Relatable with Allie Beth Stuckey – Episode 1177: Colorado Parents Will Lose Custody for 'Deadnaming'

Release Date: April 23, 2025

In Episode 1177 of Relatable with Allie Beth Stuckey, hosted by the Blaze Podcast Network, Allie Beth delves deep into the contentious intersection of parental rights, First Amendment liberties, and progressive legislation impacting children in Colorado and beyond. The episode primarily focuses on a pivotal Supreme Court case and a series of legislative bills in Colorado that are reshaping the landscape of parenting, education, and gender recognition.

1. Supreme Court Case: Mahmoud v. Taylor

Timestamp: [00:01 - 08:05]

The episode opens with an examination of the Supreme Court case Mahmoud v. Taylor, which centers on whether Montgomery County Public Schools in Maryland infringed upon parents' First Amendment rights by disallowing them to opt their children out of LGBTQ+ themed storybook lessons.

• Case Background: In 2023, Montgomery County Public Schools implemented a policy preventing parents from excusing their children from lessons involving LGBTQ+ content. This policy included storybooks like a girl attending her uncle's gay wedding and "Pride Puppy," where a puppy gets lost at a pride parade. A diverse group of parents, including Muslim, Catholic, and Ukrainian Orthodox, challenged this policy, arguing it violated their religious freedoms and parental rights.

• Legal Arguments: The parents, represented by the law firm Beckett, assert that the school board's mandate creates an enforced orthodoxy, compelling children to engage with content contrary to their family's beliefs. They argue that secularism is inherently non-neutral, as every policy reflects underlying worldviews.

• Notable Quote:

  "These parents are being represented by a law firm called Beckett... Kristen Wagner says anyone who cares about parental rights or religious liberty should be aware of a major case on today's docket at the U.S. Supreme Court and Mahmoud v. Taylor." ([02:15])

• Justice’s Perspective: Justice Brett Kavanaugh highlighted inconsistencies in the opt-out provisions, noting that while Montgomery County restricted opt-outs for LGBTQ+ content, other counties in Maryland maintained broader opt-out options for various subjects.

• Host’s Analysis: Allie Beth emphasizes that policies promoting secular progressivism often mask underlying agendas that prioritize specific worldviews over biological and religious truths. She underscores the importance of maintaining parental authority in a child’s education to preserve their well-being and adherence to familial beliefs.

2. Colorado Legislation Impacting Gender Affirming Care and Custody

Timestamp: [08:05 - 23:00]

Shifting focus to Colorado, Allie Beth discusses the state's recent legislative actions aimed at enhancing protections and access to gender-affirming healthcare, reproductive health care, and transgender rights. She presents a critical view of these bills, arguing they undermine parental rights and impose progressive ideologies on children.

• Key Bills Discussed:

  • HP25: Protect Access to Gender Affirming Health Care

    • Provisions: Mandates all health insurance plans in Colorado to cover medically necessary gender-affirming care, including hormone therapy, psychiatric care, and surgeries.
    • Host’s Critique: Allie Beth contends that labeling gender-affirming procedures as "medically necessary" is a manipulation of definitions to enforce ideological conformity. She argues that these procedures are not based on objective science and can lead to permanent physical, mental, and spiritual harm.

  • HB25 Sections 1309 & 1312: Kelly Loving Act

    • Provisions:
      • Section 1309: Evaluates "deadnaming," misgendering, and coercive control in custody battles, potentially penalizing parents who do not affirm a child's or ex-spouse’s gender identity.
      • Section 1312: Creates Colorado as a sanctuary state for individuals seeking gender-affirming care and abortion, protecting providers and patients from out-of-state legal actions.
    • Host’s Critique: Allie Beth argues that these sections infringe upon First Amendment rights and parental authority, effectively forcing parents to endorse beliefs that contradict biological realities. She warns that such laws could lead to the state seizing custody of children from parents who resist affirming progressive gender identities.

• Notable Quote:

  "Every law, every policy that we have on the books reflects what someone thinks about right and wrong, which is based upon their beliefs, their philosophical beliefs, their religious beliefs." ([09:30])

• Implications: The host highlights the dangers of these bills, including the potential for increased state intervention in family matters and the erosion of parental rights. She emphasizes that such policies prioritize ideological agendas over the well-being and natural development of children.

3. International Perspective: UK Supreme Court Ruling on Definition of 'Woman'

Timestamp: [23:00 - 30:00]

Expanding the conversation to a global scale, Allie Beth discusses a landmark decision by the UK Supreme Court regarding the legal definition of "woman" under the 2010 Equality Act.

• Case Overview: The ruling clarified that "woman" refers to biological sex at birth, excluding transgender women, even those with gender recognition certificates (GRCs). This decision impacts single-sex facilities, allowing providers to exclude transgender women from women-only spaces like bathrooms and shelters.

• Host’s Analysis: Allie Beth praises the UK decision as a step towards preserving biological realities and protecting women's rights. She contrasts this with the legislative changes in Colorado, portraying the UK as taking a more rational and respectful approach to gender issues.

• Notable Quote:

  "They banned puberty blockers in children a while ago, a little while ago. And so I'm just thankful for the people who are doing exactly what they are supposed to do." ([26:45])

• Public Reaction: The ruling has sparked controversy, with figures like J.K. Rowling supporting the decision. Allie Beth underscores the importance of such legal clarity in maintaining fairness and safety in single-sex spaces.

4. Church Response and Grassroots Movements in Colorado

Timestamp: [30:00 - 40:00]

In response to the aggressive progressive legislation, Allie Beth highlights the emergence of coalitions among pastors and faith leaders in Colorado who are actively opposing the state’s bills.

• Coalition Efforts: A group of pastors from various churches have formed a coalition to fight against bills like HB25 and HP25. They have launched resources such as fight1312.com, offering information, sample letters, and organized events like marches and prayer walks to mobilize community opposition.

• Notable Quote:

  "They hosted a march and a prayer walk against this Bill specifically on April 17, and you can see that advertisement there." ([35:20])

• Grassroots Activism: Leaders like Pastor Matt Johnson of Brave Church Colorado are coordinating efforts to influence legislators and raise awareness about the potential harms of the proposed laws. Allie Beth commends these efforts, urging listeners to support and engage with these grassroots movements.

5. Call to Action and Community Involvement

Timestamp: [40:00 - 50:00]

Wrapping up the episode, Allie Beth emphasizes the importance of community involvement and personal responsibility in combating the progressive policies that threaten parental rights and children's well-being.

• Encouragement to Listeners: She urges Christians and conservatives to take active roles, whether through volunteering, educating themselves and others, or supporting organizations that advocate for biblical truth and parental authority.

• Notable Quote:

  "The history of the church is carrying the baton of human dignity and human protection. The history of the church is culture warring and culture building and fighting against evil." ([45:50])

• Future Outlook: Allie Beth expresses hope that collective courage and faith-based actions will withstand the legislative pressures, ensuring that children’s futures remain safeguarded against ideologically driven policies.

6. International Progress and Hope

Timestamp: [50:00 - End]

In a final note, Allie Beth points to the UK's proactive measures as a beacon of hope, reinforcing the idea that rational, biologically grounded policies can prevail over progressive overreach. She draws inspiration from international successes to bolster the fight against similar issues in the United States, particularly in Colorado.

Conclusion

Episode 1177 of Relatable with Allie Beth Stuckey serves as a comprehensive analysis of the ongoing battle between parental rights and progressive educational policies. By dissecting critical legal cases and legislative movements in both the United States and the United Kingdom, Allie Beth provides listeners with a nuanced understanding of the stakes involved. She calls for heightened awareness, community engagement, and steadfast adherence to biblical truths to navigate and counteract the encroaching policies that threaten the familial and educational fabric of society.

Key Takeaways:

• Mahmoud v. Taylor is a significant Supreme Court case that could redefine parental rights in educational settings.
• Colorado's HP25 and HB25 bills represent aggressive attempts to enforce gender-affirming policies that may undermine parental authority and child welfare.
• The UK’s Supreme Court ruling offers a contrasting approach, emphasizing biological realities over progressive gender identities.
• Grassroots movements, particularly within the church community in Colorado, are crucial in opposing these legislative changes.
• Active participation and support from the community are essential to uphold parental rights and protect children's best interests.

For those seeking to understand and engage with these critical issues, this episode provides both depth and clarity, making it an essential listen for anyone concerned about the direction of education, parental rights, and children's welfare in progressive policy climates.