Podcast Summary: Restaurant Strategy – "Dialing In the Guest Experience with Coach Sal Rotolo"
Main Theme / Purpose
This episode centers on the guest experience in restaurants—moving beyond simply serving food to intentionally crafting memorable, engaging customer journeys. Host Chip Klose and returning guest Coach Sal Rotolo dissect what makes an experience extraordinary, emphasizing attention to detail, emotional connection, and operational strategies to elevate every interaction from the moment a guest enters to when they leave.
Key Discussion Points & Insights
1. What Are Restaurants Really Selling?
- Experience over Food: The hosts agree that guests seek more than meals; they crave being taken care of and immersed in a unique environment.
- “You do not sell food. You sell an experience. The experience of coming in and dining at your restaurant.” —Chip Klose [00:00]
- Transactions and Permission: Dining is a series of transactions where guests grant permission to be sold to; if salesmanship is missing, the experience feels empty.
- “If we're not sold to enough, we call it bad service. Like, we're looking over our shoulder like, where's the waiter?” —Chip Klose [07:53]
- Time as a Commodity: Dining in is among the rare, lengthy transactions left in the modern world.
- “The average transaction in a CVS isn't 20 minutes. The average transaction online isn't 20 minutes.” —Chip Klose [09:23]
2. The Power of Details
- Memorable Mentorship: Sal recalls advice from Victor Sorrentino:
- “It’s about details. It’s details, details, details. Those are the three things...that are going to set you apart from everybody else." —Victor Sorrentino via Sal Rotolo [06:59]
- Intentional Touchpoints: Every small element (lighting, music, setup, cleanliness) must be deliberately managed for consistency and excellence.
3. Salesmanship as Service
- Guiding the Guest: Staff should guide, not just take orders, acting as “experts” who help guests find the best each restaurant offers.
- “There's a way sales equals service and better salesmanship actually equals better service and better experience.” —Chip Klose [10:57]
- Making Choices Personal: In quick-service settings, staff proactively help guests navigate the menu, recommend items, and personalize the experience.
4. The Theater Analogy
- Hospitality as Performance: Both hosts draw parallels between restaurants and theater—uniforms as costumes, dining rooms as the stage, and each service a performance.
- “This is a performance, right? You have a uniform on equals costume...and we're paid...to put on a performance.” —Sal Rotolo [13:48]
- Setting the Stage: Like in theater, restaurateurs must clearly define the setting, characters, and story for guests.
- “Restaurants are so close to theater. We're backstage or we're on stage, right?...Our job is to guide them through." —Chip Klose [12:34]
5. Memorability and Story
- Deliberate Experiences Lead to Stories: Guests remember the details that stand out—speakeasy entryways, personalized greetings, sensory cues.
- “I don't remember the food, but I'm here talking about it because of everything else.” —Sal Rotolo on Capos, Las Vegas [16:06]
- Assume No One Cares—Make Them Care:
- “We just have to walk into it assuming no one cares. They care when it makes their life better. They care when it gives them a good story.” —Chip Klose [16:19]
6. Recovering from Mistakes
- View Complaints as Opportunities: Guest complaints provide a chance to demonstrate personal care, often turning one-time customers into regulars.
- “Whenever there's an issue, it's an opportunity. That's what people have to remember.” —Sal Rotolo [19:30]
7. Making Every Guest Feel Important
- Personality in Service: Recruiting and developing staff who are naturally personable is key; small, genuine interactions can transform a guest’s experience.
- Notable story: Bob Carpenter at Sunnyside Kitchen retains customers by engaging each guest personally (e.g. commenting on logos, starting personalized conversations). [24:21]
- “Customers are never an interruption of our day. They're the reason we're here." —Sal Rotolo [28:19]
8. Atmosphere & Environmental Design
- Engage All Senses: The physical environment—smell, sound, sight, touch—sets the emotional tone.
- “Every sense adds a layer to the memory that the guest takes home.” —Sal Rotolo [33:29]
- “I want you to juice a bunch of orange juice right before you open up the doors...People walk in and they get hit with that fresh OJ juice smell and...it's a sensory thing.” —Sal Rotolo [34:45]
- Optimize Seating and Lighting: Steve Hanson (Be Our Guest) is cited as obsessing over seating plans and lighting so every guest feels like the best version of themselves.
- “He would sit in every single chair...what are they going to be looking at all night?...He was willing to get rid of two covers simply because...they're not saying good things about us.” —Chip Klose [36:50]
9. Operational Tips: The “Customer Walk”
- See Through the Guest’s Eyes: Owners and managers should routinely experience their restaurant as a guest would, from parking lot to table.
- “I teach restaurateurs what's called a customer walk. Where it starts in the parking lot...Walk into the lobby, stand there...look around, be a customer...write it down. There's your action items for the day.” —Sal Rotolo [40:26]
- Involve All Staff: Empower every team member to look for details and maintain high standards consistently.
Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments
-
On experience vs. food:
- “We don't sell food, we serve food...we sell the experience, right? Like, that's what we're...they're coming to eat, but what they're really coming for is the experience.” —Chip Klose [19:57]
-
On impactful mistakes:
- “I've created more lifetime guests from that interaction than anything else.” —Sal Rotolo [19:35]
-
On customer attitude:
- “Customers are never an interruption of our day. They're the reason we're here." —Sal Rotolo [28:19]
-
On making guests feel special:
- “Our job, at its most basic level, is to make people feel important. And luckily for us, the people that we take care of are important...” —Chip Klose [23:49]
-
On operationalizing friendliness:
- “Let me give you three easy ways...three cheat codes for doing it.” —Chip Klose [27:48]
-
On the “customer walk”:
- “Be the customer…Go out in the parking lot, pretend you're a customer, take a note, paper and pen, and start being a customer and keep writing down...there's your action items for the day.” —Sal Rotolo [40:26]
Timestamps for Important Segments
- Opening premise—selling experiences: [00:00]
- Details, Details, Details story: [06:59]
- Salesmanship as service: [07:53–10:57]
- Theater performance analogy: [12:34–13:48]
- Capos speakeasy experience: [15:39]
- Creating regulars via adversity: [18:29]
- Making guests feel important/Sunnyside Kitchen story: [24:21]
- Practical staff encouragement (“customers are not an interruption”): [28:19]
- Designing the environment—lighting, seating, senses: [33:10]
- Customer walk actionable advice: [40:26]
Action Steps for Restaurant Owners
- Audit Your Experience: Routinely walk through your restaurant as a guest, noting sensory cues, cleanliness, atmosphere, and staff interactions.
- Prioritize Details: Ensure every touchpoint (menus, setup, restrooms, lighting, music) is intentional and high quality.
- Recruit Right, Train Consistently: Hire personable staff; regularly model and coach engaging service behaviors.
- Operationalize Personableness: Give staff concrete scripts or tricks (e.g., commenting on guest apparel) to personalize each interaction.
- Embrace Mistakes as Opportunities: Train staff to see guest complaints as a chance to build loyalty.
- Design for Memory: Use sensory triggers (smells, textures, visuals) to make experiences unforgettable.
Episode Takeaway
Great restaurants don’t just serve food—they choreograph entire experiences. Attention to detail, personalized service, and designing for memorable sensory moments create passionate advocates and loyal regulars. Every restaurateur’s goal should be to “dial in” guest experience from start to finish.