Podcast Summary: Relatable with Allie Beth Stuckey – Ep 1198 | Rebutting Conservatives’ Strange Response to the Glenn Greenwald Scandal

Podcast Information:

• Title: Relatable with Allie Beth Stuckey
• Host/Author: Blaze Podcast Network
• Description: Upbeat and in-depth, Relatable with Allie Beth Stuckey breaks down the latest in culture, news, theology & politics from a Christian, conservative perspective. Allie’s fresh analysis of the most important issues provides an entertaining and effective way to stay in the know.
• Episode: Ep 1198 | Rebutting Conservatives’ Strange Response to the Glenn Greenwald Scandal
• Release Date: June 2, 2025

Introduction

In Episode 1198 of "Relatable with Allie Beth Stuckey," released on June 2, 2025, host Allie Beth Stuckey delves into the recent scandal involving journalist Glenn Greenwald. She critically examines the remarkably unified defense from conservative commentators, including Christian conservatives, in response to the leaked video depicting Greenwald engaged in degrading sexual acts.

The Glenn Greenwald Scandal

Incident Overview: Over the weekend, a disturbing video surfaced on social media platform X, featuring Glenn Greenwald, a renowned journalist, engaging in what appears to be degrading sexual activities with a male prostitute. The footage shows Greenwald, who is openly gay, scantily clad in women's clothing, performing actions suggestive of a humiliation ritual, including exchanging money via PayPal.

Greenwald’s Statement: Greenwald released a statement addressing the incident:

"Videos were released online depicting behavior in my private life. Some were distorted and others were not. It's unclear what is meant by that... The only wrongdoing is the criminal and malicious publication of the videos in an attempt to malign perceived political enemies in advance of political agenda." (15:30)

He emphasized that the actions were consensual and private, urging respect for his personal life despite the publication of the videos.

Conservative Christian Reaction

Uniform Defense: Allie Beth expresses her confusion and concern over the swift and uniform defense of Greenwald by conservative commentators, including Christian figures. She notes that many defenders argue that Greenwald's private actions should remain separate from his professional work.

"It just seems like I missed some kind of mass email that said... these are the conservative Christian talking points after the Glenn Greenwald sex tapes release." (42:10)

Notable Defenders:

• Jason Whitlock (Blaze TV Host): Expressed a mixed view, stating, "I love his work, pray for him. I don't like his private actions." (64:05)
• Matt Walsh (Daily Wire): Defended Greenwald's privacy, noting the presence of a meth pipe in the video but did not condemn his actions outright.
• Michael Knowles (Daily Wire): Parodied the situation using a reference to C.S. Lewis's "The Screwtape Letters," implying that Greenwald should stay true to his principles despite societal condemnation.

Allie’s Critique: Allie questions the ethics of defending someone engaging in actions that contradict the very values conservatives profess. She points out the inconsistency in defending Greenwald while condemning similar behaviors in other public figures like Hunter Biden.

"If Hunter Biden's drug use and his use of a prostitute mattered, this doesn't matter... but Greenwald is a private citizen. Maybe." (78:50)

Theological Perspectives on Sin and Salvation

Sin and Redemption: Allie delves into Christian theology, emphasizing that all sin separates individuals from God, regardless of its nature or severity.

"Romans 3:23 says, 'for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God...'" (102:20)

She explains that salvation is attainable through grace and faith in Jesus Christ, as outlined in Ephesians 2.

Differentiating Sins: Not all sins are equal in consequence or societal impact. For instance, infidelity and homosexual behavior are viewed as more disordered from a biblical standpoint.

"Romans 1:26-27 states, 'God gave them up to dishonorable passions...'" (135:45)

Marriage and Same-Sex Marriage

Biblical Definition of Marriage: Allie underscores the biblical stance on marriage being a union exclusively between one man and one woman, citing Genesis and Jesus's teachings.

"Jesus repeats it in Matthew 19:4-5, 'Therefore, a man shall leave his father and mother...'" (160:30)

Gallup Poll Findings: A recent Gallup poll revealed a significant decline in Republican support for same-sex marriage, dropping to 41%—the lowest in 30 years.

"Republican support has hit its lowest point since Gallup began tracking this sentiment 29 years ago... 41% of Republicans now back so-called same-sex marriage." (210:15)

Cultural Implications: Allie connects the decline in support to increasing awareness of issues like Drag Queen Story Hour and gender-affirming care for children, suggesting these have influenced conservative values.

Analysis of Republican Support Trends

Shifting Perspectives: The Gallup poll highlights a drastic shift in Republican attitudes towards same-sex marriage, juxtaposed with increasing support among Democrats.

"88% of Democrats think gay marriage should have the same rights, the same validity as actual marriage, and 41% of Republicans do." (220:40)

Impact of Cultural Movements: Allie attributes the change to backlash against what she describes as the rapid and destructive aspects of the sexual revolution, particularly targeting children’s exposure to transgender ideologies.

Critique of Current Conservative Stance

Moral Confusion: Allie expresses concern that the defense of Greenwald exemplifies a broader moral confusion within conservative Christian circles, where personal ethical failings are overlooked in favor of political alliances.

"We're supposed to be building something, but it is worth having the conversation, the very fundamental conversation of what is our foundation." (185:50)

Consistency in Moral Standards: She challenges conservatives to maintain consistency in condemning sexual immorality regardless of political affiliation, drawing parallels to reactions against figures like Trump.

"Trump's lack of sexual ethics does matter. That is absolutely true. They do matter." (190:25)

Conclusion and Call to Action

Encouragement to Uphold Values: Allie encourages Christian conservatives to adhere firmly to biblical principles, even in the face of cultural and political challenges. She emphasizes the importance of standing up for what is morally right, regardless of personal failings of public figures.

"If you love your neighbor, then you believe and you advocate for the reality that God's ways are better." (305:10)

Faith and Community Support: She reiterates the significance of community support among believers to uphold and propagate Christian values amidst societal shifts.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

1. Allie Beth Stuckey on Personal Responsibility:

   "All we really are responsible to do is the next right thing in faith, with excellence and for the glory of God." (02:45)

2. Greenwald’s Statement on Video Publication:

   "The only wrongdoing, he says, is the criminal and malicious publication of the videos..." (35:20)

3. Allie on Sin and Salvation:

   "Romans 3:23 says, 'for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God...'" (102:20)

4. Discussion on Marriage Definition:

   "Jesus repeats it in Matthew 19:4-5, 'Therefore, a man shall leave his father and mother...'" (160:30)

5. Allie on Republican Support Decline:

   "A majority of Americans supported same-sex marriage for the first time. After the Obergefell ruling, public support jumped to 61%." (210:15)

6. Allie’s Critique of Conservative Defense:

   "It just seems like I missed some kind of mass email that said... these are the conservative Christian talking points after the Glenn Greenwald sex tapes release." (42:10)

7. Call to Uphold Biblical Principles:

   "If you love your neighbor, then you believe and you advocate for the reality that God's ways are better." (305:10)

Final Thoughts

In this episode, Allie Beth Stuckey provides a comprehensive critique of the conservative Christian response to Glenn Greenwald's scandal, intertwining theological insights with cultural and political analysis. She challenges her audience to maintain ethical consistency, uphold biblical values, and critically assess the shifting landscapes of moral support within Republican circles. By addressing both the immediate scandal and broader societal trends, Allie offers a thought-provoking perspective aimed at encouraging steadfastness in faith and principles among her listeners.