Relic Radio Thrillers: "The Fifth Man" by The CBS Radio Mystery Theater

Introduction

Relic Radio Thrillers, hosted by Pat Summerall, delves into classic Old Time Radio adventures encompassing crime, mystery, espionage, and suspense. In this episode titled "The Fifth Man," originally aired on June 18, 1982, listeners are immersed in a gripping tale of betrayal, murder, and covert operations.

Setting the Stage

The story unfolds with Tammy Grimes narrating the pervasive struggle between those who have and those who have not, setting a tone of intrigue and danger. She states:

"As long as there are haves and have nots, givers and takers... there will be those whose only way of competing is to rob." [00:38]

This introduction establishes the central theme of espionage and clandestine activities that drive the narrative forward.

The Crime: Murder on the Brighton London Express

The protagonist, Everett Parker, a dedicated magazine editor, finds himself entangled in a complex murder investigation. The victim is William Arthur Jackson, a man with deep connections to the War Office and enigmatic associations hinted by his bureau chief, Sir Robert Leeds.

Initial Confrontation

Parker's peaceful routine is shattered when Inspector Michael Fogg arrives unannounced at his home, informing him of Jackson's suspicious death. Their tense conversation begins with:

Inspector Michael Fogg: "I show you this picture. Do you know this person?" [00:46]

Everett Parker: "Yes, I do. His name is William Jackson. He's a very good friend." [01:59]

Inspector Fogg's probing questions and Parker's evasive responses heighten the suspense, suggesting underlying secrets.

Echoes of Suspicion

As the investigation proceeds aboard the Brighton London Express, Parker recalls the events leading to Jackson's demise. He recounts seeing a mysterious man with a red face arguing with Jackson in their compartment:

Everett Parker: "There's been a skin of my teeth. Managed to catch the last car and walked up through a corridor... when you came in." [05:25]

Parker's account introduces the enigmatic "fifth man," a figure shrouded in mystery whose presence is pivotal to unraveling the case.

Lorette Rupe’s Revelation

Lorette Rupe, Jackson's wife, provides critical insights into her husband's secretive life. Her interactions with Parker reveal layers of deceit and hidden motives:

Lorette Rupe: "I saw this notebook fall out of his pocket... I knew it was the fifth man." [24:44]

These revelations hint at espionage activities, suggesting that Jackson's murder may be linked to his covert operations.

The Arrest and Twist

Inspector Fogg arrests Carl Carson, a man connected to Jackson, based on fingerprint evidence. However, the plot takes an unexpected turn when Carson mysteriously dies during an attempt to flee:

Everett Parker: "We made a thorough search... lying right in front of the Flying Wing was Carl Carson. Or rather, what was left of him." [46:01]

This incident complicates the investigation, casting doubt on the veracity of Carson's guilt and raising questions about the true orchestrator behind Jackson's death.

Revelation of Everett Parker’s True Identity

In a climactic twist, Everett Parker discloses his true allegiance as an MI5 operative:

Everett Parker: "I, as Everett Parker, used that cover for my real job. That of an MI5 operative. We knew Jackson was passing secrets to the Soviets and that his courier was Carl Carson." [47:30]

This confession recontextualizes the entire investigation, revealing that Parker was instrumental in dismantling the spy ring responsible for Jackson's murder.

Conclusion

Inspector Fogg acknowledges the intricate web of espionage, yet the mystery remains partially unresolved as Carl Carson's involvement hangs in uncertainty. Parker's revelation underscores the pervasive nature of espionage and the personal sacrifices made by those in clandestine roles.

Final Reflections

Tammy Grimes closes the episode by reflecting on the age-old battle of espionage:

"So long as men and countries possess dangerous secrets, other men and other countries will try to steal them." [48:41]

This philosophical musing encapsulates the enduring allure and peril of spy narratives.

Key Takeaways

• Espionage and Deception: The episode masterfully weaves themes of spying, hidden agendas, and betrayal, illustrating the relentless pursuit of power and secrets.

• Character Complexity: Everett Parker's dual identity as a magazine editor and MI5 operative adds depth, highlighting the personal toll of living a double life.

• Suspense and Revelation: The narrative maintains suspense through strategic revelations and unexpected twists, keeping listeners engaged until the very end.

Notable Quotes

• "I am waiting for you, sir." — Inspector Michael Fogg [00:17]
• "You've been in the hands of that maniac. It's unbearable for me." — Everett Parker [08:39]
• "I, as Everett Parker, used that cover for my real job. That of an MI5 operative." — Everett Parker [47:30]
• "It is better 10 guilty persons escape than one innocent suffer." — Tammy Grimes [16:17]

Conclusion

"The Fifth Man" is a quintessential Old Time Radio thriller, rich with suspense, intricate plotting, and memorable characters. Relic Radio Thrillers successfully resurrects this classic tale, offering both longtime enthusiasts and new listeners an engaging auditory adventure into the shadowy world of espionage and mystery.