Podcast Summary: RISK! Episode “Virgins”

Release Date: May 15, 2025

Overview

In the “Virgins” episode of RISK!, host Kevin Allison curates a poignant and humorous exploration of innocence and self-discovery through the true stories of individuals reflecting on their more naive years. This episode delves into themes of identity, fear, rebellion, and personal growth, presenting listeners with heartfelt narratives that resonate with authenticity and vulnerability.

David Crabb: “It’s Always Halloween” [02:38 – 15:29]

David Crabb opens the episode with a nostalgic yet eerie recount of his childhood experience during Halloween. Growing up in Victoria, Texas, David shares an unforgettable night when his mother left him with a babysitter who chose to show him the horror classic "The Elephant Man." This unsettling movie became a formative experience that ignited his fascination with dark themes.

Key Points:

• Childhood Fear and Maternal Guidance: David describes his mother’s unconventional approach to parenting, blending traditional warmth with an unexpected penchant for horror and true crime literature. This juxtaposition fostered a unique environment where he was exposed to both comfort and the macabre.

  “By the time I was maybe like 12 years old, we had probably seen every horror movie that existed.” [07:45]

• Halloween Party Transformation: At the age of twelve, David details his transformative Halloween party experience. Determined to shed his wallflower persona, he creates an elaborate Freddy Krueger costume with his mother’s help, leading to a night of unexpected acceptance and laughter.

  “That was the most amazing experience I ever had. And I really think that half the people at the party just had no idea that it was me.” [10:26]

• Identity Crisis and Acceptance: The episode transitions to David’s teenage years, highlighting his struggle with his sexual identity amid societal fears of the AIDS epidemic. His Halloween persona becomes a metaphor for his desire to be someone else, ultimately leading him to embrace his true self within a supportive, albeit unconventional, community.

  “I became a goth kid. And that was when I knew I was where I was supposed to be.” [15:29]

Mara Wilson: “Virgin Minds and Virgin Bodies” [17:12 – 26:47]

Mara Wilson shares a deeply personal story about growing up in a conservative, Catholic household where discussions of sexuality were taboo. Her narrative captures the tension between her innate curiosity and the rigid expectations imposed by her stepmother.

Key Points:

• Strict Upbringing and Rebellion: Mara recounts the oppressive environment fostered by her stepmother’s strict rules and constant surveillance, which stifled open conversations about sex and personal identity.

  “Sex was not something we were encouraged to talk about in my family. It was something we were taught to fear.” [22:30]

• Secret Support and Education: An older brother introduces Mara to a progressive sex education group, providing her with the knowledge and support she lacked at home. This clandestine connection becomes a lifeline, helping her navigate her emerging sexuality.

  “Safe is sexy.” – The group’s motto becomes a secret mantra for Mara, symbolizing her desire for both safety and expression. [23:15]

• Desperate Measures and Consequences: In a bid to destroy a symbol of her forbidden knowledge, Mara details a harrowing experience where she ingests pieces of a T-shirt, leading to severe physical pain and a metaphorical struggle against her restrictive upbringing.

  “All the punishments that my parents could have given me… were never as bad as what I did to myself that night.” [26:00]

• Long-Term Impact and Reconciliation: Reflecting years later, Mara acknowledges the lasting effects of her rebellious act and the gradual softening of her parents, highlighting a journey towards mutual respect and understanding despite lingering scars.

  “I think my stepmother and I have realized that while we are very different people, we do have a mutual respect and understanding.” [25:50]

Tommy O’Malley: “Virgin Minds and Virgin Bodies” [29:05 – 52:27]

Tommy O’Malley delivers a candid and often humorous account of his tumultuous teenage years, marked by confusion, experimentation, and the quest for acceptance. His story interweaves awkward encounters, misguided attempts at rebellion, and the painful lessons of early adulthood.

Key Points:

• Early Crush and Social Struggles: Tommy reminisces about his unrequited love for a classmate, Giselle Martinez, illustrating the universal pain of adolescent infatuation and the struggles of navigating social hierarchies.

  “Giselle Martinez in eighth grade still the prettiest girl in school.” [44:00]

• Sexual Exploration and Mistakes: He recounts his first foray into sexual experimentation with his friend Richard, leading to unintended and traumatic consequences that haunt him for years.

  “The first person outside of my family who I wanted to spend time with was a girl. Her name was Talia.” [36:00]

• College Confusion and Regret: Tommy’s account of his college years is filled with hedonistic pursuits and impulsive decisions, culminating in a regrettable sexual encounter that leaves him grappling with shame and self-disgust.

  “I am paralyzed with fear. I turned the light on and I am covered in shit.” [41:38]

• Long-Term Reflections: Looking back, Tommy acknowledges the lack of preparedness and guidance that led to his missteps, highlighting the importance of open communication and self-acceptance.

  “All the punishments that my parents could have given me… were never as bad as what I did to myself that night.” [52:09]

Episode Conclusion [52:27 – End]

Kevin Allison wraps up the episode by reflecting on the shared experiences of vulnerability and the courage it takes to share such personal stories. He invites listeners to explore more about the storytellers and encourages engagement through social media platforms.

“Today’s the day. Take a risk.” [53:01]

Notable Quotes:

• “I was standing on the couch in my footy pajamas being like, leave the Elephant man alone.” – David Crabb [08:15]

• “The most beautiful thing you can give to each other is your virgin minds and your virgin bodies.” – Mara Wilson [24:50]

• “I wanted was just not to be seen.” – David Crabb [09:05]

Themes Explored:

• Identity and Self-Acceptance: Each storyteller grapples with understanding and embracing their true selves amidst societal and familial pressures.

• Fear and Courage: The narratives highlight the fears associated with vulnerability and the bravery required to confront and share personal truths.

• Rebellion and Consequences: Acts of rebellion, whether subtle or drastic, lead to significant personal growth and enduring consequences.

• Family Dynamics: The influence of family—both supportive and oppressive—plays a crucial role in shaping the storytellers' journeys.

Conclusion

The “Virgins” episode of RISK! masterfully intertwines humor with heartache, presenting a tapestry of stories that explore the complexities of growing up and the pivotal moments that define our paths. Through the candid revelations of David Crabb, Mara Wilson, and Tommy O’Malley, listeners are invited to reflect on their own experiences of innocence lost and identities forged in the fires of adolescence.