again.’ He cuts off the ear. Of a servant. Yikes, Peter.

And here is where I would love to try and justify Peter’s actions - all of them. ‘At least he’s trying.’ Or ‘he did his best.’ Or ‘he didn’t get things all the way wrong…all the time.’ Yeah, I don't believe these excuses either. And here’s the thing - the reality is, sinners trying…usually results in failure. We sure do try our best (well, some of the time), and yet nothing works out perfectly. Life is still usually messy. And hard. And awkward. And not quite right. Yeah, now we are starting to get it...

Look at the rest of the statement that Jesus says to Peter: Shall I not drink the cup that the Father has given me? Here’s the thing. God had a plan for salvation, and it doesn’t involve us trying. There is no ‘cooperation’ or ‘partnership.’ God’s plan. God’s work. For us.

When we ‘try,’ specifically in our salvation, we are always going to be wrong. In fact, the idea that we even could try is wrong. God’s Word clearly teaches us that we were dead in our trespasses - dead things can’t try. So, what does this mean? Are we just stuck being a bunch of awkward Peters - trying and (usually) failing?

Rest, dear redeemed one. Your salvation is perfectly complete in Jesus. God the Father poured out His wrath on Jesus, and Jesus took it. Jesus died. Jesus rose. Jesus lives. For you. There is no trying or needing to try as you look in faith to Jesus. You have been reconciled. It is a gift. It is yours in your Baptism. It is yours in Jesus’ Body and Blood. So now, you do get to try - but it’s for your neighbor and it isn’t to earn anything. Out of the love and mercy that you receive from God, through Jesus, you try, and you love those around you. It won’t be perfect on this side of glory, but it will be redeemed. Thanks be to God.

In the Name + of Jesus. Amen.

Be of good cheer, for God’s own Son Forgives all sins which you have done; And justified by Jesus’ blood, Your Baptism grants the highest good. (LSB 571:4)

Deac. Sarah Longmire, Curricula Curator for Higher Things and Director of Family Life at St. Matthew Lutheran Church in Lee's Summit, MO.