This episode is sponsored by…

NCH:

Set up an LLC to protect your investments! – https://nchinc.com/rtr

BLUPRINT HOME LOANS:

Get pre-approved with one of RTR’s preferred lenders at

https://bluprinthomeloans.com/renttoretirement/

BAM Capital:

Get access to premium real estate assets with BAM Capital. Rent to Retirement’s preferred multifamily partner. https://bamcapital.com/rtr/

MYND - A Roofstock company:

Your all-in-one platform for single-family rentals.

Buy, manage, and grow—without the hassle.

https://www.mynd.co/rtr

Are you better off investing in new construction rentals or fixer-uppers? In this episode, Matthew Seyoum breaks it down with real estate expert Jim Sheils—covering decades of experience, market insights, and what actually builds long-term wealth in today’s market.

If you’re serious about real estate investing, this conversation will help you understand:

Why many investors are shifting to new construction

The real difference between cash flow vs equity growth

How to evaluate markets like Florida the right way

Why “perfect deals” don’t exist—and why that’s a good thing

This is not theory—this is what’s working right now.

⏱️ Key Highlights

0:08 – Introduction & Florida real estate focus

0:31 – Jim Sheils’ 27-year investing journey

1:25 – Why investors moved away from California

2:14 – The shift from rehabs to new construction

3:06 – “Own less, better quality” strategy explained

4:49 – How equity growth outperformed cash flow

6:08 – Time freedom vs active investing trade-offs

8:32 – Why “fairway deals” beat risky home runs

9:19 – Why secondary markets outperform major cities

10:32 – The 5 key fundamentals of strong markets

11:16 – Why Ocala, FL is a top growth market

13:49 – Florida insurance concerns (real vs myth)

15:03 – How new construction reduces insurance costs

16:46 – Real insurance cost examples (surprising numbers)

21:01 – Duplex vs single-family investing strategy

22:13 – Infill lots vs large developments explained

25:16 – Why mixed neighborhoods matter for investors

27:41 – Final advice: why waiting is the biggest mistake

📧 Got a question or story to share?

Email us at: ⁠podcast@renttoretirement.com⁠

👍 Like this episode? Hit the thumbs up, subscribe, and turn on notifications so you don’t miss the next one!

💬 Comment below with your biggest takeaway from this episode!

🌐 Explore turnkey investing opportunities: ⁠⁠https://www.renttoretirement.com⁠⁠

🗓️ Schedule a Free Consultation:

⁠⁠https://bit.ly/3QSPEoS

📺 Subscribe to the YouTube Channel:

⁠⁠https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC_h1lnz1kM75Gj79VV8QtEg⁠⁠

🎧 Listen to the Rent To Retirement Podcast on the Go:

⁠⁠https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/renttoretirement⁠⁠

📬 Join Our Newsletter Email List:

Submit your info at the top right corner of the page:

⁠⁠https://renttoretirement.com⁠⁠

📩 Have Questions for the Podcast?

Send them to: ⁠podcast@renttoretirement.com⁠

Your question might be answered in a future episode!

#RealEstateInvesting #FloridaRealEstate #RentalProperties #PassiveIncome #NewConstruction #RealEstateTips #InvestingForBeginners #WealthBuilding #CashFlow #RealEstateStrategy