Relatable with Allie Beth Stuckey – Episode 1124 Summary: "Is the Church to Blame for Andrew Tate?"
Release Date: January 16, 2025
Host: Allie Beth Stuckey
Network: Blaze Podcast Network
In Episode 1124 of Relatable with Allie Beth Stuckey, host Allie Beth Stuckey delves into the controversial figure Andrew Tate, questioning the role of the Church in his rise. The episode also touches upon various political and cultural issues, including a critique of President Biden’s tenure, discussions on Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (AOC)’s statements, and reactions to Carrie Underwood’s performance at the presidential inauguration. Below is a comprehensive summary capturing the key points, discussions, insights, and conclusions from the episode.
1. Introduction: Andrew Tate’s Political Ambitions and Conservative Admiration
Allie Beth Stuckey opens the episode by highlighting Andrew Tate’s announcement to run for Prime Minister of the UK, raising questions about the feasibility of such a move and why many conservatives admire him. This sets the stage for an in-depth exploration of Tate’s influence and the possible factors behind his popularity among certain conservative circles.
Notable Quote:
“Andrew Tate says that he is running for Prime Minister of the UK. Is that even possible? And why do so many conservatives seem to believe that he is a guy worth admiring?” [00:01]
2. Capitol Hill Update: Confirmation Hearings and Christian Faith
Before delving into the main topics, Allie provides a brief update on the political landscape as the inauguration approaches. She discusses various confirmation hearings for President Biden’s cabinet picks, emphasizing that many of his nominees are staunch Christians, a stark contrast to the previous administration.
Key Points:
- Senate confirmation hearings for positions such as Attorney General Pam Bondi and Interior Department nominee Doug Burgum.
- Emphasis on the nominees’ strong Christian faith, which Allie celebrates as a positive shift from the Biden and Kamala Harris administrations.
Notable Quote:
“A lot of these picks, from what I know, have a solid faith in Christ. And that is something to just celebrate.” [02:15]
3. Critique of Biden’s Presidency: Five Lowlights
Allie transitions to a critical analysis of President Biden’s administration, reflecting on his recent farewell address. She identifies five major lowlights that, in her view, define the shortcomings of Biden’s presidency.
3.1. Afghanistan Withdrawal
Allie criticizes the chaotic withdrawal of American troops from Afghanistan, highlighting the tragic loss of lives and the strategic blunder of leaving $7 billion worth of military equipment behind, which has empowered the Taliban.
Notable Quote:
“In April of 2021, Biden ordered the complete withdrawal of American troops from Afghanistan... culminating in the abygate terrorist attack on August 26, 2021.” [07:45]
3.2. North Carolina Hurricane Helene Disaster
She discusses the inadequate federal response to Hurricane Helene in September 2024, particularly Biden’s absence from North Carolina during the crisis and FEMA’s controversial directive to avoid homes advertising Trump.
Notable Quote:
“President Biden spent the weekend at his beach house in Delaware... and had very little to say... He did not show the same compassion for North Carolina as he did for California.” [12:30]
3.3. COVID-19 Mandates
Allie condemns Biden’s executive orders mandating vaccinations for federal workers and large businesses, labeling them unconstitutional and draconian. She cites the dismissal of Coast Guard member Zach Lash for refusing the vaccine as an example of policy overreach.
Notable Quote:
“This mandate, completely unconstitutional, completely draconian, stupid, led to many consequences.” [15:20]
3.4. Celebration of Transgenderism
She criticizes the Biden administration’s support for transgender rights, including the controversial Pride Day and the redefinition of sex in Title IX rules to include gender identity, arguing that it undermines women’s rights and safety.
Notable Quote:
“They are talking about libertinism, the freedom to act out any kind of sexual perversion... they're talking about the freedom to kill your child.” [20:05]
3.5. Border Crisis
Allie highlights the administration’s mishandling of immigration policies, pointing to ineffective measures like removing border barriers in Texas and mishandling cases of human trafficking, which have led to increased illegal crossings and fatalities.
Notable Quote:
“The federal government, under Biden's direction, taking away barbed wire, taking away the buoys that Texas had implemented to protect its border. That was certainly a low light.” [26:50]
4. Response to Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez’s Comments on Transgenderism
Allie addresses AOC’s recent remarks defending transgender rights, particularly in sports, and provides a rebuttal from a Christian conservative perspective. She critiques AOC’s stance, arguing that it undermines women’s sports and safety, and emphasizes traditional gender roles.
Notable Quote:
AOC: “And what this also opens the door for is for women to try to perform a very specific kind of femininity... to open up questioning of who is a woman because of how we look... What Trans girls are girls.” [23:38]
Allie: “They are talking about sexual promiscuity, sexual perversion... killing your baby. And I guess the degeneracy... you are declaring yourself something different than what your biology tells you.” [24:15]
5. Andrew Tate: Influence, Controversy, and the Church’s Role
The core of the episode focuses on Andrew Tate’s controversial influence on young men and debates whether the Church bears responsibility for his rise.
5.1. Andrew Tate’s Background and Legal Troubles
Allie provides a detailed account of Tate’s history, including his social media influence, criminal charges in Romania for human trafficking, and his manipulative past in running a webcam business exploiting women.
Key Points:
- Tate’s conversion to Islam and his significant following on platforms like X and Rumble.
- Charges against Tate, including human trafficking, sexual assault, and money laundering.
- His announcement to run for Prime Minister of the UK amidst ongoing legal battles.
Notable Quote:
“He has admitted to assaulting these women... he faces charges in Romania for human trafficking... he denies these allegations.” [35:45]
5.2. Conservative Support and Criticism
Allie discusses the divided opinions among conservatives regarding Tate. While some praise his stance against feminism and advocate for traditional masculinity, others criticize his moral bankruptcy and harmful influence.
Notable Quote:
“He is extremely popular in the UK... but he really is very much a net negative when it comes to his influence.” [33:20]
5.3. The Church’s Role in Promoting or Preventing Tate’s Influence
Allie explores whether the Church has inadvertently contributed to Tate’s appeal by failing to provide strong masculine role models. She presents arguments from both sides:
- Supporters’ View: The Church has become too feminine, lacking strong male leadership, pushing young men towards figures like Tate.
- Critics’ View: Andrew Tate is not a true representation of masculinity and is an aberration; the real issue lies in individual discernment and strong fatherhood rather than institutional failures.
Notable Quote:
“Good fathers are the answer to bad men... strengthening leaders of young men... that's how we should respond to Andrew Tate.” [37:10]
Alternative Perspectives:
- J.D. from ACT: Suggests the evangelical establishment has suppressed true masculinity, enabling Tate’s rise.
- Rob Bernanski: Argues that true biblical masculinity does not align with Tate’s actions and that his faults are not manifestations of genuine masculinity.
Notable Exchange:
J.D.: “Evangelicals should be surprised that Tate knows their sons better than they do.” [39:00]
Rob Bernanski: “Let us define masculinity as God defined masculinity... it's not about being a manly figure like Esau.” [40:00]
5.4. Solutions and Recommendations
Allie emphasizes that strengthening fatherhood and providing genuine, godly examples of masculinity within the Church are crucial in countering harmful influences like Tate. She rejects the notion that the Church’s feminization is to blame and instead points to individual responsibility and local church leadership.
Notable Quote:
“The answer isn't to try and give men the Christian conservative version of Andrew Tate. The answer is to preach repentance, baptism of discipleship...” [39:30]
6. Carrie Underwood’s Inauguration Performance and Backlash
In a brief segment, Allie discusses Carrie Underwood’s decision to sing at President Trump’s inauguration. Despite Underwood’s intentions to unify the nation, she faces significant backlash from critics who label her as supporting “sexual predators” and express disapproval of her political alignment.
Key Points:
- Underwood’s statement expressing honor and humility in performing at the inauguration.
- Criticism from various commentators labeling her support as aligning with negative figures.
- Public backlash evidenced by harsh social media comments.
Notable Quote:
“I love our country and am honored to have been asked to sing at the inauguration... I am really happy that she went against these criticisms and said, yeah, I'm gonna do it.” [40:35]
Conclusion: Strengthening Masculinity Through Fatherhood and Church Leadership
Allie concludes the episode by reiterating the importance of responsible fatherhood and strong, godly leadership within the Church to provide authentic masculine role models. She dismisses the blame on institutional feminization and emphasizes individual and community efforts to guide young men away from negative influences like Andrew Tate.
Closing Thought:
“Good fathers are the answer to bad men... ensuring the Church creates strong, respectful, and godly leaders for young men.” [40:45]
Final Notes:
Throughout the episode, Allie maintains a critical yet analytical tone, addressing complex issues with a focus on Christian conservative values. She integrates notable quotes from both political figures and public personalities to substantiate her points, providing listeners with a nuanced perspective on the interplay between cultural influences and institutional responsibilities.